, Ì ç xj~o{r*ü @ 2 0 'd ù t @ 7ø õæÒ does the english
TRANSCRIPT
85
Does the English Language Lesson with Communicative Tasks Reduce Unwillingness to Speak English? : A Practical Report
FUKUTA, Junya Graduate Student, Nagoya University/JSPS Research Fellow
Abstract
This paper reports a lesson practice aimed to reduce unwillingness to speak English by the use of communicative tasks. The data was collected before and after a semester. The unwillingness to speak English was assessed by the Isoda’s (2009) questionnaire which consisted of three constructs (i.e., high anxiety, low perceived competence, and avoidance of speaking). One English lesson was constructed from the pre-task, main task, and post-task sequence (Willis, 2006). In the pre-task activity, the teacher introduced the topic, content, or other useful information such as words and expressions for the lesson to accomplish the main task comfortably. The main task was achieved by information-gap speaking task, followed by form-focused post-task activities (Willis, 1996). Results showed that the practice succeeded to reduce the score of low perceived competence. It was, however, not effective for the high anxiety and the tendency to avoid speaking. Post-hoc analyses implied that the effectiveness of the lesson was differed by learners’ attitudes toward speaking English before the intervention.
Horwitz, Horwitz & Cope, 1986
, 2009; , 2014; Amano, 2014
LET 中部支部研究紀要第 26 号(2014)
86
2009 Willingness to Communicate WTC
p. 54
Sentence Per Minute SPM
SPM
Amano
2014 80 Total Physical Response
TPR
80 2009
-
6
Task-based language teaching TBLT
Ellis 2003
a.
b.
c.
d.
福田:コミュニケーションタスクを用いた英語授業は英語スピーキングに対する抵抗感を軽減するか
87
�@�'D�\XQDƇ�ǛǧĴÿ�'Ô/Ȭ�A�ì+Ǜǧ۸'¼°�@�
ņœ'ìáǧƄè&\XQDƇ�ǛǧĴÿ+ĤĦȡ*ü�@ĘȢDǗ�ƕƞ'�%,Ȭ
ǏƈȪ2014ȫȬYashima, Zenuk-Nishide and ShimizuȪ2004ȫ;Maekawa and YashimaȪ2012ȫ�ĵ
�>A@�ǏƈȪ2014ȫ&,Ȭ\XQDƇÀ¤'ĸŜDşĪ��ĸŜøǵ*="%Ȭ�+nj
ǧXj~O{R1+IJİħDǹŴ�@Ǣ6Dǐ"%@�üǰ')"�ôƽƿ,ǀŜȩƢôř
+ 7Ï+ƅě&�?Ȭ�ô�čƅ&ôƽ�@ǛǧėĒ�Ƿ*#%)Ȭnjǧ¯Ʃôƽƿ&
�"��Ƈ>A�Ì\XQ,ÀŅÐȪone-wayȫ+ly[{`~Vu{&Ȭâ¤+ÏƆÖ;Ï
īDƭ��@'\XQ&�"��¾čȘ*C�@�§+ƯŖ'�%Ȭôƽƿ,Ȱ#+IJİ
ħ*ș�@ǖƪ¨%*�%IJİħDǹŴ�@�'*Īµ���ǏƈȪ2014ȫ&,ȬǴƍ)
ŕ9Ƕ5�Ȭ\XQ*ü�@ĩA;ôƽƿ+ș�ģ+ëúȬ��%\XQ*ü�@ńǘģ)(
9ĤĦȡ+ë»*ĘȢ��+&,) 'ƾû�%@�Yashima, Zenuk-Nishide and Shimizu
Ȫ2004ȫ,Ȭȩř&áȀDrax*��Xj~^۸Dǐ�'&ȬáȝĢƾģ�Ð��Ȭ¸
Ť$�;WTC+Ð�*Ƹ�"��'DæÒ�%@�5�Maekawa and YashimaȪ2012ȫ,Ȭ
ƃąôȎ+ôƅüǰ+njǧQvX&Ȭ�+ôƅ�þŔøȝ*njǧD�çȡDĥ÷�Ȭ�AD
ly[{`~Vu{\XQ'�%øȝ*ȃǐ�@�'&Ȭ�ȉĪ�� L2ymxD9"�ƃĥ
+DžȪIdeal L2 selfȫ�'Ȭ�ȉĪ�)�%,)>)'Ƽ¹ħ >ȉĪ�� L2ymx
D9"�DžȪOught-to L2 selfȫ�DėĪ�@�'�&�Ȭ.%,njǧ1+ôƽ¸Ť;WTC
DÐ���@�'�&�@�'DøǠƍ*Ƙ�%@�
� �)�>Ȭ�A>,�*ÀŅÐ+Xj~^\XQ&�?ȬÄŅÐ+TptdS~Vu{
\XQ�ĤĦȡ*(+=)ĘȢD��@ ,÷ &,)�5�Ȭœøǵ&+Ƃç9�&
�@=*Ȭ�ljŀȨ+njǧQvX,Ȭ�5�5)ýĿD9#ôƅ��Î*��ç&�@�'
9í��?Ȭ¨%+ôƅ*ÍLJ��þŔ+āŜȒDĥ÷�@�'�ßȟ&�@çÍ9�?Ȭ
Maekawa and YashimaȪ2012ȫ=?Ō*WJevx)njǧ�ƇƀŭDĥ÷�%ĸŜDşĪ�)�
A-)>)çÍ9�@'ƾ�>A@��+=)çÍ*�%9Ȭ\XQ*="%njǧ�Ƈ
D�Ȃ�@�'Dž��Ȭôƽƿ+�njǧTptdS~Vu{*ü�@IJİħ�*Ŗ��%œĖ
*=ĘȢD9�>�+ B �)�)>ȬHorwitz, Horwitz and CopeȪ1986ȫ;ƗƈȪ2009ȫ
�Ĵļ�@=*ȬXj~O{R۸,�õDħ�;�۸&�@�8ȬÀ*Xj~O{R
۸*Æ?Ʈ5�@ �&,Ȭǽ*ôƽƿ,ĕIJİħDħ�Ȭ�+IJİħDĕ8%�5�
'�ƾ�>A@ >&�@��+=)ƋÚ�ȬœĸŜøǵ��njǧTptdS~Vu{*ü
�@IJİħ�*(ĘȢ�@ DǫŘ�@¸Ť')"��
Ȱȭœøǵ
ȰȭȮ� üǰôƽƿ
� ǫŘ+üǰ')"�øǵ,Ȭơƿ*=?ơƿ�º¹�@ƺǑƥîô+�čƅ*ü�%ǐCA
�ȪN = 40ȫ�ƺǑƥ+îô&,�@�Ȭ�+ĸŜDÇǭ�@ôƅ+ýȖ,ȬFdqȬđƤ}H
LET 中部支部研究紀要第 26 号(2014)
88
{`wFȬWtKw~ȬaW\xqaGFȬ�>*,ņœƉ;Ɵ�ǿė)(Ȭ�+üǰ9Ȭü
ǰ')@ǔ�ž+ŧÊƍǃŊ9¨�Ɗ)@9+&�@����"%Ȭôƅ¨×�ƱDĺ�+�
ĝĦ'C�&9)�A-ȬņœƺǑ*LjÓ,�"%9Ǖů*ș�%¨�ƓǮ9LjÓ9)
ôƅ9@�
5�Ȭ�ô&ôƽ�@÷ėǒƂ&�@ “Where are you from?” ; “What’s your name?”Ȭ “Do
you knowȸ” )(Dƃǚ�)ôƅ9ȪĀ)�'9øǵȗòʼn*,ȫĀ) >��?Ȭnjǧ+
ƽŽď,Ŭ�%ȩ',�)�
Ȱȭȯ� øǵ+ĬȤ
� ôőȗòĚȬŎ¯+ĸŜ&,MwK{`~Vu{DǐȬ�+ĚȰÝ+ĸŜ&,Ȭ\XQ'
=?FQ`Gi`G~*ǻ۸Ȭ©�ƍ*,Ȭåœƍ) SVşǿD# 7�ĦÓȤ�+
۸ȪƈâȒ, 2005ȫ;ȬåœŃäD�"�TptdS~Vu{FQ`Gi`GDǐ"���+
ĚȬnjǧTptdS~Vu{*ü�@IJİħĂďȪƗƈ, 2009ȫ+ÝƣDū8Ȭ10Ý*C�@
\XQDƇ�ǛǧĴÿDǐ"��ôőŒ*,`XbDǐȬ�+ĚȬȯÝƏ+ǴÚƨ1+Ý
ƣDū8��
œøǵ&,Ȭ�À¤,�ĸŜ&öƯ�ȬĸŜ+şĪ,WillisȪ1996ȫ+ĬŮDÂƾ*���
�)C!Ȭ�²\XQȪpre-taskȫ۸*=?\XQ+ÿ§'XO~o+şƤDǐȬ�+Ě\
XQUHQxȪtask-cycleȫ&qH{\XQ')@H{kLq~Vu{Ps_lDÑ7Tptd
S~Vu{\XQDǐ"��qH{\XQ+ȝ*,wOsXb;lz{lbDƇ%kG~c
g_QD��@�'*=?ǛǧėĒ1+Ū$�ȪnoticingȫD��Ȭ�+ĚqH{\XQDȃǐ
�@ȝ*ŏƇ&�"�ǒƂ;ǛǧėĒ+ôƽȪlanguage focusȫ;Ȭ�ADÑ7H{l_b۸
Dǐ'9+&�"���+ȝȬEllisȪ2003ȫ*ĜȬ�²*H{l_bD��%۸D
ȃǐ�@ȝ*ŏƇ')@ĤæDĻ��@�',�@�Ȭ�²*ėĒDĴÿ�@�',)�Ȭ��
+ėĒDƇ%\XQDǐ�'ė&\XQDȃǐ�@�'9��ȬėĒ+Ĵÿ,�2%
wFQ`G|*ǐ"�����"%œøǵª&,Ȭôƽƿ,åœƍ*\XQȃǐ*ŻźDÐ�Ȭ
Dž+Ǜ��'Dnjǧ&¥ǒƂ&�)'ħ��ȝ*,ȬÀǧÀ�&+ƌǣ;f{g~
gx}TptdS~Vu{�Ĺï�A��\XQUHQx&,ȶ³DƆ¬Ű¸*¥%ȬƆ¬Ű
¸,�'�%Xj~O{R۸&�"��ȬȰ³+۸,vH`G{RDū8@9+9�"��
ŎĚ*Ȭ�Ě\XQ۸,Ȭ�²\XQ۸&ǐ"�H{l_bǪȦ;Ȭ\XQUHQx&
ǐ"�ǪȦ*ș�%+ǚǨ;ȬǛǧėĒ*ŻźDĖ%�۸*¥%>A��
福田:コミュニケーションタスクを用いた英語授業は英語スピーキングに対する抵抗感を軽減するか
89
ǒȮȭ
�A�A+\Hl*��@\XQøǵ�
Xj~O{R
\XQ+�
�²\XQ۸ \XQUHQx*șȀ�@ªú&aG
QbRzXDǐ
\XQUHQx
nF+ôƅ�Ď×}ù+ę*)?Ȭ�A
�A��&�@ �ȩ�ê@��õ�dz
��'�ġǖ&�@ǃŊ'ƏƍDij
!ȬÙÖ+êdz�ųDǐǪȦDǐ
�Ě\XQ۸ rax]HFzRDǩ6Ȭ�ų*ŏƎ'
ƾ�>A@ǒƂ}ŃŮ�ȣ+Ǩň
vH`G{R
\XQ+�
�²\XQ۸ žǧ+njŃDǩ6Ȭ�+ŞǖDÜToŹ
Ɖ&ǒƂ�@
\XQUHQx �+ÜToŹƉ*#%+ǨňDnjǧ
&ō�ȬžǧŃ+ǖƦDöĪ��@
�Ě\XQ۸
�Ī��ÜToŹƉD�+ôƅ'Ǘ�
ÍȬ(+=)çȡDTo'�%®?
Æ"� DũǺ�ȬžǧœŃDÂż�)
�>ªú*ș�@ǯǬDǐ�5�Ȭǖ
ƦŃ+Ų±Dǐ
ȰȭȰ� a~\+ÅȞ
� a~\+ÅȞ,ƗƈȪ2009ȫ&�Ī�AȬÞóƍñĖģ�śǝ�A%@�njǧTptdS
~Vu{*ü�@IJİħĂď�+ǴÚƨ�Ƈ>A���+ǴÚƨ,�njǧ*=@Xj~O{
R+ÝȌȪ��ȬÝȌȫ�Ȭ��õ�Ȭ�njǧ&TptdS~Vu{DǐDŽ´�)'ǦƓȪ�
�ȬDŽ´ȫ�+ȰÞó*ü�%�A�AȰȣƏ�#ȬǜȶȣƏ >)@9+&�"��ôƽƿ,
�+ȶȣƏ*ü� 7ŨȜ+w_N~bXS~xȪȱ��ģź&Ȭ¢�ȩ3(IJİħ�ĕ�
'DƘ�ȫ&ÝƣDǐ"��
ȱȭƯŖ'ǯǬ
ǞǼưǜ+ƯŖȬIJx^+ tś÷+ƯŖȬÃ/·ŖȓDǒȯ*5'8%@��Ǘ�%(
+ǖÞ*�%9�²=?�Ě+3�ł¢���'�C @�ȬÎʼn*�²}�Ě'9*
ȴŨȜ&ȲƜď'Ȭœøǵ&+ôƽƿ, )?ȩIJİħDƘ�Ȭ�A,øǵĚ*9Ʋ%
@�'�C @��²ǫŘ'�ĚǫŘ&+Ɛüƍ)ë»+ćDȬtś÷*="%śǝ��'�
BȬ¨�ƍ)£Ð'�%,�+ć,ưǜƍ*ŏĦ&�"��Ȭ��+ǖÞDǗ@'ȬŏĦ*ł
¢�����+,�DŽ´�+ȣƏ+6&�"��
LET 中部支部研究紀要第 26 号(2014)
90
4
N = 40
t p r
5.68� 5.39� 0.29� 2.15 .038 * .33
0.96� 1.12� 0.83�
6.17� 5.51� 0.66� 3.77 <.001 * .52
1.15� 1.42� 1.08�
5.64� 5.51� 0.13� 0.75 .458 .12
1.77� 1.62� 1.05�
5.23� 5.15� 0.07� 0.28 .779 .05
1.74� 1.51� 1.49�
福田:コミュニケーションタスクを用いた英語授業は英語スピーキングに対する抵抗感を軽減するか
91
àȮȭ�²ǫŘ'�ĚǫŘ*��@ƯŖDǒ��Łĉà�a-d,�A�AȬa: ¨�ČãȬb: �DŽ
´�Ȭc: ��õ�Ȭd: �ÝȌ�+ƯŖDƘ�%@
àȰDǗ%C @=*Ȭ¨%+QvX\*�%�DŽ´�,ǹŴ�A%�?Ȭ�ÝƏ+ǫ
Ř*�%¨ǖÞ*ü�%ȩIJİħD9#'Ýƣ�%�QvX\ȪQvX\Ȯȫ,Ȭ¨ǖ
Þ*�%ľÛ�Ǘ>A��� �)�>Ȭ¨%+ǖÞ*�%IJİħ��'Ýƣ�%�
QvX\ȪQvX\Ȱȫ���õ�Dé¶��@'DZ+ĘȢ�Ǘ>A���A,ȬQvX
\Ȯ+ǚȐ9Ñ8�Čã1+Ýċ�+ĘȢ9ƾ�>A@�Ȭ¦ǐƕƞ+ƘØ�@=*Ȭnjǧ
*=@Xj~O{R+۸�ôƽƿ+�õDĕ»�%�5ÉDŽģ�ȬœǫŘ&9Ľij�A�
'�@�� �)�>Ȭ�+QvX\Ȱ*�%9Ȭ�DŽ´�*ș�@IJİħ,ƶÕ�A@'
ƯŖ�Ƙ�A��DžĈ+DŽ´Dǁ÷ƍ*Ǘ@�'�&�@=*)"��'�ē�Ȕ')
?Ȭ�+ĚȄĐƍ*��õ�1+NJĘȢDÃ4�ÉDŽģ9ƾ�>A@�5�Ȭ�ÝȌ�*ș�
%,ȬÀ)@Ġƃſģ&,)�ǐ¸ȡ9Ñ7ǖÞ&�@+&ȬĠƃƍ)ë»*Ʋ%ǐ¸ƍ)
ë»�9�>�A@ÉDŽģ,½*ƾ�>A@��+ź*ș�%,ȬŌ*ȕőƍ)�§·ŖD
ē�Ʋ�ǫŘ�%���
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
01
23
45
67
a
pre
post
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
01
23
45
67
b
pre
post
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
01
23
45
67
c
pre
post
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
01
23
45
67
d
pre
post
LET 中部支部研究紀要第 26 号(2014)
92
àȯȭQvX\ŕ*å$�ÌQvX\+ſğ
ǒȰȭ
�A�A+QvX\*��@ł¢*å$�ſğ+ǞǼ
QvX\Ȯ
(n = 15)
QvX\ȯ
(n = 9)
QvX\Ȱ
(n = 7)
QvX\ȱ
(n = 9)
DŽ´ ȩ � � ȩ
�õ ȩ ȩ � ȩ
ÝȌ ȩ � � �
àȰȭ�A�A+QvX\*��@ǖÞ�'+Čã¢+ë»
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
� �� �
Scale
�����
�����
����
�����
!1.5
!1
!0.5
0
0.5
1���� ����� ����� �����
�� �� � �
福田:コミュニケーションタスクを用いた英語授業は英語スピーキングに対する抵抗感を軽減するか
93
n % n % n % n %
11 73% 6 67% 3 43% 6 67%
2 13% 2 22% 4 57% 3 33%
2 13% 1 11% 0 0% 0 0% 10 67% 5 56% 3 43% 9 100%
0 0% 3 33% 1 14% 0 0%
5 33% 1 11% 3 43% 0 0%
8 53% 5 56% 2 29% 5 56%
1 7% 3 33% 5 71% 2 22%
6 40% 1 11% 0 0% 2 22% 9 60% 3 33% 3 43% 5 56%
3 20% 5 56% 3 43% 4 44%
3 20% 1 11% 1 14% 0 0%
2009 2014 Amano
2014
LET 中部支部研究紀要第 26 号(2014)
94
ÂƾŃƁ
Amano, S. (2014). Reducing the unwillingness to speak English by using total physical response
activities in a Japanese university context. Journal of the Chubu English Language Education
Society, 43, 153–160.
Ellis, R. (2003). Task-based language learning and teaching. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ǐƈ¿ȍȪ2014ȫ�\XQDŰƇ��njǧĸŜ*��@ôƽƿ+njǧȆƇDŽ´'ĤĦȡ+ëú�
¨ánjǧŀǂô�Ơ 40ÝĞĄî�.
Horwitz, E. K., Horwitz, M. B., & Cope, J. (1986). Foreign language classroom anxiety. The Modern
Language Journal, 70, 125-132.
ƗƈDzȈȪ2009ȫ�njǧ&+Xj~O{R*ü�@IJİħ+ǹŴ�JACET Journal, 48, 53-66.
Maekawa, Y. & Yashima, T. (2012). Examining the motivational effect of presentation-based instruction
on Japanese engineering students: From the viewpoints of the ideal self and self-determination
theory. Language, Education, & Technology, 49, 65-92.
Willis, J. (1996). A framework for task-based learning. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Yashima, T., Zenuk-Nishide, L., & Shimizu, K. (2004). Influence of attitudes and affect on L2
communication: A study of Japanese high school students. Language Learning, 54, 119-152.
Ǔȋȭ
ǴÚȣƏȪƗƈȬ2009Ȭp. 58ȫ
Ȯȭƚ�ǣ�njǧ,ȬƐĬ*ĦÓ��C>)'Ģ5�� � � � � � � � � ȪDŽ´Ȯȫ
ȯȭƚ,Ȭ�'njǧ&ǣ�'�ȬƳĔ�5�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ȫ�õȮȫ
Ȱȭƚ,Ȭ&�A-�'njǧ&ǣ����?5�E� � � � � � � � � � � � ȪÝȌȮȫ
ȱȭƚ,Ȭ�+njǧ´&,njǧ&ǣ��',&�)'Ģ5�� � � � � � ȪDŽ´ȯȫ
Ȳȭƚ,Ȭ�'njǧ&ǣ�'�Ȭ(�(��5�� � � � � � � � � � � � � Ȫ�õȯȫ
ȳȭƚ,Ȭ�'njǧ&ǣ��',Ȍ��&�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ȪÝȌȯȫ
ȴȭƚ,Ȭnjǧ&ǣ�%ȬDž�ƾ�%@�'DƐĬ*��@�'�&�)
'Ģ5�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ȪDŽ´Ȱȫ
ȵȭƚ,Ȭ�'njǧ&ǣ�'�Ȭwv_QX�%5�� � � � � � � � � � Ȫ�õȰȫ
ȶȭƚ,Ȭnjǧ&ǣ�)�A-)>)'�,Ȭ&�@ ��:2>)=
*�%�&�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ȪÝȌȰȫ