- 2.4 – micropollutants
TRANSCRIPT
- 2.4 –
1
Micropollutants
MICROPOLLUTANTSChapter 3.8, 3.9 & 5.8 in Chapman et al.
Diederik Rousseau
2
Diederik RousseauTamara Avellan
Peter Kelderman
Online Module on Water Quality Assessment
CONTENTS
1. Types and origins of micropollutants
a) Inorganic: Heavy metals
b) Organic: PCB, PAH, Hormones and EDC, PPCPs & pesticides
3
PPCPs & pesticides
2. Bioaccumulation
3. Aquatic Ecotoxicology
4. Micropollutants in aquatic sediments
What are Micropollutants?
Inorganic and organic substances that can affect the environment in a
negative way even at very low concentrations, in the range of micro,
nano, pico-grams (µg/L (10-6 g/L); ng/L (10-9 g/L); pg/L (10-12 g/L))
4
Basically two types:
• “Heavy metals” (specific density > 4.5 kg/L) such as Cd, Pb, Cu, or
“trace metals” (Fe, Mn,..) and metalloids (As, V,..). These terms often
used as synonyms
• Organic micropollutants (DDT, PCBs,..)
Anthropogenic Sources of trace metals
5
Toxicity: The case of Cadmium in Japan
http://www.kanazawa-med.ac.jp/~pubhealt/cadmium2/itaiitai-e/itai04.html
6
• Itai-itai disease was found in the Cd polluted Jinzu River• Since the 1950's by the effort of inhabitants and Dr. Hagino• Itai-itai disease was officially recognized in 1968 as the first disease induced
by environmental pollution in Japan
Toxicity: The case of Hg in Manado Bay, Indonesia
• Gold mining with Hg extraction
• Discharge of Hg from rivers into bay
• Deposition and accumulation in
downstream locations
• Bioaccumulation in bivalves
Source: Lasut et al. (2005), Coastal Marine Science
7
Source: Lasut et al. (2005), Coastal Marine Science
Metal speciation:depends partly on redox potential (Eh, Volts), and pH
• Precipitation of PbO2 at high pH and high Eh (“aerobic conditions”)
• Low-neutral pH, high Eh: as Pb2+
• Solid Pb at low Eh (“anaerobic”for
8
• Solid Pb at low Eh (“anaerobic”foralmost all pH values)
• For intermediate Eh various dissolved species exist; at high pH and enough carbonate (“hardness”) also PbCO3 ↓
• Will influence availability for organisms; ionic form most toxic!
Organics
9
Organics – PAHs
PAHs (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons): 2-8 fused benzene rings.
May also contain S, O, N: are then called heterocyclic PAHs.
From combustion processes (automobiles, coal, oil, stacks..)
10
PAHs are hard to degrade and carcinogenic at low concentrations.
PAHs have large tendency to accumulate in sediments and in the
aquatic food chain.
Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs) in fish
Built up by two benzene rings + Clsubstitutions � more than 200 different PCB components (e.g. PCB- 28)
PCBs extremely stable; therefore widely used as thermal and electric insulators; in plastics, paints
PCBs have large tendency to be
11
PCBs have large tendency to be accumulated in sediments and in the food chain
Already at extremely low concentrations, there may be adverse effects on humans and aquatic life (“pseudo-sex hormone”)
Partial global ban in the 1980s; however still measurable concentrations (non-degradable).
Hormones
12
Hormones
13http://www.mindfully.org/Pesticide/Alligators-Apopka-PBS2jun98.htm
14
• Application rates
• Disposal of containers
• Washing of equipment
• Timing of application
Pesticide residues
15
• Timing of application
Agrochemicals in small scale farming in Ghana
16
Increased concentrations in wet season � effect of runoff
Source: Ntow (2008), PhD Thesis UNESCO-IHE
CONTENTS
1. Types and origin of micropollutants
a) Inorganic: Heavy metals
b) Organic: PCB, PAH, Hormones and EDC, PPCPs & pesticides
17
PPCPs & pesticides
2. Bioaccumulation
3. Aquatic Ecotoxicology
4. Micropollutants in aquatic sediments
Bioaccumulation:
increase in concentration of a pollutant from the environment to
the first organism in a food chain (i.e. in tissues)
Biomagnification:
Definitions
18
Biomagnification:
increase in concentration of a pollutant from one link in a food
chain to another
(Food chain/web: see Unit 5)
Bioaccumulation/magnification Process
19
CONTENTS
1. Types and origin of micropollutants
a) Inorganic: Heavy metals
b) Organic: PCB, PAH, Hormones and EDC, PPCPs & pesticides
20
PPCPs & pesticides
2. Bioaccumulation
3. Aquatic Ecotoxicology
4. Micropollutants in aquatic sediments
Start of Ecotoxicology � triggered by effects of DDT and
related organochlorine pesticides on birds and mammals
1962 - Rachel Carson: "Silent Spring”
21
Carson R (1962) Silent Spring. Houghton Mifflin Company, New York
Toxicology: science of poisons
ParacelsusA.P.T.B. von Hohenheim
1493 – 1541(Salzburg)
“Every chemical is poisonous,
22
“Every chemical is poisonous, dose determines the effect”
(“Alle Ding sind Gifft. Allein die Dosis macht daß ein Ding kein
Gifft ist”)
The dose-response-relationship
� the basis of (eco)toxicology
Survival, growth or other measure of performance
23
NOEC LC50 or LD50
(log) concentration
Ecotoxicological assessment: two parts
RISK
=
EXPOSURE
X
TOXICITY
24Source: Schwarzenbach et al. (2006)
Toxicological endpoints derived from dose-
response relationships
LC50: median lethal concentration
EC50: concentration causing 50% effect
25
50
NOEC: no observed effect concentration
These endpoints provide measure of toxicity
� Enable comparison of toxic potency of chemicals
� The lower the endpoint value, the more toxic the chemical
Chemical LD50
botulin-toxin A 0.0005
diphtheria-toxin 0.3
2,3,7,8-TCDD 1
tetrodotoxin 15
strychnin 500
aflatoxin 600
aldicarb 900
nicotin 1 000
Acute oral toxicity of selected chemicalsexpressed LD50
(lethal dose 50%) in µg per kg body weight
nicotin 1 000
Methyl mercury 1 000
parathion 3 000
HCN 10 000
thallium 10 000
DDT 113 000
Salt (NaCl) 4 000 000
Water (H2O) 160 000 000
The most standardized
aquatic test protocol
Test species Daphnia magna
Test duration 48 hTest system Static, no foodEndpoint MortalityParameter LC single compound
27
Parameter LC50 single compound
- toxicity tests on (extract of) environmental sample
- performed in the laboratory under controlled conditions
(may also be performed in the field)
- endpoints: survival, behaviour, growth, reproduction, etc.
Bioassays
Examples:
28
Examples:
• Bacterial tests (enzyme inhibition), e.g. ECHA test; metal-specific tests
• Microtox, using luminescent bacteria (Vibro fischeri)
• Algae (e.g. algal tox kit)
• Daphnids and other crustaceans, e.g. Daphtox, Rototox, Artoxkit)
Examples of toxkits used as bioassays
29
CONTENTS
1. Types and origin of micropollutants
a) Inorganic: Heavy metals
b) Organic: PCB, PAH, Hormones and EDC, PPCPs & pesticides
30
PPCPs & pesticides
2. Bioaccumulation
3. Aquatic Ecotoxicology
4. Micropollutants in aquatic sediments
WHY MONITORING AQUATIC SEDIMENTS?
• Sediments may be important “sinks” or “sources” of pollutants, e.g. of phosphorus (P) (Lake water balance � P mass balance: “In” –”out” terms � “Sediment P accumulation; may be > 80% ! (or P release)
• They may release pollutants (e.g. heavy metals) under certainconditions (pH, redox potential, salinity..)
31
conditions (pH, redox potential, salinity..)
• Sediments can give “history” of pollution
• Often slower (bio) degradation of pollutants, especially in anaerobicsediments
• Many bottom-dwelling organisms (fish, cockles) and rooted plants.
AQUATIC SEDIMENTS
Allogenic (or allochthonous) material, from outsidethe system (�)
Aquatic sediments complex mixture of minerals + organic compounds + bound ions:
32
the system (�)
• Endogenic minerals, from processes in the water system (sedimentation of carbonates, algae, etc.) (�)
• Authigenic (or authochtonous) minerals, by physico-chemical and microbiological processes in the sediment
MICROPOLLUTANTS IN AQUATIC SEDIMENTS
Micropollutants large tendency to be adsorbed onto suspended matter and sediments
Expressed with: partition coefficient P (L/kg) :
P = µµµµg micropollutant/kg particulate matter, divided by the µµµµg/L present in the water phase
33
µµµµg/L present in the water phase
Heavy metals 104 – 105 L/kgBenzo(a)pyrene (PAH) 104 - 105
PCBs 105 – 106
Methoxychlor 104
Naphthalene 103
Example: fate of dissolved heavy metals in the Dutch IJssel Lake
34
> 50% can be adsorbed onto particulate matter and thus be “lost” from the water.
THE FATE OF HEAVY METALS IN SEDIMENTS
No irreversibly bonding to the sediment; remobilisation by:
• Elevated salinity (e.g. in estuaries; Na+ replaces metal ions)
• For lower pH (higher [H+] which replaces metal ions)
• Redox potential Eh (“aerobic/anaerobic” conditions; slide 8):
35
• Redox potential Eh (“aerobic/anaerobic” conditions; slide 8):- Low Eh : precipitation of HMs as metal sulphides; - Aerobic conditions: S2- � SO4
2- ; more soluble � release HMs
• Biological and microbiological activities and conversions
• Sediment resuspension, due to waves and currents; dredging (see bullet point 3)
Minamata case, Japan:
• Industrial mercury pollution; many people were affected or even killed
• Sediments: up to 2000 mg Hg/kg (Standards: ~ 2 mg/kg)
36
(Standards: ~ 2 mg/kg)
• Methyl mercury uptake by fish � men
37
Degradation product of DDT (also toxic) in sediments of Lake Geneva (France/Switzerland)
SEDIMENT GRAIN SIZE
• Highest micropollutants contents on smallest sediment fraction (high
specific surface area)
Cadmium content on
river Rhine sediment
38
• By waves and currents, especially this “fine” sediment is transported to the
deeper areas � “sedimentation basins” of polluted sediments !
“sand” “silt” “clay”
>63 µm……… <63; > 2µm …….<2 µm
The role of sediments in water Qualty
Cu and Pb in Lake Ontario sediment profiles, 1985
Decrease due to recent sanitation measures
SEDIMENT CORES AS “HISTORICAL CALENDARS”
39
Background; increase in 1900s (industrialization)
Hg (ppm = mg/kg)
Top layer: 1960/65 sohardly any decrease yet(no abatement measures)
40
Background concentration,
before around 1800
Sediment depth = “history”
“Age” determined with e.g. radioactive dating (210Pb or 137Cs)
RADIOACTIVE SEDIMENT DATING
Effect of nuclear tests in the 1960s
41
• 210Pb (half life = 22 years)• Chernobyl accident (1986): 137Cs (half life = 30 years)
Overall
In the Netherlands, four sediment quality classes: heavy metals and organic micropollutants (mg/kg = ppm) :• class 1 +2 can be dumped into the environment • class 3+4 sediments: stored and/or cleaned-up
MANAGEMENT POLLUTED SEDIMENTS
4242
assessment:
“worst case”
E.g. Cu in class 4 -->
whole sediment
in class 4 !
43
Sediment research in a Dutch lake, using “grab sampler” and “core sampler”
44