wmata recruitment and hiring plan · – implemented the technical skills program (tsp) (hrms...
TRANSCRIPT
opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
WMATA Recruitmentand Hiring Plan
Presented to:Administration Committee
October 6, 2005
9/29/2005 2opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20052
Purpose
To inform the Board of a Recruitment andHiring Plan to address the high number ofvacancies and to recommend a revision toPerformance Policies & Procedures Manual(PPPM) 4.1, Employment Categories.
9/29/2005 3opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20053
Background
• WMATA currently has an Authority-wide 7.0%vacancy rate. Within Operations, the vacancy rateis currently 5.0%.
• A high vacancy rate impacts the Authority in variousways:– Overtime cost– Customer service– Work place stress– Employee morale
.
9/29/2005 4opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20054
Challenges to Filling Vacancies• Scarcity of specialized skills in the local market
(Washington not industrialized market), especially in thejobs below:– Bus Mechanics/Rail Mechanics– Elevator/Escalator Technicians– Plumbers, Electricians, HVAC
• Requirements for certifications/licenses• New hires are required to work the less desirable weekend
and night shifts• Difficulty in attracting professionally licensed candidates
– Engineers– Architects
9/29/2005 5opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20055
Challenges to Filling Vacancies
• Minimum age of 21 required for Commercial Driver’sLicense (CDL) in order to cross jurisdictional lines(DOT/FTA requirement)
• Work force is changing. Today’s applicants are lessattracted to regimented working conditions
• Management and professional employee turnover isfueled by the advent of Defined Contribution Plans, asopposed to Defined Benefit Plans.
9/29/2005 6opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20056
Challenges to Filling Vacancies• In addition to skill gaps and labor shortages, we find a
number of applicants cannot pass either the drug/alcoholtests, physicals or background checks
• We also find it difficult to recruit salaried employees forwhat we believe is related to:– High cost of living in local area– Lack of interest in the transit industry– Negative press coverage– Several years of low salary percentage increases (5.5% over 3
years compared to the local jurisdictions of 11.1%, and theFederal Government, which is 17.9%)
– Salary ranges have not been adjusted in three years
9/29/2005 7opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20057
Efforts to Fill Vacancies• The Authority has implemented various methods to fill key
vacancies:– Post vacancies online at military and professional
association websites– Use executive search firms where appropriate– Conduct open houses at Bus Yards– Advertise within the bus and rail system to solicit mechanics– Implemented the Technical Skills Program (TSP)
(HRMS coordinate with local technical schools)– Negotiated a scarce skill provision with the Union in order to
compete for elevator/escalator technicians
9/29/2005 8opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20058
Efforts to Fill Vacancies
• Extended advertising sources and geographical outreachto include print and electronic media (i.e., Detroit, MI;Virginia Beach, VA; Norfolk, VA; Wilmington, DE;Chicago, IL; Boston, MA and Jacksonville,FL)
• Increased participation in various job fairs/open houseswithin and outside the DC metropolitan area
9/29/2005 9opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/20059
Efforts to Fill Vacancies
Collective Bargaining Initiatives• Negotiating with Union to focus on customer service,
attendance and disciplinary record as criteria for advancement• Negotiating with Union over lock-in periods once seniority is
exercised to address migration of employees between bus andrail
• Negotiating with Union to address safety issues relating toindividual overtime work
• Discussing with Union the updating of key job descriptions tostrengthen required skill sets
9/29/2005 10opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200510
Recruitment Best Practices• In addition to what WMATA is currently doing, industry research
organizations, i.e., Corporate Leadership Council (CLC); Societyfor Human Resource Management (SHRM); and WorkforceManagement (WFM), recommend the use of employee referralprograms and signing bonuses as recruitment tools
• The above organizations also recommend partnering withcolleges and universities, engineering and technical schools
• The American Association of Retired People (AARP)recommends using strategies that retain older workers andrecommends considering re-hiring retirees thus eliminating thelearning curve and retaining institutional knowledge
9/29/2005 11opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200511
Recruitment Best Practices
• Use of Recruitment Research Services– Supplements traditional recruitment methods (i.e.,
newspapers and Internet)
– Focuses on the passive candidate market
– Establishes direct contact with people in positionsthat they have been asked to target
9/29/2005 12opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200512
Benchmarks – Other Transits• Nine (9) other major transits confirmed that they are
experiencing similar hiring challenges. Variousstrategies are being implemented with different degreesof success, e.g.,– Provide buses to technical/mechanical schools so their
students learn how to make repairs on buses– Assist with the development of curriculums at vocational
schools– Defray costs of CDL learner permits through grant
funding– Utilize employee referral programs
9/29/2005 13opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200513
Benchmarks – Local Jurisdictions
• In addition to what WMATA is currently doing,local jurisdictions have:– Utilized continuous open recruitment
– Modified salary ranges
– Instituted employee referral programs
9/29/2005 14opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200514
Recruitment & Hiring Plan Elements• Expand the employment partnerships both within and
outside the local market• Expand the number of jobs fairs and employment
workshops to better educate interested persons aboutcareer opportunities at WMATA
• Realign the recruitment staff in HR’s Employment ServicesBranch to the four (4) major divisions within WMATA
• Partner with the Washington Consortium of Colleges andUniversities to establish a college intern program forengineers
9/29/2005 15opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200515
Recruitment & Hiring Plan Elements• Establish an employee referral program* for key positions in an effort
to encourage WMATA employees to refer qualified candidates
• Establish a signing bonus program* for key critical positions to inducequalified applicants to accept positions with WMATA
• Incorporate salary range adjustments as part of the annual budgetreview process for each fiscal year
• Initiate recruitment efforts to re-hire WMATA retirees in vacantpositions
• Plan elements subject to collective bargaining will be added afternegotiations are completed
• *Will be funded out of recruitment and advertising budget
9/29/2005 16opensdoors
Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority
9/29/200516
Recommended Board Action
Request the Administration Committeerecommend approval to the Board:– Revise Personnel Policy and Procedure (PPPM 4.1,
Employment Categories) regarding the ability torehire WMATA retirees. Amendment of the WMATARetirement Plan to clarify that the retirees receive noadditional credit in that plan when they are hired inpositions covered by other pension plans.