why banks are reluctant to give mortgage loans after the 2008 recession
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
1/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans after the 2008 Recession
Ngaji, Terngu
Loyola Marymount University
April 25, 2013
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
2/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 2
Table of Contents
Abstract ....................................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 4
The economic conditions for housing and mortgages before the 2008 recession ...................... 5
The reaction of banks after the 2008 recession .......................................................................... 6
The new rules for acquiring mortgage loans .............................................................................. 8
Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 9
References ................................................................................................................................ 11
Internet links ............................................................................................................................. 12
Appendix I ................................................................................................................................ 13
Appendix II ............................................................................................................................... 14
Appendix III ............................................................................................................................. 18
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
3/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 3
Abstract
This paper unveils some of the reasons why banks and other lending financial institutions are
strict in giving out mortgage loans after the 2008 recession in United States. The paper
focuses on how financial institutions decisions about loans affect the housing industry and
the economy. The study used secondary sources of data to support the conclusions that were
drawn. The introduction gave a brief background and the objective of the study. The body of
the paper provides details of how the Fed, the Congress, the Federal Housing Administration,
the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau, and financial institutions play active roles to
restoring the housing and financial industries and the economy. The paper ends with
Appendices I through III and are deemed to be helpful in providing details about some
information in the work.
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
4/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 4
Introduction
Before the 2008 economic downturn many financial institutions felt comfortable in
giving out loans to homebuyers. The requirements needed to get loans were less stringent
compared to the post 2008 recession period. For example banks were lending to people with
FICO scores less than 590 before the economic downturn.1 This trend led to a sharp increase
in debt financing in the housing industry. As a result the willingness of households to obtain
debt financing and acquire homes increased. Since housing and employment are correlated
many working individuals remained assured that they would pay off their debts. However, the
rise in unemployment, which began in the third quarter of 2007 to 2008, affected many
households and resulted to default in mortgage payments. The states, such as California and
Nevada, where banks were found of giving huge amounts of loans easily were severely
affected. This in turn affected many financial intuitions and the housing industry in the
United States. This paper focuses on how banks decisions on giving mortgages affect the
housing industry and the economy.
The objective of this paper is to examine why financial institutions are reluctant in
giving mortgages to homebuyers after the 2008 recession. The Mortgage interest rates in
2013 are below 3.75 percent but why are banks not willing to lend to homebuyers? Why are
the Federal Reserve (the Fed), Federal Housing Administration (FHA), the Congress, and
banks setting stricter requirements for homebuyers? This paper will answer such questions
and will throw more light on the key roles the Fed and the financial institutions play in the
housing industry.
1 According to the Wall Street Journal (2012) many banks gave loans to applicants with FICO scores less than580 before the recession. The FHA FICO score minimum requirement before the 2008 recession was 580(Federal Housing Administraton, 2013).
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
5/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 5
The Economic Conditions for Housing and Mortgages before the 2008 Recession
Before the second quarter of 2008 the economic status of United States was at least on
the rise but not sufficient enough in the years of 2006 and 2007 to state that there was an
increase in the nations wealth as opposed to 2002 and 2003. Of course the construction and
manufacturing industries were booming. Investors in the real estate and house builders were
hopeful that the positive outcomes in the housing industry will be consistent for a while.
Moreover, loans were almost readily available for those who were willing to apply for them,
and buy a house, from the banks. Many banks had less strict rules in lending because default
rates were low until the third quarter of 2007 through 2008. Figure 1 shows the Federal
Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) data on mortgage default rates.
Figure 1: The mortgage default (delinquency) trend.2
2In his work, Lounsbury (2010), provided the total delinquent and default rate graph to demonstrate how mortgagedefaults were at all-time high in 2008. For more information use this link:http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/10/the-alchemy-of-securitization.html.
http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/10/the-alchemy-of-securitization.htmlhttp://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/10/the-alchemy-of-securitization.htmlhttp://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/10/the-alchemy-of-securitization.html -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
6/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 6
Throughout 2004 to 2006 financial institutions experienced less mortgage defaults
because the unemployment rate (the unemployment rate before 2008 was approximately 4.6
percent)3 was low and the GDP for the years 2006 to 2007 increased on the average of 2.2
while the cost of living of an average United States citizen was low.4 With these favorable
conditions what led to the dramatic housing default across United States and especially in
California? This question may have more than one answer but the two prominent ones are the
huge housing leverage (that is, debt financing by the banks) and the large unemployment rate
that contributed to the 2008 recession.
The Reaction of Banks after the 2008 Recession
In the beginning of the year 2000, few manufacturing companies were adopting
strategies that will lower their costs of production. Since labor is a variable cost companies
moved some jobs outside United States where labor costs were less and this trend noticeably
made many United States citizens unemployed and others laid off. 5 The correlation between
employment and the ability to make payment on mortgages came into play across United
States. In California, for instance, default on mortgage payments started increasing in 2007
alongside with the rate of unemployment. If you notice the default rate began to increase
significantly in 2007 in figure 1 on page 4 in accordance with the rising unemployment in
figure 2 on page 7.
Many financial institutions that gave loans had to foreclose and repossess the houses
they issued out mortgages for. In some cases the FHA with the congress required the banks to
3 This figure was given by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (2007). www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2007.4 According to the Bureau of Economic Analysis (2008), and the National Bureau of Economic Research (2008), theGDP for 2007 increased by 4.6 percent and the recession peaked on December. For details follow these links: BEA:www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/2008; NBER:http://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.html.5 For many authors many companies such as Hewlett-Packard and IBM led the way and adopted off-shoringstrategy before the year 2000.
http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2007http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2007http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/2008http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/2008http://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.htmlhttp://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.htmlhttp://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.htmlhttp://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.htmlhttp://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/2008http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2007 -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
7/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 7
lower the mortgage interest rates so that some homeowners would be able to continue with
their payments (Adelino, Schoar, & Severino, 2012). This applies especially to United States
citizens living on fixed incomes after the 2008 recession. Because the Fed, FHA, the congress
and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) instructed banks to reduce mortgage
interest rates to encourage consumers to purchase more houses in the market, the Fed required
banks to impose strict conditions for lending.
Figure 2: The California unemployment rate.6
Figure 3: The 30-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgage as of April 18, 2013.7
6 Source: California Employment Development Department. For details visithttp://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article11503.html andwww.edd.ca.gov.7 As of April 18, 2013, the average mortgage rate in United States was 3.52 (2013). Refer to appendix 1 for thegraph of mortgage rates of over two decades in United States for details.
http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article11503.htmlhttp://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article11503.htmlhttp://www.edd.ca.gov/http://www.edd.ca.gov/http://www.edd.ca.gov/http://www.edd.ca.gov/http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article11503.html -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
8/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 8
Despite the low 3.62 percent interest rate on mortgages beginning from 2012 as the
figure 3 on page 6 depicts, the supply of mortgages is relatively low. This is because banks
face huge penalties when there are defaults on mortgage payments. Most of the penalties
were set by CFPB and approved by the congress, the Fed and, the President of United States,
Barack Obama.
The New Rules for Acquiring Mortgage Loans
Banks are now requiring homebuyers to put down full payment, two-thirds, or over 20
percent of their payments among other strict requirements. Banks are also sticking to the
principle that loan applicants obligations8 should not exceed 36 percent of the applicants
monthly gross income for the applicants to be qualified. Of course, there are exceptions,
some home owners are buying homes without making full payments but they must meet the
strict rules offered by the banks. If banks believe that some loans will cause them trouble
down the road or are more expensive to offer, then the banks will not offer those loans
(Bernard, 2009). This is because the Fed, FHA, Congress and the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau have recently come up with a set of rules that banks must follow in
supplying loans to homebuyers. Some of the rules offered by the CFPB are listed below.9
Details of Applicants financial information must be supplied and verified. Borrowers must have sufficient assets or income to pay back the mortgage.
8 Obligations in this context refer to car loans, mortgage, child support and alimony, credit card bills, student loans,medical debt, and the like. Banks require that the applicants monthly obligations should not exceed 36 percent ofthe applicants gross monthly income. In addition, the mortgage payments only should not exceed 28 percent of theapplicants gross monthly income. According to Bernard (2009), financial advisers recommend reverting to an oldstandard known as the 28/36 rule.9According to CFPB (2013), these rules were given by CFPB to lending financial institutions in United States and
were approved by the Congress, the Fed, and the FHA. Refer to appendix II and appendix III for the details of therules. You may also use these links for details:http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdfandhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-summary.pdf.
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-summary.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-summary.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-summary.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-summary.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdfhttp://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdf -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
9/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 9
For consumers trying to refinance a risky loan, exemptions apply. No excess upfront points and fees for qualified mortgages. No toxic loan features for qualified mortgages. Cap on how much income can go toward debt. No loans with a balloon payment except those made by smaller creditors in rural or
underserved areas.
Because these rules came at the time when the prospects for the sale of new homes are
high, the banks are also strict in giving out loans. While the Fed and the financial institutions
are chiefly concerned with restoring their financial credibility in giving out loans, the CFPB is
at the same time focused on protecting consumers from getting irresponsible loans from
financial institutions that use the push-strategy and aggressive techniques to supply mortgages
to unqualified borrowers. Even though there is ample supply of houses in the market only
few homebuyers are willing to purchase them. As a result the inventory of houses keeps piling
as no buyers are available.
Conclusion
The economic downturn in 2008 served as the catalyst for the Fed, the FHA, the
Congress, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the financial institutions in United
States to come up with measures to revamp the housing and financial industries. Banks are
mainly concerned with applicants ability to repay their mortgages. For that reason
applicants credit history, monthly gross income and how much cash the mortgage applicants
can accumulate for down payment is considered. In early 2012, the FHA new FICO score
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
10/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 10
requirement for applicants is 620 minimum.10 In addition, the loan applicants debt-to-
income ratio has to be substantially low or below 43 percent. For these reasons, among others,
mortgages are harder to get by many potential homebuyers.
10Federal Housing Administration (2013). http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325.
http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325 -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
11/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 11
References
Adelino, M., Schoar, A., & Severino, F. (2012). Credit Supply and House Prices: Evidence
from Mortgage Market Segmentation. The National Bureau of Economic Research.
Bankrate.com. (2013, April 13).National Mortgage Rates For April 18, 2013. Retrieved from
www.bankrate.com: http://www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rate-roundup.aspx
Bernard, T. S. (2009, March 20). With Eyes Bigger Than Their Wallets, Homebuyers Are
Forced to Revisit Old Rules. The New York Times.
Bureau of Economic Analysis. (2008, February 28). Gross Domestic Product: Fouth Quarter
2007 (Preliminary). Retrieved from U.S Department of Commerce:
http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/2008/gdp407p.htm
Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2007, April 9). Unemployment Rate. Retrieved from United
States Department of Labor: http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2007/apr/wk2/art01.htm
Consumer Finance Protection Bureau. (2013, January 10). Protecting Consumers From
Irresponsible Mortgage Lending. Retrieved from www.onsumerfinance.gov:
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201301_cfpb_ability-to-repay-factsheet.pdf
Federal Housing Administraton. (2013). FHA Loan Articles. Retrieved from The Facts About
FHA Credit Requirements: http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325
Lounsbury, J. (2010, October 21). Credit Writedowns. Retrieved from The Alchemy of
Securitization: http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/10/the-alchemy-of-
securitization.html
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
12/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 12
National Bureau of Economic Research. (2008, December 11).Determination of the
December 2007 Peak in Economic Activity. Retrieved from Business Cycle Dating
Committee, National Bureau of Economic Research:
http://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.html
Wall Street Journal. (2012, October 31). Banks Not Making Getting a Mortgage Easier.
Market Watch, p. 1.
Internet Links
www.edd.ca.gov
www.ecapesomewhere.com
www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rate-roundup.aspx
www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325
http://www.edd.ca.gov/http://www.edd.ca.gov/http://www.ecapesomewhere.com/http://www.ecapesomewhere.com/http://www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rate-roundup.aspxhttp://www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rate-roundup.aspxhttp://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325http://www.fha.com/fha_article.cfm?id=325http://www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rate-roundup.aspxhttp://www.ecapesomewhere.com/http://www.edd.ca.gov/ -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
13/24
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 13
Appendix I
The 30-Year Fixed mortgage rates over a Period of 38 Years.11
11 Source:www.escapesomewhere.com/rates.html.
http://www.escapesomewhere.com/rates.htmlhttp://www.escapesomewhere.com/rates.htmlhttp://www.escapesomewhere.com/rates.htmlhttp://www.escapesomewhere.com/rates.html -
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
14/24
January 10, 2013
PROTECTING CONSUMERS FROM IRRESPONSIBLE MORTGAGE LENDING
When consumers apply for a mortgage, they often struggle to understand how much of a monthly
payment they can afford to take on. They may assume that lenders and mortgage brokers will not make
loans that people cannot afford. But in the years leading up to the financial crisis, lenders too often
made mortgages that could not be paid back.
Today the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) is finalizing the Ability-to-Repay rule that
requires lenders to obtain and verify information to determine whether a consumer can afford to repay
the mortgage. This is one of the signature new rules the CFPB is issuing to meet its goal to help restore
trust in the mortgage market.
BACKGROUND
In the lead up to the financial crisis, certain lending practices set consumers up to fail withmortgages they could not afford. Lenders sold no-doc and low-doc loans where consumers were
qualifying for loans beyond their means. Lenders also sold risky and complicated mortgages like
interest-only loans, negative-amortization loans where the principal and eventually the monthly
payment increases, hybrid adjustable-rate mortgages where the rate was set artificially low for years
and then adjusted upwards, and option adjustable-rate mortgages where the consumer could pick
a payment which might result in negative amortization and eventually higher monthly payments.
The deterioration in underwriting standards contributed to dramatic increases in mortgagedelinquencies and rates of foreclosures. What followed was the collapse of the housing market in
2008, and the subsequent financial crisis.
The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act recognized the need tomandate that lenders ensure consumers have the ability to pay back their mortgages.Under the
law, responsibility for drafting the Ability-to-Repay rule initially fell to the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System. Then, the CFPB took over responsibility in July 2011. The Act also provides
the CFPB the authority to define criteria for certain loans called Qualified Mortgages that are
presumed to meet the Ability-to-Repay rule requirements.
The CFPB conducted extensive research and analysis. In May 2012, the CFPB sought publiccomment on new data and information. Through meetings with stakeholders on all sides, and
rigorous analysis and research, the CFPB has come up with todays rule.
The Ability-to-Repay rule protects consumers from risky practices that helped cause the crisis. Ithelps ensure that responsible consumers get responsible loans. And it helps ensure that lenders can
extend credit responsibly without worrying about competition from unscrupulous lenders.
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 14
Appendix II
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
15/24
ABILITY TO REPAY
Under the new Ability-to-Repay rule, lenders will have to determine the consumers ability to pay back
both the principal and the interest over the long term not just during an introductory period when the
rate may be lower. Lenders can no longer offer no-doc, low-doc loans, otherwise known as Alt-A
loans, where some lenders made quick sales by not requiring documentation, then offloaded these risky
mortgages by selling them to investors.
Financial information has to be supplied and verified: Lenders must look at a consumers financialrecords and verify them. At a minimum, a lender must consider eight underwriting standards:
o Current income or assets;o Current employment status;o Credit history;o The monthly payment for the mortgage;o The monthly payments on any other loans associated with the property;o The monthly payment for other mortgage related obligations (such as property taxes);o Other debt obligations; ando The monthly debt-to-income ratio or residual income the borrower would be taking on with the
mortgage. (Debt-to-income ratio is a consumers total monthly debt divided by their totalmonthly gross income).
A borrower has to have sufficient assets or income to pay back the mortgage: Lenders must makethe determination the borrower can repay the loan by looking at the borrowers income and any
assets they have on hand.
Teaser rates can no longer mask the true cost of a mortgage: Lenders cant base their evaluation ofa consumers ability to repay the loan on teaser rates. Lenders will have to determine the
consumers ability to repay both the principal and the interest over the long term.
For consumers trying to refinance a risky loan, exemptions apply: Creditors refinancing a borrowerfrom a risky mortgage such as an adjustable-rate mortgage, an interest-only loan, or a negative-amortization loan to a more stable, standard loan can do so without undertaking the full
underwriting process required by the new rules.
QUALIFIED MORTGAGES
Lenders will be presumed to have complied with the Ability-to-Repay rule if they issue Qualified
Mortgages. Qualified Mortgages must meet certain requirements which prohibit or limit the risky
features that harmed consumers in the recent mortgage crisis.
Features of Qualified Mortgages:
No excess upfront points and fees: A Qualified Mortgage limits points and fees including those usedto compensate loan originators, such as loan officers and brokers. When lenders tack on excessive
points and fees to the origination costs, consumers end up paying a lot more than planned.
No toxic loan features: Qualified Mortgages cant have the loan features that were associated withrisky mortgages in the lead up to the crisis. Certain loans cannot be Qualified Mortgages:
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 15
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
16/24
o No interest-only loans, which are when a consumer only pays the interest for a specified amountof time so the principal does not decrease with payments;
o No loans where the principal amount increases, such as a negative-amortization loan; ando No loans where the term is longer than 30 years.
Cap on how much income can go toward debt: Qualified Mortgages generally will be provided topeople who have debt-to-income ratios less than or equal to 43 percent. This cap on debt ensures
consumers are only getting what they can likely afford. Before the crisis, many consumers took on
mortgages that raised their debt levels so high that it was nearly impossible for them to repay the
loan considering all their financial obligations. For a temporary, transitional period, loans that do not
have a 43 percent debt-to-income ratio but meet government affordability or other standards
such as that they are eligible for purchase by the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie
Mae) or the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) will be considered Qualified
Mortgages.
No loans with a balloon payment except those made by smaller creditors in rural or underservedareas: The law generally prohibits loans with balloon payments from being Qualified Mortgages.
Balloon-payment loans require a larger-than-usual payment at the end of the loan term. A smallcreditor operating in rural or underserved areas is permitted to originate such loans as Qualified
Mortgages under certain defined circumstances.
Types of Qualified Mortgages:
Qualified Mortgages with rebuttable presumption:These are higher-priced loans typically forconsumers with insufficient or weak credit history. If the loan goes south, the consumer can rebut
the presumption that the creditor properly took into account their ability to repay the loan. They
would have to prove the creditor did not consider their living expenses after their mortgage and
other debts. This does not affect the rights of a consumer to challenge a lender for violating any
other federal consumer protection laws.
Qualified Mortgages with safe harbor: These are lower-priced loans that are typically made toborrowers who pose fewer risks. If the loan goes south, the lender will be considered to have legally
satisfied the ability-to-repay requirements. But consumers can still legally challenge their lender
under this rule if they believe that the loan does not meet the definition of a Qualified Mortgage.
This does not affect the rights of a consumer to challenge a lender for violating any other federal
consumer protection laws.
PROPOSED ABILITY-TO-REPAY AMENDMENTS
Today, the CFPB is also inviting comment on proposed amendments to its Ability-to-Repay rule that
include:
Exemptions for nonprofit creditors that work to help low- to moderate-income consumers obtainaffordable housing;
Exemptions for housing finance agencies and lenders participating in housing finance agencyprograms intended to foster community development;
Exemptions for homeownership stabilization programs that work to prevent foreclosures, such asprograms operating in conjunction with the Making Home Affordable program;
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 16
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
17/24
A provision to give Qualified Mortgage status to small creditors, such as community banks and creditunions that make and hold loans in their own portfolios.
As part of this proposal, the CFPB is also seeking comment on how best to calculate the loan origination
compensation that will be part of the limitation on points and fees for Qualified Mortgages.
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 17
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
18/24
SUMMARY OF THE ABILITY-TO-REPAY AND QUALIFIED MORTGAGE RULE AND THE
CONCURRENT PROPOSAL
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (Bureau) is issuing a final rule to implement
laws requiring mortgage lenders to consider consumers ability to repay home loans before
extending them credit. The rule will take effect on January 10, 2014.
The Bureau is also releasing a proposal to seek comment on whether to adjust the final
rule for certain community-based lenders, housing stabilization programs, certain refinancing
programs of the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) or the Federal Home Loan
Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) (collectively, the GSEs) and Federal agencies, and small
portfolio creditors. The Bureau expects to finalize the concurrent proposal this spring so that
affected creditors can prepare for the January 2014 effective date.
Background
During the years preceding the mortgage crisis, too many mortgages were made to
consumers without regard to the consumers ability to repay the loans. Loose underwriting
practices by some creditorsincluding failure to verify the consumers income or debts and
qualifying consumers for mortgages based on teaser interest rates that would cause monthly
payments to jump to unaffordable levels after the first few yearscontributed to a mortgage
crisis that led to the nations most serious recession since the Great Depression.
In response to this crisis, in 2008 the Federal Reserve Board (Board) adopted a rule under
the Truth in Lending Act which prohibits creditors from making higher-price mortgage loans
without assessing consumers ability to repay the loans. Under the Boards rule, a creditor is
presumed to have complied with the ability-to-repay requirement if the creditor follows certain
specified underwriting practices. This rule has been in effect since October 2009.
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 18
Appendix III
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
19/24
In the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, Congress
required that for residential mortgages, creditors must make a reasonable and good faith
determination based on verified and documented information that the consumer has a reasonable
ability to repay the loan according to its terms. Congress also established a presumption of
compliance for a certain category of mortgages, called qualified mortgages. These provisions
are similar, but not identical to, the Boards 2008 rule and cover the entire mortgage market
rather than simply higher-priced mortgages. The Board proposed a rule to implement the new
statutory requirements before authority passed to the Bureau to finalize the rule.
Summary of Final Rule
The final rule contains the following key elements:
Ability-to-Repay Determinations. The final rule describes certain minimum requirements
for creditors making ability-to-repay determinations, but does not dictate that they follow
particular underwriting models. At a minimum, creditors generally must consider eight
underwriting factors: (1) current or reasonably expected income or assets; (2) current
employment status; (3) the monthly payment on the covered transaction; (4) the monthly
payment on any simultaneous loan; (5) the monthly payment for mortgage-related obligations;
(6) current debt obligations, alimony, and child support; (7) the monthly debt-to-income ratio or
residual income; and (8) credit history. Creditors must generally use reasonably reliable third-
party records to verify the information they use to evaluate the factors.
The rule provides guidance as to the application of these factors under the statute. For
example, monthly payments must generally be calculated by assuming that the loan is repaid in
substantially equal monthly payments during its term. For adjustable-rate mortgages, the
monthly payment must be calculated using the fully indexed rate or an introductory rate,
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 19
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
20/24
whichever is higher. Special payment calculation rules apply for loans with balloon payments,
interest-only payments, or negative amortization.
The final rule also provides special rules to encourage creditors to refinance non-
standard mortgageswhich include various types of mortgages which can lead to payment
shock that can result in defaultinto standard mortgages with fixed rates for at least five years
that reduce consumers monthly payments.
Presumption for Qualified Mortgages. The Dodd-Frank Act provides that qualified
mortgages are entitled to a presumption that the creditor making the loan satisfied the ability-to-
repay requirements. However, the Act did not specify whether the presumption of compliance is
conclusive (i.e., creates a safe harbor) or is rebuttable. The final rule provides a safe harbor for
loans that satisfy the definition of a qualified mortgage and are not higher-priced, as generally
defined by the Boards 2008 rule. The final rule provides a rebuttable presumption for higher-
priced mortgage loans, as described further below.
The line the Bureau is drawing is one that has long been recognized as a rule of thumb to
separate prime loans from subprime loans. Indeed, under the existing regulations that were
adopted by the Board in 2008, only higher-priced mortgage loans are subject to an ability-to-
repay requirement and a rebuttable presumption of compliance if creditors follow certain
requirements. The new rule strengthens the requirements needed to qualify for a rebuttable
presumption for subprime loans and defines with more particularity the grounds for rebutting the
presumption. Specifically, the final rule provides that consumers may show a violation with
regard to a subprime qualified mortgage by showing that, at the time the loan was originated, the
consumers income and debt obligations left insufficient residual income or assets to meet living
expenses. The analysis would consider the consumers monthly payments on the loan, loan-
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 20
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
21/24
related obligations, and any simultaneous loans of which the creditor was aware, as well as any
recurring, material living expenses of which the creditor was aware. Guidance accompanying
the rule notes that the longer the period of time that the consumer has demonstrated actual ability
to repay the loan by making timely payments, without modification or accommodation, after
consummation or, for an adjustable-rate mortgage, after recast, the less likely the consumer will
be able to rebut the presumption based on insufficient residual income.
With respect to prime loanswhich are not currently covered by the Boards ability-to-
repay rulethe final rule applies the new ability-to-repay requirement but creates a strong
presumption for those prime loans that constitute qualified mortgages. Thus, if a prime loan
satisfies the qualified mortgage criteria described below, it will be conclusively presumed that
the creditor made a good faith and reasonable determination of the consumers ability to repay.
General Requirements for Qualified Mortgages. The Dodd-Frank Act sets certain
product-feature prerequisites and affordability underwriting requirements for qualified mortgages
and vests discretion in the Bureau to decide whether additional underwriting or other
requirements should apply. The final rule implements the statutory criteria, which generally
prohibit loans with negative amortization, interest-only payments, balloon payments, or terms
exceeding 30 years from being qualified mortgages. So-called no-doc loans where the creditor
does not verify income or assets also cannot be qualified mortgages. Finally, a loan generally
cannot be a qualified mortgage if the points and fees paid by the consumer exceed three percent
of the total loan amount, although certain bona fide discount points are excluded for prime
loans. The rule provides guidance on the calculation of points and fees and thresholds for
smaller loans.
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 21
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
22/24
The final rule also establishes general underwriting criteria for qualified mortgages.
Most importantly, the general rule requires that monthly payments be calculated based on the
highest payment that will apply in the first five years of the loan and that the consumer have a
total (or back-end) debt-to-income ratio that is less than or equal to 43 percent. The appendix
to the rule details the calculation of debt-to-income for these purposes, drawing upon Federal
Housing Administration guidelines for such calculations. The Bureau believes that these criteria
will protect consumers by ensuring that creditors use a set of underwriting requirements that
generally safeguard affordability. At the same time, these criteria provide bright lines for
creditors who want to make qualified mortgages.
The Bureau also believes that there are many instances in which individual consumers
can afford a debt-to-income ratio above 43 percent based on their particular circumstances, but
that such loans are better evaluated on an individual basis under the ability-to-repay criteria
rather than with a blanket presumption. In light of the fragile state of the mortgage market as a
result of the recent mortgage crisis, however, the Bureau is concerned that creditors may initially
be reluctant to make loans that are not qualified mortgages, even though they are responsibly
underwritten. The final rule therefore provides for a second, temporary category of qualified
mortgages that have more flexible underwriting requirements so long as they satisfy the general
product feature prerequisites for a qualified mortgage and also satisfy the underwriting
requirements of, and are therefore eligible to be purchased, guaranteed or insured by either (1)
the GSEs while they operate under Federal conservatorship or receivership; or (2) the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Veterans Affairs, or
Department of Agriculture or Rural Housing Service. This temporary provision will phase out
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 22
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
23/24
over time as the various Federal agencies issue their own qualified mortgage rules and if GSE
conservatorship ends, and in any event after seven years.
Rural Balloon-Payment Qualified Mortgages. The final rule also implements a special
provision in the Dodd-Frank Act that would treat certain balloon-payment loans as qualified
mortgages if they are originated and held in portfolio by small creditors operating predominantly
in rural or underserved areas. This provision is designed to assure credit availability in rural
areas, where some creditors may only offer balloon-payment mortgages. Loans are only eligible
if they have a term of at least five years, a fixed-interest rate, and meet certain basic underwriting
standards; debt-to-income ratios must be considered but are not subject to the 43 percent general
requirement.
Creditors are only eligible to make rural balloon-payment qualified mortgages if they
originate at least 50 percent of their first-lien mortgages in counties that are rural or underserved,
have less than $2 billion in assets, and (along with their affiliates) originate no more than 500
first-lien mortgages per year. The Bureau will designate a list of rural and underserved
counties each year, and has defined coverage more broadly than originally had been proposed.
Creditors must generally hold the loans on their portfolios for three years in order to maintain
their qualified mortgage status.
Other Final Rule Provisions. The final rule also implements Dodd-Frank Act provisions
that generally prohibit prepayment penalties except for certain fixed-rate, qualified mortgages
where the penalties satisfy certain restrictions and the creditor has offered the consumer an
alternative loan without such penalties. To match with certain statutory changes, the final rule
also lengthens to three years the time creditors must retain records that evidence compliance with
the ability-to-repay and prepayment penalty provisions and prohibits evasion of the rule by
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 23
-
7/30/2019 Why Banks Are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession
24/24
structuring a closed-end extension of credit that does not meet the definition of open-end credit
as an open-end plan.
Summary of Concurrent Proposal
The concurrent proposal seeks comment on whether the general ability-to-repay and
qualified mortgage rule should be modified to address potential adverse consequences on certain
narrowly-defined categories of lending programs. Because those measures were not proposed by
the Board originally, the Bureau believes additional public input would be helpful. Specifically,
the proposal seeks comment on whether it would be appropriate to exempt designated non-profit
lenders, homeownership stabilization programs, and certain Federal agency and GSE refinancing
programs from the ability-to-repay requirements because they are subject to their own
specialized underwriting criteria.
The proposal also seeks comment on whether to create a new category of qualified
mortgages, similar to the one for rural balloon-payment loans, for loans without balloon-payment
features that are originated and held on portfolio by small creditors. The new category would not
be limited to lenders that operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas, but would use the
same general size thresholds and other criteria as the rural balloon-payment rules. The proposal
also seeks comment on whether to increase the threshold separating safe harbor and rebuttable
presumption qualified mortgages for both rural balloon-payment qualified mortgages and the
new small portfolio qualified mortgages, in light of the fact that small creditors often have higher
costs of funds than larger creditors. Specifically, the Bureau is proposing a threshold of 3.5
percentage points above APOR for first-lien loans.
Why Banks are Reluctant to Give Mortgage Loans After the 2008 Recession 24