danielafrost.files.wordpress.com · web viewsupplementary materials for. aatched region marks time...
TRANSCRIPT
Supplementary Materials for
Daniel A Frost, Barbara Romanowicz
Correspondence to: [email protected]
Contents of this file
Figures S1 to S14Tables S1 to S3
Introduction
The supporting information contains additional information about the data and method (Figures S1 and S3, and Table S1), observations of lower qualities that those shown in the main paper (Figures S2, and S4-S7), and the results of additional tests (Figures S8, and S9, and Tables S2 and S3). All measurements shown in the paper are listed in table S4 (available separately).
Supplementary Figures
Supplementary Figure 1. Relation beween the angles ξ1 and ξ2 of the two legs of the inner core P′ path with respect to the rotation axis for the Eilson (blue) and Yellowknife (red) arrays. All data are shown, both with and without clear P′P′ arrivals.
Supplementary Figure 2. Beams and array processing of a M7.1 event which occurred on 17/03/2003 at a depth of 33 km, recorded at YK, identified as poor quality (Supplementary Table 1). (a) Beams and F-traces formed on P′P′ab and P′P′df slownesses and back-azimuths. F-vespagrams formed for a range of (b) back-azimuths and (c) slownesses. Predicted times and slownesses from ak135 are shown by green triangles and lines. Observations are marked by blue lines representing onset times and circles showing the maximum F-amplitude, accounting for the time separation between the picks and peaks.
Supplementary Figure 3. Beams and array processing of a M6.7 event which occurred on 05/12/2003 at a depth of 10 km, recorded at IL, identified as poor quality (Supplementary Table 1).
Supplementary Figure 4. Beams and array processing of a M6.3 event which occurred on 06/03/2005 at a depth of 10 km, recorded at YK, identified as good quality (Supplementary Table 1).
Supplementary Figure 5. Beams and array processing of a M6.4 event which occurred on 08/10/2010 at a depth of 19 km, recorded at IL, identified as good quality (Supplementary Table 1).
Supplementary Figure 6. Beams and array processing of a M6.5 event which occurred on 12/03/2011 at a depth of 20 km, recorded at IL, identified as poor quality (Supplementary Table 1).
Supplementary Figure 7. Residual travel times as a function of average angle to the rotation axis for (a) ab-df differential measurements, (b) bc-df differential measurements, and (c) df absolute measurements. Individual measurements are shown by points, while moving averages (calculated in 3° bins with no overlap, calculated only for bins containing a minimum of 2 observations) are shown by purple circles with one standard deviation error bars. Residual travel times plotted along the inner core path (line color), for only the most polar of the source- and receiver-side paths (angle to pole shown by circle color), for (d) ab-df differential measurements, (e) bc-df differential measurements, and (f) df absolute measurements. Data shown have SNR greater than 1.
Supplementary Figure 8. Regions of possible scattering of P′P′ at the surface. Scattering from each location would generate waves with a characteristic (a) travel time shown relative to direct P′P′, (b) back-azimuth, and (c) slowness. The slowness and back-azimuth of scattering from other locations are distinct from reflection from the mid-point (circle) between the source (star) and array (triangle). Dashed and solid lines denote the path of the main phase and an example scattered path, respectively.
Supplementary Figure 9. Observed velocity anomalies from ab-df and bc-df differential residual travel times, as a function of average angle to the rotation axis, with corrections applied for tomographic velocities in (a) and (b) SEMUCB-WM1 scaled to P-waves, (c) and (d) S40RTS scaled to P-waves, (e) and (f) MIT_P08, (g) and (h) GAP_P4. Symbols as in Figure 4.
Supplementary Figure 10. Observed velocity anomalies from ab-df and bc-df differential residual travel times, and df absolute residual travel times, as a function of average angle to the rotation axis, with corrections applied for tomographic
velocities in (a) and (b) SEMUCB-WM1 scaled to P-waves, (c) and (d) S40RTS scaled to P-waves, (e) and (f) MIT_P08, (g) and (h) GAP_P4. Symbols as in Figure 4.
Supplementary Figure 11. Observed velocity anomalies from ab-df and bc-df differential residual travel times, as a function of average angle to the rotation axis, with events reflecting under the South Sandwich Islands removed. (a) Raw measurements for all observations are displayed as crosses and triangles for ab-df and bc-df, respectively, for df signals with SNR greater than 2. (b) Moving averages of observed velocity anomalies (purple) with one standard deviation error bars, and predicted velocity anomalies calculated from several anisotropy models for the observed events. Moving averages are calculated in 3° bins with no overlap, calculated only for bins containing a minimum of 2 observations.
Supplementary Figure 12. Observed velocity anomalies from ab-df and bc-df differential residual travel times, and df absolute differential travel times, as a function of average angle to the rotation axis. (a) Raw measurements for all observations. Velocity anomalies from paths reflecting under the South Sandwich Islands source region are shown in red. (b) Moving averages of observed velocity
anomalies (purple) with one standard deviation error bars, and predicted velocity anomalies calculated from several anisotropy models for the observed events. Moving averages are calculated in 3° bins with no overlap, calculated only for bins containing a minimum of 2 observations.
Supplementary Figure 13. Grid search over eastern and western hemisphere anisotropy. (a) Anisotropy curve (from Irving and Deuss [2011]) that is scaled to
model data. Root mean square misfit for east and west hemisphere anisotropy for: (b) all data with ab-df, bc-df, and absolute df observations, (c) excluding data reflecting under the South Sandwich Islands with ab-df, bc-df, and absolute df observations, (d) all data with only ab-df and bc-df observations, and (e) excluding data reflecting under the South Sandwich Islands with only ab-df and bc-df observations. Star shows minimum misfit with best-fitting anisotropy magnitudes shown above figure. Tested grid points shown in background.
Supplementary Figure 14. Curves to fit velocity anomalies as a function of average angle made with the polar axis, with bootstrap resampling. (a) Original data (circles) fit by a curve of equation 2 (green line). Bootstrap samples (grey) are summarized as a mean line (purple) and one standard deviation range (purple shading).
Coefficients of the line a, b, and c are shown above the figure. Curves to fit data corrected for travel time anomalies in tomographic models (b) SEMUCB-WM1 scaled to P-waves, (c) S40RTS scaled to P-waves, (d) MIT_P08, and (e) GAP_P4.
Supplementary Table 1. Details of events used. Events with discernable phases are classified as either good or poor, while events without phases are left blank.Year
Month
Day
Origin Time
Ev lat
Ev lon Depth (km)
mb Array
Ar lat Ar lon Major arc distance (deg)
P`P`df
P`P`bc
P`P`ab
2001
8 2 23:41:06.17
56.26
163.79 14 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
335.0
2001
10 8 18:14:26.44
52.59
160.32 48 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
331.0
2002
4 18
05:02:46.19
16.99
-100.86
24 6.8 IL 64.77 -146.89
303.2
2002
5 25
05:36:31.97
53.81
-161.12
33 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
346.9 GOOD
NONE
GOOD
2002
8 20
10:59:32.02
30.99
141.97 9 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.6
2002
10 3 16:08:29.62
23.32
-108.53
10 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.7
2002
10 19
12:09:05.38
44.3 149.96 33 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
320.2
2002
10 23
11:27:19.43
63.51
-147.91
4 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
358.7 GOOD
NONE
NONE
2002
11 3 03:37:42.07
38.89
141.98 39 6.4 IL 64.7714
-146.89
312.4
2002
11 3 22:12:41 63.52
-147.44
4 7.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
358.7 POOR
NONE
NONE
2002
11 7 15:14:06.76
51.2 179.33 33 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
337.9
2002
11 17
04:53:53.54
47.82
146.21 459
7.3 IL 64.7714
-146.89
321.4
2003
1 16
00:53:15.72
44.28
-129.02
10 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
337.2
2003
1 22
02:06:34.61
18.77
-104.1 24 7.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.9
2003
2 19
03:32:36.36
53.65
-164.64
19 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
345.7
2003
3 12
23:41:32.92
26.56
-110.59
10 6.4 IL 64.7714
-146.89
315.3
2003
3 17
16:36:17.31
51.27
177.98 33 7.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
337.4
2003
5 26
09:24:33.40
38.85
141.57 68 7.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.2 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2003
6 15
19:24:33.15
51.55
176.92 20 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
337.2 POOR
NONE
POOR
2003
6 16
22:08:02.14
55.49
160 174
6.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
332.8 POOR
NONE
POOR
2003
6 23
12:12:34.47
51.44
176.78 20 6.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
337.1
2003
9 27
11:33:25.08
50.04
87.81 16 7.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
302.2 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2003
9 27
11:50:56.67
49.96
88.1 0 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
302.2
2003
9 27
18:52:46.98
50.09
87.76 10 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
302.2 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2003
9 29
02:36:53.14
42.45
144.38 25 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
316.3 POOR
DIFF POOR
2003
9 29
21:33:16.74
41.45
143.98 0 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
315.3
2003
10 1 01:03:25.24
50.21
87.72 10 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
302.3 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2003
10 8 09:07:0.44
42.61
144.5 68 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
316.5 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2003
10 31
01:06:28.28
37.81
142.62 10 7.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.7 POOR
DIFF POOR
2003
11 17
06:43:06.80
51.15
178.65 33 7.8 IL 64.7714
-146.89
337.6
2003
12 5 21:26:09.48
55.54
165.78 10 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
335.3 POOR
DIFF POOR
2004
5 29
20:56:09.60
34.25
141.41 16 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
308.2
2004
6 10
15:19:57.75
55.68
160 188
6.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
333.0 POOR
DIFF GOOD
2004
6 28
09:49:47 54.8 -134.25
20 6.8 IL 64.77 -146.89
348.2
2004
7 19
08:01:49.46
49.62
-126.97
23 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
341.5
2004
9 5 10:07:07.82
33.07
136.62 14 7.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.1 POOR
POOR
GOOD
2004
9 5 14:57:18.61
33.18
137.07 10 7.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.4 POOR
NONE
POOR
2004
9 6 23:29:35.09
33.21
137.23 10 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.5 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2004
9 8 14:58:25.83
33.14
137.2 21 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.4 GOOD
POOR
POOR
2004
10 23
08:55:57.84
37.28
138.74 0 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
309.6 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2004
11 2 10:02:12.82
49.28
-128.77
10 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
341.8
2004
12 6 14:15:11.89
42.9 145.23 35 6.8 IL 64.77 -146.89
317.1 POOR
DIFF POOR
2004
12 18
06:46:19.87
48.84
156.31 11 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
326.5
2005
3 6 05:21:43.43
84.95
99.39 10 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
332.3
2005
6 14
17:10:12.28
51.24
179.31 17 6.8 IL 64.77 -146.89
337.9 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2005
6 15
02:50:54.19
41.29
-125.95
16 7.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
333.6
2005
6 27
11:35:45.60
18.78
-107.3 20 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
307.0
2005
8 16
02:46:28.40
38.28
142.04 36 7.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.9 POOR
DIFF GOOD
2005
10 19
11:44:42.79
36.4 140.84 32 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
309.8 POOR
POOR
POOR
2005
11 14
21:38:51.42
38.11
144.9 11 7.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.0 GOOD
DIFF POOR
2005
12 2 13:13:09.52
38.09
142.12 29 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.7 POOR
DIFF POOR
2006
1 4 08:32:32.40
28.16
-112.12
14 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
317.3
2006
4 20
23:24:58.39
60.93
167.02 0 7.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
339.0 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2006
4 20
23:28:03.90
60.87
167.01 10 6.1 IL 64.7714
-146.89
339.0
2006
4 29
16:58:06.32
60.49
167.52 11 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
339.0
2006
5 10
02:42:51.03
52.51
-169.26
18 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
343.2
2006
5 22
11:11:57.47
60.79
165.71 0 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
338.4 POOR
NONE
POOR
2008
7 19
02:39:28.70
37.55
142.21 22 7.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.3 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
200 7 2 15:26:19. 39.8 141.46 10 6.8 IL 64.77 - 312.9
8 3 95 8 146.892008
8 27
01:35:32.15
51.61
104.16 16 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
308.4 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2008
9 11
00:20:50.92
41.89
143.75 25 6.8 IL 64.77 -146.89
315.6 POOR
DIFF GOOD
2008
9 24
02:33:05.56
17.61
-105.5 12 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.3
2008
12 20
10:29:23.10
36.54
142.43 19 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
310.6 POOR
POOR
POOR
2009
1 15
17:49:39.07
46.86
155.15 36 7.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
324.5 GOOD
DIFF POOR
2009
3 6 10:50:29.41
80.32
-1.85 9 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
326.3 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2009
4 7 04:23:33.15
46.05
151.55 31 6.9 IL 64.7714
-146.89
322.3
2009
4 18
19:18:0.11
46.04
151.46 42 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
322.2 POOR
DIFF POOR
2009
6 5 03:30:33.06
41.82
143.45 29 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
315.4 POOR
DIFF POOR
2009
8 3 17:59:56.17
29.04
-112.9 10 6.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
318.4
2009
8 3 18:40:50.10
29.31
-113.73
10 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
318.9
2009
8 9 10:55:55.11
33.17
137.94 292
7.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
305.8 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2009
8 10
20:07:09.11
34.74
138.26 40 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
307.3 POOR
GOOD
GOOD
2009
8 12
22:48:51.42
32.82
140.4 53 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
306.5 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2009
9 24
07:16:20.26
18.83
-107.34
13 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
307.1
2009
10 13
05:37:23.69
52.75
-167 24 6.5 IL 64.7714
-146.89
344.2
2009
10 13
20:21:53.20
52.6 -167.12
14 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
344.0
2009
11 17
15:30:47.44
52.12
-131.4 17 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
345.0
2010
1 10
00:27:39.32
40.65
-124.69
29 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
332.7
2010
3 14
08:08:03.96
37.74
141.59 32 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.2
2010
4 4 22:40:43.10
32.3 -115.28
4 7.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
322.2
2010
4 4 23:15:13.89
32.33
-115.02
0 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
322.1
2010
6 18
02:23:05.58
44.45
148.69 28 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
319.8
2010
7 4 21:55:51.98
39.7 142.37 27 6.3 IL 64.7714
-146.89
313.2
2010
7 18
05:56:44.93
52.88
-169.85
14 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
343.3
2010
7 30
03:56:13.71
52.5 159.84 23 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
330.7
2010
8 4 12:58:24.20
51.42
-178.65
27 6.4 IL 64.7714
-146.89
338.9
2010
8 10
05:50:33.27
39.41
143.32 0 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.4 POOR
DIFF POOR
2010
9 3 11:16:06.60
51.45
-175.87
23 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
340.0
2010
10 8 03:26:13.71
51.37
-175.36
19 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
340.1 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2010
10 21
17:53:13.57
24.7 -109.16
13 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.1
2010
12 21
17:19:40.66
26.9 143.7 14 7.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
302.8 GOOD
GOOD
NONE
2010
12 22
21:49:40.08
26.81
143.6 18 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
302.7 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2010
12 23
14:00:32.33
53.13
171.16 18 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
336.0
2011
3 9 02:45:20.33
38.44
142.84 32 7.3 IL 64.7714
-146.89
312.4
2011
3 9 02:58:8.90
38.27
143.13 0 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.3
2011
3 9 04:36:59.11
38.63
143.11 0 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.6
2011
3 9 18:16:16.44
38.31
142.43 22 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.1
2011
3 9 21:23:59.39
38.32
142.79 0 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.2 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2011
3 11
05:46:24.12
38.3 142.37 29 9.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.0
2011
3 11
06:08:29.66
38.97
143.37 2 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.0
2011
3 11
06:11:10.93
36.08
141.83 0 7.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
309.9
2011
3 11
06:12:36.36
37.79
144.23 25 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.4
2011
3 11
06:15:23.12
37.93
143.8 35 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.3
2011
3 11
06:23:09.48
39.03
142.28 56 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.6
2011
3 11
06:25:50.30
38.06
144.59 18 7.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.8 GOOD
NONE
NONE
2011
3 11
06:29:15.99
37.81
144.23 40 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.4
2011
3 11
06:48:45.59
37.96
142.72 11 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.9
2011
3 11
06:49:16.61
37.34
144.24 47 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.0
2011
3 11
06:55:27.28
37.55
142.9 0 6.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.6
2011
3 11
06:58:53.69
37.23
144.76 0 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.2
2011
3 12
01:35:25.26
39.18
142.97 0 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.0
2011
3 12
01:43:21.02
36.37
141.62 38 6.3 IL 64.77 -146.89
310.1
2011
3 12
01:47:15.40
37.59
142.65 20 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.6 POOR
DIFF POOR
2011
3 13
01:26:04.25
35.72
141.64 8 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
309.5 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2011
3 14
06:12:36.06
37.78
142.46 14 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.6
2011
3 15
15:23:54.13
40.33
143.29 19 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
314.1
2011
3 22
07:18:45.38
37.24
144 11 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.8 GOOD
NONE
GOOD
2011
3 22
09:19:06.23
37.33
141.79 31 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.0
2011
3 22
09:44:28.42
39.85
143.44 7 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.8 POOR
NONE
GOOD
2011
3 25
11:36:24.49
38.77
141.88 39 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.2 POOR
DIFF POOR
2011
3 27
22:23:58.80
38.42
142.01 19 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.0 POOR
NONE
GOOD
2011
3 29
10:54:33.20
37.4 142.29 15 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.2
2011
4 7 14:32:43.29
38.28
141.59 42 7.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
311.7 POOR
DIFF GOOD
2011
4 11
08:16:12.73
37 140.4 11 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
310.1 GOOD
POOR
POOR
2011
4 11
23:08:16.87
35.42
140.57 15 6.2 IL 64.77 -146.89
308.8 POOR
POOR
POOR
201 4 1 19:57:25. 39.5 143.34 22 6.0 IL 64.77 - 313.5
1 3 42 8 146.892011
6 22
21:50:52.35
39.96
142.21 33 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.4
2011
6 24
03:09:39.47
52.05
-171.84
52 7.3 IL 64.7714
-146.89
341.9
2011
7 10
00:57:10.80
38.03
143.26 23 7.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
312.2 POOR
DIFF POOR
2011
7 23
04:34:24.18
38.9 141.82 41 6.3 IL 64.7714
-146.89
312.3
2011
7 30
18:53:49.68
36.94
140.96 30 6.3 IL 64.7714
-146.89
310.3
2011
8 22
11:23:32.75
36.1 141.79 0 6.0 IL 64.77 -146.89
309.9
2011
9 2 10:55:53.59
52.17
-171.71
32 6.9 IL 64.77 -146.89
342.1 POOR
DIFF POOR
2011
9 9 19:41:34.15
49.53
-126.89
22 6.4 IL 64.77 -146.89
341.4
2011
9 15
08:00:09.64
36.26
141.34 28 6.1 IL 64.77 -146.89
309.9
2011
9 16
19:26:40.97
40.27
142.78 35 6.7 IL 64.77 -146.89
313.9 POOR
DIFF POOR
2011
12 11
01:47:25.90
17.84
-99.96 54 6.5 IL 64.77 -146.89
303.6
2011
12 27
15:21:56.84
51.84
95.91 15 6.6 IL 64.77 -146.89
306.1 POOR
POOR
NONE
2001
8 2 23:41:06.17
56.26
163.79 14 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
320.7
2001
8 13
20:11:23.40
41.05
142.31 38 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
300.1 POOR
POOR
POOR
2001
10 8 18:14:26.44
52.59
160.32 48 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
316.6 POOR
DIFF NONE
2002
4 18
05:02:46.19
16.99
-100.86
24 6.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
313.5 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2002
5 25
05:36:31.97
53.81
-161.12
33 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
334.5
2002
6 16
02:46:14.03
8.78 -83.99 35 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.9 POOR
POOR
POOR
2002
7 31
00:16:44.61
7.93 -82.79 10 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
300.8
2002
10 3 16:08:29.62
23.32
-108.53
10 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
320.6
2002
10 19
12:09:05.38
44.3 149.96 33 6.3 YK 62.4932
-114.61
305.9
2002
10 23
11:27:19.43
63.51
-147.91
4 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
345.0 POOR
POOR
POOR
2002
11 3 22:12:41 63.52
-147.44
4 7.9 YK 62.49 -114.61
345.2
2002
11 3 23:11:48.87
63.05
-143.64
0 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
346.8
2002
11 7 15:14:06.76
51.2 179.33 33 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
323.9
2003
1 16
00:53:15.72
44.28
-129.02
10 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
339.9
2003
1 21
02:46:47.74
13.63
-90.77 24 6.5 YK 62.4932
-114.61
308.3
2003
1 22
02:06:34.61
18.77
-104.1 24 7.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
315.7
2003
2 19
03:32:36.36
53.65
-164.64
19 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
332.8
2003
3 12
23:41:32.92
26.56
-110.59
10 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
324.0
2003
3 17
16:36:17.31
51.27
177.98 33 7.1 YK 62.49 -114.61
323.3 POOR
DIFF POOR
2003
5 14
06:03:35.86
18.27
-58.63 41 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.5 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2003
6 15
19:24:33.15
51.55
176.92 20 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
323.0 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2003
6 16
22:08:02.14
55.49
160 174
6.9 YK 62.49 -114.61
318.6 GOOD
NONE
GOOD
2003
6 23
12:12:34.47
51.44
176.78 20 6.9 YK 62.4932
-114.61
322.9
2003
9 22
04:45:36.24
19.78
-70.67 10 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
307.8
2003
9 25
19:50:06.36
41.81
143.91 27 8.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.4
2003
9 29
02:36:53.14
42.45
144.38 25 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
302.1
2003
9 29
21:33:16.74
41.45
143.98 0 6.0 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.1
2003
10 8 09:07:0.44
42.61
144.5 68 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
302.3
2003
11 17
06:43:06.80
51.15
178.65 33 7.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
323.5 POOR
DIFF NONE
2003
12 5 21:26:09.48
55.54
165.78 10 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
321.0 POOR
NONE
POOR
2003
12 22
19:15:56 35.71
-121.1 7 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
332.9 POOR
DIFF POOR
2003
12 25
07:11:11.59
8.42 -82.82 33 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.2 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2004
4 29
00:57:21.08
10.81
-86 10 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
304.4 POOR
POOR
POOR
2004
5 3 05:12:39.95
14.5 -90.57 120
6.0 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.1 POOR
POOR
POOR
2004
6 10
15:19:57.75
55.68
160 188
6.9 YK 62.49 -114.61
318.8 POOR
DIFF POOR
2004
6 28
09:49:47 54.8 -134.25
20 6.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
347.3
2004
7 19
08:01:49.46
49.62
-126.97
23 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
345.4
2004
10 9 21:26:53.69
11.42
-86.67 35 7.0 YK 62.49 -114.61
305.2 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2004
11 2 10:02:12.82
49.28
-128.77
10 6.7 YK 62.4932
-114.61
344.6
2004
11 20
08:07:22.08
9.6 -84.17 16 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
302.7
2004
12 6 14:15:11.89
42.9 145.23 35 6.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
302.8 GOOD
POOR
POOR
2004
12 14
23:20:13.36
18.96
-81.41 10 6.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
310.8
2004
12 18
06:46:19.87
48.84
156.31 11 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
312.1 POOR
DIFF POOR
2005
3 6 05:21:43.43
84.95
99.39 10 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
328.1 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2005
6 14
17:10:12.28
51.24
179.31 17 6.8 YK 62.4932
-114.61
323.9
2005
6 15
02:50:54.19
41.29
-125.95
16 7.2 YK 62.4932
-114.61
337.7
2005
6 27
11:35:45.60
18.78
-107.3 20 6.2 YK 62.4932
-114.61
316.0
2005
7 2 02:16:43.70
11.24
-86.17 27 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
304.9 GOOD
POOR
POOR
2005
8 3 11:03:15.13
11.25
-85.54 14 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
304.7 POOR
POOR
POOR
2006
1 4 08:32:32.40
28.16
-112.12
14 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
325.6
2006
4 20
23:24:58.39
60.93
167.02 0 7.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
325.0 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2006
4 20
23:28:03.90
60.87
167.01 10 6.1 YK 62.49 -114.61
325.0
2006
4 29
16:58:06.32
60.49
167.52 11 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.9 POOR
DIFF GOOD
2006
5 10
02:42:51.03
52.51
-169.26
18 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
329.9 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
200 5 2 11:11:57. 60.7 165.71 0 6.7 YK 62.49 - 324.4 POO NON POO
6 2 47 9 114.61 R E R2006
6 14
04:18:42.51
51.75
177.08 14 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
323.2
2006
7 8 20:40:00.98
51.21
-179.31
22 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.5
2006
7 8 20:41:47.66
51.4 -179.22
0 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.6
2006
8 24
21:50:36.65
51.15
157.52 43 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
314.4
2006
9 30
17:50:23.05
46.35
153.17 11 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
308.9 POOR
POOR
POOR
2006
10 1 09:06:02.32
46.47
153.24 19 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.0
2006
10 1 09:09:57.97
46.45
153.16 0 6.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
308.9
2006
10 15
17:07:49.25
19.88
-155.93
38 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
308.9 POOR
POOR
POOR
2006
11 15
11:14:13.57
46.59
153.27 10 8.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.1
2006
11 15
11:29:22.79
46.37
154.48 10 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.4
2006
11 15
11:40:55.05
46.48
154.73 10 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.6 POOR
POOR
POOR
2006
12 7 19:10:21.85
46.15
154.39 16 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
309.2
2007
1 13
04:23:21.16
46.24
154.52 10 8.1 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.3 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2007
4 5 03:56:50.48
37.31
-24.62 14 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
302.4 GOOD
GOOD
NONE
2007
6 13
19:29:40.18
13.55
-90.62 23 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
308.2
2007
8 2 03:21:42.82
51.31
-179.97
21 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.2 POOR
NONE
POOR
2007
8 15
20:22:11.12
50.32
-177.55
9 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.7 GOOD
NONE
GOOD
2007
10 2 18:00:06.87
54.51
-161.71
32 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
334.7
2007
11 29
19:00:20.42
14.94
-61.27 156
7.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
299.6 GOOD
GOOD
POOR
2007
12 19
09:30:27.93
51.36
-179.51
34 7.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.5 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2007
12 19
09:35:13.87
51.07
-179.16
0 7.1 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.4
2007
12 21
07:24:34.03
51.37
-178.98
25 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.7 GOOD
NONE
GOOD
2007
12 26
22:04:54.67
52.56
-168.22
25 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
330.5
2008
1 5 11:01:06.11
51.25
-130.75
15 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
345.8
2008
1 5 11:44:48.17
51.16
-130.54
10 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
345.8
2008
3 3 09:31:02.50
46.41
153.18 10 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
308.9 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2008
4 12
00:46:28.17
43.91
147.55 66 6.1 YK 62.49 -114.61
304.6
2008
4 15
22:59:51.50
51.86
-179.36
11 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
324.9
2008
4 16
05:54:19.69
51.88
-179.16
13 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
325.0 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2008
5 2 01:33:37.24
51.86
-177.53
14 6.6 YK 62.4932
-114.61
325.7
2008
5 29
15:45:59.37
64.01
-21.11 0 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
321.6 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2008
9 11
00:20:50.92
41.89
143.75 25 6.8 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.4
2008
9 24
02:33:05.56
17.61
-105.5 12 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
314.7
2008
10 16
19:41:25.72
14.42
-92.36 24 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.4
2008
10 16
19:43:34.32
14.38
-92.28 0 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
309.4
2009
1 15
17:49:39.07
46.86
155.15 36 7.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
310.1
2009
3 6 10:50:29.41
80.32
-1.85 9 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
327.5 GOOD
DIFF POOR
2009
4 7 04:23:33.15
46.05
151.55 31 6.9 YK 62.49 -114.61
308.0 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2009
4 18
19:18:0.11
46.04
151.46 42 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
307.9 GOOD
GOOD
GOOD
2009
5 28
08:24:46.56
16.73
-86.22 19 7.3 YK 62.4932
-114.61
310.1
2009
6 5 03:30:33.06
41.82
143.45 29 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
301.2
2009
8 3 17:59:56.17
29.04
-112.9 10 6.9 YK 62.49 -114.61
326.5 GOOD
NONE
POOR
2009
8 3 18:40:50.10
29.31
-113.73
10 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
326.8
2009
9 24
07:16:20.26
18.83
-107.34
13 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
316.1
2009
10 13
05:37:23.69
52.75
-167 24 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
331.1
2009
10 13
20:21:53.20
52.6 -167.12
14 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
331.0
2009
11 17
15:30:47.44
52.12
-131.4 17 6.6 YK 62.49 -114.61
346.3
2010
1 10
00:27:39.32
40.65
-124.69
29 6.5 YK 62.49 -114.61
337.3 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2010
1 12
21:53:10.06
18.44
-72.57 13 7.0 YK 62.49 -114.61
307.3 POOR
POOR
POOR
2010
4 4 22:40:43.10
32.3 -115.28
4 7.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
329.8
2010
4 4 23:15:13.89
32.33
-115.02
0 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
329.8
2010
6 18
02:23:05.58
44.45
148.69 28 6.2 YK 62.49 -114.61
305.5 POOR
POOR
POOR
2010
7 18
05:56:44.93
52.88
-169.85
14 6.7 YK 62.49 -114.61
329.9 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2010
7 30
03:56:13.71
52.5 159.84 23 6.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
316.4
2010
8 4 12:58:24.20
51.42
-178.65
27 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
324.9 POOR
DIFF POOR
2010
9 3 11:16:06.60
51.45
-175.87
23 6.5 YK 62.4932
-114.61
326.2
2010
10 8 03:26:13.71
51.37
-175.36
19 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
326.4 POOR
DIFF GOOD
2010
12 23
14:00:32.33
53.13
171.16 18 6.4 YK 62.4932
-114.61
321.6
2011
6 24
03:09:39.47
52.05
-171.84
52 7.3 YK 62.49 -114.61
328.5 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2011
9 2 10:55:53.59
52.17
-171.71
32 6.9 YK 62.49 -114.61
328.6 GOOD
DIFF GOOD
2011
9 9 19:41:34.15
49.53
-126.89
22 6.4 YK 62.49 -114.61
345.4 POOR
DIFF POOR
2011
9 16
19:26:40.97
40.27
142.78 35 6.7 YK 62.4932
-114.61
299.6
2011
12 11
01:47:25.90
17.84
-99.96 54 6.5 YK 62.4932
-114.61
314.2
Supplementary Table 2. Slowness and back-azimuth residuals from resolution tests for Elison and Yellowknife arrays. For each slowness, synthetic signals were generated from -180 to 135° back-azimuth, in 45° increments.
Eilson YellowknifeInput slowness (s/deg)
Average back-azimuth residual (°)
Standard deviation
Average slowness residual (s/deg)
Standard deviation
Average back-azimuth residual (° ¿
Standard deviation
Average slowness residual (s/deg)
Standard deviation
0.0 90.0 52.3 1.6 0.0 90.0 50.4 0.4 00.5 79.8 52.0 1.1 0.4 20.3 11.9 0.2 0.11.0 68.3 50.4 0.7 0.5 9.0 5.6 0.2 0.11.5 48.0 35.1 0.7 0.4 6.8 4.6 0.2 0.12.0 25.8 13.0 0.7 0.4 6.0 2.9 0.2 0.12.5 19.3 10.6 0.7 0.4 5.2 2.7 0.1 0.13.0 15.8 8.9 0.7 0.4 3.8 2.3 0.1 0.13.5 13.8 7.3 0.7 0.4 3.2 1.6 0.1 0.04.0 11.3 6.5 0.7 0.4 2.8 1.4 0.1 0.14.5 9.8 4.6 0.7 0.4 2.5 1.1 0.2 0.15.0 8.8 4.1 0.7 0.4 2.3 1.0 0.2 0.15.5 8.0 4.6 .7 0.5 1.8 1.2 0.2 0.16.0 7.0 4.2 0.7 0.5 1.5 0.9 0.2 0.1
Supplementary Table 3: coefficients to fit velocity anomalies with equation 1 Anisotropy magnitude (%)
a b c RMS Misfit
Original 0.494 0.039 0.502 -0.008 0.755Bootstrap sampled
0.483 0.037 0.576 -0.093 0.787
No anisotropy
0 0 0 0 0.829
Supplementary Table 4: details of events used, including relative P′P′ab-df and P′P′bc-df, and P′P′df absolute travel time anomalies, pick qualities, polar angles ξ1 and ξ2, and event-receiver distances, sufficient to recreate figures shown in the paper.