water for hydraulic fracturing - gwpchydraulic fracturing in alberta >15,000 horizontal wells...
TRANSCRIPT
Water for Hydraulic Fracturing Use, Challenges and Solutions in Alberta Michael Bevan, Senior Advisor, Industry Operations
GWPC Annual Forum, Sept. 11, 2018
Alberta’s Oil and Gas Production
Over 80% of Canada’s oil production in 2017 • ~1.2 billion barrels
Nearly 70% of natural gas production in 2017 • ~4 trillion cubic feet
Much is exported to U.S.
Regulated by the Alberta Energy Regulator AER 2
GWPC 2018
Source: AER ST-98
Hydraulic Fracturing in Alberta
>15,000 horizontal wells
fractured since 2008
• 15 different formations
– e.g., Duvernay, Montney,
Cardium
• 65% oil, 35% gas
• Variable water needs
– <200,000 to >13 mil gal
Detailed additive and water
data collected since 2013
AER 3
Water for Hydraulic Fracturing
Regulatory requirement for submission • Water used (technological aspect)
– Carrier fluid, reported by stage Reported on FracFocus.ca!
– Nonsaline water use performance
• Water sourced (environmental aspect) – Where, when, how much…
Nonsaline - surface water, groundwater, municipal
Alternatives - saline groundwater, produced, recycled/reused flowback, waste/effluent
AER 4
Environmental Aspects – Impact?
Nonsaline water for Fracturing - 2016
HF 0.7%
Other Energy 21%
343 trillion gallons (est.)
Allocation:
Availability:
Use:
Unused 78%
0.8% Allocated
22% Used Energy Sector 10%
Source: AER data; Alberta Energy Industry Water Report, AER.ca
AER 5
Total
Make-up
Recycled
2013 2014 2015 2016
Environmental Aspects – Sources
Various water types used, mostly nonsaline…
AER 6 2013 2014 2015 2016
Make-up Nonsaline
Alternatives
2.6 bil gal.
0 gal.
1.3 bil gal.
2.6 bil gal.
0 gal.
1.3 bil gal.
(Preliminary 2017 data shows increases.) Source: Alberta Energy Industry Water Report, AER.ca
Technical Aspects - Performance
Nonsaline Water Use Intensity - HF
Other sectors
AER 7 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
NS In
tens
ity
bbl/B
OE
3 2 1 0
2013 2014 2015 2016
0.4 0.2 0 NS
Wat
er U
se In
tens
ity
bbl/B
OE
(Preliminary 2017 data shows increases.)
Source: Alberta Energy Industry Water Report, AER.ca
Technical Aspects – Benchmarking
Peer to peer performance comparison • Cohorts by company ‘size’ • Differing strategies
AER 8
NS In
tens
ity
Intensity by Company
Source: AER data
Technical Aspects – Benchmarking
Geologic Variability • Formation differences…. Operator can influence
AER 9
NS In
tens
ity
Intensity by Formation
NS In
tens
ity
Formation Intensity by Company
Source: AER data
Improving Water Performance
Drivers: • water conservation • environmental
protection • social license • cost
Challenges: Regulatory aspects • Limiting water
classifications – Waste vs produced
• Unclear, sometimes restrictive or absent – Conveyance… – Storage…
AER 10
Possible Solutions
Conveyance • Temporary, surface infrastructure • Poor quality nonsaline (e.g., treated effluent)
Storage • Large volumes, centralized
– ECPs, AWSSs (aka C-ring)
• Flowback, produced water
Consider fluid risk, siting, monitoring, liability…
AER 11
Benefits of Regulatory Change
Regulator • Clarity, consistency, efficiency, monitoring/
reporting, help to meet goals
Industry • Cost savings, time savings, regulatory certainty,
facilitate water sharing competitiveness
Environment • less nonsaline water use, reduced disturbance,
less trucking lower risk
AER 12
Pilot Project - ECP
Tourmaline Oil proposed engineered containment pond (ECP) for produced water/ flowback to support HF operations • Goal – reuse water, use less nonsaline water
– reduced trucking/ disposal decrease cost & risk
Restrictive rules for long-term, large volume storage • Worked with operator
– develop requirements, processes for application and approval AER 13
Success – Tourmaline Banshee ECP
Successful pilot project! • Regulator:
– Knowledge gathering – process, info requirements, gaps, site visits
3 more ECPs approved since, up to 40 mil gal.
– Informing current development of regulatory tool
• Operator: – Reuse facilitated, reduced disposal/ trucking/ NS
water use/ cost – Regulatory certainty
AER 14
Summary
Detailed HF water data = invaluable intelligence
HF activity and water use is increasing, while barrels of nonsaline water per BOE is not… • Alberta Energy Industry Water Use Report (available at
www.AER.ca Protecting What Matters Industry Performance Water)
Regulatory solutions to facilitate increased use of alternatives are under development
AER 15