volume 05, issue 03 - fall 1990
DESCRIPTION
Volume V, Number 3 Fall 1990 Sustainable agriculture, one of the most talked-about concepts in agricultural circles today, is difficult to define. Keith Dix, leader of extension's Center for Sustainable Agriculture, confers with Carolyn Merrill, vice president of the Mountain State Organic Growers and Buyers Association, prior to a public tour of four Lewis County organic operations. West Virginia University Extension Service continued page 3TRANSCRIPT
West Virginia University Extension Service
Volume V, Number 3 Fall 1990
Alternative Ideas In Agriculture Attract Interest
Sustainable agriculture, one of the most talked-about concepts in agricultural circles today, is difficult to define.
Some think "sustainable" means maintaining present production levels. Others advocate reducing reliance on purchased agricultural inputs, such as chemical fertilizers and pesticides, in order to sustain the environment and safeguard human health.
Edmond B. Collins, extension division leader for agriculture, forestry and community development at West Virginia University, combines both aspects in his definition: "Sustainable agriculture involves finding economical and environmentally safe ways to manage pests and diseases that will allow farmers to maintain production and profits. But it also involves total crop management, which includes decisions about fertilizers, cultural practices, labor and equipment, in \ddition to controlling insects, dis-
- eases and weeds." continued page 3
Extension
Keith Dix, leader of extension's Center for Sustainable Agriculture, confers with Carolyn Merrill, vice president of the Mountain State Organic Growers and Buyers Association, prior to a public tour of four Lewis County organic operations.
Viewpoint
West Virginia University has just issued a Strategic Plan for Economic Development at West Virginia University. The document was prepared by the Economic Development Council, composed of deans and of directors of research centers, and chaired by me. It was reviewed and approved by the provost and president and will serve as a guide for program development, budget planning and hiring in the next few years. The plan applies to all units at West Virginia University, but it has special implications for West Virginia University Extension. For that reason, I want to share with you the mission statement, 11 long-range goals, and a one-year implementation plan.
Mission West Virginia University's mission in economic development is to serve as a catalyst and to exercise leadership; to be an intellectual resource to government, communities and industry through planning, research and policy development; to be a source of direct assistance to communities, businesses and other groups; and to provide high-quality education for students, citizens and leaders.
Long-Range Goals in Support of the Mission
1. Conduct research on West Virginia's economic needs and potential.
2. Examine emerging issues of critical importance to the state, provide economic and policy studies, develop solutions and disseminate information to state and local leaders and to citizens to enable them to make informed decisions.
2
3. Make relevant data, research, analytical tools and training available to West Virginia businesses and governments.
4. Help businesses from start-up to maturity to identify and solve problems, develop and apply technology, and improve labor/management relations.
5. Improve the linkages between citizens, the extension network and campuses so that people all over the state can access the institution's intellectual resources.
6. Identify and implement mechanisms and facilities that will support the development of intellectual properties and the commercialization of research. 7. Improve collaboration with local, regional and state organizations and agencies interested in economic development.
8. Educate students and citizens to compete in the global economy, to assume professional and managerial leadership roles in West Virginia and to continue their education throughout life.
9. Expand student involvement in community service and internship opportunities, which expose them to West Virginia problems and possibilities and match their talents and energies with community needs and opportunities.
1 0. Improve the health status of all West Virginians through a variety of means including recruiting students to practice primary care medicine in rural areas of the state.
11 . Act as a catalyst and leader to improve the quality of public education in K-12, vocational, early childhood through professional development, parent and citizen education, and policy development and implementation.
1991 West Virginia University Plan of Action in Economic Development
1 - Implement the West Virginia Industrial Extension Service to provide direct assistance in modernization of small and medium-sized manufacturers.
2- Develop a resource guide and a clearinghouse to enable citizens, government and industry to access the intellectual resources of West Virginia University. 3 - Expand assistance to North Central West Virginia in collaboration with other higher education institutions and economic development planning groups in the region.
4- Seek additional federal funding for travel and tourism research in collaboration with the Appalachian Travel Research and Development Center at Concord College.
5- Develop and implement expanded corporate health care services at the Health Sciences Center.
6- Create seminars for state leaders on emerging policy issues which build upon existing policy studies published by West Virginia University faculty.
7- Aggressively pursue federal and private support for research in energy, health sciences, software and artificial intelligence, advanced materials, education, environment and manufacturing.
8- Continue development of the Research Corporation as a mechanism to facilitate expanded research by faculty and to increase commercialization of research. As these goals are implemented in the next five years , the West Virginia University Extension network in each county will be linked into all of West Virginia University 's resources in support of economic development, making us much better able to respond to community issues with appropriate educational programming. The Strategic Plan is a map with routes marked; we still must make the journey to accomplish the mission. I look forward to your comments and would be happy to share a copy of the complete plan.
Rachel B~~ Associate Provost for Extension and Economic Development Director, Cooperative Extension Service
West Virginians are becoming interested in organic gardening; 85 people participated in the Earth Tenders Walking Workshop tour offered in July by four organic producers in Lewis County.
Alternative Ideas Continued from page 1
To coordinate its programs in this area, the Extension Service recently appointed Keith Dix as leader of its Center for Sustainable Agriculture .
"Keith's role is to gather information on alternative ways to control pests and diseases and disseminate it to county agents and interested producers," Collins explained. "He'll help increase extension faculty's awareness of the importance of sustainable agriculture."
Dix, who works one day per week in the position, began farming part-time in 1975. He resigned as associate professor in WVU's Institute for Labor Studies in 1987 in order to devote all of his time to growing vegetables, apples, other fruits and herbs, using organic techniques.
Organic producers represent one end of the sustainable agriculture spectrum. True organic growers use no synthetic chemicals on their crops and soils, but depend upon biological controls, disease-resistant crop vari-
ties, and such cultural practices as
rotating crops, mulching, tilling, and using manures and cover crops to enrich the soil.
When Dix decided to become a fulltime producer, he wanted to have his operation certified as organic. West Virginia has no regulations concerning organic certification, and there was no state growers organization to carry out the certification .
"I thought there would be perhaps six or eight organic growers in West Virginia, but 25 came to an organizational meeting two years ago," he reported . The producers organized the Mountain State Organic Growers and Buyers Association (MSOGBA) and elected Dix president. MSOGBA now has about 100 members, most of whom produce on a small scale. Their operations range from less than an acre to 600 acres.
This year, 16 MSOGBA members applied to the association for certification. An independent evaluator inspected their farms and checked records including soil tests. Produc-
ers believe certification is worth the $50 cost because a growing number of consumers want assurance that they are buying organically grown produce.
"A convergence of issues is leading to an upsurge of interest in alternative agricultural methods," Dix pointed out. "In addition to concerns about food safety and the environment, especially groundwater pollution, we're seeing more conventional farmers becoming interested in lowering their use of off-farm inputs because they are expensive and cut into profits," he stated.
"I think there's an opportunity in specialty crops for small farmers in the state," Dix said, "and we're eager to help anyone using organic or other sustainable techniques to be competitive."
"A convergence of issues is leading to an upsurge of interest in alternative agricultural methods."
Evidence of interest in organic production was shown on a rainy Saturday this July, when 85 people participated in a tour of four Lewis County organic gardens.
"I was overwhelmed by the attendance; we had people from as far away as Pittsburgh, Charleston and Monroe County," commented Carolyn Merrill, MSOGBA vice president and an organizer of the Earth Tenders Walking Workshop.
She would like to see association members offer tours in several regions next year. "Also, if the tours include larger scale farmers who are making a living from organic production, then perhaps we could get more farmers to see what can be done," she said. Merrill, who markets garden produce through the Central W.Va. Farmers Market at Weston, understands the hesitancy of commercial growers to quit using agricultural chemicals. "However," she continued, "it's time
continued next page
3
"It's time to educate farmers, county agents and others about organic production, because people are afraid of what they don't know."
to educate farmers, county agents and others about organic production, because people are afraid of what they don't know."
Lewis County extension agent Robin Poling participated in an organic agriculture training session in Massachusetts this spring and returned "in awe of organic farmers and what they know about plants and pests."
Poling believes that the Farmers Market, which she helped to reorganize as a cooperative, provides an opportunity for marketing organically grown produce. In cooperation with the market, she is planning a seminar on organic production this fall.
"Organic is not for everyone," Poling emphasized. "It requires high management input and it's labor-intensive, which is why organic growers charge more for their products."
Although there are only four major organic producers in her county, Poling is finding that other growers are showing interest, "perhaps not in going the whole organic route but in trying to use sustainable practices."
Among the sustainable practices emphasized in West Virginia and throughout the nation since the 1970s are Integrated Pest Management (IPM) and its companion, Integrated Crop Management (ICM).
The philosophy behind IPM is to manage insect pests rather than eradicate them. Under this program, trained producers or their employees scout crops in order to monitor insect populations. They then determine whether pest levels warrant the use of a chemical control and, if so, when and at what rate the control should be applied. When making these decisions, producers look at the economics of the situation to see if the cost of controlling a pest will be less than the expected crop damage.
4
Organic grower Carolyn Merrill uses no synthetic chemicals on the vegetables she markets through the Central W.Va. Farmers Market in Weston.
"Organic is not for everyone," Poling emphasized. "It requires high management input and it's labor-intensive, which is why organic growers charge more for their products."
Dr. John F. Baniecki, extension entomology/plant pathology and pest control specialist, has directed West Virginia's IPM effort since it began as a pilot project in the Eastern Panhandle in 1978.
IPM soon evolved into ICM as the program broadened from just managing pests to managing crops. "We felt that producers would be more interested in total crop management, involving weeds, diseases, soil conditions, cultural practices and record keeping," commented Baniecki .
In early IPM/ICM efforts, Baniecki and others trained scouts hired by the producers to monitor their alfalfa and corn fields weekly. Now producers are doing their own monitoring. Also, West Virginia Department of Agriculture scouts monitor conditions on
"Monitoring usually leads to fewer sprayings of insecticides," noted Baniecki, "because producers spray only when it's necessary rather than on a predetermined schedule."
about 125 farms statewide and provide survey information to extension specialists and agents who make recommendations to farmers.
"Monitoring usually leads to fewer sprayings of insecticides," noted Baniecki, "because producers spray only when it's necessary rather than on a predetermined schedule." He added that this "not only helps the environment but also means a savings to producers who are looking to reduce costs and manage efficiently." Also, soil tests help producers determine whether they can cut back on fertilizer applications.
The IPM/ICM program spread to tree fruits in the early 1980s, when Eastern Panhandle producers hired trained scouts to monitor their orchards. In 1984, Dr. Henry Hogmire, extension entomology specialist, began training growers and their employees to do their own monitoring. Hogmire, who is based at the WVU Experiment Farm at Kearneysville, trains about 75 people from West Virginia and nearby states each year.
"Generally speaking, monitoring has allowed orchardists to eliminate two to four of their 1 0 to 13 sprays per season, although this varies among growers," commented Hogmire.
The specialist believes that one advantage of IPM/ICM is that growers are in their orchards each week and therefore can apply pesticides in a more timely fashion. "So they not only reduce the number of applications, but they're also doing a better job when they do spray, which leads to improved fruit quality."
Leaf analyses and soil samples help orchardists monitor nutrition levels. In one recent year, 40 percent found that their soils had excessive levels
of nitrogen; this knowledge allowed them to cut back or eliminate nitrogen applications for a year or two.
A pilot IPM/ICM program involving nine producers of sweet corn is now under way. Preston Co•Jnty farmer Ed Grose's operation was featured in the April1, 1990 issue of Pennsylvania Farmer. He uses hormonecontaining traps to determine insect populations in his 1 0 acres of sweet corn. When he traps more than 10 fall armyworm moths in one night, for example, he knows it's time to spray.
"We've learned that the best time to spray is in the evening because that's when insects are most active," said his son Tom Grose. "We get a better kill and better control because sunlight quickly breaks down the chemicals," he added.
"Dr. Baniecki got us fired up on it," the younger Grose said of IPM. He is enthusiastic about using IPM as a pest management plan: "IPM tells us when to spray and we use less pesticides; also, we can control insects at the proper time with a minimum amount of insecticide."
Tom Grose thinks chemicals will be necessary in tomorrow's agriculture, "but they should be used wisely. Some of the chemicals taken off the market were good chemicals but they were overused or not used properly."
Extension also is working with other agencies in a program that encourages producers to adopt ICM practices. In Berkeley and Jefferson counties, seven cooperating orchardists received ICM training from Hogmire. Seven farmers in Mason and Greenbrier counties also enrolled in the program, which features costsharing by the Agricultural Stabilization and Conservation Service (ASCS), technical assistance by the Soil Conservation Service, and education by extension.
The goal of the interagency program is for producers to reduce their use of pesticides and fertilizers by 20 percent.
SCS is paying 75 percent of the ,osts involved in hiring scouts, testing
Agronomy specialist Charles B. Sperow is one of several state and county extension faculty who are cooperating with other agencies to encourage farmers to adopt Integrated Crop Management practices.
"I feel that everything we in extension do is with the intention of helping agriculture be sustainable; we recommend programs and practices to help producers make a profit, while meeting community standards."
soils and manure, and analyzing leaf tissue. Payment limits are $7 per acre for small grains, forages and hay, and $14 per acre for tree fruits.
In Greenbrier County, the ICM program is tied in with a three-year project involving the Greenbrier River Basin, one of 37 hydrologic units in the nation chosen by the U.S. Department of Agriculture for increased technical, educational and financial assistance to improve water quality. In addition to USDA agencies, cooperators include extension, the state Department of Agriculture, the West Virginia Soil Conservation Committee, the local soil conservation district and landowners.
All are working to implement agricultural practices designed to keep pollutants out of groundwater, streams and ponds. Agriculture is the leading industry in the region. Project organizers are encouraging producers to manage animal wastes properly, control erosion and sediment, and adopt nutrient and pest management practices.
As part of the effort, extension agronomy specialist Charles B. Sperow will conduct demonstrations on using legume cover crops, manure and treated sludge as sources of nitrogen. Follow-up soil tests will increase farmers' confidence in using these organic sources of nitrogen, according to Sperow. He also plans trials of alfalfa, corn and fall cover crops that will show the results of good crop management.
The agronomist predicts that Greenbrier farmers will see greater yields as they adopt ICM practices. One cooperator, for example, had never had his soil tested before joining the program.
Does Sperow consider ICM as part of sustainable agriculture? "One problem I have with the term is that everyone has a different definition for it," he admitted. "I feel that everything we in extension do is with the intention of helping agriculture be sustainable; we recommend programs and practices to help producers make a profit, while meeting community standards."
Observed division leader Collins about the concept of sustainability: "People are beginning to see that there are choices in agriculture and are beginning to look at their management choices."
As farmers and gardeners in the state explore alternative production approaches and methods, extension faculty will continue to advise them as they make their choices. ai
5
6
Multicultural Camps ... an opportunity to move from textbooks to real life
African arts and crafts help Mercy Kareithi (left) of Kenya and Tanka Ibrahim (right) of Nigeria discuss their homelands with three multicultural camp participants.
Multicultural Camps ... an opportunity to move from textbooks to real life.
That was the experience 160 junior and senior high school students had during three multicultural camps sponsored by the West Virginia University Extension Service in 1989-90.
The multicultural camps were designed to acquaint the students with people from other countries and with such global issues as human rights, hunger, homelessness, population growth and terrorism.
Each participant explored two of the four cultural spheres offered: Africa, Asia, Europe and Latin America. The classes were taught by WVU international graduate students, state residents from other countries and
professionals with international experience. Instructors discussed educational systems, geography, government, family life, social customs, religion and language of their countries. In addition to classes, the camps included recreational and social activities featuring international music, dancing and food.
As might be expected, most of the campers were enrolled in world cultures or foreign language courses at their junior and senior high schools. The camps were promoted among the state's foreign language teachers by Debra Brown, coordinator of foreign languages for the West Virginia Department of Education.
She endorsed the camps because research has shown that people remember more when they experience something rather than just read about it in a book.
"Students, especially those from rural counties, begin to wonder if they're ever going to meet someone who speaks the language they're studying," commented Brown, who served on the committee to plan the camps.
"Students, especially those from rural counties, begin to wonder if they're ever going to meet someone who speaks the language they're studying,"
Dr. Ronald W. Dunbar, associate chairman of the WVU foreign languages department, shared those sentiments: "It's difficult for West Virginia kids to have any contact with foreign languages, with people from other countries or even anyone not from West Virginia in some cases."
Dunbar helped select the foreign language students who served as camp instructors. "I tried to make sure that the campers would meet outgoing people who would be good represen-
"Who can find Czechoslovakia on the map?" is the question Pavlina Vagoun asks her class.
tatives of their countries," he said, adding that the WVU international students enjoyed the camp teaching and would like to do it again.
olombian Adriana Velasquez describes daily life in her South American ;ountry to Rob Gilpin, a Paw Paw High School sophomore in Morgan County.
Nuanprang Charoenwong shows money from Thailand. She lived and worked in Mineral County last year as an exchange teacher with the American Field Service.
"I highly recommend it for students (because) they find out that those from other countries are people just like us; of course, there are differences but there are more similarities."
Gail Stone, a Spanish teacher at Roane County's Walton High School, accompanied four students to the Jackson's Mill camp and was so impressed with the program that she drove five hours to take five students to the Eastern Panhandle camp at Hedgesville.
"I highly recommend it for students (because) they find out that those from other countries are people just like us; of course, there are differences but there are more similarities," Stone commented.
Jan a Mersing of Terra Alta decided to attend the camp "because it sounded like a chance to be with friends."
She and two others from East Preston High School who participated in the Hedgesville camp were excused from Friday classes. "It was a lot of
continued next page
7
Meals and recreation periods provide opportunities for campers to talk informally with their international instructors.
Multicultural ... continued from page 7
fun and we learned stuff in the Africa section that isn't in our books," said the sophomore, adding that she'd recommend a similar experience to her friends .
"Perhaps these efforts will lead to more opportunities for West Virginia kids to go abroad, also."
The three camps were directed by Richard L. Fleisher, extension associate professor and director of the West Virginia Affiliate, Council of International Programs (CIP).
"The idea originated in extension's Southern District where several county agents had multicultural camps," explained Fleisher. "I met with some of the agents and we decided to 'institutionalize' the camps by tying them closer to school systems and involving older kids."
Extension faculty instrumental in planning the camp programs included Southern District interim division leader Mark Dillon, then in Lincoln County; John Marra, Cabell County; and
8
Some special guests at the multicultural camps were international human service professionals participating in a work experience sponsored by the Council of International Programs. At the Eastern Panhandle camp, Sergey Kuznetsov (center) of the Soviet Union talks with Dr. Douglas Smith (left), coordinator of the WVU Graduate Center at Shepherd College, and Dr. Michael P. Riccards, Shepherd College president.
Donna Patton, Kanawha County. Serving on the planning committee for the Eastern Panhandle camp were agents Carol Bogacz, Berkeley County; Kay Davis, Mineral County; and Jane Jopling, Hardy County.
Two grants from the West Virginia Humanities Foundation helped fund the camps, and scholarship money was donated by C&P Telephone , the Herscher Foundation and the West Virginia State 4-H Club Foundation.
Holding the two-night residential camps near Charleston, at Jackson 's Mill and in the Eastern Panhandle enabled youths from throughout the state to attend one near their homes.
"We saw the camps as a pilot project in order to gauge the amount of interest among kids and teachers, and we feel it's a viable camp," said Fleisher. He would like to see it become a larger camp, perhaps one held in the summer at the Jackson's Mill State 4-H Conference Center.
"We'd also like to 'internationalize' it even further by involving more international students," said the CIP director, who is working to develop exchange programs with Mexico and Brazil. "Perhaps these efforts will lead to more opportunities for West Virginia kids to go abroad, also."
"After all, these kids are the ones who will be making future decisions about our role in the world and our relations with other countries."
Fleisher believes that the chance to interact with folks from other countries and to develop an appreciation for other cultures can only benefit the young participants: "After all, these kids are the ones who will be making future decisions about our role in the world and our relations with other countries."
Dunbar, who feels that it's important to reach children when they're young, expressed hope that the multicultural camp program will continue "because there's really nothing else like it." me
Not to Decide is to Decide Teen-agers Find
Skills in Judging Apply Elsewhere
Sweating palms. Knocking knees.
Churning stomach.
Remember those symptoms? They would attack as you waited to speak before your high school teacher and classmates.
That's how you felt when you had had at least several days to prepare your speech. Can you imagine your symptoms if you had been asked not only to give a presentation based on your own series of decisions but also to defend those decisions ... with just an hour to pull the whole thing together? And, without any notes?!?
Now, can you imagine teen-agers voluntarily signing up for such an exercise ... in the summer?
Well, they do. They do it every year in 4-H. And it's not that they love sweaty palms or churning stomachs so much. It's what they love more. It's the horses. Or the livestock. Or the dairy cows. Or the poultry.
And while they enjoy pursuing their special interests, these 4-H'ers simultaneously begin developing decisionmaking and communication skills that
Having knowledge is not the same as being able to use knowledge. Gathering information -pertinent information -is just part of the decision-making process.
Looking at the same things at the same time, 4-H horse judging contestants and a contest judge (kneeling) collect details to rank this performance class animal on a variety of "points," including how well it obeys commands.
not only can last a lifetime but can affect the quality of that lifetime.
You've probably heard the saying: "Not to decide is to decide." So, actually making a decision is an important step. But what about the quality of that decision? Just how should you choose between Issue A and Issue B? What steps do you take to make a "sound decision"?
Unfortunately, decision-making skills don't automatically arrive with puberty. And some educators fear that many adults never fully develop the skill to gather and analyze information properly for life's cwcial decisions.
Currently, public schools and higher education are refocusing on the need to build decision-making skills into their curricula. Having knowledge is not the same as being able to use knowledge. Gathering informationpertinent information-is just part of the decision-making process. How to recognize and select alternatives are the next tests that must be mastered.
As educators grapple with ways to build decision-making experiences into classroom activities, 4-H'ers working with 4-H judging programs remain one step ahead of their classmates.
Each discipline requires that the youths not only know "facts" but also understand how to interpret that information and apply it.
Through county workshops and state contests, hundreds of 4-H'ers exercise decision making via their learnby-doing experiences in 4-H's horticulture, land use, forestry, wildlife, dairy, livestock, poultry and horse judging programs. Each discipline requires that the youths not only know "facts" but also understand how to interpret that information and apply it.
The youths' decision-making skills become more finely honed when they must explain how they arrived at the judgments they made. Judging in dairy, livestock, poultry and horse contests adds this extra contest criterion, which is called "oral reasons."
The exercise of "giving oral reasons" is so effective in building decisionmaking and communication skills that the West Virginia University Extension Service's Division of Home
continued next page
9
Not to Decide is ... continued from page 9
Economics and 4-H and the WVU animal production program go extra steps to make sure that those youths interested in horses have a way to explore their interests.
"When graduates come back, they tell me that it (horse judging) was one of the most important things they did ... because it increased their communication abilities, their abilities to express themselves ... regardless of the field they entered," explained Bob McCurley, assistant professor in WVU's College of Agriculture and Forestry.
That feedback continues to motivate Dr. McCurley to "create" a horse program for a school that has no horses. Unlike other universities with horse judging courses and horse judging teams, WVU does not have any horses. Dr. McCurley compensates for that shortcoming by arranging for students' studies at area stables. After all, horse judges need to be able to see real horses.
However, all youths quickly begin to share the same intrinsic benefits: a self-confidence gained from being able to think, to compete and to communicate.
Parallel creativity continues to blossom in county 4-H programs throughout West Virginia and in WVU's Knapp Hall, where 4-H specialists also have been maintaining a state 4-H horse judging program-without owning any horses.
According to Jean Woloshuk, state 4-H agricultural events coordinator, 4-H keeps the horse program going because horses continue to fascinate kids-both urban as well as rural. And, as any 4-H educator will tell you: Just let a youngster pick the animal he or she wants to work with, and then be prepared to watch that youngster develop.
Additionally, Dr. Woloshuk said, 4-H specialists recognize that the horse industry is a growth industry, with particular promise in a tourist state
10
This halter class horse is about to be evaluated for its conformation, which includes muscling, balance and structural correctness.
like West Virginia. For some West Virginia youths, horses may become a hobby; for others, a career.
However, all youths quickly begin to share the same intrinsic benefits: a self-confidence gained from being able to think, to compete and to communicate.
Dr. Woloshuk said that 792 youths were enrolled in some type of 4-H horse project in 1989. Sixty-nine were eligible to compete in the 1990 state horse judging contest.
That participation is apart from 4-H members' activities in the Junior Horse and Pony Show. Horse judging is not part of that equestrian contest, which is held in August during the West Virginia State Fair in Greenbrier County.
Unlike the horse show, the homeless state horse judging contest has appeared wherever it could be "accommodated" -meaning wherever horses and facilities are provided at no charge to WVU. Sites have included the Jefferson County Fairgrounds, a private stable in Weston and a private stable in Monongalia County.
In July, the state judging contest returned to one of its previous homes, Meredith Manor International Equestrian Centre in Waverly (Wood County).
The school's availability gave an educational bonus to the 1990 contest while taking a huge burden off the shoulders of the volunteers, parents
and extension faculty, who would have had to find and transport not just a lot of horses but a lot of horses with a lot in common.
Meredith Manor's stables (60 to 90 horses) meant the event arrangers would not have difficulty in structuring the eight-class contest. Within each
It's lonely at the top. These 4-H'ers need a little space and solitude to study their notes one last time before leaving them behind. No notes are allowed in the oral reasons presentations.
class, 4-H'ers needed to examine four horses of the same breed, the same age, the same sex, and the same physical condition.
That sameness is crucial. 4-H'ers study the horses within each class to rank them according to their characteristics, such as their ":;orrectness of legs," "spring of rib," "faults on the head," and possible "unsoundness and defects."
While the senior 4-H members confidently toiled through their oral reasons, the junior 4-H members (who write out decisions but don't give oral reasons) and their families watched a variety of educational demonstrations conducted by Meredith Manor students and staff.
In another year or so, the juniors will be eligible to compete for the senior state horse judging title . That title carries the state 4-H horse judging team to the annual national competition in November in Louisville, Ky.
No "No Talking" signs needed here. Decision making underway!
Beyond 4-H titles await college judging teams and their regional and national honors ... and careers ... and basic skills -skills that transfer from 4-H into the classroom and into adult professional and daily life.
Beyond 4-H titles await college judging teams and their regional and national honors .. . and careers . .. and basic skills-skills that transfer from 4-H into the classroom and into adult professional and daily life.
Professors such as Dr. McCurley are motivated by what their students tell them about judging experiences. Professors such as Dr. McCurley also say they can see a difference between students with pre-college judging experience and those without.
High school teachers agree, too.
Particularly insightful testimony comes from Mary Jane Harvey, a former 4-H horse judging team member and a former WVU horse judging team member. Now an agricultural education graduate student at WVU, Harvey said her 4-H experiences, particularly giving oral reasons, have helped her gain self-confidence and have helped her with her classroom teaching.
"Learning to give reasons for making decisions has helped me in everyday life," she said, "when making decisions about school, family and friends."
The impact 4-H has on youths' abilities impressed her once again when she did her practice teaching in Pleasants County. 4-H members, especially the high school freshmen, were generally group leaders.
"The 4-H'ers," she said, "exhibited a tremendous amount of leadership."
continued next page
"I place this class ... " Each senior 4-H horse judging team member takes a turn at standing before a contest judge to describe how each of four horses in a class should be ranked and why each deserves its respective placement.
11
Not to Decide is ... continued from page 11
Harvey feels indebted to 4-H for what 4-H in general and 4-H judging in particular have done for her and for others. She repays that debt by serving as a 4-H volunteer. The debt is one that many 4-H judging team members acknowledge.
Dr. Julia S. McCann, a Uoliversity of Georgia professor who is studying the benefits of collegiate judging programs, sums up teachers and students' estimations this way:
"Life after graduation has few written tests. But innumerable post-graduation 'tests' require acute perception of a situation, sound decision-making skills, ability to communicate effectively, and the 'heart' or perseverance to carry on in the face of adversity so that personal and professional goals may be attained. These are the tests that students become better prepared for if they have participated on a well-trained judging team." nd
VISION is published three times a year by the West Virginia University Extension Service.
Contributing writers: Joyce Bower Florita Montgomery Rachel B. Tompkins
Layout & Graphics: Hoye Walls
Printing: WVU Communications Services
Photo Credits: Bob Beverly, Charles Bower and Ed Petrosky
Rachel B.Tompkins Associate Provost for Extension and Economic Development
Meredith Manor students and staff held junior 4-H'ers, parents and volunteers' interest with horse care and grooming demonstrations. The shoeing demonstration was a favorite.
Programs and activities offered by the West Virginia University Cooperative Extension Service are available to all persons without regard to race, color, sex, national origin, or handicap.
Cooperative Extension Work in Agriculture and Home Economics, West Virginia University and the United States Department of Agriculture, Cooperating. Rachel B. Tompkins, Director, Morgantown, West Virginia. Published in Furtherance of Acts of Congress of May 8 and June 30,1914.
Director, Cooperative Extension Service P.O. Box 6031, Knapp Hall
Nonprofit Organization U.S. Postage Paid Morgantown, WV
Permit No. 34
Morgantown, WV 26506-6031