uwe bristol ‘child & family wishes’ for end of life care: a multi-service case notes review...
Post on 20-Dec-2015
214 views
TRANSCRIPT
UWE Bristol
‘Child & Family Wishes’ for end of life care:a multi-service case notes review of end of life planning for children with life-limiting conditions
Dr. Antonia BeringerSenior Research Fellow, University of the West of England, Bristol.
Dr. Emma HeckfordSpR Paediatric Palliative Medicine, University Hospital Wales, Cardiff.
Background
• Planning for end of life (EoL) is a sensitive and important part of providing comprehensive and individualised palliative care – reflected in ACT standards
• Least well achieved of the pathway standards • Bristol based project group developed ‘Child &
Family Wishes document’ guidance to support EoL planning (Fraser et al 2010)
Aims
• To review documentary evidence of planning against the ACT key standards for EoL care across hospital and community health service and voluntary sector children’s palliative care providers.
• To measure the impact of the ‘Child & Family Wishes’ document on EoL care planning.
Method
• a manual, retrospective, case notes review• children with a diagnosed life-limiting condition• died between October 2008 and March 2010• identified from Child Death Overview Panel
review data• defined geographical area• ethical and individual service permissions
Sample
• Source: 114 sets of notes from NHS hospital, NHS community, hospice and home based voluntary services
• 48 children/young people: 24 girls, 24 boys
ACT category n=
I 19
II 0
III 18
IV 11
Lead specialty
Lead specialty: Number of children
Oncology 16Neurology 11Neonatology 5Respiratory 5Cardiology 3Intensivists 3Community paediatrics 3Endocrinology 1General paediatrics 1
ACT standards for EoL careStandard
1 Professionals should be open and honest with families when the approach to end of life is recognised
2 Joint planning with families and relevant professionals should take place as soon as possible
3 A written plan of care should be agreed including decisions about methods of resuscitation; emergency services should be informed
4 Care plans should be reviewed and altered to take account of changes
5 There should be 24 hour access to pain and symptom control including access to medication
6 Emotional and spiritual support should be available to the child and carers
7 Children and families should be supported in their choices and goals for quality of life to the end
Standard 1: Professionals should be open and honest with families when the approach to end of life is recognised
Open discussion
• Discussion documented in 35/48 cases• In 1/48 case young person had been present• Cases where siblings told but not affected child • Discussion about EoL plans sometimes resisted
by parents and postponed by staff.
Standard 2: Joint planning with families and relevant professionals should take place as soon as possible
Joint planningServices involved: min 3, max 22, mean 5.
Plans often made late in the child's life• delays related to diagnostic/prognostic uncertainty or
ongoing curative management• plans triggered by an acute life threatening event• timely and comprehensive planning more likely by
specialist palliative care services
Standard 3: A written plan of care should be agreed including decisions about resuscitation; emergency services should be informed*
Wishes at different stages of life
*Emergency services informed in 6/48 cases.
Yes No
During the child's life 30 18
If the child becomes more unwell 34 14
In event of acute life-threatening event 36 12
After the child's death 23 25
Standard 4: Care plans should be reviewed and altered to take account of changes
Care plan review
• 29/48 had been regularly reviewed and updated• Plans often buried with narrative of the notes• ‘Wishes’ document not used – services ‘own’
forms preferred
Standard 5: there should be 24 hour access to pain and symptom control including access to medication
24/7 access
Standard 6: Emotional and spiritual support should be available to the child and carers
Bereavement support
• 8/48 cases - support not documented (all NHS services)• Non-NHS services - detail of support offered and taken
up.• Extended periods of post-bereavement support reported
by community based services.• Parent-led support group established.
Standard 7: Children and families should be supported in their choices and goals for quality of life to the end
Place of care Preferred place of care
Preferred place of death
Actual placeof death
Home 14 9 11
Hospice 4 12 16
Hospice or home 6 6 -
Hospital 3 1 19
Not stated 21 20 -
Ambulance 1
College 1
Key points
Wide variation between and within services in level to which ACT End of Life care standards are being met.
EoL care information buried within narrative of notes making it hard to find and act upon.
Multi-service nature and uncertain trajectory of end of life care creates challenges for services and families.
What will help?
• Awareness raising
• Training & support
• Accessible documents
• Prompts – verbal, electronic, written
• Deeper cultural shift...