university grants

1
656 Annotations. UNIVERSITY GRANTS. "Ne aaict nimis." THE Universities Grants Committee have just issued their report, which they describe as a preliminary survey of some of the outstanding difficulties of finance and organisation which confront the universities at the present time. The Committee consist of Sir William M’Cormick (Chairman), Dr. W. Bateson, Sir Dugald Clerk, Sir J. J. Dobbie, Miss S. M. Fry, Sir F. G. Kenyon, Sir Stanley Leathes, Sir Wilmot Herringham (who was appointed in place of the late Sir William Osler), and Sir J. J. Thomson. The report opens with an expression of the Committee’s sense of the efficiency maintained in the universities and colleges generally in the face of serious difficulties; the members were convinced at an early stage in their investigations that the present resources of the universities are inadequate. Since the armistice the Treasury grants as a whole have been increased by 83 per cent., and support has been obtained through increased tuition fees, and, in some instances, assistance from local education authorities; but all expenditure has increased enormously, and even if pre-war incomes had been doubled it is doubtful whether the universities would be as well off as they were before the war. The Committee are satisfied that the efficiency of university education will be seriously endangered unless further substantial improvement is made in the salaries of teaching staffs. It was clear from evidence received that some members of university staffs were living in circumstances quite incompatible with continued efficiency; material re- adjustments of salaries were long overdue in 1914, and present economic conditions emphasise the urgency of the question. The Committee doubt whether universal flat rates and automatic increments are possible or desirable, but they consider that it would be an advantage if all grant-aided institutions could agree upon basic minimum salaries within grades and faculties. Hardly less important is the provision of a suitable system of superannuation, with maintenance of the autonomy of the universities, and facility for free transference of teachers into other professions. The insufficient numbers of teachers are also causing anxiety to university authorities; members of the staffs are, as a rule, not only under- paid but also overworked, and sufficient leisure to pursue research is as essential as adequate remuneration. With reference to tenure of appoint- ments the Committee are of opinion that greater fixity is in many cases desirable; and as regards status, lecturers below the rank of professor should be given an effective voice in internal administration and the regulation of study and discipline. Passing on to the subjects of equipment and accommodation, the Com- mittee refer to the necessity of adequate provision for increase and upkeep of university libraries, and to the wider recognition of the importance of the librarian’s position. The needs of the Faculty of Arts are mainly for personnel; the Faculty of Pure Science requires, in addition, accommodation and material equipment, particularly in view of the large numbers of ex-Service students who have recently entered the latter depart- ment of study. Turning to applied science, the Committee take the Faculty of Medicine as the best example of the theoretical and practical in combination, as the requisite thorough I grounding in the basic sciences of physics, chemistry, and biology, and in the intermediate anatomy and 1 physiology, illustrate the essential condition of a uni- f versity education in any applied subject. The Com- mittee are of opinion that no education can be called i liberal which leaves a student at 18 ignorant of ] the fundamental laws of nature; but there are i too few secondary schools in which these subjects are at present properly taught to permit the uni- i versities to dispense with elementary instruction ’- in them. Within the past 25 years the teaching J of students of medicine has been very widely extended, and is now passing into the hands of teachers devoting their entire time to the work, each subject of which requires much space and great expense for laboratory purposes. It has not in England been considered a necessary qualification for teaching medicine that a man should have practised laboratory methods of advancing the science; the Royal Commission of University Education in London, reporting in 1913, recommended the setting up of a system which would provide teachers and assistant staffs willing to devote themselves to scientific investigation. This system is now in operation by means of the clinical units estab- lished, with the assistance of grant aid from the Treasury, at the medical schools of four London hospitals, and the Committee state that everywhere throughout England and Scotland the principle has been seized upon and the need realised; they have issued a statement for the guidance of university bodies contemplating the establishment of new arrangements to this end. In considering general needs, the Committee recom- mend throughout the provision of grant aid in the form of block grants. Reference is made in the report to the serious shortage of residential accommodation for students in most of the great cities, and to the wide extension of extra-mural work. In consultation with the authorities of universities and colleges the Committee have drawn up for annual presentation to Parliament schedules displaying the essential items of income and expenditure, together with statistics of students. They express the opinion that it is not perhaps an impossible ideal to look forward to a general scheme whereby the areas served by different uni- versities should be defined, and all rating authorities should contribute to their local university the proceeds of a penny rate. In conclusion, the Committee emphasise the possibility of local support in future grant allocations, and urge upon university authorities the importance of regarding their endowment funds as their central source of revenue. ACUTE PERITONITIS SIMULATING ENTERITIS. CONSTIPATION is the rule in acute peritonitis and in the cases in which diarrhoea occurs the peritoneal symptoms-abdominal pain and tenderness and repeated vomiting-generally render the diagnosis clear. At a meeting of the Societe Medicale des H6pitaux of Paris, MM. A. Berge and J. Roberti reported a case in which the diarrhoea was so prominent a symptom and the signs of peritonitis so slight that the diagnosis from acute enteritis remained doubtful for a long time and prevented operation at the most favourable time. A dressmaker, aged 21 years, was admitted into hospital on July 23rd, 1920. The history was that after dancing all night on the 17th and taking six or seven ices she had slight rigors on the evening of the 18th. However, she was able to work on the 19th. That night she was. attacked with diarrhoea and pain in the abdomen, which from the first was generalised. On the morning of the 20th she vomited her coffee. The diarrhaea, accompanied by colic, continued. Fifteen to 20 greenish glairy stools were passed daily. For five months she had suffered from leucorrhoea. Menstruation was very irregular. On examination she was prostrate, and the eyes were sunken. More than 10 greenish glairy foetid stools had been passed in 12 hours and one contained a little blood. There was no nausea. In the hospital she vomited three-quarters of a litre of greenish fluid; f this was the second time she vomited in four days. The abdomen was a little distended, tender all over, and especially in’the left iliac fossa. But the tenderness was neither exquisite nor superficial; strong pressure was necessary to provoke it. There was no cutaneous hyperaesthesia and no pain on sudden depression of the abdominal wall. The patient could sit up without pain. The tongue was moist, the temperature 102’80 F., the pulse 116 and good, and the respiration 35. There was oliguria and no albuminuria. Attempts at inducing abortion were denied. Menstruation last took place at the end of June. Vaginal examination showed the cervix a little

Upload: ashley-r

Post on 30-Dec-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNIVERSITY GRANTS

656

Annotations.UNIVERSITY GRANTS.

"Ne aaict nimis."

THE Universities Grants Committee have just issuedtheir report, which they describe as a preliminarysurvey of some of the outstanding difficulties of financeand organisation which confront the universities at thepresent time. The Committee consist of Sir WilliamM’Cormick (Chairman), Dr. W. Bateson, Sir DugaldClerk, Sir J. J. Dobbie, Miss S. M. Fry, Sir F. G.Kenyon, Sir Stanley Leathes, Sir Wilmot Herringham(who was appointed in place of the late Sir WilliamOsler), and Sir J. J. Thomson. The report opens withan expression of the Committee’s sense of the efficiencymaintained in the universities and colleges generally inthe face of serious difficulties; the members wereconvinced at an early stage in their investigationsthat the present resources of the universities areinadequate. Since the armistice the Treasury grantsas a whole have been increased by 83 per cent., andsupport has been obtained through increased tuitionfees, and, in some instances, assistance from localeducation authorities; but all expenditure has increasedenormously, and even if pre-war incomes had beendoubled it is doubtful whether the universities would beas well off as they were before the war. The Committeeare satisfied that the efficiency of university educationwill be seriously endangered unless further substantialimprovement is made in the salaries of teaching staffs.It was clear from evidence received that some membersof university staffs were living in circumstances quiteincompatible with continued efficiency; material re-adjustments of salaries were long overdue in 1914, andpresent economic conditions emphasise the urgency ofthe question. The Committee doubt whether universalflat rates and automatic increments are possible ordesirable, but they consider that it would be an

advantage if all grant-aided institutions could agreeupon basic minimum salaries within grades andfaculties. Hardly less important is the provision ofa suitable system of superannuation, with maintenanceof the autonomy of the universities, and facility forfree transference of teachers into other professions.The insufficient numbers of teachers are also

causing anxiety to university authorities; membersof the staffs are, as a rule, not only under-

paid but also overworked, and sufficient leisureto pursue research is as essential as adequateremuneration. With reference to tenure of appoint-ments the Committee are of opinion that greater fixityis in many cases desirable; and as regards status,lecturers below the rank of professor should be givenan effective voice in internal administration and theregulation of study and discipline. Passing on to thesubjects of equipment and accommodation, the Com-mittee refer to the necessity of adequate provision forincrease and upkeep of university libraries, and to thewider recognition of the importance of the librarian’sposition. The needs of the Faculty of Arts are mainlyfor personnel; the Faculty of Pure Science requires,in addition, accommodation and material equipment,particularly in view of the large numbers of ex-Servicestudents who have recently entered the latter depart-ment of study.Turning to applied science, the Committee take the

Faculty of Medicine as the best example of the theoreticaland practical in combination, as the requisite thorough I

grounding in the basic sciences of physics, chemistry,and biology, and in the intermediate anatomy and 1

physiology, illustrate the essential condition of a uni- fversity education in any applied subject. The Com-mittee are of opinion that no education can be called iliberal which leaves a student at 18 ignorant of ]the fundamental laws of nature; but there are i

too few secondary schools in which these subjectsare at present properly taught to permit the uni- i

versities to dispense with elementary instruction ’-in them. Within the past 25 years the teaching J

of students of medicine has been very widely extended,and is now passing into the hands of teachers devotingtheir entire time to the work, each subject of whichrequires much space and great expense for laboratorypurposes. It has not in England been considered anecessary qualification for teaching medicine that aman should have practised laboratory methods of

advancing the science; the Royal Commission of

University Education in London, reporting in 1913,recommended the setting up of a system which wouldprovide teachers and assistant staffs willing to devotethemselves to scientific investigation. This system isnow in operation by means of the clinical units estab-lished, with the assistance of grant aid from the Treasury,at the medical schools of four London hospitals, andthe Committee state that everywhere throughoutEngland and Scotland the principle has been seized uponand the need realised; they have issued a statementfor the guidance of university bodies contemplating theestablishment of new arrangements to this end.In considering general needs, the Committee recom-

mend throughout the provision of grant aid in the formof block grants. Reference is made in the report to theserious shortage of residential accommodation forstudents in most of the great cities, and to the wideextension of extra-mural work. In consultation withthe authorities of universities and colleges theCommittee have drawn up for annual presentation toParliament schedules displaying the essential items ofincome and expenditure, together with statistics ofstudents. They express the opinion that it is notperhaps an impossible ideal to look forward to a generalscheme whereby the areas served by different uni-versities should be defined, and all rating authoritiesshould contribute to their local university the proceedsof a penny rate. In conclusion, the Committeeemphasise the possibility of local support in futuregrant allocations, and urge upon university authoritiesthe importance of regarding their endowment funds astheir central source of revenue.

ACUTE PERITONITIS SIMULATING ENTERITIS.

CONSTIPATION is the rule in acute peritonitis and inthe cases in which diarrhoea occurs the peritonealsymptoms-abdominal pain and tenderness and repeatedvomiting-generally render the diagnosis clear. At ameeting of the Societe Medicale des H6pitaux of Paris,MM. A. Berge and J. Roberti reported a case in whichthe diarrhoea was so prominent a symptom and thesigns of peritonitis so slight that the diagnosis fromacute enteritis remained doubtful for a long time andprevented operation at the most favourable time. Adressmaker, aged 21 years, was admitted into hospitalon July 23rd, 1920. The history was that after dancingall night on the 17th and taking six or seven ices shehad slight rigors on the evening of the 18th. However,she was able to work on the 19th. That night she was.attacked with diarrhoea and pain in the abdomen, whichfrom the first was generalised. On the morningof the 20th she vomited her coffee. The diarrhaea,accompanied by colic, continued. Fifteen to 20 greenishglairy stools were passed daily. For five months shehad suffered from leucorrhoea. Menstruation was veryirregular. On examination she was prostrate, and theeyes were sunken. More than 10 greenish glairy foetidstools had been passed in 12 hours and one contained alittle blood. There was no nausea. In the hospital shevomited three-quarters of a litre of greenish fluid; fthis was the second time she vomited in four days.The abdomen was a little distended, tender allover, and especially in’the left iliac fossa. But thetenderness was neither exquisite nor superficial;strong pressure was necessary to provoke it. Therewas no cutaneous hyperaesthesia and no pain on

sudden depression of the abdominal wall. Thepatient could sit up without pain. The tongue wasmoist, the temperature 102’80 F., the pulse 116 andgood, and the respiration 35. There was oliguria andno albuminuria. Attempts at inducing abortion weredenied. Menstruation last took place at the end ofJune. Vaginal examination showed the cervix a little