two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · achernar eri 6.5 339 m. rieutord 2d...

27
Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars Michel Rieutord Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Plan´ etologie, Toulouse, France IAU – GA – 2015 – Honolulu M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Upload: others

Post on 01-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Two-dimensional models of early-type fastrotating stars

Michel Rieutord

Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planetologie,Toulouse, France

IAU – GA – 2015 – Honolulu

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 2: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Why should we make 2D-models ?

To deal properly with rotation !

Rotation means

non spherical stars

baroclinic flows in radiative region

anisotropic convection

We note that

1D rotating models are valid when Ω→ 0

A lot of physics is condensed inside adjustable (transport)coefficients

1D models are not usable in asteroseismology of rapidrotators

New data from optical/IR interferometry require a 2D view...

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 3: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Why should we make 2D-models ?

To deal properly with rotation !

Rotation means

non spherical stars

baroclinic flows in radiative region

anisotropic convection

We note that

1D rotating models are valid when Ω→ 0

A lot of physics is condensed inside adjustable (transport)coefficients

1D models are not usable in asteroseismology of rapidrotators

New data from optical/IR interferometry require a 2D view...

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 4: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Interferometry : Achernar

Figure : Achernar with VLTI (Domiciano de Souza et al. 2014, AA 569)

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 5: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Interferometry : Altair

Figure : Altair seen by CHARA (Monnier et al. 2007).

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 6: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

An idealization/simplification

We consider a lonely rotating star

We are interested in long time-scales

We discard all magnetic fields.

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 7: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

An idealization/simplification

We consider a lonely rotating star

We are interested in long time-scales

We discard all magnetic fields.

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 8: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

An idealization/simplification

We consider a lonely rotating star

We are interested in long time-scales

We discard all magnetic fields.

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 9: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

The equations of the structurePDE

∆φ = 4πGρρT~v · ~∇S = −Div~F + ε∗

ρ(2~Ω∗ ∧ ~v + ~v · ~∇~v) = −~∇P − ρ~∇(φ − 12Ω2∗s

2) + ~Fv

Div(ρ~v) = 0.

(1)

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 10: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

The equations of the structureMicrophysics

P ≡ P(ρ,T) OPALκ ≡ κ(ρ,T) OPALε∗ ≡ ε∗(ρ,T) NACRE

(2)

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 11: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

The equations of the structureTurbulence

The energy flux~F = −χr~∇T −

χturbTRM

~∇S

The transport of momentum

~Fv = µ ~Fµ(~v) = µ

[∆~v +

13~∇

(~∇ · ~v

)+ 2

(~∇ ln µ · ~∇

)~v

+~∇ ln µ × (~∇ × ~v) −23

(~∇ · ~v

)~∇ ln µ

].

or any mean-field expression of the Reynolds stress.

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 12: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Boundary conditions

On pressure

Ps =23

On the velocity field

~v · ~n = 0 and ([σ]~n) ∧ ~n = ~0

On temperature (black body radiation)

~n · ~∇T + T/LT = 0

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 13: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

The last touch

∫(V)

r sin θρuϕ dV = L

or

vϕ(r = R, θ = π/2) = VEq

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 14: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

The ESTER code

Figure : Freely available on the www

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 15: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Gravity darkening of Achernar (α Eri)

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 16: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Gravity darkening exponent : Teff ∝ gβeff

Figure : Observed values of β and a simple model of Espinosa Lara &Rieutord (2011).

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 17: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Models of nearby stars

We have modeled 8 stars of intermediate mass :

Star M (M) Veq(km/s)Altair α Aql 1.9 286Alderamin α Cep 1.9 265Ras Alhague α Oph 2.2 242

δA Vel 2.27 & 2.43 150 & 143Vega α Lyr 2.4 205Regulus α Leo 4.1 335Achernar α Eri 6.5 339

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 18: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

δ Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with PIONIER

Figure : The orbit of delta vel (Kervella et al. 2013).

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 19: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

δ Velorum AAn eclipsing binary made of A stars

Star Delta Velorum Aa Delta Velorum AbObs. Model Obs. Model

Mass (M) 2.43 ± 0.02 2.43 2.27±0.02 2.27Req (R) 2.97±0.02 2.95 2.52±0.03 2.52Rpol (R) 2.79±0.04 2.77 2.37±0.02 2.36Teq (K) 9450 9440 9560 9477Tpol(K) 10100 10044 10120 10115L (L) 67±3 65.2 51±2 48.5Veq (km/s) 143 143 150 153Peq (days) 1.045 0.832Ppol (days) 1.084 0.924Xenv. 0.70 0.70Xcore/Xenv. 0.10 0.30Z 0.011 0.011

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 20: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Inside the stars : internal differential rotationM=30M at 98% of critical angular velocity

Espinosa Lara & Rieutord (2013) A&A,552,A35

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 21: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Inside the stars : meridional circulationM=5M at 70% of critical angular velocity

Espinosa Lara & Rieutord (2013)

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 22: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Towards evolutionHR diagram track of a 7M star of constant angular momentum, starting at Ω/Ωk = 0.5.

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 23: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Towards evolutionHR diagram tracks at constant angular momentum

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 24: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Towards evolution : increasing impact of rotation

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 25: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Evolution of a 5M star at constant angular momentum :heading to the Be state

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 26: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Conclusions

Two points to take away :

1 ESTER 2D models are ripe to face observational data inasteroseismologyinterferometry

for early-type stars.

2 The radiative envelope of a fast rotating early-type star ownscomplex flows not accounted for in 1D models

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars

Page 27: Two-dimensional models of early-type fast rotating stars · Achernar Eri 6.5 339 M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars Vel seen by Kervella et al. 2013 at VLTI with

Some references

Espinosa Lara & Rieutord (2013), A&A,552, A35

Rieutord & Espinosa Lara (2013), LNP,865, 49

ESTER website : http ://ester-project.github.io/ester/

M. Rieutord 2D models of early-type fast rotating stars