trial dxv037 - europaart45-paediatric-studies-docs.ema.europa.eu/group i... · trial no.: dxv03î13...
TRANSCRIPT
Reference 2 \.\
CLIMCAL TRIAL FINAL REPORT
NYCOMEDIA¡AGING
13 December 1995
Trial No.DXV037
IODD(ANOL (yISrpAQUE9 rN PAEDTATRTC EXCRETORYUROGRAPHY
A multicentre randomized, parallel group, double-blind phase III comparison betweeniodixanol (Vsnaqun\270 mg Vml and 320 mg Uml,
and iohexot (Omnipaqueo¡ 300 mg Umlat
Hôpital de Clocheville, Service de RadiologieTours, France,
Hôpital Charles Nicolle, Service de RadiologieRouen, France
andHôpital Robert Debre, Service de Radiologie
Paris, France
Trial No.: DXV03î13 December 1995 S1 of6
SYNOPSIS
In the present trial iodixanol (Vlsnequeo) was investigated in excretory urography in paediatric
patients. The study was a phase III randomized, parallel group, double-blind comparison between
iodixanol320 mg Vml and 270mgVml, and iohexol (Omnipaquet) ¡00 mg Vml.
The original intention was to perform a combined open phase tr and a double-blind phase Itr
study. However, by April 1995 fifty-eight paediatric patients had been included in the American
and European Visipaque@ paediatric programme. Twenty-four of these patients were below three
years ofage, and only one serious adverse event had been reported. Based on these results, it was
considered safe to include phase III patients, and to cancel the phase II part ofthe study
(Amendment 01, dated 21 April 1994).
The trial was performed at th¡ee different centres in France; Hôpital de Clocheville, Tours,
Hôpital Cha¡les Nicolle, Rouen, and Hôpital Robert Debre, Pa¡is. The inclusion of patients
started in May 1994 and was completed in June 1995. A total of 72 patients (aged three weeks to
15 years and two months) were included in the trial; 25 patients at Hôpital de Clocheville, 30
patients at Hôpital Cha¡les Nicolle, and 17 patients at Hôpital Robert Debre.
The main objective of the study was to compare iodixanol and iohexol regarding safety and
efficacy in excretory urography in paediatric patients. Safety was documented by means of
recording adverse events (including injection-associated discomfort and distress) and vital signs,
whereas efficacy was evaluated from the diagnostic information obtained from urograms of both
kidneys. Four anatomical areas were evaluated separately; parenchyma, calyces, pelvis and ureter.
Images were acquired immediately (0 minutes) after the injection of cont¡ast medium, 3 minutes
and 15 min afterwa¡ds, and when maximum hlling took place. An overall diagnostic evaluation
was also made based on a review of the enhanced images obtained at all time points.
N\ NYCOftIEDIÀAAGING
52of6Trial No.: DXV03nl3 December 1995
The main safefy parameter for statistical analysis wa.s the proportion of patients with adverse
events, including injection-associated discomfort and distress, during and up to 24 hours after the
end of the examination.
Seventy-five patients were randomized into three groups of 25 patients; 25 patients received
iodixanol 320 mg Vml and 25 patients received iohexol 300 mg Vml. Only 22 patients received
iodixanol 270 mg Vml. This was due to prolonged storage of the th¡ee contrast medium vials in
the heating cabinet for three of the patients which precluded their use; all three vials contained
iodixanol 270 mg VmI. The three groups were judged to be comparable regarding demographic
cha¡acteristics and risk factors (Table S.1), and concerning relevant medical history, presenting
symptoms and medications.
Results
The mean volumes of contrast medium injected in the three groups during the trial were24.4 mI
(iodixanol 320mgVrnl),23.6 ml (iodixanol27O mg Vml), and27.6 ml (iohexol300 mg Urnl).
The corresponding doses in terms of iodine were 0.56 g iodine per kg body weight (gllkg b.w.),
O.43 gllkg b.w. and 0.49 gllkg b.w.
One case of injection-associated discomfort was reported in this trial. Patient No. 439, in the
iodixanol 320 mg Vml group, reported a mild sensation of heat in his throat in connection with
the injection of the contrast medium (Table S.2).
None of the patients in this trial reported injection-associated distress.
Three patients in the iodixanol 320 mg Vml group experienced adve¡se events other than
injection-associated discomfort and distress. These events were periorbital oedema, fever and
erythema (Table S.2). The fever and erythema were both of mild intensity, whereas the periorbital
oedema was of severe intensity. The periorbital oedema was classified as being related to the t¡ial
drug, whereas the episode of fever was reported to be of uncertain origin.
z
Trial No.: DXV03^13 December 1995
NYCOMEDIÀAAGING
53 of6
The erythema was considered as being related to the patient's underþing disease.
One patient (No. 332) in the iodixanol2T0 mg Uml reported an adverse event other than
injection-associated discomfort and distress. The patient had fever in the evening after the
examination. The intensity was reported to be mild, and the cause was stated to be the patient's
underlying disease.
One patient (No. 338) in the iohexol 300 mg Vml group reported an adverse event other than
injection-associated discomfort and distress. The patient had pruritus of mild intensiry lasting for
30 minutes in the evening after the examination. The cause was classified as related to the t¡ial
drug.
In order to compare the proportion of patients with any adverse events including injection-
associated discomfort and distress in each of the iodixanol groups to the group receiving iohexol,
Fisher's Exact test was performed twice. The result showed that the proportions were not
statistically significantly different. However, the lowest proportion of adverse events including
injection-associated discomfort and distress was reco¡ded in the iodixanol 210 mg Vml group.
No serious adverse event occuûed during the conduct of this trial.
Changes in vital signs were stated to be of clinical importance for one patient (No 317). This
patient received iodixanol 32O mg Vml. His blood pressure increased considerably (from 80/40
mm Hg befo¡e injection to I20l9O mm Hg 20-30 minutes after the end of the examination) and
this was judged to be due to crying during the procedure,
The scores for overall diagnostic information for both kidneys a¡e shown in Table S.3. The
qualiry of overall diagnostic information for the right kidney in the iodixanol32O mg Vml group
was classified as "excellent" for 15 patients, "good" for 8 patients, "poor" for I patient, and
"inadequate" for I patient. In the iodixanol 270 mg Vml group the quality of diagnostic
s\
\\ NYCOT,IEDIÀ4AGING
54of6Trial No.: DXV03nl3 December 1995
information was rated "excellent" for 12 patients, "good" for 9 patients, and "poor" for 1 patient.
In the iohexol 3ffi mg Vml group it was rated as "excellent" for 11 patients, "good" for 13
patients, and "inadequate" for 1 patient.
The results for the left kidney were essentially the same; 13 patients had urograms with
"excellent" overall diagnostic information in the iodixanol 320 mg Uml group, whereas 12
patients had "good" overall diagnostic information. Among the patients receiving iodixanol 270
mg Vml, ten patients had images rated to give "excellent" overall diagnostic information, eight
patients had images that gave "good" overall diagnostic information, whereas images fuom?
patients were judged to give "¡)oor" overall diagnostic information. For the last 2 patients in this
group, overall diagnostic inforrration was considered to be "inadequate". In the iohexol 300 mg
Vml group images from 8 patients were rated "excellent", 13 "good", 3 "poor" and 1 "inadequate"
(Table S.3).
A Fisher's Exact test (two tails) for 2 x 3 tables was used to test the equality in the distribution of
adequate or inadequate overall radiographic quality between the three contrast rnedia groups. The
results showed no significant differences in the probabilistic distribution regarding these two
categories between any of the contrast media. For the left kidney the p-value was 0.28, and for
the right kidney the p-value was 1.00.
Summing up, no statistically significant differences were found between the iodixanol gloups and
the iohexol group as regards the proportion of patients with adverse events and overall efficacy.
The dose of iodine given (gllkg b.w.) was lowest for the patients receiving iodixanol 270 mg
Vml. However, this dose was shown to be sufficient to provide images with excellent overall
diagnostic information in 50Vo of the patients, whereas 387o of the images from patients receiving
iohexol30O mg Vml was given this rating.
In conclusion, iodixanol in the two concent¡ations tested in this ar'al (270 mg Vml and 320 mg
Vml) proved to be effective and well tolerated when administrated intravenously for excretory
N ffitRg'oTrial No.: DXVO3nl3 December 1995 55of6
urography in paediatric patients. The lower concentration of iodixanol (270 mg Vml) may be
recommended for paediatric use, where a high dose of iodine per kg b.w. often is used.
Table S. 1 DEMOGRAPHICS/KNOWN RISK FACTORS
Number of pts. randomized 25 25 25
Number of pts. examined with contrast
lmale/female)
22 (t3t9) 25 (15/r0) 2s (14il1)
Mean ase (std) months 49.5 (55.6) 45.1 (53.3) 59.3 (59.9)
Mean heisht (std) cm 95.3 (33.5) 92.0 G5.r 99.3 (37.3)
Mean weieht (std) ks 16.4 (r2.1\ 16.9 (r4.2\ 19.0 (13.5)
Ethnic oriein; Caucasian (other) 2t (r 2s (0) 22 (3',)
Number of pts. with risk factors (No. of risk
factors)
5 (6) 4 (s) 3 (5)
Mean volume iniected lstd) ml 23.6 023\ 24.4 (r4.5) 27.6 (15.6\
Mean dosase iodine (std) sI 6.4 (3.3) 7.8 (4.6) 8.3 ø.7\
Mean dosage iodine (std) gVkg b.w. 0.43 (0,10) 0.56 (0.17) 0.49 (0.12)
Table S.2 SAFETY RESULTS
,,1-gno¡¡¡ónmt
ADVERSE EVENTS other than injcction-associated
discomfort/distress. No. of ots. l%)
1 (4.s) 3 (12.0',) l (4.0)
INJECTION-ASSOCTATED DISCOMFORT, No.
of ots. l%)
0 I (4) 0
INJECTION-ASSOCIATED DISTRESS,
No. of pts. (7o)
0 0 0
I
Trial No.: DXV03nt3 December 1995 56of6
Table S.3
EFFICACY RF^SULTS ; OVERALL DIAGNOSTIC QUALITYRIGIIT/LEFT KIDNEY
Iodixanol 270 me Uml. rishúleft kidnev tuto 918 v2 0t2
Iodixanol 320 meUrî1. riehtneft kidnev t5l13 8^2 1/0 l/0
Iohexol 300 ms Vnil. richt/left kidriev I 1/8 t1t13 0/3 vlTotal, right/left kidncy 38/3 I 30t33 a5 u3
t7