transforming school funding - education resource strategies · bargaining agreements and state...
TRANSCRIPT
A Guide to Implementing Student-Based Budgeting (SBB)
Transforming School Funding
Foreword by Karen Hawley Miles
Standards
Teaching
School Design
Leadership
School Support
Partners
Funding
JANUARY 2014
Taking the Plunge
IMPLEMENTING STUDENT-BASED BUDGETING (SBB)
Adjust Core Processes
Rethink Principal and District Office Roles
Design Training and Support
Build and Sustain Investment
Implementing SBB
Define the Eligible Pool of Resources
Build the Funding Formula
Unlock Resources
Make Policy Decisions
Project the Size of the SBB Pool
Choose Weight Values and Test
Scenarios
Designing the System
Is SBB Right for My District?
What Kind of Team Do We Need?
When and How Should We Roll Out SBB?
CONTENTS
Foreword and Introduction ................................................................. 4
Student-Based Budgeting, Defined ..................................................... 6
Taking the Plunge ................................................................................ 8 •IsSBBRightforMyDistrict? •WhatKindofTeamDoWeNeed? •WhenandHowShouldWeRollOutSBB?
Designing the System ........................................................................... 13 •DefinetheEligiblePoolofResources •UnlockResources •ProjecttheSizeoftheSBBPool •BuildtheFundingFormula •MakePolicyDecisions •ChooseWeightValuesandTestScenarios
Implementing SBB ............................................................................... 24 •AdjustCoreProcesses •RethinkPrincipalandDistrictOfficeRoles •DesignTrainingandSupport •BuildandSustainInvestment
In Closing: Keys to Success ..................................................................33
4
Foreword and Introduction by Karen Hawley Miles
Schooldistrictleadersfaceanarrayofchallengesthataffecthowtheyallocatescarceresourcestoschools—stubbornachievementgaps,changingandcomplexdemographics,andshrinkingfederalandstatesupport.Astherangeofneedgrowsmorecomplex,schoolsaregrowingasdiverseasthestudentstheyserve.Inthiscontext,manyleadersareactivelyseekingwaystoensurethatallschoolshaveflexibilitytoorganizeresourcestomatchstudentandschoolneeds,whilealsoensuringequityacrossschooltypes.
EducationResourceStrategies(ERS)leveragesmorethan15yearsofexperiencehelpingdistrictleadersstrategicallyreallocatetheirresourcestoimprovestudentperformance.Aspartofthiswork,we’vecollaboratedwithsomeoftheleadingdistrictsthathavemadeboldchangestotheirfundingsystemsandworkedthroughtheresultsofthesechanges.OurworkonfundingispartofourbroaderSchoolSystem20/20vision—anaction-orientedframeworkforurbanschooldistrictstoensurethateveryschoolsucceedsforeverychild.
Ourworkonschoolfundingisbasedonsevenprinciplesforeffectiveschoolbudgeting.Webelievethatallschoolfundingsystemsneedtorestonthisfoundation:
ERS Principles for Effective School Budgeting
Principle Description
Student-focused Provides resources based on students, not on buildings, adults, or programs
Equitable Allocates similar funding levels to students with similar characteristics, regardless of which school they attend
Transparent Easily understood by all stakeholders
Differentiated Allocates resources through a comprehensive framework that is based on student needs
Predictable School allocation process is predictable and is structured to minimize school-level disruption
Empowering Empowers school-based decision-making to effectively use resources
Aligned with district strategy
Supports the district’s multiyear strategic plan
5
Anincreasinglypopularapproachtoachievetheseendsistoexplicitlytiedollarstospecificstudentneeds.Thesemodelsgobymanynames:WeightedStudentFunding,FairStudentFunding,and (ourpreference)Student-BasedBudgeting,orSBB.1Inourworksupportingdistrictsaroundthedesignandimplementationofthesemodels,ERShasidentifiedaseriesofcrucialdesigndecisions,implementationtools,andchangemanagementstrategiesthatarehallmarksofthemostsuccessfulSBBefforts.
ThispapercodifiesthosepracticesintoaprocessthatcanbeadaptedbydistrictleaderswhobelieveSBBiscrucialtotheirbroaderdistrict-improvementplan.Weaimtoempowertheseleadersandtheirteamswiththecontext,knowledge,andstrategiesthey’llneedtodesignandimplementanSBBapproachthatdistributesresourcesmoreequitablyandeffectivelyacrossthedistrict.
Wehopethispapercatalyzesdialogueandcollaborationamongdistrictleadersandotherswho wanttoimprovetheirapproachtoresourceallocationtobenefitthemostimportantpeopleinoureducationsystem—ourstudents.
Acknowledgements
This work resulted from the efforts of numerous ERS team members over time. We would like to particularly recognize lead authors David Rosenberg, Jeff Gordon, and Betty Hsu, as well as our School Funding Practice Area, led by Stephen Frank and including Chris Lewis and Laura Schick. In addition, we are indebted to leaders from several ERS partner districts, including Baltimore City, Boston, Denver, Rochester, Prince George’s County, and Cleveland, who helped us develop and test these ideas through their own efforts to implement new funding systems. We are grateful to Carnegie Corporation of New York for providing funding for this report. ERS is solely responsible for any ideas presented in this paper, as well as any errors.
1Manydistrictsnametheprogramtoreflectitsprimarygoals.Forexample,leadersinRochester(NY)determinedthattheirmainobjective withSBBwastocreatemoreequitablefundingacrossthedistrict;therefore,theycalledtheirprogramEquitableStudentFunding.Engagingmultipleplayers,includingadministrators,principals,andteachers,intheearlydecisiononwhattocallyourprogramisacommonapproachtoensureyourefforttobuildconsensusaroundthestrategygetsoffontherightfoot.
6
Student-Based Budgeting, Defined
“Student-BasedBudgeting”describesanydistrictfundingmodelthat:
•Allocatesdollars(i.e.,insteadofstaff);
•Isbasedonthenumberofstudents;
•Isweightedusingobjective,measurablefactsabouteachindividualstudent.
Inshort,withSBB,dollarsfollowthestudentsbasedonstudentneed.
SBBdiffersfundamentallyfromthetraditionalfundingmodelstillemployedbymostAmericanschooldistricts,whichdistributesresourcestoschoolsintheformofstaffanddollarsdesignated forspecificpurposes.
Comparing Funding Systems
Traditional System Student-Based Budgeting Systems
Schools receive funds based on…
Districtwide staffing and resourcing ratios
A formula that provides a base amount to each school, supplemented by student need–based funding
School budgets include… Specific staff positions and a targeted set of prescribed resources
Funds to be spent on staff and other resourc-es based on the school’s instructional model, plus resources for categorical and centrally controlled funds
School leaders actively control…
As little as 1–5% of school budgets
40–80% of school budgets
ManydistrictsthatpursueStudent-BasedBudgetingseekthethreefoundationsofhigh-performingfundingsystems—equity,flexibility,andtransparency.
•Equity.Thestrongestfundingmodelsensurethatresourcesaredistributedequitablybasedonstudentneed.However,indistrictswehavestudied,it’snotuncommonforsomeschoolswiththehighest-needstudentstoreceiveaslittleashalfasmanyresourcescomparedtoschoolswiththelowest-needstudents.SBBrepresentsonewaytoremedythisinequity.
7
•Flexibility.Mostallocationdecisions—whetherofpeopleordollars—aremadeatthedistrictlevel.InfocusgroupsthatERShasconductedacrossthecountry,principalscommonlysaytheirbudgetdiscretionorauthoritycoverslessthanfivepercentoftheirschool’stotalbudget.Theyrarelyhaveaformalsayin,forexample,howmanyteachers,aides,ornoninstructionalstafftheyreceive,letalonewhothosepeoplewillbe.Ideally,leadersineachschoolbuildinghavetheopportunitytodefineoradjusttheresourcestheyneedtodrivestudentachieve-ment,giventheirspecificneeds.
•Transparency.Commonly,theaverageprincipaldoesn’tknow—andcan’ttell—howhisorheroverallresourceallocationcameabout.Theprocessisfragmentedandasaresult,exceedinglydifficulttounderstandatabroadlevel.Theoptimalfundingsystemhasclearandeasilyunderstoodrulesforwhere,how,andwhydollarsflow.
Itispossibleforatraditionalmodeltobeequitable,flexible,andtransparent;it’salsopossiblethataStudent-BasedBudgetingmodelcouldbeinequitable,inflexible,andopaque.Thisiswhywebelieve,firstandforemost,thatadistrictmustbeclearonitsoverallimprovementstrategy,including implicationsforresourceuseandallocation,beforesettlingonSBBasameanstoachieveitsgoals.
Key Takeaways•WithStudent-BasedBudgeting,dollarsfollowstudentsbasedonstudentneed.
•Student-BasedBudgetinggivesschoolsdollars,notfixedstafforprograms.
•Student-BasedBudgetingisalmostnevertheonlysourceofresourceallocationina district;categoricalfundswith“strings-attached”requirementstypicallysupplement themoreflexibleSBBallocation.
•DistrictsthatpursueSBBarecommonlysolvingforasystemwithequity,flexibility andtransparency.
Questions for Reflection•Howdoesyourdistrictcurrentlyallocateresourcesanddollarstoschools?
– Isitequitable?Howdoyouknow?
– Isitflexible?Howdoyouknow?
– Isittransparent?Howdoyouknow?
8
Taking the Plunge
BeforeyoujumpintoStudent-BasedBudgeting,werecommendsteppingbacktodothreethings.First,makesureSBBisrightforyourdistrict.Second,ifitis,organizeyourteamforsuccess.Third,determinewhenandhowtorolloutSBB.
Is SBB Right for My District?Tofigurethisout,startbyaskingsomebig-picturequestions:
•What role does SBB play in my broader strategy for improving student outcomes? ManydistrictleadersthinkofSBBasthestrategy.Inreality,SBBisbestthoughtofaspart ofabroaderapproachtobetterutilizingresources,oftenbyimprovingschooldesign,givingmoreautonomytoprincipals,andintensifyingleadershipdevelopmentatalllevels.IfyouarethinkingofSBBinthecontextoftheseorsimilarmoves,great;ifnot,youmaywanttostopandputSBBinabiggercontext.ERS’SchoolSystem20/20providesaframeworkforaligningresourcesacrossalllevels—district,school,andclassroom.
•How do I expect resources to shift as a result of SBB? Which schools may gain resources, and which lose resources? Ifyou’reconsideringSBB,youprobablythinksomeschoolsarecurrentlyoverfundedrelativetoneed,whileothersareunderfunded.Playingoutapotentialscenarioofwhichschoolswilllikely“win”and“lose”willhelpyouquicklyassesstheimplicationsofSBBsoyoucangetaheadofanyunexpectedconsequences.
•When I imagine what my district will look like after SBB is implemented, what other changes are implicitly included in that vision? What does that imply for the magnitude of the effort? SBBchangesthedollarsschoolsreceiveandtherulesforspendingthem,butitdoesNOTbyitselfleadtomoreeffectiveresourceuseandimprovedstudentperformance.It’scrucialtodetermineupfrontwhatelsemayneedtochange,andlaythegroundworkformakingithappen.Forexample,ifSBBispairedwithnewautonomiesforprincipals(asitcommonlyis),howpreparedareyourprincipalstomanagetheirownbudgetsandexerciseautonomyoverresourceuse?Whatothersupportisneededtorealizethefullpotentialofyourstrategy?
Onceyou’veconsideredthebroaderstrategicissues,you’rereadytoevaluateseveralconcretedecisionfactors.Ofcourse,conditionscanchangeovertime.AfteradecadeasapioneeroftheSBBmove-ment,SeattlePublicSchoolselectedtoreturntoamoretraditional,centralizedapproach.Districtleadersfeltthatduetolowoverallfundinglevels,aswellasconstraintsassociatedwithitscollectivebargainingagreementsandstatefunding,theproportionoffundsoverwhichschoolshadtruediscretionwithSBBwasn’tlargeenoughtomateriallyimpactschooldesign.Asaresult,Seattle movedtoahybridapproachcalledWeightedStudentStaffing,whichtakestheconceptofSBBweightsandappliesthemtothetraditionalratio-basedapproach.
9
Key Factors in the SBB Decision Process
Decision Factor SBB may be right for you if: SBB may be wrong for you if:
Per-pupil funding levels
At or above national average for your set of peer districts
Below average vs. peer districts and/or falling to the point where even with added school-level flexibility, resources are so scarce that SBB is unlikely to be a transformational lever
Potential resource flexibility
Is significant, even if principals do not yet have access to it
Is constrained by collective bargaining agreements, state-level oversight, or other factors not addressed by SBB
School leadership capacity
Principals are motivated by and capable of making wise, fact-based decisions about resource use and school design
Principals and district leaders are cautious about change (e.g., committed to “doing things the way we’ve always done them”)
Central office capacity
Leadership and managers have appetite and capacity for re-thinking their role in supporting schools and shifting mind-sets among school leaders
Leadership and managers are cautious about change, or focused solely on “putting out fires,” and lack capacity or willingness to change compliance mind-set
Data infrastructure
Systems run smoothly and de-liver accurate, timely data about students, teachers, and funds
Systems are fragmented, with teams pursuing “workarounds” to get and act on critical information
District leadership capacity
The district’s leadership team has the vision, passion, and appetite to overcome any challenges identified in the issues above
The district’s leadership team requires some “wind at their back” to facilitate the level of change SBB requires
AmidallthefactorsnecessaryforSBB,thecapacityofdistrictleaderstodrivechangehasthe potentialtooutweightheothers.Astrong-willedvisionaryleaderwiththeenergy,knowledge,passion,andteamtobreakdownbarrierswhilebuildingastrongculturecouldconceivably overcomesomeofthefactsintheright-handcolumn.
Case Study Driving a Change in Mindset from the Top
Baltimore’s SBB system is called Fair Student Funding due to its initial focus on improving funding equity, but another appropriate name for it would be the “Principal-as-CEO Funding System.” Superintendent Andrés Alonso was clear about his vision of a successful principal, and his standards were high. Arriving in 2007, Alonso offered principals new flexibility in exchange for heightened accountability for results. According to his theory of action, principals could not disclaim responsibility for student outcomes if they controlled the majority of school budgets. The market, he believed, would deliver the most capable school leaders. As a result, though there were challenges along the way, the mind-sets of district and school leaders were necessarily and meaningfully shifted.
10
IfSBBmakessenseinthecontextofyourvision,aswellasyourdistrict’sportfolio,capacity,andinfrastructure,you’rereadytofocusonyourteamandprogramtiming.
What Kind of Team Do We Need? SBBisnotjustaboutchangingfinancialformulas;itrequirespolicyandoperationalchangesacrossmanydepartmentsthatmustbecoordinatedandintegrateddistrictwide.Therefore,a dedicated project managerwiththeabilitytomarshalsupportandinspireactionacrossthedistrictiscrucial.
Innearlyallofthedistrictswherewe’veworked,eveniftheSBBprocessdidn’tstartwithaprojectmanager,itendedupwithone.SBBprojectmanagerscommonlyreportdirectlytothesuperintendentwithregular,directinteractiontoensurethesuperintendenthastheopportunitytohelpguidetheprocess.SBBprojectmanagementisatminimumahalf-timerole,andpossiblymore,dependingonyourdistrict’scontextandimplementationtimeline.
The ideal project manager:
•Isarelationship-builder,bothwithinthedistrictofficeandwithschoolleaders;
•Hastheabilitytomarshalresourcesfromvariousdepartmentsinthedistrictoffice;
• IsfamiliarwiththecurrentbudgetingandstaffingprocessesandthelikelyimplicationsofSBB;
•Hasexcellentskillsaroundorganizingandmanagingwork;doesnotletballsdrop;
•Hasstronganalyticskillsorpassionfordevelopinghisorheranalyticskillset;
•Istrustedbythesuperintendentandhisorherleadershipteam.
Becausethefinanceteamwillbearmostoftheresponsibilityforgatheringdataandmodelingscenarios,wealsorecommenddesignatinga finance team liaisontocoordinateandensurethese needsaremetinatimelyandaccuratefashion.
The ideal finance team liaison:
•Isdeeplyfamiliarwiththedistrict’sbudgetacrossallfundsanddepartments;
•Understandsthevisionandstrategybehindthedistrict’smovetoSBBandcanprovidecontextuallyappropriatedata;
•Hasverystronganalyticskillsandafamiliaritywithbuildingandusingdatabasemodels.
Finally,themosteffectiveSBBdevelopmentprocessesincludea cross-functional design and implementation task forcethatmeetsregularlythroughouttheproject.Thistaskforcemightincluderepresentativesfromacademics,finance,operations,andHR,aswellasprincipalsfromarangeofschoolsinthedistrict’sportfolio;specificassignmentswillvarybasedonthedistrict’sstructureandcapacity.Eachteammembershouldbepositionedasatrueleader,withtheauthorityandknowledgetorepresenthisorherdepartmenteffectivelythroughoutdesignandimplementationwork.Ideally,you’llsetupthisteamtomakeorreviewkeydecisionsthatwillshapeyourSBBsystem,aswellasshareprogressupdateswithpeersandothersacrossthedistrict.
11
When and How Should We Roll Out SBB? EvenbeforeyoubegindesigningyourSBBsystem,werecommendthatyouconsideryourgeneralapproachforrollingoutSBB.ThesimplestandmostdirectapproachistorolloutSBBtoallschoolswiththosefundingcategoriesthedistrictisabletounlock.2However,somedistrictspreferalternativesthatlimitthescopeofSBBinyearonetopilotthestrategyandunderstanditspotentialimpactinacontrolledenvironment.
ThemostcommonalternativefocusesSBBonasubsetofschools.Thisapproachoftenenablesthedistricttooffermoreintensivesupporttoprincipalswhowillhave,forthefirsttime,newflexibilityaroundhowtheyallocateresourceswithintheirschoolbuildings.AchallengetothisapproachisthattheschoolscommonlymostinterestedinspearheadingSBBarethosethatareunderfunded,whichmakesthisapproachinherentlymoreexpensiveforthedistrict.Focusingonasubsetofschoolsthereforerequirescarefulselection,aswellasaholdingbackoffundsinadvancetoprepareforanetincreaseinfundingtopilotschools.
AsecondalternativefocusesSBBonasubsetofresourcebucketsinyearone.Ontheplusside, thisenablesthedistrictandprincipalstodeploythoseresourceswherethereiscurrentlythemostflexibilityandpotentialforimpact.However,thisapproachreducestotalfundsavailableforSBB.
Thesimplestalternativephasedmethodistogiveapilotcohortflexibilityoveritsresourceswithoutintroducingweightedfundsuntilallschoolsjoininsubsequentyears.
Case Studies Variations on Rollout Strategy
Cleveland: Pilot for High-Performing SchoolsFor Cleveland, as a district operating under a portfolio mind-set, the most exciting aspect of Student-Based Budgeting was the opportunity to put schools in control of their dollars and designs. This was also the biggest challenge for a central office accustomed to control. Because school resource autonomy was such a radical change, Cleveland chose to ease in via a pilot year in which nine high-performing schools controlled their budgets. These schools did not receive dollars through a weighted formula, but rather the monetary equivalent of the same staff and programs they had traditionally received. The success of this pilot proved a valuable example for hesitant principals and administrators in the subsequent year.
Denver: Expanding the System Over TimeThe rollout strategy in Denver Public Schools was balanced: The simple fundamentals came “all at once,” while additional layers grew over time. Denver introduced SBB to all schools in 2007–08, but a transition adjustment ensured that no school saw less money than it had under the old budgeting sys-tem. Over each of the next three years, pieces of this adjustment were removed. Over each of the first six years, new weights were added and new resources unlocked. The gradual nature of this implementation allowed all schools to enter SBB at the same time and slowly grow accustomed to its newest features.
2Moreonthisinthenextsection,DesigningtheSystem.
12
Key Takeaways•SBBworksbestasonetoolamidabroaderkitofstrategiescoordinatedfordistrict
transformation.
•SBBworksbestwhenschoolleaders,centralofficeadministrators,anddatasystems areallequippedwithakeysetofcapacities.
•AcommonmistakeistoboxinSBBasa“financeteaminitiative.”Successful implementationrequiresadedicatedprojectmanagerwhocoordinatesacross-functional groupofstakeholders(includingschoolleaders)fromthroughoutthedistrict.
•WhilemanydistrictsrolloutSBBinonestep,otherschoosetophaseinSBBby limitingthenumberofschools,resourcesaffected,and/ortheswinginfundingequityexperiencedinthefirstyear(s)ofimplementation.
Questions for Reflection•WhatroledoesSBBplayinmybroaderstrategyforimprovingstudentoutcomes?
•HowdoIexpectresourcestoshiftasaresultofSBB?Whichschoolsmaygainresources, andwhichmayloseresources?
•WhenIimaginewhatmydistrictwilllooklikeafterSBBisimplemented,whatotherchangesareimplicitlyincludedinthatvision?Whatdoesthatimplyforthemagnitudeofthiseffort?
•WhatconditionsbestpositionusforsuccesswithSBB?Whatconditionswillbe mostchallenging?
“This is the first time in my 30 years in the district that we can really get what we need.”
—Teacher in an SBB “Transformation Schools Pilot” Cleveland Metropolitan School District
13
Designing the System
BuildinganeffectiveStudent-BasedBudgetingsystemtypicallyincludessixsteps—definetheeligiblepoolofresources;unlockresources:projectthesizeoftheSBBpool;buildthefundingformula; makepolicydecisions;andchooseweightvaluesandtestscenarios.Belowwerevieweachofthesestepsindetail.
Define the Eligible Pool of ResourcesFundsthatareeligibleforinclusioninyourSBBmodelhavetwocommoncharacteristics.First,theyareschool-based,thatis,usedforservicesdeliveredintheschoolbuilding.Thesearenotjustresourcesthatappearonschoolbudgets—insomedistricts,aslittleasonepercentofallfundsisincludedinschoolbudgets.Rather,resourcesthatareschool-basedareusedtopayforallservicesthatactuallyaredeliveredinschools,regardlessofwheretheyappearondepartmentbudgets.
Forexample,insomedistricts,custodialservicesmaybebudgetedcentrallyintheCustodialServicesDepartment,eventhoughmostcustodiansworkatschools.Theportionofcustodiansactuallyworkingatschoolsshouldbeconsideredintheuniverseofschool-basedresources—andthereforeeligibletobeconsideredforSBB.OtherexamplesofresourcescommonlybudgetedcentrallybututilizedatschoolsincludespecialeducationorELLitinerantservices,maintenancestaff,instructionalmaterials,andtextbooks.
Second,SBB-eligiblefundsaregeneral, unrestricted funds.BecausecategoricalfundslikeTitleIorIDEAtypicallyhavetheirownrulesondistributionandeligibility,theymaynotbeeligibleforyourSBBmodel,evenifthosefundsaredistributedtoschoolsonadollar-per-pupilbasisand/orweightedbystudentneed.
Unlock ResourcesNotallSBB-eligibleresourceswillbeincludedintheactualSBBformula.Wecalltheprocessofdefiningwhichresourcesareincluded“unlockingresources.”
UnlockingaresourcesimplymeansthatfundscurrentlyallottedforthatresourceareputintothepooloffundstobedistributedthroughtheSBBformula.Conversely,lockedresourcesarenot includedinthepooloffundsavailableforSBB;instead,theseresourcescontinuetobeallocated withspecificdirectionsfromthedistrict.
Thedecisiontolockorunlockhappensthroughasetoffilteringquestions.Aresourcethatpassesthroughmostofthesefilters(explainedbelow)isastrongcandidateforbeingunlocked.
Thefirstfilteristheextenttowhichschool-basedcontrolofaresourcefitsyourdistrict’svision for the principal’s role.Forexample,ifyourvisionincludesgivingprincipalsgreaterautonomyasinstructionalleaders,thenyou’lllikelywanttounlockinstructionalstaffandresources.Ifyourvisionisthat
14
principalsserveasbuildingleaders,operationalresourcesareprimecandidatesforunlocking.Ifyourvisionfortheprincipal’sroleincludesboth,thenbothinstructionalandoperationalresourceswill beconsideredforunlocking.
Second,doesdevolvingcontrolofagivenresourcetotheschoollevelpotentiallyputstudent health and safetyatrisk?Forexample,adistrictmightjudgethateveryschoolneedsasecurityofficerandanurse,withnoexceptions.Thedistrictcouldchoosetokeeptheseresourceslockedandavoidpotentialrisksinremovingtheseresources,evenifcertainschoolsostensiblyhavegoodreasonstodoso.
Third,doesthedistricthaveexternal accountabilityfortheresourcethatmakesitdifficulttogiveschoolscontroland/orcreateslegalrisksindoingso?Specialeducationresourcestypicallydeservescrutinyonthispoint,asstateandfederalrequirementsaccompanytheiruse.Onlyifadistrictbelievesthatprincipalscanstaffthespecialeducationteachersandprovidetheservicesnecessary toservetheirstudents’IEPscanthoseteacherssafelybeunlocked.
Fourth,istheresourcemorecritical to district-level strategythanitisforindividualschools?Ifso, theresourceshouldprobablybelocked.Somedistrictschoosetoensureaccesstopreferredcurricularmaterialsoracademicinterventionsatallschoolsinordertoguaranteesimilarlearningexperiencesacrossthedistrict.
Fifth,doestheresourcerequire specialized skillstowhichaprincipalisunlikelytohaveaccess? Somedistrictswouldprefernottoburdenprincipalswithmanagingspecializedmaintenanceandcustodialoperations,andthereforekeepthesestaffpositionslocked.
Sixth,arethereeconomies of scaleinspendingresourcesatadistrictlevel?Districtstypically usemasspurchasingpowertogetbetterpriceswithtextbookvendors;thiscouldbeareasontolocktheresource,ortounlockitbutofferamenuofpreferredvendorsaccompaniedbybetter pricesfromwhichschoolscouldchoose.
Last,istheneedfortheresourcepredictableenoughforprincipalstoplanforitsuse?For example,large,occasionalinvestmentssuchasmajorfacilitiesrepairsaretypicallybestleft underdistrictmanagement.
“ My school’s schedule is now centered on what students need instead of adults.”
—Principal in an SBB “Transformation Schools Pilot” Cleveland Metropolitan School District
15
Unlocking Filters
Fits vision for the principal’s role
No risk to student health and safety
No external compliance needed
Not critical to district strategy
Specialized experi-ence not required
No economies of scale
Predictable costs
NO
Lock, keep in district control
NOLock, keep in
district controlNO
Unlock for SBB model
YES YESEligible Resources
General unrestricted funds spent in schools
NO: Resources often locked for this reason
YES: Resources often unlocked
• Schoolutilities
•Nurses
• Specialeducationstaff
• Districtachievement gap initiative
• Securityofficers
• Summerschool,if shared among multiple school sites
• Substitutesforlong-termabsences
• Generaleducation teachers
•Textbooks
• Englishlanguage- learner staff
• Instructionalsupplies and materials
• Secretariesandschool office staff
• Guidancecounselors
• Dailysubstituteteachers
To Lock or Unlock Eligible Resources?
Unlocking Filters
Fits vision for the principal’s role
No risk to student health and safety
No external compliance needed
Not critical to district strategy
Specialized experi-ence not required
No economies of scale
Predictable costs
NO
NO: Lock, keep in district controlLock, keep in
district control
YES: Unlock for SBB model
YES
IF...
Eligible ResourcesGeneral unrestricted
funds spent in schools
16
Whenconsideringwhetheraprogramorserviceshouldbeunlocked,it’salsoimportanttoconsidertheimplicationsforotherresources.Forexample,let’ssayyourdistrictemploysareadingprogramwidelyconsideredtobeacornerstoneofhigh-impactreadingeducationinthedistrict.Youmaydecidetolockthatprogramtoensureitscontinueduseinthedistrict.Thereadingprogrammayrequireaspecifictextbook.Therefore,evenifyouunlocktextbookspendingingeneral,you’llwant tolocktheportiondedicatedtopurchasingtextbooksforthelockedhigh-valuereadingprogram.
Project the Size of the SBB PoolAswenotedabove,unlockedresourcesareputintothepooloffundstobedistributedaccordingtotheSBBformula.Onceyou’vedeterminedwhichservicesandprogramsyou’llunlock,you’reabletodeterminehowmuchfundingisavailablefordistributiontoschoolsaccordingtotheSBBformula.
Inourexperience,districtsendupunlockinganywherefrom50to70percentofeligibleresources(i.e.,general,unrestrictedfundsspentinschools)forStudent-BasedBudgeting.Thereisnomagicnumberortargetforhowmuchyoushouldunlock;however,onceyou’vedeterminedwhichresourcestounlock,it’sworthaquickchecktoseeifyourdecisionscreateascenariothatlinesupwithyourvisionforSBB.
Forexample,youmayhaveenteredtheSBBprocesswithabiastowardunlockingasmanyresourcesaspossibletomaximizetheflexibilityandautonomyofschoolprincipals.Ifyouthenfindthatyouhaveunlockedonly20percentofeligibleresources,youmaywanttorevisityourinitialassumptionsandensureyou’reontheSBBpaththatisrightforyourdistrict.
Percent of Eligible Resources Distributed Through SBB Formula
Dollars unlocked for SBB as a % of…
District All PreK-12 operating funds School-based funds
Denver 55% 65%
Baltimore 43% 64%
Cleveland 40% 51%
Prince George’s County 26% 28%
Note: All PreK-12 operating funds includes all general and categorical funds used for operations.
School-based funds include only those dollars spent on school-based services, whether budgeted at the school level or centrally. (i.e. excluding leadership and management, and shared services)
17
Build the Funding Formula
Components of the SBB Funding Formula
Outside the formula Inside the formula
Categorical funds are district-based and distributed to schools based on preestablished requirements. A common example is Title I funding.
Locked funds for services and programs that remain controlled at the district level, based on your previous lock/unlock decisions.
A foundation amount for each school, or for the smallest schools, representing the minimum funding required to “keep the lights on.” Some districts define this as the amount it takes to hire a principal and a secretary.3
A base weight per student, representing the lowest common denominator of per-student funding in the simplest possible scenario.
A student- based adjustment, allocated according to student need.
WithSBB,youcanthinkofeachschool’sallocationinfiveportions.Astherightsideofthetableindicates,yourSBBformulawillincludethreecomponents—afoundationamount,abaseweight,andastudent-basedadjustment.Asoneofthosecomponentsincreases,theothersnecessarilydecrease.Sothemoreyousetasideforafoundationamount,thelesswillbeavailableforallocationbasedonstudentneed.Nomatterhowmuchyou’veunlocked,thepoolofresourcesforSBBisfixed.Inotherwords,withSBB,“thepieisthepie.”
Thisconceptiscrucialasyoudeterminewhichstudent-basedfactorstoweight.Formostdistricts, theinitialurgeistoweighteverything.However,weightingtoomanyfactorscreatesaformulathatisoverlycomplicatedtomanageandexplaintoothers.Also,everytimeyouchoosetoaddanadditionalstudentcharacteristicweight,youreducethebaseweightforall.
Forexample,let’simagineadistrictwith30,000students,$200millioninunlockedfundsandaformulathatincludesabaseweightof$5,000perpupil,withadjustmentsforstudentsreceivingspecialeducationorELLservices.Let’salsoimaginethatthedistrict’sleadershipisconsideringaproposaltoprovideanadditional$1,000perpupilforthe12,000studentsingradesK-3—criticalgrades,whereanincreasedinvestmenthasthepotentialtopayoffinbothshort-andlong-termstudentgains.
Byincludinganotherstudentcharacteristicweight,thedistrictisaddingan“additionalsliceofthepie.”Since“thepieisthepie,”anincreaseinfundingforstudentsintargetedgradelevelsreducesthebaseweightsignificantly,from$5,000to$4,600perpupil.Thismaybeaworthwhiletrade-offforthedistrict;thekeyistoensurethatthesetrade-offsanddecisionsaremadetransparently,andwithconsiderationoftheconsequences,givenafinitepoolofresources.
3Somedistrictschoosenottoofferfoundationamountsasadeliberatedecisionnottoprovideapremiumforsmallschools.Foundationamountsaremostconsistentwithfundingequitywhensmallschoolshavetheopportunitytoaddstudentsand“outgrow”their foundationovertime.
18
No Grade Weight Grade Weight of $1,000/pp for K-3
Here’sanotherwaytorepresentthisgraphically.Wheneveryouchoosetoofferastudentcharacteristicweight,you’reimplicitlydecidingthatthestudentswithoutthatcharacteristicwillreceiveless.
Inlimitingthenumberofweightsyouchoose,you’llalsowanttoensurethatyouchooseweightingcriteriathathaveseveralimportantcharacteristics.Eachweightshouldbe:
• Relevant:tiedtoarealstudentneedthattypicallyrequiresadditionalresourcestobeaddressedeffectively.Forinstance,manyformulasusesomemeasureofpovertystatusasaproxyforacademicneed.Whilethetwoarehighlycorrelated,especiallyintheprimarygrades,therelationshipweakensasstudentsreachhighschool.Therefore,apovertyweightforhighschoolstudentsmaybelessrelevantthanotherpotentialweights.
• Measurable:objectivelyandquantifiably.
• Independent:toavoidperverseincentivesorpunishingschoolsforachievingdesiredoutcomes,schoolsshouldnothavedirectcontroloragencyoverthemetric.Forexample,aweightforacademicperformanceatahighschoolshouldbebasedontheacademicperformanceofthestudentswhen they were in 8th grade,ratherthantheirperformanceattheschooltheycurrentlyattend.
• Significant:presentinatleastthreetofivepercentofthestudentpopulationwithoutapplyingtoallstudents.
• Diversified:existatmorethanoneschoolandwithsignificantvariationacrossschools.
SPED $40m
ELL $10m
Base Weight $150m = > $5,000/pp
No Grade Weight K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Everyone gets the same $5,000 pp
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
These grades now get $4,600 pp
K 1 2 3
These grades now get $5,600
SPED $40m
ELL $10m
Grade $12mBase Weight $138m = > $4,600/pp
Grade Weight of $1,000/pp for K-3
19
Finally,afteragroupofweightshasmetthesecriteriaindividually,ask:Isthecompletesetofweightsconcise?Fewerweightsmaybebetter,andredundantweightsshouldbeavoided.
Student Weights Used in National Array of SBB Districts
Baltimore Cincinnati Denver Hartford Houston New York City Oakland San
Francisco Cleveland
Foundation
Amount 3 3 3 3
Grade 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Academic
Performance:
High3 3 3 3 3
Academic
Performance:
Low3 3 3 3 3
Poverty 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
SPED 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
ELL 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Other 3 3 3 3
Make Policy DecisionsBythispoint,you’veidentifiedthestudentcharacteristicsyouwanttoincludeinyourSBBformula,whichhasallowedyoutodetermineabaseweightandtoprojectestimatedper-pupilfundinglevels.Beforebeginningtotestscenariosforyourfundingmodel,werecommendmakingthreeimportantpolicydecisions:
1. Enrollment projections and adjustments.BecauseSBBallocationsareinitiallydeliveredtoschoolsbeforetheschoolyearbegins,theyarenecessarilybasedonprojectedstudentenrollment.Actualenrollment,usuallydeterminedbyOctober,typicallydiffersfromtheseprojections.Thedistrictmustdecideifandhowitwilladjustthedollaramountthatschoolsreceiveduringtheschoolyearbasedonupdatedenrollmentfigures.
Almostalldistrictsmakeadjustments;thequestionis,howsignificantwillthoseadjustmentsbe?Thisisessentiallyatrade-offbetweenequityacrossschools(howequitablewillfundingbeonceadjustmentsaremade?)andstabilityforschools(howmuchchangeinfundingcanoccuraftertheschoolyearstarts?).
Districtstypicallypursueoneoftwooptions.Somedistrictsadjustbudgetsupwardonly,incaseswhereactualschoolenrollmentexceedsprojections.ThisapproachrequiresthedistricttoholdbackasmallportionoftheSBBpool(typically2-4percent)asareservetofunnelintoover-enrolledschoolsonceactualenrollmentfiguresareavailable.Schoolswhereactualenrollmentfallsshortofprojectionsdonotexperiencearesultingchangeinfunding.
20
Otherdistrictsadjustschoolbudgetsbothupanddown.Toprotectagainstunsustainable swingsinfunding,thesedistrictscommonlycap,orlimit,changesinfundingineitherdirection(e.g.,nomorethanathreepercentchange).Withthisapproach,there’snoneedtoholdbackmoney;however,schoolsthatareunder-enrolledareforcedtogivebacksomeoftheirinitialallocationofresourcesmidyear.
NearlyalldistrictsthatsuccessfullyimplementSBBinvestinimprovingthequalityofenroll-mentprojections.Thiscanbechallengingindistrictswithhighmobilityandschool-choicepolicies,whereenrollmentsaremorelikelytofluctuateaftertheschoolyearbegins.Still,even amodestimprovementintheaccuracyofspringprojectionshasthepotentialtotrumpthebest-designedfalladjustmentpolicy,sothisisaninvestmentworthmaking.
2. Actual or average salary.Whenaschoolelectstoaddanewteacher,howmuchshoulditsbudgetbecharged?Shouldtheschoolhavetopaytheteacher’sactualsalary(say,$70,000foramoreexperiencedteacher)orthedistrictaverageforateacher(say,$55,000)?
Thisdecision,knownas“actualvs.averagesalary,”hassignificantimpactonthewayschoolsgoaboutbuildingbudgets.Averagesalaryissimplerforprincipals,whoarelikelyaccustomedtoallteacherscountingequallytowardthebottomline.However,averagesalarymasksinequitiesinstaffcompensationacrossschools;aschoolwithahighlytenured(andmoreexpensive)teachingforcewouldbetreatedjustlikeaschoolwithalesstenured(andlessexpensive)teachingforceunderthismodel.
Incontrast,usingtheactualsalaryholdsprincipalsaccountableforthesalarydistributionoftheirstaff.Italsoencouragesthemtocreatestrategicstaffingarrangementsthat,forexample,balancemoreexpensivemasterteacherswithdeveloping,noviceteachers.Budgetingbasedonactualsalarymakesthemostsensewhencompensationistightlylinkedtoperformanceandcontribution.Inamoretraditionalcompensationsystemthatscalespaywithseniority,budgetingbyactualsalarymay“penalize”schoolswithmoreexperiencedstaff.
3. Year-to-year rollover.Doschoolbudgetsrolloversurplusesanddeficitsfromoneyeartothenext?SBBprovidestheopportunitytomakeschoolplanningamultiyearactivityandschoolbudgetsamultiyearinstrument.
InDenver,schoolleadersmaycarryasurplusacrossmultipleyearstosaveforalargeexpense,suchasacomputerlab.Itislesscommonfordistrictstopermityear-enddeficits,butDenverschoolsmayruntemporarydeficitsbytakingoutaloanfromthebudgetofficeinanticipation ofreceivinganupwardbudgetadjustmentforthefallstudentcount.
Themostcommonsourceofapotentialbudgetsurplusisthefundingallocatedforschoolpositionsthatendupremainingvacant.Districtsmustsetaclearpolicyonwhetherschoolscanreallocatesalarydollarsafteritbecomesclearthatapositionwillnotbefilled,orwhethersalaries“lock”onacertaindateandthedistrictrecoversthosefundsassavings.
21
Choose Weight Values and Test ScenariosWiththosekeypolicydecisionsresolved,you’rereadytomoveintothequantitativelyrigorousphaseofscenario-testingtobuildyourSBBformula.Thistypicallyrequiresrobustmodelingtoolsandappropriateexpertisetotesteachelementoftheformula.Youcanthinkofthisphaseinsixparts:
1. Define baseline services.Districtstypicallyidentifyasetofbaselineservicesthataretheminimumrequiredtorunanyschool,regardlessofstudentpopulation.Ultimately,thecostofthesebaselineservicesshouldbecoveredbythecombinationofafoundationamountforeachschool,abaseweightperstudentregardlessofneed,andanygrade-levelweightsbuiltintotheSBBformula.Notethatonlyresourcesinthe“unlocked”SBBpoolshouldbeaccountedforinidentifyingbaselineservices.
2. Decide whether to set a foundation amount for some or all schools.Smallschoolsfacemanyofthesamefixedcostsaslargeschools—possiblyaslittleasaprincipalandsecretary,butpotentiallyalsoincludinganassistantprincipal,custodian,etc.Whenfundedonaper-pupilbasis,smallschoolsfacethedangerofnotbeingabletoaffordenoughteachersandstafftokeepthedoorsopen.Forthisreason,districtsoftendecidetogivesmallschoolsa“foundationamount”toremainviable,regardlessofhowmanystudentsenroll.Thekeydecisionshereare:(a)howmuchthefoundationamountwillbe,and(b)thesizethresholdbelowwhichschoolswouldreceivethatamount.Keepinmindthatanyfoundationamountwillnecessarilyreduceequityacrossschools,becauseatasmallschoolthesamefoundationamountwillbesplitamongfewerstudents.SomedistrictschoosetoofferafoundationamountonlytemporarilywiththeexpectationthatsmallschoolsshouldgainenrollmenttoprovetheirfinancialviabilityinthefirstfewyearsofSBB.
3. Choose values for grade weights and need weights.Earlier,youidentifiedanidealsetofstudentcharacteristicstoweight.Nowit’stimetocalculateanidealvalueforeach.Forgrade-based(e.g.,highschool)andneed-based(e.g.,specialeducationinclusion)weights, thistypicallyinvolvesthedistrictresearchinghowmuchitcurrentlyspendstoserveeachstudentwithagivenattribute,andhowmuchitwouldideallyliketospend.Tosetthelatterbenchmark,academicdepartmentsmightdesigntheiridealprogrammaticmodelforservingstudentswiththisneed.Thesetwoyardsticks—currentspendingandidealspending—arethebenchmarksaroundwhichSBBweightsaredetermined.Ofcourse,eventheidealspendingprojectionisnotmeanttodefinehowschoolsmustusetheirresources;rather,itisasample ofwhatittakestoserveparticularstudentswell.
4. Back into the base weight.Calculatingthebaseweightthatallstudentsreceivetakesverylittlework:it’sjusttheper-pupilamountremainingaftertherestoftheSBBpoolhasbeenspentonfoundationamounts,gradeweights,andneedweights.Becauseapoolofresources isfixed,adesigntaskforceusuallydiscoversitsproposedbaseweightaftersettingproposalsfortheotherelements.
22
5. Test SBB scenarios.Thisisahighlyiterativeprocessthatwillleadtoadjustmentstothe base,grade-based,andneed-basedweightsestablishedabove.Mostdistrictschoosetouseafinancialmodeltoanalyzemultiplescenarios.Whenusingamodel,districtspayparticularattentiontotwoissues:underfundedschoolsandequitygains/losses.
Underfundedschoolsarethoseforwhichthecombinationofafoundationamount,grade-levelweights,andbaseweightswouldbeinsufficienttopayfortheirbaselineservices.AviableSBBformulashouldnotleaveanyschoolsunderfundedunlessthedistrictisintentionallysettingaviabilitythresholdtoforcesmallschoolstogainenrollment,consolidate,orclose.
Equitygainsandlossesarethechangestofundingthatschoolswouldexperiencebetweenthedistrict’straditionalfundingsystemandSBB.RadicalshiftsinfundingassociatedwiththetransitiontoSBBmightleadadistricttoestablishmechanismsforsmoothingthetransition.
6. Set “hold harmless” and other soft landings.DuringthetransitiontoSBB,mostschools’staffandresourceallocationswillchangefromprioryears.Thegeneralpatternofequityissuchthatpreviously“underfunded”schoolswillreceivemoreresources,andpreviously“overfunded”schoolswillreceivefewer.Tosoftentheimpactonschoolsthatwerepreviouslyoverfunded,manydistrictsdevisea“holdharmless”or“softlanding”policythatlimitstheamountanyschoolcanloseorgainbetweenthepre-transitionyearandthefirstyearofSBB.
Forexample,aschoolsettolose10percentofitsbudgetmightexperiencethatlossas5percentperyear,phasedovertwoseparateschoolyears.Variationsonthisstrategyincludesettingequallimitsonlossesandgains;settingatighterlimitonlossesthanongains,whichrequiresholdingsomemoneyinreserve;orsettingatighterlimitongainsthanonlosses,whichresultsinsavingsthatthedistrictcouldfunnelbackintothebaseweight.
“ Now I don’t have to call central office to beg for money; I can just make decisions.”
—Principal in an SBB “Transformation Schools Pilot” Cleveland Metropolitan School District
23
Key Takeaways•TodefinewhichresourceswillcometoschoolsthroughtheSBBformula,thedistrictmust
gothroughaprocessof“unlocking”todecidewhichresourcesareappropriateandpracticalforschoolcontrol.
•Thereisnomagicnumberfordetermininghowmuchtounlock;however,manydistrictsunlockbetween50and70percentofschool-basedresources.
•“Thepieisthepie,”i.e.,themoredifferentfactorsyouusetoslice“thepie,”thelessmoneyremainsforotherstudents.Therefore,chooseaselectfewweightsthataresimple,measurable,anddirectlysupportinvestmentinkeydistrictpriorities.
•Projectingenrollmentisfundamentaltoallocatingmoneytoyourschools.ImplementingSBBoftenleadsdistrictstoinvestinimprovingenrollmentprojections,whilealsobuildingamechanismtomovemoneywhenenrollmentchangesareidentifiedinthefall.
•Budgetingon“actualsalary”candramaticallyenhanceequity,whileintroducingawholehostofnewincentivestoschoolleaders.Thinkcarefullyaboutwhethertheseincentivesmakesensegivenyourcompensationlandscape.
•CreatinganSBBformulaisnot“formulaic.”Finalizingtheformularequiresiterationandcarefuldeliberation.
Questions for Reflection•Inyourvisionoftheprincipal’srole,whatresourcesdoesheorshemanage?Whatresources
wouldyoubelikelytounlock?
•Whattypesofstudentsdoesyourstrategysuggestyoushouldbeinvestingin?Dothesestudentcharacteristicstranslateneatlyintopotentialweights,giventhecriteriafor weightselection?
•Howwelldoyoucurrentlyprojectenrollment?Towhatextentdoesstudentmobility affecttheaccuracyoftheseprojections?Howmightyouimproveprojections?
•Whatwouldbetheimpactofusingactualsalaryinyourschoolbudgets?Which schoolswould“gain?”
•Movingtowardequitycanentailadramaticshiftforsomeschools.Howlargeaswing (upordown)areyoucomfortablewithschoolsexperiencinginyearone?Whatdoesthis implyforapossible“holdharmless”policy?
24
Implementing SBB
Intheprevioussection,wedescribedtheprocessofdefiningthemechanicsofresourceallocation.Thatisabig,butnottheonly,partofsuccessfullyimplementingyourSBBsystem.Inaddition,districtsmust:
•Adjustcoreannualplanningprocesses,includingbudgeting,staffing,andschool improvementplanning;
•Re-thinktheroleofprincipalsandkeydistrictofficestaff,aswellashowtheseteamsinteract;
•Trainandsupportprincipalsanddistrictofficestaffinthecontextofnewprocessesandexpectations;and
•Engageabroadgroupofstakeholderstodevelopandmaintaininvestmentinyourstrategy.
Adjust Core ProcessesBudgeting,staffing,andschool-improvementplanningarethreeofthemostcrucialprocessesthatprepareadistrictfortheupcomingschoolyear.SBBimpactseachone.
Inatraditionalfundingmodel,theseprocesseshappenintandembutdon’talwayslink.SBBrequiresthatthedistrictcoordinateeachstep,sothatschoolplansflowintohiringandfiringdecisionsforstaffingschools,thenintoanaggregatebudgetproposal.Whilepreexistingtimelinesvarybydistrict,thissequenceoftenmeansthatbudgetandstaffingcyclesneedtobepushedlaterthantheytraditionallyoccur,whiletheplanningprocessmusthappenearlier.
Inmanytraditionaldistricts,thebudgetteamfirstsetsadistrictbudget,thenthehumanresourcesteamstaffsschools,andonlythendoprincipalscreateacademicplans.InanSBBdistrict,schoolacademicplanscomefirst,creatingasetofrequeststoguideHRinstaffingschools,andthenfinallyrollingupintoanaggregatedistrictbudgetbasedontheresourcesschoolshavechosen.
The budgeting, staffing, and planning timeline in traditional and SBB districts
TRADITIONAL BUDGETING: 1. Budget 2. Staffing 3. Planning
STUDENT-BASED BUDGETING: 1. Planning 3. Budget2. Staffing
25
ManydistrictssubmittentativebudgetstotheirboardsinFebruaryoftheprecedingschoolyear,whichrequiresthatindividualschoolscreatetheirownbudgetsasearlyasDecember.Thispresentstwoproblemsforplanning:First,enrollmentprojectionsarelikelynotyetaccurateenoughtoestimateresourceneedsbyschool,andsecond,thecurrentschoolyearhasnotprogressedfarenoughforprincipalstoincorporatelessonslearnedfromtheircurrentresourceuse.Thisdynamicarguesforstrategicplanningtooccuraslateasmid-spring.
Butthecandleburnsatbothends.InanSBBsystem,theannualhiringtimelinemustrespondtothespecificpositionsandqualificationsthatschoolsarerequestingintheirstrategicplans.Iftheplanningprocessoccurstoolate,theHRdepartmentcan’tincorporateschools’plansintoahiringandfiringstrategythatcustomizestheworkforcetoschools’needs.
ThemostdistinctivefeatureofthetimelineinanSBBdistrictisthatschoolplanningcomesfirst:Itsetsthegoalstowhichbudgetingandstaffingrespond.Inadditiontoshiftingbackitsbudgetingandhiringtimelinestomeetthispriority,thetransitioningdistrictshouldmapoutallelementsoftheschoolplanningprocess—suchasplansforrestrictedgrantfunds,contractualwaiverapplications,etc.—andalignthemwiththeat-largebudget-planningprocess.
Rethink Principal and District Office RolesAtthecenterofaneffectiveSBBsystemisafundamentalshiftintherelationshipbetweenschoolsandthedistrict.Traditionally,thedistrictofficeexertssignificanttop-downcontrolovernotonlyhowmanyresourcesareallocatedtoschools,butwhichandwhatkindofresourcesaredelivered.Principalsmustworkwithwhatthey’regiven.
SBBshiftsthefocustoamodelthatbeginswitheachprincipal(andhisorherteam)settingavisionfortheschoolthatheorshebelieveswillgivestudentsthebestopportunitiestosucceed.Thisvisionthenshapestheprincipal’sdecisionsabouthowtousetheresourcesallocatedtotheschool,basedonstudentneed.Thedistrictoffice’sprimaryfunctionbecomesaservicefunction:Howcanwehelpeachprincipalrealizehisorhervisionfortheschool?Specifically,effectivedistrictofficeteamsask:Whatdoeseachschoolneed?Howcanweprovideit?Whatelsecanwedotostreamlinedecisionprocesseswithinthedistrictoffice?Putanotherway,thedistrictofficemustshiftfroma“yes/no”compliancemind-settoasolutions-orientedoneof“yes,if…”
Additionally,inatraditionalmodel,principalsmustoftennavigateaseriesofparallelbureaucraciesresponsibleforvariousdecisionsaboutwhatresourceseachschoolgetsandhowthoseresourcesare tobeused.Inreimaginingtheroleofthedistrictofficevis-à-visprincipals,manydistrictscreateadistrict-level“singlepointofcontact”foreachprincipalwhoisresponsibleforcoordinatingdistrictresponsestoprincipalneedsandrequests.Thisisapivotalrolethatcanhaveanoutsizedimpactonthedistrict’sabilitytomakeasmoothtransitiontoSBB.
Overall,theseshiftsimplysignificantchangesinmind-setandexpectationsforprincipalsandtheirteamsaswellasdistrictofficeteams,especially(butnotsolely)HRandfinance.DistrictsthatsucceedatthisculturechangearefarmorelikelytohavesuccesswithSBB;thosethatdon’tmayleavealotofvalueonthetable.
26
How Principals’ Roles Change
WithSBB,principalsarechargedwithmanagingabudgetthatismanytimeslargerthananytheymanagedbefore,withaviewintoabroaderrangeofservicesthantheytypicallythinkabout.What’smore,becauseSBBisusuallypairedwithincreasedschool-basedautonomyoveruseofresources,schoolleadersmaybeempoweredtomakearangeofnewstaffingandresourcingdecisions.Eventhemostsuccessfulprincipalsareunlikelytohavehadtheopportunitytodevelopskillsforthesecrucialstrategictasks.
The Principal’s Role in SBB
FROM… TO…
Complying with district requirements Articulating a clear vision for the school
Implementing a standard instruction and delivery model
Adjusting program, time, and staffing for student mastery
Executing system processes Becoming an effective human capital manager/strategist
Managing and protecting physical assets Managing complex systems
Running a tight ship Setting ambitious goals and holding teams accountable
Representing the district to local community Developing and managing partnerships to extend time and instruction based on student need
PrincipalsinanSBBdistrictmayalsofindthemselveswithgreateraccountabilityforhowresourcesareused,aswellasforstudentresults.Inatraditionalfundingmodel,weoftenfindacorrelationbetweenper-pupilfundingandstudentperformance—higher-performingschoolsreceivemorefunding.(Notethatthisdoesnotmeanmorefundinggeneratesgreatergains,onlythatacorrelationexists.)WithSBB,strategicresourceuseandstudentgainsbecomepartoftheprincipal’sjob- performanceevaluationand/orbroaderschool-performanceframework.
Case Study Creative School Design in Denver
Denver, through its SBB system and tiered accountability structure, has been at the forefront of pushing for innovative school designs. In addition to giving schools the ability to decide how much to spend on various resources, the district’s SBB system also pushes conventional boundaries to allow schools to decide on whom and what to spend their budgets: for example, allowing schools to contract out to nursing clinics instead of hiring a full-time nurse or piloting the option for schools to purchase social workers by the hour. The district says that SBB has put the entire district in a place where leaders can have truly meaningful conversations around the importance of the strategic use and management of resources.
27
How District Office Roles Change
Academic Superintendents and Other Principal Support.Inatraditionalsystem,thepeoplewhosupportandmanageprincipalscommonlyfocusonhelpingprincipalscomplywithstate,district, andprogrampolicies,andnavigatebureaucraticchallengeswiththedistrictoffice.SBBgeneratesagreaterneedforcoachingandsupportaroundbudgetmanagement,resourceallocation,andotherbuilding-leveldecisions.Complianceisnecessary,butnotsufficienttotakefulladvantageofSBB.
AfoundationalquestionhereishowtheacademicsdepartmentwantstoofferguidanceandsupporttoschoolsaroundnewinstructionaldecisionstheymaybefreedtomakewithSBB.Forexample,consideradistrictthathasunlockedtextbookspending.Inasystemwithlittletonoschool-levelautonomy,theacademicsdepartmentdecideswhatandhowmanytextbookseachschoolgets.InasystemwhereSBBispairedwithincreasedschoolautonomy,thegroupmightinsteaddevelopan“approvedlist”oftextbooksfromwhichaschoolleadercouldchoose;offerschoolswiderfreedomtochoose,whilerequiringperiodicreportingontitles,age,andnumberoftextbooks;orsimplyadviseprincipalsandofferrecommendationsonwhichtextbookstopurchase,withnospecificrequirements.
Thedistrictmustalsodecidehowitwantstohandlesituationswhenaschoolleaderandhisorhermanagerdisagreeonthebestuseofresources.Sayaprincipalwantstocutacoachingpositionsoheorshecanfundtwoparaprofessionalstoputintotheclassroomforreadingintervention,buttheschoolchiefoverseeingtheprincipaldisagrees.It’sworthestablishinggroundrulesanddecisionrightsearlyontoavoidprotractedandultimatelyunproductivebattlesdowntheroad.
Basedonyourvisionforhowtheroleoftheacademicteamintersectswiththeprincipal’srole,youmaywanttorevisitthesupportstructurethatexistsforprincipals.Onedistrictcreatedfull-time,cross-functionalschool-supportteams,organizedbygeographyandmadeupoffourtofivedistrictofficestaffsolelydedicatedtoon-callsupportoftheirzone’sprincipals.OtherdistrictscreatedtemporarySBBsupportteamsdedicatedtoasmallgroupofprincipalsduringbudgetseason;atothertimes,principalswouldcalladesignatedSBBliaisonineachdepartmentforsupport.Ultimately,theprincipal-supportsystemyoucreatedependsonyourdistrict’sneeds,capabilities,andvision.
Human Resources. Becausethemajorityofschool-basedresourcesaretypicallydevotedtopayingtheadultswhosejobitistoeducateandcreateapositivelearningenvironmentforchildren,anyshiftinhowresourcesareallocatedandspentwillnecessarilyhaveabigimpactonyourHRteam.
Inatraditionalmodel,theHRgroupistypicallyshapinghowFull-TimeEquivalentsareassigned—towhichschools,inwhichgradesandsubjects,andinwhatnonacademicfunctions.However,inanSBBmodelthatincludesschool-baseddecision-makingaboutresourceuse,HR’sroleshiftstofacilitatingthehumanresourcestrategydevelopedbyeachschoolleader.Tactically,thisimpliesseveralbigshiftsfortheHRteam:
•Asoutlinedabove,HRislikelytoreceiveinformationaboutstaffingrequirementslater intheyearthanhastypicallybeenthecase,necessitatingareconsiderationofhowstaffing needsarefulfilled.
28
•Theteamalsomaybeaskedtostaffrolesthatdidn’texistinthedistrictpreviously.Forexample,inoneSBBdistrict,halftheprincipalsoptedtobudgetforanew“businessmanager”positionthathadrarelybeenemployedinschools.
•HRmaybeaskedtoidentifycandidateswhomeetanewsetofhiringcriteriabased oneachschool’sevolvinginstructionalmodel.
•Inadistrictwithmanysmallschools,whichtypicallyreceivelessfundinginanSBBsystem,HRwillbetaskedwithidentifyingmorepart-timeanddual-certifiedteachers.Thishelpsschoolsandtheoveralldistrictmaintainmaximumflexibilityaroundstaffingtoensurethemostefficientuseofavailableresources.
Inlightoftheseandotherpotentialchanges,thedistrict’sHumanResourcesteamshouldbeinvolvedwithallaspectsoftheSBBplanningprocessfromtheearliestdays,withaparticularmandatetoidentifyhowSBBwillaffectexistingsystemsandhowtheHRgroupplanstoevolvetomeettheneedsofthenewstrategy.InthefirstyearwithSBB,HRmayalsowanttosetguidelinesaroundstaffingchangestoensurethatthegroupcaneffectivelyadapttochangingrequestsfromschoolleaders.ThiscouldgivetheteammoretimetounderstandschoolstaffingbehaviorunderSBBandreviseprocessesandpoliciesaccordingly.
Case Study School-Support Teams in Baltimore
In Baltimore, school-support teams operate full time for the entire school year. These teams are organized by zone and made up of four to five district office staff across a variety of disciplines that include academics, finance, operations, and special education. A “team lead” is responsible for supervising, coordinating, and managing the work of the team. This structure was introduced after the first year of “Fair Student Funding,” when central office staff realized that principals needed more support to be successful. Team members are solely dedicated to the on-call support of their zone’s principals—they have no responsibility to direct or evaluate the principals, though they naturally act as a conduit of information to and from central office about what’s working.
Finance. Ofcourse,muchoftheworkwehavediscussedthusfarinvolvesthefinanceteamleadingtheway.WithSBB,thefinanceteamshiftsfromfocusingonhow mucheachschoolgetstohow welleachschoolisusingavailableresources.Thisspeakstothebroaderissueofmind-setandculturechangewithinthedistrictoffice.Thefinanceteammustaligntheschool-budgetingprocesswiththeschool-improvementandannualplanningprocesses,asdescribedabove.Manybudgetingsoftwareprogramsenableschoolstomaketheselinks.
Finally,thefinanceteamisresponsibleformaintainingandadaptingtheSBBmodeltoensureitcontinuestoenablethelevelsofequity,transparency,andflexibilityitwasdesignedtoenable.Thisinvolvesdevelopingandmanagingasetofresource-allocationandbudget-developmenttoolsthatofferawindowintotheSBBprocessfordistrictleadership,districtofficestaff,andschoolleaders, andadjustingtheSBBmodelovertime.
29
Design Training and SupportRollingoutSBBrequiresaninvestmentintrainingandsupportforprincipalsanddistrict-levelstaffwhowillbeaskedtoadjusthowtheyplanandmanageresources.Thisinvestmentcommonlytakesthreeforms—anintroductorytraining,astaffsupportstructure,andtoolsanddocumentation.
Introductory Training
BuildingcapacityaroundfinancialmanagementandstrategicresourceuseisthelinchpinofanysuccessfulSBBimplementation.Youcanhavetheperfectsystemdesignedandinplace,butifschoolsdon’tknowhowtousetheadditionalflexibilitygiventothem—andifdistrict-levelstaffcontinuetooperateasdecisionarbitersratherthandecisionenablers—muchofthevalueoflocalizeddecision-makinghasbeenlost.InordertodrivehomethemessagethatSBBshouldrepresentasignificantshiftinthemodeofdoingbusinessandnotjustanewbudgetingformula,wesuggestthatacademicsstaff,notonlyfinancestaff,shouldleadtrainingsonSBB.
DistrictsthathavehadsuccessfulSBBimplementationshaveallinvestedinhigh-qualityandrelevanttrainingsforprincipalsanddistrict-levelstafftosetexpectations,buildcapabilities,andintroducenewprocesses.Buildingthiscapacitytakestime.InthefirstyearofSBB,themajorityofschoolswillsubmitschoolbudgetsthataremoreorlessthesameastheywereinpreviousyears.Asschoolsbecomemorecomfortablewiththenewsystem,theywillbemorecreativeandadjustschooldesignstotakeadvantageoftheflexibilityandautonomySBBoffers.
Forthisreason,itoftenmakessensetostartbytrainingprincipalsandkeydistrictstaffaroundstrategicschooldesign,whichwedefineasthedeliberateorganizationofaschool’speople,time,technology,andmoneytooptimizestudentoutcomes.ThenSBBbecomesatooltohelpthemrealizetheirvision.Forinstance,whenERSleadstraining,wetypicallystructurethematerialthroughthreestages.First,weintroduceprincipalsanddistrictstafftotheprocessofusingdatatopinpointstudentneedandteachercapacityatschools.Second,wehelpthemnarrowinontheprioritiesforchange.Finally,weintroducethemtothetechnicaltoolsthroughwhichtheywillmanagetheirbudgets,andhelpthempracticereallocatingresourcesinanticipationoftheirfinalplans.ForschoolswhereteachercontractsandtheSBBmodelaffordprincipalswideautonomyoverhiringandfiring,thedistrictmaywanttoinvestinfurthersupportstohelpprincipalsmake—anddistrictstaffsupport—wisehiringandstaff-developmentdecisions.
Support Tools and Guidance Documents
Inordertoefficientlyandclearlyconveyschooldesignplanstothedistrictoffice,schoolleaderstypicallyneedabudgetinginterfacethroughwhichtheycantrackdollarsthathavebeenallocated,aswellasstaffingandresourcerequeststheyhavemade.Likeanydata-drivensystem,SBBreliesonaccurate,timelydatatoinformdecision-makingattheschoolanddistrictofficelevels.Thisincludesup-to-dateinformationonstudentperformance,pastfinancialdecisions,teachereffectiveness,classsizeandotherschooldesignfactors,andcurrentfinancials.Totheextentpossible,thesedatashouldflowintothebudgetinginterface.
30
Manydistrictshavefoundittremendouslyhelpfultocreatewrittenandonlinesupportmaterials—fromguidancedocumentsforschool-controlledresourcestoschooldesigntemplatestospurcreativeideasforprincipals,toclarificationofkeySBBfactsandmyths—andmakethemavailabletoprinci-palsinonecentrallocation.We’veseendistrictsofferaninternalSharePointsite,createawikipagethatcanberevisedandeditedbyprincipals,orevenprintSBBinformationbindersforeveryschool.Inmanycases,thesematerialshavebeencreated,buttheyneedtobeorganizedandcompiledintoausableandsearchableformat.
Build and Sustain InvestmentStudent-BasedBudgetingaffectseveryoneinyourdistrict,fromthemostsenioradministratorto thenewestteacher,andfromthestaffmemberdeeplyembeddedinthedistrictofficetothechildenteringkindergarten.TotrulygaintractionwithSBB,it’scrucialthatyoudevelopaclearandproactivestrategyforsharingwhatSBBisaboutandhowitwillaffectthelivesofpeoplewhoaredeeplyinvestedinyourschools.
Creating a Common Language
Especiallyintimesofdecliningbudgets—andinsomedistricts,layoffsandschoolclosures—anyreformthatadjustshowscarceresourcesaredistributedmaybeseenasathreatbysomestakeholders.Forthatreason,it’sworthcreatingacommonlanguagearoundwhichyoucanbuildyourSBBcommunicationsstrategy.Thismightinclude:
•Clarityaboutyourobjectives:
– “Wewantasystemwhereresourcesgowheretheyareneededmost,nottothe personwhoknowswheretolookforthem.”
– “Wewanttodistributeresourcesequitablyacrossschoolstocreatealevelplaying fieldforallstudents.”
– “Wewanttoensurethateveryonecanseeclearlyhowandwhereresourcesarebeingspent.”
– “Webelievethatprincipalsandtheirteamsshouldbeempoweredtomakedecisions abouthowtouseresourcesintheirschools.”
•OutliningthebasicconceptsassociatedwithSBB:
– “Moneyfollowsstudentsbasedonneed.”
– “WeidentifiedXstudentcharacteristicsthatdefinehowwedistributefundstoschools.”
•DescribingtheexpectedimpactofSBB:
– “Overthenextthreeyears,weexpectthatsomeofourmostunderfundedschools willseeincreasesinresources,whilesomeschoolsthathavebeenartificially advantagedintheoldsystemmaybeaskedtooperatewithabitless.”
– “Schoolswillbeabletomoreeffectivelyadjusttheirstrategytobestmeettheneedsoftheirstudents.”
31
Considering Your Stakeholders
ThebestpublicspokespeopleforSBBarefrequentlyschoolprincipals.Theyarewellknownand oftenbelovedintheircommunitiesandamongparents,andarerightfullyatthecenterofSBB.
Inconjunctionwithtrainingonschooldesignandbudgeting,somedistrictsofferprincipals communicationstrainingandsupporttohelpthemshareimportantinformationwiththeirstaff andcommunity.Withdistrict-wideinitiatives,principalsareoftentheunofficialspokespeople,so itiscriticaltopreparethemassoonaspossible.
Schoolleadershipdoesn’tjustcomefromtheprincipal’soffice.Itcanalsobehelpfulforprincipals todevelopanSBBteam—madeupofteachersandotherstaffattheirschool—toreachconsensusaroundschooldesignandbudgetdecisions.Inonedistrictwhereweworked,principalswere specificallyaskedtoincludetheirschool’sunionreponthedesignteamaswell.
Manyunionshavealong-helddistrustofSBB,groundedinaconcernthatwithlocalizeddecision-making,unioncontractsandrequirementswillnolongerbeupheld.It’simportanttonotethatSBBitselfdoesnotchangetheparametersaroundwhichschoolsaredesignedorhowbudgetsandstaffingdecisionsaremade.Opencommunicationandinclusionofunionrepsonschool-baseddesignteamscanhelpcleartheaironthisandotherpotentiallycontentioustopics.
Asdiscussedabove,SBBhasadirectandsignificantimpactonhowthedistrictofficeoperates.Therefore,effectivetransitionstoSBBtypicallyinvolvedclearinternalcommunicationanda change-managementstrategyfordistrictstaff.
Finally,it’sworthconsideringtheimpactofSBBonstudents,parents,andthebroadercommunityandtodevelopacommunicationsstrategy—potentiallyincludingdirectparentcommunications,discussionswithlocalpartners,andlocalmediaoutlets—thathelpsallpartiesdevelopacommonunderstandingoftherationalebehindthenewSBBsystem,howitwillwork,howitfitsintothebroaderdistrictcontext,andanticipatedoutcomes.
Case Study Engaging the Community in Boston
Boston Public Schools focused on two core messages as it rolled out a new budgeting system. First, after years of budget cuts, the district emphasized that “weighted student funding is about spending limited dollars much more wisely.” Second, anticipating the questions and concern from parents and staff in schools that were ‘losing’ money through the new formula, BPS reiterated that “Dollars Follow Students,” not buildings or programs. The district also used soft landings to cushion these losses, a strategy that succeeded in calming public concern because it was applied consistently and fairly across all schools. In the second year of implementation, families and schools still argued that they should receive more resources, but they did so within the language of weights and equity.4
4BostonPublicSchools,“WeightedStudentFunding,”NationalSchoolBoardsAssociation,April20,2012
32
Key Takeaways•MovingtoSBBcanupendadistrict’straditionaltimeline(oratleastitssequence)of
allocatingstaffandbuildingabudget.Schoolplanningmusttypicallyoccurmuchsoonerthanbefore.
•SBBisanopportunitytoexpandanddeepentheprincipal’srole.Ifitjustseemslike “morework”forprincipals,somethinghasgonewrong.
•SBBrequiresanew“service-provider”mindsetfrommanycentralfunctions.Centralemployeesneedtrainingandsupportsotheycanbecomestrategicadvisorstoschool leaders.Somedistrictschoosetorevamptheirstructureofschoolsupporttofittheneeds ofaprincipalunderSBB.
•Significanttrainingforschoolleadersisessential,notonlyonthetechnicaldetailsofhow tobudget,butalsoonthebroaderquestionofhowtoallocateresourcesforstudentsuccess.
•Whenresourcesarescarce,it’seasytoblamethenewsystem.It’sessentialfordistrict leaderstoclearlycommunicatetheobjectivesandguidingprinciplesofSBB,considering theperspectivesofallwhohaveaninterestinthesystem.
Questions for Reflection•Whendoschoolplanning,staffing,anddistrictbudgetingcurrentlyoccur?Wouldthat
sequenceworkinanSBBworld?
•WhatwillSBBaddtoyourprincipals’plates?Shouldanythingbetakenofftocompensate?
•Whatstructureofsupportwouldyourprincipalsneedtomakestrategicresourcedecisions inadditiontotheirotherresponsibilities?
•Towhatextentdoyourcentralfunctionscurrentlyoperatewithaserviceprovidermindset?WhatwouldbemostdifficultfortheminatransitiontoSBB?
•ImaginethefirstSBBtrainingforyourprincipals:whatarethetopthreethingsyouwouldwantthemtoemergebelieving,understanding,orknowinghowtodo?
•HowwouldyoucommunicatethepurposeofyourmovetoSBB?Ifaparentoremployeeaskedwhythenewsystemwastakingresourcesawayfromtheirschool,whatwouldyousay?
33
In Closing: Keys to Success
Throughoutthisdocumentwe’veidentifiedkeytakeawaystohelpyoumosteffectivelydevelopandpursueyourvisionforSBB.Inclosing,wewanttohighlightfivethemesthatcarryacrosstheentireprocessand,atamacrolevel,oftenmakethedifferencebetweensuccessandstruggleinimplementingStudent-BasedBudgeting.
•Have a clear vision—bothaboutthedistrict’sstrategyoverallandtheroleofStudent-BasedBudgetingwithinit.AnunclearvisionisthesurestwaytoengenderfundamentalconcernsaboutyourdirectionwithSBB,butaclearandcompellingvisionwillmotivateothersto “getonthebus”astheprocessunfolds.
•Understand the district’s capacity for change.Asmuchasanyotherpotentiallytrans- formativeinitiative,SBBrequiressignificantchangetomindsetsandbehaviorsatalllevels oftheorganization,fromtopdistrictleaderstothenewestprincipalsandteachers.Make aclear-eyedassessmentupfrontofwhereyourteamisandisnotreadytotakeonthe changesyouenvision,anddevelopastrategythatleveragestheirstrengthsinembracing anddrivingchangewhileacknowledgingandprovidingadditionalsupportwherechange isgoingtobehardest.
•Run a transparent process.Justasaneffectivefinancialsystemistransparentaswellasequitableandflexible,soshouldtheprocessthroughwhichyoudevelopandimplement SBBbetransparenttoallstakeholders.Atitsbest,SBBcreatesclarityinanotherwise murkyprocess,helpingeveryoneunderstandandembraceasystemwheredollarsfollowstudentneed.
•Engage key players in a true collaboration.Likemanynewsystems,ifSBBisdesigned inasilo,itsimpactislikelytoremaininasilo.Activelyengagedprincipals,teachersanddistrictstaffhavetheknowledgeandexperiencetomakeyourSBBsystemstrongerwhile alsoservingascrucialchampionsforthenewsystemacrossthedistrict.
•Adjust course.ItshouldbeclearbynowthatdevelopingandrunningSBBisnotaone-stepprocess.Ineachphase,therewillbeadjustments—fromwhichresourcestounlocktohow tosupportprincipalstohowtheformulamightneedtoshiftovertime.EmbracetheseadjustmentsinpursuitofthemosteffectiveStudent-BasedBudgetingsystemtosupport yourdistrict’sgoals.
Standards Rigorous, information-age standards and curricula to
support them.
Partners Partnering to create innovative and cost-effective ways to
serve students better.
School Support A central office that is a service and strategy partner instead of a
compliance watchdog.
Teaching A new way we hire,
assign, support, pay and promote teachers.
School Design A re-imagined school day with new schedules and
dynamic groupings.
Leadership Leadership roles with
clear goals, accountability and career paths, and the flexibility and support to
achieve results.
Funding Systems that allocate
resources equitably and flexibly across schools.
Get our email updates at www.ERStrategies.org/signup
Learn More at ERStrategies.org
Get our email updates at www.ERStrategies.org/signup
Resource CheckUnderstand how
well your district is using its resources.
DREAMCreate budget scenarios and
envision change.
Hold’emLearn how you can
invest in kids and still meet the bottom line.
Practical Tools for District Transformation
Assess your funding system for equity,
transparency, and flexibility
One Vision, 7 Strategies
Learn how the seven strategies support
the creation of high-performing schools.
School Funding Systems Guide
One Vision, 7 Strategies
Education Resource Strategies (ERS) is a non-profit organization
dedicated to transforming how urban school systems organize resources—
people, time, and money—so that every school succeeds for every student.
ERS provides innovative tools to help districts achieve their transformation
goals. The School System 20/20 assessment tools help district leaders understand
whether their district policies, structures, and practices create the conditions
for improving student performance at scale—and how well their resources are
aligned with the areas most critical to improving student outcomes. Based on
our experience working with districts, on our extensive district database, and on
published research, the tools use qualitative and quantitative metrics to evaluate
two key areas of district performance:
• System Conditions Evaluation — Assess how well system conditions and
structures support strategic practice and resource use, across the seven
School System 20/20 transformation areas.
• District Practice and Resource Use — Evaluate actual practice and resource
use, across all seven School System 20/20 transformation areas.
©2014EducationResourceStrategies.Allrightsreserved.
Education Resource Strategies|480PleasantStreet,SuiteC–200|Watertown,MA02472|Phone:617.607.8000
EducationResourceStrategies(ERS)isanon-profitorganizationdedicatedtotransforminghowurbanschoolsystemsorganizeresources—people,time,technology,andmoney—sothateveryschoolsucceedsforeverystudent.