trade finance as an investment vbk 2017 - kimura capital · economies, then trade finance is the...
TRANSCRIPT
TradeFinanceasanInvestment
bankingwise.com
WhitePaper
February2017
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 2
TABLEOFCONTENTS
INTRODUCTION......................................................................................................................................3
1. WHATIS“TRADEFINANCE”?..........................................................................................................4
Whatarethenuances?...................................................................................................................5
Who’sinvolved?.............................................................................................................................6
2. WHATISTHEINVESTMENTOPPORTUNITY?...................................................................................7
BridgingtheTradeFinancegap......................................................................................................8
Identifiableflowsgeneratingtransparentreturns.........................................................................9
CapturingtheTransactionChain..................................................................................................10
3. WHATARETHERISKS?..................................................................................................................11
ThedatareinforcesTradeFinance’slowdefaultprofile..............................................................11
Puttingnumbersinperspective....................................................................................................15
ValueaddedTradeFinanceexpertise...........................................................................................16
4. HOWCANINVESTORSPARTICIPATE?...........................................................................................17
CONCLUSION........................................................................................................................................19
APPENDIX……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………20
BANKINGWISELIMITED KIMURACAPITALLLPOXFORD LONDONUNITEDKINGDOM UNITEDKINGDOM
TEL.+44(0)7769507944 TEL.+44(0)2078872231E-MAIL:[email protected] [email protected]
©BankingwiseLimited/KimuraCapitalLLP,February2017.Allrightsreserved
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 3
INTRODUCTION
‘Trade Finance’ is essentially the provision of dedicated funding in support of the movement of physical goods being traded along a supply chain.
As an established discipline, Trade Finance has been around almost since trade itself, from providing working capital loans to merchants venturing to far flung lands in search of local produce to intermediating in the exchange of transactional documents and the resultant payments flow. If trade is the engine that keeps goods and services flowing to support economies, then Trade Finance is the fuel the engine needs to keep running.
And yet, for all its longevity, Trade Finance has been little understood beyond its core of practitioners: often absorbed within such umbrellas as Global Transaction Banking or general Corporate Banking, Trade Finance has been under the radar from an asset class perspective. But things are changing. In the face of diminished liquidity as a consequence of burdening regulation, banks have been opening the door to institutional investors and specialist funds to participate in trade deals that were previously shared amongst themselves. In tandem, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) has been gathering dedicated market data for its Trade Register, which provides previously unavailable but meaningful statistics for banks, regulators and other stakeholders to present a view of the risk profile of the Trade Finance industry globally, with particular focus on credit-related default and loss experience - all of which is reinforcing Trade Finance’s claim to be a low default proposition compared to the general corporate banking world it is lumped within.
The natural evolution of these developments is to view Trade Finance as an investment opportunity.
This paper therefore explores the rationale for accepting Trade Finance as an investable asset class, from an understanding of what Trade Finance actually is to a suggestion of what opportunities may exist.
It seeks to answer the questions:
- What is Trade Finance
- What is the Investment Opportunity
- What are the Risks
- How can Investors participate
This paper is the first in a series to explain Trade Finance as an asset class for investment. Further features will delve more deeply into the type of transactions being financed, into commodity trade finance in particular, and into how risks are being managed. These will be supplemented by topical articles and FAQs from time to time.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 4
1. WHAT IS “TRADE FINANCE”?
“WhoareYOU?”saidtheCaterpillar.Thiswasnotanencouragingopeningforaconversation.Alicereplied,rathershyly,“I--Ihardlyknow,sir,justatpresent—atleastIknowwhoIWASwhenIgotupthismorning,butIthinkImusthavebeenchangedseveraltimessincethen”.–LewisCarroll’s‘AliceinWonderland’
TRADEFINANCEappearstobeundergoingsomethingofatransformation.AsitprogressesthroughitsownWonderland,ittoohasbeenchangedseveraltimestothepointwhere‘TradeFinance’todaymeansdifferentthingstodifferentpractitioners.Tosomeit’sassimpleasissuingacashcoveredLetterofCredit,whilsttoothersitinvolvesprovidingfinanceinanyofseveralwaysasabridgebetweenanexporter’soutlayandreceiptofhissalesproceeds.Sojustwhatis‘TradeFinance’?
Simplyput,TradeFinanceistheprovisionofdedicatedfundingtosupportthemovementofphysicalgoods(merchandise)tradedalongasupplychain.
Thesupplychainistypicallyinternational(cross-border)butaslendersengagefurtheralongachain,elementsofdomestictrademayfeature.WTOstatisticsputtheglobaltradeinmerchandiseatUS$16trillion(seechartbelow)ofwhich90%iswidelyacceptedtobesubjecttosomeformoffinance,equatingtotheUS$14trillionestimatedbytheICCtobethevolumeofinternationaltradefinanceprovidedglobally.
Source: World Trade Statistical Review 2016
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 5
TradeFinancethoughcomesindifferentguisesandit’sarguablytheHOWofdeliveringTradeFinancewhichmakesthedifferencebetweenitbeinganinvestableassetclassornot:sometradefinance‘products’or–intheirownright–‘propositions’havecharacteristicsthatlendthemselvesmoreappropriatelytobeinganinvestableassetclassthanothers(assetbacked,transparent,self-liquidating,time-boundflexibility,identifiablecashflowandreturns).
For‘TradeFinance’isafamilyofrelatedofferingsthatindividuallyorcollectivelydeliveronthestatedobjective…butwhereeachbringsitsownuniquecharacteristicstoprovideasolutionwhichwillhaveinfluenceonintendedoutcomesandrisk.
Forinvestors,it’simportanttounderstandwhichsideofthefamilyyou’reinvestingin.
What are the nuances?
VanillaTradeFinance(VTF)istherootwhichoffersthemorebasictradeproductsofLettersofCredit,Guarantees/StandbyLCs,BidandPerformancebonds,Acceptance&DiscountingofBillsofExchange,andImportorExportLoans.Typically,intheeventofadefaultalenderlookstothebalancesheetofitscustomer(asobligor)andhasnoimmediaterecoursetotheunderlyinggoods,beingtypicallygeneralmerchandise.ExpectedLossthoughinvanillaTradeFinanceaveragesonly0.02%acrossallproducts(source:ICCTradeRegisterReport)duelargelytothecontingencyofthetradeinstrumentsi,whichareonlypayableifcertainstatedconditionshavebeenmet.WithinVTF,onlyImport/ExportLoans,BillsDiscountingorConfirmationsofExportLCsreallylendthemselvesasaviableinvestment,particularlywhenpooled.Atanobligorlevel,thedefaultratefortheloansis0.80%whilstit’sonly0.05%fortheExportLCs,astheyrepresentriskonaFinancialInstitution.
CommodityTradeFinance(CTF)hasbeendefinedtodifferentiatethetransactionalcommoditytradelendingtoSMEsiiandgeneralcorporatesfrombalancesheetlendingtoinvestmentgradecommodityfirms:commoditiesincontextbeingrawmaterialinputsforfood,energyormanufacturing.CommoditytradersaremajorusersofVTFinstruments,whichareblendedwithoverdraftortermloanstoprovidebespoke,oftenself-liquidating,transactionallending.CTFtendstobetransparent,isfrequentlyassetbacked,isshort-termwithoftenrepetitivedealsandtypicallyforstrategicoressentialcommercialinputs.Assuchitlendsitselfverywelltobeinginvestable.ThesizeoftheCTFmarketdependssomewhatoncommoditypricesbutisestimatedtoequatetoaround30%-35%oftheglobalTradeFinancemarket,ie.c.US$4-5trillion.Recourseistypicallytoabankissuedreceivableonbehalfofathird-partyortothecommodityitselfratherthantothebalancesheetofthedefactoborrower.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 6
A2015reviewofthehistoriccreditloss/defaultexperiencebyacoreofcommoditytradefinancebankspointstoa0.20%averagelossrateagainsta0.81%averageobligordefaultrate,whichcomparesfavourablytoStandard&Poor’sUScorporatedefaultratewhichstoodat2.8%inDecember2015.Moody’sglobalspeculative-gradedefaultrateroseto3.4%attheendof2015.
ReceivablesFinance(RF)maytaketheformofdiscountingwithorwithoutrecoursetotheselleraspecificorapoolofthird-partyinvoicesorbookdebts.Becauseunderlyinggoodswillhavealreadypassedhands,lenderstypicallytakeoutcreditinsurancetoprovideabackstopforbothwithandwithoutrecoursefinancings.Specificdefaultdataisnotavailable,althoughtheICChasstateditsambitiontobridgethegapinfuturereviews.ExpectationswouldbeforanaveragedefaultratethatfallssomewhereinthemiddlebetweenthatofcommoditytradefinanceandS&P’s/Moody’scorporatedefaultrates–ie.c.1to1.5%.Whereallconditionalityhasbeenmet(includingforinsurance)andareceivableisdueandpayable,anRFportfolioofferscharacteristicsthatmakeiteminentlyinvestable.
SupplyChainFinance(SCF)isperhapsthemostmisunderstood,largelybecauselenderswouldarguethatwhattheyalreadydoisfinancesupplychains…however,thenuancehereisthatinsteadoffinancingabilateraltradebetweentwopartiesalongasupplychain,thelenderslooktotheultimatereceivableattheendofachaintofinancethevarioussuppliersdowntheline.ItisineffectanexpandedformofReceivablesFinance.
StructuredTradeorStructuredCommodityFinance(STCF)tendstoinvolvemoremediumtolong-termfinancingsforeithercommoditiesorcapitalgoods,whichmaybebackedbyanExportCreditAgency(ECA)iiiorsecuredbyanassetbackedborrowingbase(usuallyofcommoditiesortheirreceivables).InsuchcasesSTCFlendsitselfwellasaninvestableTradeFinanceoffering,thoughtherearecaveats:wheretheuseoffundscannotbedirectlycorrelatedtotradeflowsorrecourseisdeemedtobesquarelytoacustomer’sbalancesheet,theloanwillbeconstruedascorporatelendingwhichwouldthenfallwithinacorporateassetclassratherthanTradeFinance.Seethecautionarytale,page14.
Who’s involved?
• AtradeinitssimplestformexistsbetweenBuyer(Importer)andSeller(Exporter)
• OftentheBuyerofonetrademaybetheSellerofanother,ashepurchasesinputstoproduceoutputs(thesupplychainview).
• Theremaybemiddlemen(traders),whobuyfromonepartytosellthesameproducttoanotherpartyaddingvaluethroughjust-in-timedeliveryorperhapssemi-processing.
• FinancingmaybeprovideddirectlybytheSellerextendingtradecredittotheBuyer,orbyanintermediaryextendingloanstoeitherBuyerorSellerorboth.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 7
• Counterpartiestoindividualtradesmayincludecorporates,financialinstitutions,sovereignsorspecialisedentities(set-upforthesolepurposeofatransaction)
• Alsoindirectlypartytoatradeislikelytobeanarrayoffacilitators/serviceproviderssuchasFreightForwarders,Shippers,InspectionCompanies,Warehouses,Insurers,PortAuthoritiesandvariousGovernmentLicensingAgencies.
Tradecanthenbesimple(bilateralbetweenBuyerandSeller)oritcanhavevaryingdegreesofcomplexity(anadditionalormultiplepartiesbuyingandsellingalongaspecifictransactionsupplychain).TradeFinancecanthenbesimilarlysimpleorcomplex,andinvestorsshouldthereforeunderstandsomethingoftheriskprofiletheyarebuyinginto(see‘WhataretheRisks’below).
2. WHAT IS THE INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY?
Theopportunityisforinvestorstoparticipatedirectlyorindirectlyinprovidingtradefinancefunding(tradeloans)toborrowersengagedinthephysicaltradeflowsofmerchandise,whomaybeproducers,semi-processors,tradersorconsumersalongthetradesupplychain.(Pleasesee‘HowcanInvestorsparticipate’below)
Worldtradehasbeengrowingyearonyearalmostconsistentlythispastdecade,witnessinganotableblipin2009(post-bankingcrisis)whichwasfollowedbyarecoveringgrowthin2010and2011,beforeanotherblipin2015ascommoditypricestumbledinthewakeofaChinaslowdown.TheWorldBank,however,projectsworldtradegrowthat3%.
Page 3
The Transaction Chain
Exporter(Seller)
Trader/Distributor(Buyer / Seller)
Importer(Buyer)
Lender / Intermediary
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 8
Principaltradegrowthwillbeintheemerginganddevelopingeconomies(c.4-5%)withthemoreadvancedeconomiesbeingrelativelyflat(<2%).
Source: World Trade Statistical Review 2016
Bridging the Trade Finance gap Asthefinancialservicesindustryadaptstothechangingregulatorylandscape,banksalonecannolongerfulfillthedemandforTradeFinancefunding,particularlytoSMEs:alreadytheAsianDevelopmentBankhasidentifiedatradefinancegapof$1.6trillioncausingtheindustrytomakearenewedchallengetowardstheregulators.Meanwhile,newspecialistfundsandboutiquesareemergingtobridgethegap,whilstthebanksthatpreviouslykeptbusinessbetweenthemselveshaveopenedtheirdoorstonon-bankfinancialinsititutionsandspecialistinvestors.GivenTradeFinance’slowrisk:highrecoveryrate(see‘WhataretheRisks’)andayieldlinkedtypicallytoaspreadoverfloating1,3or6monthsLIBORiv,it’slittlewonderTradeFinanceiscatchingtheeyeofinvestors–asyieldsfallontheirtraditionaltargets,TradeFinanceoffersacounterbalance,deservingtobeconsideredwithinadiversifiedinvestmentportfolio.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 9
Source: World Trade Statistical Review 2016
OneoftheattractionsofTradeFinanceasaninvestmentisitsflexibility:
- Dealscanbepackagedtomeetaninvestor’sriskprofileintermsoftenors,valueand,ifappropriate,goodsorgeography.
- Yieldswillbetransparentacrossthedifferentriskprofilesandinvestmentcanbetailoredtooffercapitalorincomegrowth
- Monitoringidentifiablecashflowsmakesiteasiertospotanypotentialpitfallsandtakeproactiveorreactivemeasurestomitigate
- Shorttermtenorsofdealsfacilitateinvestorsmovinginorout
Identifiable flows generating transparent returns Returns vary according to the type of fund and the risks it assumes, but in general Trade Finance returns are said to compare favourably to investing in bonds or leveraged loans: indeed, it has been argued that investors in trade finance loans would have enjoyed positive returns in any 12 month period since 2007, whilst even bond investors may have suffered negative returns during some holding periods. For Trade finance as an asset class is uncorrelated to stocks or bonds, taking as it does its roots in tangible ‘kick the tyres’ trade flows. Money is lent against identifiable transactions and repaid from their proceeds.
Investors should be careful though to understand exactly what each fund means by its offered rates of return, as a “net 20% pa” target might be achievable in higher risk markets (eg. Africa) but only if earned interest is being capitalised and rolled into further successful deals throughout the year. Investments in Asia might achieve 4% to 5%* pa. (reduced due to there being a more established and liquid market), whilst a more geographically diversified fund might achieve somewhere in the region of 7% - 10% *pa.. *Figures extracted from established funds
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 10
For investors seeking to take regular income (eg. quarterly or semi-annually), the achievable return will be rather less, being more aligned to the margin being received at each short-term maturity, which is subject to a number of influences: the range of spreads is therefore broad, from 50 basis points per annum (bppa), ie. 0.5% pa, up to 500 bppa, ie. 5.0% pa or more.
Funds may target markets where local currency borrowing costs are relatively high in order to offer cheaper US$ funding which nonetheless affords an attractive spread (eg. local costs 10% but US$ 3mth LIBOR 1% + spread 5% = 6% overall borrowing cost – subject to local market restrictions).
Due to the nature of returns being tied to an agreed transaction margin or funding spread, Trade Finance loans offer relatively low volatility of income and, assuming funds invested can regularly be deployed, there is also a consistent flow.
Capturing the Transaction Chain ThekeytoanyinvestmentinTradeFinanceisthentheabilityofthefundmanagertodeployfunds,forwhichtherearevariousopportunitiesalongthetransactionchain.
Forfundmanagersit’sthenaquestionofwhichTradeFinancefundingopportunitybestmeetstheriskandrewardprofileofthefund.
CapturingtheAtoZofthetransactionchainpresentsseveralopportunitiesforalendertointerposeandaddvalueforreward.Italsoaffordsgreaterleverageoflimitedresources(peopleandcapital)andactuallyimprovestransparencyandthereforeriskprofile.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 11
3. WHAT ARE THE RISKS?
TradeFinancehasnothithertobeenrecognisedasanindependentassetclassbuthasratherbeenconsideredasub-setoftheFinancialInstitutionandCorporateassetclasses.ThedownsideofsuchanapproachisthatTradeFinanceistypicallyviewedfromariskperspectiveasbeingonaparwithcorporateloansandotherlendingproducts,whereastherealityismuchmorefavourable:
AccordingtotheICCTradeRegisterReport,TradeFinancehasanaveragedefaultrateof0.02%acrossallvanillatradefinanceproductsandtradefinancelendingis5timeslessriskythangeneralcorporatelending.DefaultinTradeFinancedoesnotalwaysmeanloss,duetocontingentinstrumentsandhighrecoveryrates.
TheICCTradeRegisteranditsresultingannualReportareproducedbytheICCBankingCommissionandremaintheonlycomprehensive,authoritativeandwidelyreferencedsourceofdefaultandcreditriskdataforTradeandExportFinanceintheworldtoday.Whenseencollectively,the2015and2016ReportspresentaconsistentlylowcomparativeriskforTradeFinanceversusotherassetclasses,notwithstandingaworseningobligordefaultrateforTradeinthemorerecentfindings–up0.08%onLoans(seewww.iccwbo.org).
The2015Reportcites:
• “Lowoveralltransaction-levellossrate…theaveragetotalcustomerlevelExpectedLossforTradeFinanceproductsislessthanone-tenthoftheexpectedlossoftheMoody’srateduniverseoverthe2008–2014periodforLCsandGuaranteesandapproximatelyonefifthofthesameforLoansforImport/Export”
ThislowcomparativerateisexplainedbyTradeFinance’seventdrivencontingencywherethedefaulteventdependsontheoutcomeofotherprecedingevents,orthelackthereof.
The2016Reportreinforcesearlierpatterns:
• “The2016ReportcorroboratesfindingsfrompreviousyearsthatTradeFinancepresentsbankswithlowaveragematuritiesandlittlecreditrisk,withlowdefaultrates,lossgivendefault(LGD)andexpectedloss(EL)rates…Short-TermTradeFinanceremainslow-riskwhencomparedtootherassetclasses,includingcorporateandSMElending
The data reinforces Trade Finance’s low default profile
WepresentbelowsomeselecteddataextractsfromtheICCTradeRegisterReport2016which,forthepurposeofthisguide,focusesondatarelevanttotheinvestableExportL/CsandLoansforImport/Export,whicharedefinedthus:
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 12
Short-term data
AdaptedfromICCTradeRegisterReport2016
Intheprevious(2015)TradeRegisterReportwhichcarriedcomparabledata,itcites:-“ComparingthesedefaultrateswithMoody’scorporatedefaultratesoverthesametimeperiodallowsforarepresentationofdefaultratesinawidelyknownframework.WhilstExportL/CscomparetosomewherebetweenaAaaandAaMoody’srating,eventherelativelyhigherdefaultratesofPerformanceGuaranteesorLoansforImport/ExportcanberepresentedbyaBaaandBaMoody’srating,respectively,andcompareveryfavourablywiththeMoody’sratingofanaveragecorporatecreditportfoliocoveringallratingclassesof~2.1%”.
Analysisofshort-termtradefinancedataintheTradeRegister2008-2015
ProductTransactiondefaultrate
Exposureweighteddefaultrate
Obligordefaultrate
Moody'sratingforcomparabledefaultrate
ExportL/C 0.01% 0.04% 0.05% Aaa-AaLoansforImport/Export 0.24% 0.21% 0.80% Ba
Totalcustomersanddefaultratebyproduct,2008-2015
ProductTotal#Obligors
Total#defaultedobligors
Obligordefaultrate
Moody'sratingforcomparabledefaultrate
ExportL/C 116,646 55 0.05% Aaa-AaLoansforImport/Export 203,811 1,623 0.80% Ba
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 13
Furtherdatawithinthe2016reportrevealsthefollowing,evidencingtherelativelyshort-termnatureofTradeFinancewheretypicaltradecyclesfallwithin120–180days.
AdaptedfromICCTradeRegisterReport2016
ContributingtotheunderstandingofTradeFinanceisthebreakdownbelowofcustomerdefaultratebyassetcategory,whichshowstherelativeweightingofFIs,SovereignsandSpecialisedentitiestoCorporates.Notedisthatthedatatimeframecapturesthe2008-2009‘bankingcrisis’post-LehmanBrothers,whichmayaccountforthehigherdefaultrateandlowerrecoveryrateamongFIs(ExportL/Cs)thanamongcorporates(Loans).
Totaltransactionsanddefaultratebyproduct,2008-2015
ProductTotal#transactions
Total#defaultedtransactions
Defaultrate
Weightedaveragematurity(days)
ExportL/C 2,098,540 198 0.01% 133.8LoansforImport/Export 8,692,811 20,519 0.24% 160
Exposure-weightedtransactiondefaultratebyproduct,2008-2015
Product
Totalexposure($000)
Totaldefaultedexposure($000)
Exposureweighteddefaultrate
Transactiondefaultrate
ExportL/C 1,201,351 461 0.04% 0.01%LoansforImport/Export 3,919,215 8,072 0.21% 0.24%
Recoverydata
ProductAveragetimetorecovery(days)
Averagetimetorecoveryinyears
Averagerecoveryrate
ExportL/C 114 0.31 64%LoansforImport/Export 145 0.40 69%
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 14
The Medium-term view Short-termTradeFinanceisemphasisedandwhilstMedium-LongtermTradeFinanceloansarepossibleforECAorasset-backedborrowingbases,thereisacautionarytaleforthesehighlightedbythefollowingchartandcommentarypresentedintheICCTradeRegisterReport2015:
“ThesefindingshighlightthatidiosyncraticshockscanhavesignificanteffectsondefaultratesforMLTproducts.Assuch,careshouldbetakentounderstandingthecompositionofagivenportfoliowithregardstounderlyingassetclassesandgeographicaldistribution”.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 15
Inessence,tradefinanceloanswouldnormallybeprioritizedintheeventofamoratoriumofacountry’sdebtsbutwhereanMLTtradefinanceloanhascharacteristicsmoreakintoabalancesheetdrivencorporateloan,the‘tradefinance’relevancehasbeenchallengedinthecourtsandrelateddebthasbeenreclassifiedtofallamonggeneralcreditors.Kazakhstanprovidedadefiningprecedent.Thechallengessucceededbecausethefinancewastooremovedfromthecycleoftradeflowsactuallybenefittingthecountry.Cautionisthereforeneededtoavoidinvestingintradefinanceassetswhichdonotfullymeetthetradefinancedefinitionthatacourtmaydetermineinaparticularjurisdictionwhereredressisrequired–wherethatcourtisitselfrepresentingtheinterestsofitscountry.
Afurtherchallengeisofcoursepredictingeventswhichmaybe3to5yearsaway.
Putting numbers in perspective
AlthoughtheICCTradeRegisterReportisthedefinitivesourceofTradeFinancedefaultdata,itdoeshaveitslimitations.Itgathersdataonthe‘vanilla’tradefinanceproducts(LettersofCredit,Performancebondsandguarantees,ImportorExportLoans)buttodatedoesnotyetspecificallyaddressthemoreelaborateofferingsofreceivablesfinance,borrowingbasefinanceandownership-basedfinance,allofwhicharehowevercomponentsofacommoditytradefinanceproposition.
More specifically for commodity trade finance, a working group of the most active banks in commodity finance contributed to a dedicated review of the sector, benefitting from the anonymized pooling of data by the Global Credit Data Consortium: over the 2008 – 1H2015 review period, implied LGD (loss rate/default rate) was 20% or less consistently, reflecting the high recoveries from structure and collateral. Indeed, average default rate over the period was 0.81% notwithstanding the downturn years of 2008 and 2009 which saw 1.32% and a peak default rate of 1.85% respectively. All other years recorded < 1.0%.
Toputthesenumbersinperspective,S&P’svUScorporatedefaultratejumpedto3.3%inFebruary2016,withexpectationsthatthedefaultratewouldriseto3.9%byDecember2016.Thiscomparesto2.8%inDecember2015and1.6%inDecember2014. Moody’sglobalspeculative-gradedefaultrateroseto3.4%attheendof2015.
ThereareindeedrisksinTradeFinancelendingandinCommodityTradeFinancelendingbutthelowdefaultexperiencecompareswelltoothercorporatelendingandisduetotwofundamentaldifferences:
1. TradeFinanceandCommodityTradeFinanceuseforwardlookingriskassessments
2. CommodityTradeFinancebenefitsfromadedicatedriskcentricoperatingmodel
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 16
Traditionalcorporateriskassessmentslookathistoricbalancesheetstoestablishcreditworthinessandtheirriskmodelsputemphasisonturnover,EBITDAandinterestcover.TradeFinanceontheotherhand,especiallycommoditytradefinance,lookstosuchbalancesheetsnotsomuchforcreditworthinessbutratherforvulnerabilityandplacesmoreonusontheforwardviewofthevariousfactorsthatwillinfluenceandimpactontheoperationalisationofthetransactiontobefinanced.Whererecourseisself-liquidatingratherthantothecorporatebalancesheet,acorporateriskmodelisirrelevant.
TradeFinancethenisnottypicalcorporatebankingandshouldnotbeconstrainedbytypicalcorporatebankingtechniques.Itisspecialisedbankingandthemarketrecognisesapremiumforthepractitionerswhobringtheirvalue-addedexpertisetoanalyse,manageandmitigaterisksdynamicallyevolvingalongthetransactionchain.
Value added Trade Finance expertise Riskmanagementisadifferentiator.Thevalue-addedofanexperiencedanddedicatedteamofspecialistsset-uptomeetthedemandsoftheTradeFinancebusinessshouldnotbeunderestimated:whenthisexpertiseisharnessedwithinariskcentricframeworkit’sthereasonthatsomelendersavoidthepitfallsthatothershaveapenchantforfallinginto.
Knowingwhattolookfor,butmoreimportantlyhowtomanageandmitigatetherisksarisingalongatransactionchainistheskilloftheexperiencedTradeFinancepractitioner.Itbringsanaddedvalueinnotonlystructuringdealsforprotectionbutalsoinensuringthatoncefundshavebeenlentthereisanongoingmonitoringand,wherepossible,controlovertheensuingtransitiontowardseventualsettlement.Thisoftenmakesthedifferencebetweensuccessandfailureandisthechiefreasonwhythereistypicallyariskpremiumtobepaidtofundmanagers.
Thisbecomesallthemorerelevantwhenfundsarelendingtosupportcross-bordertradeflowswhereonepartymaybeinanunregulatedmarketoramarketwherepubliclyavailableinformationisnotreadilyavailable.TradeFinancepractitionerswillrelyontheirownnetworksandshouldbemakingfrequentvisitsandenquirytoprotecttheirloans.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 17
FraudisthemaincauseoflossinTradeFinanceandfraudisfacilitatedwherethelenderdoesn’thavesufficientmarketknowledgeorexpertisetospotitortotakestepstopreventit.That’sfrequentlywherelendershaveinvestedinthelast5years,beefingupriskandcomplianceteamstoensureappropriateduediligenceiscarriedoutpriortoanyengagementandthenmonitoringexposuresonanongoingbasistoavoidanysurprises.Thestrongerthefund’sriskmanagementpractices,thelesslikelyisthepotentialforfraud.
4. HOW CAN INVESTORS PARTICIPATE?
AccesstoinvestinginTradeFinanceloansmaytakeanumberofforms:
- Directlending(bilaterally)orco-lendingwithoneormorepartners.Thisisadvisableonlyforthosewithaprofessionalexperienceintradefinanceandwithasizeableamountofcapitalattheirdisposal.Directlendingwouldmeanoriginatingadealoneselfwhereasco-lendingcouldbesharinginadealsourcedbyanotherparty,usuallyacommercialbank.
- InvestinginaregulatedTradeFinancefund,eitherdirectly(asshareholder)orindirectlyviasubscriptiontothefund’sassets(ie.Buyingintotheindividualfundsbeingmanagedtoparticipateintheirgrowth).Specialisttradefundshavebeenaroundsincetheturnofthecenturybutmorehaveevolvedinrecentyearsledbyformerbankersandtraderswithvaryingdegreesofpedigreewho
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 18
offermostlynicheopportunitiesinsectorsorgeographiestheyarefamiliarwith.Whenreviewingsuchfundsit’simportanttoknowtheexpertiseoftheowners/managersandtounderstandhowthefundengages:
o Isitafundoffunds(sourcingfromotherfundsandlendingdirectly)orafundlendingtoafundoffunds?
o whatisitsmodusoperandi–directloans,‘repos’viorstep-inasprincipal?
o Whatsectorsorgeographiesdoesitcoverand/oravoid?
- Agrowingtrendforinstitutionalinvestorsandthelargerfamilyofficesorhighnetworthindividualsistoplacefundswitharegulatedspecialistfundmanagertoapplyintoatailoredriskprofileoftradefinanceassets.Investorsbenefitfromtheexpertiseofthefundmanagerinsourcingtransactionswhichmeettheirspecificgoalsfordiversificationofsector/geographyetc.
Inthepast,attemptstopackageandsecuritisetradefinanceassetsmetwithanumberofdifficulties:
- thedynamicsofmanydealsalterstheriskprofilefromonestagetoanothermakingformalratingsofportfoliosachallenge,eg.Whenfundsaredisbursedriskmaybetoarecourseonthegoodsthemselves,butasthetransactionevolvesanexportletterofcreditmaybeconfirmedbyabank,transferringtherisktotheratingofthatbank.
- thiscreatesachallengeforfundmanagerstoretainthefundwithinasetrating,asassetsmoveinandoutofscope.
Amoreappropriatesolutionbeingappliedtodayistoconsidertheriskprofileofportfoliosasaseriesof‘buckets’,affordinggreaterflexibilitytofundmanagerswhilstenablinginvestorstodetermineabucketprofilewhichsuitsthem:eg.AnemergingmarketsfundversusanOECDfund,orafundinvestinginbankexportLCconfirmationsversusaninvestmentincorporatereceivables.Fundsmaybesegmentedbycommodityorbygeographyorbyobligortype(FI,sovereign,corporate,specialised).
Thereispresentlyno‘go-to’registerofTradeFinancefunds,althoughthismayberemediedasthemarketevolves.
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 19
CONCLUSION
TradeFinancelendsitselfwelltobeingrecognisedasanassetclassforinvestment,wheresomeelementsofitaremoreinvestablethanothers.Whilstcomparativeriskislow,it’stheexperienceandprofessionalismofpractitionersinsourcingqualitycounterparts,carryingoutappropriateduediligenceandapplyingandmonitoringmitigantsthatmakesTradeFinancewhatitis-sobackingtherightfundmanagersbecomespivotal.
ThereisotherwiseadangerthatthedriveforTradeFinanceinvestmentswillbringaplethoraoffundsallclaimingtoofferinvestorsexactlywhattheyneedbutnotallbeingabletoeffectivelydeliver-anabsenceofgenuineexperienceandpedigreeintheindustrybeingtherootcause.Yes,TradeFinanceriskiscomparativelylow.No,thatdoesn’tmeanit’sriskfree.Fraudremainsthemajorconcern,butispreventablewithproventechniques.
ThetimeisrightforTradeFinancetobetreatedasaninvestableassetclass.Afundinggapmeansthere’sgreateropportunityforinvestmentfundstobeprofitablydeployed,whilstTradeFinanceinvestmentoffersaconsistentincome,isrelativelyliquidtomoveinorout,andhasdemonstratedlowvolatility.
TradeFinanceshouldaccordinglyearnitsplacewithinadiversifiedinvestmentportfolio.
iLettersofcredit,Guarantees/StandbyLCs,BidandPerformanceBondsiiSmallandMediumSizedEnterprises,usuallydefinedbyturnoveriiiExportCreditAgency,astatesponsoredentitytosupportexportsviaguaranteestolenderivLondonInterBankOfferedRate,thebenchmarkappliedtofundingininternationalmarketsvStandard&Poor’s,financialservicescompanyandratingagencyviSaleandrepurchaseobligationswherethefundbuysassetstakingownershipwithapre-arrangedforwardsaleusuallybacktotheoriginalseller
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 20
APPENDIX
TheICCTradeRegisterReport2016givesthefollowingstatisticsforTradeFinance.
Short-term Trade Finance Statistics
BelowisacomprehensivebreakdownofthedefaultratecompositionoftheLoansforImport/Exportbetweenbankandcorporaterisk,andofthetransactiondefaultratebyassetcategory:
Source:ICCTradeRegisterReport2016
Medium – Long term Trade Finance Statistics
TheMediumandLongTerm(MLT)productsin-scopeoftheICCTradeRegisterarethosewiththebackingofanOECDvimemberbasedECA,representingthefullfaithandcreditoftheirrespectivegovernment.Althoughthein-scopeMLTtransactionshavedifferent
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 21
productcharacteristicsthanthetransactionsincludedintheShort-termTradeRegister,theriskprofileoftheMLTproductsisalsoconsideredlow.
ThisisprimarilyduetoalowExpectedLossunlesstheECAitselfdefaults,whichistypicallyconsideredunlikelyasthein-scopeECAsaresponsoredbyhigh-incomeOECDgovernmentsandhaveinvestmentgraderatings.
Source:ICCTradeRegisterReport2016
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 22
Source:ICCTradeRegisterReport2016
AboutBankingwiseLimited
Bankingwiseisanichebusinessandmanagementconsultancydeliveringtailoredadvice,supportandtrainingtotheFinancialServicesandCorporatesectors.
AboutKimuraCapitalLLP
KimuraCapital,LLPisanassetmanagementfirmheadquarteredinLondonwithanadditionalrepresentativeofficeinNewYork.KimuraprovidesanalternativetobankfundingincommoditytradefinanceforSmall-MediumSizedEnterprises(SMEs).Kimura’ssectorfocusisEnergy,BaseMetals,SoftsandAgriculturewithsubsectorexposuretopetrochemicals,alloys,concentrates,polymersandfertilizersandwillconsidertransactionsglobally.Kimuraadoptsastringentclienton-boardingprocess.Duediligenceisatthecentreofthecompany’soperationalmandate;athoroughreviewprocessisconductedoneachnewcounterpartyandeverytransaction.
Disclaimer
ThispaperisintendedasgeneralinformationforanyoneconsideringTradeFinancefundsasaninvestment.ItdoesnotconstituteanofferorrecommendationtoapplyforanyparticularfundorfundsandneitherBankingwiseLimitednorKimuraCapitalLLPholdthemselvesoutassolicitingforanyspecificinvestments.TheinformationhereinistohelpinformopinionandtosuggesttopotentialinvestorswhattheyshouldbetakingintoaccountwhenconsideringTradeFinanceasaninvestment.CounterpartiestoTradeFinancetransactionsmaynotthemselvesbeofinvestmentgradeandthereisariskoflossofpartoralloftheinvestmentsthroughdefaultonrepaymentdespitebesteffortsinselectingcreditworthytransactions.Potentialinvestorsshouldnotethattheirfundsmaybeinvestedinunregulatedandmorevolatilemarketswherethereislikelytobe
TradeFinanceasanInvestment 23
lessinformationpubliclyavailable.PotentialinvestorsareencouragedtoreadthetermsandconditionscontainedinarelevantOfferingMemorandumbeforeanyinvestmentismadeandtoseekguidancefromaregulatedadviserwhenrequired..