tii - migration research fair migration and community relations coping with the changes + challenges...

TII - Migration Research Fair

Migration and Community Relations

Coping with the changes + challenges of exile: The experiences of unaccompanied

minors living in Ireland.

Muireann Ní Raghallaigh, School of Social Work and Social Policy, TCD.

This research was funded by The National Children’s Office, The Children’s Research Centre (TCD), and The School of Social Work and Social Policy (TCD)

24/09/2007 [email protected] 2

Research Methodology Attempts to elicit the young people’s

experiences of adjusting to life in Ireland

Qualitative study: participant observation & interviews (32)

Trust and distrust as influential factors in the research design.


Key Insights – 1 – Ordinary Lives, Changes and Challenges

Talking about the ‘ordinary’ aspects of their past lives:

Family, Friendships, and Schooling

Encountering multiple changes and challenges:

Life without family and childhood friends Adjusting to a new and different culture Dealing with the challenges of the asylum

process


Key Insights – 2 - Coping

Using various coping strategies: Maintaining continuity Adjusting by learning and changing Adopting a positive outlook Suppressing emotions and seeking

distraction Viewing themselves as self reliant


Maintaining Continuity in a Changed Context

Ireland now, Maybe the Irish people may not accept it but it’s mixed culture now. And there is different cultures here. There is African shop. If I want my Nigerian food I can get it. And if I want to go to Nigerian church I could go. But assuming all these things are not there and it’s purely Ireland, you know it would be more difficult because you really miss home. Because that life is not there. But the way it is now. I’m in Ireland but if I want to live a Nigerian life, you could still get it, like.


Viewing Themselves as Self-Reliant

You are no longer Mammy’s boy or Daddy’s boy, you know how you grow up, you take care of yourself, you have to learn to live without your parents, you know. Eh, taking your own responsibilities … I’m deal-with-your-own-problems guy. I deal with my own problems


Key Insights – 3 – The Prevalence of Distrust

Participant observation– Distrust of me as researcher– Spontaneous conversations about not trusting

Interviews:– Often only trusting certain people or trusting

people to a certain extent


Key Insight – 4 - Reasons for Distrust

1. Past experiences

2. Being accustomed to distrust

3. Being distrusted by others

4. Inability to tell the truth

5. Not knowing people well

Their distrust was ‘functional’ (Kohli, 2006) – another coping strategy


Key Insights – 5 – Importance of Faith

Negotiating a very different religious culture

Religion was depicted as being embedded in the participants’ countries of origin

Irish people perceived to be uninterested in faith.

Young people spontaneously mentioned God and religion


Irish Peers and Church

Oh they never go to church [laughs] […] No. They would only laugh at me when I say ‘you wanna go to church’ or something like that. No. They would probably still be like … probably still like, sleep ins while I’m in church, like, in the morning. And everything like that. They wake up at 12 o clock or 11.


The Role of Faith

(A) Faith Provided Comfort and Companionship

God as a source of comfort and support, and a companion who journeyed with them.

Also: comfort and companionship provided by those they met at religious services.


Relationship with God God perceived as trustworthy God providing continuous support

The only, only, only friend [laughs] I trusted all the time, that’s God. […] I don’t have any more friends, I trusted more than God, I don’t think so. You know because, always God knows more than everybody. And God’s gonna help you all the

time. […]God always gonna help.


Seeking God’s support through prayer

Their ‘ordinary’ and ‘extraordinary’ life experiences (Kohli, 2006) evident in what they prayed for:I just pray for God to help me, you know? Help me to … see the right man. That will like, love me. Get married. Settle down. Have a nice job. Just to get my status. You understand? Get my status. Have a nice job. Live a nice life with my family […] I would pray for my aunt. … My brother. For God to help him. I want to see him.


The Role of Faith

(B) Faith provided continuity amidst much discontinuity

Continuity in their relationships with God Continuity in religious services Religion and faith served as ‘anchors’ for

the Ums


Continuous Relationship with God

God helped them at home and continues to help them in IrelandBecause I believe he’s the one that sent the man to help me. I believe he’s the one that brought me to this, eh, country, you understand? I believe he’s the one that’s still protecting me up till now. I believe with him everything is possible.


Opting for Continuity

The young people chose to practice their faith

They also adapted their faith to their new circumstances

The African Christians chose churches that provided continuity


Deciding what Church to Attend

That church [African church] is like … Catholic church back home. They sing and dance and … all … But I don’t like the way they pray and all that stuff. When they praying, they screaming and so, I just go like (?) a Catholic church, you know how they pray very quiet. And in my own way I pray very quiet. […] They’re not screaming, praying.


Enjoying Services Wanting vibrant and lively services:

It’s a good church. I like it. The most thing I like about it is the pastor. The pastor is really good. I like him. He, like, he would preach and he would make jokes. You know jokes like, making an example. He would say something in Bible and try to make an example of it and make it as, as a joke. I mean he is funny…. And he don’t get boring, you know. Some pastors when they are starting preaching, can nearly get asleep, but this one, no way.


Reflections on Methodology Used

Participant observation: can build trust and arouse suspicion! Overall, a worthwhile endeavour.

Interviews: A positive experience for the young people? Eager to talk, particularly about their ‘ordinary’ lives.

“I happy to tell you because … I like to tell someone, to talk someone about my country.”


Concluding Comments

This research draws attention to– Multiple challenges + changes faced by UMs– Their purposeful use of various coping strategies– The particularly important role played by faith

They emerge as “active survivors” rather than as “passive victims” (Rousseau & Drapeau, 2003, p. 78).


References

Kohli, R.K.S. (2006b) The Sound of Silence: Listening to What Unaccompanied Asylum-Seeking Children Say and Do Not Say. British Journal of Social Work, 36 (5): 707-721. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Pargament, K.I. (1997) The Psychology of Religion and Coping – Theory, Research, Practice. London: Guilford Press.

Rousseau, C. & Drapeau, A. (2003) Are refugee children an at-risk group? A Longitudinal study of Cambodian Adolescents. Journal of Refugee Studies, 16 (1), 67-81.

tii - migration research fair migration and community relations coping with the changes + challenges...

Documents

religion slide

coping strategy slide

social policy tcd slide

key insights

trusting people

certain extent slide

certain people

asylum process slide