threatened - alexander von humboldt foundation · the photo shows two proud snow-house builders....

35
THREATENED How researchers become refugees DEUTSCHE VERSION: BITTE WENDEN Humboldt  kosmos No. 106 / 2016 Research – Diplomacy – Internationality TAX HAVEN SECRETS A journey into the realm of wealth managers GOOD FRIENDS DESPITE BREXIT Why Germany is now becoming more important for the British

Upload: others

Post on 19-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

THREATENEDHow researchers become refugees

DEUTSCHE

VERSION:

BITTE

WENDEN

Humboldt kosmosNo. 106 / 2016 Research – Diplomacy – Internationality

TAX HAVEN SECRETS

A journey into the realm of wealth managers

GOOD FRIENDS DESPITE BREXIT

Why Germany is now becoming more important for the British

Page 2: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

27 000 researchers of all disciplines worldwide12 000 collaborative partners in Germany1001 new ideas1 place to connect Humboldt Life – the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation’sonline network

www.humboldt-life.de

Page 3: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

3Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Winter 1983 in Natters – this village in Austria’s Stubai Valley is where we grew up. Altogether there were four of us children, but after Philipp was born, he and I soon became an inseparable team – and have remained so to this day.

The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one on top of the other and finally fused them together – what fun we had! Our father taught me how to do it and I showed Philipp (on the right). Then, as now, we pursued joint projects and goals. As children we built a house of snow blocks, today we do scientific experiments which we construct and discuss.

Was it chance or intention that made us choose the same path? I have no idea, it just happened that way. Our father was a scientist and took us to his lab when we were still small. I later studied medicine, so did Philipp. I chose immunology, so did Philipp. And we even have the same special-isation: liver research. So it is hardly surprising that our CVs and projects are similar. The fact that we are brothers is beside the point. When you are a researcher, you need a buddy, and we found each other – ages ago.

Being so similar makes us strong. We both tackle problems analyt-ically. When we discuss things we immediately know what the other

one is thinking. Some people have their lightbulb moments in the shower, we have them when we are talking to one another.

At the moment, we are working together on a collaborative research project at Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf where Philipp is head of a department. The university hospital there was one of our most seminal stages in our lives. Supported by the Humboldt Foundation, we spent five years working on our research and made one of our most important discoveries to date: enforced viral replication – an immu-nological process which is incredibly important for enabling the body’s immune system to fight viruses.

There is really nothing that divides us. We even share a dislike of fried liver. Although I can think of one thing we don’t both enjoy: jam dumplings with vanilla sauce – even he can’t get me to like them.

By KARL SEBASTIAN LANG, recorded by KRISTIN HÜTTMANN

The brothers PROFESSOR DR KARL SEBASTIAN LANG and

PROFESSOR DR PHILIPP LANG were both granted the Sofja Kova-

levskaja Award. Karl Sebastian Lang is the Director of the Institute

of Immunology at Essen University Hospital; Philipp Lang heads the

Department of Molecular Medicine II at University Hospital Düsseldorf.

HUMBOLDTIANS IN PRIVATE

Ph

oto

: pri

vate

BROTHERS IN SPIRIT

Page 4: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

4 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Dear readers,

At the entrance to Istanbul University there is a plaque with the inscription: With gratitude to the Turkish people who, between 1933 and 1945 under the leadership of President Atatürk, gave refuge to German university teachers in their academic institu-tions. In the name of the German people, Richard von Weizsäcker, President of the Federal Republic of Germany, 29 May 1986.

One of the 300 or so researchers, artists, architects and politicians who had fled from Nazi Germany and are remembered on this plaque was the pathologist Philipp Schwartz. He founded the Notgemeinschaft deutscher Wissenschaftler im Ausland (Emergency Society of German Scholars Abroad) and helped many persecuted researchers to find sanctuary.

It is after him that the Humboldt Foundation has named the new initiative it has launched together with the Federal Foreign Office to offer refuge to threatened and persecuted researchers at German universities. Today, Turkey, along with Syria, is one of the main countries of origin of Philipp Schwartz Fellows. Irrespective of the country they hail from, the fates and stories behind their flight illustrate the importance of such help and how sadly relevant the notion of an emergency society for researchers is today.

In this edition, we tell some of these stories of threat and displacement, but also of hope and soli-darity amongst researchers who help their colleagues in need – just as Philipp Schwartz once did.

GEORG SCHOLLEditor in Chief

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Dav

id A

uss

erh

ofe

r

03 HUMBOLDTIANS IN PRIVATE Brothers in spirit

06 BRIEF ENQUIRIES What drives researchers and what they are currently doing

EDITORIAL CONTENTS

06

Page 5: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

5Humboldt kosmos 106/2016

Ph

oto

s: H

um

bo

ldt

Fo

un

dat

ion

 / D

avid

Mat

thie

sse

n, i

mag

o/I

TAR

-TA

SS

, Fo

tolia

/Ne

jro

n P

ho

to

IMPRINT HUMBOLDT KOSMOS 106

PUBLISHER Alexander von Humboldt Foundation

EDITOR IN CHIEF Georg Scholl (responsible)

EDITORS Ulla Hecken, Alexandra Hostert,

Lena Schnabel

ENGLISH TRANSLATIONS Dr. Lynda Lich-Knight

PRODUCTION & GRAPHICS Raufeld Medien GmbH

Birgit Metzner (Project Management),

Daniel Krüger (Creative Direction),

Lotte Rosa Buchholz (Art Direction)

FREQUENCY twice a year

CIRCULATION OF THE ISSUE 38,000

PRINTER WM Druck + Verlag, Rheinbach

ADDRESS Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung

Redaktion Humboldt kosmos

Jean-Paul-Straße 12, 53173 Bonn, Germany

[email protected], www.humboldt-foundation.de

ISSN 0344-0354

FOCUS

12 On dangerous paths How researchers become refugees and who helps them

19 Keeping prospects alive Foreign Minister Steinmeier on the Philipp Schwartz Initiative

20 Safe haven: university Out of war and into work

24 FOCUS ON GERMANY Good friends despite Brexit

28 CLOSE UP ON RESEARCH “You can open a shell company in five minutes”

32 NEWS

34 THE FACES OF THE FOUNDATION A who’s who of the people behind the scenes at the Humboldt Foundation

2812

Page 6: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

6 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Nik

ola

us

Bra

de

BRIEF ENQUIRIES

Page 7: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

7Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

MR ADUM, HOW DO YOU SAVE FROGS?

Gilbert Adum is Ghana’s frogman. Crawling through the under-growth, diving into ponds, wading through rivers – this is his job. As one of the founders and head of the SAVE THE FROGS! Ghana organisation, he passionately campaigns for the survival of the amphibians in his native country. His aim is to save frogs from extinction and conserve their environment. To this end, he uses all his powers of persuasion to engage miners and loggers as well as villagers in nature conservation.

And who better than Gilbert Adum? His family descends from the Chiana-Gwenia, a tribe of hunters in northern Ghana. As a child, he catches frogs and eats them. The amphibians are part of the villagers’ staple diet. The frog hunter, however, turns brilliant schoolboy, quite capable of studying medicine. “But I could never imagine working as a doctor,” he says. “My love of nature was much greater.” So he studies natural resources management and soon discovers what an important role frogs play in the ecosystem. “Frogs are indispensable for the food chain in the forest and thus for us humans, too. On top of this, they eat disease-carrying mosquitoes.”

Today, Adum is one of the leading amphibian conservationists on the African continent. He has received numerous awards for his work, including the prestigious Whitley Award, the Green Oscar. One par-ticular frog has a special place in his heart: the Giant Squeaker Frog. He has never met anyone, he likes to report, who was not captivated by the call of this frog. When he then grins and imitates its squeaky courtship cry, you believe every word he says.

The Giant Squeaker Frog was thought to be extinct – until Adum and his team rediscovered a small population in 2009; they have been fighting for its survival ever since. “We have to protect its habitat by stopping the environmental damage being done by mining and log-ging and restoring natural plant growth.”

GILBERT ADUM spent a year at the Museum für Naturkunde in

Berlin on an International Climate Protection Fellowship. He is now

back in Ghana working for SAVE THE FROGS! Ghana once more. Text KRISTIN HÜTTMANN

Page 8: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

8 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

HOW DO YOU MAKE NANO ROBOTS OUT OF DNA AND GOLD, MS LIU?

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Dav

id M

atth

iess

en

A mini robot that is made of the same material as our DNA, that can be controlled by light and that can move within a cell ? This is no longer a future vision – the Chinese physicist Laura Na Liu has built one in nano format.

In her research, Liu delves into the realms of the tiniest things: on the nanometre scale. The main component of her smallest machine is just a ten-thousandth of a human hair in diameter. It is composed of bundles of coiled DNA which are joined together by a kind of hinge, rather like scissor blades that can be opened and closed.

“It is crucial that the process can be reversed,” says Liu. In order to visualise the opening and closing of the hinge, the physicist turns to nanoplasmonics. She has managed to equip the DNA bundles with tiny gold particles and excite them with UV light. The gold particles then begin to oscillate and emit optical signals which Liu can measure

precisely. “Now the nano machines have to function just as well in living cells as they do in the test tube because, figuratively speaking, a cell is stuffed full of ballast.”

Working at the interface of biology, chemistry and materials science, Laura Na Liu is embarking on unknown territory with this nanoplas-monic system. In future, she may be able to trace processes within cells on the level of individual particles and thus contribute significantly to our understanding of biochemical processes.

The Sofja Kovalevskaja Award Winner PROFESSOR DR LAURA NA LIU conducts research at the Max Planck Institute for Intelligent

Systems in Stuttgart and holds a professorship in the Kirchhoff

Institute for Physics at Heidelberg University.

Text NADINE QUERFURTH

BRIEF ENQUIRIES

Page 9: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

9Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Nik

ola

us

Bra

de

In retrospect, Daniel Müllensiefen cannot gauge to what extent his youthful guitar strumming influenced his intellectual development, but one thing he does know: “Music makes me happier and more contented.” He still plays the guitar when he finds time alongside work and three young children. And he certainly cannot complain about a lack of success at his job.

The music psychologist from the University of London is a sought-after expert when it comes to investigating the impact of music on people. He invented a test for measuring musicality: the Goldsmiths Musical Sophistication Index (Gold-MSI), which has become a stan-dard tool in musical research.

He also made a name for himself with computer analysis for detect-ing plagiarism and earworms, tunes you get on the brain. Together with his colleagues in Hanover, Müllensiefen now wants to discover

how engagement with music shapes children and teenagers – their personalities, intelligence and social skills. “We intend to spend at least five years observing natural development from Year 5 onwards.” A kind of musical PISA survey.

“Making music trains the memory, concentration and perception. This helps children’s entire development,” says the music researcher. Above all, music is supposed to be fun and should be pursued for its own sake – because, according to Müllensiefen, “Music is not a com-petitive sport”.

DR DANIEL MÜLLENSIEFEN from Goldsmiths College, University

of London, United Kingdom, is an Anneliese Maier Research

Award Winner cooperating with the Hanover University of Music,

Drama and the Media. Text KRISTIN HÜTTMANN

MR MÜLLENSIEFEN, HOW DOES MUSIC MAKE CHILDREN SMARTER?

Page 10: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

10 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

It all started with a simple observation: it cannot be a coincidence that the fishermen in M’Bour sometimes catch a lot of fish and some-times only a few – and they have no idea why. If it is not coincidence, however, but sheer logic, then it must be a job for a mathematician: one like Mouhamed Moustapha Fall who conducts his research near M’Bour in the west of Senegal.

So Fall and some researchers from the Leibniz Center for Tropical Marine Ecology in Bremen, plus a student from Ghana, set about inves-tigating the fishermen’s behaviour. They observed when the fishermen went to sea and enquired where they made their hauls and how many fish they netted. Fall plans to compare these results with information on the size of fish stocks in the area.

His goal is to develop a mathematically precise model based on the data relating to the catch and the fish stocks. This will allow him

to calculate how much fish the fishermen can catch without endan-gering stocks.

One day, it might even be possible to develop an app which the fishermen could use to decide where would be the best place to fish plentifully as well as sustainably. Fall’s mathematical model would therefore help the fishermen to catch more fish – and stabilise fish stocks at the same time. Because if the fish do well, the fishermen do well, too.

The former Humboldt Research Fellow, DR MOUHAMED MOUSTA-PHA FALL, holds the German Research Chair at the African Institute

for Mathematical Sciences (AIMS) in Senegal, which is sponsored

by the Humboldt Foundation and funded by the Federal Ministry of

Education and Research. Text ANDREAS UNGER

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /A

nd

reas

Un

ge

r

BRIEF ENQUIRIES

HOW DOES MATHEMATICS HELP FISHERMEN, MR FALL?

Page 11: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

11Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Mar

tin

Ste

ffe

n

Every day, when Nowsheen Goonoo enters her lab in Siegen, she brings a little bit of home with her. The scientist from Mauritius experiments with substances taken from indigenous plants.

“My grandfather knew all about the effects of Aloe vera and healed my childhood scratches with it,” she remembers. The parts of the plant the chemist wants to utilise resemble a bloated gummi bear: the gel in the water-storing tissue in the leaves. It has long been an important ingredient in cosmetics. Goonoo now wants to use elements of the gel and other synthetic polymers to produce fibres, which can then be a support for cell growth.

“Mauritius still has many untapped raw materials,” says Goonoo. Currently, she is also experimenting with Fucoidan, an ingredient which occurs in the brown seaweed found in the coastal waters off Mauritius. “I can combine its positive properties with those of synthetic

polymers.” By subjecting the polymer solution to an electrospinning process she can produce novel blend fibres that form a supporting structure on which bone cells can grow and mature, eventually gener-ating new bone. “If the cells are happy on the surface of the support-ing template, then they grow well,” Goonoo notes.

She intends to continue investigating the correlation between blend miscibility, mechanical properties and biodegradability more precisely. In the more distant future, tissue cultivated by Goonoo could then potentially be used in transplants.

DR NOWSHEEN GOONOO from the Centre for Biomedical

and Biomaterials Research, Mauritius, is a Georg Forster Research

Fellow at the University of Siegen.

Text NADINE QUERFURTH

CAN ALOE VERA HELP TO CULTIVATE BONE CELLS, MS GOONOO?

Page 12: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

12 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

When Nedal Said talks about the last months in his home city of Aleppo, he lowers his eyes. The Syrian microbiol-ogist tells of a devastating civil war, of

the long prison sentence meted out to his dissident brother and of the secret service that started appearing ever more often at his university and spreading terror. Back then, in 2013, he spent part of his time working at the university and part at the Department of Laboratories for Monitor-ing Drinking Water. “One day, a friend who had good contacts in the secret service rang me and said I was in great danger because of my opposition to Assad and should leave the country immediately,” Said reports. He quickly packed suitcases, and he and his wife and their three small children went to Turkey. When their savings ran out, the family spent a year in a Turkish refugee camp.

Then, in summer 2015, Nedal Said got on a small boat – without his family – and survived the dangerous journey to his destination of choice, Germany.

“I AM A WHOLE PERSON AGAIN”Today, the Syrian scientist spends his time at the Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research – UFZ in Leipzig and studies miniscule organisms under state-of-the-art micro-scopes. He speaks German – not perfectly, but amazingly well for someone who only started learning the language a year ago. “I work in science. Colleagues support me, and my family is with me at last – I am a whole person again,” says the 43-year-old, beaming.

Nedal Said is one of the first fellows of the Philipp Schwartz Initiative, a funding programme run by the Humboldt Foundation with the support of the Federal For-

FOCUS

ON DANGEROUS PATHS

Text LILO BERG

They flee from violence and destruction just like other people, but because they are independent thinkers, researchers are often subject to greater threat. Their stories tell of persecution and hardship, but also of new prospects thanks to the solidarity of their colleagues abroad.

Ph

oto

: im

ago

/ITA

R-T

AS

S

Page 13: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

13Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

eign Office. It is designed to enable German universities and research institutions to employ endangered foreign researchers for a period of two years. In summer 2016, Said and 22 other selected researchers from Syria, Turkey, Libya, Pakistan and Uzbekistan had their fellowships confirmed; over 40 more fellows are due to follow at the beginning of 2017. They can all bank on an adequate salary and access to language courses and other educational opportunities.

In the contest for this coveted fellowship, dedicated mentors are important. One such is Hans-Hermann Richnow, the head of the Department Isotope Biogeochem-istry at UFZ. Even before the fellowship started, he orga-nised work experience for Nedal Said in his institute, helped with the application and made sure he had a place to work. “We were actually already looking for a micro-biologist,” Richnow reports. “We found Mr Said by

A R E A S O F O R I G I N of displaced researchers (in per cent)

T O P 5 refugee countries of origin

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Sub-Sahara

n Afri

ca

South A

sia

Central/E

ast/S

outh E

ast Asia

Latin and S

outh A

meric

a

Eastern

Euro

pe

20152016

63

21

8

4 3 1

71

15

5 4

1

2

3

4

5

Iran Syria

2015 2016

Syria Iran

Iraq Iraq

Turkey

2015: n = 146, 1.9.2014–31.08.2015 2016: n = 192, 1.9.2015–31.08.2016

Number of individuals supported by the largest aid organisation for threatened researchers,

the Scholars at Risk Network

2015: n = 146, 1.9.2014–31.08.2015 2016: n = 192, 1.9.2015–31.08.2016

Number of individuals supported by the Scholars at Risk Network

Ethiopia

Pakistan Ethiopia

PLAYING IN THE RUBBLEA child in a largely decimated resi dential area of Aleppo in March 2016

Middle

East and N

orth A

frica

incl. Turk

ey

2 3

So

urc

e: S

cho

lars

at

Ris

k

Page 14: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

14 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

FOCUS

“ A FRIEND WHO HAD GOOD CONTACTS IN THE SECRET SERVICE RANG ME AND SAID I SHOULD LEAVE SYRIA IMMEDIATELY.”

Social S

cience

s

Arts and H

umanitie

s

Philipp Schwartz Fellow NEDAL SAID (rt) from Syria and his host HANS- HERMANN RICHNOW at the Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research – UFZ in Leipzig

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Nik

ola

us

Bra

de

Page 15: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

15Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

chance, and it had a lot to do with the fact that he himself went looking for work from the very beginning.”

In Leipzig, it was the refugee’s own initiative that did the trick; in Berlin, an established relationship paid dividends: the geographer Mohamed Ali Mohamed, who also comes from Aleppo, was a doctoral student at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin from 2004 to 2010. After completing his doctorate, he returned to his native city and became a professor at the university there. “The bom-bardments began in 2012,” says the scientist in fluent Ger-man, “and our house with all our worldly goods was destroyed in the first attacks.” The family of five was then homeless. On top of this came the permanent fear of being conscripted, a realistic prospect even though Mohamed was then already 40. Finally, he decided to leave his wife and their three children behind and to flee across the “green border” to Turkey. From there, he made contact with his supervisor, Hilmar Schröder, who arranged for his former student to leave the country on a work visa at the end of 2015.

“When he arrived in Berlin, Mohamed was timid and anxious – we’d never seen him like that before,” says Hilmar Schröder. But his colleague soon became his old self. Today, he holds his own seminars again and is doing a soil research project with funding from the Philipp Schwartz Initiative. Schröder and other members of the faculty are currently trying to bring Mohamed’s wife and children to Germany from a Syrian refugee camp. One

colleague has provided a fridge, another saucepans and when a contract has to be signed, someone from the insti-tute is there to help him. “I am so grateful for the support I am being given in Germany,” says the man from Aleppo who himself helps his refugee compatriots by interpreting for them – pro bono, of course.

PROTECTED BY UNIVERSITIESThe narratives in the Philipp Schwarz Initiative tell of great danger and successful rescue. More than 60 researchers are being sponsored by the initiative and they are all part of the global stream of refugees displaced by war and per-secution. Exactly how many researchers there are, where they come from, what disciplines they represent and where they find refuge is not precisely known. Some light is thrown on the matter by the statistics of the largest aid organisation for threatened researchers, the Scholars at Risk Network (SAR). More than 400 universities and research institutions around the world belong to this network; in the last two years, they have provided a safe haven for some 340 researchers. Now, 20 members of the newly founded German section with headquarters at the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation belong to the SAR Network, as well.

According to Scholars at Risk data, European univer-sities accept the largest percentage of threatened research-ers (see graph on page 18). Following major growth in Germany’s admission figures in 2016, the country now

D I S C I P L I N E S of displaced researchers (in per cent)

20152016

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Social S

cience

s

Arts and H

umanitie

s

Physical a

nd Life S

cience

s

Law/H

uman R

ights

Medicine a

nd Public

Health

Mathem

atics a

nd Info

rmat

ion Scie

nce

Journ

alism

and Writ

ing

Business

and Finance

M O S T F R E Q U E N T LY - C I T E D C A U S E S of flight (in per cent)

 Threat to life

 Threat of arrest/violence

 General risk

 Harassment/intimidation

 Other

201544

31

8

152

2016

36

32

20

111

2015: n = 146, 1.9.2014–31.08.2015 2016: n = 192, 1.9.2015–31.08.2016

Number of individuals supported by the Scholars at Risk Network

Source: Scholars at Risk

2119 20 20

15

18

9

3

6 5 5

11

3 3 2

40

Page 16: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

16 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

FOCUS

The Syrian geogra - pher MOHAMED ALI MOHAMED (rt) with his host Hilmar Schröder at Humboldt- Universität zu Berlin

“ I AM SO GRATEFUL FOR THE SUPPORT I AM BEING GIVEN IN GERMANY.”

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Nik

ola

us

Bra

de

Page 17: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

17Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

The Turkish trans-lation scholar MERAL CAMCI (lt) and her host DILEK DIZDAR at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz

“ SHE CAMPAIGNS FOR HER CONVICTIONS – THIS HAS BECOME QUITE UNUSUAL.”

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Ale

xan

de

r P

aul E

ng

lert

Page 18: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

18 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

FOCUS

In 2015 and 2016, figures remained almost constant:

6 out of 10 researchers fled to Europe, 4 out of 10 to America. What did change, however, was the per-

centage distribution within Europe.

heads the European statistics together with the Nether-lands. A look at the SAR statistics with reference to aca-demic disciplines reveals that there is an increasing num-ber of social scientists and humanities scholars amongst the persecuted (see graph on page 15). In terms of coun-tries of origin, Syria took over the lead from Iran in 2016 and now clearly heads the sad statistics for threatened researchers. The data also reveal that ever more Turkish academics are under threat at home (see graph on page 13).

Meral Camcı is one of these. In January 2016, the trans-lation scholar signed an appeal for peace against the bom-bardment of Kurdish territory by the Turkish government. From then on, she and some 2,000 other signatories have been subject to massive pressure. By the end of February 2016, she was given her notice as a professor; later she was arrested and released again after three weeks in custody. With the help of her mentor, the German scholar Dilek Dizdar from the University of Mainz, Meral Camcı received a Philipp Schwartz Fellowship. Since then, she

has been able to stay in Germany and conduct her project on the development of feminist discourse in Turkey from a safe distance. Despite all, Camcı still travels home to do research on the spot and to support the peace movement. Dilek Dizdar is full of admiration for her intrepid col-league. “She campaigns courageously and selflessly for her convictions – this has become quite unusual in the aca-demic world.”

THE DREAM OF PEACEMost of all, Meral Camcı would like to return home to live and work. The Syrian geographer, Mohamed Ali Mohamed, also basically wants to go back, “but only if there is really peace in my country.” Nedal Said in Leipzig dreams of a peaceful future, too. Then he could work for an interna-tional company and sell scientific microscopes in the Mid-dle East – but from a base in Europe.

Whichever way the decision turns out, “refugee researchers can be our best ambassadors,” says Said’s men-tor, Hans-Hermann Richnow. He argues in favour of a spe-cial database bundling the institutes that are willing to host threatened researchers, especially as soon after their arrival as possible. “At the moment, highly-qualified spe-cialists still lose far too much time,” the Leipzig research manager complains. He is just in the process of establish-ing another position for a refugee researcher in his depart-ment – this time in bioinformatics.

T A R G E T C O U N T R I E S of displaced researchers (in per cent)

1

6

2

7

3

8

4

9

5

10

Netherlands (54)

France (5)

Germany (26)

2015 2016

Norway (15)

United Kingdom (4)

United Kingdom (7)

Netherlands (25)

France (5)

Germany (10) Switzerland (9)

Belgium (5)

Sweden (6) Norway (9)

Ireland (4)

Switzerland (6) Sweden (7)

Other (3)

a

a

a

More than 400 universities and research institutions in

39 countries cooperate in this network. The objectives are

to protect threatened researchers and promote academic

freedom. Every year, Scholars at Risk supports hundreds

of researchers by providing fixed-term positions at member

institutions. The network also advises host institutions

and offers on-the-spot assistance for researchers and their

families.

PHILIPP SCHWARTZ INITIATIVEThe initiative grants funding to universities and research

institutions in Germany which host researchers at risk on

a fellowship for a period of 24 months. It was established

in 2015 by the Humboldt Foundation with the support of

the Federal Foreign Office and is co-financed by the

Alfried Krupp von Bohlen und Halbach Foundation, the

Fritz Thyssen Foundation, the Gerda Henkel Foundation,

the Klaus Tschira Foundation, the Robert Bosch Stiftung

and the Stiftung Mercator. Universities applying for fund-

ing are required, amongst other things, to submit a strat-

egy for assisting threatened researchers.

2015: n = 84, 1.9.2014–31.08.2015 2016: n = 98, 1.9.2015–31.08.2016 Number of individuals supported by the Scholars at Risk Network S

ou

rce

: Sch

ola

rs a

t R

isk

Page 19: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

19Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

KEEPING PROSPECTS ALIVE

Whether we think of the civil war in Syria, which has now entered its sixth year, or IS terror, which has spread as far as Europe, or the con-tinuing destabilisation of the Eastern Ukraine – the many crises and conflicts in a world bereft of an over-arching order are occurring thick and fast.

Around the world, more than 60 million people are currently fleeing their countries, more than at any time since the end of the Second World War. They are seeking sanctuary from war and violence, many of them from personal threat and persecution, as well. This is particu-larly true of scientists and scholars, students and intellectuals who are often courageous enough to use their academic work to condemn abuses in their own countries and are therefore a particular target for state violence and oppression. It is thus all the more important to offer these people prospects outside their own countries.

Through the Philipp Schwartz Initiative, we enable persecuted research-ers to continue their work free of threat in order to be able to assume responsibility for a better future in their own countries at a later time. Together with the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, we are send-ing a clear message that protecting persecuted researchers in a con-flict-ridden world is a long-term task that we are specifically addressing with the tools of foreign cultural and educational policy.

Against the backdrop of our own history, Germany has a special responsibility which we are gladly assuming. The man after whom this initiative is named, the Jewish pathologist Philipp Schwartz, had to flee himself in the 1930s: from the National Socialists, from Germany – because he was a Jew. In exile, he founded the Notgemeinschaft deutscher Wissenschaftler im Ausland (Emergency Society of German Scholars Abroad). Thanks to his activities, hundreds of researchers managed to find positions abroad. Thus it is only right and fitting that we should be the ones to help persecuted researchers today.

Just how important this initiative is, becomes even clearer when one hears the moving accounts of the fellows’ personal fates, especially of those like the Syrian professor of geography, Hussein Almohamad from Aleppo, who had to conduct their research under the most extreme conditions and who barely managed to escape with their lives.

I am, therefore, very pleased that, in July 2016, the first 23 fellows received fellowships to start working at German universities and that at the beginning of 2017, over 40 more endangered researchers are due to come to Germany to continue their research here.

The potential this holds for both sides, fellows and universities, is enor-mous. When an archaeologist from Damascus or a social scientist from Düzce conduct research and teach at their host institutions, their own personal experiences help to broaden our horizons and to engender a consciousness for the situation of displaced and threatened researchers.

At the same time, the Philipp Schwartz Initiative offers fellows the opportunity to network, both with one another and internationally, in order to be able to take on responsibility once again when they return home. Hussein Almohamad is a good example: in spring 2016, his host university in Giessen organised a conference on Syria – he himself has become a central point of contact for the network of Syrian geogra-phers it generated. These geographers are engaged in making plans for the reconstruction of Syria when the war comes to an end. Professor Abdulrahman, former Director of the Department of Archaeology at Damascus University, who will spend two years working on research and teaching at the University of Tübingen, also hopes that, one day, he will be able to help rebuild his country’s cultural artefacts destroyed by the IS militias.

The Philipp Schwartz Initiative is just one of several building blocks in our work in cultural and educational crisis situations. Nevertheless, it stands for the freedom of science, the protection of cultural identity, scientific networking and, last but not least, humanity in action. For these reasons, the Philipp Schwartz Initiative makes an indispensable contribution to offering endangered researchers prospects for the future – and as such for their own countries, as well.

“Desperate need prompted us to form a community.” PHILIPP SCHWARTZ

Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the Philipp Schwartz Initiative

Ph

oto

: AF

P /

 Get

ty Im

age

s

Breakfast with refugees from Syria: Foreign

Minister Steinmeier in Berlin in summer 2014

Page 20: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

20 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

FOCUS

Text BARBARA SHELDON

When threatened researchers have fled abroad they need support to find their feet at university once again. Many institutions run special programmes in order to help,

but if they are going to be successful, good will alone is not sufficient.

SAFE HAVEN: UNIVERSITY

Page 21: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

21Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

How does the asylum process work? What sort of help do people who have fled from perse-cution really need? For years, questions like this did not regularly crop up at German uni-

versities or research institutions. The disintegration of the Syrian education and science system has changed all that. Students and researchers are having to flee the country and are seeking a safe haven where they can continue to study and work – not least in Germany. These people bring along valuable skills and knowledge with them. But research institutions and universities also have to cope with their special experiences and problems.

In the last few years, international aid organisations, foundations and funding institutions have launched a raft of initiatives to help threatened researchers from Syria and other countries. You meet representatives of these organisations at conferences and strategy meetings. They are all absolutely determined to do something, even if it can only be a drop in the ocean. Many are totally dedi-cated, working hours that drive them to the very limits of their own capacity. And they are all also plagued by doubt: are we really helping? How can we reach the people who are supposed to benefit from our efforts? Who can we

EXAMPLES OF GERMAN AND EUROPEAN INITIATIVES

To harbour and support students and

researchers from crisis areas is the objec-

tive of various university programmes

which are designed to create better

structures such as additional language

courses and integration measures.

• With its Integra Programme, the Ger-

man Academic Exchange Service pre-

pares academically-qualified refugees

at universities and Studienkollegs (pre-

paratory colleges) to embark on degree

courses. Its Welcome Programme sup-

ports projects run by students who

actively engage with refugees. Both

programmes are financed by the Fed-

eral Ministry of Education and Research.

• With the support of the Federal Foreign

Office, the Alexander von Humboldt

Foundation has created the Philipp

Schwartz Initiative for endangered

researchers (see also box on page 18).

• The European Union’s HOPES Pro-

gramme supports Syrian refugees

searching for a place at university in

Turkey or the Middle East by providing

advisory services and scholarships.

EVERYONE IS DETERMINED TO DO SOMETHING, EVEN IF IT CAN ONLY BE A DROP IN THE OCEAN.

Page 22: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

22 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

FOCUS

cooperate with, who will give us advice, whom can we trust? How can we avoid making mistakes in what is potentially a political minefield?

THE UNIVERSITIES TOOK THE INITIATIVEIn Germany, too, many activities have been started for ref-ugees in the education and research arena. According to statistics published by the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, amongst the refugees who applied for asylum in Germany in 2015, 55 per cent were under 25 and about 80 per cent were under 35. One thing soon became clear: the education sector, in particular, needed to work on solu-tions. Suddenly, the refugees were there, in some cases on campus or living nearby. And the universities took the ini-tiative: guest student status was quickly introduced, librar-ies were opened up and mentoring schemes were created – and one university even ended a long-lasting debate on whether lectures in economics should be held in German or English by simply swapping to English so that refugees could participate.

The science organisations had to take special account of the situation of fully-educated researchers in order to develop suitable support mechanisms for them. Whilst stu-dents have often not made an irreversible decision about their careers, refugee researchers have already chosen aca-demia and spent years preparing for it. So for them the markets for scientific and science-related jobs are particu-larly relevant. This has its advantages: international activ-ities are part of every scientist’s life; many academic dis-ciplines can be practised anywhere and the language of science is often English in the first place. Therefore, in the-ory, researchers can find their feet abroad much faster than

other occupational groups. In most countries, however, the academic job market is restricted.

Against this backdrop, opening up existing positions for endangered researchers would not seem to be the way forward – at least not at present. Take the experience of the European Commission: on their job portal for researchers with job offers from all

over Europe, flags with the caption science4refugees were attached to hundreds of job offers. During the first nine months of operation, however, not a single refugee responded to the announcements on this portal. And the word from the major German science organisations which have opened up their programmes and job offers is that there certainly has not been a run on opportunities for refugees. The Alexander von Humboldt Foundation’s

RESEARCHERS CAN EASLIY FIND THEIR FEET ABROAD – IN THEORY.

EXAMPLES OF GLOBAL INITIATIVES

For decades, globally-active organisa-

tions have been campaigning for endan-

gered researchers from all over the

world – irrespective of whether they have

fled from war or been persecuted in their

own countries.

• The Scholar Rescue Fund grants fel-

lowships to established researchers

whose lives and work are threatened in

their own countries; it also helps uni-

versities to host them.

• The Council for At-Risk Academics

(Cara) has a long tradition reaching back

to the 1930s and 1940s when it cooper-

ated with Philipp Schwartz’s Not gemein-

schaft deutscher Wissenschaftler im

Ausland (Emergency Society of German

Scholars Abroad). Cara mostly finds

positions for at-risk academics in the

United Kingdom but is increasingly

working together with universities in

other countries, as well.

• Scholars at Risk is a global network of

universities that are willing to accept

endangered researchers. The organisa-

tion also seeks to draw attention to

threats to academic freedom (see also

box on page 18).

Page 23: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

23Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

DR BARBARA SHELDON heads

the Alexander von Humboldt Foun-

dation’s Strategic Planning Division,

which developed the Philipp

Schwartz Initiative together with

the Federal Foreign Office.

Philipp Schwartz Initiative with its tailor-made fellowships for threatened researchers, on the other hand, is in great demand.

FROM REFUGEE TO JOB-SEEKER The inference that might be drawn is that endangered researchers need more active support and guidance in mas-tering the transition from being a refugee to participating in the normal employment market. Perhaps we also have to realise that, depending on the country of origin, the general conditions for research may be so different that even highly gifted Syrian researchers, for example, may not have had the opportunity to publish at a level that would make them internationally competitive.

The scientists sponsored under the Philipp Schwartz Initiative are not competing with their German colleagues; their special situation is taken into account. The fellow-ship allows them to work in Germany and get their bear-ings for a period of two years. They may then be lucky enough to find a position within the German science sys-tem. Science-related sectors, such as industrial research, also offer them opportunities. Maybe the next step will take them to a university in another country via the Schol-ars at Risk Network, or perhaps they will be able to return to their own countries at a later stage.

One thing is, however, clear: during the time they spend in Germany, these researchers with their knowledge and experience will certainly benefit their host institutions in no small measure. Meeting them in seminars and lectures will open the eyes of many German students to the fact that academic freedom and freedom of expression are not a matter of course.

EXAMPLES OF ONLINE OFFERS OF AID

Young refugees who are not lucky

enough to gain access to education

where they find themselves can turn to

the internet for a whole range of virtual

courses. There are also online jobs

forums designed to help refugee

researchers find work at universities and

research institutions.

• jamiya.org offers online teaching

opportunities in Arabic to academics

who have fled from Syria and connects

them with European universities and

NGOs.

• In cooperation with partner universities,

kiron.ngo offers the option of learning

via a digital platform. The courses

are tailored to prepare for university

entrance and facilitate a smooth

transition.

• chance-for-science.de is a platform

operated by the University of Leipzig

which connects displaced academics

and students with German universities

and research institutions.

• The European Union’s online portal

science4refugees finds job offers for

endangered researchers across Europe.

Page 24: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

24 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

A slim majority for Brexit: Germany held its breath when this news was announced on the morning of 24 June 2016. Right up to the end, people had believed the predictions that prom-

ised a sizeable majority for the pro-Europeans in the EU referendum. But then almost 52 per cent of Britons opted to leave – for days, this shocking news dominated the head-lines. Europe has still not digested it even now.

Take Rüdiger Görner: he still wakes up some days and simply cannot believe it. The distinguished German liter-ary scholar has lived in England since 1981. He arrived as a student, worked as a researcher, writer, translator and critic, and became a professor of German with Compara-tive Literature. In 2005, he founded the Centre for Anglo-

German Cultural Relations at Queen Mary University of London, which he still heads. And in 2015, his scholarly achievements and services to cultural exchange between the United Kingdom and Germany earned him the Rei-mar Lüst Award, which is granted jointly by the Humboldt Foundation and the Fritz Thyssen Foundation.

A STRIKING LACK OF EDUCATIONTo this day, Rüdiger Görner is fascinated by cosmopoli-tan, liberal Britain with its democratic and cultural tradi-tion. And yet, for years, he has seen cracks appearing in the noble facade. “Above all, there is a striking lack of politi cal education in the population; people are turning their backs on the European idea and foster the danger-

FOCUS ON GERMANY

GOOD FRIENDS DESPITE BREXIT The British are leaving the EU, which could mean that relations with Germany become more important. What could help is that people on the island have a more positive image of the Germans than they used to.

Text LILO BERG

Ph

oto

s: S

hu

tte

rsto

ck/W

ille

eC

ole

Ph

oto

gra

ph

y, iS

tock

ph

oto

/alv

arez

Page 25: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

25Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

ous dream of reviving the Empire.” But, in the last resort, it was an irresponsible government that was to blame for Brexit, a government that had wilfully called a referendum the consequences of which it was completely unable to han-dle. “It’s a political shambles,” says Görner whose exper-tise is in great demand across Europe these days.

Even though millions of Britons are now calling for another referendum, Rüdiger Görner is convinced that Brexit cannot be reversed. He expects the British govern-ment to declare that they are leaving the European Union in the next few months and that negotiations will then begin in earnest. At the same time, agreements will have to be made with all sorts of different countries in order to replace the Brussels provisions with bilateral agreements.

GERMANY, THE HEAVYWEIGHT“Germany will play a privileged role in this,” Görner asserts. The strength of economic relations between the two coun-tries, Germany’s political weight, the many cultural ties – all of this will tend to reinforce the relationship. This was already becoming clear in the months before Brexit. “It was evident that the standard prejudices about Germans were not being dragged out very often,” the cultural scholar reports. Spiked helmets and Nazi comparisons hardly cropped up in the media at all and the government itself had also refrained from employing barbed rhetoric against one of its most important partners.

This reflects the change in the emotional state between the two nations. For decades, Britons responded to ›

Page 26: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

26 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

research would be particularly meaningful. In his opinion, special funding should be made available for this purpose from the European Regional Development Fund.

But what happens when the existing EU funding runs out? After all, at some British research institutions, it accounts for 15 per cent of the annual budget. Will there be a major exodus of researchers, for example to Germany?

Whilst there is some evidence of British researchers head-ing for other English-speaking countries and German col-leagues returning home, there is no indication of a mass emigration as yet.

FOCUS ON GERMANY

“ SPIKED HELMETS AND NAZI COMPARISONS FEATURE LESS OFTEN IN THE MEDIA. REJECTION MODE IS NO LONGER SO WIDESPREAD.”

Germans’ unshakeable anglophilia with unflinching Ger-manophobia. But the 2006 World Cup at the latest marked a departure from rejection mode, according to Rüdiger Görner. “That was when many British fans headed for Ger-many and discovered a relaxed, cosmopolitan country.” And this has been compounded by the Berlin effect that draws thousands of Britons to the hip German capital every year, not to mention the excellent work done by German cultural institutions in the United Kingdom. “What the Goethe Institute, the German Academic Exchange Service and the cultural department of the German Embassy have achieved in the last few decades is unparalleled and even more important now than ever.”

THE CONVERSATION MUST NOT STOPCulture is the catalyst for everything the future holds for Great Britain and Germany, says Rüdiger Görner, more sig-nificant than politics or business. He therefore argues in favour of promoting relevant activities to an even greater extent. “We absolutely have to make sure that the conver-sation between the cultural mediators does not break down.” In this context, the key platforms are the newly-established German Network on the British side and the Centres for British Studies and courses at German universities as well as the British Council, of course, on the German side (see also box on page 27). Görner thinks that joint projects in fields like comparative media research and migration

Page 27: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

27Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

The Reimar Lüst Award Winner PROFESSOR DR RÜDIGER GÖRNER has been living and working

in London for more than 35 years. He is the author

of numerous books including “Streifzüge durch

die englische Literatur” (1998), “Dover im Harz.

Studien zu britisch-deutschen Kulturbeziehungen”

(Dover in the Harz – Studies in Anglo-German

Cultural Relations, 2012) or “London, querstadtein.

Vieldeutige Liebeserklärungen” (2014). Further-

more, he is also the editor of “Angermion. The Year-

book for Anglo-German Literary Criticism, Intellec-

tual History and Cultural Transfers”, published by

de Gruyter. In 2012, Görner was awarded the

Deutscher Sprachpreis (German Language Prize)

by the Henning Kaufmann Foundation.

The GERMAN NETWORK brings

together people in different regions

of Britain who are interested in the

German language as well as the

cultures and economies of German-

speaking countries. Apart from a

comprehensive calendar of events,

the Greater London German Network

(www.glgn.org.uk), for example,

also offers language courses and

functions as a jobs board. The German

Network is funded by the German

Embassy in London.

The CENTRE FOR BRITISH STUDIES

at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin

and similar institutions like the one at

the University of Bamberg focus on

interdisciplinary research and teach-

ing. Many other German universities

offer courses in British literature and

British Studies.

He himself wants to stay in London as long as possible and keep building the big cultural bridge to Germany. He sees great potential in partnerships between cities and regions in the two countries. “There are close networks of relationships in the field of cultural work, but they urgently need to be rejuvenated.” Twinning celebrations such as the 70th anniversaries of prominent city partner-ships like Frankfurt-Birmingham in 2016 and Hanover-

Bristol in 2017 are a good opportunity. Part of the idea is to study the history of such alliances at his centre, Rüdi-ger Görner reports. And some town councils are already considering annual, bi-national conferences on certain major topics. Cementing the friendship between Britons and Germans is apparently a matter of great importance to many – in preparation for the day when Brexit becomes reality.

Page 28: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

28 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Interview KATRIN LANGHANS

Brooke Harrington’s research took her into a world few people ever get to see: she studied wealth managers, who help the rich to hide their money. She spoke to people who only seldom give interviews, let alone divulge tax tricks. In order to get to the heart of the matter, the economic sociologist decided to join them.

CLOSE UP ON RESEARCH

KOSMOS: You spent eight years investigating the off-shore world. What did you discover?HARRINGTON: When you have the specific knowledge, you can hide your money nearly everywhere you want. You just need to be able to use the loopholes in the financial systems. That is where wealth managers come into play: it is their business to help the rich to hide their money.

Why do rich people hide their money?The main reason is some combination of tax avoidance, creditor avoidance and the avoidance of legal judgments related to family, like alimony payments or inheritances.

Are their motives always bad?In the case of people who live in unstable countries you can understand that they don’t want themselves or their families to be kidnapped and blackmailed, so it is in their interest to conceal as much as possible to not get targeted.

In order to study the work of wealth managers, you decided to become one yourself. Why?There wasn’t any way to learn enough about the profession without entering the training programme. Their work changes so rapidly because the laws about taxes change very quickly.

Can anyone do the training programme?Yes, if you are willing to invest £25,000 for the two years of training, including the travel costs to visit workshops, in which you learn the laws of trusts, foundations and cor-porations: where they come from and how you can use them to hide assets.

How come they were willing to allow a researcher to lis-ten in on their secrets?I think because from the beginning they knew who was financing me. I wore a name badge at all times, just like all the other course participants, but mine made clear that I was a member of a research institution. The Max Planck Institute and the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation paid me a salary for the first two years of my study; with-out that support I couldn’t have done this research. In total, I did 65 interviews with wealth managers in 18 countries.

What is your impression? Do wealth managers have a guilty conscience about helping the rich to avoid taxa-tion?Some people believe very strongly in the notion of free markets and they see the freedom to get rich. I asked every-one I interviewed, what is good about your job? And the majority said, I enjoy helping families.

“ YOU CAN OPEN A SHELL COMPANY IN FIVE MINUTES”

Page 29: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

29Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Tax havens like the Bahamas are the piggy bank of the rich. The real Bahamas swimming pigs were released there 200 years ago – today they enter-tain tourists.

Ph

oto

: Fo

tolia

/Ne

jro

n P

ho

to

Page 30: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

30 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

CLOSE UP ON RESEARCH

Rich families who get richer whilst the poor get poorer.Only a few have considered that consequence and for them it was a struggle. I interviewed an accountant who worked for Greenpeace before becoming a wealth man-ager. She said she was troubled by the amount of privileges her clients had.

What kind of privileges?The whole system of western states wasn’t relevant to them. They could just buy their way out of the system. These people don’t even need a passport to travel internationally.

There is this private air system, no passport check, no lug-gage check, you go where you want, when you want.

So is there always a way for rich people to avoid the law?If you are rich enough, probably. There have been notable cases where people have been convicted of crimes. Allen Stanford, for example, who was a very wealthy hedge fund manager in the Caribbean. He got caught; he went to jail for defrauding his clients. But for every conviction I assume there are many more cases where wealthy people can avoid jail. Although tax avoidance gets all the headlines, it is generally more a question of law avoidance.

How do rich people actually go about avoiding the law?At the extreme, you can just buy a different passport and that happens so often that now there is a market for

boutique companies that help wealthy people change citizenship.

Jonathan Ostry, the Deputy Director of the Research Department at the International Monetary Fund, once said that inequality and growth are linked. A society in which wealth is distributed more equally grows faster because inequality reduces the chances of the poor. Wealth managers play into that in the following way: by helping people avoid taxes they are depriving states of their resources to provide things like public education, health care and transportation. And if you are a poor person you need public transportation, you need health care so that you don’t use all your savings when you get sick; you need good education to get a good job one day. States have less money to finance all these things under conditions of mass tax avoidance by the rich.

The rich shift the burden downwards. Everyone has to pay more because states need a basic mini-mum amount to function. So the burden gets shifted to those of us who can’t pay wealth managers to avoid taxes. You and me.

How much extra do we have to pay because of the rich hiding their assets?In the US and other places that amount has been estimated to be 15 per cent. That’s annoying for a middle-class per-son like me, but for a poor person that’s the difference between being able to save up and start a business or not. The countries that suffer the most under prosperity aus-terity are the ones that had the highest rates of tax avoid-ance before the crisis: Greece, Spain, Portugal.

You conducted more than 60 interviews with people all over the world, on the Cook Islands, in South America, on the Seychelles. What was your impression of these places?Many of the offshore tax havens are kind of scary places. Often I felt quite unsafe and that is unusual for me, because I’d travelled a lot by myself before, including the Middle East, and never felt unsafe. There is this idea that when small countries develop things like offshore financial struc-

“ PRIVATE AIR SYSTEM, NO PASSPORT CHECK, NO LUGGAGE CHECK – THEY GO WHEREVER THEY WANT.”

Page 31: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

31Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

tures everything starts to go wrong: the democracy starts to fall apart, crime rates go up, and there is a general kind of moral corruption that goes on.

What do you mean by moral corruption?In my first night on the Cook Islands, for example, I was robbed by someone while I was sleeping with my five-year-old son in the hotel. He took my tablet phone, my only way of communicating with the world. And then the people who were in charge of the accommodation said: too bad, you can’t have your $3,000 back you paid in advance to stay here for a week. Too bad, if you can’t deal with being robbed; there is something wrong with you.

What did you do?I looked for flights but it was too expensive, so I moved to another hotel. The rest of my stay I was looking over my shoulder the whole time. I was very scared. In the course of walking around after the robbery I met a fisherman who said, “Ah, you know, that is why they call us the ‘Crook Islands’.”

The Cook Islands are also known for shell companies. It’s very easy to set up a company online. Why do rich people bother to employ wealth managers?You can open a shell company in five minutes, but in order to use it to your advantage you have to have some special-ised knowledge. If you make a mistake you might go to jail. Rich people pay wealth managers to take those risks

for them. Wealth managers know exactly how to keep you just one centimetre on the right side of the law. They can help you to hide your money, even in countries like the UK or Germany.

Did you interview a German wealth manager?Actually, one of the most interesting people I interviewed was German, a man who had a “von” in his last name. Dur-ing the Second World War his family lost all their land holdings, he had little money. This guy didn’t even go to university, but he was still able to make a great thirty years’ career for himself managing people’s money.

How did he do it?He had the right kind of manners and what sociologists call social capital to make wealthy people want to work with him. He would play polo, go skiing, he would go to the opera and drink champagne. He knew how to behave, one of the things he said was, “You never ever approach a client directly about money, you wait for them to raise that topic.”

Is there anywhere in the world that doesn’t have offshore finance?As far as I learned, Greenland is free from offshore finance. It is sort of a mystery. Why does an island that has noth-ing except whaling not become an offshore tax haven? No one seems to have a good answer to this question. Maybe it hasn’t occurred to them yet.

“ MANY TAX HAVENS ARE SCARY PLACES.”

PROFESSOR DR BROOKE HARRINGTON has been an Asso-

ciate Professor for Sociology at Copenhagen Business School

in Denmark since 2010. After studying English Lite rature at

Stanford University, she read Sociology at Harvard. A Humboldt

Research Fellowship took her to the Max Planck Institute for

the Study of Societies in Cologne. Her research into the

offshore world informed her book “Capital without Borders:

Wealth Managers and the One Percent” which was published

by Harvard University Press in 2016.

Page 32: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

32 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Dav

id A

uss

erh

ofe

r

NEWS

The economy, financial markets, new media, history, and the effects of music: humanities scholars and social scien-tists deal with subjects that are on people’s minds and are of fundamental importance to society. In order to promote international collaborations in these important research fields, the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation grants the Anneliese Maier Research Awards, valued at € 250,000 each.

In September, this year’s awards were presented by the Federal Minister of Education and Research, Johanna Wanka, and the President of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, Helmut Schwarz. “All six researchers receiv-ing this award have one thing in common: they actively seek intellectual exchange,” said Johanna Wanka during her official speech in Berlin’s Auditorium Friedrichstrasse. “We are not, however, just talking about international exchange,” she continued, “but above all about cross-bor-der exchange in their own disciplines.”

In his address, Helmut Schwarz emphasised, “This award is designed to recruit leading researchers from abroad to work together with partners in Germany. It also seeks to pave the way for junior researchers to be integrated at an early stage.” The researchers honoured will spend five

years collaborating with German colleagues. Two of this year’s award winners address economic

issues: Ève Chiapello from France researches, amongst other things, into the consequences of economising social policy whilst Marti G. Subrahmanyam from the United States investigates the regulation of financial markets by the central banks.

Themes such as anger and rage in Homer, and new edi-tions of Greek tragedies are the special focus of the award winner Glenn W. Most, a classicist from Italy, whilst Sum-athi Ramaswamy from the USA, who is considered one of the most multifaceted experts in the field of Asian Stud-ies, examines themes in Indian history.

Two further award winners work in the field of psychol-ogy: the US-American social psychologist E. Tory Higgins studies how opinions shared, for example, by groups – known as shared realities – are influenced by social media. With his work on the reasons for earworms, tunes you get on the brain, the music psychologist Daniel Müllensiefen caused a furore; he is currently investigating how music shapes the development of children and young people (see also page 9).

GREAT THINKERS FOR GERMAN UNIVERSITIES

Anneliese Maier Research Awards granted

Anneliese Maier Research Awards in Berlin: Federal Research Minister Johanna Wanka and Helmut Schwarz, President of the Humboldt Founda-tion, with the award winners 2016

Page 33: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

33Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Fe

lix R

ettb

erg

A Humboldt Colloquium entitled “Bridges to the future: German-Israeli scientific relations” brought together some 200 Humboldt Foundation alumni, junior researchers and invited guests in Tel Aviv in September 2016. The research-ers presented their own research topics to a broadly-based specialist audience and were thus able to inject new momentum into specialist and interdisciplinary networks. Humboldtians, moreover, told young researchers about their experiences in Germany.

The colloquium also focused on issues surrounding the particular opportunities and challenges inherent in Ger-man-Israeli research collaborations: how can science con-tinue to act as a bridge between Germany and Israel in future? What specific role does the Humboldt Network play in German-Israeli cooperation? Since 1958, the Alex-ander von Humboldt Foundation has sponsored about 300 Israeli Humboldtians.

The Alliance of Science Organisations in Germany has launched a new initiative to provide comprehensive and transparent information on research involving experi-ments on animals. The online platform www.tierversuche-verstehen.de features news, background information, reports, films, infographics, interviews and photos on the topic (for the time being in German language only). It will also act as a forum for debate and an expert database. The initiative also uses video clips to broadcast its message on YouTube and @TTVde to break news on Twitter.

The initiative Tierversuche verstehen (Understanding Ani-mal Experiments) is the result of close cooperation between scientists and communication experts. It targets the pub-lic and the media, and sees its mission in promoting the conversation on the necessity and benefits of animal research as well as relevant alternatives.

The Alliance of Science Organisations in Germany addresses matters relating to research policy and funding and the structural development of the German science sys-tem. The members of the Alliance are the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, the German Academic Exchange Service, the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, Ger-man Research Foundation), the Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft, the Helmholtz Association of German Research Centres, the German Rectors’ Conference, the Leibniz Association, the Max Planck Society, the German National Academy of Sciences Leopoldina and the German Council of Sci-ence and Humanities.

UNDERSTANDING ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS

Initiative to inform about experimental animal research

BRIDGES TO THE FUTURE

Israeli and German researchers build networks

Eine Informationsinitiative der WissenschaftTierversuche verstehen

Mathematics, health sciences, linguistics and many more: researchers in the most diverse subjects met at the Humboldt Colloquium in Tel Aviv.

Today, there is a tight network of relations between Ger-man and Israeli researchers. It will be interesting to see how many of the junior researchers who formed an opin-ion of the Foundation and Germany whilst in Tel Aviv, will follow the example set by Israeli Humboldt Alumni.

Page 34: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

34 Humboldt kosmos 106 /2016

If you ever send an email to [email protected], then you will prob-ably get an answer from me. I look after the Humboldt Foundation’s website and make sure that our online presence is easy for everyone to understand and works well. And if you ever have a problem with the login or completing an online form, I do everything in my power to get it sorted as quickly as possible. At the moment, I am particularly involved in setting things up so that applications, nominations and reviews can be submitted online for all the Foundation’s programmes. Watch this space!

I am something of an old stager at the Humboldt Foundation. In fact, I joined the Foundation even before I started studying to become a translator. I have worked in the secretariat for our former Secretary General, Heinrich Pfeiffer, for example, organised the logistics and accompanied some of the study tours around Germany that the

Foundation runs for its fellows, supervised the building of guest houses for foreign researchers at East German universities – never a dull moment.

For some while now, I have been assigned to the Communications Department. What I enjoy most about working here is the particular combination of content work and technical activities. For instance, I am part of the editorial team of Humboldt Kosmos and proofread all the articles for each issue.

Things can get a bit hectic at times as I try to juggle all the different tasks my work involves. This is where long walks with my Australian Shepherd dog Wanja come in. When we are out in the woods around Bonn she makes sure I can switch off and relax – which is often pre-cisely when I get good, new ideas for the website or find just the right solution for a technical problem. Text ULLA HECKEN

MRS @NLINEWho actually does what at Humboldt headquarters? Who are the people behind the scenes making

sure that everything runs smoothly? This page is devoted to the colleagues at the Humboldt Foundation, their lives at work and beyond. TODAY: ULLA HECKEN.

Ph

oto

: Hu

mb

old

t F

ou

nd

atio

n /

 Mic

hae

l Jo

rdan

THE FACES OF THE FOUNDATION

THIS IS WHERE THE ENGLISH

VERSION FINISHES.BITTE WENDEN SIE DAS HEFT,

UM DIE DEUTSCHE FASSUNG ZU LESEN.

Page 35: THREATENED - Alexander von Humboldt Foundation · The photo shows two proud snow-house builders. Block by block we pressed the snow together in a square bucket, stood the blocks one

Ph

oto

: Get

ty Im

ages

 / P

aul N

ickl

en

THIS IS WHERE THE ENGLISH

VERSION FINISHES.BITTE WENDEN SIE DAS HEFT,

UM DIE DEUTSCHE FASSUNG ZU LESEN.