third trimester amniotic fluid as source of mesenchymal...
TRANSCRIPT
Introduction•Stemcell-basedregenerativemedicinewillrevolutionizecurrentapproachesandprovidetreatmentsforavarietyofcurrentlyincurablediseases[Weismann 2000].
•Anumberofstemcelltherapiesalreadyexisttoday,suchastreatingbonemarrowtransplantation,regen-erationandhealingofboneinspinalfusionsurgery[Orhtofix],preventionofacuteGraftvsHostDisease[LeBlanc 2008]andmoretreatmentsareonthehorizon.
•Mesenchymalstemcells(MSCs)havebeenleadingthewayinstemcelltherapydevelopment.AsofDecem-ber2010,over160clinicaltrialswithMSCshavebeenreportedforsuchdiseasesasmultiplesclerosis,autoim-munediseases,diabetes,cardiovasculardisease,Crohn’s,cirrhosis,andotherdiseases[www.clinicaltrials.gov].
•Amnioticfluidisemergingasoneofthemostat-tractivesourcesofMSCswithbroadutilityfortissuecreationandregeneration[Kaviani 2001; t’Anker 2003],andgrowthoftrachea,diaphragm,boneandheartvalveshasbeendemonstrated[Kunisaki 2006; Fuchs 2004; Steigman 2009; Schmidt 2008.]
•Currently,amnioticfluidMSCsarecollectedprimarilyduring2ndtrimestergeneticamniocentesis,thuslim-itingitsbroadavailability.Inthisstudy,weexploredwhetheramnioticfluidcollectedduring3dtrimesterisaviablesourceofMSCsfortherapeuticpurposes
•Ithasbeenpreviouslydemonstratedthat3dtrimesteramnioticfluidcontainsMSCswithcharacteristicssimilartoMSCsfrom2ndtrimesterfluid[You 2009]butprotocolsforcollectionshavenotbeenimplementedandcharacterizationofcellsaftercryopreservationhasnotbeenperformed,andarethemainfocusofourresearch.
Stem Cells – Sources
“Mesenchymal stem cells are poised to be the next major success in cell therapy that could be used to treat
tens of thousand of patients.”—Dr. Jeffrey Karp, MIT/Brigham & Women’s,
December 18th, 2009•MSCsarebecomingthestemcellsofchoiceformanynewtherapeuticdevelopment.
•MSCsarepluripotentstemcellsthatareabletodifferentiateintomanytypesofcellsincludingskin,muscle,neurons,cardiactissue,kidney,liver,cartilage,bone,etc,andarepotentiallyusefulforabroadrangeoftherapeuticapplications[Kaviani 2001; de Coppi 2007.]
•MSCswereinitiallyidentifiedinadultbonemarrow,butlaterwerefoundinothertissues,includingamnioticfluid.
Worldwide Human Clinical Trials with MSCs
160+humantrialsareon-goingworld-widewith5,000+patientsenrolled[Ankrum 2010; www.
clinicaltrials.gov]
Amniotic Fluid is an Attractive Source of MSCs
•AmnioticfluidishighlyconcentratedsourceofMSCs[Caplan 2009; Steigman 2009]•Concentration of mesenchymal cells decreases dramatically
with age, from 1/100 in amniotic fluid, to 1/10,000 in umbilical cord blood, to 1/250,000 – 1/2,000,000 in adult bone marrow
•AmnioticfluidMCSsaregeneticallystableandnon-oncogenic[Miranda-Sayago 2011]
•AmnioticFluidMCSsposseshighproliferationcapacity,solargequantitiesofcellscanbegrownoutofsmallinitialsample
Amniotic Fluid is a Unique Source of MSCs For Tissue Engineering
•Amnioticfluidcellsarehighlyamendabletotissueengineering[Fuchs 2004; Kunisaki 2006; Kunisaki 2007]:•Express high levels of elastin•Resistant to hypoxic (low oxygen) conditions•Posses immunomodulation properties
•2-5ccof2ndtrimesteramnioticfluidissufficienttogenerate100+millionofcellsinseveralweeks–sufficienttosupportsurgicaltissuereplacement/graft[t’Anker 2003, Kunisaki 2006.]
•ProtocolstocollectandcryopreservethesecellshavebeendevelopedfortheapprovalbyFoodandDrugAdministration[Kunisaki 2007; Steigman 2008.]
Ethical Consideration•Thereisnocontroversyorethicaldilemmainamnioticfluidstemcellscollectionandusebecausetheircollectiondoesnotharmthefetus.
“...[amniotic fluid] stem cell source is considered morally licit as it does not require the destruction of
human embryos….and is called by many “the future of medicine.
—L’Osservatore Romano, February 2010
“Amniotic-fluid stem cells underscore the advances in so-called “ethical” stem cells, which hold the potential
to revolutionize medical treatment without being contentious.”
—The Washington Times, December 2009
Figure 1. Tissue Grafts Have Been Grown from Amniotic Fluid MSCs.
WithRecentadvancementsintissueengineering,tis-suesandorganpartscanbecreatedinjustfewweeksandutilizedtotreatconditionssuchasdiaphragmatichernia,trachealatrisia,andasternaldevelopment.
Third Trimester Amniotic Fluid as Source of Mesenchymal Stem Cells for Regenerative ApplicationsLucy Bayer-Zwirello1, Dario Fauza2, Myriam Armant3, Renee Procopio4, Emanuela Roselli5, Gaia Zanna1, Massimiliano Manganini4, Kate Torchilin4, Federico Maggi5, Francesca Grati5, Giuseppe Simoni4,5
1St. Elizabeth Medical Center, Boston, MA, 2Children’s Hospital, Surgery, Boston, MA, 3Immune Disease Institute, Center for Human Cell Therapy, Boston, MA, 4Biocell Center, Medford, MA and Varese, Italy, 5TOMA Advanced Biomedical Assays S.p.A, Varese, Italy
Neuron
Stem Cells
Hematopoie.c stroma
Tenocyte
Osteocyte
Chondrocytes
Muscle Pathway
Neural Pathway
Adpocyte
Skeletal muscle
Smooth muscle
Cardiac muscle
Astrocyte
Oligodendrocyte
Mature Cells
Mesenchymal Stem Cells
Sources: In’tAnker 2003; Modifiedfrom http://hemo-genix.com/the_mesenchymal_stem_cell_system/
Mesenchymal Stem Cells are Pluripotent
MSC
s pe
r Mar
row
Cel
ls
1
2’000’000
1
400’000
1
250’000
1
100’000
1
10’000
1
100 Human MSCs Decline With Age
7
Amnio&c Fluid
Newborn Teen 30 50 80
Pluripotency Prolifera0on Gene0c Stability
Comments
Embryonic To#potent Very High Not stable Ethical considera#on
Fetal Pluripotent High Stable Easily collected from amnio0c fluid, placenta, etc.
Adult Mul#potent or Unipotent
Low Stable O?en, hard to harvest (bone marrow, fat, muscle)
Induced Pluripotent
Pluripotent Varied
Varied Reverse engineered from adult #ssue
(A)DiaphragmaticTendon[Fuchs 2004]
(B)TracheaConstruct[Kunisaki 2006]
(C)BoneGraft[Steigman 2009]
(continue on reverse)
Experimental Methods•IRBApprovalStElizabeth’sHospitalandChildren’sHospitalinBoston(2008-present)
•IRBapprovalStElizabeth’sHospital&BiocellCenter(2010-present)•Allpatientcounseledfirstforamniocentesisforvariousobstetricalindications:
•Fetal Lung Maturity (FLM) amniocentesis•Late Genetic amniocentesis (defined as >20 weeks gestation)•Paternity testing•Twin-to-Twin Transfusion Syndrome and other polyhydramnios
Figure 2. Experimental Workflow
Results and Discussion•78+%ofsamplesfrom3dtrimesterinBiocellCenterstudy,66%ofsamplesfromBostonChildren’sand60%inTOMAstudiesdemonstratedviablecellgrowthinculture(comparedto~95%ofsamplescollectedduring2ndtrimester[TOMA, Biocell Center data])(Table1)
•Thissomewhatlowerpercentage,eventhoughstillimpressivelyhigh,mightbeduetopresenceofothercomponentsintheamnioticfluidatlategestationthatcanaffectviabilityofstemcell(i.e.higherconcentrationoffetallungsurfactant)
•Itisworthnotingthatsuccessrateofstemcellscollectionsfromamnioticfluidcomparesfavorablytootherstemcellcollectionmodalities.Forexample,collectionofumbilicalcordbloodresultsin~50%ofallsamplesproducingsufficientquantitiesofhematopoieticstemcells[National Marrow Donor Program data]
Table 1. Third Trimester Amniotic Fluid Contains Viable MSCs.
•PercentageofsampleswithviableMSCswascomparablebetweenthreegroups,andcanbefurtherimprovedwithbettersamplingandmodifiedculturingtechniques
1 - Total of 60 samples were collected at both 2nd and 3d trimester2 - Some samples for Children’s’ studies were collected using amnio reduction – i.e. 1+ liter of fluid that might have affected the viability studies for MSCs3 – During the initial culture, 7 out of 9 samples showed viable cell growth. During second culture attempt, including modifications to culture protocol, 8 out of 9 (89%) samples produced viable cells, including one of the samples that did not grow during the first culture attempt.4 – Most samples collected just prior to elective C-section.
Results and Discussion (continued)•CellsfromthirdtrimestersampleswereanalyzedbasedonthecriteriaofMSCsdefinedbytheInternationalSocietyofCellularTherapy[Position Paper]:•Fibroblastic morphology•Positive expression of surface markers CD73, CD90 and CD105, and negative expression of surface
markers CD14, CD34, CD45, CD19 and HLA-DR•Differentiation into cells of all three germ layers, such as adipogenic, osteogenic and chondrogenic
lineages•Allculturedsamplesdisplayedcellswithdistinctfibroblasticmorphology,characteristicofMSCs(Figure2,A.)
• TheMSCsphenotypeofcellsin3dtrimesteramnioticfluidwasfurtherconfirmedbyFACSanalysis.AlltestedsampleshadexpressionprofilecharacteristictoMSCs•the positive expression of CD73, CD90 and CD105 surface
molecules•negative expression of hematopoietic markers as CD14, CD34,
CD45, CD19 and HLA-DR •One sample in Biocell Center study had less than 10% of cells
expressing CD90 and 40% of cells e xpressing CD105. Further analysis of this sample is on-going
• Severalsamplesweretestedindifferentiationexperimentsanddemonstrateddifferentiationintoadipogenic,chondrogenicandosteogeniclineages(Figure2,B.)Completedifferentiationanalysisofallcollectedsamplesison-going
Figure 3. Cells from Third Trimester Amniotic Fluid Meet the Defining
Criteria of MSCs (A) Cells cultured from third trimester amniotic fluid have fibroblastic morphology characteristic to MSCs (Biocell Center data)
(B) Third trimester amniotic fluid MSCs can differentiate in cells of adipogenic, osteogenic and chondrogenic lineages (TOMA data)
Conclusions•Itispossibletoisolate,cryopreserveandexpandAF-MSCatlatestagesofgestation.TheyarecomparabletoyoungerAF-MSCscollectedduringsecondtrimester.
•Thirdtrimestersamplesresultinviablestemcellsis78+%,noticeablyhigherthanmethodsofstemcellscollectionsfromothersources(althoughlowerthan~95+%successrateofMSCscollectionfrom2ndtrimesteramnioticfluid.)
•Thisstudyisongoingtocomparesamplingandcellculturetechniquesinordertofurtherimprovethesuccessrateof3dtrimestercollections.
•WeconcludethatthirdtrimesteramnioticfluidcanserveasanovelsourceofhumanMSCsforclinicalresearchandfamilybanking.
References# Samples Collected
Mean GA % Samples with viable MSCs
St E. / Boston Children’s 44 1 34 weeks 66% 2 St. E. / Biocell Center 9 34.5 weeks 78+% 3 TOMA 17 38.5 weeks 60% 4
Collect 20-‐30 cc during amnio for FLM or poly/gene;c
Process and cryopreserve in liquid nitrogen
Thaw cells and culture in MSCs media
Confirm MSC phenotype & viability
St. Elizabeth Hospital / Biocell Center Workflow
St. Elizabeth Hospital / Boston Children’s Hospital Workflow
Collect 10 to 1500 cc during amnio for FLM or poly/gene:c
Processed & spun down
Confirm MSC phenotype & viability
Remove pellets, resuspend in DMEM; then culture
St. Elizabeth Hospital / Boston Children’s Hospital Workflow
Collect 10 to 1500 cc during amnio for FLM or poly/gene:c
Processed & spun down
Confirm MSC phenotype & viability
Remove pellets, resuspend in DMEM; then culture
A.
ADIPO OSTEO CHONDRO B.
CaplanA.I.,WhyareMSCstherapeutic?Newdata:newinsight,JPathol2009;217:318–324ClinicalTrials-www.clinicaltrials.govDeCoppiP.,etal.,Isolationofamnioticstemcelllineswithpotentialfortherapy.NatureBiotechnology,2007,25(1):100-106.Fuchs,J.R.,etal,DiaphragmaticReconstructionWithAutologousTendonEngineeredFromMesenchymalAmniocytes,JournalofPediatricSurgery,2004,9:834-838KavianiA.,etal.,Theamnioticfluidasasourceofcellsforfetaltissueengineering.J.PediatrSurg2001,36:1662-5.KunisakiS.M.,etal.,Fetaltrachealreconstructionwithcartilaginousgraftsengineeredfrommesenchymalamniocytes..JournalofPediatricSurgery,2006,41(4):675-682.KunisakiS.M.,etal.,Tissueengineeringfromhumanmesenchymalamniocytes:apreludetoclinialtrials.J.Pediatr.Surg2007,42:974-9,discussion9-80.KunisakiS.M.,etal.,Acomparativeanalysisofcartilageengineeredfromdifferentpreinatalmesenchymalprogenitorcells.TissueEng.2007,13:2633-44.LeBlanc,K.,etal.,Mesenchymalstemcellsfortreatmentofsteroid-resistant,severe,acutegraft-versus-hostdisease:aphaseIIstudy,Lancet.2008;371:1579-86
Miranda-SayagoJ.M,etal.,Lifespanofhumanamnioticfluid-derivedmultipotentmesenchymalstromalcells,Cytotherapy,2011;EarlyOnline,1–10NationalMarrowDonorProgram-http://www.marrow.org/index.htmlOrthofix-http://www.orthofix.com/products/trinity-evolution.asp?cid=36PositionPaper,InternationalSocietyforCellularTherapy,Cytotherapy2006,8,315-317SchmidtD.,etal.,Cryopreservedamnioticfluid-derivedcells:alifelongautologousfetalstemcellsourceforheartvalvetissueengineering,JHeartValveDis.2008Jul;17(4):446-55SteigmanS.A.,Preclinicalregulatoryvalidationofa3-stageamnioticmesenchymalstemcellmanufacturingprotocol.JournalofPediatricSurgery,2008,43(6):1164-1169SteigmanS.A.,Sternalrepairwithbonegraftsengineeredfromamnioticmesenchy-malstemcells,JPediatrSurg.2009Jun;44(6):1120-6;discussion1126T’Ankeretal.,Amnioticfluidasanovelsourceofmesenchymalstemcellsfortherapeutictransplantation,Blood.2003,102(4),1548-1549.Weissman,I.L.,Stemcells:unitsofdevelopment,unitsofregeneration,andunitsinevolution.Cell,2000.100(1):p.157-68.YouQ.etal.,Thebiologicalcharacteristicsofhumanthirdtrimesteramnioticfluidstemcells.JIntMedRes,2009Jan-Feb;37(1):105-12.