the world between the wars 1921-1941. how involved does the us want to be? isolationism – myth or...
TRANSCRIPT
The World Between the Wars1921-1941
How involved does the US want to be?
Isolationism – myth or realityInterventionism – disarmament &
negotiationThe men who would make policy:
President Sect. of StateWilson (1913-1921) Bainbridge Colby (1920-21)Harding (1921-1923) Charles E. Hughes (1921-25)Coolidge (1923-1929) Frank B. Kellogg (1925-29)Hoover (1929-1933) Henry L. Stimson (1929-33)Roosevelt (1933-1945) Cordell Hull (1933-44)
The pursuit of “independent internationalism”
War between US & Germany ends 1921Naval rankings: Great Brit., US, JapanWashington Disarmament Conference,
1921
“Hughes sank in 35 minutes more ships than all the admirals of the world have sunk in centuries”
Five Power Treaty A battleship ratio was achieved through this ratio:
US Britain Japan France Italy 5 5 3 1.67 1.67
Japan got a guarantee that the US and Britain would stop fortifying their Far East territories [including the Philippines].
Loophole no restrictions on small warships
Nine-Power Pact—a polite endorsement of the Open Door in China
Four-Power Act—abolished the Anglo-Japanese Alliance
European Debts to the US
Dawes Plan (1924)• The problem of Germany– In 1923 Germany could no longer pay
reparations– Hughes sponsored a meeting to deal with the
crisis– The result was the Dawes Plan—Germany’s
reparations payments were reduced, Germany was loaned $200 million
– The limited initial commitment quickly mushroomed into a massive and ongoing obligation to keep the system working
• War debts and loans could be used as diplomatic “tools” – in Europe and elsewhere
Kellogg-Briand Pact (1928)
15 nations dedicated to outlawing aggression and war as tools of foreign policy.
62 nations signed.
Problems no means of actual enforcement and gave Americans a false sense of security.
Economic expansion in Latin America—our sphere of influence
The US military maintained a presence in many Latin American countries such as Haiti
US investments in Latin American doubled between 1924 and 1929
Latin Americans had difficulty repaying the loans in the face of the US tariff barrier
Hoover and the world crisis—Latin AmericaHoover’s goodwill tourRemoval of troops from HaitiRepudiation of the Roosevelt corollary to the
Monroe Doctrine
Hoover and the world crisis—EuropeHoover refused to cancel war debts Instead the Hoover administration focused on
disarmament World Disarmament Conference 1932 resulted
in frustration European countries were worried about
Germany and Italy
ItalyBenito Mussolini and the rise of the Fascist
PartyBy the 1930s the regime became increasingly
militaristic and nationalistic
Germany– The rise of the Nazi Party– By the late 1920s the Weimar Republic had lost
the support of the German people– Adolf Hitler swept into power by 1933• He believed in the superiority of the Aryan
race• He was committed to Lebensraum (Living
Space)• He was pathologically anti-Semitic • He was passionately militaristic
Japan Coup & invade Manchuria (1931) Militarists expand into China (1932) China looking for outside help Japan violates Kellogg Briand & leaves the
League. Hoover wanted no part in an American military
action in the Far East.
Failure of America’s Diplomacy in the Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover years
Based on voluntary cooperation instead of military or economic actions
FDR’s departure from preceding policiesEnds circular system of repayment through loansRejected currency stabilization
agreement@World Econ. ConferenceLaw forbidding Amer. banks from loaning to
defaulting nationsw/in months war repayments stop for good
(except Finland)
FDR Recognizes the Soviet Union (late 1933)
FDR felt that recognizing Moscow might bolster US economy - trade with the USSR
Moscow hoping relations with US might ward off Japanese incursions in the southeast
Pretty much a distrustful strained relationship as neither side really got what it wanted
Uniting the Western Hemisphere. The Good Neighbor Policy
FDR was critical of American intervention in Latin America during the 1920s.
Because of prior American actions, Latin Americans distrusted his sentiments.
This strategy will continue to develop during war Inter-American Conference (Montevideo-1933)
the United States accepted the principle of establishing inter-American relations on the principle of non-interference, which much improved hemispheric relations
US using econ. influence in region rather than military threats
FDR's goals.Halt Europe's drift to war
If war happens – keep US out of direct involvement
World disarmament would accomplish first goal, but Congress resistant to giving FDR right to selectively embargo belligerents and, more importantly, Hitler's desire to rearm Germany and Japanese cancellation of its adherence to the Washington Naval Treaty make war likely
Relations with Great Britain and the Soviet Union
Collapse in disarmament accompanied by deterioration in American relations w/leading anti-Hitler powers, particularly Britain who toyed with the idea of a Japanese alliance (scuttled by extravagant Japanese rearmament demands).
Relations with the Soviet Union, renormalized in 1933, floundered over issues of the Comintern and Russian debts & treatment of American diplomatic personnel in SU
Nye Committee Hearings (1934-1936) The Nye Committee I
investigated idea WW I was needless & US entered so munitions owners could make big profits [“merchants of death.”]
The Committee did charge that bankers (House of Morgan)wanted war to protect their loans & arms manufacturers to make money.
Claimed that Wilson had provoked Germany by sailing in to warring nations’ waters.
Used influence on public sentiment to block FDR’s desire to join world court & move toward increasingly isolationist politics
Neutrality Acts: 1935, 1936, 1937When the President proclaimed the existence of a
foreign war, certain restrictions would automatically go into effect:
Prohibited sales of arms to belligerent nations.
Prohibited loans and credits to belligerent nations.
Forbade Americans to travel on vessels of nations at war
Non-military goods must be purchased on a “cash-and-carry” basis pay when goods are picked up. (in response to arguments that true neutrality was aiding nondemocratic forces – helped GB & Japan because of their merchant marine & hurt Germany & China)
Banned involvement in the Spanish Civil War. Essentially banning all the “things” that dragged
US into WWI
The Quarantine Speech (October 1937)
Roosevelt warned of the threat to US security by Nazi expansion &Japanese aggression in China.
He compared them to an epidemic & urged they be "quarantined" from international community.
Probable purposes of the speech alert American people to the dangers of the
international situation Explore the readiness of the American people to
support some form of boycott against the aggressors--whether moral, diplomatic, or economic.
Reaction to the Quarantine Speech Overseas: British reaction was positive Mixed domestic reaction -vociferous & organized
condemnation from isolationists - recession & hatred of war outweighed hatred of dictators among Americans
Panay Incident (1937) Japan bombed USS
Panay gunboat & threeStandard Oil tankers onthe Yangtze River.
river was an international waterway
Japan apologized, paid US an indemnity, and promised no further attacks.
Most Americans were satisfied with the apology
Showed American public commitment to avoiding war
Fascist Aggression
1935: Hitler denounced the Versailles Treaty & the League of Nations [re-arming!] Mussolini attacks Ethiopia.
1936: German troops sent into the Rhineland. Fascist forces sent to fight with Franco in Spain.
1938: Austrian Anschluss. Rome-Berlin Tokyo Pact [AXIS] Munich Agreement APPEASEMENT
1939: German troops march into the rest of Czechoslovakia. Hitler-Stalin Non-Aggression Pact.
September 1, 1939: German troops march into Poland blitzkrieg WW II begins
1939 Neutrality Act In response to Germany’s invasion of Poland.
FDR persuades Congress in special session to allow the US to aid European democracies in a limited way:
The US could sell weapons to the European democracies on a “cash-and-carry” basis – Neutrality ‘37.
FDR was authorized to proclaim danger zones which US ships and citizens could not enter.
Results of the 1939 Neutrality Act: Aggressors could not send ships to buy US
munitions.
The US economy improved as European demands for war goods helped bring the country out of the 1937-38 recession.
America becomes the “Arsenal of Democracy.”
“America First” Committee
• On September 4, 1940, a group of prominent American Patriots formed an organization known as the America First Committee
• Dedicated to the simple proposition that neither private financial interests, nor foreign governmental influences should come before the welfare of America.
• The struggle was to prevent America from being dragged into another war for another nation's benefit, that of Great Britain.
The Election of 1940 The Third Term Republicans: despite basically isolationist
sentiment nominated an internationalist candidate, Wendell Willkie.
With no heir apparent in the wings (either by happenstance or design), New Deal Democrats defeated opposition led by Vice-President Garner to block a third nomination for FDR (Henry A. Wallace was chosen to replace the "treasonous" Garner).
Wilkie tries to paint FDR as leading us to war (WW didn’t come out against Selective Service Act,Aug. ’40)
Popular vote: 54.8% FDR 44.8% WW“Four Freedoms” inaugural address
War is Progressing
Blitzkrieg Poland, 1940
Evacuation at Dunkirk, 1940
France Surrenders, 1940
Hitler Tours Paris, 1940
Battle of Britain, 1940
The Siege of Leningrad 1941
The Lend-Lease Act Cash and Carry was nearing the limits of its effectiveness in
1940, because British dollar reserves were nearing exhaustion and the effectiveness of the German submarine campaign against the British
In response, FDR proposed "Lend-Lease" in January 1941. The measure authorized the President to sell, transfer, exchange, lend, lease, or otherwise dispose of war equipment or other material to foreign governments whose defense the president deemed vital to American national security
The proposal brought a bitter isolationist response, but Congress still passed the bill in March 1941
“Lend-Lease” Act (1941)
• Great Britain.........................$31 billionSoviet Union...........................$11 billionFrance......................................$ 3 billionChina.......................................$1.5 billionOther European.................$500 millionSouth America...................$400 millionThe amount totaled: $48,601,365,000
• Consequences.
Lend-Lease committed the United States economically to the defense of Great Britain, but also a naval commitment to insure the safe arrival of supplies.
FDR sent American forces to Greenland and Iceland to bolster the North Atlantic lifeline and strengthen Western Hemisphere defenses.
FDR's sentiment that Britain still might defeat the Nazis without American military intervention and lack of preparedness dictated his course
Tripartite Pact, September 1940
Loose defensive allianceEmboldened Japanese aggression
Kurusu, Ciano, Hitler
Atlantic Charter, August 1941No military commitment“common principles” for “a better future
for the world”Right of determination
Access to raw materials & trade
Economic cooperation
“final destruction of Nazi tyranny”
disarmament
Road to war President Roosevelt had banned all exports of scrap iron, steel
and oil to Japan. The reason for the embargo was the Japanese invasion of China.
Japan had lost more than 90% of its oil supply. This crippled their economy and military.
The belief that Western powers were hostile to Japan.
The United States wanted Japan to withdraw from Indo-China.
The US opposed Japanese expansion and Japan’s demands were not being achieved by diplomacy.
The Japanese were keen on expanding their empire and had to make a decision between surrendering or going to war with the United States.
They wanted the US to acquiesce to their expansion into Asia.
Pearl Harbor – Dec. 7, 1941
Pearl Harbor from cockpit of Japanese plane
FDR Signs the War Declaration
December 7th, a date that will live in infamy
