the supreme court of mauritius hearing... · 4 on tuesday 28th march 2017 114559 (5a/72/17) ireo...

35
THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS ON MONDAY 27 TH MARCH 2017 1363 (6B/16/16) Omnicane Limited & Anor v.s A R Fowdar & Anor Merits 107937 (5C/18/13) Mauritius Post Limited v.s Blue Penny Museum & Anor Merits 114083 (5A/331/16) Mr P Luchun v.s The State of Mauritius Arguments 8964 (3/89/16) The Director of Public Prosecutions v.s T P J M Lagesse & Ors Merits 8859 (3/137/15) Director of Public Prosecutions v.s J J K Carly Merits 6818 (4/28/15) D Deville v.s J I Hector Merits 79175 (1/543/02) M Ramdoo & Ors v.s The State Bank of Mauritius Mention/Stand (at 10.15 am) 113421 (5A/182/16) P J F Guimbeau v.s The Employment Relations Tribunal Arguments (at 1.30 pm) 8757 (3/35/15) A K Jhungee v.s State of Mauritius Merits 8847 (3/125/15) O J B W Saydraouten v.s The State Merits CS 10/16 The State v.s D Ross & Ors Mention (at 10.00 am) CS 1/17 The State v.s S Cheetamun Ruling/Mention (at 10.00 am) CS 12/16 The State v.s T S Agathe Hearing (at 10.00 am) RC 1/17 Ex-Parte:- The Honourable Attorney General Hearing (at 10.00 a.m)

Upload: others

Post on 20-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS

ON MONDAY 27TH MARCH 2017

1363

(6B/16/16)

Omnicane Limited & Anor v.s A R Fowdar & Anor Merits

107937

(5C/18/13)

Mauritius Post Limited v.s Blue Penny Museum & Anor Merits

114083

(5A/331/16)

Mr P Luchun v.s The State of Mauritius Arguments

8964

(3/89/16)

The Director of Public

Prosecutions

v.s T P J M Lagesse & Ors Merits

8859

(3/137/15)

Director of Public

Prosecutions

v.s J J K Carly Merits

6818

(4/28/15)

D Deville v.s J I Hector Merits

79175

(1/543/02)

M Ramdoo & Ors v.s The State Bank

of Mauritius

Mention/Stand

(at 10.15 am)

113421

(5A/182/16)

P J F Guimbeau v.s The Employment

Relations Tribunal

Arguments

(at 1.30 pm)

8757

(3/35/15)

A K Jhungee v.s State of Mauritius Merits

8847

(3/125/15)

O J B W Saydraouten v.s The State Merits

CS 10/16 The State v.s D Ross & Ors Mention

(at 10.00 am)

CS 1/17 The State v.s S Cheetamun Ruling/Mention

(at 10.00 am)

CS 12/16 The State v.s T S Agathe Hearing

(at 10.00 am)

RC 1/17 Ex-Parte:- The Honourable Attorney General Hearing

(at 10.00 a.m)

Page 2: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

2

ON MONDAY 27TH MARCH 2017

MOTIONS/FORMAL MATTERSBEFORE HON. AG. CHIEF JUSTICE

IN CHAMBERS AT 10.00 A.M IN COURT NO.1

113517(1/445/16)

M J Allas v.s L P M Ribet & Ors Mention

113829(5A/273/16)

Teyliom Telecom & Ors v.s Director General, The Mauritius Revenue Authority & Ors

Do

114223(5A/357/16)

Sir C A Hohn) v.s Mr M M O N Oosman & Ors Do

114323(5A/13/17)

Bus Owners Co-Operative Society (North) Limited

v.s The Ministry of Public Infrastructure and Land Transport (Land Transport Division) & 5 Ors

Do

114353(5A/18/17)

Mrs Jogeeta Boyjonauth v.s APAC Services Ltd & Ors Do

114449(5A/43/17)

P R P Gellé v.s N Venkitachalamiyer Do

114522(5A/60/17)

J D Peten v.s F M C Le Breton de la Vieuville Ah Youne

Do

114553(5A/66/17)

I J C Planteau de Maroussem & Anor

v.s Societe des Deux Intendances & Ors Do

114554(5A/67/17)

A R Imambacccus & Anor v.s The Mauritius Commercial Bank Ltd & Ors

Do

114580(5A/75/17)

S Sunasee v.s M H Shamtally Do

114579(5A/74/17)

Oriental Treasures Ltd v.s Mrs N Chong & Anor Do

114583(5A/78/17)

M B Doolhur & Anor v.s Mrs P Audit Do

112231(5A/215/15)

A P Wilson v.s Standard Bank Trust Company (Mauritius) Limited and Ors

Do

114080(5A/328/16)

Standard Bank Trust Company (Mauritius) Limited

v.s A P Wilson & Ors Do

114088(5A/336/16)

F Barles v.s The Mauritius Commercial Bank Limited

Do

Page 3: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

3

114509(5A/55/17)

K Maureemootoo & Anor v.s Aamil Portfolio Management Ltd & Ors Mention

114584(5A/79/17)

M R Bissessur v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

114628(5A/82/17)

The Public Service Commission

v.s Public Service Appeal Tribunal & Ors Do

8841(3/119/15)

V Bissoon v.s The State Do

Page 4: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

4

ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017

114559

(5A/72/17)

Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention

(at 10.15 am)

1399

(6B/53/16)

Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention to follow

SCR 114559 –

5A/72/17

(at 10.15 am)

6870

(4/41/16)

Ireo Fund 1 Ltd (In

Liquidation)

v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention to follow

SCR 114559 –

5A/72/17

(at 10.15 am)

113940

(5A/291/16)

Sir C A Hohn & Anor v.s Ireo Fund 1 Ltd Mention to follow

SCR 114559 –

5A/72/17

(at 10.15 am)

113042

(5A/87/16)

K Takoordyal v.s National Transport

Authority & Anor

Merits

113045

(5A/90/16)

New Mauritius Hotels-

Plaisance Catering Ltd

v.s The Employment

Tribunal & Anor

Disposal

(at 10.15 am)

113318

(5A/154/16)

V Sanassy v.s S Thandrayen & Anor Mention

113922

(5A/284/16)

P T Jones v.s S B Sahebjam Arguments

110930

(1/624/14)

Heirs of Late A Gaungoo v.s R Gaungoo Stand/Disposal

107462

(1/675/12)

J A Bassy v.s D Francoeur & Anor Arguments

99728

(1/650/07)

Mrs M C S Ribet & Ors v.s M G P Ribet & Ors Final Disposal

(at 10.15 am)

101876

(1/704/08)

D Ramful v.s The Central Water

Authority & Ors

Merits

96499

(1/108/07)

B F M Toona Nanak &

Ors

v.s A Seekundur & Ors Mention/Disposal

(at 10.00 am)

Page 5: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

5

109588

(1/233/14)

F Toona Nanak & Ors v.s A Sekender & Ors Mention/Disposal

(at 10.00 am)

102633

(1/279/09)

M Pillai & Ors v.s Valetta Murugan

Society & Ors

Merits

102984

(1/451/09)

J Dooblad v.s U Sookhary & Ors Continuation

76140

(1/753/01)

P Raghoo & Ors v.s I Soomaroo & Ors Merits

106483

(1/140/12)

A Dudhee & Anor v.s M Dudhee Merits

104131

(1/296/10)

V Jharee v.s V Alkoree Disposal

85072

(1/255/04)

M Kaurooa v.s The Commissioner

of Police & Anor

Continuation

111365

(1/86/15)

ABC Datacall Ltd v.s C Bohu & Ors Mention

(at 10.00 am)

(In Chambers)

112121

(1/428/15)

B S Bhaugeerutty v.s Swan General Ltd Merits

112119

(1/426/15)

R Seebaru & Anor v.s Swan General Ltd Merits

114180

(1/688/16)

P S Rampoortab v.s Swan Insurance Co. Ltd Merits

108814

(1/647/13)

I Timol & Ors v.s Modern Building

Investment & Anor

Arguments

111779

(1/276/15)

D Ramrichia v.s A Choonucksing

& Anor

Merits

109885

(1/394/14)

J J Patel & 68 Ors v.s Dynamic India Fund III &

Ors

Arguments

(at 1.30 p.m)

Page 6: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

6

ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017

FORMAL MATTERS BEFORE HIS HONOUR AG DEPUTY MASTER & REGISTRAR AT 9.30 A.M IN COURT NO. 3

75357

(1/599/01)

B Jugduth & Ors v.s A Lamoureux & Ors Mention

88337

(1/112/05)

Heirs of late Mrs C

Matadeen & Ors

v.s S Kishtoo & Ors Do

100058

(1/726/07)

Mrs L David & Ors v.s Honourable G Gunness & Ors Do

100646

(1/254/08)

L F C Wong Min Fong v.s Centre Gaming House Ltd &

Ors

Do

101523

(1/571/08)

C Marday v.s Dr B P Naiken & Anor Do

101337

(1/508/08)

T K T Tang Sing Cheong

& Anor

v.s A S Kadarally & Ors Do

103149

(1/537/09)

R Akkulugadu v.s Rosco Limitée (In Liquidation)

& Ors

Do

103371

(1/658/09)

A S Nassur v.s M Dowlut & Ors Do

103121

(1/519/09)

Separation Scientific

(Mauritius) Ltd

v.s Dr B C Gowreesunkur Do

103542

(1/742/09)

Beresford Trust &

Corporate Services

Limited

v.s G Dalton Do

103947

(1/187/10)

D Dookhy & Ors v.s S Callychurn & Ors Do

104097

(1/272/10)

D Dookhun & Anor v.s V Bijloll & Anor Do

105460

(1/306/11)

V A Montocchio v.s G G Y Montocchio & Ors Do

106492

(1/145/12)

M V Ramseeran & Ors v.s L R Beaux Yeux & Ors Do

Page 7: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

7

107400

(1/642/12)

D Naik & Anor v.s State Bank of Mauritius Mention

112163

(1/447/15)

SBM Bank (Mtius) Ltd v.s Mr D P P Avrillon & Anor Do

107410

(1/649/12)

M S Kistnamah v.s S Bhurosah & Ors Do

108323

(1/390/13)

Mrs S Seetamonee & Ors v.s Mrs N Lobogun & Ors Do

108438

(1/439/13)

R P Dassruth v.s Femi Publishing Co. Ltd & Ors Do

108663

(1/560/13)

M F Harel & Ors v.s Ww M T J Mathieu & Ors Do

108803

(1/642/13)

Med Point Ltd v.s ICAC Do

110669

(1/487/14)

Côte Ouest Audiovisuel

Maurice

v.s M A Dearham Do

108388

(5A/199/13)

The District Council of

Grand Port

v.s J A Monneron Do

110801

(1/553/14)

S Lachkar v.s K R Mooten Do

110816

(1/560/14)

C A Croot v.s Pierre Sports Diving Ltd & Ors Do

110874

(1/591/14)

H Aubdool v.s B N Dookhun & Anor Do

110994

(1/665/14)

Rameshwarnath Society v.s V Moothoosawmy Maistry &

Ors

Do

111139

(1/721/14)

A F Mallam Hassam v.s P K Dash Do

|108991

(5A/3/14)

Dr H B Chittoo v.s The University of Technology,

Mauritius

Do

109361

(5A/95/14)

B A Athar Saib v.s S Appadoo Do

1219

(6B/4/14)

Torenia Impex Ltd v.s Best Luck (Mtius) Ltd (In

Receivership) & Ors

Do

111264(1/23/15)

Ww V R Ittoo v.s Ww R Ittoo & Ors Do

Page 8: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

8

111725

(1/238/15)

C Poonith v.s National Transport Corporation

& Anor

Mention

111746

(1/251/15)

Ww Z Chinapyel & Anor v.s S Chinapyel & Ors Do

111770

(1/267/15)

N A Soodhun v.s State Insurance Company of

Mauritius Ltd

Do

112052

(1/381/15)

Central Electricity Board v.s N D L C Coquet Do

112071

(1/388/15)

A D Toolsy v.s R Dajee & Ors Do

112137

(1/436/15)

V Canhye v.s Sumida Ltd Do

112197

(1/461/15)

The Mauritius

Commercial Bank Ltd

v.s R Ramdoyal & Ors Do

112222

(1/476/15)

B Pandea v.s Mansuy & Ors Do

112278 (Ter)

(1/505/15)

Sam Musique & Anor v.s District Council of Flacq &

Ors

Do

112281

(1/509/15)

K K Bhoyroo v.s A Auleear Do

112303

(1/518/15)

S P Patpur & Anor v.s British American Hospitals

Enterprise Ltd & Anor

Do

112304

(1/519/15)

R Mohun & Anor v.s S Somary & Anor Do

112311

(1/526/15)

M F Mosafeer v.s B Z N Owasil & Anor Do

112343

(1/540/15)

A Appalsawmy & Anor v.s K Rungee & Anor Do

112420

(1/571/15)

Maryven (Mtius) Ltd v.s Swan General Ltd Do

112435

(1/582/15)

L C J Antoine v.s B Bissendary & Ors Do

112475

(1/605/15)

The Honourable J R

Dayal

v.s Honourable Dr A Boolell Do

112557(1/654/15)

B K Panray Ramchurn & Anor

v.s P Sumbal & Ors Do

Page 9: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

9

112572

(1/661/15)

K Pichha v.s R Pichha & Ors Mention

112615

(1/13/16)

E M C Solvery v.s M J S Frivet Do

112642

(1/24/16)

H Chundunsing v.s La Sentinelle Ltée & Ors Do

112681

(1/30/16)

B C J L Bègue & Anor v.s M B N Maingard & Ors Do

112709

(1/36/16)

G S Domingue & Ors v.s M F Banymadhoo Do

112712

(1/39/16)

U Badry v.s Epi De Dieu Ltee & Anor Do

112720

(1/46/16)

The Mauritius Civil

Service Mutual Aid

Association Ltd

v.s K Ramloll & Anor Do

112742

(1/64/16)

J F G Veerasamy &

Anor

v.s Phoenix Insurance Co Ltd &

Anor

Do

112803

(1/83/16)

M L. I Baumann v.s The Riviere Du Rempart

District Council

Do

112842

(1/106/16)

E G Hart De Keating &

Anor

v.s A Macbeth & Ors Do

112862

(1/114/16)

Vacoas Popular Multi-

Purpose Cooperative

Society Ltd

v.s J C Germain Do

112875

(1/127/16)

Vacoas Popular Multi-

Purpose Cooperative

Society Ltd

v.s P D Anthony Do

112883

(1/135/16)

Vacoas Popular Multi-

Purpose Cooperative

Society Ltd

v.s S A N Jaulim & Anor Do

112889

(1/140/16)

M P M Hurrhungee v.s R N Paupiah Do

112890

(1/141/16)

Central Water Authority v.s Denim de l'Ile Limited Do

113028(1/208/16)

S Pareatumbee v.s The Mauritius Tamil Temples Federation

Do

Page 10: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

10

113071

(1/227/16)

Dr R Munbodh & Anor v.s Work Your Wealth Ltd & Ors Mention

113078

(1/232/16)

N Appadoo v.s Swan Insurance Co. Ltd & Ors Do

113094

(1/233/16)

Mr S

Lutchmeenaraidoo,GCS

K

v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Do

113103

(1/235/16)

S Golapkhan & Anor v.s R Jugoo & Anor Do

113106

(1/238/16)

M Dauhoo v.s Sheik Al Ghilane Society Do

113107

(1/239/16)

Y Koonjul v.s C Aubeeluck & Anor Do

113109

(1/245/16)

C Bhuwanee v.s S Auhammud & Anor Do

113118

(1/250/16)

N Chummun & Anor v.s S Moothoocurpen & Anor Do

113148

(1/264/16)

Mr. G Ramlugan v.s Mrs. S D Ramrakha & Ors Do

113153

(1/266/16)

G R Beedassy v.s Deramann Management

Company Limited

Do

113160

(1/269/16)

M R C Uteem v.s S Soodhun Do

113165

(1/274/16)

C C Arekion v.s M C J Jacquin & Ors Do

113167

(1/276/16)

The Honourable S

Soodhun

v.s Honourable R M Uteem Do

113173

(1/280/16)

M B Hosenbocus & Ors v.s A K B Y Hosenbocus & Anor Do

113182

(1/288/16)

N Delhomme v.s T S Jamodhee Do

113219

(1/305/16)

Isabelle Anne-Catherine

Mathilde Baronne De

Traux De Wardin

v.s B D'Hotman De Villiers &

Anor

Do

113222(1/308/16)

M L Young Chuan Yen & Ors

v.s Huan Xiong & Ors Do

Page 11: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

11

113222 (BIS)

(1/311/16)

D Ghoora & Ors v.s H Ghoora Mention

113241

(1/315/16)

S A Jaumdally & Anor v.s M S E N Appadoo & Ors Do

113294

(1/347/16)

L M C Sauzier & Anor v.s The Central Water Authority Do

113300 (Bis)

(1/349/16)

H Gunesh v.s The District Council of Flacq Do

113363

(1/371/16)

S Reesaul & Anor v.s I Rambojun Do

113406

(1/394/16)

K Dookun v.s Engen Petroleum ( Mauritius)

Limited

Do

113424

(1/403/16)

Mauritius Civil Service

Mutual Aid Association

Ltd

v.s R Imrith & Ors Do

113475(Bis)

(1/425/16)

S Shanmuganaden v.s V Payen Do

113537

(1/450/16)

Eastern Stone Crusher

Ltd (ESCL) & Ors

v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Do

113694

(1/474/16)

Kim-Fee Lee Shing Fong v.s H Mungrah Do

113700

(1/476/16)

S Boholah & Ors v.s S Jagessur & Ors Do

113703

(1/477/16)

V Jugun & Ors v.s G Chumbit Do

113797

(1/507/16)

B C D Pecile v.s M E B Seeyave & Anor Do

113860

(1/542/16)

Central Electricity Board v.s K Nobeen Do

113863

(1/545/16)

Eastern Stone Crushers

Ltd

v.s H Dowlut Do

113936

(1/580/16)

A P Marie v.s Marine Biotechnology

Products Ltd

Do

113943

(1/582/16)

J C Lillah & Anor v.s Mauritius Union Assurance

Co. Ltd

Do

Page 12: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

12

113950

(1/588/16)

C Karl Rosse v.s Deep River Beau Champ

Milling Company Limited c/o

Alteo Milling Company

Limited

Mention

114070

(1/649/16)

Kiddy Land (Indian

Ocean) & Co. Ltd

v.s State Property Development

Co Ltd

Do

114258

(5C/75/16)

Real Estates

International SA-SPF

v.s GMG Trust Ltd & Ors Do

114259

(5C/76/16)

Real Estates

International SA-SPF

v.s GMG Trust Ltd & Ors Do

9030

(3/8/17)

District Council of

Riviere du Rempart

v.s V Meeheelaul Do

6880

(4/1/17)

Food Paradise Co Ltd v.s The Permanent Secretary,

Ministry of Health and Quality

of Life & Anor

Do

6886

(4/7/17)

D M Ramcheran v.s L Mahadoowa & Anor Do

114440 (Bis)

(5C/6/17)

A Wally & Son Co. Ltd v.s Ramsaha & Co. Ltd Do

79477

(1/611/02)

S Nawosah & Ors v.s Heirs L Nawosah & Ors Do

99972

(1/703/07)

T Dawoodarry v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

100889

(1/351/08)

Ducray Lenoir Ltd v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

101346

(1/509/08)

J P Haulkory v.s K E Haulkory & Ors Do

108838

(1/662/13)

J P Haulkory & Anor v.s K E Haulkory & Ors Do

101524

(1/572/08)

A K Phokeerah & Ors v.s D S Dhoneeram & Ors Do

104237

(1/355/10)

The State of Mauritius v.s R Randha & Ors Do

105660

(1/397/11)

A K Ghallu v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

Page 13: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

13

105948

(1/543/11)

B S Burahee & Ors v.s S R Ossenbox & Ors Mention

106364

(1/66/12)

A Beebeejaun & Ors v.s Seayu Ltd & Ors Do

107149

(1/522/12)

D Mooken & Ors v.s G R Mooken & Ors Do

107194

(1/541/12)

Sport Data Feed Ltd v.s The Automatic Systems Ltd &

Anor

Do

107593

(1/13/13)

A Treebhoowon v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

107799

(1/122/13)

R Doger De Speville v.s Les Creolias Holdings Ltd &

Ors

Do

108602

(1/519/13)

L Imrit & Ors v.s The Curator of Vacant Estates

& Ors

Do

109120

(1/58/14)

La Société de l’Histoire

de l’Ile Maurice & Ors

v.s The Ministry of Education &

Human Resources & Ors

Do

108177

(1/322/13)

K C Papas & Ors v.s Bank of Mauritius & Anor Do

108194

(5A/157/13)

K C Papas & Ors v.s Bank of Mauritius & Ors Do

114352

(5A/17/17)

Barclays Bank Mauritius

Limited & Anor

v.s Kleantis Constantinos Papas &

Ors

Do

108760

(1/621/13)

D Narayanen v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

109247

(1/115/14)

Mr D Subratty & Anor v.s Maubank Ltd & Ors Do

109337

(1/161/14)

R Burosee & Ors v.s D Burosee & Ors Do

111262

(1/21/15)

M A Mohit v.s D Pannoo & Ors Do

112745

(1/67/16)

A Jogeea v.s A Ramjatan & Ors Do

112821

(1/93/16)

I Mudon v.s V M Seeam & Ors Do

112919(1/156/16)

J J Prudence v.s H W R Prudence & Ors Do

Page 14: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

14

113069

(1/226/16)

B Deenoololl & Ors v.s S Luckhoo & Ors Mention

113174

(1/281/16)

Ww M H B Trompeuse v.s J C B Trompeuse & Anor Do

114163

(5A/348/16)

Societe Agricole Mont

sur Mont

v.s Baie du Cap Estates Ltd & Ors Do

8905

(3/30/16)

D Kistoo v.s The State Do

9008

(3/133/16)

R Ramlugun v.s The Commissioner of Police Do

9031

(3/9/17)

E Y Amode v.s The State of Mauritius Do

9032

(3/10/17)

M Dilloosing v.s The State Do

89239

(1/247/05)

Mrs Ww S Appanah &

Ors

v.s M Chenadoo & Anor Do

100447

(1/165/08)

R Mathoorasingh v.s D Brand Do

103312

(1/626/09)

L X Pel & Anor v.s Victory Exports Ltd & Ors Do

104857

(1/681/10)

S A D Rutteea & Anor v.s A Heerah & Ors Do

105502

(1/325/11)

A K Ramdin & Ors v.s The Mauritius Cane Industry

Authority & Ors

Do

105607

(1/376/11)

Mr A Rashid Mir & Ors v.s Island Blyth Ltd & Ors Do

106615

(1/227/12)

R Seerkissoon & Ors v.s H Aubeeluck & Ors Do

107490

(1/689/12)

M G V Thevenau v.s Blychem Ltd Do

108188

(1/328/13)

Mrs Y Purang v.s Outremer Telecom Ltée Do

81786

(1/360/03)

Innodis Ltd v.s C Madayah Do

110945(5A/273/14)

S Beeharry v.s Sugar Industry Labour Welfare Fund & Ors

Do

Page 15: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

15

110968

(5A/279/14)

I Ruchaia-Pudaruth &

Ors

v.s The Public Bodies Tribunal &

Ors

Mention

111275

(1/31/15)

Ramsaha & Co Ltd v.s The State of Mauritius Do

112363

(1/550/15)

San Marino v.s The Mauritius Post &

Cooperative Bank Ltd

Do

8907

(3/32/16)

M R A F E Peermamode v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

8911

(3/36/16)

J Casimir v.s The State Do

8912

(3/37/16)

J Casimir v.s The State Do

114044

(5A/322/16)

The Minister of Housing

& Lands

v.s The Board of Assessment &

Ors

Do

105976

(1/559/11)

Anderson Ross Holdings

Ltd & Ors

v.s The ICAC & Ors Do

106266

(1/26/12)

J H Cleopatre Ltd v.s A Sanz Do

110907

(1/612/14)

I Perrine v.s The Registrar of Civil Status &

Ors

Do

1396

(6B/50/16)

A Shanto & Anor v.s D Sunnassee & Ors Do

114404

(1/39/17)

Reziztans ek Alternativ v.s The State of Mauritius & 23

Ors

Do

98326

(1/404/07)

R Reetun v.s The Central Water Authority Do

103861

(1/135/10)

Central Water Authority v.s Joint Venture Besix Gamma

Civic

Do

105786

(1/454/11)

Joint Venture Besix

Gamma Civic

v.s New India Insurance Co Ltd &

Ors

Do

105428

(1/288/11)

A Habeboolla v.s M Mohanut & Ors Do

107588

(1/8/13)

Société Face-Aux-Iles v.s A G E Desvaux De Marigny Do

110791(1/544/14)

M M Pampusa v.s A Toorabally Do

Page 16: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

16

111992

(1/350/15)

TRIO STAR Co Ltd &

Anor

v.s D Doorbir & Anor Mention

114397

(5A/29/17)

Mr B K Bhunjun v.s Mr A Bhunjun Do

87842 (Bis)

(1/27/05)

H Gopall v.s L Gopall & Ors Do

102556

(1/232/09)

R Sungkur & Ors v.s K Daby & Ors Do

102711

(1/304/09)

G Teckah v.s B Tribhowon & Ors Do

105961

(1/550/11)

Indigo Marketing

Company Limited

v.s The Ministry of Health and

Quality of Life & Ors

Do

107193

(1/539/12)

Le Hameau Limitée &

Ors

v.s A A A Ebrahim & Ors Do

108976

(1/743/13)

N Dulloo v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

110888

(1/603/14)

A A K Mustun & Anor v.s J D Vilar & Ors Do

111553

(1/161/15)

D Gunesh & Anor v.s R A Bungaree & Ors Do

112322

(1/532/15)

Ww S Samjawon &

Anor

v.s K Samjawon & Anor Do

112502

(1/616/15)

S G Nunkoo v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

111840

(5A/143/15)

V Saurty v.s The Public Bodies Tribunal &

Ors

Do

113323

(1/353/16)

P L I Anthony & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

113508

(1/441/16)

D Khodabux & Anor v.s M N Khodabux & Ors Do

113662 (Ter)

(1/463/16)

The World of Furniture

Ltd & Anor

v.s The Mauritius Revenue

Authority & Ors

Do

114033

(1/623/16)

Trionex Development

Ltd

v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

114036 (Bis)(1/628/16)

R Bokhoree v.s S D Chavrimootoo & Ors Do

Page 17: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

17

114057 (Bis)

(1/639/16)

B Sewruttun v.s B Sewruttun & Ors Mention

114286

(1/738/16)

O K Dobory & Anor v.s V Saneechur & Anor Do

113431

(5A/183/16)

W Jeeawody & 7 Ors v.s The Ministry of Industry,

Commerce and Consumer

Protection & Anor

Do

113667

(5A/213/16)

D Napal v.s The Public Bodies Appeal

Tribunal & Anor

Do

113769

(5A/250/16)

Sport Data Feed Ltd v.s Value Plus Ltd & Ors Do

113925

(5A/287/16)

M A Z Fokeerbux & 24

Ors

v.s The Ministry of Health &

Quality of Life & Ors

Do

114354

(5A/19/17)

Dr Reshiana Rumzan v.s Public Service Commission &

Ors

Do

114489

(5A/49/17)

B Sobrun & 2 Ors v.s Best Food Distributors Co. Ltd

& Ors

Do

76076

(1/739/01)

R Moneeram & Ors v.s Societe des Plantations de

Bois Chéri

Do

107734

(1/87/13)

Mecatronics Ltd v.s The Government of Mauritius

& Ors

Do

110987

(1/658/14)

D Deerpaul v.s S Daby & Ors Do

113161

(1/270/16)

L K Dumar v.s The Ministry of Housing and

Lands & Ors

Do

113250

(1/322/16)

K K Kawol v.s P J Milap Do

112168

(5A/194/15)

M I Santally v.s The University of Mauritius &

Ors

Do

ON WEDNESDAY 29TH MARCH 2017

PUBLIC HOLIDAY

Page 18: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

18

ON THURSDAY 30TH MARCH 2017

107211

(5A/270/12)

J R A Nayna & Ors v.s The Environment Appeal

Tribunal & Ors

Merits

110845

(5A/251/14)

M V Clement v.s B J Karlsson & Ors Mention/Disposal

104065

(1/260/10)

M V Ramseeran v.s L J Pyndiah & Ors Continuation

96632

(1/131/07)

C Sumrah v.s P Conhye & Ors Continuation

111514

(5A/79/15)

K L Ramdin v.s The Mauritius Revenue

Authority & Anor

Merits

114217

(5A/351/16)

Saihotel Ltd & Anor v.s The Ministry of Housing

& Lands & Anor

Arguments

102708

(1/303/09)

Amar Company Limited &

Ors

v.s Bramer Banking

Corporation Ltd & Anor

Mention

112942

(1/167/16)

Societe de la Hogue v.s Mr K Sam Make Out Case

107840

(1/140/13)

M Churitter v.s H Churitter & Ors Merits

112149

(5A/183/15)

M O Vuille v.s M M L Vuille & Anor Merits

CS 5/15 The State v.s Ziaoudeen Noorah Mention

(at 10.00 am)

CS 2/17 The State v.s M P M Ajeon Mention

(at 10.00 am)

CS 3/17 The State v.s M L Josephine Mention

(at 10.00 am)

CS 4/17 The State v.s R Seegoolam & Anor Mention

(at 10.00 am)

SCS 1/17 The State v.s V Seeruttun Mention

(at 10.00 am)

CS 18/15 The State v.s R Garburrun & Anor Continuation

(at 10.00 am)

Page 19: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

19

102565

(1/238/09)

C Beedasee & Ors v.s T Beedassee & Anor Merits

103906

(1/165/10)

Mrs R Ujodha & Ors v.s R Poteeram & Ors Merits

113031

(1/210/16)

A Pyaneeandee & Anor v.s Lamco International

Insurance Ltd

Merits

99683

(1/634/07)

N Jugessur & Ors v.s P Gokool & Ors Continuation

107996

(1/237/13)

D Jennah & Anor v.s O Ramdenee & Anor Arguments

Page 20: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

20

ON THURSDAY 30TH MARCH 2017

FORMAL MATTERS BEFORE HIS HONOUR AG DEPUTY MASTER & REGISTRAR AT 9.30 A.M IN COURT NO. 3

63927

(1/273/98)

R Purmessur & Anor v.s P Poonpoon & Ors Mention

76021

(1/724/01)

P Poonpoon & Ors v.s R Purmessur & Anor Do

75926

(1/700/01)

G Seewoopaul & Ors v.s A Mohabuth & Ors Do

107908

(1/180/13)

R Seerputh & Ors v.s M Luchmun & Ors Do

89026

(1/222/05)

S B G Casse & Ors v.s Mauritius Commercial Bank

Ltd

Do

98578

(1/455/07)

M L Desforges v.s Rainbow Insurance Company

Ltd (In Liquidation) & Ors

Do

103860

(1/134/10)

I Seboruth & Anor v.s K K Seboruth & Ors Do

105044

(1/78/11)

R Seeboruth & Anor v.s I Seboruth & Ors Do

107756

(5A/53/13)

P K Seboruth & Anor v.s K K Seboruth & Ors Do

108200

(1/334/13)

S A Dilmohamed v.s M O Karamuth Do

108044

(1/263/13)

R Lallbahadoor & Ors v.s C O T Lindor & Ors Do

112306

(1/521/15)

SICOM Ltd v.s C O T Lindor & Anor Do

108319

(1/386/13)

P Jodhun & Ors v.s C Jodhun Do

108573

(1/500/13)

A M Hermance v.s M Armany Do

6731

(4/36/13)

S Soomaroo v.s H Burahee & Ors Do

Page 21: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

21

6732

(4/37/13)

R Dookaran v.s H Burahee & Ors Mention

6733

(4/38/13)

Ww S Dookaran & Ors v.s H Burahee & Ors Do

6734

(4/39/13)

B Dookaran v.s H Burahee & Ors Do

109137

(1/65/14)

Motorex Limited v.s The Rainbow Insurance

Company Limited ( In

Liquidation)

Do

110003

(1/435/14)

T Maurick v.s Dr V Pyneeandee Do

110840

(1/573/14)

M S Foondun v.s Mr I K A H Hosses & Anor Do

111310

(1/53/15)

M Dabydin & Ors v.s A Seumber & Ors Do

111918

(1/313/15)

S Sheoraj & Ors v.s Mauritius Union Assurance &

Ors

Do

113147

(1/263/16)

M D S L Pitot & Ors v.s Dr. M R Rajabally & Anor Do

112022

(1/366/15)

H O S Sookur v.s R Dhani Do

113389

(1/387/16)

B M Goolab v.s Jardins de Fragrances Ltd &

Ors

Do

113838

(1/527/16)

Securiclean (Mauritius) Ltd

(Under Administration)

v.s The District Council of Black

River & Anor

Do

114229

(1/717/16)

Z M Atchia v.s Societe Ocean Drive Do

114278

(1/734/16)

Phoenix Wear Ltd v.s Medi System Ltd Do

112671

(5A/19/16)

G Hurril & Ors v.s N Ramessur & Ors Do

113137

(5A/114/16)

K Rambaruth & Ors v.s R Deerpaul & Ors Do

113347

(5A/159/16)

P Cathan v.s N Kalcuttee Do

Page 22: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

22

113731

(5A/229/15)

L C Appavoo & Ors v.s W Buttie & Ors Mention

113761

(5A/242/16)

J Chady v.s C Chady Do

113990

(5A/306/16)

Mrs Ww R Vythilingum &

Ors

v.s Mrs P D Gangaparsad Do

114219

(5A/353/16)

Axys Leasing Ltd v.s V Baldee Do

114220

(5A/354/16)

Axys Leasing Ltd v.s V Baldee Do

1372

(6B/25/16)

VIEO Industries Ltd (In

Liquidation) & Anor

v.s SBI (Mauritius) Ltd Do

114532 (Bis)

(1/92/17)

D Komul v.s Sinohydro Corporation

(Mauritius) Ltd

Do

114541

(1/96/17)

M L V Rumjansing v.s Innodis Ltd & Anor Do

114542

(1/97/17)

K Ramdoyal v.s A S S Ramdoyal & Ors Do

114546

(1/98/17)

R P Callychurn & Anor v.s Bank One Limited & Ors Do

114548

(1/99/17)

B Aubeeluck v.s M. A. B. I Marketing Ltd &

Ors

Do

114549

(1/100/17)

Ww P D Caussy & Ors v.s Derocking and Transport Co

Ltd & Anor

Do

114550

(1/101/17)

The Mauritius Housing

Company Ltd

v.s E N Parmessur & Anor Do

114551

(1/102/17)

Domaine De Labourdonnais

Ltée

v.s Kenzo Ltd Do

114552

(1/103/17)

C R Lecordier v.s L V J C Oxemham & Ors Do

114560

(1/104/17)

N K Naudeer v.s Central Electricity Board Do

114561

(1/105/17)

J D Aristide v.s D Bhoyroo Do

114562(1/106/17)

Mouvement Civique de Plaine Lauzun & Ors

v.s The Central Electricity Board & Ors

Do

Page 23: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

23

114563

(1/107/17)

Mechanization Company

Limited

v.s Mauritius Care Industry

Authority

Mention

114564

(1/108/17)

Societe Coutelin & Ors v.s J J Planteau de Maroussen &

Ors

Do

114565

(1/109/17)

The City Council of Port

Louis

v.s Islands Holdings Ltd Do

114567

(1/110/17)

S Permal &Ors v.s Sun Insurance Co Ltd & Anor Do

114568

(1/111/17)

Le Chaland Hotel Limited v.s G Chin-Fee Ah Yan & Anor Do

114571

(1/112/17)

B N Jahangeer v.s M A Jahangeer & Anor Do

114572

(1/113/17)

V Peroomal v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Anor Do

114573

(1/114/17)

L K S Chan Cheung Shing

& Anor

v.s H C Morad & Ors Do

75522

(1/623/01)

P C Lutchman & Ors v.s Beau Plan Milling Co Ltd &

Ors

Do

91014

(1/569/05)

M YLamour & Anor v.s M J Faron & Ors Do

96217

(1/63/07)

B Toraub & Ors v.s C Toraub & Anor Do

101389

(1/529/08)

P Tacouri & Ors v.s F Mohamud & Ors Do

102231

(1/68/09)

M C C R Collet & Ors v.s H Faoulez & Ors Do

103347

(1/643/09)

I Koolmoteea & Ors v.s Llyod Bowmaker (Mauritius)

Ltd & Anor

Do

104295

(1/389/10)

M E Faoulez & Ors v.s M C C R Collet & Ors Do

105050

(1/84/11)

Sandy Row (Mauritius) Ltd

& Anor

v.s Société Domaine Le Mapou &

Ors

Do

107333(1/599/12)

Sandy Row (Mauritius) Ltd v.s R Lekha & Ors Do

107334(1/600/12)

Llyod Bowmaker (Mtius) Ltd

v.s Societe Domaine Le Mapou & Ors

Do

Page 24: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

24

102178(1/43/09)

Ww D Teeluck v.s A P Bouchez & Ors Mention

103101

(1/503/09)

P Veeraragoo MSK v.s Millenium Marketing Co Ltd

& Ors

Do

103207

(1/566/09)

R P Marimootoo v.s S Rama & Ors Do

103379

(1/665/09)

J D L Médon & Ors v.s Lateral Holdings Limited &

Ors

Do

104268

(1/374/10)

Swan Life Ltd v.s C A Ramkhalawon & Ors Do

104622

(1/552/10)

B K Kallypersand & Ors v.s V Tacouri & Ors Do

104994

(1/57/11)

W Ecroignard & Anor v.s F G Ecroignard & Ors Do

105243

(1/187/11)

E J Rozaux & Anor v.s S C Sian-Zh & Ors Do

105741

(1/431/11)

S Lall & Ors v.s I Goolaub & Ors Do

105809

(1/469/11)

Anisht Co Ltd v.s M Mooraghen & Ors Do

105896

(1/519/11)

A B Malepa & Ors v.s C L Laridain & Anor Do

105897

(1/520/11)

A B Malepa & Ors v.s C L Laridain & Anor Do

105928

(1/530/11)

L Ramphall v.s I Ramphall & Anor Do

106379

(1/77/12)

Chandradip Jodhun v.s Savitree Jodhun & Ors Do

107176

(1/535/12)

M L C Lanferna v.s P F G Lanferna & Ors Do

112944

(1/170/16)

P F G Lenferna v.s J V G Randabel & Anor Do

106682(1/259/12)

The Hugo Boss Trade Mark Management GmbH & Co KG

v.s M T Eadally & Anor Do

Page 25: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

25

106692

(1/265/12)

The Polo/Lauren Company,

L.P

v.s M T Eadally & Anor Mention

107442

(1/667/12)

O Lodeechand & Ors v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do

107443

(1/668/12)

Mrs G Sookun & Ors v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do

107951

(1/203/13)

H Hurbungs v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do

108743

(1/605/13)

J Anauth v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do

108744

(1/606/13)

S Bholah v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do

108745

(1/607/13)

N Balchand & Ors v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do

107451 (Bis)

(1/672/12)

M S Khoyratty v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

107841

(1/141/13)

Mungroo & Sons Ltd v.s The Ministry of Health & Do

108780

(1/630/13)

Me. M J L Panglose & Anor v.s The Trust Fund for Specialised

Medical Care & Ors

Do

109385

(1/178/14)

The Official Receiver of the

Commercial Division of the

Supreme Court of Mauritius

v.s S Bangari & Ors Do

109820

(1/357/14)

S Boodhun & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

110731

(1/514/14)

Y Bissessur v.s The Independent Commission

against Corruption & Ors

Do

110756

(1/525/14)

D Ramsurrun v.s A Soyjaudah & Anor Do

110919

(1/620/14)

R Jaunky & Ors v.s S Lutchigadoo & Ors Do

111193

(1/753/14)

Hon P K Jugnauth v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Do

110772 (bis)

(5C/41/14)

I Peerajee & Ors v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Do

Page 26: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

26

111198

(BIS)

(5C/60/14)

S K Cheekhooree & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Mention

111297

(1/48/15)

R Bhoodhoo v.s Heirs of late P Bucha & Ors Do

111485

(1/122/15)

M Rammohun & Anor v.s Kong Ltd & Ors Do

111540

(1/150/15)

L A P Wright & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111541

(1/151/15)

G Ramdhari & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111542

(1/152/15)

L D Rambhujun & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111543

(1/153/15)

M M L Moorghen & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111544

(1/154/15)

L Henriette & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111545

(1/155/15)

D Khoosye & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111546

(1/156/15)

S Tewary v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111547

(1/157/15)

S D Bhobany & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111548

(1/158/15)

H C V Lai Kim v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111549

(1/159/15)

Y Tewary & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

111784

(1/277/15)

A Seewoosurrun & Ors v.s K Sirputh & Ors Do

111830 (1/295/15)

B Sobrun & Ors v.s Best Foods Distributors Co Ltd & Ors

Do

112301

(1/516/15)

B Jharee & Ors v.s S Kewal & Ors Do

112489(1/608/15)

A Bysooa v.s S Rambojan & Ors Do

112581

(1/665/15)

A H Nazrally v.s M Naushad Ramchurn & Ors Do

Page 27: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

27

111647

(5A/105/15)

K J Bheenick & Ors v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Mention

112444

(5A/264/15)

Cancrie Ltd v.s The Beach Authority Do

1306

(6B/9/15)

Compagnie Atchia Hossen

Freres

v.s Swan Life Ltd & Ors Do

112589

(1/1/16)

L Appa & 34 Ors v.s C Appa & Ors Do

112665

(1/27/16)

D Veerapen Chetty & Ors v.s Samben Properties Co. Ltd &

Ors

Do

112728

(1/52/16)

Mrs Ah Choo Lo Choy &

Ors

v.s Ww I Rughobur & Anor Do

112856

(1/108/16)

M Chinien & Anor v.s K Chinien & Anor Do

112906

(1/148/16)

Y Mann & Ors v.s The Mauritius Revenue

Authority & Ors

Do

112911

(1/153/16)

M Sreemuntoo v.s D Mohadawo & Ors Do

113003

(1/197/16)

B R Labelle v.s M D S Labelle & Ors Do

113112

(1/247/16)

Dr U G Paratian v.s P A Sotiri & Anor Do

113171

(1/278/16)

D Dhannoo v.s D Dhannoo & Ors Do

113210

(1/303/16)

The Diabetes Parent Support

Group

v.s S Balloo & Anor Do

113276

(1/335/16)

Saving Our Strays v.s Mauritius Society for Animal

Welfare (MSAW) & Ors

Do

113301 (Bis)(1/350/16)

D Gunesh & Anor v.s R A Bungaree & Ors Do

113693

(1/473/16)

S Bindabun & Anor v.s The Mauritius Housing

Company Ltd & Ors

Do

113849(1/536/16)

S Govinden v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

113861

(1/543/16)

Touring Car Ltd v.s Mrs. Ww Bhoowan Aubeeluck

& Anor

Do

Page 28: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

28

113862

(1/544/16)

SBM Bank (Mauritius) Ltd v.s The Independent Commission

Against Corruption & Ors

Mention

114018

(1/617/16)

M Chintaram & Ors v.s N Ramchurrun & Ors Do

8908

(3/33/16)

R M Chiniah v.s The State Do

8910

(3/35/16)

S Boyjonauth v.s The State Do

8915

(3/40/16)

J A B Andony v.s The State Do

103915 Cie Sucriere de St Antoine

Ltd

v.s State of Mauritius & Anor Do

101366

(1/515/08)

K R Dassoo & Ors v.s V Dassoo & Anor Do

102888

(1/403/09)

English Estates Ltd & Anor v.s Expert Medical Ltd & Anor Do

105880

(1/512/11)

Jyoti’s Clinic Ltd v.s Central Electricity Board Do

106736

(1/287/12)

Central Electricity Board v.s Jyoti’s Clinic Ltd Do

106063

(1/605/11)

A T Pierrot v.s N Oozeerally & Ors Do

107070

(1/491/12)

M R Warsalee v.s The Independent Commission

Against Corruption & Ors

Do

107453

(1/673/12)

Mrs B R Bengraz v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

108131

(1/300/13)

S A Ahmed v.s Y Ahmed Do

110929 (1/623/14)

S J Angeline & Anor v.s L G Maurice Constantin & Anor

Do

111731

(1/241/15)

U D Luchoomun v.s U D Hurechurn & Ors Do

111804 (1/284/15)

J D D Govind v.s J L Capdor & Anor Do

109790

(1/342/14)

A Jandally & Ors v.s A F Jaudally & Ors Do

Page 29: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

29

112099

(1/408/15)

The District Council of

Savanne

v.s S K Luchmun & Ors Mention

112179

(1/457/15)

M B Ammamoothoo & Ors v.s R Appadoo & Ors Do

112193

(1/460/15)

T Krankenkasse v.s S Ramdoyal & Anor Do

112274

(1/500/15)

K Beegoo & Anor v.s Air Mauritius Ltd Do

110765

(1/534/14)

DR K Sreenivasulu v.s Dr R Das & Ors Do

112437

(1/584/15)

V Y Tauckoor v.s S Tauckoor Do

112550

(1/649/15)

D Ajoodhea & Anor v.s D Ajoodhea & Ors Do

111355

(5A/47/15)

J G Seetamane v.s J S R F M Lacreole Do

112229

(5C/45/15)

B N Dhunoo v.s Board of Assessment Do

112753

(1/71/16)

N Ramnauth v.s Y Munian & Anor Do

113056

(1/220/16)

N Emambocus & Ors v.s Phoenix Insurance (Mauritius)

Ltd

Do

113202

(1/298/16)

J M P E Bignoux v.s ServEquip Ltd Do

113258

(1/329/16)

Case Noyale Limitee v.s Association Socio Culturelle

Rastafari

Do

113322

(1/352/16)

B B N Hannum Mauthoor v.s M Ramlall & Ors Do

113719(5A/223/16)

Play on line Ltd v.s Gambling Regulatory Authority

Do

113966

(5A/300/16)

B R Maraye v.s The Mahatma Gandhi Institute Do

77506

(1/182/02)

The Development Bank of

Mauritius Ltd

v.s B O Jacquin & Ors Do

86104

(1/462/04)

B Sujore & Ors v.s G Sujore & Ors Do

Page 30: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

30

107404

(1/646/12)

G A Muksoodhally v.s E J Manfred Bru & Ors Mention

110724

(1/506/14)

GFA Insurance Ltd v.s J C Sanstoupet & Ors Do

107746

(1/94/13)

A H Karamuth & Ors v.s Barclays Bank Plc & Ors Do

107906

(1/178/13)

J M F Potou v.s Ministry of Public

Infrastructure, N.D.U, Land

Transport & Shipping & Anor

Do

8705

(3/126/14)

The Director of Public

Prosecutions

v.s G Gunness & Ors Do

112376

(1/554/15)

M C A Elliot v.s A D D Nam Kam & Ors Do

112439

(1/586/15)

Dr L Pyneeandee v.s DYP Worldwide Ltd & Ors Do

112458

(5A/266/15)

Maxi Clean Co Ltd v.s Ministry of Environment and

Sustainable Development,

Disaster Beach and

Management & Ors

Do

112626

(1/21/16)

R Nowransing v.s N P Nowransing & Ors Do

112726

(1/51/16)

The Motor Vehicle Dealers

Association

v.s The Director General,

Mauritius Revenue Authority

& Ors

Do

113237

(5A/135/16)

B B Doorga v.s The Public Bodies Appeal

Tribunal & Ors

Do

113978

(5A/304/16)

L C Lamarque & Ors v.s The Tourism Authority & Anor Do

114162(5A/347/16)

D Panday v.s The Rt. Hon. Prime Minister Do

114255

(5A/361/16)

V R Boodhoo v.s The Commissioner of Police & Anor Do

114412

(1/42/17)

P D Kalandaramen v.s Central Electicity Board Do

114468

(1/64/17)

S Reekhaye & Anor v.s The Rt Hon Sir A Jugnauth,

GCSK, KCMG, QC

Do

Page 31: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

31

78866

(1/455/02)

K Persand v.s D Persand & Ors Mention

81610

(1/325/03)

C Sowkhee & Ors v.s The Curator of Vacant Estates

& Ors

Do

8688

(3/109/14)

M D Planche & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius Do

111339

(1/70/15)

D Balkissur v.s Independent Commission

Against Corruption (ICAC) &

Anor

Do

111886

(1/302/15)

The Director of Public

Prosecutions

v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do

113087

(5A/102/16)

B Jogeea v.s The National Transport

Authority & Anor

Do

114626

(5A/80/17)

SBM Bank(Mauritius) Ltd v.s N Sadien Do

106392

(1/86/12)

R Chakowry & Anor v.s M A H Nobeebux Do

106768

(1/307/12)

Reckitt & Colman

(Overseas) Ltd

v.s Curepharma Ltd & Anor Do

92836

(1/173/06)

A C Cassam & Co Ltd v.s CSK Properties Ltd & Ors Do

102025

(1/761/08)

Tectromatic Ltd v.s Freeport Operations

(Mauritius) Ltd

Do

105910

(1/525/11)

B J Moossun & Ors v.s A H Moossun & Ors Do

107401

(1/643/12)

C Kumal & Ors v.s Solpro Supplies Ltd & Ors Do

107636

(1/32/13)

Business Parks of Mauritius

Ltd (BPML)

v.s SICOM & Ors Do

114055

(1/636/16)

L J Jean & Anor v.s The Mauritius Union

Assurance Co Ltd

Do

114062

(1/643/16)

R Jangeerkhan & Anor v.s B M Ramdowar Do

106210

(1/675/11)

A M Christophe v.s P Shibnauth & Ors Do

Page 32: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

32

104982

(5A/24/11)

Terragri Ltd v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Mention

112096

(1/405/15)

S M N E Maudarbocus v.s Teck Yan Chan Sui Ko & Ors Do

113805

(1/515/16)

M H Florent v.s GFA Insurance ltd & Anor Do

114151

(5C/67/16)

K Kauroo & Ors v.s The Honourable Minister of

Housing & Lands

Do

113214

(5A/125/16)

Emtel Ltd v.s Mr K Conhye & Ors Do

114084

(5A/332/16)

M Goundem & 8 Ors v.s The Minisry of Housing &

Lands & Ors

Do

81654

(1/341/03)

N R Naik & Ors v.s K Rampersad & Ors Do

87635

(1/767/04)

A Dhurbarrylall v.s M R Kurmally Do

89891

(1/346/05)

H Rolf & Ors v.s A V O'Reilly & Ors Do

98243

(1/391/07)

M T Carlos & Ors v.s F Brelu Brelu & Ors

State Attorney

Do

98413

(1/421/07)

Ten Company Ltd v.s K Sicharam & Anor

M I Dauhoo

Do

98414

(1/422/07)

R M Mulleegadoo v.s K Sicharam & Anor Do

102830

(1/369/09)

A Ganga & Anor v.s The State & Anor Do

103026

(1/479/09)

Mauritius Union Assurance

Co Ltd & Anor

v.s Lamco International Insurance

Co Ltd & Ors

Do

106258

(1/18/12)

M Mungra v.s V Anacootee & Anor Do

107411(Ter)

(1/652/12)

Bramer Banking

Corporation Ltd (In

Receivership)

v.s M Y Katoaroo & Ors Do

110795

(1/548/14)

Rubric Quality Consultants

Ltd

v.s U Ramjutton (Curator of

Vacant Estates)

Do

Page 33: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

33

110796

(1/549/14)

Rubric Quality Consultants

Ltd

v.s U Ramjutton (Curator of

Vacant Estates)

Mention

111561

(1/167/15)

Dr N Ramgoolam v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do

112084

(1/398/15)

G Lalleebeeharry v.s The Local Government Service

Commission & Ors

Do

113720

(1/484/16)

B N Imandee & Ors v.s M A A Carrim & Ors Do

104619

(1/549/10)

N Chatharoo & Ors v.s A R Chatharoo & Ors Do

108925(1/713/13)

Mrs Ww J C Padiachy & Ors

v.s The State Do

105871(1/504/11)

OCII – Ocean Indian Immobilier Ltd (OCIL)

v.s B M Bucktowar & Ors Do

106800(1/324/12)

B M Bucktowar & Ors v.s OC11 – Ocean Indien Immobilier Ltd & Ors

Do

Page 34: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

34

ON FRIDAY 31ST MARCH 2017

1251(6B/37/14)

S Bathfield & Anor v.s M D Angteeah & Anor Merits

8868(3/147/15)

L J Marthe v.s The State Merits

8870(3/149/15)

J J Alexis v.s The State Merits

8875(3/154/15)

A D F Azie v.s The State Merits

54930(1/815/95)

Compagnie des Magasins Populaires Limited

v.s The Government ofMauritius

Mention(at 10.15 am)

110905 (1/610/14)

M L Rose & Ors v.s M L Rose & Ors Mention

103958 (1/193/10)

A M Mansoor v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Continuation

104164(1/313/10)

A M Mansoor v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Continuation

99043(1/533/07)

B Seeboruth v.s N Mahadea & Anor Mention

104305(1/394/10)

B J Mohoboob & Anor v.s A Mohoboob & Ors Mention

107887(1/175/13)

K Jugessur v.s S Jugessur & Anor Written Submission

109147(1/73/14)

E Begue v.s The State of Mauritius Continuation

112230(5A/214/15)

H B Jankoo v.s G Jankoo & Anor Disposal

102744(1/323/09)

S D Beeharry & Anor v.s The Official Receiver& Anor

Continuation

110063 (1/484/14)

J M M Tuyau v.s D D H Jewooth & Ors Mention(at 10.15 am)

102489(1/200/09)

Y A Chuttoo v.s M Hosany Mention

95161(1/569/06)

D Rambojun v.s R Seewooram & Ors Continuation

112008(5A/166/15)

S Soobiah v.s Sicom Financial ServicesLtd & Ors

Continuation

108425(1/433/13)

M Bhundoo & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Mention(at 10.00 am)(In Chambers)

Page 35: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund

35

103857 (1/131/10)

R L M Fin & Anor v.s P H B de Coriolis & Ors Merits

113881(5A/279/16)

G A Eustasie & Anor v.s O Daby Disposal

END OF TERM