the supreme court of mauritius hearing... · 4 on tuesday 28th march 2017 114559 (5a/72/17) ireo...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS
ON MONDAY 27TH MARCH 2017
1363
(6B/16/16)
Omnicane Limited & Anor v.s A R Fowdar & Anor Merits
107937
(5C/18/13)
Mauritius Post Limited v.s Blue Penny Museum & Anor Merits
114083
(5A/331/16)
Mr P Luchun v.s The State of Mauritius Arguments
8964
(3/89/16)
The Director of Public
Prosecutions
v.s T P J M Lagesse & Ors Merits
8859
(3/137/15)
Director of Public
Prosecutions
v.s J J K Carly Merits
6818
(4/28/15)
D Deville v.s J I Hector Merits
79175
(1/543/02)
M Ramdoo & Ors v.s The State Bank
of Mauritius
Mention/Stand
(at 10.15 am)
113421
(5A/182/16)
P J F Guimbeau v.s The Employment
Relations Tribunal
Arguments
(at 1.30 pm)
8757
(3/35/15)
A K Jhungee v.s State of Mauritius Merits
8847
(3/125/15)
O J B W Saydraouten v.s The State Merits
CS 10/16 The State v.s D Ross & Ors Mention
(at 10.00 am)
CS 1/17 The State v.s S Cheetamun Ruling/Mention
(at 10.00 am)
CS 12/16 The State v.s T S Agathe Hearing
(at 10.00 am)
RC 1/17 Ex-Parte:- The Honourable Attorney General Hearing
(at 10.00 a.m)
![Page 2: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
ON MONDAY 27TH MARCH 2017
MOTIONS/FORMAL MATTERSBEFORE HON. AG. CHIEF JUSTICE
IN CHAMBERS AT 10.00 A.M IN COURT NO.1
113517(1/445/16)
M J Allas v.s L P M Ribet & Ors Mention
113829(5A/273/16)
Teyliom Telecom & Ors v.s Director General, The Mauritius Revenue Authority & Ors
Do
114223(5A/357/16)
Sir C A Hohn) v.s Mr M M O N Oosman & Ors Do
114323(5A/13/17)
Bus Owners Co-Operative Society (North) Limited
v.s The Ministry of Public Infrastructure and Land Transport (Land Transport Division) & 5 Ors
Do
114353(5A/18/17)
Mrs Jogeeta Boyjonauth v.s APAC Services Ltd & Ors Do
114449(5A/43/17)
P R P Gellé v.s N Venkitachalamiyer Do
114522(5A/60/17)
J D Peten v.s F M C Le Breton de la Vieuville Ah Youne
Do
114553(5A/66/17)
I J C Planteau de Maroussem & Anor
v.s Societe des Deux Intendances & Ors Do
114554(5A/67/17)
A R Imambacccus & Anor v.s The Mauritius Commercial Bank Ltd & Ors
Do
114580(5A/75/17)
S Sunasee v.s M H Shamtally Do
114579(5A/74/17)
Oriental Treasures Ltd v.s Mrs N Chong & Anor Do
114583(5A/78/17)
M B Doolhur & Anor v.s Mrs P Audit Do
112231(5A/215/15)
A P Wilson v.s Standard Bank Trust Company (Mauritius) Limited and Ors
Do
114080(5A/328/16)
Standard Bank Trust Company (Mauritius) Limited
v.s A P Wilson & Ors Do
114088(5A/336/16)
F Barles v.s The Mauritius Commercial Bank Limited
Do
![Page 3: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
114509(5A/55/17)
K Maureemootoo & Anor v.s Aamil Portfolio Management Ltd & Ors Mention
114584(5A/79/17)
M R Bissessur v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
114628(5A/82/17)
The Public Service Commission
v.s Public Service Appeal Tribunal & Ors Do
8841(3/119/15)
V Bissoon v.s The State Do
![Page 4: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017
114559
(5A/72/17)
Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention
(at 10.15 am)
1399
(6B/53/16)
Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention to follow
SCR 114559 –
5A/72/17
(at 10.15 am)
6870
(4/41/16)
Ireo Fund 1 Ltd (In
Liquidation)
v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention to follow
SCR 114559 –
5A/72/17
(at 10.15 am)
113940
(5A/291/16)
Sir C A Hohn & Anor v.s Ireo Fund 1 Ltd Mention to follow
SCR 114559 –
5A/72/17
(at 10.15 am)
113042
(5A/87/16)
K Takoordyal v.s National Transport
Authority & Anor
Merits
113045
(5A/90/16)
New Mauritius Hotels-
Plaisance Catering Ltd
v.s The Employment
Tribunal & Anor
Disposal
(at 10.15 am)
113318
(5A/154/16)
V Sanassy v.s S Thandrayen & Anor Mention
113922
(5A/284/16)
P T Jones v.s S B Sahebjam Arguments
110930
(1/624/14)
Heirs of Late A Gaungoo v.s R Gaungoo Stand/Disposal
107462
(1/675/12)
J A Bassy v.s D Francoeur & Anor Arguments
99728
(1/650/07)
Mrs M C S Ribet & Ors v.s M G P Ribet & Ors Final Disposal
(at 10.15 am)
101876
(1/704/08)
D Ramful v.s The Central Water
Authority & Ors
Merits
96499
(1/108/07)
B F M Toona Nanak &
Ors
v.s A Seekundur & Ors Mention/Disposal
(at 10.00 am)
![Page 5: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
109588
(1/233/14)
F Toona Nanak & Ors v.s A Sekender & Ors Mention/Disposal
(at 10.00 am)
102633
(1/279/09)
M Pillai & Ors v.s Valetta Murugan
Society & Ors
Merits
102984
(1/451/09)
J Dooblad v.s U Sookhary & Ors Continuation
76140
(1/753/01)
P Raghoo & Ors v.s I Soomaroo & Ors Merits
106483
(1/140/12)
A Dudhee & Anor v.s M Dudhee Merits
104131
(1/296/10)
V Jharee v.s V Alkoree Disposal
85072
(1/255/04)
M Kaurooa v.s The Commissioner
of Police & Anor
Continuation
111365
(1/86/15)
ABC Datacall Ltd v.s C Bohu & Ors Mention
(at 10.00 am)
(In Chambers)
112121
(1/428/15)
B S Bhaugeerutty v.s Swan General Ltd Merits
112119
(1/426/15)
R Seebaru & Anor v.s Swan General Ltd Merits
114180
(1/688/16)
P S Rampoortab v.s Swan Insurance Co. Ltd Merits
108814
(1/647/13)
I Timol & Ors v.s Modern Building
Investment & Anor
Arguments
111779
(1/276/15)
D Ramrichia v.s A Choonucksing
& Anor
Merits
109885
(1/394/14)
J J Patel & 68 Ors v.s Dynamic India Fund III &
Ors
Arguments
(at 1.30 p.m)
![Page 6: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017
FORMAL MATTERS BEFORE HIS HONOUR AG DEPUTY MASTER & REGISTRAR AT 9.30 A.M IN COURT NO. 3
75357
(1/599/01)
B Jugduth & Ors v.s A Lamoureux & Ors Mention
88337
(1/112/05)
Heirs of late Mrs C
Matadeen & Ors
v.s S Kishtoo & Ors Do
100058
(1/726/07)
Mrs L David & Ors v.s Honourable G Gunness & Ors Do
100646
(1/254/08)
L F C Wong Min Fong v.s Centre Gaming House Ltd &
Ors
Do
101523
(1/571/08)
C Marday v.s Dr B P Naiken & Anor Do
101337
(1/508/08)
T K T Tang Sing Cheong
& Anor
v.s A S Kadarally & Ors Do
103149
(1/537/09)
R Akkulugadu v.s Rosco Limitée (In Liquidation)
& Ors
Do
103371
(1/658/09)
A S Nassur v.s M Dowlut & Ors Do
103121
(1/519/09)
Separation Scientific
(Mauritius) Ltd
v.s Dr B C Gowreesunkur Do
103542
(1/742/09)
Beresford Trust &
Corporate Services
Limited
v.s G Dalton Do
103947
(1/187/10)
D Dookhy & Ors v.s S Callychurn & Ors Do
104097
(1/272/10)
D Dookhun & Anor v.s V Bijloll & Anor Do
105460
(1/306/11)
V A Montocchio v.s G G Y Montocchio & Ors Do
106492
(1/145/12)
M V Ramseeran & Ors v.s L R Beaux Yeux & Ors Do
![Page 7: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
107400
(1/642/12)
D Naik & Anor v.s State Bank of Mauritius Mention
112163
(1/447/15)
SBM Bank (Mtius) Ltd v.s Mr D P P Avrillon & Anor Do
107410
(1/649/12)
M S Kistnamah v.s S Bhurosah & Ors Do
108323
(1/390/13)
Mrs S Seetamonee & Ors v.s Mrs N Lobogun & Ors Do
108438
(1/439/13)
R P Dassruth v.s Femi Publishing Co. Ltd & Ors Do
108663
(1/560/13)
M F Harel & Ors v.s Ww M T J Mathieu & Ors Do
108803
(1/642/13)
Med Point Ltd v.s ICAC Do
110669
(1/487/14)
Côte Ouest Audiovisuel
Maurice
v.s M A Dearham Do
108388
(5A/199/13)
The District Council of
Grand Port
v.s J A Monneron Do
110801
(1/553/14)
S Lachkar v.s K R Mooten Do
110816
(1/560/14)
C A Croot v.s Pierre Sports Diving Ltd & Ors Do
110874
(1/591/14)
H Aubdool v.s B N Dookhun & Anor Do
110994
(1/665/14)
Rameshwarnath Society v.s V Moothoosawmy Maistry &
Ors
Do
111139
(1/721/14)
A F Mallam Hassam v.s P K Dash Do
|108991
(5A/3/14)
Dr H B Chittoo v.s The University of Technology,
Mauritius
Do
109361
(5A/95/14)
B A Athar Saib v.s S Appadoo Do
1219
(6B/4/14)
Torenia Impex Ltd v.s Best Luck (Mtius) Ltd (In
Receivership) & Ors
Do
111264(1/23/15)
Ww V R Ittoo v.s Ww R Ittoo & Ors Do
![Page 8: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
111725
(1/238/15)
C Poonith v.s National Transport Corporation
& Anor
Mention
111746
(1/251/15)
Ww Z Chinapyel & Anor v.s S Chinapyel & Ors Do
111770
(1/267/15)
N A Soodhun v.s State Insurance Company of
Mauritius Ltd
Do
112052
(1/381/15)
Central Electricity Board v.s N D L C Coquet Do
112071
(1/388/15)
A D Toolsy v.s R Dajee & Ors Do
112137
(1/436/15)
V Canhye v.s Sumida Ltd Do
112197
(1/461/15)
The Mauritius
Commercial Bank Ltd
v.s R Ramdoyal & Ors Do
112222
(1/476/15)
B Pandea v.s Mansuy & Ors Do
112278 (Ter)
(1/505/15)
Sam Musique & Anor v.s District Council of Flacq &
Ors
Do
112281
(1/509/15)
K K Bhoyroo v.s A Auleear Do
112303
(1/518/15)
S P Patpur & Anor v.s British American Hospitals
Enterprise Ltd & Anor
Do
112304
(1/519/15)
R Mohun & Anor v.s S Somary & Anor Do
112311
(1/526/15)
M F Mosafeer v.s B Z N Owasil & Anor Do
112343
(1/540/15)
A Appalsawmy & Anor v.s K Rungee & Anor Do
112420
(1/571/15)
Maryven (Mtius) Ltd v.s Swan General Ltd Do
112435
(1/582/15)
L C J Antoine v.s B Bissendary & Ors Do
112475
(1/605/15)
The Honourable J R
Dayal
v.s Honourable Dr A Boolell Do
112557(1/654/15)
B K Panray Ramchurn & Anor
v.s P Sumbal & Ors Do
![Page 9: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
112572
(1/661/15)
K Pichha v.s R Pichha & Ors Mention
112615
(1/13/16)
E M C Solvery v.s M J S Frivet Do
112642
(1/24/16)
H Chundunsing v.s La Sentinelle Ltée & Ors Do
112681
(1/30/16)
B C J L Bègue & Anor v.s M B N Maingard & Ors Do
112709
(1/36/16)
G S Domingue & Ors v.s M F Banymadhoo Do
112712
(1/39/16)
U Badry v.s Epi De Dieu Ltee & Anor Do
112720
(1/46/16)
The Mauritius Civil
Service Mutual Aid
Association Ltd
v.s K Ramloll & Anor Do
112742
(1/64/16)
J F G Veerasamy &
Anor
v.s Phoenix Insurance Co Ltd &
Anor
Do
112803
(1/83/16)
M L. I Baumann v.s The Riviere Du Rempart
District Council
Do
112842
(1/106/16)
E G Hart De Keating &
Anor
v.s A Macbeth & Ors Do
112862
(1/114/16)
Vacoas Popular Multi-
Purpose Cooperative
Society Ltd
v.s J C Germain Do
112875
(1/127/16)
Vacoas Popular Multi-
Purpose Cooperative
Society Ltd
v.s P D Anthony Do
112883
(1/135/16)
Vacoas Popular Multi-
Purpose Cooperative
Society Ltd
v.s S A N Jaulim & Anor Do
112889
(1/140/16)
M P M Hurrhungee v.s R N Paupiah Do
112890
(1/141/16)
Central Water Authority v.s Denim de l'Ile Limited Do
113028(1/208/16)
S Pareatumbee v.s The Mauritius Tamil Temples Federation
Do
![Page 10: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
113071
(1/227/16)
Dr R Munbodh & Anor v.s Work Your Wealth Ltd & Ors Mention
113078
(1/232/16)
N Appadoo v.s Swan Insurance Co. Ltd & Ors Do
113094
(1/233/16)
Mr S
Lutchmeenaraidoo,GCS
K
v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Do
113103
(1/235/16)
S Golapkhan & Anor v.s R Jugoo & Anor Do
113106
(1/238/16)
M Dauhoo v.s Sheik Al Ghilane Society Do
113107
(1/239/16)
Y Koonjul v.s C Aubeeluck & Anor Do
113109
(1/245/16)
C Bhuwanee v.s S Auhammud & Anor Do
113118
(1/250/16)
N Chummun & Anor v.s S Moothoocurpen & Anor Do
113148
(1/264/16)
Mr. G Ramlugan v.s Mrs. S D Ramrakha & Ors Do
113153
(1/266/16)
G R Beedassy v.s Deramann Management
Company Limited
Do
113160
(1/269/16)
M R C Uteem v.s S Soodhun Do
113165
(1/274/16)
C C Arekion v.s M C J Jacquin & Ors Do
113167
(1/276/16)
The Honourable S
Soodhun
v.s Honourable R M Uteem Do
113173
(1/280/16)
M B Hosenbocus & Ors v.s A K B Y Hosenbocus & Anor Do
113182
(1/288/16)
N Delhomme v.s T S Jamodhee Do
113219
(1/305/16)
Isabelle Anne-Catherine
Mathilde Baronne De
Traux De Wardin
v.s B D'Hotman De Villiers &
Anor
Do
113222(1/308/16)
M L Young Chuan Yen & Ors
v.s Huan Xiong & Ors Do
![Page 11: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
113222 (BIS)
(1/311/16)
D Ghoora & Ors v.s H Ghoora Mention
113241
(1/315/16)
S A Jaumdally & Anor v.s M S E N Appadoo & Ors Do
113294
(1/347/16)
L M C Sauzier & Anor v.s The Central Water Authority Do
113300 (Bis)
(1/349/16)
H Gunesh v.s The District Council of Flacq Do
113363
(1/371/16)
S Reesaul & Anor v.s I Rambojun Do
113406
(1/394/16)
K Dookun v.s Engen Petroleum ( Mauritius)
Limited
Do
113424
(1/403/16)
Mauritius Civil Service
Mutual Aid Association
Ltd
v.s R Imrith & Ors Do
113475(Bis)
(1/425/16)
S Shanmuganaden v.s V Payen Do
113537
(1/450/16)
Eastern Stone Crusher
Ltd (ESCL) & Ors
v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Do
113694
(1/474/16)
Kim-Fee Lee Shing Fong v.s H Mungrah Do
113700
(1/476/16)
S Boholah & Ors v.s S Jagessur & Ors Do
113703
(1/477/16)
V Jugun & Ors v.s G Chumbit Do
113797
(1/507/16)
B C D Pecile v.s M E B Seeyave & Anor Do
113860
(1/542/16)
Central Electricity Board v.s K Nobeen Do
113863
(1/545/16)
Eastern Stone Crushers
Ltd
v.s H Dowlut Do
113936
(1/580/16)
A P Marie v.s Marine Biotechnology
Products Ltd
Do
113943
(1/582/16)
J C Lillah & Anor v.s Mauritius Union Assurance
Co. Ltd
Do
![Page 12: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
113950
(1/588/16)
C Karl Rosse v.s Deep River Beau Champ
Milling Company Limited c/o
Alteo Milling Company
Limited
Mention
114070
(1/649/16)
Kiddy Land (Indian
Ocean) & Co. Ltd
v.s State Property Development
Co Ltd
Do
114258
(5C/75/16)
Real Estates
International SA-SPF
v.s GMG Trust Ltd & Ors Do
114259
(5C/76/16)
Real Estates
International SA-SPF
v.s GMG Trust Ltd & Ors Do
9030
(3/8/17)
District Council of
Riviere du Rempart
v.s V Meeheelaul Do
6880
(4/1/17)
Food Paradise Co Ltd v.s The Permanent Secretary,
Ministry of Health and Quality
of Life & Anor
Do
6886
(4/7/17)
D M Ramcheran v.s L Mahadoowa & Anor Do
114440 (Bis)
(5C/6/17)
A Wally & Son Co. Ltd v.s Ramsaha & Co. Ltd Do
79477
(1/611/02)
S Nawosah & Ors v.s Heirs L Nawosah & Ors Do
99972
(1/703/07)
T Dawoodarry v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
100889
(1/351/08)
Ducray Lenoir Ltd v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
101346
(1/509/08)
J P Haulkory v.s K E Haulkory & Ors Do
108838
(1/662/13)
J P Haulkory & Anor v.s K E Haulkory & Ors Do
101524
(1/572/08)
A K Phokeerah & Ors v.s D S Dhoneeram & Ors Do
104237
(1/355/10)
The State of Mauritius v.s R Randha & Ors Do
105660
(1/397/11)
A K Ghallu v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
![Page 13: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
105948
(1/543/11)
B S Burahee & Ors v.s S R Ossenbox & Ors Mention
106364
(1/66/12)
A Beebeejaun & Ors v.s Seayu Ltd & Ors Do
107149
(1/522/12)
D Mooken & Ors v.s G R Mooken & Ors Do
107194
(1/541/12)
Sport Data Feed Ltd v.s The Automatic Systems Ltd &
Anor
Do
107593
(1/13/13)
A Treebhoowon v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
107799
(1/122/13)
R Doger De Speville v.s Les Creolias Holdings Ltd &
Ors
Do
108602
(1/519/13)
L Imrit & Ors v.s The Curator of Vacant Estates
& Ors
Do
109120
(1/58/14)
La Société de l’Histoire
de l’Ile Maurice & Ors
v.s The Ministry of Education &
Human Resources & Ors
Do
108177
(1/322/13)
K C Papas & Ors v.s Bank of Mauritius & Anor Do
108194
(5A/157/13)
K C Papas & Ors v.s Bank of Mauritius & Ors Do
114352
(5A/17/17)
Barclays Bank Mauritius
Limited & Anor
v.s Kleantis Constantinos Papas &
Ors
Do
108760
(1/621/13)
D Narayanen v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
109247
(1/115/14)
Mr D Subratty & Anor v.s Maubank Ltd & Ors Do
109337
(1/161/14)
R Burosee & Ors v.s D Burosee & Ors Do
111262
(1/21/15)
M A Mohit v.s D Pannoo & Ors Do
112745
(1/67/16)
A Jogeea v.s A Ramjatan & Ors Do
112821
(1/93/16)
I Mudon v.s V M Seeam & Ors Do
112919(1/156/16)
J J Prudence v.s H W R Prudence & Ors Do
![Page 14: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
113069
(1/226/16)
B Deenoololl & Ors v.s S Luckhoo & Ors Mention
113174
(1/281/16)
Ww M H B Trompeuse v.s J C B Trompeuse & Anor Do
114163
(5A/348/16)
Societe Agricole Mont
sur Mont
v.s Baie du Cap Estates Ltd & Ors Do
8905
(3/30/16)
D Kistoo v.s The State Do
9008
(3/133/16)
R Ramlugun v.s The Commissioner of Police Do
9031
(3/9/17)
E Y Amode v.s The State of Mauritius Do
9032
(3/10/17)
M Dilloosing v.s The State Do
89239
(1/247/05)
Mrs Ww S Appanah &
Ors
v.s M Chenadoo & Anor Do
100447
(1/165/08)
R Mathoorasingh v.s D Brand Do
103312
(1/626/09)
L X Pel & Anor v.s Victory Exports Ltd & Ors Do
104857
(1/681/10)
S A D Rutteea & Anor v.s A Heerah & Ors Do
105502
(1/325/11)
A K Ramdin & Ors v.s The Mauritius Cane Industry
Authority & Ors
Do
105607
(1/376/11)
Mr A Rashid Mir & Ors v.s Island Blyth Ltd & Ors Do
106615
(1/227/12)
R Seerkissoon & Ors v.s H Aubeeluck & Ors Do
107490
(1/689/12)
M G V Thevenau v.s Blychem Ltd Do
108188
(1/328/13)
Mrs Y Purang v.s Outremer Telecom Ltée Do
81786
(1/360/03)
Innodis Ltd v.s C Madayah Do
110945(5A/273/14)
S Beeharry v.s Sugar Industry Labour Welfare Fund & Ors
Do
![Page 15: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
110968
(5A/279/14)
I Ruchaia-Pudaruth &
Ors
v.s The Public Bodies Tribunal &
Ors
Mention
111275
(1/31/15)
Ramsaha & Co Ltd v.s The State of Mauritius Do
112363
(1/550/15)
San Marino v.s The Mauritius Post &
Cooperative Bank Ltd
Do
8907
(3/32/16)
M R A F E Peermamode v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
8911
(3/36/16)
J Casimir v.s The State Do
8912
(3/37/16)
J Casimir v.s The State Do
114044
(5A/322/16)
The Minister of Housing
& Lands
v.s The Board of Assessment &
Ors
Do
105976
(1/559/11)
Anderson Ross Holdings
Ltd & Ors
v.s The ICAC & Ors Do
106266
(1/26/12)
J H Cleopatre Ltd v.s A Sanz Do
110907
(1/612/14)
I Perrine v.s The Registrar of Civil Status &
Ors
Do
1396
(6B/50/16)
A Shanto & Anor v.s D Sunnassee & Ors Do
114404
(1/39/17)
Reziztans ek Alternativ v.s The State of Mauritius & 23
Ors
Do
98326
(1/404/07)
R Reetun v.s The Central Water Authority Do
103861
(1/135/10)
Central Water Authority v.s Joint Venture Besix Gamma
Civic
Do
105786
(1/454/11)
Joint Venture Besix
Gamma Civic
v.s New India Insurance Co Ltd &
Ors
Do
105428
(1/288/11)
A Habeboolla v.s M Mohanut & Ors Do
107588
(1/8/13)
Société Face-Aux-Iles v.s A G E Desvaux De Marigny Do
110791(1/544/14)
M M Pampusa v.s A Toorabally Do
![Page 16: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
111992
(1/350/15)
TRIO STAR Co Ltd &
Anor
v.s D Doorbir & Anor Mention
114397
(5A/29/17)
Mr B K Bhunjun v.s Mr A Bhunjun Do
87842 (Bis)
(1/27/05)
H Gopall v.s L Gopall & Ors Do
102556
(1/232/09)
R Sungkur & Ors v.s K Daby & Ors Do
102711
(1/304/09)
G Teckah v.s B Tribhowon & Ors Do
105961
(1/550/11)
Indigo Marketing
Company Limited
v.s The Ministry of Health and
Quality of Life & Ors
Do
107193
(1/539/12)
Le Hameau Limitée &
Ors
v.s A A A Ebrahim & Ors Do
108976
(1/743/13)
N Dulloo v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
110888
(1/603/14)
A A K Mustun & Anor v.s J D Vilar & Ors Do
111553
(1/161/15)
D Gunesh & Anor v.s R A Bungaree & Ors Do
112322
(1/532/15)
Ww S Samjawon &
Anor
v.s K Samjawon & Anor Do
112502
(1/616/15)
S G Nunkoo v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
111840
(5A/143/15)
V Saurty v.s The Public Bodies Tribunal &
Ors
Do
113323
(1/353/16)
P L I Anthony & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
113508
(1/441/16)
D Khodabux & Anor v.s M N Khodabux & Ors Do
113662 (Ter)
(1/463/16)
The World of Furniture
Ltd & Anor
v.s The Mauritius Revenue
Authority & Ors
Do
114033
(1/623/16)
Trionex Development
Ltd
v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
114036 (Bis)(1/628/16)
R Bokhoree v.s S D Chavrimootoo & Ors Do
![Page 17: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
114057 (Bis)
(1/639/16)
B Sewruttun v.s B Sewruttun & Ors Mention
114286
(1/738/16)
O K Dobory & Anor v.s V Saneechur & Anor Do
113431
(5A/183/16)
W Jeeawody & 7 Ors v.s The Ministry of Industry,
Commerce and Consumer
Protection & Anor
Do
113667
(5A/213/16)
D Napal v.s The Public Bodies Appeal
Tribunal & Anor
Do
113769
(5A/250/16)
Sport Data Feed Ltd v.s Value Plus Ltd & Ors Do
113925
(5A/287/16)
M A Z Fokeerbux & 24
Ors
v.s The Ministry of Health &
Quality of Life & Ors
Do
114354
(5A/19/17)
Dr Reshiana Rumzan v.s Public Service Commission &
Ors
Do
114489
(5A/49/17)
B Sobrun & 2 Ors v.s Best Food Distributors Co. Ltd
& Ors
Do
76076
(1/739/01)
R Moneeram & Ors v.s Societe des Plantations de
Bois Chéri
Do
107734
(1/87/13)
Mecatronics Ltd v.s The Government of Mauritius
& Ors
Do
110987
(1/658/14)
D Deerpaul v.s S Daby & Ors Do
113161
(1/270/16)
L K Dumar v.s The Ministry of Housing and
Lands & Ors
Do
113250
(1/322/16)
K K Kawol v.s P J Milap Do
112168
(5A/194/15)
M I Santally v.s The University of Mauritius &
Ors
Do
ON WEDNESDAY 29TH MARCH 2017
PUBLIC HOLIDAY
![Page 18: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
ON THURSDAY 30TH MARCH 2017
107211
(5A/270/12)
J R A Nayna & Ors v.s The Environment Appeal
Tribunal & Ors
Merits
110845
(5A/251/14)
M V Clement v.s B J Karlsson & Ors Mention/Disposal
104065
(1/260/10)
M V Ramseeran v.s L J Pyndiah & Ors Continuation
96632
(1/131/07)
C Sumrah v.s P Conhye & Ors Continuation
111514
(5A/79/15)
K L Ramdin v.s The Mauritius Revenue
Authority & Anor
Merits
114217
(5A/351/16)
Saihotel Ltd & Anor v.s The Ministry of Housing
& Lands & Anor
Arguments
102708
(1/303/09)
Amar Company Limited &
Ors
v.s Bramer Banking
Corporation Ltd & Anor
Mention
112942
(1/167/16)
Societe de la Hogue v.s Mr K Sam Make Out Case
107840
(1/140/13)
M Churitter v.s H Churitter & Ors Merits
112149
(5A/183/15)
M O Vuille v.s M M L Vuille & Anor Merits
CS 5/15 The State v.s Ziaoudeen Noorah Mention
(at 10.00 am)
CS 2/17 The State v.s M P M Ajeon Mention
(at 10.00 am)
CS 3/17 The State v.s M L Josephine Mention
(at 10.00 am)
CS 4/17 The State v.s R Seegoolam & Anor Mention
(at 10.00 am)
SCS 1/17 The State v.s V Seeruttun Mention
(at 10.00 am)
CS 18/15 The State v.s R Garburrun & Anor Continuation
(at 10.00 am)
![Page 19: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
102565
(1/238/09)
C Beedasee & Ors v.s T Beedassee & Anor Merits
103906
(1/165/10)
Mrs R Ujodha & Ors v.s R Poteeram & Ors Merits
113031
(1/210/16)
A Pyaneeandee & Anor v.s Lamco International
Insurance Ltd
Merits
99683
(1/634/07)
N Jugessur & Ors v.s P Gokool & Ors Continuation
107996
(1/237/13)
D Jennah & Anor v.s O Ramdenee & Anor Arguments
![Page 20: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
ON THURSDAY 30TH MARCH 2017
FORMAL MATTERS BEFORE HIS HONOUR AG DEPUTY MASTER & REGISTRAR AT 9.30 A.M IN COURT NO. 3
63927
(1/273/98)
R Purmessur & Anor v.s P Poonpoon & Ors Mention
76021
(1/724/01)
P Poonpoon & Ors v.s R Purmessur & Anor Do
75926
(1/700/01)
G Seewoopaul & Ors v.s A Mohabuth & Ors Do
107908
(1/180/13)
R Seerputh & Ors v.s M Luchmun & Ors Do
89026
(1/222/05)
S B G Casse & Ors v.s Mauritius Commercial Bank
Ltd
Do
98578
(1/455/07)
M L Desforges v.s Rainbow Insurance Company
Ltd (In Liquidation) & Ors
Do
103860
(1/134/10)
I Seboruth & Anor v.s K K Seboruth & Ors Do
105044
(1/78/11)
R Seeboruth & Anor v.s I Seboruth & Ors Do
107756
(5A/53/13)
P K Seboruth & Anor v.s K K Seboruth & Ors Do
108200
(1/334/13)
S A Dilmohamed v.s M O Karamuth Do
108044
(1/263/13)
R Lallbahadoor & Ors v.s C O T Lindor & Ors Do
112306
(1/521/15)
SICOM Ltd v.s C O T Lindor & Anor Do
108319
(1/386/13)
P Jodhun & Ors v.s C Jodhun Do
108573
(1/500/13)
A M Hermance v.s M Armany Do
6731
(4/36/13)
S Soomaroo v.s H Burahee & Ors Do
![Page 21: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
6732
(4/37/13)
R Dookaran v.s H Burahee & Ors Mention
6733
(4/38/13)
Ww S Dookaran & Ors v.s H Burahee & Ors Do
6734
(4/39/13)
B Dookaran v.s H Burahee & Ors Do
109137
(1/65/14)
Motorex Limited v.s The Rainbow Insurance
Company Limited ( In
Liquidation)
Do
110003
(1/435/14)
T Maurick v.s Dr V Pyneeandee Do
110840
(1/573/14)
M S Foondun v.s Mr I K A H Hosses & Anor Do
111310
(1/53/15)
M Dabydin & Ors v.s A Seumber & Ors Do
111918
(1/313/15)
S Sheoraj & Ors v.s Mauritius Union Assurance &
Ors
Do
113147
(1/263/16)
M D S L Pitot & Ors v.s Dr. M R Rajabally & Anor Do
112022
(1/366/15)
H O S Sookur v.s R Dhani Do
113389
(1/387/16)
B M Goolab v.s Jardins de Fragrances Ltd &
Ors
Do
113838
(1/527/16)
Securiclean (Mauritius) Ltd
(Under Administration)
v.s The District Council of Black
River & Anor
Do
114229
(1/717/16)
Z M Atchia v.s Societe Ocean Drive Do
114278
(1/734/16)
Phoenix Wear Ltd v.s Medi System Ltd Do
112671
(5A/19/16)
G Hurril & Ors v.s N Ramessur & Ors Do
113137
(5A/114/16)
K Rambaruth & Ors v.s R Deerpaul & Ors Do
113347
(5A/159/16)
P Cathan v.s N Kalcuttee Do
![Page 22: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
113731
(5A/229/15)
L C Appavoo & Ors v.s W Buttie & Ors Mention
113761
(5A/242/16)
J Chady v.s C Chady Do
113990
(5A/306/16)
Mrs Ww R Vythilingum &
Ors
v.s Mrs P D Gangaparsad Do
114219
(5A/353/16)
Axys Leasing Ltd v.s V Baldee Do
114220
(5A/354/16)
Axys Leasing Ltd v.s V Baldee Do
1372
(6B/25/16)
VIEO Industries Ltd (In
Liquidation) & Anor
v.s SBI (Mauritius) Ltd Do
114532 (Bis)
(1/92/17)
D Komul v.s Sinohydro Corporation
(Mauritius) Ltd
Do
114541
(1/96/17)
M L V Rumjansing v.s Innodis Ltd & Anor Do
114542
(1/97/17)
K Ramdoyal v.s A S S Ramdoyal & Ors Do
114546
(1/98/17)
R P Callychurn & Anor v.s Bank One Limited & Ors Do
114548
(1/99/17)
B Aubeeluck v.s M. A. B. I Marketing Ltd &
Ors
Do
114549
(1/100/17)
Ww P D Caussy & Ors v.s Derocking and Transport Co
Ltd & Anor
Do
114550
(1/101/17)
The Mauritius Housing
Company Ltd
v.s E N Parmessur & Anor Do
114551
(1/102/17)
Domaine De Labourdonnais
Ltée
v.s Kenzo Ltd Do
114552
(1/103/17)
C R Lecordier v.s L V J C Oxemham & Ors Do
114560
(1/104/17)
N K Naudeer v.s Central Electricity Board Do
114561
(1/105/17)
J D Aristide v.s D Bhoyroo Do
114562(1/106/17)
Mouvement Civique de Plaine Lauzun & Ors
v.s The Central Electricity Board & Ors
Do
![Page 23: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
114563
(1/107/17)
Mechanization Company
Limited
v.s Mauritius Care Industry
Authority
Mention
114564
(1/108/17)
Societe Coutelin & Ors v.s J J Planteau de Maroussen &
Ors
Do
114565
(1/109/17)
The City Council of Port
Louis
v.s Islands Holdings Ltd Do
114567
(1/110/17)
S Permal &Ors v.s Sun Insurance Co Ltd & Anor Do
114568
(1/111/17)
Le Chaland Hotel Limited v.s G Chin-Fee Ah Yan & Anor Do
114571
(1/112/17)
B N Jahangeer v.s M A Jahangeer & Anor Do
114572
(1/113/17)
V Peroomal v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Anor Do
114573
(1/114/17)
L K S Chan Cheung Shing
& Anor
v.s H C Morad & Ors Do
75522
(1/623/01)
P C Lutchman & Ors v.s Beau Plan Milling Co Ltd &
Ors
Do
91014
(1/569/05)
M YLamour & Anor v.s M J Faron & Ors Do
96217
(1/63/07)
B Toraub & Ors v.s C Toraub & Anor Do
101389
(1/529/08)
P Tacouri & Ors v.s F Mohamud & Ors Do
102231
(1/68/09)
M C C R Collet & Ors v.s H Faoulez & Ors Do
103347
(1/643/09)
I Koolmoteea & Ors v.s Llyod Bowmaker (Mauritius)
Ltd & Anor
Do
104295
(1/389/10)
M E Faoulez & Ors v.s M C C R Collet & Ors Do
105050
(1/84/11)
Sandy Row (Mauritius) Ltd
& Anor
v.s Société Domaine Le Mapou &
Ors
Do
107333(1/599/12)
Sandy Row (Mauritius) Ltd v.s R Lekha & Ors Do
107334(1/600/12)
Llyod Bowmaker (Mtius) Ltd
v.s Societe Domaine Le Mapou & Ors
Do
![Page 24: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
102178(1/43/09)
Ww D Teeluck v.s A P Bouchez & Ors Mention
103101
(1/503/09)
P Veeraragoo MSK v.s Millenium Marketing Co Ltd
& Ors
Do
103207
(1/566/09)
R P Marimootoo v.s S Rama & Ors Do
103379
(1/665/09)
J D L Médon & Ors v.s Lateral Holdings Limited &
Ors
Do
104268
(1/374/10)
Swan Life Ltd v.s C A Ramkhalawon & Ors Do
104622
(1/552/10)
B K Kallypersand & Ors v.s V Tacouri & Ors Do
104994
(1/57/11)
W Ecroignard & Anor v.s F G Ecroignard & Ors Do
105243
(1/187/11)
E J Rozaux & Anor v.s S C Sian-Zh & Ors Do
105741
(1/431/11)
S Lall & Ors v.s I Goolaub & Ors Do
105809
(1/469/11)
Anisht Co Ltd v.s M Mooraghen & Ors Do
105896
(1/519/11)
A B Malepa & Ors v.s C L Laridain & Anor Do
105897
(1/520/11)
A B Malepa & Ors v.s C L Laridain & Anor Do
105928
(1/530/11)
L Ramphall v.s I Ramphall & Anor Do
106379
(1/77/12)
Chandradip Jodhun v.s Savitree Jodhun & Ors Do
107176
(1/535/12)
M L C Lanferna v.s P F G Lanferna & Ors Do
112944
(1/170/16)
P F G Lenferna v.s J V G Randabel & Anor Do
106682(1/259/12)
The Hugo Boss Trade Mark Management GmbH & Co KG
v.s M T Eadally & Anor Do
![Page 25: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
106692
(1/265/12)
The Polo/Lauren Company,
L.P
v.s M T Eadally & Anor Mention
107442
(1/667/12)
O Lodeechand & Ors v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do
107443
(1/668/12)
Mrs G Sookun & Ors v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do
107951
(1/203/13)
H Hurbungs v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do
108743
(1/605/13)
J Anauth v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do
108744
(1/606/13)
S Bholah v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do
108745
(1/607/13)
N Balchand & Ors v.s S B A Hamuth & Ors Do
107451 (Bis)
(1/672/12)
M S Khoyratty v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
107841
(1/141/13)
Mungroo & Sons Ltd v.s The Ministry of Health & Do
108780
(1/630/13)
Me. M J L Panglose & Anor v.s The Trust Fund for Specialised
Medical Care & Ors
Do
109385
(1/178/14)
The Official Receiver of the
Commercial Division of the
Supreme Court of Mauritius
v.s S Bangari & Ors Do
109820
(1/357/14)
S Boodhun & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
110731
(1/514/14)
Y Bissessur v.s The Independent Commission
against Corruption & Ors
Do
110756
(1/525/14)
D Ramsurrun v.s A Soyjaudah & Anor Do
110919
(1/620/14)
R Jaunky & Ors v.s S Lutchigadoo & Ors Do
111193
(1/753/14)
Hon P K Jugnauth v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Do
110772 (bis)
(5C/41/14)
I Peerajee & Ors v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Do
![Page 26: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
111198
(BIS)
(5C/60/14)
S K Cheekhooree & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Mention
111297
(1/48/15)
R Bhoodhoo v.s Heirs of late P Bucha & Ors Do
111485
(1/122/15)
M Rammohun & Anor v.s Kong Ltd & Ors Do
111540
(1/150/15)
L A P Wright & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111541
(1/151/15)
G Ramdhari & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111542
(1/152/15)
L D Rambhujun & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111543
(1/153/15)
M M L Moorghen & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111544
(1/154/15)
L Henriette & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111545
(1/155/15)
D Khoosye & Ors v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111546
(1/156/15)
S Tewary v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111547
(1/157/15)
S D Bhobany & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111548
(1/158/15)
H C V Lai Kim v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111549
(1/159/15)
Y Tewary & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
111784
(1/277/15)
A Seewoosurrun & Ors v.s K Sirputh & Ors Do
111830 (1/295/15)
B Sobrun & Ors v.s Best Foods Distributors Co Ltd & Ors
Do
112301
(1/516/15)
B Jharee & Ors v.s S Kewal & Ors Do
112489(1/608/15)
A Bysooa v.s S Rambojan & Ors Do
112581
(1/665/15)
A H Nazrally v.s M Naushad Ramchurn & Ors Do
![Page 27: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
111647
(5A/105/15)
K J Bheenick & Ors v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Mention
112444
(5A/264/15)
Cancrie Ltd v.s The Beach Authority Do
1306
(6B/9/15)
Compagnie Atchia Hossen
Freres
v.s Swan Life Ltd & Ors Do
112589
(1/1/16)
L Appa & 34 Ors v.s C Appa & Ors Do
112665
(1/27/16)
D Veerapen Chetty & Ors v.s Samben Properties Co. Ltd &
Ors
Do
112728
(1/52/16)
Mrs Ah Choo Lo Choy &
Ors
v.s Ww I Rughobur & Anor Do
112856
(1/108/16)
M Chinien & Anor v.s K Chinien & Anor Do
112906
(1/148/16)
Y Mann & Ors v.s The Mauritius Revenue
Authority & Ors
Do
112911
(1/153/16)
M Sreemuntoo v.s D Mohadawo & Ors Do
113003
(1/197/16)
B R Labelle v.s M D S Labelle & Ors Do
113112
(1/247/16)
Dr U G Paratian v.s P A Sotiri & Anor Do
113171
(1/278/16)
D Dhannoo v.s D Dhannoo & Ors Do
113210
(1/303/16)
The Diabetes Parent Support
Group
v.s S Balloo & Anor Do
113276
(1/335/16)
Saving Our Strays v.s Mauritius Society for Animal
Welfare (MSAW) & Ors
Do
113301 (Bis)(1/350/16)
D Gunesh & Anor v.s R A Bungaree & Ors Do
113693
(1/473/16)
S Bindabun & Anor v.s The Mauritius Housing
Company Ltd & Ors
Do
113849(1/536/16)
S Govinden v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
113861
(1/543/16)
Touring Car Ltd v.s Mrs. Ww Bhoowan Aubeeluck
& Anor
Do
![Page 28: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
113862
(1/544/16)
SBM Bank (Mauritius) Ltd v.s The Independent Commission
Against Corruption & Ors
Mention
114018
(1/617/16)
M Chintaram & Ors v.s N Ramchurrun & Ors Do
8908
(3/33/16)
R M Chiniah v.s The State Do
8910
(3/35/16)
S Boyjonauth v.s The State Do
8915
(3/40/16)
J A B Andony v.s The State Do
103915 Cie Sucriere de St Antoine
Ltd
v.s State of Mauritius & Anor Do
101366
(1/515/08)
K R Dassoo & Ors v.s V Dassoo & Anor Do
102888
(1/403/09)
English Estates Ltd & Anor v.s Expert Medical Ltd & Anor Do
105880
(1/512/11)
Jyoti’s Clinic Ltd v.s Central Electricity Board Do
106736
(1/287/12)
Central Electricity Board v.s Jyoti’s Clinic Ltd Do
106063
(1/605/11)
A T Pierrot v.s N Oozeerally & Ors Do
107070
(1/491/12)
M R Warsalee v.s The Independent Commission
Against Corruption & Ors
Do
107453
(1/673/12)
Mrs B R Bengraz v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
108131
(1/300/13)
S A Ahmed v.s Y Ahmed Do
110929 (1/623/14)
S J Angeline & Anor v.s L G Maurice Constantin & Anor
Do
111731
(1/241/15)
U D Luchoomun v.s U D Hurechurn & Ors Do
111804 (1/284/15)
J D D Govind v.s J L Capdor & Anor Do
109790
(1/342/14)
A Jandally & Ors v.s A F Jaudally & Ors Do
![Page 29: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
112099
(1/408/15)
The District Council of
Savanne
v.s S K Luchmun & Ors Mention
112179
(1/457/15)
M B Ammamoothoo & Ors v.s R Appadoo & Ors Do
112193
(1/460/15)
T Krankenkasse v.s S Ramdoyal & Anor Do
112274
(1/500/15)
K Beegoo & Anor v.s Air Mauritius Ltd Do
110765
(1/534/14)
DR K Sreenivasulu v.s Dr R Das & Ors Do
112437
(1/584/15)
V Y Tauckoor v.s S Tauckoor Do
112550
(1/649/15)
D Ajoodhea & Anor v.s D Ajoodhea & Ors Do
111355
(5A/47/15)
J G Seetamane v.s J S R F M Lacreole Do
112229
(5C/45/15)
B N Dhunoo v.s Board of Assessment Do
112753
(1/71/16)
N Ramnauth v.s Y Munian & Anor Do
113056
(1/220/16)
N Emambocus & Ors v.s Phoenix Insurance (Mauritius)
Ltd
Do
113202
(1/298/16)
J M P E Bignoux v.s ServEquip Ltd Do
113258
(1/329/16)
Case Noyale Limitee v.s Association Socio Culturelle
Rastafari
Do
113322
(1/352/16)
B B N Hannum Mauthoor v.s M Ramlall & Ors Do
113719(5A/223/16)
Play on line Ltd v.s Gambling Regulatory Authority
Do
113966
(5A/300/16)
B R Maraye v.s The Mahatma Gandhi Institute Do
77506
(1/182/02)
The Development Bank of
Mauritius Ltd
v.s B O Jacquin & Ors Do
86104
(1/462/04)
B Sujore & Ors v.s G Sujore & Ors Do
![Page 30: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
107404
(1/646/12)
G A Muksoodhally v.s E J Manfred Bru & Ors Mention
110724
(1/506/14)
GFA Insurance Ltd v.s J C Sanstoupet & Ors Do
107746
(1/94/13)
A H Karamuth & Ors v.s Barclays Bank Plc & Ors Do
107906
(1/178/13)
J M F Potou v.s Ministry of Public
Infrastructure, N.D.U, Land
Transport & Shipping & Anor
Do
8705
(3/126/14)
The Director of Public
Prosecutions
v.s G Gunness & Ors Do
112376
(1/554/15)
M C A Elliot v.s A D D Nam Kam & Ors Do
112439
(1/586/15)
Dr L Pyneeandee v.s DYP Worldwide Ltd & Ors Do
112458
(5A/266/15)
Maxi Clean Co Ltd v.s Ministry of Environment and
Sustainable Development,
Disaster Beach and
Management & Ors
Do
112626
(1/21/16)
R Nowransing v.s N P Nowransing & Ors Do
112726
(1/51/16)
The Motor Vehicle Dealers
Association
v.s The Director General,
Mauritius Revenue Authority
& Ors
Do
113237
(5A/135/16)
B B Doorga v.s The Public Bodies Appeal
Tribunal & Ors
Do
113978
(5A/304/16)
L C Lamarque & Ors v.s The Tourism Authority & Anor Do
114162(5A/347/16)
D Panday v.s The Rt. Hon. Prime Minister Do
114255
(5A/361/16)
V R Boodhoo v.s The Commissioner of Police & Anor Do
114412
(1/42/17)
P D Kalandaramen v.s Central Electicity Board Do
114468
(1/64/17)
S Reekhaye & Anor v.s The Rt Hon Sir A Jugnauth,
GCSK, KCMG, QC
Do
![Page 31: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
78866
(1/455/02)
K Persand v.s D Persand & Ors Mention
81610
(1/325/03)
C Sowkhee & Ors v.s The Curator of Vacant Estates
& Ors
Do
8688
(3/109/14)
M D Planche & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius Do
111339
(1/70/15)
D Balkissur v.s Independent Commission
Against Corruption (ICAC) &
Anor
Do
111886
(1/302/15)
The Director of Public
Prosecutions
v.s The State of Mauritius & Anor Do
113087
(5A/102/16)
B Jogeea v.s The National Transport
Authority & Anor
Do
114626
(5A/80/17)
SBM Bank(Mauritius) Ltd v.s N Sadien Do
106392
(1/86/12)
R Chakowry & Anor v.s M A H Nobeebux Do
106768
(1/307/12)
Reckitt & Colman
(Overseas) Ltd
v.s Curepharma Ltd & Anor Do
92836
(1/173/06)
A C Cassam & Co Ltd v.s CSK Properties Ltd & Ors Do
102025
(1/761/08)
Tectromatic Ltd v.s Freeport Operations
(Mauritius) Ltd
Do
105910
(1/525/11)
B J Moossun & Ors v.s A H Moossun & Ors Do
107401
(1/643/12)
C Kumal & Ors v.s Solpro Supplies Ltd & Ors Do
107636
(1/32/13)
Business Parks of Mauritius
Ltd (BPML)
v.s SICOM & Ors Do
114055
(1/636/16)
L J Jean & Anor v.s The Mauritius Union
Assurance Co Ltd
Do
114062
(1/643/16)
R Jangeerkhan & Anor v.s B M Ramdowar Do
106210
(1/675/11)
A M Christophe v.s P Shibnauth & Ors Do
![Page 32: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
104982
(5A/24/11)
Terragri Ltd v.s State of Mauritius & Ors Mention
112096
(1/405/15)
S M N E Maudarbocus v.s Teck Yan Chan Sui Ko & Ors Do
113805
(1/515/16)
M H Florent v.s GFA Insurance ltd & Anor Do
114151
(5C/67/16)
K Kauroo & Ors v.s The Honourable Minister of
Housing & Lands
Do
113214
(5A/125/16)
Emtel Ltd v.s Mr K Conhye & Ors Do
114084
(5A/332/16)
M Goundem & 8 Ors v.s The Minisry of Housing &
Lands & Ors
Do
81654
(1/341/03)
N R Naik & Ors v.s K Rampersad & Ors Do
87635
(1/767/04)
A Dhurbarrylall v.s M R Kurmally Do
89891
(1/346/05)
H Rolf & Ors v.s A V O'Reilly & Ors Do
98243
(1/391/07)
M T Carlos & Ors v.s F Brelu Brelu & Ors
State Attorney
Do
98413
(1/421/07)
Ten Company Ltd v.s K Sicharam & Anor
M I Dauhoo
Do
98414
(1/422/07)
R M Mulleegadoo v.s K Sicharam & Anor Do
102830
(1/369/09)
A Ganga & Anor v.s The State & Anor Do
103026
(1/479/09)
Mauritius Union Assurance
Co Ltd & Anor
v.s Lamco International Insurance
Co Ltd & Ors
Do
106258
(1/18/12)
M Mungra v.s V Anacootee & Anor Do
107411(Ter)
(1/652/12)
Bramer Banking
Corporation Ltd (In
Receivership)
v.s M Y Katoaroo & Ors Do
110795
(1/548/14)
Rubric Quality Consultants
Ltd
v.s U Ramjutton (Curator of
Vacant Estates)
Do
![Page 33: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
110796
(1/549/14)
Rubric Quality Consultants
Ltd
v.s U Ramjutton (Curator of
Vacant Estates)
Mention
111561
(1/167/15)
Dr N Ramgoolam v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Do
112084
(1/398/15)
G Lalleebeeharry v.s The Local Government Service
Commission & Ors
Do
113720
(1/484/16)
B N Imandee & Ors v.s M A A Carrim & Ors Do
104619
(1/549/10)
N Chatharoo & Ors v.s A R Chatharoo & Ors Do
108925(1/713/13)
Mrs Ww J C Padiachy & Ors
v.s The State Do
105871(1/504/11)
OCII – Ocean Indian Immobilier Ltd (OCIL)
v.s B M Bucktowar & Ors Do
106800(1/324/12)
B M Bucktowar & Ors v.s OC11 – Ocean Indien Immobilier Ltd & Ors
Do
![Page 34: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
ON FRIDAY 31ST MARCH 2017
1251(6B/37/14)
S Bathfield & Anor v.s M D Angteeah & Anor Merits
8868(3/147/15)
L J Marthe v.s The State Merits
8870(3/149/15)
J J Alexis v.s The State Merits
8875(3/154/15)
A D F Azie v.s The State Merits
54930(1/815/95)
Compagnie des Magasins Populaires Limited
v.s The Government ofMauritius
Mention(at 10.15 am)
110905 (1/610/14)
M L Rose & Ors v.s M L Rose & Ors Mention
103958 (1/193/10)
A M Mansoor v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Continuation
104164(1/313/10)
A M Mansoor v.s Le Mauricien Ltd & Ors Continuation
99043(1/533/07)
B Seeboruth v.s N Mahadea & Anor Mention
104305(1/394/10)
B J Mohoboob & Anor v.s A Mohoboob & Ors Mention
107887(1/175/13)
K Jugessur v.s S Jugessur & Anor Written Submission
109147(1/73/14)
E Begue v.s The State of Mauritius Continuation
112230(5A/214/15)
H B Jankoo v.s G Jankoo & Anor Disposal
102744(1/323/09)
S D Beeharry & Anor v.s The Official Receiver& Anor
Continuation
110063 (1/484/14)
J M M Tuyau v.s D D H Jewooth & Ors Mention(at 10.15 am)
102489(1/200/09)
Y A Chuttoo v.s M Hosany Mention
95161(1/569/06)
D Rambojun v.s R Seewooram & Ors Continuation
112008(5A/166/15)
S Soobiah v.s Sicom Financial ServicesLtd & Ors
Continuation
108425(1/433/13)
M Bhundoo & Anor v.s The State of Mauritius & Ors Mention(at 10.00 am)(In Chambers)
![Page 35: THE SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS Hearing... · 4 ON TUESDAY 28TH MARCH 2017 114559 (5A/72/17) Ireo Fund 1 Ltd v.s Sir C A Hohn & Anor Mention (at 10.15 am) 1399 (6B/53/16) Ireo Fund](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022060306/5f099b507e708231d427a40a/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
103857 (1/131/10)
R L M Fin & Anor v.s P H B de Coriolis & Ors Merits
113881(5A/279/16)
G A Eustasie & Anor v.s O Daby Disposal
END OF TERM