the second g.a. leonards lecture - college of engineering€¦ · karst. dams on pervious...

56
The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture Victor Milligan Purdue Geotechnical Society May 11, 2003

Upload: others

Post on 19-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent

The Second G.A. Leonards LectureVictor Milligan

Purdue Geotechnical Society

May 11, 2003

Page 2: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent

– Eliminate or reduce seepage to a minimal amount by construction of seepage barriers.

– Reduce seepage as much as economically practicable and provide for control of any subsequent water losses.

– Do nothing to reduce seepage – but provide for control of anticipated water losses.

Generally speaking, most engineers endeavour to design almost all embankment dams to satisfy the first premise.

However – where the foundation is extremely pervious, construction of a complete barrier to seepage is rarely possible – and even more rarely achieved. An extreme of this situation is represented by the construction of dams on KARST.

Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action:

Page 3: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent

Because this condition is dependent on the regional geology – not just the geology specific to the dam site – water may seep from the reservoir and below the dam for great distances and in considerable amounts.

Thus the critical questions are:– What can be done – in realistic, economical terms – to reduce the

likely seepage to reasonable amounts?

– What amount of seepage is reasonable?

– What will be the effect of such seepage on the safety of the damand reservoir.

The term KARST refers to regions or terranes where sinkholes and solution channels have been formed by water in soluble rocks – generally, but not exclusively, in limestones, dolomites and carbonate conglomerates.

Page 4: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent

– Greece (2)– Turkey– USA

These critical questions and the use of grout curtains and reservoir blankets to inhibit possible seepage discussed by reference to four embankment dams –located variously in:

Page 5: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 6: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 7: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 8: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 9: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 10: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 11: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 12: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 13: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 14: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 15: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 16: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 17: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 18: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 19: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 20: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 21: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 22: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 23: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 24: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 25: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 26: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 27: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 28: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 29: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 30: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 31: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 32: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 33: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 34: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 35: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 36: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 37: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 38: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 39: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 40: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 41: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 42: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 43: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 44: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 45: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 46: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 47: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 48: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 49: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 50: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 51: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 52: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 53: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 54: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 55: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent
Page 56: The Second G.A. Leonards Lecture - College of Engineering€¦ · KARST. Dams on pervious foundations involve three possible courses of action: Because this condition is dependent

Closing Remarks• On karstic foundations, even after extensive site investigations

it is generally extremely difficult, if not impossible, to make reasonably exact estimates of the extent and quantity of seepage to be expected.

• Curtain grouting below the embankment is invariably carried out, but even if extensive, usually only moderates rather than prevents seepage losses.

• The permissible amount of seepage losses is specific to each site and is related to inflows, the reservoir volume and required downstream river flows.

• First impoundment of the reservoir is the decisive test and the only indicator of what remedial measures, if any, should be implemented.

• In all cases, because of the likelihood of further solution and erosion of karst features in the foundation, or the possibility of clogging of drains or the like within abutments, or the embankment, it is essential that continuous monitoring and supervision be carried out throughout the life of the dam.