the lure of linguistics, and the glamour of grammar
DESCRIPTION
The lure of linguistics, and the glamour of grammar. Richard Hudson Royal Grammar School, Guildford May 2014. My main points. ‘Language’ includes English as well as Foreign Linguistics is the science of language Linguistics can be i nteresting surprising useful difficult. - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
1
The lure of linguistics, and the glamour of grammar
Richard HudsonRoyal Grammar School, Guildford
May 2014
2
My main points
• ‘Language’ includes English as well as Foreign
• Linguistics is the science of language• Linguistics can be
– interesting– surprising– useful– difficult
3
English: me or I?
• Which would you say?1. You and I could do it together.2. You and me could do it together.
• Why 2?– Bad grammar?
• “The two personal pronouns I and me are often used wrongly, ....” (Oxford Dictionaries)
• And what about between you and I?– New grammar
4
Compare German and French
• Du und ich könnten es zusammen tun.– *!Dich und mich könnten es zusammen tun.
• Toi et moi nous pourrions le faire ensemble– *! Tu et je pourrions le faire ensemble.
• So maybe English is moving from German-like to French-like?– Because, like French, it’s lost ‘case’
5
Why?
• Everyone:– I did it (not: *Me did it)
• Me: Use I for subjects• You: Use I for subjects, except with and.• Why prefer the more complicated rule?• We don’t know.
6
Description or prescription?
• Why not proscribe me and prescribe I?– And proscribe French too?– Languages do change
• nor never none Shall mistress be of it• to: nor shall any ever be mistress of it.
• Better:– Describe what people actually say
• and what others think of it– Try to understand:
• why they say it• why other people object
Shakespeare
7
Description to explanation
description
theory
Why? What?
Now for another puzzle about English
8
Verb paradigms: Latin
am+o mon+e+o trah+oam+a+s mon+e+s trah+i+sam+a+t mon+e+t trah+i+tam+a+mus mon+e+mus trah+i+musam+a+tis mon+e+tis ??am+a+nt mon+e+nt trah+u+nt
+a+ +e+ +i+
+o
+s
+t
+tis
+mus
+nt
trah+i+tis
9
And English: am + n’t = ?
I am I am+n’t are+n’t I?you are you are+n’t are+n’t you?she is she is+n’t is+n’t she?we are we are+n’t are+n’t we?you are you are+n’t are+n’t you?they are they are+n’t are+n’t they?
+n’t
am
is
are
10
Why?
Maybe because of our logic?• e.g. hats:
– If sunny, then wear a sun hat– If cold, then wear a woolly hat– But: If both sunny and cold, then ....?
• e.g. language:– too big:They have too big a car. (not: too big car)– plural: They have cars (not: a cars).– But: too big + plural: They have ....?
11
The amn’t gap
• Similarly:– If after I, then: am– If before n’t, then: are– But: if both after I and before n’t, then ...?
• NB This is the frontier of research! – So we need
• good description• good arguments• good theory
12
Linguistics
• Description is the method– science, not correction
• Explanation is the goal– science, not mere collection
• Includes:– synchrony – a statistic snapshot of language – diachrony – how language changes through
time
13
Change: Etymology
• Etymology = study of historical links between words– fascinating!– e.g. Online Etymology Dictionary
• The Oxford English Dictionary– online– launched by linguists in the 19th century
• For example, take glamour.
14
The facts
15
What's gramarye?
16
A complex history
grammar
'writing skill'
learning
wizardry
gramarie
glamour
flashy appeal
'corruption'
mea
ns
17
Explanation: wanna
• Try these after He’s the man ...
• Why?– Because want to > wanna only where they
would normally be together– Compare:
• I want to meet him. > I wanna meet him.• I want him to win it. [not: I wanna him win it]
I want to meet. I wanna meet.I want to win it. I wanna win it.
18
So what?
• Linguistics studies language by– describing– explaining
• It studies written and spoken language.• It studies words and sentences.• It studies sounds, grammar and meaning.• It studies all languages
– and finds great diversity.
19
Diversity: mechanics
• How do you pronounce these?– Put the pizza/pasty in the oven.– I saw/see it.
• What’s going on?– We insert /r/ to separate vowels– when those vowels could historically be
separated by /r/. • Compare Beja
– my PhD language
20
Beja: /j/ insertion
• Spoken in the N-E Sudan, not written
tam+ta ‘she ate’ na+ta ‘she spent the night’
tam+an ‘I ate’ na+j+an ‘I spent the night
added to separate /a+a/
21
Diversity: organisation
• He likes it consists of– V - a verb likes – S - its subject he– O - its object it
• 6 orders are possible:VSO likes he it VOS likes it he
SVO he likes it OVS it likes he
SOV he it likes OSV it he likes
22
Word order typology
• Languages can be classified by preferred word order
• All possibilities have been found• But some are very, very rare: O .. S• The most common is ....
– SOV (e.g. Latin, maybe German)– then SVO (e.g. English)– then VSO (e.g. Welsh)
23
Diversity: possible messages
• Accurate translation is impossible– because different languages permit different
messages• e.g. English has gone contrasts with went
– He has gone to lunch vs He went to lunch.– ‘present relevance’
• So languages without this contrast can’t express ‘He has gone to lunch’.
24
Verbs of motionTranslate into French (or Spanish): He walked into the room• Not: Il a marché dans la chambre.
• But: Il est entré dans la chambre (en marchant).
manner of movement
direction of movement
direction of movement
manner of movement
25
Linguistic relativity
• Different languages allow different messages.
• What effect does this have on the way we think?– Do we live in different mental worlds?– Or do we just communicate differently?
26
Applications of linguistics
• In IT:– predictive texting– Google translate
• Speech therapy• Dictionary and grammar writing• Language education
– English, e.g. phonics, grammar– Foreign, e.g. course books
27
The difficulty of linguistics
• Language is complex– Arguably, the most complex structure in the
universe!• So we desperately need a good theory
– But it’s hard to build a theory for such a complex object
• But the challenge is rewarding.
28
The Linguistics Olympiad
• The UK Linguistics Olympiad is like the Maths Challenge and Olympiad– except that it’s all about language
• Three levels– the Advanced level selects winners for
• Round 2 (residential)• the UK team to the International Linguistics
Olympiad
• Here’s a sample problem.
29
Ulwa (Nicaragua)
30
Zooming in on Ulwa
-ni = "our (inc)"
-ma = "your (sing)"
-kana = "their"
-mana = "your (plur)"
'infix'suffix
31
What’s going on in Ulwa?
• Why does a ‘possessive’ affix – sometimes appear at the end of a word, – and sometimes in the middle?
• The suffix follows the first long syllable– VV: diimuih + kana = diikanamuih – VVC: gaad + ni = gaadni
• Otherwise it follows the second syllable– CVCV: bilam + kana = bilamkana
32
Why not try it out?
• Try the Linguistics Olympiad– See www.uklo.org for (a lot) more.
• Try Linguistics for your degree– on its own or with other subjects.
• Linguistics combines – the human interest of human language– the rigour of mathematics– the breadth of area studies– the usefulness of engineering– the challenge of sudoku and cross-word puzzles.