the labor theory of value and the concept
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
1/44
Ali RehmanKhizar bin NasirUmair Kiani
Saquib iqbalArmaghan Khan
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
2/44
Define value by reference to exchange-value
Exchange-value is a property of things which are
desired
In Marxian Language, then, it is a property of
use-values
Property, not of all use-values, but of those use-
values which are bought and sold
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
3/44
Exchange-value, then, is a property ofcommodities
Exchange-value of a commodity is its power ofexchanging against quantities of other
commodities.
Exchange-value is measured by the number ofcommodities of any other kind for which it will
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
4/44
The central claim of the labor theory of value isthat magnitude of value is determined by socially
necessary labor time
The exchange-value of a commodity variesdirectly and uniformly with the quantity of labortime required to produce it under standardconditions of productivity
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
5/44
Inversely and uniformly with the quantity of labortime standardly required to produce other
commodities, and with no further circumstance.
The labor theory of value is not true by the very
definition of value, as we defined it.
Alternative presentations
Value is defined as socially necessary labor time
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
6/44
We have two propositions
(1) Socially necessary labor time determines
value.(2) Value determines equilibrium price.
We say that (2) is true by definition. Others saythat ( 1 )
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
7/44
The conjunction of ( 1 ) and (2) entails
(3) Socially necessary labor time determinesequilibrium price
Author says that 3 is wrong by the definition.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
8/44
The labor theory of surplus value is intended toexplain the origin of non-wage income under
capitalism.
Under capitalism labor power is a commodity
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
9/44
The value of labour power is the value of themeans of subsistence necessary for themaintenance of the labourer.
The origin of non-wage income is, then, thedifference between the value of labor power andthe value produced by him in whom it inheres
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
10/44
The capital paid out as wages is equal to thevalue of the producer's labor power. It is knownas variable capital
The value produced by the worker over andabove that represented by variable capital iscalled surplus value
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
11/44
The ratio of surplus value to variable capital iscalled the rate of exploitation
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
12/44
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
13/44
Author begin with an argument which is basedon the labor theory of value
Which Conclusion is that the worker is exploited.
Author call it the Traditional Marxian Argument.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
14/44
It may be attributed to those believers in (4) whohold that the labor theory of value supports (4)
(4) Stated that One reason for overthrowingcapitalism is that it is a regime of exploitation(and exploitation is unjust).
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
15/44
1. Labor and labor alone creates value.
2. The labourer receives the value of his laborpower.
3. The value of the product is greater than thevalue of his labor power.
4. The labourer receives less value than he
creates.5. The capitalist receives the remaining value.
6. The labourer is exploited by the capitalist
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
16/44
(1) comes from the labor theory of value, and thelabor theory of surplus value supplies premises(2), (3), and (5).
This statement of the Traditional MarxianArgument is incomplete.
The incompleteness is the argument's failure, asstated, to characterize pertinent features of therelationship between capital and labor
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
17/44
As the fact that the labourer is forced, by hispropertylessness, to work for the capitalist.
The Traditional Argument, speaks of "thelabourer" and "the capitalist," therebyindividualizing the class relationship, in imitationof Capital's practice
This sidesteps the problem of identifying theworking and capitalist classes
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
18/44
The Traditional Argument employs the labortheory of surplus value, which yields premises(2), (3), and (5).
Author modify these point that depend on theLabor theory of surplus.
The result is this simpler Marxian argument
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
19/44
Labor and labor alone creates value.
(Add.)The capitalist receives some of the value
of the product.
The labourer receives less value than hecreates.
The capitalist receives some of the value thelabourer creates.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
20/44
The labor theory of surplus value is, then,unnecessary to the moral claim Marxists makewhen they say that capitalism is exploitative
It does not matter what explains the differencebetween the value the worker produces and thevalue he receives, there will always be somedifference.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
21/44
Labor theory of value, states that the value of acommodity is determined by the sociallynecessary labor time required to produce it.
Suppose a commodity has a certain value at atime t. Then that value, says the labor theory, isdetermined by the socially necessary labor timerequired to produce a commodity of that kind.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
22/44
The amount of time required to produce it in thepast, and, the amount of time actually spentproducing it are magnitudes strictly irrelevant to
its value, if the labor theory is true.
The theory demands that past labor is irrelevantto how much value a commodity now has, Butpast labor would not be irrelevant if it created thevalue of the commodity. It follows that labor doesnot create value, if the labor theory of value is
true.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
23/44
Suppose the thesis that value is determined by sociallynecessary labor time-that is, the labor theory of value
1. the strict doctrine, and let us say that such sentencesas , or ones which speak of value as embodied orcongealed labor, belong to the
2. Popular doctrine
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
24/44
There are two reasons why the amount of laborwhich was actually spent on a particular productmight differ from the amount now standard
required to produce that kind of product.
1. The first is a non-standard level of efficiency inthe actual labor process, which can be more orless efficient than the social norm.
2. The second is techno-logical change, which
alters that norm.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
25/44
Consider the case of inefficient labor. Marxists have
always regarded it as a particularly inept criticism of
the labor theory of value to object that it entails that
an inefficiently produced lamp has more value thanone produced efficiently and therefore in less time.
If inefficient labor takes more time, should that lamp
be considered to be of more value?
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
26/44
What was required in the past, and still more what
happened in the past-these facts are in principle irrelevant
to how much value a commodity has, if the labor theory
of value is true.
Since technical conditions change relatively slowly, sociallynecessary labor time in the recent past is usually a goodguide to socially necessary labor time now.
Typical past actual labor time is, moreover, the best guideto how much labor time was necessary in the past.Thereby what did occur becomes a good index of what isnow required. It does not follow that it creates the value of
the commodity
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
27/44
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
28/44
Value determined by what???
Ownership or the labor?
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
29/44
But if value is something the explanation ofwhich must literally create it, then sinceownership of means of production literally
creates nothing, it would follow that, despiteappearances the pattern of that ownershipcannot effect value formation
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
30/44
But this line of defense depends essentially onthe idea that labor creates value. If we stay withthe strict doctrine, which rightly does not requirethat anything creates value, it has no motivation
what so-ever. To make this more clear, we returnto the three propositions in our initialpresentation of the labor theory of value:
( 1) Socially necessary labor time determinesvalue.
(2) Value determines equilibrium price.
(3) Socially necessary labor time determines
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
31/44
Labor theory Is proven wrong by his owncontradiction
Differences of phrasing
This does not answer the difficult question, Who
is a producer?
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
32/44
The laborer is the only person who creates theproduct, that which has value.
The capitalist receives some of the value of theproduct. .
The laborer receives less value than the value ofwhat he creates, and
The capitalist receives some of the value ofwhat the la-borer creates.
The laborer is exploited by the capitalist.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
33/44
It is labor's creation of what has value, not its(sup-posed) creation of value, which founds thecharge that capitalism is a system of exploitation.
Even if labor did create its own value, still wouldhave no bearing on the question of exploitation.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
34/44
Value is created by desire and not by labor
It remains true that labor creates all that has
value, and that the capitalist appropriates someof the value, does the charge of exploitation loseforce?
Surely not.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
35/44
Then the assertion that the workers create valuecannot be necessary to that charge
If labor's creation of value would give the laborer
a claim to value because he had created it? Then the desirers could claim to
Absurd notion
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
36/44
Absurd but does not seem like it
Impossible to forget that labor creates what has
value
Naturally think that they could create value only
by creating what has it
In solidarity they state only that we are
exploited with out mentioning about value
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
37/44
So in the end its not that labor creates value
Its only the obvious truth that labor creates somethingthat has value.
The real paradigm of exploitation in Marxism, it is theexploitation of the feudal serf, who does not, according toMarx, produce value
His exploitation is the most mani-fest.
The proletarian's is more covert
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
38/44
Marx seeks to show that he too is exploited
Part of what he produces redounds not to him
but to his feudal superior
This is not so in the same plain sense under
capi-talism
Now Marxists allege that the labor theory ofvalue is required to un-cover the exploitation ofthe wage worker
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
39/44
Authors disagreement
What we need is the concept of value, as
defined, independently of the labor theory
Marxists say that
1. The serf produces the whole product, but thefeudal lord appropriates part of the product
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
40/44
2. The serf produces the whole product, but thefeudal lord appropriates part of the product
Author agrees with 1 however alter 2 to say
The proletarian produces the whole product, but
the capitalist appropriates part of the value of theproduct
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
41/44
Author continuously denies that labor creates itsvalue
Although it can be said that Since labor createswhat has value, labor creates value
But the objection is misguide
It is not the relevant traditional sense, thatintended by Marxists
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
42/44
How could it follow from the fact that laborcreates what has value that the amount of valuein what it creates varies directly and uniformly
with the amount of labor expended?
If an artist creates a beautiful object out ofsomething which was less beautiful, then we find
it natural to say that he creates beauty.
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
43/44
Similarly natural to say of a worker who creates avaluable object out of something less valuablethat he creates value
But that would not support the popular version ofthe labor theory of value,
If anything justifies the Marxian charge that thecapitalist exploits the worker
That workers alone create the product
-
8/2/2019 The Labor Theory of Value and the Concept
44/44
THANK YOU AND MOST
WELCOME FOR HEALTHYDISCUSSION