the iraq wars theo farrell, csi lecture 5, 2011
TRANSCRIPT
The Iraq WarsTheo Farrell, CSI Lecture 5, 2011
1990-91 Gulf War: timeline
Bill from Iraq to Kuwait for $24.5 b (16 July 1990)
Invasion of Kuwait (2 August 1990)
UNSCR 660 demanding unconditional withdrawal
UNSCR 678 (29 Nov) authorising use of “all necessary means” and requiring Iraq withdrawal by 15 January 1991
1990-91 Gulf War: timeline
Bill from Iraq to Kuwait for $24.5 b (16 July 1990)
Invasion of Kuwait (2 August 1990)
UNSCR 660 demanding unconditional withdrawal
UNSCR 678 (29 Nov) authorising use of “all necessary means” and requiring Iraq withdrawal by 15 January 1991
Campaign phases
1. Op Desert Shield: build-up of defensive force (8 Aug – early Nov 1990)
2. Build-up of offensive force (8 Nov – 16 Jan 1991)
3. Op Desert Storm: air offensive (17 Jan – 23 Feb)
4. Op Desert Sabre: ground offensive (24 – 27 Feb).
Coalition Iraq
Force size
950,00 550,00
War dead >300 25-35,000
Air campaign
•1800 planes
•6 carriers
•43 days
•‘tank plinking’
Attrition of Iraqi forces in KTO (% destroyed)
Iraqi Air campaign
War total
Tanks 39 76APCs 32 55Artillery 47 90
Key questions
1.Why did Saddam invade Kuwait?
2.Why did the US fail to deter Iraq?
3.Was war necessary?
Key questions
1.Why did Saddam invade Kuwait?
2. Why did the US fail to deter Iraq?
3. Was war necessary?
Why invade?
Impasse with Iran
Economic crisis in Iraq
End of Cold War
Dispute with Kuwait
Assumption of US impotence
Was war necessary?
Did Bush “go the extra mile” for piece?
Saddam responded vaguely to proposals by ME states (22 Sept), Soviets (5 Oct), France (10 Oct), Ed Heath (21 Oct), and Soviets again (19 Feb)
Giving sanctions more time? Debate in Congress. Vote for war (12 Jan) – Senate 52/47 (House 250/183).
Why stop after 100 hours?
UNSCR 687 (3 April 1991)
Articles 8-10:
Iraq to get rid of chemical and biological weapons
Not to develop nuclear weapons
Not to acquire ballistic missiles with range over 150km
Containing Saddam
Sanctions regime
No fly zones
Road to war in 2003
UNSC 687 (April 1991)
UNSCOM destroy Iraq’s poison gas stockpile (1991-92)
Defection of head of Iraq’s WMD programme (1995) reveals Iraqi deception
Road to war (continued)
• collapse of UNSCOM process (1997)
• US/UK bombing (1998)
• Failure of UN sanctions materially: up to $3 b stolen annually from oil for food
morally: half million killed
Cost of sanctions regime
From 9/11 to Iraq War
Freedman: “worse-case analysis gained a new credibility”
the logic of prevention – Rice: “we don’t want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud.”
Neocons “hijack” US foreign policy – emphasise 3 Ms: moral certainty, military unilateralism and the Middle East
Iraq and Al Qaeda?
• CIA’s Oct 2002 NIE downplays connection
• Bush before Congress vote (Oct 8):
“Share a common enemy” and “have had high-level contacts that go back a decade.” Also “Iraq has trained al-Qaeda members in bombing-making and poisons and deadly gasses.”
Iraq and Al Qaeda?
Public ignorance (Jan/Sept 2003): 9/11 hijackers were Iraqi: 44%
Saddam behind 9/11 attacks: 32%
Iraq gave support to al-Qaeda: 51%
The case for war
“The threat from Iraq stands alone because it gathers the most serious dangers of our age in our place”
• WMD
• Murderous tyrant
• Tried to dominate Middle East
• Unrelenting hostility towards US
President Bush speech at Cincinnati, Ohio (Oct 2002)
Iraqi WMD
“Iraq has continued its WMA programs in defiance of UN resolutions and restrictions. Baghdad has chemical and biological weapons as well as missiles with ranges in excess of UN restrictions; if left unchecked, it probably will have a nuclear weapon during this decade.”
CIA report, October 2002
Legal case for war
678: carte blanche for US war
687: imposes cease-fire conditions
who determines ‘material breach’ and what are the implications?
1441: recognises ‘material breach’ but does not authorise use of force
Legal case for war
678: carte blanche for US war
687: imposes cease-fire conditions
who determines ‘material breach’ and what are the implications?
1441: recognises ‘material breach’ but does not authorise use of force
Balance of forces
Coalition
116,000 (US), 25,000 (UK)
V Corps (US Army): 3 Mech, 4ID, 101, 82
1 MEF (USMC): 1 Div, TF Tarawa, UK 1 Arm Div
Iraqi
350,000
20+ divisions
2,000 tanks, 3,700 Avs, 2,400 artillery, 300 aircraft
Petraeus takes charge (Jan. 2007)