the future of science advice in europe...europe 8 2.4. panel: the science advice ecosystem in...

30
THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE 13 November 2019 Helsinki Symposium report

Upload: others

Post on 13-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE

ADVICE IN EUROPE

13 November 2019Helsinki

Symposium report

Page 2: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

Contact

�e{)e��ŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹŸ�kþÏå

�ƚå�Úű)čĵŅĹƋ�ŎƐ

ŎLjLjLj��ųƚŸŸåĬŸØ��åĬčĜƚĵ

ÏŅĹƋ±ÏƋÄŸ±Şå±ţĜĹüŅ

Publisher

SAPEA

ÏxŅ�±Ï±ƋåÏĘ

{±ųĜŸåų�{Ĭ±ƋDŽ�ĉ±

ŎLjŎŎƀ��åųĬĜĹØ�:åųĵ±ĹƼ

�Ęå�ƋåƻƋ�Ņü�ƋĘĜŸ�ƵŅųĩ�ĜŸ�ĬĜÏåĹŸåÚ�ƚĹÚåų�ƋĘå�ƋåųĵŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå��ųå±ƋĜƴå��ŅĵĵŅĹŸ�eƋƋųĜÆƚƋĜŅĹ�ĬĜÏåĹÏå�

ƵĘĜÏĘ�ŞåųĵĜƋŸ�ƚĹųåŸƋųĜÏƋåÚ�ƚŸåØ�ŞųŅƴĜÚåÚ�ƋĘå�ŅųĜčĜűĬ�±ƚƋĘŅų�±ĹÚ�ŸŅƚųÏå�±ųå�ÏųåÚĜƋåÚţ��Ęå�

ĬĜÏåĹÏå�ĜŸ�±ƴ±ĜĬ±ÆĬå�±Ƌ�ĘƋƋŞ×xxÏųå±ƋĜƴåÏŅĵĵŅĹŸţŅųčxĬĜÏåĹŸåŸxÆƼxĉţLjţ�Fĵ±čåŸ�±ųå�ĜĹÏĬƚÚåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�

ĬĜÏåĹÏå�ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘå�±ÚÚĜƋĜŅűĬ�ŸƋĜŞƚĬ±ƋĜŅĹ�ƋʱƋ�±ĹƼ�Ĝĵ±čåŸ�ųåŞųŅÚƚÏåÚ�åĬŸåƵĘåųå�ĵƚŸƋ�ųåƋ±ĜĹ�ƋĘå�

ŞĘŅƋŅčų±ŞĘĜÏ�ÏųåÚĜƋ�ĬĜŸƋåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�ÚŅÏƚĵåĹƋţ

�ĘĜŸ�ÚŅÏƚĵåĹƋ�ʱŸ�ÆååĹ�ŞųŅÚƚÏåÚ�ÆƼ�ƋĘå��e{)e�ÏŅĹŸŅųƋĜƚĵţ��Ęå�ĜĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹØ�ü±ÏƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ŅŞĜĹĜŅĹŸ�

ŸåƋ�ŅƚƋ�ĜĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�ųåŞŅųƋ�±ųå�ƋĘŅŸå�Ņü�ƋĘå�±ƚƋĘŅųŸ�±ĹÚ�ÚŅ�ĹŅƋ�ĹåÏ域±ųĜĬƼ�ųåāåÏƋ�ƋĘå�ŅŞĜĹĜŅĹ�Ņü�ƋĘå�

)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹţ��Ęå��e{)e��ŅĹŸŅųƋĜƚĵ�ĜŸ�ĹŅƋ�ųåŸŞŅĹŸĜÆĬå�üŅų�ƋĘå�ƚŸå�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ĵ±Ƽ�Æå�ĵ±Úå�

Ņü�ƋĘå�ĜĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹ�ÏŅĹƋ±ĜĹåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�ųåŞŅųƋ�ÆƼ�±ĹƼŅĹåØ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚĜĹč�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĹĜŅĹ�ĜĹŸƋĜƋƚƋĜŅĹŸ�

±ĹÚ�ÆŅÚĜåŸ�Ņų�±ĹƼ�ŞåųŸŅĹ�±ÏƋĜĹč�ŅĹ�ƋĘåĜų�ÆåʱĬüţ

� F��c�ĿƀíěƐěĿíƖLjƐLjŎěƅěƅ

� %kF�ŎLjţƖƅƐĂƅxĘåĬŸĜĹĩĜěųåŞŅųƋ

� %ŅƵĹĬŅ±Ú±ÆĬå�üųŅĵ�ƵƵƵţŸ±Şå±ţĜĹüŅxåƴåĹƋŸxƋĘåěüƚƋƚųåěŅüěŸÏĜåĹÏåě±ÚƴĜÏåěĜĹěåƚųŅŞåx

� 8Ņų�ƴåųŸĜŅĹ�ĘĜŸƋŅųƼØ�Ÿåå�ޱčå�ĉ

�e{)eØ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�üŅų�{ŅĬĜÏƼ�ÆƼ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵĜåŸţ�ŠƖLjƖLjšţ�The future of science advice in

Europe: Symposium reportţ��åųĬĜĹ×��e{)eţ�ĘƋƋŞŸ×xxÚŅĜţŅųčxŎLjţƖƅƐĂƅxĘåĬŸĜĹĩĜ÷ųåŞŅųƋ

Page 3: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

The future of science advice in Europe�ƼĵŞŅŸĜƚĵ�ųåŞŅųƋ

13 November 2019

Page 4: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

Version history

Version Date Summary of changes

1.0 February 2020 First published version

Page 5: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

5

Table of contents1. Introduction 7

2. Programme summary 82.1. Welcome 8

2.2. Why are we here today? 8

2.3. Dialogue: The future of science advice in Europe 8

2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10

2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11

2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to the EU and Finland 12

3. Speakers and participants 133.1. Speakers 13

3.2. Participants 13

4. Outcomes 144.1. Key messages 14

4.2. Strategic outcomes for SAPEA 15

4.3. Successful innovations 17

Appendix 1: List of speakers 21

Appendix 2: List of participants 23

Appendix 3: List of messages formulated and debated by participants 26

Appendix 4: Acknowledgements 29

Page 6: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

6

About SAPEA�e{)e�Š�ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�üŅų�{ŅĬĜÏƼ�ÆƼ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵĜ埚�ÆųĜĹčŸ�ƋŅčåƋĘåų�ŅƚƋŸƋ±ĹÚĜĹč�

åƻŞåųƋĜŸå�ĜĹ�åĹčĜĹååųĜĹčØ�Ęƚĵ±ĹĜƋĜåŸØ�ĵåÚĜÏĜĹåØ�űƋƚų±Ĭ�±ĹÚ�ŸŅÏĜ±Ĭ�ŸÏĜåĹÏåŸ�üųŅĵ�Ņƴåų�ŎLjLj�

±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸØ�ƼŅƚĹč�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�±ĹÚ�Ĭå±ųĹåÚ�ŸŅÏĜåƋĜåŸ�±ÏųŅŸŸ�)ƚųŅŞåţ

�e{)e�ĜŸ�ޱųƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜÏå�aåÏʱĹĜŸĵţ��ŅčåƋĘåų�

ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘå�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸØ�Ƶå�ŞųŅƴĜÚå�ĜĹÚåŞåĹÚåĹƋ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�±ÚƴĜÏå�ƋŅ�

)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹåųŸ�ƋŅ�ŸƚŞŞŅųƋ�ƋĘåĜų�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹěĵ±ĩĜĹčţ��å�±ĬŸŅ�ƵŅųĩ�ƋŅ�ŸƋųåĹčƋĘåĹ�

ÏŅĹĹåÏƋĜŅĹŸ�ÆåƋƵååĹ�)ƚųŅŞåűŸ�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�±ĹÚ�eϱÚåĵƼ�cåƋƵŅųĩŸØ�±ĹÚ�ƋŅ�ŸƋĜĵƚĬ±Ƌå�

ÚåƱƋå�ĜĹ�)ƚųŅŞå�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜĹ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩĜĹčţ

�e{)e�ĜŸ�±�ÏŅĹŸŅųƋĜƚĵ�Ņü�Āƴå�eϱÚåĵƼ�cåƋƵŅųĩŸ×

� eϱÚåĵĜ±�)ƚųŅޱå±

� eXX)e×�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�8åÚåų±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�eϱÚåĵĜåŸ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ�±ĹÚ�Bƚĵ±ĹĜƋĜåŸ

� )e�e�×�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵĜåŸ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸŅųƼ��ŅƚĹÏĜĬ

� )ƚųŅě�e�)×�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅƚĹÏĜĬ�Ņü�eϱÚåĵĜåŸ�Ņü�eŞŞĬĜåÚ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸØ��åÏĘĹŅĬŅčĜåŸ�

±ĹÚ�)ĹčĜĹååųĜĹč

� 8)ea×�ƋĘå�8åÚåų±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵĜåŸ�Ņü�aåÚĜÏĜĹå

�e{)e�ĜŸ�üƚĹÚåÚ�ÆƼ�čų±ĹƋ�ƀƐƀĉƐƖ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĹĜŅĹűŸ�BŅųĜDŽŅĹ�ƖLjƖLj�ŞųŅčų±ĵĵåţ

Page 7: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

7

Introduction

1. Introduction�ŅÚ±ƼűŸ�ƵŅųĬÚ�ü±ÏåŸ�±Ĺ�ĜĹÏų屟ĜĹčĬƼ�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹƋåųÏŅĹĹåÏƋåÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�åĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋţ��ĘĜŸ�

ʱŸ�ŞųŅĵŞƋåÚ�ƋĘå�)��±ĹÚ�űƋĜŅűĬ�čŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋŸ�ƋŅ�ųåƋĘĜĹĩ�åƻĜŸƋĜĹč�ƋŅŅĬŸ�±ĹÚ�ŸƋųƚÏƋƚųåŸ�

üŅų�ÚåŸĜčĹĜĹč�ŞŅĬĜÏƼØ�±ĹÚ�ƋŅ�Ÿååĩ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜƴå�Ƶ±ƼŸ�ƋŅ�čŅƴåųĹţ

�ĘĜŸ�ųåƋĘĜĹĩĜĹč�åƻƋåĹÚŸ�±ĬŸŅ�ƋŅ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�±Ƌ�ÆŅƋĘ�±Ĺ�)��±ĹÚ�±�űƋĜŅűĬ�ĬåƴåĬţ�a±ĹƼ�

ĩåƼ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ƋƵåĹƋƼěĀųŸƋ�ÏåĹƋƚųƼ�ÚåŞåĹÚ�ŅĹ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ĀåĬÚŸ�ƵĘåųå�ƋĘå�

åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜŸ�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻØ�ƚĹÏåųƋ±ĜĹ�Ņų�ų±ŞĜÚĬƼ�åƴŅĬƴĜĹčØ�Ņų�ƵĘåųå�ƋĘåųå�ĜŸ�ÏŅĹƋųŅƴåųŸƼ�ÆŅƋĘ�

ƵĜƋĘĜĹ�±ĹÚ�ŅƚƋŸĜÚå�ƋĘå�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜƋƼţ

FĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�ÏŅĹƋåƻƋØ��e{)e�Ņųč±ĹĜŸåÚ�±�ŸƼĵŞŅŸĜƚĵ�ĜĹ�cŅƴåĵÆåų�ƖLjŎĿ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�ŸƚÆģåÏƋ�Ņü�The

future of science advice in Europe�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�c±ƋĜŅűĬ�aƚŸåƚĵ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚØ�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜţ��Ęå�åƴåĹƋ�

ÆųŅƚčĘƋ�ƋŅčåƋĘåų�ŸŅĵå�ƖLjLj�Ĭå±ÚĜĹč�Şų±ÏƋĜƋĜŅĹåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ŸÏĘŅĬ±ųŸ�üųŅĵ�±ųŅƚĹÚ�)ƚųŅŞå�ƋŅ�

ŞųŅƴĜÚå�åƻŞåųƋ�ĜĹŞƚƋ�±Ÿ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�ÚåƴåĬŅŞåÚ�ĜƋŸ�ĹåƻƋěčåĹåų±ƋĜŅĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ϱޱÆĜĬĜƋĜåŸØ�

±ĹÚ�ƋŅ�ŸåĹÚ�±�ÏĬå±ų�ĵ域±čå�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ĹåƵ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�

ĜĹ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩĜĹčţ

�Ęå�åƴåĹƋ�Ƶ±Ÿ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸåÚ�±ĹÚ�ųƚĹ�ĜĹ�ÏŅĬĬ±ÆŅų±ƋĜŅĹ�ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ޱųƋĹåųŸ×

� 8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ�ŠĬå±Ú�ޱųƋĹåų�±ĹÚ�ĘŅŸƋš

� eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� �ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�FĹĜƋĜ±ƋĜƴå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� �Ęå�kþÏå�Ņü�ƋĘå�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåų�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�ŠĜĹ�ĜƋŸ�ųŅĬå�±Ÿ�ĘŅĬÚĜĹč�ƋĘå�ųŅƋ±ƋĜĹč�

ŞųåŸĜÚåĹÏƼ�Ņü�ƋĘå��ŅƚĹÏĜĬ�Ņü�aĜĹĜŸƋåųŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĹĜŅĹš

� aĜĹĜŸƋųƼ�Ņü�)ÚƚϱƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ��ƚĬƋƚųåØ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

aŅųå�ĜĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚĜĹč�ųåÏŅųÚĜĹčŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ĬĜƴåŸƋųå±ĵ�ƴĜÚåŅ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�

ŞĬåűųƼ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹŸØ�ĜŸ�±ƴ±ĜĬ±ÆĬå�ŅĹ�ƋĘå��e{)e�ƵåÆŸĜƋå×�ƵƵƵţŸ±Şå±ţĜĹüŅxåƴåĹƋŸx

ƋĘåěüƚƋƚųåěŅüěŸÏĜåĹÏåě±ÚƴĜÏåěĜĹěåƚųŅŞåx

Page 8: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

8

Programme summary

2. Programme summary

2.1. Welcome

�Ęå�åƴåĹƋ�Æåč±Ĺ�ƵĜƋĘ�ƵŅųÚŸ�Ņü�ƵåĬÏŅĵå�üųŅĵ�I±±ĩĩŅ�UƚŅŸĵ±ĹåĹØ�čåĹåų±Ĭ�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼ�Ņü�

ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ÏŅŅųÚĜűƋŅų�Ņü��ŅĀØ�ƋĘå��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�

FĹĜƋĜ±ƋĜƴå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚØ�±�ŞųŅģåÏƋ�ƋŅ�ÚåƴåĬŅŞ�±�ĹåƵ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵţ

2.2. Why are we here today?

�ƵŅ�ŸĘŅųƋ�ĜĹƋųŅÚƚÏƋŅųƼ�±ÚÚų域åŸ�ŅƚƋĬĜĹåÚ�ƋĘå�ÏŅĹƋåƻƋ�üŅų�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋűŸ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹŸ×

� Risto NieminenØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸØ�ÚåŸÏųĜÆåÚ�

ƋĘå�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹÏå�Ņü�ŸåĹÚĜĹč�±�ĵ域±čå�üųŅĵ�)ƚųŅŞåűŸ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜƋƼ�

ƋŅ�ÆŅƋĘ�ƋĘå�ĹåƵ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹØ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ʱÚ�ģƚŸƋ�Ƌ±ĩåĹ�ŅþÏåØ�±ĹÚ�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�

čŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚØ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ŞųŅÏ域�Ņü�ųåĜĹƴåĹƋĜĹč�ĜƋŸ�ŅƵĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�

±ÚƴĜÏå�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵ�üŅų�ƋĘå�ƋƵåĹƋƼěĀųŸƋ�ÏåĹƋƚųƼţ

� Sierd CloetinghØ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå�ÆŅ±ųÚ�Ņü��e{)eØ�ŅƚƋĬĜĹåÚ�ƋĘå�ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸ�ü±ÏåÚ�ÆƼ�

ƋĘå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜƋƼØ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚĜĹč�ÆŅƋĘ�ƋĘå�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻĜƋƼ�Ņü�ƋŅÚ±ƼűŸ�ÆĜč�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�

ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĜĹÏų屟ĜĹč�ŸÏųƚƋĜĹƼØ�ÏųĜƋĜÏĜŸĵ�Ņų�åƴåĹ�ÚĜŸƋųƚŸƋ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ÆƼ�ŸŅĵå�

ޱųƋŸ�Ņü�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼţ�Bå�č±ƴå�ŸŅĵå�ƋĘŅƚčĘƋŸ�ŅĹ�ĘŅƵ�ƋĘåŸå�ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸ�ÏŅƚĬÚ�Æå�ĵåƋ�

ÆŅƋĘ�±Ƌ�±�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�ĬåƴåĬ�±ĹÚ�ƵĜƋĘĜĹ�ĜĹÚĜƴĜÚƚ±Ĭ�ÏŅƚĹƋųĜåŸţ

2.3. Dialogue: The future of science advice in Europe

e�üųååěų±ĹčĜĹč�ŅŞåĹĜĹč�ÚĜ±ĬŅčƚå�±ÚÚų域åÚ�ƋĘå�ŧƚåŸƋĜŅĹŸ�Ņü�ĘŅƵ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�

ĜĹāƚåĹÏåŸ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĹĜŅĹØ�ĘŅƵ�ƵåĬĬ�ƋĘå�ÏƚųųåĹƋ�ŸƼŸƋåĵ�ƵŅųĩŸØ�±ĹÚ�ĘŅƵ�ĜƋ�

ĵĜčĘƋ�åƴŅĬƴå�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�üƚƋƚųåţ

�Ęå�ĜĹƋåųĬŅÏƚƋŅųŸ�Ƶåųå×

� Pearl DykstraØ�ÚåŞƚƋƼ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå�)�űŸ�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ

� Wim van SaarloosØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå��ŅƼ±Ĭ�cåƋĘåųĬ±ĹÚŸ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�eųƋŸ�±ĹÚ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

�Ęå�ޱĹåĬ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĵŅÚåų±ƋåÚ�ÆƼ�a±ųģ±�a±ĩ±ųŅƵØ�ƴĜÏåěŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�

±ĹÚ�ÚĜųåÏƋŅų�Ņü��ĜŅÏåĹƋåų�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚţ

e�ĬĜƴåĬƼ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹ�üŅĬĬŅƵåÚØ�ƵĜƋĘ�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋĜŅĹŸ�üųŅĵ�±Ï±ÚåĵĜÏŸØ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸØ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�

ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹŸ�ŞųŅü域ĜŅűĬŸØ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�Ņü�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�c:kŸØ�±ĹÚ�ŅƋĘåų�

±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ĵåĵÆåųŸţ

Page 9: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

9

Programme summary

Challenges for science advice: Sierd Cloetingh (SAPEA/Tomi Setälä)

In dialogue: Wim van Saarloos and Pearl Dykstra (SAPEA/Tomi Setälä)

Page 10: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

10

Programme summary

2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland

8Ĝƴå�ޱĹåĬĬĜŸƋŸ�ÚåŸÏųĜÆåÚ�ÏƚųųåĹƋ�Ƶ±ƼŸ�ĜĹ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸ�Ÿååĩ�±ĹÚ�ŅÆƋ±ĜĹ�

ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåØ�±ĹÚ�ŅƚƋĬĜĹåÚ�ŞųŅčų域�ĵ±Úå�ŸŅ�ü±ų�ĜĹ��ŅĀØ�ƋĘå�ŞųŅģåÏƋ�ĬåÚ�ÆƼ�ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�

eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ�ƋŅ�ÚåƴåĬŅŞ�±�ĹåƵ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵ�üŅų�ƋĘå�

üƚƋƚųå×

� Heikki MannilaØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� Risto NieminenØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� Seppo MäättäØ�ÚĜųåÏƋŅų�čåĹåų±Ĭ�Ņü�ƋĘå�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�ŸƋų±ƋåčƼ�ƚĹĜƋ

� Lea KauppiØ�ÚĜųåÏƋŅų�čåĹåų±Ĭ�Ņü�ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå

� Johanna VuorelmaØ�ŞŅŸƋÚŅÏƋŅų±Ĭ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåų�±Ƌ��±ĵŞåųå��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼűŸ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå�üŅų�

eÚƴ±ĹÏåÚ��ŅÏĜ±Ĭ��åŸå±ųÏĘ

�Ęå�ޱĹåĬ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ÏʱĜųåÚ�ÆƼ�{ĜĬƴĜ��ŅųŸƋĜØ�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼ�Ņü�ŸƋ±Ƌå�üŅų�Ĭ±ÆŅƚų�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�aĜĹĜŸƋųƼ�Ņü�

)ÏŅĹŅĵĜÏ�eý±ĜųŸ�±ĹÚ�)ĵŞĬŅƼĵåĹƋţ

The science advice ecosystem in Finland: Pilvi Torsti (SAPEA/Tomi Setälä)

Page 11: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

11

Programme summary

2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions

%åĬåč±ƋåŸ�±ƋƋåĹÚåÚ�ŸåƴåĹ�ޱų±ĬĬåĬ�ĜĹƋåų±ÏƋĜƴå�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹŸ�ųƚĹ�ÆƼ�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸţ��Ęå�

ŸåŸŸĜŅĹŸ�ÏŅƴåųåÚ�±�ƴ±ųĜåƋƼ�Ņü�ŸƚÆģåÏƋŸ�ųåĬ±ƋåÚ�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�üƚƋƚųå�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåţ

Workshop title Organiser Summary (provided by organisers)

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜĹ�±�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻ�ƵŅųĬÚ

�e{)e�¼�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ

�å�ĀųŸƋ�ÆųĜåāƼ�Ÿƚĵĵ±ųĜŸåÚ�ƋĘå�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�åĵåųčĜĹč�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ųåƴĜåƵ�ųåŞŅųƋ�Making sense of science under conditions of complexity and uncertainty�ƵųĜƋƋåĹ�ÆƼ�ƋĘå��e{)e�ÏŅĹŸŅųƋĜƚĵØ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�åĹŸƚĜĹč�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�opinion �ÏĞåĻƒĞĀÏƐ±ÚƽĞÏåƐƒŇƐ)ƣŹŇŤå±ĻƐŤŇĮĞÏDž�ƵųĜƋƋåĹ�ÆƼ�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸţ�cåƻƋØ�Ƶå�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸåÚ�ƋĘå�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĜĵŞĬĜϱƋĜŅĹŸ�üŅų�Ņųč±ĹĜŸĜĹč�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ƋŅ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸţ

�Ęå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå×�±Ĺ�ŅŞåĹ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹ

�ŅƼ±Ĭ�cåƋĘåųĬ±ĹÚŸ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�eųƋŸ�±ĹÚ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

�ĘĜŸ�ĜĹƋåų±ÏƋĜƴå�±ĹÚ�ųåāåÏƋĜƴå�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞ�ŸƋ±ųƋåÚ�ƵĜƋĘ�±Ĺ�ĜĹƋųŅÚƚÏƋĜŅĹ�ÆƼ��Ĝĵ�ƴ±Ĺ��±±ųĬŅŅŸØ�ƵĘŅ�ųåāåÏƋåÚ�ÏųĜƋĜϱĬĬƼ�ŅĹ�ĘĜŸ�åƻŞåųĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ŞųŅŸ�±ĹÚ�ÏŅĹŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�%ƚƋÏĘ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŸƼŸƋåĵØ�±ĹÚ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ĘĜŸ�±Ï±ÚåĵƼţ�%ĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹŸ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�ĜŸŸƚåŸ�ų±ĜŸåÚ�ƋĘåĹ�ÏŅĹƋĜĹƚåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋƵŅ�čųŅƚŞŸØ�±ĹÚ�Ƶå�ĀűĬĬƼ�ƋŅŅĩ�ŸƋŅÏĩ�ƵĜƋĘ�±ĬĬ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�ƋŅčåƋĘåųţ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�±Ÿ�±�Ƌå±ĵ�ŸŞŅųƋ×�ĹåƵ�Şų±ÏƋĜÏåŸ�±ĹÚ�ŸĩĜĬĬŸ�üŅų�ÏŅĬĬ±ÆŅų±ƋĜŅĹ

eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�¼�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�±ÏƋĜƴĜƋĜåŸ�ϱĹ�±ĹÚ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�Æå�±ųų±ĹčåÚ�ĜĹ�ĵƚĬƋĜŞĬå�Ƶ±ƼŸØ�ŸĜĹÏå�ƋĘå�ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸ�Ņƚų�ŸŅÏĜåƋĜåŸ�ü±Ïå�ƴ±ųƼ�±Ÿ�±ĬŸŅ�ÚŅ�ƋĘå�Şų±ÏƋĜÏåŸ�ƋŅ�ʱĹÚĬå�±ĹÚ�ŸŅĬƴå�ƋĘåĵţ��ĘĜŸ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹ�ĬŅŅĩåÚ�ĜĹƋŅ�ƋĘå�ŞųĜĹÏĜŞĬåŸ�Ņü�ĘŅƵ�ƋŅ�ÚåĀĹå�ƋĘå�ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸØ�ĘŅƵ�ƋŅ�ÏĘŅŅŸå�Şų±ÏƋĜÏåŸ�üŅų�ÏŅĬĬ±ÆŅų±ƋĜŅĹ�ƵĜƋĘ�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹěĵ±ĩĜĹč�ĜĹŸƋĜƋƚƋĜŅĹŸØ�±ĹÚ�ĘŅƵ�ƋŅ�ĀĹÚ�±ĹÚ�ÏĘŅŅŸå�ƋĘå�ĵŅŸƋ�ŸƚĜƋ±ÆĬå�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸØ�ŸƋ±ĩåĘŅĬÚåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�Ņü�åĹÚěƚŸåųŸ�ƋŅ�ŅýåųØ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸ�±ĹÚ�ƚŸå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜĹ�ޱųƋĜÏƚĬ±ų�ŸĜƋƚ±ƋĜŅĹŸţ

{ƚƋƋĜĹč�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�±ĹÚ�ų屟ŅĹ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�Ęå±ųƋ�Ņü�ŞŅĬĜƋĜϱĬ�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹěĵ±ĩĜĹč

)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ�IŅĜĹƋ��åŸå±ųÏĘ��åĹƋųå

�ĘƼ�ĜŸ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜĹÏų屟ĜĹčĬƼ�ĜčĹŅųåÚ�ÆƼ�ŞŅĬĜƋĜÏĜ±ĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ƴŅƋåųŸũ�BŅƵ�ϱĹ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�ĜĹÏų屟å�ƋĘå�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ĜĵޱÏƋ�Ņü�ƋĘåĜų�ƵŅųĩũ�eƋƋåĹÚååŸ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸåÚ�ƋĘå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�Ņü�ƵĘƼ�åƴĜÚåĹÏåěĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ĜŸ�ŸŅ�ʱųÚ�±ĹÚ�ƵʱƋ�Ƶå�ϱĹ�ÚŅ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ĜƋţ

FĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜƴå�±ŞŞųŅ±ÏĘåŸ�ƋŅ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå

¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�ĘƼ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�ƼŅƚĹč�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ�Æå�Ƌ±ĩåĹ�ĜĹƋŅ�±ÏÏŅƚĹƋ�±Ÿ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜŸŅųŸũ�BŅƵ�ϱĹ�Ƶå�ŸƋųåĹčƋĘåĹ�ƋĘå�±ÆĜĬĜƋƼ�±ĹÚ�ƵĜĬĬ�ƋŅ�åĹč±čå�ĜĹ�ŸŅÏĜåƋ±Ĭ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹũ�eƋƋåĹÚååŸ�Ęå±ųÚ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜƴå�åƻ±ĵŞĬåŸ�Ņü�ÆƚĜĬÚĜĹč�ÏŅĹĹåÏƋĜŅĹŸ�ÆåƋƵååĹ�ƼŅƚĹč�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸØ�±ĹÚ�ģŅĜĹåÚ�±�ÚåĵŅĹŸƋų±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�±�ĹåƵ�ÚĜ±ĬŅčĜϱĬ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹ�ĵåƋĘŅÚ�ϱĬĬåÚ�ů�ĜĵåŅƚƋűţ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�üŅų�±�ŸƚŸƋ±ĜűÆĬå�üƚƋƚųå

:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ

)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ±Ĭ�ŸƚŸƋ±ĜűÆĜĬĜƋƼ�±ĹÚ�ÏĬĜĵ±Ƌå�ÏʱĹčå�ĵĜƋĜč±ƋĜŅĹ�±ųå�ƋŅŞ�ŞųĜŅųĜƋĜåŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ĹåƻƋ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�ƖLjŎĿôƖLjƖĉţ�BŅƵ�ϱĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋå�ƋŅ�±ÏĘĜåƴĜĹč�ƋĘåŸå�ŅÆģåÏƋĜƴåŸ�ĜĹ�)ƚųŅŞå�±ĹÚ�ÆåƼŅĹÚũ��ʱƋ�±ųå�ƋĘå�ŸŞåÏĜĀÏ�ĹååÚŸ�±ĹÚ�ÏʱĬĬåĹčåŸũ�eųå�ĹåƵ�üŅųĵŸ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĹååÚåÚ�ĜĹ�ŅųÚåų�ƋŅ�ĜĹüŅųĵ�åýåÏƋĜƴå�ŸƚŸƋ±ĜűÆĜĬĜƋƼ�±ĹÚ�ÏĬĜĵ±Ƌå�ŞŅĬĜÏĜåŸũ

e�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ĘŅųĜDŽŅĹěŸÏ±ĹĹĜĹč�ĵŅÚåĬ�üŅų�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�FĹĜƋĜ±ƋĜƴå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�Ęå�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞ�üŅÏƚŸåÚ�ŅĹ�±�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ĘŅųĜDŽŅĹěŸÏ±ĹĹĜĹč�ŞĜĬŅƋ�ƋʱƋ�Ƶ±Ÿ�Ĭ±ƚĹÏĘåÚ�ĜĹ�kÏƋŅÆåų�ƖLjŎĿ�ÆƼ�ƋĘå��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�FĹĜƋĜ±ƋĜƴå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚţ�FĹ�ƋĘå�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞØ�Ƶå�ŸĘ±ųåÚ�ƋĘå�Ĭ±ƋåŸƋ�ĹåƵŸ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�ŞĜĬŅƋØ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ�ƋĘå�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�ƋŅ�ģŅĜĹ�ƋĘå�Ƌå±ĵ�ƋŅ�ÏŅěÚåŸĜčĹ�ޱųƋŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ŞĜĬŅƋţ

Page 12: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

12

Programme summary

Workshop: Innovative approaches to science advice (SAPEA/Tomi Setälä)

2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to the EU and Finland

FĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�ÏĬŅŸĜĹč�ŞĬåűųƼ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹØ�üååÚƱÏĩ�±ĹÚ�ųåāåÏƋĜŅĹŸ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�Ú±ƼűŸ�ÚåƱƋåŸ�Ƶåųå�

±ƚčĵåĹƋåÚ�ÆƼ�±ÚƴĜÏå�üųŅĵ�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�ƵĘŅ�ʱÚ�ÆååĹ�±ƚÚĜƋĜĹč�

ŞųŅÏååÚĜĹčŸţ�8Ņų�ĵŅųå�ĜĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹ�ŅĹ�ƋĘåŸå�±ƚÚĜƋŅųŸØ�Ÿåå�ޱčå�Ŏƀţ

�Ęå�ŸƼĵŞŅŸĜƚĵ�åĹÚåÚ�ƵĜƋĘ�±�ĬĜƴåĬƼ�üųåå�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ÚåƱƋå�±ĵŅĹč�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�

ĵåĵÆåųŸØ�±ĹÚ�±�ŞĬåűųƼ�ƴŅƋå�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�ĵŅŸƋ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�ĵ域±čåŸ�ƋŅ�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋå�ƋŅ�

)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�±ĹÚ�űƋĜŅűĬ�čŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋŸ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�üƚƋƚųå�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåţ��ĘåŸå�ĵ域±čåŸ�

åĵåųčåÚ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ŞųåÏåÚĜĹč�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞŸ�±Ÿ�ƵåĬĬ�±Ÿ�ĵŅųå�ƋʱĹ�ĉLj�ÚĜŸƋĜĹÏƋ�ŞųŅŞŅŸ±ĬŸ�üųŅĵ�

±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ĵåĵÆåųŸØ�ÏŅĬĬåÏƋåÚ�±ĹÚ�ų±ĹĩåÚ�ƚŸĜĹč�±�ĬĜƴå�ŅĹĬĜĹå�ƴŅƋĜĹč�ŸƼŸƋåĵţ�8Ņų�ĵŅųå�

ÚåƋ±ĜĬŸØ�Ÿåå�ŮUåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸŰ�ŅĹ�ޱčå�Ŏĉţ

�Ęå�ÏĬŅŸĜĹč�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĵŅÚåų±ƋåÚ�ÆƼ��ŅÆƼ��±ųÚĵ±ĹØ�Ęå±Ú�Ņü�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹŸ�±Ƌ�

�e{)eţ

Page 13: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

13

Speakers and participants

3. Speakers and participants

3.1. Speakers

�Ęå�åƴåĹƋ�±ƋƋų±ÏƋåÚ�ŎƐ�ĜĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬ�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ŎƐ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸţ��e{)e�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�

8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�ޱĜÚ�ޱųƋĜÏƚĬ±ų�±ƋƋåĹƋĜŅĹ�ƋŅ�±ÏĘĜåƴĜĹč�čåĹÚåų�ƱĬ±ĹÏåØ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ųåŸƚĬƋåÚ�ĜĹ�

ŎƖ�ƵŅĵåĹ�±ĹÚ�Ŏĉ�ĵåĹ�±ĵŅĹč�ƋĘå�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸţ

�Ęå�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚåÚ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�Ņü�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸØ�ƼŅƚĹč�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸØ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸ�

ĜĹÏĬƚÚĜĹč�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹØ�ŅƋĘåų�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÆŅÚĜåŸØ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ĜĹŸƋĜƋƚƋåŸ�±ĹÚ�

ĹŅĹěčŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋ±Ĭ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸţ�aŅŸƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸ�Ƶåųå�ƋĘå�ƋŅŞ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�Ņü�

ƋĘåĜų�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸţ

e�üƚĬĬ�ĬĜŸƋ�Ņü�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸ�ĜŸ�ŞųŅƴĜÚåÚ�ĜĹ�eŞŞåĹÚĜƻ�Ŏ�ŅĹ�ޱčå�ƖŎţ

3.2. Participants

ŎƖŎ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�±ƋƋåĹÚåÚ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�ƴåĹƚå�±ĹÚ�ƅĿ�±ĹŅĹƼĵŅƚŸ�ŞåŅŞĬå�Ƶ±ƋÏĘåÚ�ƋĘå�ĬĜƴå�

ŸƋųå±ĵ�ŅĹĬĜĹåØ�üŅų�±�ƋŅƋ±Ĭ�Ņü�ŎĿLj�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸţ

eĵŅĹč�ƋĘå�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�ƴåĹƚå�Ƶåųå�Ÿåƴåų±Ĭ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸØ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚĜĹč�ŸåĹĜŅų�

ŸƋ±ý�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�ŅþÏå�±ĹÚ�ƴ±ųĜŅƚŸ�ĵĜĹĜŸƋųĜåŸţ�cƚĵåųŅƚŸ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�

Ņü�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�±ĹÚ�ƚĹĜƴåųŸĜƋĜåŸ�Ƶåųå�ŞųåŸåĹƋØ�±Ÿ�ƵåĬĬ�±Ÿ�ŸŅĵå�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�

Ņü�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ĜĹŸƋĜƋƚƋåŸţ��ƋƚÚåĹƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋ±ƋĜƴåŸ�Ņü�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸű�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�Ƶåųå�±ĬŸŅ�

ŞųåŸåĹƋţ

{±ųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�Ƶåųå�±ŸĩåÚ�üŅų�ƋĘåĜų�ŞåųĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�ƋŅ�ŞƚÆĬĜŸĘ�ƋĘåĜų�űĵåŸ�±ĹÚ�ģŅÆ�ƋĜƋĬåŸţ��ĘŅŸå�

ƵĘŅ�č±ƴå�ŞåųĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�±ųå�ŞųŅƴĜÚåÚ�ĜĹ�eŞŞåĹÚĜƻ�Ɩ�ŅĹ�ޱčå�ƖƐţ

Page 14: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

14

Outcomes

4. Outcomes�ĘĜŸ�åƴåĹƋ�ŠüŅųĵ±ĬĬƼØ�ƋĘå�ŞųåŸåĹƋ�ųåŞŅųƋ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋš�ĜŸ�ÚåĬĜƴåų±ÆĬå�ƐţƐ�Ņü�ƋĘå��e{)e�

ÏŅĹŸŅųƋĜƚĵ�ĜĹ�ųåŸŞåÏƋ�Ņü�čų±ĹƋ�±čųååĵåĹƋ�ƀƐƀĉƐƖ�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĹĜŅĹűŸ�BŅųĜDŽŅĹ�ƖLjƖLj�

ŞųŅčų±ĵĵåţ

FĹ�±ÚÚĜƋĜŅĹØ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�ʱÚ�±�ĹƚĵÆåų�Ņü�ĵ屟ƚų±ÆĬå�üŅųĵ±Ĭ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹüŅųĵ±Ĭ�ŅƚƋÏŅĵåŸ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�

±ųå�ÚåŸÏųĜÆåÚ�ÆåĬŅƵţ

4.1. Key messages

�Ęå�ŞųĜĵ±ųƼ�ŅƚƋÏŅĵå�üŅų�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�±Ÿ�±�ƵĘŅĬå�Ƶ±Ÿ�ƋŅ�üŅųĵƚĬ±Ƌå�±ĹÚ�ŸåĬåÏƋ�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�

ƋŅ�ŸåĹÚ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜƋƼ�Ņü�)ƚųŅŞåØ�±Ÿ�ųåŞųåŸåĹƋåÚ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�ƋŅ�

ÆŅƋĘ�ƋĘå�ĹåƵ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�čŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�±Ÿ�ĜƋ�ŸåƋ�ŅƚƋ�ƋŅ�Ïųå±Ƌå�

±�ĹåƵ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵţ��ĘåŸå�ĵ域±čåŸ�Ƶåųå�ÚåųĜƴåÚ�±ĹÚ�åĬ±ÆŅų±ƋåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋƵŅ�

ޱų±ĬĬåĬ�Ƶ±ƼŸ×

� )±ÏĘ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ŸåƴåĹ�ޱų±ĬĬåĬ�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞŸ�±ĹÚ�ĵĜĹĜěŸåŸŸĜŅĹŸ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸåÚ�±ĹÚ�±čųååÚ�ŅĹå�

Ņų�ĵŅųå�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ƋĘåƼ�ÏŅĹŸĜÚåųåÚ�ƋĘå�ĵŅŸƋ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�ŞŅĜĹƋŸ�ƋŅ�åĵåųčå�

üųŅĵ�ƋĘåĜų�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹŸţ

� FĹ�ƋĘå�ĀűĬ�ŞĬåűųƼ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹØ�ÚƚųĜĹč�ƋĘå�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ÚåƱƋåØ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�Ƶåųå�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ�ƋŅ�

ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋå�ƋĘåĜų�ŅƵĹ�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�ƚŸĜĹč�±�ĬĜƴå�ŅĹĬĜĹå�ƴŅƋĜĹč�ŸƼŸƋåĵţ��ĘåŸå�Ƶåųå�ƋĘåĹ�

±ÚÚåÚ�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ųåŸƚĬƋĜĹč�ĬĜŸƋ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ų±ĹĩåÚ�ÆƼ�

±�ųå±ĬěƋĜĵå�åĬåÏƋųŅĹĜÏ�ƴŅƋå�Ņü�±ĬĬ�ƋĘŅŸå�ŞųåŸåĹƋţ

4.1.1. Key messages from the workshops

Workshop title Key messages provided by workshop leaders

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜĹ�±�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻ�ƵŅųĬÚ

8Ņų�ƋĘå�)�ſ��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĹååÚŸ�ƋŅ�Æå�Ņųč±ĹĜŸåÚ�ŸŅ�ƋʱƋ�ĜƋ�ĜŸ�ĜĹÚåŞåĹÚåĹƋ�±ĹÚ�ƱŸåÚ�ŅĹ�ĜĹƋåųűĬ�ŧƚ±ĬĜƋƼ�ÏŅĹƋųŅĬØ�ÆƚƋ�ƼåƋ�ÏĬŅŸå�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ÏŅĹÏåųĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĹååÚŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�ĜĹ�čåĹåų±Ĭ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ƴ±ųĜŅƚŸ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�±ųåűŸ�ĜĹ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ƋĘåƼ�ĜĹƋåų±ÏƋţ

8Ņų�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ×��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�ÏųƚÏĜ±Ĭ�ޱųƋĜÏƚĬ±ųĬƼ�Ĝü�ĜŸŸƚåŸ�±ųå�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻØ�ƚĹÏåųƋ±ĜĹ�±ĹÚ�ÏŅĹƋåŸƋåÚţ�FƋűŸ�±ĬƵ±ƼŸ�ÆåƋƋåų�ƋʱĹ�ĜĹƋƚĜƋĜŅĹţ

�Ęå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå×�±Ĺ�ŅŞåĹ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹ

%Ņ�ĹŅƋ�ĵĜƻ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�üŅų�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�Š±ÚƴĜÏåš�±ĹÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�üŅų�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ŠĬŅÆÆƼĜĹčšţ

8Ņų�ĜĵޱÏƋ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ƼŅƚ�ĹååÚ�ƋŅ�ĜÚåĹƋĜüƼ�ƋĘå�ųåÏĜŞĜåĹƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ƵŅųĩ�ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘåĵ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ÆåčĜĹĹĜĹčţ

�ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�±ųå�ĹŅƋ�±�ޱŸŸĜƴå�ŸŅƚųÏå�Ņü�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�ÆƚƋ�±�ŞųŅ±ÏƋĜƴå�ųåŸŅƚųÏå�ƋŅ�åƻÏʱĹčå�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�ƵĜƋĘţ

Page 15: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

15

Outcomes

Workshop title Key messages provided by workshop leaders

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�±Ÿ�±�Ƌå±ĵ�ŸŞŅųƋ×�ĹåƵ�Şų±ÏƋĜÏåŸ�±ĹÚ�ŸĩĜĬĬŸ�üŅų�ÏŅĬĬ±ÆŅų±ƋĜŅĹ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�±�Ƌå±ĵ�ŸŞŅųƋţ�BŅƵ�ƋŅ�åĹč±čå�±ĹÚ�ĵŅƋĜƴ±Ƌå�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ×�ųåŸŞŅĹŸĜÆĜĬĜƋĜåŸ�ƋŅ�ƵŅųĩ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�ƋŅŞĜÏØ�ĵŅƋĜƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹÏåĹƋĜƴåŸ�ƋŅ�ƵŅųĩ�±ĹÚ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋåØ�åĹč±čåĵåĹƋ�ĹååÚåÚ�ÆƚƋ�ƋʱƋ�Úåĵ±ĹÚŸ�ųåŸŅƚųÏåŸţ

{ųŅÏ域åŸ�ĹååÚ�čŅŅÚ�ŞĬ±ĹĹĜĹčØ�ƋĜĵå�±ĹÚ�ƵåĬĬěƵŅųĩĜĹč�Ƌų±ĹŸŞ±ųåĹÏƼţ

{ƚƋƋĜĹč�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�±ĹÚ�ų屟ŅĹ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�Ęå±ųƋ�Ņü�ŞŅĬĜƋĜϱĬ�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹěĵ±ĩĜĹč

�Ęå�ŞųĜĹÏĜŞĬå�ƋʱƋ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�Æå�ĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ÆƼ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜŸ�ƚĹÚåų�ŸåųĜŅƚŸ�±ƋƋ±Ïĩţ�{ŅĬĜƋĜÏĜ±ĹŸØ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�ĹååÚ�ƋŅ�ÚåüåĹÚ�ƋĘĜŸ�ÏŅųĹåųŸƋŅĹå�Ņü�ĬĜÆåų±Ĭ�ÚåĵŅÏų±ÏƼţ

FĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜƴå�±ŞŞųŅ±ÏĘåŸ�ƋŅ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå

FĹ�ŅųÚåų�ƋŅ�åĹŸƚųå�ƋĘå�ŞĬƚų±ĬĜƋƼ�Ņü�ƴŅĜÏåŸ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�Ƌų±ĜĹĜĹč�Ņü�üƚƋƚųå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�Ĭå±ÚåųŸØ�ƼŅƚĹč�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�±ĹÚ�)ƚųŅŞå�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�ʱƴå�±�ųåÏŅčĹĜDŽåÚØ�ŸƚŞŞŅųƋåÚ�±ĹÚ�üŅųĵ±Ĭ�ųŅĬå�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵŸ�ŠŅü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚx)ƚųŅŞåšţ

8ƚƋƚųå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵŸ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�Ƌ±ĩå�ĜĹƋŅ�±ÏÏŅƚĹƋ�ƋĘå�ŞĬƚų±ĬĜƋƼ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ƋŅŅĬŸ�ƋʱƋ�ϱĹ�Æå�ƚŸåÚ�ƋŅ�ĬåčĜƋĜĵĜŸå�ƋĘå�ŞŅŸĜƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼţ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�üŅų�±�ŸƚŸƋ±ĜűÆĬå�üƚƋƚųå

�ŅÏĜ±ĬØ�ŞŅĬĜƋĜϱĬ�±ĹÚ�ƋåÏĘĹŅĬŅčĜϱĬ�ŸÏĜåĹÏåŸ�ϱĹ�ƋåĬĬ�ƚŸ�ƋĘå�ŮĘŅƵŰØ�ĹŅƋ�ģƚŸƋ�ƋĘå�ŮƵʱƋŰţ

Ë�ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚÌ�ÆåƋƋåų�ƚĹÚåųŸƋ±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹÏå�Ņü�ƴ±ĬƚåŸØ�åĵŅƋĜŅĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ÆåĬĜåüŸţ�Š{ĘĜĬŅŸŅŞĘåųŸ�ϱĹ�ĘåĬŞţš

e�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ĘŅųĜDŽŅĹěŸÏ±ĹĹĜĹč�ĵŅÚåĬ�üŅų�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

8Ņų�ƋĘå�)�×�XŅƵ�ĘĜåų±ųÏĘĜåŸØ�ĘĜčĘ�ŸŅÏĜåƋ±Ĭ�ƋųƚŸƋØ�±ĹÚ�ĘĜčĘ�ƋųƚŸƋ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�åűÆĬå�åƻŞåųĜĵåĹƋ±ƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�ĜĹ�ÚåƴåĬŅŞĜĹč�üƚƋƚųå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ϱޱÆĜĬĜƋĜåŸţ

8Ņų�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ×��ŅĬÚ�ŞĜĬŅƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ޱƋĜåĹÏå�±ųå�ƋĘå�ĩåƼ�üŅų�ĬŅĹčěƋåųĵ�ŸƼŸƋåĵĜÏ�ÏʱĹčåţ�8ĬåƻĜÆĜĬĜƋƼØ�åĹč±čåĵåĹƋ�ĜĹ�ĹåƋƵŅųĩŸ�ƵĘåųå�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�åƻĜŸƋŸţ

4.1.2. Key messages following the audience debate and vote

8ŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ƋĘå�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ÚåƱƋåØ�ƋĘå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ƋƵŅ�ĵ域±čåŸ�åĵåųčåÚ�ģŅĜĹƋĬƼ�ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘå�

ĘĜčĘåŸƋ�ĹƚĵÆåų�Ņü�ƴŅƋåŸ×

�Ęå�ŞųĜĹÏĜŞĬå�ƋʱƋ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�Æå�ĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ÆƼ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜŸ�ƚĹÚåų�ŸåųĜŅƚŸ�±ƋƋ±Ïĩţ�{ŅĬĜƋĜÏĜ±ĹŸØ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�ĹååÚ�ƋŅ�ÚåüåĹÚ�ƋĘĜŸ�ÏŅųĹåųŸƋŅĹå�Ņü�ĬĜÆåų±Ĭ�ÚåĵŅÏų±ÏƼţ

Ë�ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚÌ�ÆåƋƋåų�ƚĹÚåųŸƋ±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹÏå�Ņü�ƴ±ĬƚåŸØ�åĵŅƋĜŅĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ÆåĬĜåüŸţ�Š{ĘĜĬŅŸŅŞĘåųŸ�ϱĹ�ĘåĬŞţš

e�üƚĬĬ�ĬĜŸƋ�Ņü�ĵ域±čåŸ�åĵåųčĜĹč�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ÚåƱƋå�ĜŸ�ŞųŅƴĜÚåÚ�ĜĹ�eŞŞåĹÚĜƻ�Ɛ�ŅĹ�

ޱčå�Ɩƅţ

4.2. Strategic outcomes for SAPEA

4.2.1. Measurable impact on audience understanding and attitudes

�e{)e�ÏŅĹÚƚÏƋåÚ�±�ÚåƋ±ĜĬåÚ�åƴ±Ĭƚ±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�ƚŸĜĹč�ŸƋųƚÏƋƚųåÚ�ŅÆŸåųƴ±ƋĜŅĹŸØ�

ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋ�ŧƚåŸƋĜŅĹűĜųåŸØ�ŸŅÏĜ±Ĭ�ĵåÚĜ±�±Ĺ±ĬƼƋĜÏŸ�±ĹÚ�±ŞŞ�ƚŸ±čå�±Ĺ±ĬƼƋĜÏŸţ��ĘĜŸ�

åƴ±Ĭƚ±ƋĜŅĹ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĜĹƋåĹÚåÚ�ĹŅƋ�ŅĹĬƼ�ƋŅ�ŞųŅƴĜÚå�±�ųŅÆƚŸƋ�Ƶ±Ƽ�ƋŅ�ĵ屟ƚųå�ƋĘå�ĜĵޱÏƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�

åƴåĹƋ�±ĹÚ�ĜĵŞųŅƴå�ŸĜĵĜĬ±ų�åƴåĹƋŸ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�üƚƋƚųåØ�ÆƚƋ�±ĬŸŅ�ƋŅ�±ÏƋ�±Ÿ�±�ŞųŅŅüěŅüěÏŅĹÏåŞƋ�üŅų�

ŸƚÏĘ�ŸƋųƚÏƋƚųåÚ�åƴ±Ĭƚ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�ƵĜƋĘĜĹ�ƋĘå�üų±ĵåƵŅųĩ�Ņü�ƋĘå��e{)e�ÏŅĹŸŅųƋĜƚĵţ

Page 16: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

16

Outcomes

eĵŅĹč�ƋĘå�ÏŅĹÏĬƚŸĜŅĹŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�åƴ±Ĭƚ±ƋĜŅĹ�Ƶåųå�ƋĘå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ŅƚƋÏŅĵåŸ×

� {±ųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�Ƶåųå�ĘĜčĘĬƼ�åĹč±čåÚØ�ƵĜƋĘ�Ņƴåų�ƐĂŢ�ÏŅĵŞĬåƋĜĹč�±�ƴŅĬƚĹƋ±ųƼ�ŸƚųƴåƼ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�

åĹÚ�Ņü�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋţ

� �Ęå�ĵ±ģŅųĜƋƼ�Ņü�ųåŸŞŅĹÚåĹƋŸ�ųåŞŅųƋåÚ�ƋʱƋ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�ĜĹÏų屟åÚ�ƋĘåĜų�ĜĹƋåųåŸƋ�ĜĹ�)��

ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩĜĹčţ

� cå±ųĬƼ�±ĬĬ�ųåŸŞŅĹÚåĹƋŸ�Ƶåųå�Ņü�ƋĘå�ŅŞĜĹĜŅĹ�ƋʱƋ��e{)eűŸ�ųŅĬå�ĜĹ�)��ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩĜĹč�ĜŸ�

åĜƋĘåų�ƴåųƼ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�Ņų�ŸŅĵåƵʱƋ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋţ

� a±ĹƼ�ųåŸŞŅĹÚåĹƋŸ�±ÚÚåÚ�üųåå�ƋåƻƋ�ÏŅĵĵåĹƋŸ�ĜĹÚĜϱƋĜĹč�ƋĘå�ĘĜčĘĬĜčĘƋŸ�üŅų�ƋĘåĵ�Ņü�

ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚåÚ×

� ŞĬåűųƼ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ÚåƱƋåŸ

� ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞŸ�±ĹÚ�ĵĜĹĜěŸåŸŸĜŅĹŸ

� ĹåƋƵŅųĩĜĹč�ŅŞŞŅųƋƚĹĜƋĜåŸ

� ƋĘå�ĜĹÏĬƚŸĜŅĹ�Ņü�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜƴå�åĬåĵåĹƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ĹåƵ�ü±ÏåŸ

� ƋĘå�ŧƚ±ĬĜƋƼ�Ņü�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹ

(SAPEA/Tomi Setälä)

4.2.2. Broader conversations on social media

�Ęå�åƴåĹƋ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ŸƚÏÏ域üƚĬ�ĜĹ�åĹč±čĜĹč�ÚĜƴåųŸå�ĵåĵÆåųŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜƋƼ�ŅĹ�ŸŅÏĜ±Ĭ�

ĵåÚĜ±�ÆåƼŅĹÚ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�ĜƋŸåĬüţ�Ŏƅĉ�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ��ƵĜƋƋåų�ƚŸåųŸ�üųŅĵ�ĵ±ĹƼ�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�ŸƋ±ĩåĘŅĬÚåų�

čųŅƚŞŸ�ƋŅŅĩ�ޱųƋ�ĜĹ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹŸ�ƚŸĜĹč�ƋĘå�ʱŸĘƋ±č�ńŸÏĜ±ÚƴĜÏåŎĿØ�ųåŸƚĬƋĜĹč�ĜĹ�ĂLjƖ�ƋƵååƋŸ�

Page 17: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

17

Outcomes

ƵĜƋĘ�±�ÏŅĵÆĜĹåÚ�ųå±ÏĘ�Ņü�ƀŎĉƤƖíƐ�ŞåŅŞĬå�ŠƋĘŅƚčĘ�ƋĘĜŸ�ĵ±Ƽ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚå�ŸŅĵå�ÚŅƚÆĬåě

ÏŅƚĹƋĜĹč�Ĝü�ƋĘŅŸå�ĜĹƴŅĬƴåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ÏŅĹƴåųŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�ʱƴå�±�ĬŅƋ�Ņü�ŅƴåųĬ±Ş�ĜĹ�üŅĬĬŅƵåųŸšţ

�Ęå�ĵŅŸƋ�ŸĜčĹĜĀϱĹƋ�ŸŅÏĜ±Ĭ�ĵåÚĜ±�ĜĹāƚåĹÏåųŸ�ƵĘŅ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹŸ�Ƶåųå�

üųŅĵ�±ÏųŅŸŸ�)ƚųŅŞå�ŠĜţåţ�ĹŅƋ�ĬŅϱĬ�ƋŅ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚš�±ĹÚ�čåĹåų±ĬĬƼ�ĹŅƋ�ŞųåŸåĹƋ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋţ

4.2.3. Follow-up and associated events

FĹüŅųĵ±Ĭ�üååÚƱÏĩ�±ĹÚ�üŅĬĬŅƵěƚŞ�üųŅĵ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�ʱŸ�ĘĜčĘĬĜčĘƋåÚ�ƋĘå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ĜĹüŅųĵ±Ĭ�

ŅƚƋÏŅĵåŸ�üŅų�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ×

� %ƚå�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ÏĬŅŸå�ĜĹƴŅĬƴåĵåĹƋ�Ņü�ƼŅƚĹč�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�ƋĘå�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�±ĹÚ�

�åĬčĜ±Ĺ�ƼŅƚĹč�±Ï±ÚåĵĜåŸ�±ųå�Ņųč±ĹĜŸĜĹč�±�ŸåĵĜűų�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�üƚƋƚųå�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜĹ�

�ųƚŸŸåĬŸ�ĜĹ�ƖLjƖLjØ�±ĹÚ�ʱƴå�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ��e{)e�ƋŅ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋåţ

� e�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�ĵåĵÆåų�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�{±ųĬĜ±ĵåĹƋ�ŸåĹƋ�±�ƴĜÚåŅ�ĵ域±čå�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�±ĹÚ�

ʱŸ�åƻŞų域åÚ�±Ĺ�ĜĹƋåųåŸƋ�ĜĹ�Ĭå±ųĹĜĹč�ĵŅųå�±ÆŅƚƋ��e{)e�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå��eaţ

� 8ŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ƋĘå�ŸƚÏÏ域üƚĬ�ĜĹÏĬƚŸĜŅĹ�Ņü�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�±ƚÚĜƋŅųŸ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�ŠŸåå�ޱčå�

ŎƀšØ�ƋĘåŸå�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ŅƋĘåųŸ�ŞĬ±ĹĹåÚ�ƋŅ�Ïųå±Ƌå�±Ĺ�ĜĹüŅųĵ±Ĭ�)�ěƵĜÚå�ĹåƋƵŅųĩ�

ƋŅ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸ�ŸƋųåĹčƋĘåĹĜĹč�ƋĘå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå

� �e{)e�ʱŸ�ÆååĹ�±ŞŞųŅ±ÏĘåÚ�ÆƼ�±�%ƚƋÏĘ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹ�ƵŅųĩĜĹč�ƵĜƋĘ�XåĜÚåĹ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�

ƋŅ�ģŅĜĹ�ƋĘå�ŞųŅčų±ĵĵå�ÏŅĵĵĜƋƋåå�üŅų�ĜĹ�±Ĺ�ĜĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬ�ÏŅĹüåųåĹÏå�ŅĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�

±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜĹ�ƖLjƖLj

� e��ųƚŸŸåĬŸěƱŸåÚ�ŞŅĬĜƋĜϱĬ�ģŅƚųűĬĜŸƋ�±ŞŞųŅ±ÏĘåÚ��e{)e�ƋŅ�åŸƋ±ÆĬĜŸĘ�ÏŅĹƋ±ÏƋ

� �ƵŅ�űƋĜŅűĬěĬåƴåĬ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�ʱƴå�ƴŅĬƚĹƋååųåÚ�ƋŅ�

ÚĜŸŸåĵĜűƋå�ƋĘå�ŅƚƋÏŅĵåŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�åŸŞåÏĜ±ĬĬƼ�ƋĘå�ĵ域±čåŸ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�

±ÚƴĜÏåØ�ƋŅ�ƋĘåĜų�ŅƵĹ�±ƚÚĜåĹÏåŸ

4.3. Successful innovations

%ƚųĜĹč�ƋĘå�ŸƼĵŞŅŸĜƚĵØ��e{)e�±ĹÚ�ĜƋŸ�ޱųƋĹåųŸ�ƋųĜ±ĬĬåÚ�ƋƵŅ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�Ƶåųå�

ŞŅŸĜƋĜƴåĬƼ�ųåÏåĜƴåÚ�±ĹÚ�ϱĹ�Æå�Ƌ±ĩåĹ�üŅųƵ±ųÚ�üŅų�üƚƋƚųå�åƴåĹƋŸţ

4.3.1. Civil society auditors

eĹ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�ŞųĜŅųĜƋƼ�üŅų��e{)e�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�Ņųč±ĹĜŸĜĹč�ޱųƋĹåųŸ�ĜŸ�ƋŅ�ĀĹÚ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜƴå�Ƶ±ƼŸ�ƋŅ�

ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋå�ƵĜƋĘ�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�üŅų�ŞŅĬĜÏƼØ�±ĹÚ�ƋŅ�ĜĹƴŅĬƴå�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�

ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŞųŅÏ域ţ�8Ņų�ƋĘĜŸ�ų屟ŅĹØ�±�ޱĹåĬ�Ņü�ů±ƚÚĜƋŅųŸű�üųŅĵ�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�

ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ�ƋŅ�±ƋƋåĹÚ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�±Ÿ�ůÏųĜƋĜϱĬ�üųĜåĹÚŸű�

ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜƋƼØ�ŞųŅƴĜÚå�üååÚƱÏĩ�ÚƚųĜĹč�ƋĘå�Ú±ƼØ�±ĹÚ�Ĭå±Ú�ƋĘå�ĀűĬ�

ÆųŅ±Ú�ŞĬåűųƼ�ÚåƱƋå×

� Marzia MazzonettoØ�)�ě�ĜƋĜDŽåĹţ�ÏĜåĹÏå�ŞųŅģåÏƋ�ĵ±Ĺ±čåų

Page 18: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

18

Outcomes

� Javier PedreiraØ��ޱĹĜŸĘ�eŸŸŅÏĜ±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå��ŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹ

� Outi SilfverbergØ�åƻåÏƚƋĜƴå�ÚĜųåÏƋŅų�Ņü�ƋĘå�8Ņųƚĵ�üŅų�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ±Ĭ�FĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹ�ĜĹ�

8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� Lari HokkanenØ�čų±Úƚ±Ƌå�ŸƋƚÚåĹƋ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

8ååÚƱÏĩ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹŞƚƋ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�±ƚÚĜƋŅųŸ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ŸŅƚčĘƋ�ÆƼ�ƋĘå�ĵŅÚåų±ƋŅųŸ�Ņü�å±ÏĘ�ŞĬåűųƼ�

ŸåŸŸĜŅĹØ�±ĹÚ�ŞųŅĵŞƋåÚ�ĬĜƴåĬƼ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸĜŅĹ�±ĵŅĹč�ƋĘå�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�±Ÿ�ƵåĬĬ�±Ÿ�ÆåĜĹč�ŸŞåÏĜĀϱĬĬƼ�

ĵåĹƋĜŅĹåÚ�ĜĹ�ŞŅŸĜƋĜƴå�üååÚƱÏĩ�üųŅĵ�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ĵåĵÆåųŸ�±üƋåų�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋţ

�Ęå�±ƚÚĜƋŅųŸ�ƋĘåĵŸåĬƴåŸ�ųåŞŅųƋåÚ�ƋʱƋ�ƋĘåƼ�ʱÚ�Ĺåƴåų�ÆååĹ�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ�ƋŅ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋå�ĜĹ�ƋĘĜŸ�

Ƶ±Ƽ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�åƴåĹƋŸ�ÆåüŅųåØ�ÆƚƋ�ƋʱƋ�ƋĘå�ŅŞŞŅųƋƚĹĜƋƼ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĵƚÏĘ�±ŞŞųåÏĜ±ƋåÚţ�eŸ�

±�ųåŸƚĬƋ�Ņü�ÏŅĹƋ±ÏƋŸ�ĵ±Úå�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋØ�Ÿåƴåų±Ĭ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�Æåč±Ĺ�ŞĬ±ĹĹĜĹč�ƋŅ�Ïųå±Ƌå�±Ĺ�

ĜĹüŅųĵ±Ĭ�)�ěƵĜÚå�ĹåƋƵŅųĩ�ƋŅ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸ�ŸƋųåĹčƋĘåĹĜĹč�ƋĘå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåţ

4.3.2. Mobile app

�e{)e�ŞĜĬŅƋåÚ�±Ĺ�±ŞŞ�üŅų�ĵŅÆĜĬå�ÚåƴĜÏåŸ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ųåŞĬ±ÏåÚ�ƋĘå�Ƌų±ÚĜƋĜŅűĬ�ޱŞåų�ÆųŅÏĘƚųå�

üŅų�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸţ��Ęå�±ŞŞ�Ƶ±Ÿ�±ƴ±ĜĬ±ÆĬå�ĜĹ�űƋĜƴå�üŅųĵ�üŅų�eŞŞĬå�±ĹÚ�eĹÚųŅĜÚ�ŞĘŅĹåŸ�±ĹÚ�

Ƌ±ÆĬåƋŸØ�±Ÿ�ƵåĬĬ�±Ÿ�Ĭ±ŞƋŅŞ�±ĹÚ�ĹŅƋåÆŅŅĩ�ÏŅĵŞƚƋåųŸţ�FƋ�ÏŅĹƋ±ĜĹåÚ�ƋĘå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ĜĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹ×

� )ƴåĹƋ�ŞųŅčų±ĵĵå

� �Şå±ĩåų�ÆĜŅčų±ŞĘĜåŸ

� XĜŸƋ�Ņü�±ƋƋåĹÚååŸ�ƵĜƋĘ�ÏŅĹƋ±ÏƋ�ÚåƋ±ĜĬŸ

� FĹƋåų±ÏƋĜƴå�ĵ±ƋåųĜ±ĬŸ�üŅų�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞŸ

� XĜƴå�ŞĘŅƋŅŸ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ

� a±ŞŸ�±ĹÚ�ÚĜųåÏƋĜŅĹŸ

� XĜĹĩŸ�ƋŅ��e{)eØ��ea�±ĹÚ�ޱųƋĹåų�ƵåÆŸĜƋåŸ

�±ĩåƚŞ�Ņü�ƋĘå�±ŞŞ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ĘĜčĘ�±ĹÚ�üååÚƱÏĩ�üųŅĵ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ŞŅŸĜƋĜƴåţ��Ęå�Ÿ±ĵå�

ƋåÏĘĹŅĬŅčƼ�ƵĜĬĬ�ĹŅƵ�Æå�ƚŸåÚ�üŅų�üƚƋƚųå��e{)e�åƴåĹƋŸØ�±ĹÚ�ĜƋ�ƚŸå�ĬåÚ�ƋŅ�ĜĹƋåųåŸƋ�üųŅĵ�±Ĺ�

±Ï±ÚåĵƼ�ĹåƋƵŅųĩ�ĜĹ�ƚŸĜĹč�ŸĜĵĜĬ±ų�ƋåÏĘĹŅĬŅčƼ�üŅų�ĜƋŸ�ŅƵĹ�åƴåĹƋŸţ

Page 19: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

19

Outcomes

Pilvi Torsti; Seppo Määttä; Johanna Vuorelma; Lea Kauppi; Risto Nieminen; Heikki Mannila

�GMIRXMǻG�ORS[PIHKI�EX�XLI�LIEVX�SJ�TSPMXMGEP�HIGMWMSR�QEOMRK��)EZMH�2EMV� �&5*&�8SQM��IX®P®�

Page 20: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

20

Page 21: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

21

List of speakers

Appendix 1: List of speakers � �ĜåųÚ��ĬŅåƋĜĹčĘØ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå�ÆŅ±ųÚ�Ņü��e{)e�±ĹÚ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�ŅüƤeϱÚåĵĜ±�)ƚųŅޱå±

� {å±ųĬ�%ƼĩŸƋų±Ø�ÚåŞƚƋƼ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸƤ:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�

eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ

� IƼųĩĜ�B±ĩ±Ş··Ø�ÚĜųåÏƋŅų�Ņü�ŸƋų±ƋåčĜÏ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�±Ƌ�ƋĘåƤeϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� X±ųĜ�BŅĩĩ±ĹåĹØ�:ų±Úƚ±Ƌå�ŸƋƚÚåĹƋ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ�

� Xå±�U±ƚŞŞĜØ�ÚĜųåÏƋŅųěčåĹåų±Ĭ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå

� eĹĹåě:ųååƋ�UåĜDŽåųØ�)ƻåÏƚƋĜƴå�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼ�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸű�8Ņųƚĵ�

� �±ųĜű�UåŸĩĜƋ±ĬŅØ�aåĵÆåų�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�

eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ�

� I±±ĩĩŅ�UƚŅŸĵ±ĹåĹØ�±Ï±ÚåĵƼ�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�

XåƋƋåųŸƤ±ĹÚ�ÏĘĜåü�ÏŅŅųÚĜűƋŅų�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�FĹĜƋĜ±ƋĜƴå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�

� �åŞŞŅ�a··ƋƋ·ØƤÚĜųåÏƋŅų�čåĹåų±Ĭ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚƤŸƋų±ƋåčƼ�ƚĹĜƋ�

� %±ƴĜÚ�a±ĜųØ�Ęå±Ú�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ƚĹĜƋ�±Ƌ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸƤIŅĜĹƋ��åŸå±ųÏĘ�

�åĹƋųå

� U±ƋųĜ�a·ĩĜĹåĹě�ŅŸƋåÚƋØ�ŸåĹĜŅų�±ÚƴĜŸŅų�±ƋƤ¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� BåĜĩĩĜ�a±ĹĹĜĬ±Ø�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤeϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� a±ųģ±�a±ĩ±ųŅƵØ�ÚĜųåÏƋŅų�ŅüƤ�ĜŅÏåĹƋåų�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� a±ųDŽĜ±�a±DŽDŽŅĹåƋƋŅØ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĜƋĜDŽåĹ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eŸŸŅÏĜ±ƋĜŅĹ�

� �ĜŸƋŅ�cĜåĵĜĹåĹØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� I±ƴĜåų�{åÚųåĜų±Ø��ޱĹĜŸĘ�eŸŸŅÏĜ±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå��ŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹ�

� kųƋƵĜĹ��åĹĹØ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå��e{)eƤƵŅųĩĜĹč�čųŅƚŞ�ŅĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå

� �Ĝĵ�ƴ±Ĺ��±±ųĬŅŅŸØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ�ŅƼ±Ĭ�cåƋĘåųĬ±ĹÚŸ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�eųƋŸ�±ĹÚ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

� kƚƋĜ��ĜĬüƴåųÆåųčØ�8Ņųƚĵ�üŅų�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ±Ĭ�FĹüŅųĵ±ƋĜŅĹ�

� �±ųĵŅ��ŅŅĵåųåØ�ŞųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ)ŸƋŅĹĜ±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

� {·ĜƴĜ��Ĝĩĩ±Ø�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼěčåĹåų±Ĭ�Ņü�ƋĘåƤ�ŅƚĹÏĜĬ�Ņü�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵĜåŸ

� {ĜĬƴĜ��ŅųŸƋĜØ�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼ�Ņü�ŸƋ±Ƌå�üŅų�Ĭ±ÆŅƚųØƤaĜĹĜŸƋųƼ�Ņü�)ÏŅĹŅĵĜÏ�eý±ĜųŸ�±ĹÚ�)ĵŞĬŅƼĵåĹƋ

� )ųĜĩ�ƴ±Ĺ�Úåų�XĜĹÚåØ�%ĜųåÏƋŅų�Ņü�ĜĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬ�±ý±ĜųŸ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå��ŅƼ±Ĭ�cåƋĘåųĬ±ĹÚŸ�eϱÚåĵƼ�

Ņü�eųƋŸ�±ĹÚ��ÏĜåĹÏå�

� IŅʱĹű��ƚŅųåĬĵ±Ø�ŞŅŸƋÚŅÏƋŅų±Ĭ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåų�±Ƌ��±ĵŞåųå��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼűŸƤFĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå�üŅų�

eÚƴ±ĹÏåÚ��ŅÏĜ±Ĭ��åŸå±ųÏĘ

� �ŅÆƼ��±ųÚĵ±ĹØ�Ęå±Ú�Ņü�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹŸ�±Ƌ��e{)e�

� �ĜčųĜÚ��åĜĬ±ĹÚØ�ĵ±Ĺ±čåų�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�

eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ

Page 22: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

22

List of speakers

Substitutions

�Ęå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸ�åƻŞų域åÚ�ƵĜĬĬĜĹčĹ域�ƋŅ�±ƋƋåĹÚ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�ÆƚƋ�Ƶåųå�ƚűÆĬå�ƋŅ�ÚŅ�

ŸŅ�ÆåϱƚŸå�Ņü�ŞųĜŅų�ÏŅĵĵĜƋĵåĹƋŸ×

� Peter GluckmanØ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå�FĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬ�cåƋƵŅųĩ�üŅų�:ŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå

� Rolf-Dieter HeuerØ�ÏʱĜų�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ�:ųŅƚŞ�Ņü��ĘĜåü��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�

eÚƴĜŸŅųŸţ��Ęå�ÚåŞƚƋƼ�ÏʱĜųØ�{å±ųĬ�%ƼĩŸƋų±Ø�±ƋƋåĹÚåÚ�ĜĹ�ĘĜŸ�ŞĬ±Ïå

� Johannes KlumpersØ�Ęå±Ú�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜÏå�aåÏʱĹĜŸĵ�

�ĹĜƋ×��ĜčųĜÚ��åĜĬ±ĹÚØ�±�Ƌå±ĵ�Ĭå±Úåų�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ƚĹĜƋØ�±ƋƋåĹÚåÚ�ĜĹ�ĘĜŸ�ŞĬ±Ïå

Page 23: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

23

List of participants

Appendix 2: List of participants�Ęå�ĬĜŸƋ�ÆåĬŅƵ�ĜĹÏĬƚÚåŸ�ŅĹĬƼ�ƋĘŅŸå�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�ƵĘŅ�č±ƴå�åƻŞĬĜÏĜƋ�ŞåųĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�üŅų�ƋĘåĜų�

ÚåƋ±ĜĬŸ�ƋŅ�Æå�ŸĘ±ųåÚţ��ĜƋĬåŸ�±ĹÚ�±þĬĜ±ƋĜŅĹŸ�±ųå�ųåŞųŅÚƚÏåÚ�ƴåųƱƋĜĵ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸű�

ŸƚÆĵĜŸŸĜŅĹŸţ

{±±ƴŅě{åƋųĜ�eĘŅĹåĹ

IŅŅűŸ�eĜƋŅĹƚųĵĜØ��ŞåÏĜ±ĬĜŸƋØ�{ŅŞƚĬ±ƋĜŅĹ��åčĜŸƋåų��åĹƋųå�Š�·åŸƋʼnųåĩĜŸƋåųĜĩåŸĩƚŸš

�ĜŸƋŅ�eĬ±Ƌ±ųƴ±ŸØ��åĹĜŅų��ŞåÏĜ±ĬĜŸƋØ�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå

)ųģ±��ĵĵ·Ĭ±ĘƋĜØ��åĹĜŅų�eÚƴĜŸŅųØ�e±ĬƋŅ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ

FĬĩĩ±�eųĵĜĹåĹØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ��B

a±ųƋĜ�e±ƴĜĩØ�)ŸƋŅĹĜ±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

cţ�)ĵų±Ę�eƼÚĜĹŅűƋØ��åŸå±ųÏĘåųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�±ĵ±ų±��±ųěa±čåĹ�cƚĵʱƚŸåųØ�:ų±ĹƋ��ųĜƋåųØ�:åŅĬŅčĜϱĬ��ƚųƴåƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

cĜű��ĬŅĵØ�{ųŅģåÏƋ�a±Ĺ±čåųØ��åÏĘĹŅĬŅčƼ�eϱÚåĵƼ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

UFųŸĜĵ±ųģ±��ĬŅĵŧƴĜŸƋØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ�X����ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ

)ųĜĩ��ŅĹŸÚŅųýØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ��ÆŅ�eĩ±ÚåĵĜ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ

BƚčŅ��Ĭ±ųĩåØ��åĹĜŅų�FĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬ�{ųŅčų±ĵĵåŸ�eÚƴĜŸåų

eĬĩĜŸƋĜŸ�)ĬĬĜŅƋƋě:ų±ƴåŸØ�a±ųĜå��ĩĴŅÚŅƵŸĩ±ě�ƚųĜå�8åĬĬŅƵØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

IŅʱĹű�)ĹŧƴĜŸƋØ��åŸå±ųÏĘ�ÏŅŅųÚĜűƋŅųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜx�ĜåƋååĹ�ƋåųĵĜޱĹĩĩĜ

{ĜųģŅěXååű�8ŅųŸŸƋųʼnĵØ�%åƴåĬŅŞĵåĹƋ�%ĜųåÏƋŅųØ����

�±ĬƋƋåųĜ�8ų±ĹƋŸĜØ�eűĬƼŸƋØ�FĹüŅųčĬŅÆå

�±ųĬ�:±ĘĵÆåųčØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

eĹÚƼ�:±ųÚĹåųØ�{ųŅü域Ņų�Ņü��ĜŅĬŅčƼØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü��Ƌ�eĹÚųåƵŸ�x�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏŅƋĬ±ĹÚ

eĬåƻ±ĹÚåų�:ŅųÚĜåĹĩŅØ��ƚŸŸĜ±Ĺ�)ĵƱŸŸƼ�ĜĹ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

IƼųĩĜ�B±ĩ±Ş··Ø��åĹĜŅų��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

a±ųĜ±�B·ĹĹĜĹåĹØ��åŸå±ųÏĘ�%ĜųåÏƋŅųØ�UŅƋĩ±�a±ųĜƋĜĵå��åŸå±ųÏĘ�eŸŸŅÏĜ±ƋĜŅĹ

�±ųƚ�BåĹųĜĩŸŸŅĹØ��åĹĜŅų�eÚƴĜŸŅųØ�e±ĬƋŅ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ

�ƚÚŅĬü�BĜåĬŸÏĘåųØ��ŅŅųÚĜűƋŅųØ��e{)eØ�±Ï±ƋåÏĘ

�ĘĬŅå�BĜĬĬØ�{ŅĬĜÏƼ�kþÏåųØ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ�:åŅŸÏĜåĹÏåŸ��ĹĜŅĹ

IƚƚĬĜ�BĜĬŸĩ±

X±ųĜ�BŅĩĩ±ĹåĹ

I±ĹĹå�Fţ�BƚĩĩĜĹåĹØ�{ųŅü域Ņų�Ņü�åĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ±Ĭ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

B±ĹĹƚě{åĩĩ±�Fĩ·ĘåĜĵŅØ�8ŅųåŸĜčĘƋ�ŸŞåÏĜ±ĬĜŸƋØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�FĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�8ƚĹÚ��ĜƋų±

)ƼŸƋåĜĹ�I±ĹŸåĹØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü��åųčåĹ

eĹĹå�IŅĘĹŸŅĹØ��ĜÏåě{ųåŸĜÚåĹƋ�ě�FĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬØ��Ęå�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�aåÚĜϱĬ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸØ��U

�ĜĜű�IŅĩåĬ±Ø��åĹĜŅų�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ÏŅƚĹŸåĬØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�ŅŅŞå�U±±ųŅĹåĹØ�%ŅÏƋŅų±Ĭ�ϱĹÚĜÚ±ƋåØ��ĹĜţ�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�ŅĵĵĜ�U·ųĩĩ·ĜĹåĹØ��ƋƚÚåĹƋØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü��ƚųĩƚ

eĹĹåě:ųååƋ�UåĜDŽåųØ�)ƻåÏƚƋĜƴå�ŸåÏųåƋ±ųƼØ�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸŅųŸ�8Ņųƚĵ�Š)�e8š

IŅʱĹű�UåƋŅĬ±Ø��ÏĜåĹÏå��åÏųåƋ±ųƼØ�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

Page 24: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

24

List of participants

U±ĬĬå�UŅųĘŅĹåĹØ�%ĜųåÏƋŅų�Ņü��åŸå±ųÏĘ�8ƚĹÚĜĹčØ�UŅĹå�8ŅƚĹÚ±ƋĜŅĹ

U±ĜŸ±�UŅųĘŅĹåĹě�ĩƚųĩĜØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�±Ĝģ±�UŅŸĩĜĹåĹØ�{Ę%�ŸƋƚÚåĹƋØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

I±ĹĹå�UŅƋĜ±ĘŅØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�IƼƴ·ŸĩƼĬ·

U±ĜŸ±�X·ĘƋååĹĵ·ĩĜě�ĵĜƋĘØ�%åƴåĬŅŞĵåĹƋ�ÚĜųåÏƋŅųØ�a%F

�ååĵƚ�X±ųĜØ�%ŅÏƋŅų±Ĭ��ƋƚÚåĹƋØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�±ĹƋƋƚ�XåĘƋĜĹåĹØ��åŸå±ųÏĘ��ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋØ����

�ĜĬĵ±�XåĘƋĜĹåĹØ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

IŅŅű�XåĘƋŅĵ·ĩĜØ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

a±ųĩĩƚ�XåŸĩåĬ·Ø�ŞųŅü域ŅųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�Ÿ±�XĜĹÚÆåųčØ��åÏųåƋ±ųƼ�:åĹåų±ĬØ��Ęå��ƵåÚĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�)ĹčĜĹååųĜĹč��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ�ĜĹ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

IƚÚĜƋĘ�XĜƋģåĹŸØ�{ŅĬĜÏƼ�kþÏåųØ��k��

�ŅųŸƋĜ�XŅĜĩĩ±ĹåĹØ�FĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜŅĹ��ŅĹŸƚĬƋ±ĹƋØ��±Ş±ų�kƼ�ŠXƋÚš

UĜųŸĜěa±ųģ±�XŅĹĩĜĬ±Ø�%åĵŅŸ�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�±ųĜ�XʼnƼƋʼnĩŅųŞĜØ��ĘĜåü��ŞåÏĜ±ĬĜŸƋØ�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

I±ųĜ�XƼƼƋĜĵ·ĩĜØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå

�Ÿĩ±ĬĜ�a·ĩĜØ�{ųŅü域Ņų�åĵåųĜƋƚŸØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

U±ƋųĜ�a·ĩĜĹåĹě�ŅŸƋåÚƋØ�{Ę%��±ĹÚĜÚ±ƋåØ��åĹĜŅų�eÚƴĜŸåųØ��±ĵŞåųå��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼØ�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

a±čÚ±Ĭåű�a±ĴåÏĩ±Ø�a±ųĜå��ĩĴŅÚŅƵŸĩ±ě�ƚųĜå�8åĬĬŅƵØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�±ƋåųĜű�a±ųÏĘĜŅĹĹĜ

a±ųDŽĜ±�a±DŽDŽŅĹåƋƋŅØ�{ųŅģåÏƋ�a±Ĺ±čåųØ�)��e

{·ĜƴĜ�aåűųÚØ��ĜųÏƚĬ±ų�)ÏŅĹŅĵƼ��Ƌų±ƋåčĜŸƋØ�a�e�ŸƋƚÚĜåŸ�ĜĹ�ƖLjŎĿ

�åų±�aĜĩĩĜĬ·Ø��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

XƚĜŸ�aĜųåĬåŸě8ĬŅųåŸØ�{ŅŸƋÚŅÏƋŅų±Ĭ��åŸå±ųÏĘåųØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

kĬ±ƴĜ�cåƴ±ĹĬĜĹűØ�{ųŅü域ŅųØ�e±ĬƋŅ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ

�ųƚĹč�cčƚƼåĹ�Bƚƚ�B±ĜØ�FĹƋåųĹŸĘĜŞØ�aåƋųŅŞŅĬĜ±

FĬĩĩ±�cĜĜĹĜĬƚŅƋŅØ�ŞųŅü域Ņų�åĵåųĜƋƚŸØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

�±ĵĜ�cĜĜĹĜĵ·ĩĜØ��åĹĜŅų�eÚƴĜŸŅųØ�aĜĹĜŸƋųƼ�Ņü�)ÚƚϱƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ��ƚĬƋƚųå

UųĜŸƋ±�cƚƚƋĜĹåĹØ��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�ŅĜĬå�kĜĹŅĹåĹØ�%åƴåĬŅŞĵåĹƋ�ĵ±Ĺ±čåųØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå

U±ĜŸ±�kĩŸ±ĹåĹØ��ĘĜåü��ŞåÏĜ±ĬĜŸƋØ�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå

eĹƋƋĜ�{åĬĩŅĹåĹØ��ÏĜåĹÏå��ŞåÏĜ±ĬĜŸƋØ�{ųĜĵå�aĜĹĜŸƋåųűŸ�kþÏå

aĜĩĩŅ�{åĬƋŅĹåĹØ��åŸå±ųÏĘ�%ĜųåÏƋŅųØ�aĜĹĜŸƋųƼ�Ņü�ečųĜÏƚĬƋƚųå�±ĹÚ�8ŅųåŸƋųƼ

aåĬĜŸŸ±�{Ĭ±ƋĘØ�{ųŅģåÏƋ�a±Ĺ±čåųØ��ĹĜ{F%

�ĜĩƋŅųĜ±�{ų±ĹƋĹåų

UĜųŸĜ�{ƚĬĩĩĜĹåĹ

eĹĹĜĩ±��±ĜƋ±Ĭ±Ø��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

IåĹĹĜ��±ĜƋŅʱųģƚØ�ŸåĹĜŅų�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�)ĹƴĜųŅĹĵåĹƋ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋåx¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

U±ųĜ��±ĜƴĜŅ

�ĬĬå��±ƚÚØ�Bå±Ú�Ņü��ŅŅŞåų±ƋĜŅĹØ�)ŸƋŅĹĜ±Ĺ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

�±ų±Ę��ĜƋÏĘĜåØ��åĹĜŅų�{ŅĬĜÏƼ�kþÏåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�aåÚĜϱĬ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ�Š�Uš

8ĬŅŅų±��ƚŅĩŅĹåĹØ�%ĜųåÏƋŅųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

aĜĬģ±��±±ųĜØ��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚØ��Ƌų±ƋåčĜÏ��åŸå±ųÏĘ

�Ņĵ±��ƚŸĜØ��ĜÏåě�ʱĜųØ��Ęå�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�)ƚųŅŞå

�ĜƋƋ±��±ŞĜŅĬ±Ø�Xå±ÚĜĹč�åƻŞåųƋØ�c±Ƌƚų±Ĭ��åŸŅƚųÏåŸ�FĹŸƋĜƋƚƋå�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ�ŠXƚĩåš

kĬĬĜ��ĜĜĩĩ±ĜĹåĹ

{·ĜƴĜ��Ĝĩĩ±Ø��ŅƚĹÏĜĬ�Ņü�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵĜåŸ

{ĜĬƴĜ��ŅŞŞĜĹåĹØ��ÏĜåĹÏå�eÚƴĜŸåųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

Xååű��ƚĬĩĩĜØ�{ĘÚ�ŸƋƚÚåĹƋØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

IŅƚĹĜ��ƚŅĵĜŸƋŅØ�ÏĘĜåü�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųØ��BX

Page 25: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

25

List of participants

U±ĜŸ±��·ĬĜĵ·ĩĜØ�¥ĵŞ·ųĜŸƋʼnƋĜåÚŅĹ�üŅŅųƚĵĜ

)ųĜĩ�ƴ±Ĺ�Úåų�XĜĹÚåØ�%ĜųåÏƋŅų�FĹƋåųűƋĜŅűĬ�eý±ĜųŸØ��ŅƼ±Ĭ�cåƋĘåųĬ±ĹÚŸ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�eųƋŸ�±ĹÚ��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ

IƚŸŸĜ��±ƚĘĩŅĹåĹØ�%ĜųåÏƋŅųØ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

B±ĹĹåĬå��·ƼųƼĹåĹØ�{ŅŸƋÚŅÏƋŅų±Ĭ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųØ��±ĵŞåųå��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ

UŅåĹ��åųĵåĜųØ��Ņě�ʱĜųØ�:ĬŅƱĬ�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ

:ĜåÚųĜƚŸ��ĜĬĜƚűŸØ�%ĜųåÏƋŅųØ�:ŅƴåųĹĵåĹƋ��Ƌų±ƋåčĜÏ�eűĬƼŸĜŸ��åĹƋųå

XåĹĜ�ƴŅĹ��ŅĹŸÚŅųýØ��ʱĜųĵ±ĹØ��Ęå��ƵåÚĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�)ĹčĜĹååųĜĹč��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ�ĜĹ�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

�ĜƋ±ĬĜƼ��ŅDŽĹƼ±ĩØ�%ĜŞĬŅĵ±ƋØ����)ĵƱŸŸƼ

eĹű��åƋƋåųÆŅĵØ��)kØ�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ƵåÚåĹ

a±ĬĜĹ��ĜĩŸƋåÚƋØ�B±ĹĩåĹ��ÏĘŅŅĬ�Ņü�Economics

Other participants

ĿƖ�ŅƋĘåų�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�ÚåÏĬĜĹåÚ�ƋŅ�čĜƴå�ŞåųĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�ƋŅ�ŞƚÆĬĜŸĘ�ƋĘåĜų�ÚåƋ±ĜĬŸţ

Page 26: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

26

List of messages formulated and debated by participants

Appendix 3: List of messages formulated and debated by participants

Key messages ranked by number of votes

FĹ�ƋĘå�ĀűĬ�ŞĬåűųƼ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹØ�ÚƚųĜĹč�ƋĘå�±ƚÚĜåĹÏå�ÚåƱƋåØ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�Ƶåųå�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ�ƋŅ�

ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋå�ƋĘåĜų�ŅƵĹ�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�ƚŸĜĹč�±�ĬĜƴå�ŅĹĬĜĹå�ƴŅƋĜĹč�ŸƼŸƋåĵţ��ĘåŸå�Ƶåųå�ƋĘåĹ�

±ÚÚåÚ�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ĩåƼ�ĵ域±čåŸ�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ƵŅųĩŸĘŅŞŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ųåŸƚĬƋĜĹč�ĬĜŸƋ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ų±ĹĩåÚ�ÆƼ�±�

ųå±ĬěƋĜĵå�åĬåÏƋųŅĹĜÏ�ƴŅƋå�Ņü�±ĬĬ�ƋĘŅŸå�ŞųåŸåĹƋţ��ĘĜŸ�ĬĜŸƋ�ĜŸ�ųåŞųŅÚƚÏåÚ�ÆåĬŅƵţ

1. �Ęå�ŞųĜĹÏĜŞĬå�ƋʱƋ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�Æå�ĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ÆƼ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜŸ�ƚĹÚåų�ŸåųĜŅƚŸ�±ƋƋ±Ïĩţ�

{ŅĬĜƋĜÏĜ±ĹŸØ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�ĹååÚ�ƋŅ�ÚåüåĹÚ�ƋĘĜŸ�ÏŅųĹåųŸƋŅĹå�Ņü�ĬĜÆåų±Ĭ�

ÚåĵŅÏų±ÏƼ

Ë�ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�ŸĘŅƚĬÚÌ�ÆåƋƋåų�ƚĹÚåųŸƋ±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹÏå�Ņü�ƴ±ĬƚåŸØ�åĵŅƋĜŅĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ÆåĬĜåüŸţ�

Š{ĘĜĬŅŸŅŞĘåųŸ�ϱĹ�ĘåĬŞţš

2. �ŅĬÚ�ŞĜĬŅƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ޱƋĜåĹÏå�±ųå�ƋĘå�ĩåƼ�üŅų�ĬŅĹčěƋåųĵ�ŸƼŸƋåĵĜÏ�ÏʱĹčåţ�8ĬåƻĜÆĜĬĜƋƼØ�

åĹč±čåĵåĹƋ�ĜĹ�ĹåƋƵŅųĩŸ�ƵĘåųå�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�åƻĜŸƋŸţ

3. 8Ņų�ĜĵޱÏƋ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ƼŅƚ�ĹååÚ�ƋŅ�ĜÚåĹƋĜüƼ�ƋĘå�ųåÏĜŞĜåĹƋŸ�±ĹÚ�ƵŅųĩ�ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘåĵ�

üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�ÆåčĜĹĹĜĹčţ

4. FĹÏĬƚÚå�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�å±ųĬƼ�ŸƋ±čåŸ�Ņü�Úų±üƋĜĹč�±ÚƴĜÏå�üŅų�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ó�ĹŅƋ�ģƚŸƋ�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�åĹÚţ�

Šů�ÏĜåĹÏå�ϱŞĜƋ±Ĭű�ÏŅĹÏåŞƋ�ϱĹ�ĘåĬŞ�ƋŅ�ĜÚåĹƋĜüƼ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸš

5. �ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�ÏųƚÏĜ±Ĭ�ޱųƋĜÏƚĬ±ųĬƼ�Ĝü�ĜŸŸƚåŸ�±ųå�ÏŅĵŞĬåƻØ�ƚĹÏåųƋ±ĜĹ�±ĹÚ�ÏŅĹƋåŸƋåÚţ�

FƋűŸ�±ĬƵ±ƼŸ�ÆåƋƋåų�ƋʱĹ�ĜĹƋƚĜƋĜŅĹţ

6. XŅƵ�ĘĜåų±ųÏĘĜåŸØ�ĘĜčĘ�ŸŅÏĜåƋ±Ĭ�ƋųƚŸƋØ�±ĹÚ�ĘĜčĘ�ƋųƚŸƋ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�åűÆĬå�åƻŞåųĜĵåĹƋ±ƋĜŅĹ�

±ĹÚ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�ĜĹ�ÚåƴåĬŅŞĜĹč�üƚƋƚųå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ϱޱÆĜĬĜƋĜåŸţ

7. %Ņ�ĹŅƋ�ĵĜƻ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�üŅų�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�Š±ÚƴĜÏåš�±ĹÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�üŅų�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ŠĬŅÆÆƼĜĹčšţ

8. �ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�±ųå�ĹŅƋ�±�ޱŸŸĜƴå�ŸŅƚųÏå�Ņü�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�ÆƚƋ�±�ŞųŅě±ÏƋĜƴå�ųåŸŅƚųÏå�ƋŅ�

åƻÏʱĹčå�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�ƵĜƋĘ

9. �ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĹååÚŸ�ƋŅ�Æå�Ņųč±ĹĜŸåÚ�ŸŅ�ƋʱƋ�ĜƋ�ĜŸ�ĜĹÚåŞåĹÚåĹƋ�±ĹÚ�ƱŸåÚ�ŅĹ�ĜĹƋåųűĬ�

ŧƚ±ĬĜƋƼ�ÏŅĹƋųŅĬØ�ÆƚƋ�ƼåƋ�ÏĬŅŸå�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�ÏŅĹÏåųĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ĹååÚŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�ĜĹ�

čåĹåų±Ĭ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘå�ƴ±ųĜŅƚŸ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�±ųåűŸ�ĜĹ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ƋĘåƼ�ĜĹƋåų±ÏƋţ

Page 27: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

27

List of messages formulated and debated by participants

10. BŅƵ�ƋŅ�åĹč±čå�±ĹÚ�ĵŅƋĜƴ±Ƌå�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ×�ųåŸŞŅĹŸĜÆĜĬĜƋĜåŸ�ƋŅ�ƵŅųĩ�ŅĹ�ƋĘå�ƋŅŞĜÏØ�

ĵŅƋĜƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹÏåĹƋĜƴåŸ�ƋŅ�ƵŅųĩ�±ĹÚ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋåØ�åĹč±čåĵåĹƋ�ĹååÚåÚ�ÆƚƋ�ƋʱƋ�

Úåĵ±ĹÚŸ�ųåŸŅƚųÏåŸţ

11. {ųŅÏ域åŸ�ĹååÚ�čŅŅÚ�ŞĬ±ĹĹĜĹčØ�ƋĜĵå�±ĹÚ�ƵåĬĬěƵŅųĩĜĹč�Ƌų±ĹŸŞ±ųåĹÏƼţ

12. �ŅÏĜ±ĬØ�ŞŅĬĜƋĜϱĬ�±ĹÚ�ƋåÏĘĹŅĬŅčĜϱĬ�ŸÏĜåĹÏåŸ�ϱĹ�ƋåĬĬ�ƚŸ�ƋĘå�ŮĘŅƵŰ�ĹŅƋ�ģƚŸƋ�ƋĘå�ŮƵʱƋŰţ

13. FĹƴŅĬƴå�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸ�ĵŅųå�ŸƋųŅĹčĬƼ�ĜĹ�ÏŅěÏųå±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�±ÚƴĜÏåØ�±Ÿ�ƵåĬĬ�±Ÿ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�

ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋŅųŸţ

Important themes not discussed

%ƚųĜĹč�ƋĘå�ĀűĬ�ŸåŸŸĜŅĹØ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�Ƶåųå�±ĬŸŅ�ĜĹƴĜƋåÚ�ƋŅ�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋå�±ĹƼ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�ƋĘåĵåŸ�

ƋʱƋ�ʱÚ�ĹŅƋ�ÆååĹ�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�ŸŅ�ü±ųţ��ĘåŸå�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋĜŅĹŸ�Ƶåųå�ÚĜŸŞĬ±ƼåÚ�ĬĜƴå�

ƋŅ�±ĬĬ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸØ�ƵĘŅ�Ƶåųå�ƋĘåĹ�±ÆĬå�ƋŅ�ųåŸŞŅĹÚ�ƋŅ�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋĜŅĹŸ�üųŅĵ�ŅƋĘåųŸ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�

ƋĘåƼ�üåĬƋ�Ƶåųå�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋØ�üŅųĵĜĹč�ƋĘå�ƱŸĜŸ�üŅų�üƚųƋĘåų�ÚåƱƋåţ��Ęå�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋĜŅĹŸ�±ųå�

ųåŞųŅÚƚÏåÚ�ÆåĬŅƵţ��ĘåƼ�±ųå�ŞųåŸåĹƋåÚ�ƴåųƱƋĜĵØ�ƵĜƋĘŅƚƋ�åÚĜƋĜĹčØ�ŸŅųƋåÚ�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ŅųÚåų�ĜĹ�

ƵĘĜÏĘ�ƋĘå�ÏŅĹƋųĜÆƚƋĜŅĹ�Ƶ±Ÿ�åĹƋåųåÚ�ĜĹƋŅ�Ņƚų�ŅĹĬĜĹå�ŸƼŸƋåĵţ

�ʱƋ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ÚåŸƋųƚÏƋĜƴå�ŞŅĬĜÏĜåŸ�ƋʱƋ�ϱƚŸå�ŸŅÏĜåƋ±Ĭ�ʱųĵ�ÆƚƋ�üŅų�ŸŅĵå�ų屟ŅĹ�±ųå�ŸƋĜĬĬ�ĜĵŞĬåĵåĹƋåÚũ��ĘŅƚĬÚ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�ŸååĩØ�ĜÚåĹƋĜüƼØ�ŸƋƚÚƼ�±ĹÚ�ŞųŅĵŅƋå�ųåģåÏƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�ƋĘåĵũ��Ęå�ü±ÏƋ�ƋʱƋ�ƋĘåƼ�±ųå�ĜĵŞĬåĵåĹƋåÚ�ĜĵŞĬĜåŸ�ƋʱƋ�ƋĘåƼ�±ųå�ĜĹ�±�ÆĬĜĹÚ�ŸŞŅƋ�üŅų�ŞŅĬĜƋĜÏĜ±ĹŸ�±ĹÚ�ƋĘåƼ�±ųå�ĹŅƋ�ĜĹƋåųåŸƋåÚ�ĜĹ�Ęå±ųĜĹč�ƋʱƋ�ƋĘå�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ĜŸ�ÚåŸƋųƚÏƋĜƴåţ��ĘŅƚĬÚ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ�ŸƋĜĬĬ�ĵ±ĩå�ĹŅĜŸå�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘåĵũ�)ţčţ�ĵ±ĹƼ�±ÏƋĜƴĜƋĜåŸ�ŞųŅÚƚÏĜĹč�ÏĬĜĵ±Ƌå�åĵĜŸŸĜŅĹŸ�ü±ĬĬ�ĜĹƋŅ�ƋĘå�ϱƋåčŅųƼ�Ņü�ÚåŸƋųƚÏƋĜƴå�ŞŅĬĜÏĜåŸţ

�ÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋűŸ�ŞåųŸŞåÏƋĜƴå�ƋŅ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜŸå�ĵ±Ƽ�Æå�ų±ƋĘåų�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�üųŅĵ�ƋʱƋ�Ņü�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸ�ě�ƵŅƚĬÚ�Æå�čųå±Ƌ�ƋŅ�Ęå±ų�ƋĘåĜų�ŞåųŸŞåÏƋĜƴåØ�ƋŅŅú���

�ʱƋ�ƵŅƚĬÚ�ÏŅƚĹƋ�±Ÿ�ƱÚxÚƼŸüƚĹÏƋĜŅűĬ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåũ���

e�ŞųŅÆĬåĵ�ƵĜƋĘ�ƋĘå�ŮÚåüåĹÚ�ĬĜÆåų±Ĭ�ÚåĵŅÏų±ÏƼŰ�ĵ域±čå�ĜŸ�ƋʱƋ�ĜƋ�ĜŸ�ĵŅŸƋĬƼ�±�ƴ±ĬƚåěƱŸåÚ�ŅŞĜĹĜŅĹ�ų±ƋĘåų�ƋʱĹ�±Ĺ�ĜĹŸĜčĘƋ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼţ

cŅƋå�ƋʱƋ�ůŸÏĜåĹÏåű�ĜŸ�ĹŅƋ�ƋĘå�Ÿ±ĵå�±Ÿ�ůŞƚÆĬĜÏ�ĜĹƋåųåŸƋűţ��ĘƚŸ�ĜĹ�Ņƚų�čųå±Ƌ�ÚåĵŅÏų±ÏĜåŸØ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�Š±ÚƴĜÏåš�ĜŸ�ÆƼ�ÚåĀĹĜƋĜŅĹ�ĹŅƋ�ŸŅĵåƋĘĜĹč�ÚŅĹå�ÆƼ�ŞŅŞƚĬ±ų�ƴŅƋåţ���

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�ĵ域ƼØ�屟ĜĬƼ�ĜĹåþÏĜåĹƋ�±ĹÚ�ŸƚÆģåÏƋ�ƋŅ�ĵĜŸƚŸåţ��ĘåųåüŅųå�ÚåŸĜčĹ�ƋĘå�ŸƼŸƋåĵ�ÆƼ�åƻŞĬŅĜƋĜĹč�ƋĘå�ÆåŸƋ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ŅĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ĜƋŸåĬüØ�ĜƋŸ�ŸŅÏĜ±Ĭ�Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ĜƋŸ�ŸŅÏĜ±Ĭ�ųåĬ±ƋĜŅĹŸţ

eĬƵ±ƼŸ�åĹč±čå�ÏƚŸƋŅĵåųŸ

�åŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ�ϱĹ�ÏʱĬĬåĹčå�å±ÏĘ�ŅƋĘåų�ƋŅ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋå�ĜĹ�ŞųŅÆĬåĵ�ŸŅĬƴĜĹč���

�Ÿå�ŸåųƴĜÏå�ÚåŸĜčĹØ�ƚŸåųěÏåĹƋųĜÏØ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋŅųƼ�ĵåƋĘŅÚŸ�åĹč±čĜĹč�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�ŸƋ±ĩåĘŅĬÚåųŸØ�ÚåĀĹå�ŞųŅÆĬåĵØ�ĜƋåų±ƋåØ�ŞųŅƋŅƋƼŞåØ�ŞĜĬŅƋ

�ÏĜåĹÏå�ĹååÚŸ�ƋŅ�ƚŸå�ƋĘå�±ųƋŸØ�ŸŞŅųƋŸØ�±ĹÚ�åĹƋųåŞųåĹåƚųŸØ�ƋŅ�ĜĹƋųŅÚƚÏå�±ĹÚ�ÆųĜÚčå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ƋŅ�ŞåŅŞĬåØ�ÆåüŅųå�ŸŞå±ĩĜĹč�±ÆŅƚƋ�ƋĘå�±ÏƋƚ±Ĭ�ŸÏĜåĹÏåţ

�åŸå±ųÏĘ�ŅĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�±ĹÚ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�ĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹěĵ±ĩĜĹč�ŠƼåŸØ�ƋĘåųå�ĜŸ�ŸƚÏĘ�±�ƋĘĜĹčúš

a±ĩå�±ÏƋĜŅĹŸ�ŞĬ±Ĺ�üŅų�±ĬĬ�ƋĘåŸå�ƴ±Ĭƚ±ÆĬå�čŅ±ĬŸØ�ĘŅƵ�ƋŅ�ųå±ÏĘ�ƋĘåĵ

�ƚĜĬÚ�ųŅÆƚŸƋ�ĵåÏʱĹĜŸĵŸ�ƋʱƋ�ϱĹ�åĹÚƚųå�ÏʱĹčåŸ�ĜĹ�ŞŅĬĜƋĜϱĬ�ƵĜĹÚŸ

{ŅĬĜƋĜÏŸ�ʱƴå�ƋŅ�ƋåĬĬ�ŅĹ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ƋĘåƼ�ÚåÏĜÏĜŅĹŸ�±ųå�ƱŸåÚţ���

�ÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�ĹŅƋ�ųŅÏĩåƋ�ŸÏĜåĹÏåţ�IƚŸƋ�ʱųÚ�±ĹÚ�üƚĹ�ƵŅųĩţ

Page 28: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

28

List of messages formulated and debated by participants

�ĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå

kƋĘåų�ƋƼŞåŸ�Ņü�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�ƋʱĹ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ

�Ęå�ƴŅĜÏå�Ņü�ÏĜƴĜĬ�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�±ƚÚĜƋŅųŸ�ÏŅƚĬÚ�Æå�Ęå±ųÚ�ĵŅųåţ�eĬŸŅ�ƋĘåĜų�ÏųĜƋĜϱĬ�ŞŅĜĹƋŸ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ĵ±Ƽ�ŞŅĜĹƋ�ƋŅ�ƚĹÏŅĵüŅųƋ±ÆĬå�ĜŸŸƚåŸţ

B±ƴå�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�åƴ±Ĭƚ±ƋåÚ�ÚƚųĜĹč�ƋĘå�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ÆƼ�ŸƋ±ĩåĘŅĬÚåųŸ���

BŅƵ�ƋŅ�åĵÆåÚ�ŸÏĜ�±ÚƴĜÏå�±Ÿ�±�ųåčƚĬ±ų�åƻåųÏĜŸå�ĜĹ�ĵ±ĜĹŸƋųå±ĵ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ĵ±ĩĜĹč�±Ÿ�ĜƋ�ĜŸ�ƵĜƋĘ�ųåčƚĬ±ƋŅųƼ�ĜĵޱÏƋ�±ŸŸåŸŸĵåĹƋ

�ĘĜŸ�ĜŸ�±�čųå±Ƌ�ŸƋ±ųƋ�ÆƚƋ�Ƶå�ʱƴå�ƋŅ�čŅ�ÆåƼŅĹÚ�ÆƚDŽDŽƵŅųÚŸ�±ĹÚ�ŅŞåų±ƋĜŅűĬĜDŽå�ƋĘåŸå�ŞųŅĵĜĹåĹƋ�ĜÚ屟�ĜĹ�ĵƚĬƋĜŞĬå�Ƶ±ƼŸú

�±Şå±�ĹååÚŸ�±�ĘĜčĘåų�ÆƚÚčåƋú��å±ĬĬƼúú

�±Ÿĩ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�ƋŅ�ĘåĬŞ�ĵ±ĩå�ŞŅĬĜÏƼěĵ±ĩĜĹč�åƴĜÚåĹÏåěĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ěěě�{ŅĬĜÏĜåŸ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜƋŸåĬü�ŸĘŅƚĬÚ�Æå�åƴĜÚåĹÏåěĜĹüŅųĵåÚ�ŠƋĘå�ÚåŸĜčĹØ�ųåÚåŸĜčĹØ�±ĹÚ�ŅŞåų±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŸƼŸƋåĵŸš��Ņ×�ĜĹƋåčų±Ƌå�ŞĘĜĬŅŸŅŞĘƼ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�����ĜĹƋŅ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŸƼŸƋåĵŸ

�Ęå�ϱޱÏĜƋƼ�ƋŅ�ŞƚÆĬĜÏĬƼ�ŸŞå±ĩ�±ÆŅƚƋ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ƋŅ�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�±ƚÚĜåĹÏåŸØ�Ņü�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�ƱÏĩčųŅƚĹÚŸØ�ĜŸ�ģƚŸƋ�±Ÿ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�±Ÿ�ƋĘå�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�ƵŅųĩ�ĜƋŸåĬüţ���

BŅƵ�ƋŅ�ĘåĬŞ�ƋĘå��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹ�ƋŅ�ÚåĬĜƴåų�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ƱŸåÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏĜåŸ�±ĹÚ�ŞųŅŞŅŸ±ĬŸ�üŅų�±ÏƋĜŅĹŸ�ĜĹ�ŎLjLj�Ú±ƼŸţ���

�ŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜŅĹ�ĜŸ�ÏųƚÏĜ±Ĭ

BŅƵ�ƋŅ�ŸƚŞŞŅųƋ�ģŅƚųűĬĜŸƋŸű�ƵŅųĩ�ĜĹ�ƋåųĵŸ�Ņü�ÏŅĵĵƚĹĜϱƋĜĹč�ŸÏĜåĹÏå

�ų±ĹŸŞ±ųåĹÏƼ�üŅų�ŞųŅÏ域åŸ

FĹƴŅĬƴå�ƼŅƚĹč�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜŸƋŸ�±ĹÚ�üƚƋƚųå�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�Ĭå±ÚåųŸ�ĜĹ�ĵƚĬƋĜŞĬå�Ƶ±ƼŸ

F�ƴŅƋå�üŅų�ƋĘå�ĀųŸƋ�ųåÏŅĵĵĵåĹÚ±ƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�ƵŅųĩĜĹč�čųŅƚŞ�ĹŅ�Ă�ĜĹÏĬƚÚĜĹč�åĹč±čĜĹč�ƵĜƋĘ�ƼŅƚĹč�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ

�Ƌų±ƋåčĜÏ�8ŅųåŸĜčĘƋ�±ĹÚ�8ƚƋƚųåŸ��åŸå±ųÏĘ

�ŅĹƋĜĹčåĹÏƼØ�ÚĜýåųåĹƋ�ÏŅĹƋåƻƋŸ�Ņü�ƚŸĜĹč�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�üŅų�ÏʱĹčĜĹč�Ņƚų�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ

BŅƵ�ƋŅ�Ņųč±ĹĜDŽå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŧƚĜÏĩĬƼØ�±Ÿ�åƻŞåųƋ�Ƌ±Ÿĩ�üŅųÏåŸ

�ŅĵĵƚĹĜƋĜåŸ

�ŅĬå�Ņü�Ƌ±ųčåƋ�čųŅƚŞŸ�ĹŅƋ�ƵĜĬĬĜĹč�ƋŅ�Ƌ±ĩå�ƋĘå�±ÚƴĜÏå

�åŸŞŅĹŸĜÆĜĬĜƋƼ�ě�ĵŅƋĜƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�ě�åĹč±čåĵåĹƋ���

BŅƵ�ϱĹ�Ƶå�ŸƋĜĵƚĬ±Ƌå�±ĹÚ�ĜĵŞųŅƴå�ƋĘå�Úåĵ±ĹÚ�üŅų�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�åƴĜÚåĹÏå�üųŅĵ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ŞŅĬĜƋĜÏĜ±ĹŸũ

�Ęå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ÚĜčĜƋ±Ĭ�ÏʱĹĹåĬŸ�±ĹÚ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåţ

FĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�ĵååƋĜĹčſ�ƵŸńƖ�Ƶ±Ÿ�ƚĹƚŸƚ±ĬĬƼ�ŸƋųĜĹčåĹƋ�±ĹÚ�ƋŅěƋĘåěŞŅĜĹƋţ��Ęå�ƋĘųåå�ÆƚĬĬåƋŸ�Ïųå±ƋåÚ�±ųå�ƴĜƋ±Ĭţ

�ĘåĹ�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹŸ�±ųå�ĵ±Úå�ě�±ųŅƚĹÚ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�Ƌ±ÆĬåŸ�Ņų�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�ĵåĹƋ±Ĭ�üų±ĵåŸ�Ņü�ŞŅĬĜÏƼĵ±ĩåųŸũ���

�ų±ĹŸŞ±ųåĹÏƼ�üŅų�ŞųŅÏ域åŸ

�Ęå�ŠųåĬ±ƋĜƴåĬƼ�ĹŅųĵ±ƋĜƴåš�±ŸŸƚĵŞƋĜŅĹ�ÆåĘĜĹÚ�ĵƚÏĘ�ƋĘå�Ƌ±Ĭĩ�ƋŅÚ±Ƽ�ʱŸ�ÆååĹ�ŮƵå�ĹååÚ�ƋŅ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ÆåƋƋåųŰ�±ĹÚ�ŮĵŅųå�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ĜŸ�ÆåƋƋåųŰţ�F�ƋĘĜĹĩ�ĜƋűŸ�ĜĵŞŅųƋ±ĹƋ�ƋŅ�±Ÿĩ�ƵĘƼ�åƻ±ÏƋĬƼØ�üŅų�ƵĘŅĵ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ÏŅĹƋåƻƋ�ĜŸ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŠĜĹ�±ĬĬ�Ņü�ĜƋŸ�ŞĬƚų±Ĭ�üŅųĵŸš�ĹååÚåÚţ

�ĜƋĜDŽåĹŸÏĜåĹÏåØ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱƋĜŅĹ�Ņü�ÏĜƋĜDŽåĹŸ�ŅĹ�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�±Ƌ�ĜƋŸ�±ĬĬ�ĬåƴåĬŸţ

BŅƵ�ƋŅ�åƴ±Ĭƚ±Ƌå�ƋĘå�ŧƚ±ĬĜƋƼ�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏå

FĹƴŅĬƴå�ƼŅƚĹč�ųåŸå±ųÏĘåųŸ�ĜĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�±ÚƴĜÏåţ

�ĘŅ�ĜŸ�ÚåÏĜŸĜŅĹěĵ±ĩåų

�åųƼ�čŅŅÚ�ÏŅĹƴåųŸ±ƋĜŅĹŸú�{åųĘ±ŞŸ�ƋĘå�ƴ±Ĭƚå�Ņü�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�Š�Ņü�±ĹƼũš�üŅų�ŸŅÏĜåƋƼ�±Ÿ�ŸƚÏĘťŎ

:ųŅƵĜĹč�ĹååÚ�üŅų�ÏŅĹƋĜĹƚåÚ�ŸĜƋƚ±ƋĜŅűĬ�±Ĺ±ĬƼŸĜŸ�ĜĹ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼěĵ±ĩĜĹč�ŠĜĹ�ÏŅĹƋų±ŸƋ�ƋŅ�ŰųåŞŅųƋŸŰš

cåƵ�ŅŞŞŅųƋƚĹĜƋĜåŸ�ŅýåųåÚ�ÆƼ�±Úƴ±ĹÏåÚ�Ú±Ƌ±�±Ĺ±ĬƼƋĜÏŸ�±ĹÚ�±Ĝ�ʱƴå�ÚĜŸÏƚŸŸåÚ�ƴåųƼ�ĬĜƋƋĬå

�Ęå�ųŅĬå�Ņü�ŅƋĘåų�ŞŅĬĜÏƼěųåĬåƴ±ĹƋ�ƋƼŞåŸ�Ņü�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčå�ƋʱĹ�ŸÏĜåĹÏå�ŠüŅųåŸĜčĘƋØ�åƻŞåųĜĵåĹƋěƱŸåÚ�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčåØ�Ƌ±ÏĜƋ�ĩĹŅƵĬåÚčåØ�åƋÏţš

Page 29: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

29

Acknowledgements

Appendix 4: Acknowledgements�Ęå�Ņųč±ĹĜŸåųŸ�Ņü�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋ�åƻƋåĹÚ�ƋĘåĜų�Ƶ±ųĵ�ƋʱĹĩŸ�ƋŅ�±ĬĬ�ƋĘå�ŸŞå±ĩåųŸ�±ĹÚ�ޱųƋĜÏĜޱĹƋŸ�

Ņü�ƋĘå�ŸƼĵŞŅŸĜƚĵØ�±ĹÚ�åŸŞåÏĜ±ĬĬƼ�ƋŅ�ƋĘå�üŅĬĬŅƵĜĹč�ŞåŅŞĬå�ƵĘŅ�ŞĬ±ƼåÚ�±�ĩåƼ�ųŅĬå�ĜĹ�ƋĘå�

Ņųč±ĹĜŸ±ƋĜŅĹ�±ĹÚ�ŸĵŅŅƋĘ�ųƚĹĹĜĹč�Ņü�ƋĘå�åƴåĹƋţ

� eĹĩĜ�:åƚŸƋØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ��ŅÏĜåƋƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏåŸ�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� a±ƋƋĘĜ±Ÿ�IŅʱĹĹŸåĹØ�eXX)e

� IŅʱĹű�UåƋŅĬ±Ø�¥ŅƚĹč�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü�8ĜĹĬ±ĹÚ

� I±±ĩĩŅ�UƚŅŸĵ±ĹåĹØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� a±ųĜåĬ±�X±ĵŞĜĹåĹ

� �ååų±�X±ƚĹĜŸØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� ečĹĜåŸDŽĩ±�{ĜåƋųƚÏDŽƚĩØ��e{)e

� cĜű��±ŞåĬŅØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� �ƚƴĜ��±ĬĵĜØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� �ĜųŞĜ��±ĬŅģ·ųƴĜØ��ĹĜƴåųŸĜƋƼ�Ņü�BåĬŸĜĹĩĜ

� c±Ĺű��·ųĩĩ·Ø�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� a±ųģ±��ĜƴŅĹåĹØ�8ĜĹĹĜŸĘ�eϱÚåĵƼ�Ņü��ÏĜåĹÏå�±ĹÚ�XåƋƋåųŸ

� �ŅÆåųƋ��ŅčƋØ��e{)e

� �ŅÆƼ��±ųÚĵ±ĹØ��e{)e

� �Ƌ±ý�±Ƌ�ƋĘå�U±ĹŸ±ĬĬĜŸĵƚŸåŅ

Page 30: THE FUTURE OF SCIENCE ADVICE IN EUROPE...Europe 8 2.4. Panel: The science advice ecosystem in Finland 10 2.5. Workshops and mini-sessions 11 2.6. Debriefs and votes: our message to

ƵƵƵţŸ±Şå±ţĜĹüŅ Ä�e{)eĹåƵŸ�

�e{)e�ĜŸ�ޱųƋ�Ņü�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹűŸ��ÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�eÚƴĜÏå�aåÏʱĹĜŸĵØ�ƵĘĜÏĘ�ŞųŅƴĜÚåŸ�ĜĹÚåŞåĹÚåĹƋØ�ĜĹƋåųÚĜŸÏĜŞĬĜűųƼØ�±ĹÚ�åƴĜÚåĹÏåěƱŸåÚ�ŸÏĜåĹƋĜĀÏ�±ÚƴĜÏå�ŅĹ�ŞŅĬĜÏƼ�ĜŸŸƚåŸ�ƋŅ�

ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ŅĵĵĜŸŸĜŅĹţ

�e{)e�ʱŸ�ųåÏåĜƴåÚ�üƚĹÚĜĹč�üųŅĵ�ƋĘå�)ƚųŅŞå±Ĺ��ĹĜŅĹűŸ�BŅųĜDŽŅĹ�ƖLjƖLj�ųåŸå±ųÏĘ�±ĹÚ�ĜĹĹŅƴ±ƋĜŅĹ�ŞųŅčų±ĵĵå�ƚĹÚåų�čų±ĹƋ�±čųååĵåĹƋ�ĹŅţ�ƀƐƀĉƐƖţ