the ecology and distribution of steelhead in the eel river · •do summer and winter-run fish...

23
The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River Samantha Kannry Master’s Student Ecology Graduate Group University of California, Davis

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in

the Eel River

Samantha Kannry

Master’s Student

Ecology Graduate Group

University of California, Davis

Page 2: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

The Van Duzen River has a small remnant run of summer steelhead.

Page 3: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

In California there are two distinct runs of

steelhead, winter and summer.

Summer steelhead in the Middle Fork Eel

Page 4: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

The Eel River is currently the southernmost extent of summer steelhead in California.

Page 5: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

The Eel River is extremely erosive and characterized by many large, complex stretches of “roughs”.

Page 6: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Historic Counts of summer steelhead in the Van Duzen averaged an order of magnitude lower than what we have observed.

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020

Van Duzen River Summer Steelhead Counts

Year

Nu

mb

er o

f In

div

idu

als

Page 7: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Many questions have remained unanswered regarding current and historic distribution of steelhead in the Eel River.

• Are Van Duzen summer steelhead an independent population?

• Is Eaton Falls a complete barrier to anadromy?

• Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different locations?

• Would the resident trout population above Scott Dam be a good restoration source if the dam were to be removed?

Page 8: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to obtain sufficient samples.

• High spatial distribution

• Young of the year sampling

• 2 years of sampling

Basin Number of SitesTotal number of samples

Van Duzen 29 480

Middle Fork 13 183

Upper Eel 8 173

Total = 836

Page 9: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Genetic analyses provide useful tools for addressing ecological questions.

• Laboratory preparation

• Rapture

• Overall differentiation, OMY5 and GREB1L

Page 10: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Many questions have remained unanswered regarding current and historic distribution of steelhead in the Eel River.

• Are Van Duzen summer steelhead an independent population?

• Is Eaton Falls a complete barrier to anadromy?

• Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different locations?

• Would the resident trout population above Scott Dam be a good restoration source if the dam were to be removed?

Summer steelhead in the Van Duzen

Page 11: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Van Duzen summer steelhead are an independent population, not strays from the Middle Fork Eel.

PC1 (1.13%) / PC2 (0.945%)

Page 12: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Many questions have remained unanswered regarding current and historic distribution of steelhead in the Eel River.

• Are Van Duzen summer steelhead an independent population?

• Is Eaton Falls a complete barrier to anadromy?

• Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different locations?

• Would the resident trout population above Scott Dam be a good restoration source if the dam were to be removed?

Eaton Falls

Page 13: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

There is a high frequency of the anadromous genotype above Eaton Falls.

Page 14: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Eaton Falls is not a complete barrier to anadromy.

Page 15: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Many questions have remained unanswered regarding current and historic distribution of steelhead in the Eel River.

• Are Van Duzen summer steelhead an independent population?

• Is Eaton Falls a complete barrier to anadromy?

• Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different locations?

• Would the resident trout population above Scott Dam be a good restoration source if the dam were to be removed?

Pink Caves

Page 16: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

We observe distinct spatial segregation around the three major Lost Duzen barriers at the GREB1L locus.

Page 17: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

We observe similar spatial segregation of summer and winter-run steelhead around barriers in the Middle Fork.

Page 18: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Many questions have remained unanswered regarding current and historic distribution of steelhead in the Eel River.

• Are Van Duzen summer steelhead an independent population?

• Is Eaton Falls a complete barrier to anadromy?

• Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different locations?

• Would the resident trout population above Scott Dam be a good restoration source if the dam were to be removed?

Upper Eel above Scott Dam

Page 19: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

The summer-run allele is

present in the resident trout

population above Scott

Dam.

Page 20: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Life history diversity is being

maintained in the resident

population above the dam.

Page 21: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Overall genetic diversity is being maintained in the resident population above the dam.

Page 22: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Conclusions• Van Duzen River summer steelhead are an

independent population

• Anadromous fish are passing Eaton Falls with some regularity

• Summer and winter-run steelhead are reproductively isolated by distinct geographic barriers

• Summer-run steelhead inhabited the Upper Eel above Scott Dam prior to dam construction

• Genetic diversity is being maintained in the resident population above the dam

Page 23: The Ecology and Distribution of Steelhead in the Eel River · •Do summer and winter-run fish spawn and rear in different ... Dip-netting proved to be the most effective method to

Acknowledgements• Shaun Thompson, Scott Harris

• Amazing volunteers: Lindsey Holm, Sam Rizza, Jeff Abrams, Natalie Okun, Seth Ricker, Cat Fong, Ryan Thompson, Mary Clapp, Alisha Saley, Rose Dana, Eric Stockwell, Jake Crawford, Tasha Thomson, Ethan Bertz, Cameron Holmgren

• Additional samples: Bob Pagliuco, Keith Lackey

• Landowners: Mark and Dina Moore, Humboldt Redwood Company, Eric Larsen, Griff Bramble

• Funding: Ecology Graduate Group, Department of Animal Science UC Davis, Native Fish Society, Patagonia Inc., Friends of the Eel River

• Mike Miller, Sean O’Rourke

• And many more