„the challenges ofachieving eucandidatestatus“
DESCRIPTION
„THE CHALLENGES OF ACHIEVING EU CANDIDATE STATUS“TRANSCRIPT
Page | 1
Publication
„THE CHALLENGES OF
ACHIEVING EU
CANDIDATE
STATUS“
Page | 2
Publication
„THE CHALLENGES OF ACHIEVING
EU CANDIDATE STATUS“
Partners of the final event:
Page | 4
Publication
„THE CHALLENGES OF ACHIEVING EU CANDIDATE
STATUS“
Editors:
„Time for Plan B(alkans)“ group members:
Irma Zulić (B&H)
Dajana Džindo (B&H)
Rezarta Chausaj (ALB)
Sonja Delova (MK)
Cristian Gherasim (ROM)
Žarko Petrović (MN)
Publisher:
Year of pubication:
2012.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Author of the cover photograph: Bojan Elek
The photograph was acquired with the author's permission. It is
one out of two winning photographs in the competition: „How can
the EU do better in the Balkans“, organized by our partnering
group (also a participant of the Southeast Europe
and the EU – Leadership Development Programme 2011).
The author finds that the EU can do better in the region, by giving
a „green light“ as a reassure that the Balkan countries are moving
in the right direction of becoming EU Member States.
In this publication authors of 10 best essays, think that in order to
reach the green light, there are many challenges which these
countries need to overcome.
Page | 5
CONTENTS:
1. „Time for Plan B(alkans)“ and LDP 2011 ....................... 6
2. About the Project ............................................................ 7
3. Essay of Anja Lejli Hessarbani (B&H)………………..….8
4. Essay of Neven Obradović (SER)……………………...11
5. Essay of Nenad Kovačević (SER)……………………...14
6. Essay of Anton Jurovicki (MNE)……………………......17
7. Essay of Dino Pešut (CRO)……………………………..20
8. Essay of Ana Kristijan (SER)……………………………23
9. Essay of Ena Peeva (MK)……………………………….26
10. Essay of Anastazija Dimitrova (MK)...........................29
11. Essay of Aleda Kushta (ALB)………………………….31
12. Essay of Arber Selmani (KOS)………………………..34
13. About AIESEC B&H…………………………………….37
Page | 6
1. „Time for Plan B(alkans)“ and LDP 2011
This publication is outcome of the overall activities conducted
within project called “Time for Plan B(alkans)”
The members of this project group are LDP 2011 fellows. The
Southeast Europe and the EU – Leadership Development
Programme is organized jointly by the European Fund for the
Balkans, the College of Europe and the TRANSFUSE
Association. The Programme aims to transmit knowledge
about the EU and its relation to the SEE, to stimulate the
leadership and professional skills of participants and to
encourage an exchange of views of young people who aspire
to play an active role in the future of their countries.
The 2011/2012 Programme consists of the following activities:
Two-week Summer Academy in Austria and Slovakia
in September 2011
Group projects
Spring Seminar in Belgium (Brussels/Bruges), in
April 2012
Page | 7
2. About the project
The main aim of this project is to raise awareness by
creating a platform for the debate on the challenges of
achieving EU candidate status for the countries of Western
Balkans. The target groups are students from 18-25 years
old and from countries in the region. Other beneficiaries,
such as politicians, business sector, academics, professors,
NGOs and media, will also be included in the project.
The project is implemented in three phases:
1. Short essays competition on the topic of “The challenges
of achieving EU candidate status in my country”;
2. Issuing a publication with best 10 short essays;
3. Organization of a debate, where two best essays will be
presented and the participants will have the opportunity to
discuss on the mentioned topic.
The name of the project is also related to the SEE countries.
Each country faces the challenges and fulfils the conditions
for candidacy in the EU, on its own. In our opinion, “Plan B”
is that if the neighboring countries help and support each
other in achieving the same goal, all of them will reach it
faster.
In this publication are the 10 best essays of our Essay
Competition.
More info on the project can be found on the website
http://www.wix.com/planbalkans/planb#!
Page | 8
Anja Lejli Hessarbani
...is a student of Political Science and Diplomacy in Sarajevo.
Anja worked as an intern in Transparency International B&H, and Embassies of B&H
in Vienna and Athens.
Bosnia and Herzegovina’s challenge is to act as one, homogenous state and not as divided communities.
My country is Bosnia and Herzegovina. Even though many did not hear about it, it is small and beautiful country centered in the heart of Europe with approximately 4 million people on the area of 51, 197 km2. However, this small country was marked with a turbulent history (1992-1995). This country has very complex political structure which is the result of Dayton Peace Agreement that played a big role in the establishing peace at that time.
Complexity of the political system in Bosnia and Herzegovina is reflected in two entities plus Brcko District, 10 cantons, 3 presidents and numerous dysfunctional bureaucracies.
From the above briefly mentioned facts one can see that one of the biggest challenges of Bosnia and Herzegovina to become a part of EU is its constitution that is incompatible with the EU. Moreover, the will of political leaders is also one of the crucial elements in the process in itself. Some political leaders enjoying the positions they occupy, using
Page | 9
various tools, such as media, make even more divisions in this society.
Moreover, in the constitution of the Bosnia and Herzegovina it is said that Bosnia and Herzegovina is a secular state, but it seems that it is far from that, taking into account that religious leaders give their opinion on the questions that are political and get involved in every aspect of current politics which makes such complicated system even more complicated. Some fundamental human rights are violated by its constitution, as the inclusion of the minority representatives in politics and its institutions. Bosnia and Herzegovina’s challenge is to act as one, homogenous state and not as divided communities. This can only be reached by the change of the Dayton Peace Agreement and the change of the constitution, which can be easily reached if we only regarded them by the “Living tree approach”
1, but
that will not be possible because of the lack of the political will.
To be able to be an active member of EU, it is also need to have the economic conditions for that. It is necessary to raise the living standards in order to be able to cope with the standards established by the EU. Because in a country, with its 27, 6% people unemployed (even though it is considered that this number is even higher), 48% of the people live on the margins of existence, and the others with the retirements and salaries that are the lowest in the region, will give the headache to the citizens of Bosnia and
1 Living Tree approach is approach of constitutional interpretation
which claims that constitution is organic and has to be read in a broad and progressive manner so as to adapt it to the changing times.
Page | 10
Herzegovina placing their existence into the question, but also to the EU.
Together with this is the fact that aids, donations and other programs designed for and targeted at this group of people have to be more effectively applied and monitored in order to improve the quality of the people living here, instead of the money distributed on the projects that remain only as dead letter on the paper.
However, youth and minorities have to be included in order to give them prosperous country for which they will have a vision and wish to improve and not to see this country as the station while waiting the train for another country which raises more global issues concerning this country but also the other.
And last, but not less important challenge is corruption. Why this issue? Because if you manage to reduce it, many other questions will be solved. All state institutions need a revision of the budget spent and people employed, because many people still working in these institutions got the job illegally, or it is time for them to get retired which would open the positions for the younger people and more effective ones. The bureaucracy has to be reaching the minimum level and to be composed of the small, accurate people, well educated that will know to do their job more effectively by which money and time will be saved. Corruption is also reflected in the media, infrastructure, medicine, politics and many other aspects. Corruption in these segments is also high which prevents this country to get improved. However, this country has a good chance to be a candidate country of the EU, only if there is will for that and hard work to confront and overcome above mentioned challenges.
Page | 11
Neven Obradović
...is a student of journalism master
studies in Niš, Sebia. In addition, Neven
works as a teaching assistant on the
Faculty of Philosophy on subjects:
Investigative journalism and Agency
journalism.
When speaking about Serbia, corruption is the
systematical problem of the society, or better said it’s a
way of life.
Serbia probably has one of the greatest challenges of all the
countries in the region in getting the membership in the EU.
Politicians both from EU and Serbia and the media label
Kosovo as the biggest challenge. The unsolved problem of
Kosovo surely is the major problem for many reasons which
are familiar to everybody; however, the government is
putting that problem on top of its agenda, and putting the
rest of the challenges, which are equally important for
getting a full membership, to the bottom. Those problems
are concerning simple man and the normalization of life in
the Balkans. In order to even think of joining the community
of European nations corruption, unemployment, education
are definitely fields that crave for changes in Serbia.
When speaking about Serbia, corruption is the systematical
problem of the society, or better said it’s a way of life. The
best way of representing it is the circular example from birth
to death.
Page | 12
However, when you are born, your father, should, as if by a
rule, give some “present” to the doctor and nurses in order for
them to take better care of you. If not, they could be rude with
your mother or slightly careless with you. After a couple of
interesting years of growing up comes a new challenge -
getting a place in the kindergarten. There is a shortage of
preschool institutions, and if you are not able to pay for a
private one, just in order to get on the waiting list for a public
one, which can count more than 2 000 kids, you should offer a
certain amount of money to the headmaster or an employee
just to provide a normal growing up and socialization, and of
course, after getting a place in the kindergarten there are
more things to pay, but let’s not go into details. Then comes
the elementary school where teachers are the “target group”.
During high school you get more mature and you learn the
rules of survival in the system. We are witnessing various,
even interesting, ways of bribe and corruption by those who
are not willing to study and in order to get the passing grade
often offer fixing your house, collecting your cherries during
the summer break, mending your car, it all depends which
crafts your family can offer and what your teacher needs.
When it comes to high education, there are exact price lists of
the exams on certain universities which were put by
professors and which are well known by all the students. It’s
simple, like in a fast-food restaurant, when you open the
menu, instead of the meals there are exams, and in the end
you won’t get a fiscal bill. After getting a university degree
comes a time when a citizen of Serbia spends a lot of money
in the name of corruption.
Page | 13
Of course, just to get in touch with your eventual employer
you have to be a member of a political party, and not just
any party but the ruling one, and in some cases, the
opposition can provide a job for its sympathizers. Having a
job and a family you enter the enchanted circle of corruption
which your parents passed in order to get you out on the
right way. After that you get old and ill. Health care is a
system of its own when it comes to corruption. In order to
get a decent treatment and to be sure that the doctors won’t
forget a scalpel or some other instrument in your body you
need to make things easier. The beginner level is a pack of
coffee and a bottle of juice, intermediate level is a bottle of
Scotch or some other hard liquor, and the advanced level
represents an envelope filled with Euros, a currency of a
union that we desperately crave, a paradox isn’t it? And at
the end of the circle, comes death, and, since the corruption
follows that circular process there were some cases that
after your close relatives died you had to provide a better
place at the graveyard with a “small investment”.
For Serbian authorities elimination of corruption represents
probably the greatest challenge when the membership in
the EU is questioned, but so far the acts showed that they
are not dealing with it seriously and systematically. It all
comes down to the eventual preventive actions which serve
for politicians to show off in front of the cameras instead of
showing us the way out of the dark tunnel of corruption.
Page | 14
Nenad Kovačević
…is from Serbia and currently is
enrolled in MA of European Studies on
the University of Bonn while his
educational background is primarily
connected to law. He has relatively
wide professional experience in that field.
In my opinion, two most important challenges that Serbia
faces in achieving EU candidate status, are: (disputed)
status of Kosovo and corruption
The reason why this essay is wrote just couple of hours
before deadline is not because this author is lazy or has spent
too much time thinking about possible challenges for
achieving EU candidate status for Serbia. The simple thing is
that prognosis and analysis regarding result of the meeting of
European Council, which will take place on 9 December, and
which will clarify whether Serbia is, at least in opinion of
European Council, ready for candidacy are changing on daily
basis. At the moment, prospects, both on the round tables in
Brussels and on the field, are not good. European project is in
peril, Serbia needs attention of the European friends, but the
times are critical for the very survival of the Union. Still, with
having this is mind, I will deal with, in my opinion, with two
most important challenges that Serbia faces in achieving EU
candidate status.
Page | 15
(Disputed) status of Kosovo
As much we can blame political elites in Serbia for
dishonesty and passivity in EU integration, there must be
some understanding for the difficult situation that current
Serbian government is facing. Without even going into
deeper analysis of history of the conflict, it is more than
clear that unresolved status of territory of Kosovo will be a
problem that will heat tensions on already flammable
Balkans. Weak and not unanimous position of EU, impatient
adversaries at the negotiation table, constant tension on the
field, the atmosphere of mistrust, imposition and extortion
without realizing complexity of the situation are not element
that are messenger of good news for Serbia. All actors in
the process must understand that cycles of mistrust and
frustrations in Balkans usually ends with bloodshed and
wars. Still, one must hope that EU, although in crucial times
for its very survival, will show its capacity for export of
stability into the region and, when disputed parties on the
ground are now ready, to define and set into motion new
and functional model of cooperation between two
communities, Serbs and Albanians. The challenge of
“Kosovisation” of the region will remain present until political
elites do not realize that negotiation cannot have winners
and losers.
(Miss) using the process of European integration for
internal politics purposes
(Miss) use of process of European integration for internal
politics purposes is not something unfamiliar to Serbia, or
other countries in the region for that matter.
Page | 16
Corruption of European idea by political elites has created
several devastating effects namely, image of EU as
“blackmailing bureaucracy machine”, reforms that are
conducted only because Brussels wants so, looking at EU as
political nanny that will punish the country for everything bad
that it does and award for making progress in right direction.
This “do ut des” (Latin for "I give so that you may give") policy
is not helping at all. Nevertheless, of course, EU is not only to
blame. They are acting in that manner only because they
have politicians who are manipulating with uneducated voters
about what the Union is all about. Surely, EU should not
involve into the internal politics, but it must its capacity to raise
awareness in NGO sector and in direct contact with citizens,
especially with youth activist and academics. This is one of
the ways to create better understanding and good
environment about realistic and responsible debate on EU.
Unfortunately, it seems that “chasing the candidacy status”
has become more of a prestige intended only to help political
elite in power in their political battle for winning the elections
and therefore, we cannot count on Serbian political elite to do
such a thing.
That is one of the core problems of the EU integration
process, surely not only in Serbia. Country lead in such
irresponsible way is figuratively speaking “bad news”, and it
seems that present Europe cannot cope anymore with bad
news, especially not from (potential) candidate.
Page | 17
Anton Jurovicki
…is a student of Information
Systems
and Technology in Podgorica.
Anton is a young entrepreneur.
He owns a number of websites and
a Promotion and Design Agency.
Doing business inside Montenegro can be good in
many ways but if I would like to spread my business,
MNE is small country that can’t offer big profits and
international brand.
When it was very oblivious that Montenegro will soon
become a candidate for EU I started thinking about my
future. I heard a lot about EU on my University, from my
friends but no one talked about options I will have when
Montenegro becomes part of European Union.
People only talk how EU will be a great benefit for us
because of the potential of raising the economic standard,
better conditions for living; they don’t talk how actually all
that depends only from us. EU is a new start and a possible
linger for all of those who sit at home and wait to be called
on a job interview or just called to start working. EU
demands competitiveness, constant work and progress.
Page | 18
Being in EU is a new chance and opportunity for all young
people in Montenegro to prove themselves on the new
market, to show new ideas in an area that is enormous
comparing it to Montenegro. Soon we will live in the county
that has 600 million people! Soon my partner or rival in
business will be a student from France, Germany. We need to
cope and realize that becoming a part of EU is new motivation
which has to lift us to unseen heights! When we sum all
impressions EU is one strong bureaucratic creation that
demands many upgrades and developments of our society so
that it can be shoulder to shoulder with other countries in
the EU. For me personally EU is more than a chance it’s
simply one big area that has place for me, my ideas, creation,
knowledge. Strong laws and regulations from EU will linger
some things, such as starting new business, minimal wage of
an employee, taxes and other.
I guess that the best thing about EU is international expansion
of ideas, products and companies. Our country has to make
good business bases so entrepreneurs can succeed in EU.
Doing business inside Montenegro can be good in many ways
but if I would like to spread my business, MNE is small
country that can’t offer big profits and international brand.
Goal of MNE should also be to create good encouraging wave
of positive thinking towards EU, so people here can have
company that is strong and competitive in Europe and world
because people are afraid of going global and they are scared
of competition which EU will give us plenty
Montenegro is one of the world's fastest growing tourism
markets but I think it will have to improve a lot, considering
Page | 19
that some new laws will have to apply on it. There are also
many other things that Montenegro will face with, in order to
become a good student of EU. We need to root out
corruption, business barriers, make our government more
transparent. We also need to improve our information
system. Recently I read census data and it shows that
almost half of citizens are IT illiterate. This will have to
change. One of future obstacles of our society is definitely
this information illiteracy which is sad, considering that we
live in 21. century. We are living in the digital age where
basics of IT are required on daily basis.
One of the challenges that we will face is “challenges of our
own mind”. People will soon realize that openness and
cooperation is the best method to succeed and that’s what
EU can offer. Better life is expected in one way or
another, only it will take some time for things
to stabilize and fortify so things and life generally can
move positive during the merger process with the other
members of the European Union.
EU will offer riddance of business barriers especially when it
comes to pushing products internationally. It
is obvious that entering EU will contribute
to society, individuals, businesses and that it will contribute
to overall development of Montenegro.
I know that leaders of my county are opt to every challenge
and that all tasks or requirements that are needed from
Montenegro will be done in satisfying way. I’m sure our path
towards EU will be pawed with excellence and
determination.
Page | 20
Dino Pešut
…is a student of Dramatic Arts in
Zagreb. Dino is an artistic soul and
has been actively involved in
contemporary dance, acting
and producing. Currently, Dino is
living in Ljubljana as a Basileus
scholar.
Not long after approval for acceptance in the EU, in
Croatia happened a big incident during a gay pride in
Split and still no legal action nor political will has been
showed.
Croatia will most probably enter the European Union in the
next 12 months and my possible grant for Erasmus Mundus in
performing arts will drop more than 50 percent enabling me a
semi- decent life in France or Belgium. The obvious paradox
of acceptance and exclusion in the apparatus of the European
Union. The paradox of the end of one and beginning of the
other struggle connected to the European Union.
Hence, I would like to propose certain points which clarify
this paradoxical situations and somewhat schizophrenic
messages send by European union towards Croatia as it is
the first country (sans Slovenia) which will enter. There are
two aspects pointing each other. On one side, we have
European Union as a permutation of the European
economical alliance. Without doubt, a strong political initial
context is the most obvious while preparing for the entrance.
Page | 21
Each country, without doubt has to be prepared, not only to
become similar as well to be able to integrate in the new
economical machine. On the other hand, there is a concept
of United Europe which constructs of collective symbolic
values nurtured within the walls of the boarders of European
Union.
Hence, as we might see recently, economy is neither a
possession nor value. It transformed in highly sophisticated
system which operates alone and in between global
activities. Obviously, the values Europe gathers is the one
based on thousands of years of philosophical thought and
mistakes, or better to say catastrophic, from which we all
should been learning. Those values, although may be
considered ideological is the edge of modernity.
The struggle for the candidate is therefore not only in the
economical as it is in ideological as well. The Balkan
countries still have not figured out how to deal with blame of
the history, nor had it been able to rethink its complexes
regarding to it. History is still treated as a populist political
campaign and strong ideology is somewhat felt. What is
candidate to do? It is certain that the standard will always be
lower, but those things which might be changed are not. Let
me issue the question of human rights. Here is the obvious
contradiction which happened in Croatia. Not long after
approval for acceptance in the EU, in Croatia happened a
big incident during a gay pride in Split and still no legal
action nor political will has been showed. More recently,
even the left option said it will not approve further steps
toward LGBTQ rights.
Page | 22
Although it is just one of the possible problems, it occurs to
me as paradigmatic evidence of those messages sent from
the inside. Without doubt, my generation is the one who will
carry those values given to us. My generation is the one who
will embrace United Europe and we have done some share.
With boyfriends in Paris, best friends in London, colleagues in
Prague, with internet connection, with concerts of Bon Iver in
Vienna... But still, it is for privileged children, often from the
upper middle class, educated and from liberal households.
The ideological apparatus is strong here. I would like to argue
Athusser and induct the triangle church-family-school as the
representatives of populist neo-90s ideologies which of
course have risen hence the recession.
Will the few of us be able to spread the word?
In conclusion, I would like to propose a plea to let us in as we
described above are your target. You should re-read Hannah
Arendt, re-think the new philosophers and re-approach Susan
Sontag. You should let us in, give us opportunities and show
us. We have not been able to travel the Europe while
eighteen. Our families are poorer than yours and we carry the
blame of not completely understanding our own history.
In conclusion, as I wait for my Easy jet to go to Paris, to feel,
to dream of my experience, I hope our voices will be heard
and welcomed and in some years maybe paid, not necessary
only in money, but more importantly in exchanging values.
Page | 23
Ana Kristijan
…is a student of Law in Novi Sad.
Ana’s main fields of interest are
international relations, with a focus on the
European Union, human rights and
economics development.
The European Union is not about satisfying the
requirements of fellow member states while oppressing
one’s own people.
The challenges Serbia faces on its way to the European
Union are – like in the case of any former EU candidate who
is a member now – numberless. Nevertheless, as I see it,
there is one fundamental problem: Serbia is not pursuing
E.U.R.O.P.E. Haven’t heard about this buzzword yet?
E.U.R.O.P.E. is an ideology that highlights the milestones
along the path towards the European Union. Look how it
works:
E : economic development. If a country seeks to integrate
into an economic entity, it will need to adjust the objectives
of its economic policy to the goals of the community, and it
will need to harmonize its economic cycles with those of the
members of the community. Serbia, being a small and open
export-oriented economy, should pay special attention to its
trade relations, the progressive development of its economy
Page | 24
including financial stability, high rates of employment and an
effective reduction of poverty, and R&D among other
investments.
U : unity of the nation. Becoming a member of the European
Union should be the reflection of the will of the
overwhelming majority of the nation of Serbia. Not a single
citizen should feel deprived of her/his possibilities and rights
by the process. Therefore, decision makers in Serbia shall
take full advantage of the opportunities provided by the
European integration, and should advocate it in a way that
makes the nation stand behind the idea as a unity.
R : respect towards all people(s) and their rights. The
European Union is not about satisfying the requirements of
fellow member states while oppressing one’s own people.
On the contrary: first the rights of citizens should be
guaranteed, and then, after having set up a solid system
that represents the rights of the population can the domestic
structure of the country be ‘interconnected’ to other states.
In Serbia where the mixed population is a potential and a
challenge at the same time, this issue needs to be dealt with
special care.
O : outside relations. It goes without saying that
international relations are crucial. Note however, that it is
not only EU member states whose sympathy should be
sought. Particular attention should be paid to neighboring
countries. None of the former Yugoslavian republics should
let history doom present relations to failure. Unless Serbia
will be able to have mature negotiations with its neighbors
Page | 25
concerning the most important aspects of life, the European
Union – and other supra- and international organizations –
will not handle the country as an equal partner.
P : potential. Serbia is a lucky country. Don’t agree? Just
think about the favorable conditions and potential it has! Its
geographical location, the influence of its economy in the
region, its multi-ethnic population and rich cultural life are all
chances which should be seized now in order to build up a
well-functioning country which will benefit present and
upcoming generations too.
E : a European perspective. Being a European is a very
good starting point in many respects, and it brings about a
lot of assumptions towards a country. Dealing with global
issues with European generosity often delivers satisfying
results; therefore Serbia should follow this ideology in its
foreign policy and international affairs. Harmonizing foreign
policy is a prerequisite of membership too.
My conclusion is that the only thing Serbia should do in
order to overcome the challenges it faces on its way to the
EU, is to listen to EUROPE, while safeguarding its own
values and protecting its traditions – which is, by the way,
an essential element of being European and being a
member of the European Union.
Page | 26
Ena Peeva
…is 18 years old and in her
last year in high school.
For Ena this topic is something that
she finds very important
and attractive, because she wants to
study International Relations
and work in this field in the future.
I approve the changes in the Justice System, changes in
the Health Resources, as well as the one in the
Educational system and I must say that I feel very happy
when I see that they are slowly becoming real life
changes that people can feel throughout real life
situations.
Becoming part of the European Union is one of the most
important goals for my country, its current government and
most of its citizens. Macedonia, as a crossroad country, has
been attractive for foreign investments since always, but
unfortunately, it was also very attractive for conquering. It is a
real Balkan treasure, small, rich with natural resources and
most important with a very strategic location. It is a transit
country, which connects the Balkans to Eastern, Western and
Central Europe.
Nowadays, the politicians that are leading the Macedonian
government have one main issue, called Macedonia in
Europe.
Page | 27
Most of the citizens are for achieving this issue, but there
are also a big number of them that does not want to see its
bellowed homeland country in the EU, because they do not
want to be in the EU as citizens of a country that is not
Macedonia. I, as a young citizen of this country, at almost
18 years of age, can say that yes, I admit and respect
almost all challenges that the EU gives to its member states,
but I do not agree with changing the identity in order to
become an EU member. There must be another solution for
this challenge, but time is needed to find it out.
I approve the changes in the Justice System, changes in the
Health Resources, as well as the one in the Educational
system and I must say that I feel very happy when I see that
they are slowly becoming real life changes that people can
feel throughout real life situations. Macedonia is a candidate
for accession to Europe since 2005 and until then and also
since then a lot of things have started going positive. As a
student, I mostly appreciate the changes in Education,
because on its way towards the EU, Macedonia has made
big changes in the Educational programs and what I like the
most about the changes, it has opened the students’
prospective viewing much more widely than it used to be
before.
Since achieving the candidate status, the students got a
chance to expand their knowledge outside the borders of
their country, throughout different Exchange programs,
mostly funded by the European Union. If we perceive it from
the real point of view, without the EU’s pleading for
Macedonian students, 95% of them wouldn’t ever get a
Page | 28
chance to expand their knowledge outside the country
borders.
I believe that the cancelling of the visa system for Macedonia
has also helped a lot for expanding the horizons of citizens of
one country and making them ready for accepting the
challenges that EU gives in order to become its member. It is
very hard to explain to the citizens of a country that until
yesterday was part of a communist system that did not make
any changes for ages, the reforms that they have to make in
order to join the EU family, unless you show them and open
their horizons. I strongly believe that throughout traveling,
exchanges and, most important, with meeting new cultures
and traditions, people expand their views and start accepting
change easier.
To summarize, I think that Macedonia as a country system
has passed successfully a lot of challenges in order to
achieve the candidate status. The exams that were given to
us until now were successfully passed, but before us there is
a new challenge in the period that is to follow and that we
have to pass it even more successfully in order to get into the
EU. We should learn that we cannot use our hot-strings in
order to achieve something, as well as that being a string
puller is not allowed when talking about the Justice System,
Health System and any other system that is state-funded. We
should teach the young generations that becoming successful
and achieving the life challenges is not easy, but when you
fulfill it with your own work, then they are a million times
worthier than when fulfilling it as a string puller. When, we will
say out loud that we have achieved all this, than we can say
that we are ready for becoming EU members.
Page | 29
Anastazija Dimitrova
…studies environmental engineering and
landscape architecture in Skopje.
In the future Anastazija hopes to
achieve her goals, contribute to the
society and inspire people in many ways.
If we become a member of the EU under a different
name that is not Macedonia that is just a desperate
nation with lost identity, history and tradition who will
never be able to do much good in the Union.
During these 19 years of my life, according to some people I
have seen a lot, and according to other yet so little. One
thing that everyone can be sure of, is that I have seen and
felt the never-ending battle my country is leading in order to
become a member of the European Union. It has been
stated over and over again that this is our primary goal, but
the question why after 20 years we are still far away from
becoming a member still stays unanswered.
One of the most complicated problems that Macedonia is
facing in the process of becoming a candidate is the name
issue. Many people will say that this is just a silly
misunderstanding, a battle of Don Quixote against the wind
mills, but how can we stay indifferent when someone wants
to rename us against our will. If we become a member of
the EU under a different name that is not Macedonia that is
Page | 30
just a desperate nation with lost identity, history and tradition
who will never be able to do much good in the Union. In
order to solve this problem, it is my belief that we have to
explain to the world that a name is never just a name, it is a
whole identity and identity is the one thing that no one has
the right to take away from you.
Of course the name is not the only problem. As residents of
the Balkan Polynesian, is in our mentality to think that we are
better then everyone, that we need no help or assistance from
anyone, that we can make it on our own. Well, if I have the
chance to say one thing to the people who run my country it
will be this: You cannot do everything, you do not know
everything. Ask for help, ask for opinions! We have to
understand that asking for help is not a bad thing to do. It will
not make us look bad and it will not make us loose. We can
learn so much from countries and nations around the world. If
we just try to change and fix things one by one, by looking
and comparing what other have done, we will be more
developed, more organized and more appreciated from
Europe and the world.
These changes of course, can never happen by night. But we,
as young people can help to make them happen sooner. We
have to understand that it is of great importance for
Macedonia to become a part of the European family, because
that will help us and our fellow citizens in the future. We have
to stand up and speak, we have to inspire change and be the
change. We have to take some action and show that we, the
youth have the power within us. It is never easy to conquer so
many challenges. But if we don’t try who will?
Page | 31
Aleda Kushta
…is 19 years old and she is studying
Economics in her first
academic year, in Tirana.
Aleda speaks English, Turkish and a
little bit of Spanish
and Italian language.
The barriers that are created between the opposition
and government are making our achievement in the EU
even more difficult and the time of admission is being
extended indefinitely.
“A day will come when you, France, you, Italy, you, England,
you, Germany, all of you nations of the continent, will,
without losing your distinctive qualities, be blended into a
European fraternity.” This was what Victor Hugo, a well
known French poet and novelist predicted about the future
of Europe. In this century, his predictions came true.
But what is the EU? European Union is an economic
alliance of nations. It unifies standards and laws that
contribute to economic growth. The EU goals include
promoting economic and social progress, introducing
European citizenship as a complement to national
citizenship, and giving the EU a significant role in
international affairs. To achieve its goal of a borderless
Europe, the EU is removing barriers to free trade among its
members.
Page | 32
The right to free movement under the same conditions as
every national citizen in the EU Member state. The right to
vote and to stand in local and European elections throughout
the EU. The right to diplomatic protection by every EU
Members States representation in the world. The right to file a
petition to the EU Parliament. Everyone who is citizen of a
Member State is automatically a EU citizen.
Every country that wants to be a member of the EU must not
allow corruption in administrative bureaus. Everyone must be
treated equally in front of the law. The comprehension
between the government and the opposition is also a very
important issue because it gives a political stability to the
country. The independence of the courts is another obligation
if you want to be an EU member. The implementation of the
new currency, the Euro, so we won’t use anymore the Lek
currency. The economy of the state must be in a certain level
so that the country development and welfare could be greater.
The first step that my country, Albania took last December
was the liberalization of the visa. I remember very well that
day because it made possible our free movement among the
European countries. The joy and happiness that this brought
to people that went for the first time outside Albania to see
their families or relatives after many years was indescribable.
I was also one of this people; I went to see my relatives in
Austria after 4 years. This was a successful achievement for
Albania. Another important achievement was also the
membership in the OTAN.
Page | 33
The main point that makes the EU to be so requested is the
importance of an extraordinary practice such as the one that
determines not only the politics and economy, but also the
everyday issues of all citizens including day by day even
more areas. As an important example we can use the
implementation of the currency Euro as a mean of payment
since 2002. Another reason is that now the decisions are
not only taken in the capital cities of the states which are
members in the EU, but also in Brussels.
The EU is considered as the biggest economical zone in the
world. The importance of the EU has increased also due to
its gradual expansion. There were only 6 countries when it
started and now there are 27 members of the EU. Taking
this in consideration, if Albania could achieve being an EU
member in the future would be a significant accomplishment
which will help my country to have a greater development
and prosperity.
Meanwhile, Albania did not achieve her challenges because
of the disputes between the government and opposition.
The last elections for the Major of Tirana brought once again
the political forces into conflicts. Even though the elections
were declared by the respective ambassadors in Albania
and the EU ambassadors as regular and impartial ones, the
opposition forces rejected them.
The barriers that are created between the opposition and
government are making our achievement in the EU even
more difficult and the time of admission is being extended
indefinitely. As soon as these disputes could be solved, our
acceptance in the EU family will be a reality.
Page | 34
Arber Selmani
…currently works as an arts journalist
in a daily newspaper in Pristine.
In the last years he has worked on
the
radio and a television station.
Arber is also a student of Marketing.
Five European countries do not recognize Kosovo as an
independent country, there is corruption, murders,
crimes, and other things, but the main justification to all
these things is: “we are in transition.”
When I think about that almost 45% of population of
Republic of Kosovo, my country, are unemployed, 35% of
them lives in poor conditions, 18% of them are facing the
death and from the corruption field we are the best one, with
all these facts it looks like we are far away from the
integration of European Union. Its not that I don’t want to,
but those guys from the EU are not “foolish” people to
accept us, the country which they expect stability and they
don’t find something near that. However, if you think about
the development of this country in the period after the war,
EU had made only one mistake, when they asked for State
stability in Kosovo, because in fact the Republic of Kosovo
is the most stabile country in Balkans, Europe or almost in
the whole world, but still if we take a look to the state
Page | 35
stability of European countries we have many examples
when people of those countries have abused state finances.
Half-stability we can count either when the number of
unemployment is very high approximately 45%-50% ,
stability is when the young people are not educated and
everyday they used to spend their lives to the coffee bars
and pubs, there is no future from these places. It is stabile
even the citizen votes that happens once in a while, and it
doesn’t change anything. If it is required the stability of the
country in order to integrate to EU, what we can say about
this, is that Kosovo is on a sub-way with no end. Kosovo
was always been stabile even though we had many
promises from politicians in their electoral campaigns that
they will change and improve our country for a better future;
those were only bunch of lies from them, of course with a lot
of stability again.
I checked the other things to figure out other conditions to
be part of EU. It was required a stable economy. Maybe I’m
not exaggerating this, but the stability was always there.
Economic tenders are always won by inexperienced people.
Kosovo as a new country is the biggest victim of Former-
Yugoslavia which means that is far away from this
integration. Five European countries do not recognize
Kosovo as an independent country, there is corruption,
murders, crimes, and other things, but the main justification
to all these things is: “we are in transition.” Recently, Japan
had a powerful earthquake which left many consequences
in that country but if we compare the photographs which
Page | 36
were taken after the earthquake and those taken 6 months
after that happened, it looks different country and what
Japanese people did was a masterpiece because for 6
months they achieved rebuilding their country in the best
possible way. In Kosovo, since the war is over 11 years are
not enough to improve the country and still the only
justification is that we are in Transition.
Years ago when the police files were stolen inside the police
department, it would be a huge scandal all over the world but
what the prime minister said was “the police was careless in
this situation and we have to be more careful”. If you can
make it to steal files in police department that means that you
can kill 20 people in the middle of the day. 12 years have
gone and I’m 12 years older now, so if I multiply with 5 or 6 I
will be quite old when this country can make it possible to
integrate between other EU countries. It is not random that we
had internationals for a quite long time after the war, because
not many of them help us, if we don’t firstly help ourselves.
Often it is said that young people can shake rocks but I do not
agree that they can move the terrible foundation. Millions
money of Kosovo have lost and I cannot return them back as
an economist. Personally what I can do is to create a good
state education, so these things cannot happen again.
Page | 37
13. About AIESEC B&H
AIESEC is the biggest global organization administered by students and young people. It is an international network which enables organizations to collaborate and find students and graduates throughout exchange programmes, seminars, conferences and virtual systems of communication.
Focus of AIESEC is the individual and his personal and professional development.
AIESEC is present in B&H since 1953, which makes B&H one of the oldest AIESEC countries in the world. Today, AIESEC in Sarajevo has around 50 members, which actively
Page | 38
participate in the implementation of various activities and projects.
Projects of AIESEC B&H
„AIESEC Career Days“– Primary goal of the project is enabling contact between students and labor market and in such way to reduce unemployment of young people and augmentation of their activities.
PboX (Project based on exchange) – This is a
project which is based on exchange of students, but
it also includes organizing lectures, workshops,
round tables and conferences on a topic of social
importance.
FLMS (Future Leaders Motivation Seminar) – The
main aim of this project is admittance of new
members in AIESEC, their acquaintance with the
organization, their involvement and a start of training
for development of young leaders.
LTS (Local Training Seminar) – The goals of this
conference are member training, presentation of
future plans (especially of the local committee) and
through workshops, sessions and different
simulations to
Summer NatCo – The aim of this conference is to
present to the members the achievements of
AIESEC B&H in the past period and to choose the
president and members of the management boards
on the national and local levels.
Page | 39
Page | 40
„Time for Plan B(alkans)” group members:
Irma Zulić (B&H) Sonja
Project Coordinator Delova
(MK)
Dajana Džindo Cristian
(B&H) Gherasim
(ROM)
Rezarta Caushaj Žarko
(ALB) Petrović
(MN)
The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of the
members of “Time for Plan B (alkans)” Project group and can in no
way be taken to reflect the views of the organizers of the Southeast
Europe and the EU – Leadership Development Programme