the 7 deadly sins agileagilesocal.com/files/agilesocal-2016-09_deadly-sins-agile.pdf · the 7...

43
HOW CULTURE THREATENS AGILE: THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, CSM®, CSPO®, CBAP® LEAD BUSINESS SYSTEMS ANALYST, FIRST AMERICAN TITLE

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

H O W C U L T U R E T H R E A T E N S A G I L E : T H E 7 D E A D L Y D Y S F U N C T I O N S O F O R G A N I Z A T I O N S & H O W T O F I X T H E M

A PA RNA SU R E SH , M . A , M . S , C S M ® , C S P O ® , C B A P ®

L E A D B U S I N E S S S Y S T E M S A N A LY S T , F I R S T A M E R I C A N T I T L E

Page 2: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

WHAT IS CULTURE?

Page 3: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

WHAT IS CULTURE?

•Organizational culture is a system of

shared assumptions, values, and beliefs.

•These shared values influence how people

dress, act, and do their jobs.

•Culture dictates HOW people BEHAVE in

organizations.

Page 4: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

WHAT IS STRATEGY?

Page 5: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

WHAT IS STRATEGY?

•An organizational strategy is the plan a

company intends to execute to achieve long-

term goals.

•Organizational behavior should be driven by

organizational strategy.

Page 6: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

STRATEGY VS. CULTURE: WHO WINS?

Organizational behavior should be driven by organizational strategy.

vs.

Culture dictates HOW people BEHAVE in organizations.

Page 7: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

WHY DOES CULTURE MATTER?

“Culture EATS Strategy

for Lunch!”

Page 8: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#1 BUSINESS DOES NOT 'GET ' AGILE

Page 9: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#1 BUSINESS DOES NOT 'GET' AGILE: SYMPTOMS

• Business stakeholders with competing priorities/interests

• Unrealistic expectations

• ‘Gotta-have-it-now’ Fires

Page 10: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#1 BUSINESS DOES NOT 'GET' AGILE: CONSEQUENCES

• Scope creep every sprint

• Team caught in the middle

•Overworked team/Failure to deliver

Page 11: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#1 BUSINESS DOES NOT 'GET' AGILE: SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 12: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#1 BUSINESS DOES NOT 'GET' AGILE: SOLUTION

• Chief product owner with ‘teeth’

•Mandatory Agile training/education for business

stakeholders

• Scrum Master with ‘teeth’

Page 13: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#2 MANAGEMENT DOES NOT 'DO ' AGILE

Page 14: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#2 MANAGEMENT DOES NOT 'DO' AGILE: SYMPTOMS

• Senior Management insists team accept 'side projects'

• PMO tries to ‘direct’ team

• Prioritizing non-value added work

Page 15: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#2 MANAGEMENT DOES NOT 'DO' AGILE: CONSEQUENCES

•Team has no say in scope of sprint

•Overworked and demoralized team

•Quality of critical work drops

Page 16: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#2 MANAGEMENT DOES NOT 'DO' AGILE : SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 17: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#2 MANAGEMENT DOES NOT 'DO' AGILE: SOLUTION

• Each Side Project = Sized Interruption story

• Scrum Master with ‘teeth’

• Enlist Top Management Support with ear to the ground

Page 18: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#3 FOSTERING UNHEALTHY COMPETITION

Page 19: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#3 FOSTERING UNHEALTHY COMPETITION: SYMPTOMS

• Comparing velocities of 2 teams

•Managers playing show-off

• Theory X Managers doubling down on team

Page 20: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#3 FOSTERING UNHEALTHY COMPETITION: CONSEQUENCES

• Lowers team morale

• Ups chances of velocity being gamed

• Reduces collaboration between teams

Page 21: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#3 FOSTERING UNHEALTHY COMPETITION: SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 22: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#3 FOSTERING UNHEALTHY COMPETITION: SOLUTION

•Measure and grow ‘Agile IQ’ of organization

• Recognize and Reward agile-savvy managers

• Refuse to ‘play the game’

Page 23: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#4 MAXING OUT CAPACITY AT START OF A SPRINT

Page 24: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#4 MAXING OUT CAPACITY AT START OF A SPRINT: SYMPTOMS

•Overworked team

•Disruptive interruptions

• Scrum master ignores Murphy’s Law

Page 25: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#4 MAXING OUT TEAM CAPACITY AT START OF SPRINT: CONSEQUENCES

• Sets up team for failure

• Fails to account for real life uncertainties

• Fails to acknowledge nature of agile discovery

Page 26: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#4 MAXING OUT TEAM CAPACITY AT START OF SPRINT : SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 27: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#4 MAXING OUT TEAM CAPACITY AT START OF SPRINT : SOLUTION

• Allocate no more than 70% of capacity during iteration

planning

• Tie Team Capacity to Project Health Indicators to raise

visibilty

• Better agile project planning with buffers

Page 28: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#5 TOXIC RETROSPECTIVES

Page 29: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#5 TOXIC RETROSPECTIVES : SYMPTOMS

• Retrospective used to assign blame/pass the buck

• Bucket List of Action Items

• You can cut the tension with a knife

Page 30: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#5 TOXIC RETROSPECTIVES: CONSEQUENCES

• Team dreads retrospectives

• Lower team morale

• People vote with their feet

Page 31: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#5 TOXIC RETROSPECTIVES: SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 32: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#5 TOXIC RETROSPECTIVES: SOLUTION

•Get a more effective scrum master

• Enforce no ‘A**hole’ Rule within team

• Stick to a really short list of action items – even just one

and get it done

Page 33: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#6 BAD POWER STRUCTURES WITHIN AGILE TEAM

Page 34: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#6 BAD POWER STRUCTURES WITHIN AGILE TEAM: SYMPTOMS

• Scrum Master = Functional Manager

•Development Lead = Functional Manager

• Product Owner = Functional Manager

Page 35: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#6 BAD POWER STRUCTURES WITHIN AGILE TEAM: CONSEQUENCES

• Truth is the first casualty

• Fairness is the next

• Retrospectives are the last nail in the coffin

Page 36: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#6 BAD POWER STRUCTURES WITHIN AGILE TEAM: SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 37: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#6 BAD POWER STRUCTURES WITHIN AGILE TEAM : SOLUTION

• Ask for expert help – get an Agile Coach

• Volunteer to rotate Scrum Master role between team

members

• Ramp up on negotiation and conflict resolution skills

Page 38: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#7 BLIND BELIEF IN METRICS

Page 39: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#7 BLIND BELIEF IN METRICS: SYMPTOMS

• Excessive time spent on non-value added activities

• Retrospectives focus on metrics, metrics, metrics

• Unexpected and unpleasant side effects

Page 40: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#7 BLIND BELIEF IN METRICS: CONSEQUENCES

•What can be measured can be massaged

• People will focus on what is rewarded – the metrics, not

the work

• Can reduce collaboration

Page 41: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#7 BLIND BELIEF IN METRICS: SOLUTIONS?

What worked for you?

Page 42: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

#7 BLIND BELIEF IN METRICS: SOLUTION

• Be careful what you measure: “As you measure, so shall

you reap!”

•Get an Agile Coach to determine what should be

measured and more important what shouldn’t

•Decide carefully what metrics should be made visible, to

whom and why

Page 43: The 7 Deadly Sins Agileagilesocal.com/files/AgileSoCal-2016-09_Deadly-Sins-Agile.pdf · THE 7 DEADLY DYSFUNCTIONS OF ORGANIZATIONS & HOW TO FIX THEM APARNA SURESH, M.A, M.S, ... planning

Q & A