Taming Mr Hayes: Mitigating Signaling Based Attacks on Smartphones

Colin Mulliner, Steffen Liebergeld, Matthias Lannge, and Jean-Pierre Seifert

Technische Universitat Berlin and Deutsche Telekom Laboratories

Outline

Introduction

Background

Threats

Design

Implementation

The AT Command Filter

Conclusions

Introduction

Mobile botnets hijack mobile phone to produce signaling traffic sent from mobile phones to the cellular network core. – DDoS

Rooted smartphones disable protection mechanisms. Applications may launch intentional malicious activity and accidental harmful operations.

Introduction

Protect the cellular network infrastructure from malicious smartphones

Virtual modem Device-side protection system Android-based AT-command filter The OS is separated from the baseband Safe-to-root virtualized Android

Background

Cellular Network ArchitectureBase Station

Serving GPRS Support Node Gateway

GPRS Support Node

Home Location Register

Mobile Switching

Center

Background

Cellular Signaling Signaling traffic MSC and HLR

Voice call, SMS, and updating account settings Packet-data SGSN, GGSN, and HLR

Packet Data Protocol (PDP) ME establishes a PDP context by sending a GPRS-attach

message to SGSN.

Background

Smartphone Architecture

Baseband Processor

Application Processor

Threats

Hijacked Phones and Mobile Botnets

PDP Context Change

Premium Rate SMS Trojans

Rooted Phones

Threats

Hijacked Phones and Mobile Botnets ikee.B iPhone botnet infects about 22,000 devices

HTTP-based C&C channel Traynor et al. issue the AT command to configure and

enable call-forwarding settings in order to cause a high load on the HLR.

Mobile botnets use SMS messages for C&C.

Threats

PDP context activation and de-activation leads to high network load on the GGSN and SGSN.

On Android, it’s possible to force an PDP context change every 2 seconds. 43,200 PDP activation per day.

Pre-paid SIM cards may cause DoS attacks.

Threats

Premium Rate SMS Trojans FakePlayer-A The same problem applies to voice calls to premium

numbers android.permission.SEND_SMS

Threats

Rooted Phones Simply install a modified firmware on the device Exploiting known security flaws

EX: DroidDream

Design

Virtualize

Isolated

Assume the device’s DMA feature can be restricted to safe memory locations. IO-MMU

Design

Micro Kernel as Secure Foundation Modern third-generation micro kernels implement

object-capabilities POLA (principle of least authority)

Design

Virtualized Android Smartphone CPUs are not natively virtualizable. The overhead of running a monolithic OS on top of a micro

kernel is between 5 and 10 percent. Enforce Android to access the baseband by not giving it

access to the baseband’s IO memory. Safe-to-root A commercial version requires a bootloader that is

capable of restricting updates to the Android partition.

Design

Virtual Modem Baseband driver Virtual serial interface AT command filter Virtual network interface IP filter

NAT

Implementation

Intel x86-based smartphone Moorestown platform (SOC) Atom core

ST-Ericsson U300 – baseband

Fiasco.OC micro kernel A L4 micro kernel

Implementation

L4Android Based on L4Linux L4Android kernel ABI is compatible with Android

Implementation

System Setup

L4Android L4Linux

Implementation

L4Linux Booting and initializing the baseband Running baseband driver

Implementation

Modifications to Android RIL libreference-ril.so libsect-ril.so

They built their own abstraction library

The AT Command Filter

AT Command and Man-machine Interface (MMI)

##002#

MMI

Phone app

AT Command

AT+CCFC=0,4

The AT Command Filter

AT+CGDCONT Configure a PDP context

AT+CGACT Activated a configured PDP

AT*EPPSD PDP context control for our ST-Ericsson baseband

AT+CMGS Send an SMS message

ATD+<number>;

Initiates a voice call to given number

AT+CCFC Configure, activate, and de-activate call-forwarding settings

AT+CFUN Configuration of the baseband state

Not used on ST-Ericsson basebnad

AT+CMGS=17>0001000c81101521436587000004d4f29c0e

AT+CCFC=1,1,”4915112345678”, 129, 0

AT+CFUN=4

The AT Command Filter

PDP Context Setup on the STE Baseband

AT+CGDCONT=1,“ip”, “internet.t-mobile”,””,0,0OKAT*EPPSD=1,1,1<?xml version=“1.0”?><connection_parameters><ip_address>10.165.132.86</ip_address> <subnet_mask>255.255.255.255</subnet_mask> <mtu>1500</mtu> <dns_server>193.189.244.255</dns_server> <dns_server>193.189.244.206</dns_server></connection_parameters>OK*EPSB

The AT Command Filter

Special Problem Special case APN

APN for MMS Command side effects

If the baseband is switched between 2G and 3G, the PDP context is disconnected and reconnected

The AT Command Filter

Filtering AT Commands AT_CCFC_interval = 60 (seconds) AT_CCFC_threshold = 5 (# commands)

The AT Command Filter

SMS Filter Short code detector

Short code (4-6 digits): Premium rate numbers Block all SMS to short codes Future work: secure GUI for legit SMS to short codes

Binary Message Payload Detector Non-printable characters Base64 encoding

The AT Command Filter

Blocking Commands To not confuse the application logic in the RIL, our filter

would inject the error message into the stream that carries the responses from the baseband to the RIL

Some commands are never blocked Switch to flight mode (AT+CFUN=4) PDP context deactivation (AT*EPPSD) Emergency calls (ATD 911;)

The AT Command Filter

Profiling Benign AT Command Usage Count the number of commands used

Command # When Why

AT+CFUN 2 Boot Flight mode. Normal mode.

AT+CFUN 1 Use Switch to GSM-only.

AT+CDGMNT 1 Boot Set PDP configuration.

AT*EPPSD 1 Boot Activate PDP context.

AT+CMGS 1 Use Send a SMS message.

ATD 1 Use Issue a voice call.

AT+CCFC 3 Use Query forwarding settings.

AT+CCFC 2 Use Set a call-forwarding.

Evaluation

Setting nanoBTS - openBSC Faraday Cage

Evaluation

Limiting the Call-forwarding Attack [ref] 2,500 TPS (Transactions per second) for low traffic

network 30,000 TPS for high traffic network AT+CCFC takes 4.7 seconds 12 commands per minute

4.7 seconds * 2,500 TPS = 11,750 hosts Threshold = 5 commands / minutes

Evaluation

Evaluation

Limiting PDP Context Changes Switch the baseband mode between GSM-only, 3G-only,

and GSM+3G The threshold for PDP context changes, pt

The threshold for AT*EPPSD commands, et

The threhold for AT+CFUN commands, ct

Pt = et + ct

Without any limit, 30 changes per minute is the maximum possible

Evaluation

Evaluation

SMS Trojan FakePlayer-A premium SMS Trojan

Number 3353

AT+CMGS=1500010004813335999996b71cce56bb01number: 3353short number >3353< detected, could be premiumfilterd: filter returned:0filterd: blocking00010004813335999996b71cce56bb01

Evaluation

SMS Controlled Botnets Binary Payload Detector Blocking text messages will be complicated since they

would need to be analyzed thoroughly before one is able to safety block them

Conclusions

Virtual modem

Future work VPN Gateway Advanced IDS/IPS Policy Update Infrastructure Secure GUI Hardware Virtualization