sustainable vs. organic - mcmanis family …...organic farming is not sustainable pesti ides,...

1
On less land, using less water, and with fewer pescide and ferlizer applicaons (resulng in lower CO2 emissions) sustainable farmers produce higher yields at a lower cost while ensuring future producon of the land. ORGANIC FARMING IS NOT SUSTAINABLE PESTICIDES, FERTILIZERS AND EARTHS RESOURCES An organic farmer is restricted in the pescides and ferlizers he or she is allowed to use making it necessary to do mulple applicaons in a season to ensure a crop (yes, pescides are allowed on organic crops). Mulple applicaons equal more fuel consumpon, more compacon of the soil, and use of more water. A sustainable farmer can choose a pescide or ferlizer that requires few applicaons during the growing season and can rotate their choices to ensure less bug and weed resistance. LABOR An organic farmer must use laborers to remove weeds from a vineyard resulng in higher costs. A sustainable farmer can control weeds throughout the season with mechanizaon and few laborers, keeping costs down. WINES An organic U.S. wine must not contain any added sulfites which greatly reduces shelf life and will oſten change the flavor. (European and Canadian wines may have sulfites added and are labeled organic or biowine.) HOW DO SUSTAINABLE AND ORGANIC DIFFER IN WINE TERMS? HERE ARE SOME EXAMPLES: Sources for more information on sustainable and organic farming—www.nal.usda.gov/afsic www.sustainablewinegrowing.org Organic pesticide list—www.omri.org/omri-list Sustainable farming uses the science and mechanizaon of convenonal farming and the biodiversity of organic farming to reduce the impact on soil, water use and pescide and ferlizer use while maintaining yields and a quality product (organic farming, on average, yields 25% less product). IN BRIEF, SUSTAINABLE FARMING IS A COMBINATION OF BOTH CONVENTIONAL AND ORGANIC FARMING WHATS THE DIFFERENCE? SUSTAINABLE VS. ORGANIC In CA for the 2015 harvest, 25% of wine grapes were certified sustainable vs. less than 2% which were certified organic. In 2015, 64% of CA case production (more than 171M cases) was certified sustainable under 1 of the 4 programs.

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SUSTAINABLE VS. ORGANIC - McManis Family …...ORGANIC FARMING IS NOT SUSTAINABLE PESTI IDES, FERTILIZERS AND EARTH’S RESOUR ES An organic farmer is restricted in the pesticides

On less land, using less water, and with fewer pesticide and fertilizer applications

(resulting in lower CO2 emissions) sustainable farmers produce higher yields at a

lower cost while ensuring future production of the land.

ORGANIC FARMING IS NOT SUSTAINABLE

PESTICIDES, FERTILIZERS AND

EARTH’S RESOURCES

An organic farmer is restricted

in the pesticides and fertilizers

he or she is allowed to use

making it necessary to do

multiple applications in a season

to ensure a crop (yes, pesticides

are allowed on organic crops).

Multiple applications equal

more fuel consumption, more

compaction of the soil, and use

of more water.

A sustainable farmer can choose

a pesticide or fertilizer that

requires few applications during

the growing season and can

rotate their choices to ensure

less bug and weed resistance.

LABOR

An organic farmer must use

laborers to remove weeds from

a vineyard resulting in higher

costs.

A sustainable farmer can control

weeds throughout the season

with mechanization and few

laborers, keeping costs down.

WINES

An organic U.S. wine must not

contain any added sulfites which

greatly reduces shelf life and will

often change the flavor.

(European and Canadian wines

may have sulfites added and are

labeled organic or “bio” wine.)

HOW DO SUSTAINABLE AND ORGANIC DIFFER IN WINE TERMS?

HERE ARE SOME EXAMPLES:

Sources for more information on sustainable and organic farming—www.nal.usda.gov/afsic

www.sustainablewinegrowing.org Organic pesticide list—www.omri.org/omri-list

Sustainable farming uses the science and mechanization of

conventional farming and the biodiversity of organic farming to

reduce the impact on soil, water use and pesticide and fertilizer use

while maintaining yields and a quality product (organic farming, on

average, yields 25% less product).

IN BRIEF, SUSTAINABLE FARMING IS A COMBINATION OF

BOTH CONVENTIONAL AND ORGANIC FARMING

WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE?

SUSTAINABLE VS. ORGANIC

In C

A fo

r the 2

01

5 h

arvest, 2

5%

of w

ine grap

es were certified

sustain

able v

s. less than

2%

wh

ich w

ere certified o

rganic.

In 2

01

5, 6

4%

of

CA

cas

e p

rod

uct

ion

(m

ore

th

an 1

71

M c

ases

) w

as c

erti

fied

su

stai

nab

le u

nd

er 1

of

the

4 p

rogr

ams.