sustainable procurement and community benefits getting ready for procurement reform in scotland...
TRANSCRIPT
Sustainable Procurement and Community Benefits
Getting ready for Procurement Reform in ScotlandJennifer Marshall
What?Developments in Public Procurement Law
- New procurement regulations later this year or early next- Implement 2014 EU Procurement Directive- Implement Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014
- Sustainable Procurement Duty- Community Benefit Requirements- In Scotland only new duties and rules apply to “Regulated
Procurements”- public works contracts with a value over £2m- other public contracts with a value over £50k
What? New Scottish Duties- General Duties apply to regulated procurements but not
“EU Regulated Procurements”- treat relevant economic operators equally- act in a transparent and proportionate manner
- Sustainable Procurement Duty applies to all regulated procurements
- Community Benefit Requirements apply to all “major contracts”
- EU Treaty Principles of equal treatment, non-discrimination and transparency continue to apply to contracts in which there is a “cross-border interest”
Why?Scottish Procurement Policy
Who? Contracting Authorities
- 69 named bodies, office holders and persons- Scottish Administration and Scottish Parliament- Local Government- Others (e.g. Scottish Housing Regulator, Healthcare
Improvement Scotland, Health Boards, Private rented housing panel, Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, Scottish Police Authority)
- Any other contracting authority whose functions are exercisable in or as regards Scotland and do not relate to reserved matters
- But not Utilities (e.g. Scottish Water, Network Rail)
How? Sustainable Procurement Duty
- “before carrying out a regulated procurement, to consider how in conducting the procurement process it can – - improve the economic, social, and environmental
wellbeing of the authority’s area- Facilitate the involvement of small and medium
enterprises, third sector bodies and supported businesses in the process, and
- promote innovation, and- in carrying out the procurement, to act with a view to
securing such improvements identified”
Sustainable Procurement Duty – FAQ
- Must consider only matters that are relevant to what is proposed to be procured and the extent that it is proportionate to take these into account
- Small and Medium Enterprises = not more than 250 employees
- Third sector bodies = non-statutory bodies that exist to provide benefits for society or the environment
- “wellbeing of the authority’s area” includes reducing inequality in the area
- Scottish Government will publish guidance
Technical Specifications
- Standards- Eco-labels- “Dutch Coffee” (Commission v Netherlands Case C-
368/10)- Fair Trade - Organic
- Scottish Government is considering whether Scottish rules on technical specifications should be the same as EU Rules
Contract Conditions
- General freedom to define subject matter of contract- But, restricted by EU law- Non Discrimination (e.g. requirement to have a pre-
existing office in a particular area)- Equal Treatment- Free movement of goods, services etc.
- Terms must be linked to the actual supply, works or services that the contracting authority wants to buy
- “Special” social or environmental conditions may be used
Exclusion and Selection - EU
- Mandatory and Discretionary grounds for rejection- May apply minimum standards of economic and financial
standing and technical and professional ability:- skills, efficiency experience and reliability- environmental management measures - must be linked to the subject matter of the contract
- Cannot exclude for inability to comply with “special conditions” which do not relate to technical ability
Exclusion and Selection – Scotland
- Likely to mirror structure of EU rules- Mandatory rejection grounds related to specified offences- Discretionary rejection grounds may differ slightly:- e.g. failure to comply with statutory duty/specified
misconduct- Provisions for minimum standards- Guidance will cover living wage and employee
representation
Award: Most Economically Advantageous Tender
- “linked to the subject matter of the contract”- Consumption effects (e.g. noise/pollution)- Production effects (renewable energy supply)- Disposal effects (waste)- Workforce matters (equality/ health protection/ social
integration/ employment)- Price or Cost? - “the best price-quality ratio, which shall be
assessed on the basis of criteria, including qualitative, environmental and/or social aspects, linked to the subject matter of the public contract in question”
What is a Community Benefit?
- “a contractual duty imposed by a contracting authority relating to –- Training and recruitment- Availability of sub-contracting opportunities or
- which is otherwise intended to improve the economic, social or environmental wellbeing of the authority’s area in a way additional to the main purpose of the contract in which the requirement is included”
Major Contracts
- Estimated value is equal to or greater than £4 million- Must consider community benefits before carrying out the
procurement- Must include in the contract notice either:- Summary of community benefit requirements, or- Statement of reasons for not including any requirements
- Contract award notice must contain a statement of the benefits which will be derived from the requirements
Contact:
Michael Dean – 0330 222 1713Email: [email protected]
Catriona Munro – 0330 222 1902Email: [email protected]
David McGowan – 0330 222 1880Email: [email protected]
Jennifer Marshall – 0330 222 1860Email: [email protected]