strategic renewal competing at the speed of life©2001 by prentice hall, inc.1-1 the case for...
TRANSCRIPT
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-11
The Case for Strategic Renewal—The The Case for Strategic Renewal—The BasicsBasics
All businesses exist in a dynamic environment.
The dynamics and the level of uncertainty differ by economy, geography, industry, and its particular characteristics.
Businesses constantly interact with their external links and environments; all organizations are extremely dependent and sensitive to their environments.
Companies failing to anticipate, or change in response to, their environments will be outperformed by more proactive/responsive/agile/innovative competitors and will ultimately be driven out of business.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-22
The Certainties of Change & The Certainties of Change & Competition…Competition…
1. The velocity of change is currently at its peak and continues to grow at exponential rates.
2. The level, scope, and breadth of change are increasingly unpredictable and more systemic.
3. Shifts in competitive dynamics, technology, rate of innovation, and increasingly global trends are causing economies, markets, and industries to blur all changing and constantly reinventing the rules of competing.
4. The historical sources of competitive advantage and methods of forming strategy have been largely neutralized or significantly mitigated by global political and economic changes, rapidly developing technologies, and changing demographics.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-33
Change & Strategic ThinkingChange & Strategic Thinking
Imitate, substitute Competitors are rivals Leverage suppliers for
concessions and lower prices Create vertically integrated
structures Organize for size and efficiency Compete for industry
position/rely on size and barriers
to entry Reduce bargaining power of
customers Compete on price and least cost Create functional specialization
and separation within
organization Compete for maximum market
share within a well-defined
industry
Traditional Strategic Planning
Innovate, collaborate, complement Competitors can be partners and
co-opetitors Engage suppliers as collaborators Disaggregate and focus on core
competencies and selectively outsource
Optimize agility and adaptability Create a new industry/define new
rules of competing Engage the customer, delight the
customer Compete on value and offer a
compelling value proposition; create a pleasant experience
Emphasize organizational integration or functions and processes
Create virtual marketspace across industries and optimize profit pools
High-Performance Strategy Formulation
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-44
The Traditional Sources of Competitive The Traditional Sources of Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
MAJOR THEMESMAJOR THEMES
Size
Price
Quality
Location
Product
Structure
Stability
Consistency
Incrementalism
Well-delineated structural lines
MARKET CONDITIONSMARKET CONDITIONS
Markets were growing
Industries were well defined
Geography was important
Natural resources
Natural topography
Customers were local
Environment was predictable
Workforces were stable and risk averse
Communications were linear
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-55
The Competitive Environment Is The Competitive Environment Is Changing…Changing…
Faster, more fluid, increasingly uncertain, and less defined.
Industry structures and boundaries are less defined; becoming fuzzy.
Workforces are more mobile and more assuming of risk.
Incremental improvement and change are not sufficient for survival: 10% growth doesn’t have it anymore.
Less forgiving and tolerant of mistakes.
New Rules:New Rules:
Price, quality, and products are “givens.” All companies must
have these if they are to be in the game.
Price, quality, and products are “givens.” All companies must
have these if they are to be in the game.
New Basis of Competing
New Basis of Competing
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-66
Three Key Drivers of Change…Three Key Drivers of Change…
There are three major forces that drive changes and developments in the marketspace:
INFORMATION INFORMATION TECHNOLOGYTECHNOLOGY
INFORMATION INFORMATION TECHNOLOGYTECHNOLOGY
GLOBALIZATION & GLOBALIZATION & TRANSNATIONALISTRANSNATIONALIS
MM
GLOBALIZATION & GLOBALIZATION & TRANSNATIONALISTRANSNATIONALIS
MM
DIVERSITY & DIVERSITY & MULTICULTURALISMMULTICULTURALISM
DIVERSITY & DIVERSITY & MULTICULTURALISMMULTICULTURALISM
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-77
Key Factors Affecting the Ability to Key Factors Affecting the Ability to Change…Change…
AGE OF THE ORGANIZATIO
N
AGE OF THE ORGANIZATIO
N
SIZE OF THE ORGANIZATIO
N
SIZE OF THE ORGANIZATIO
N
ENVIRONMENTAL
INFLUENCES
ENVIRONMENTAL
INFLUENCES
OWNERSHIP & EQUITY
STRUCTURE
OWNERSHIP & EQUITY
STRUCTURE
FINANCIAL & MARKET SUCCESS
FINANCIAL & MARKET SUCCESS
ABILITY TO LEARN AND
DISCERN PATTERNS
ABILITY TO LEARN AND
DISCERN PATTERNS
CERTAINTY/ UNCERTAINT
Y
CERTAINTY/ UNCERTAINT
Y
LEADERSHIP
LEADERSHIP
How are these likely to affect a company’s propensity and ability to change?
What are some real-life cases in point?
How are these likely to affect a company’s propensity and ability to change?
What are some real-life cases in point?
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-88
The Path of Strategic DeclineThe Path of Strategic Decline
Causes of Strategic Causes of Strategic DDeecline:cline:
Lack sense of reality Institutional arrogance Lost perspective Insular focus Loss of urgency Poor strategy/
products/services Failure to learn Low innovation Recycle leaders/
single mindedness Overreliance on inter-
nal talent
Typical Indicators & Typical Indicators & Symptoms:Symptoms:
Lower revenues Reduced market
presence Reduced earnings Increased employee
turnover Increased cost/high
structural cost Declining market
presence Decrease in customer
interest and satisfaction
Strategic Consequences:Strategic Consequences:
Lower market value/capitalization
Inconsistent strategies Diminished capacity
to compete Diminished capacity
to attract top talent Increased
vulnerability Misalignment of
strategies/actions and external imperatives
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-99
Foundation for Change…Foundation for Change…
The five domains of change for any organization are:
To achieve competitive advantage and successful systemic change, companies can rarely change only one element: they must change all domains (Majchrzak, Blumenthal, Mische, others).
STRATEGYSTRATEGY
PROCESSPROCESS
PEOPLEPEOPLETECHNOLOG
Y
TECHNOLOGY
KNOWLEDGE
KNOWLEDGE
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1010
Three Scopes of ChangeThree Scopes of Change
INCREMENTAL CHANGE: Confined to designated area Low targets of 5–15% value
improvement Generally cost reduction Low risk/low impact
TACTICAL CHANGE: Cross-functional process
change Radical redesign of processes
and selected organizations High risk/high return
SYSTEMIC CHANGE: Complete organizational
change Redefines rules/creates new
market dynamics Linked to innovation strategies Very high risk and return
Level of
Ch
an
ge &
Ris
k
Strategic Implications &
Value
SYSTEMICSYSTEMIC
TACTICALTACTICAL
INCREMENTALINCREMENTAL
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1111
The Five Strategic Pillars: The Keys to High The Five Strategic Pillars: The Keys to High PerformancePerformance
Element Attributes
Knowledge Management: Knowledge must be relevant, accessible, and used if it is to be a source of competitive advantage. Knowledge is difficult to measure, but is inherently recognized for its value.
Information Technology: IT must be used to create new operational processes and organizational designs and support knowledge management and effective transfer. It is rarely a strategy itself; however, if properly aligned with organizational resources, infrastructures, and strategy, it enables effective execution and implementation for competitive advantage.
Organizational Agility Organizational agility involves not only speed, but
& Process Excellence: the ability to adapt to changes and redeploy and reconstitute its assets and resources. Process excellence involves operational leverage, zero defects, and usually high velocities.
Leadership: All organizations require leadership at various levels. To be competitive, organizations require leaders who can communicate, have extensive personal experiences and insights, and encourage learning and innovation.
Innovation: Strategic renewal requires the ability to constantly innovate its processes, products, organization and management
practices. This requires an organizational environment conducive to innovation.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1212
Economy, Market, & Industry Convergence and Integration
Economy, Market, & Industry Convergence and Integration
Creation of MARKETSPACE as a New Competitive Domain
Creation of MARKETSPACE as a New Competitive Domain
The concept of creating/competing in a MARKETSPACE:
Abandons the restrictive definitions and frontiers of traditional industries and markets
Allows for quick adaptation to environmental changes and new imperatives
Allows for innovation and creation of new products/markets/infrastructures, etc.
Discounts old sources of competitive advantage and takes full advantage of the new, key bases for competing (i.e., 5 pillars of strategy)
Is aggressively pursued by the great companies and leads to their sustained high performance (e.g., Dell, Charles Schwab, Wal-Mart)
The concept of creating/competing in a MARKETSPACE:
Abandons the restrictive definitions and frontiers of traditional industries and markets
Allows for quick adaptation to environmental changes and new imperatives
Allows for innovation and creation of new products/markets/infrastructures, etc.
Discounts old sources of competitive advantage and takes full advantage of the new, key bases for competing (i.e., 5 pillars of strategy)
Is aggressively pursued by the great companies and leads to their sustained high performance (e.g., Dell, Charles Schwab, Wal-Mart)
Today’s Strategic Givens…Today’s Strategic Givens…
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1313
The Six Strategic Choices for CompetingThe Six Strategic Choices for Competing
Most Most AggressiveAggressive
Most PassiveMost Passive
11 22 33 44 55 66
INNOVATEINNOVATE SUBSTITUTESUBSTITUTE IMITATEIMITATE COMPLEMENTCOMPLEMENT COLLABORATECOLLABORATE WITHHOLDWITHHOLD
High expense
High risk Very high
return potential
Create new rules
Force competitors to change
Set the pace
Create or capture market within the industry
Leverage existing assets and channels
Force competitors to make changes
Provide flexibility
Lack innovation
Perform better than leader
Content with being a follower
Lower risk Unsure as
to what to do
Peaceful coexistence
Complement leader’s services and products
Backfill needs and requirements
Create partnerships
Provide value-added content
Share risk Requires
trust Requires
commitment
Preserve the right to compete
Failure to act
Unclear direction or need
Acquire necessary resources
Wait for clear signal
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1414
““Winning the competitive battles of today is not just Winning the competitive battles of today is not just
about competing better, or having strategies, or using about competing better, or having strategies, or using
continuous quality and performance improvement continuous quality and performance improvement
programs. It is about competing to be the best and, most programs. It is about competing to be the best and, most
importantly, competing differently.”importantly, competing differently.”
Michael Mische: Michael Mische: Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1515
Heading towardsHeading towards “Pervasive “Pervasive Computing”…Computing”…
Anytime/anyplace computing capability
Convergent integration of many computing methods, such as personal digital assistants (PDAs ), thin client-servers, interactive video telephones, wireless communication, and multimedia service boxes
Supported by extensive wireless and hardwired broadband networks and their applications
Enabled through the use of the Internet as the definitive channel of distribution for computing resources and software
An alternative to the traditional client-server, PC-based, and legacy computing solutions
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1616
Five Tenets of IT…Five Tenets of IT…
1. IT neutralizes many of the traditional sources of competitive advantage hr.; thus, it is a strategic weapon.
2. IT extends the enterprise in multiple dimensions and into multiple markets. This extension further differentiates the performance and strategic options of organizations, business units, and societies. As such, IT is a force multiplier for the organization.
3. IT has precipitated a permanent and systemic shift in the composition of the global economy, organizational dynamics, human interactions and competing. Thus, IT is a catalyst and an enabler of strategic change.
4. IT is a disintermediary that changes the historical models of customer contact, customer service, and product distribution. IT shifts the balance of power and is, therefore, a source of innovation.
5. IT accelerates change and can disrupt the continuity and “balance of power” in any industry or economy.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1717
The Strategic Importance of IT…The Strategic Importance of IT…
Strategic Themes
EI = Embedded Intelligence. IT has knowledge embedded in it to facilitate process excellence and agility.
PT = Process Transformation. IT enables new process designs and performance metrics.
MI = Management Information. IT provides information and indicators from which to make decisions.
TP = Transaction Processing. IT simply supports the processing of homogeneous transactions and volumes of data.
HighestValue
Financial Systems
Human Resource Systems
Knowledge Management
Customer Systems
Data Mining
E-Commerce
Logistics and Distribution
Office Automation
Auditing Systems
Enterprisewide Repositories
Product Development
EI/MIMI/TP
EI/PTPT/TP
Manufacturing
Lowest Value
StrategicStrategicValueValue
StrategicStrategicValueValue
OperationalOperationalValueValue
OperationalOperationalValueValue
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1818
IT, Strategy, and High Performance…IT, Strategy, and High Performance…
IT affects the competitive dynamics in five major ways:
1. High-performance organizations use IT to selectively integrate important operational aspects of their organizations.
2. High-performance organizations extend their enterprises through IT to suppliers, vendors, and customers.
3. High-performance organizations leverage IT to increase market share, enhance revenues, support knowledge management, and improve customer relationships, attractiveness, retention, and loyalty.
4. High-performance organizations use IT to accelerate and enhance the product design and development process.
5. High-performance organizations create extraordinary speed and agility through IT.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-1919
2.2. IT as an Enterprisewide ResourceIT as an Enterprisewide Resource
Fully integrate and leverage the capabilities of IT.
Institutionalize the strategies, priorities, and practices for delivering and deploying technology solutions.
View IT as an integral and integrated part of the organization’s social and business architecture requires application of the concepts of:1. LOGICAL CONSOLIDATION
2. PHYSICAL DISTRIBUTION
– These concepts provide a construct for managing IT as an enterprisewide asset on a consistent, flexible, and optimized basis.
– It allows for the implementation of enterprisewide policies, strategies, practices, and measurements for managing the IT function on a rationalized basis.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2020
IT & Strategy: An Issue of Alignment… IT & Strategy: An Issue of Alignment…
IT must be in alignment with the organization’s business strategy.
Three criteria constitute major determinants of alignment:
1. Existence of a clear economic value proposition for IT investments to the overall financial objectives of the organization.
2. Clear alignment of IT initiatives and projects to the strategic goals, purpose and objective of the organization.
3. A direct cause-and-effect relationship between IT and results.
Additionally, the return generated by IT must be measured using a number of different criteria, including the overall economic contribution of IT to the enterprise and the ability of IT to support enterprisewide integration and collaboration.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2121
Human CapitalHuman Capital
Partnering between IT personnel and users is critical to leveraging IT and improving IT return.
IT professional must posses technical capabilities as well as broad business skills and competencies, including understanding and knowledge of:– Business issues and emerging trends– Organizational/business processes– Financial goals– Economic value propositions– Collaborative practices– Competitors initiatives
Use of Strategic Solutions Integrator (SSI) – Solutions provider and service integrator for the
user/customer– Dual reporting relationship (IT and user/client)
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2222
Measuring ITMeasuring IT
Traditional measurements such as NPV, IRR, ROI, or Payback Period are not appropriate for measuring IT contribution; they are designed for:– Finite-type investments– Investments with a high degree of cost/return
predictability
To accurately assess and measure IT, use the concept of contribute value, in which IT:– Helps generate greater financial results– Contributes to the company’s growth– Guided by clear economic value proposition (EVP)
• Linked to revenue generation• Major operational and organizational efforts• Designed for competitive advantage
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2323
The Five Drivers of Global Growth…The Five Drivers of Global Growth…
1. The democratization of politically and economically repressed countries and societies, increasing the mobility of employees
2. The proliferation and availability of information technology, neutralizing the traditional sources of competitive advantage
3. The interconnectivity of economies and the emergence of borderless companies and markets, changing the basic equation of market and economic equilibrium
4. Increased consumer knowledge and choices, forcing companies to employ innovative practices and operations
5. Megamergers and alliances, creating new forms of organizations that have deep competencies, extensive financial resources, and the ability to redefine the rules of competing
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2424
Defining Globalization…Defining Globalization…
“The process of viewing and managing resources, products, customers, competencies and markets on a geographically indiscriminate and culturally inclusive basis, in a manner that best leverages and integrates
the organization’s capabilities, optimizes its worldwide identity and de-emphasizes geographical uniqueness and
national identity or origin.”
Mische The Basic Principle:
Being geographically indiscriminate.
The Basic Principle:Being geographically indiscriminate.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2525
Six Key Attributes of Globalization…Six Key Attributes of Globalization…
1. Competing on a geographically indiscriminate basis
2. Utilizing cultural inclusiveness for strategic advantage
3. Providing for the standardization of product and process using “cross-platform” designs
4. Adaptability of product and process to a wide variety of uses based on common platform designs, highly configurable designs, and standardized assessment measurements
5. Adopting a consistent view of the market in its totality with the ability to “move” and reallocate resources and assets in a manner that optimizes strategic value
6. Acknowledging the realization that an organization can exist in multiple states of “globalization” and standardization
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2626
Effective global strategies create synergies of purpose through the integration of:
Synergy of purpose is best attained by:1. Focusing on long-term business and social benefits2. Integrating social responsibility with business
strategies, policies, and governance.3. Implementing financial, cultural, educational, and
social commitments in the communities affected by their business.
4. Working to develop effective levels of social affiliation between the organization and the local communities
Synergies of PurposeSynergies of Purpose…Central Theme of …Central Theme of GlobalizationGlobalization
STRATEGIES
STRATEGIES
CONSISTENT
PURPOSES
CONSISTENT
PURPOSES VISION VISION
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2727
The Five Challenges of Global Enterprises…The Five Challenges of Global Enterprises…
Developing sensitivity to changes in political, social, and economic balance of power, and the ability to distinguish between ascending and descending economies.
Leverage technology investments to more effectively reach existing and emerging constituencies to communicate, transfer knowledge, share information, and leverage resources at any time and any place – extend the enterprise.
Driven by developments such as WTO, EMU, etc.; companies must now compete against, and with, global alternatives in mind.
Globalization and more liberal trade agreements open an arena for new competitors; Any company that has a global competitor working in a local or domestic market must consider itself a global company.
An effective use of business alliances and partnership will be critical to an organization’s ability to compete on a global scale and to become a global leader.
Democratization:Democratization:
IT:IT:
Interconnectivity:Interconnectivity:
Increased Competition:Increased Competition:
Megamergers & Intl. Alliances:
Megamergers & Intl. Alliances:
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2828
Impact of Globalization on Leaders and Brand Impact of Globalization on Leaders and Brand Management…Management…
GlobalizationGlobalization
Globalization drives new leadership traits and brand
management concepts
Globalization drives new leadership traits and brand
management concepts
Global perspective and awareness
Organizational and cultural integration
Cultural immersion
Logical consolidation and physical distribution of resources
Organize around core competencies and shared services
Global perspective and awareness
Organizational and cultural integration
Cultural immersion
Logical consolidation and physical distribution of resources
Organize around core competencies and shared services
Leadership Qualities
Leadership Qualities
Global leverage of brand identity at the enterprise level
Single image and perception of enterprise
Common platform, tailorable to unique markets
Brand is the most important asset
Global leverage of brand identity at the enterprise level
Single image and perception of enterprise
Common platform, tailorable to unique markets
Brand is the most important asset
BrandsBrands
View and manage resources on a geographically indiscriminate basis
Deemphasize national origin; emphasize brand identity
Global platform, local adaptation
View and manage resources on a geographically indiscriminate basis
Deemphasize national origin; emphasize brand identity
Global platform, local adaptation
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-2929
Strategic Implications of Globalization…Strategic Implications of Globalization…
1. Defining completely new rules of competing:
Negates traditional management and strategy formulation practices.
2. Creating increasingly competitive and intensive environments
3. Creating significant investment and marketing opportunities
4. Driving new forms of business and global scales through mega-mergers and acquisitions on an unprecedented scale:
Increases global alliances and partnerships
5. Destroying the physical and geographic boundaries of companies, industries and markets
6. Demanding new types of leaders and leadership styles
7. Defining new ethics and morals for competing and leading
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3030
Changes in the Workplace…Changes in the Workplace…
Changes in the current workforce are caused by five major factors, which drive further implications…
Lifestyle ChoicesLifestyle Choices Changes in Political Changes in Political SystemsSystems
New Technology New Technology & Innovations& Innovations
Changing World Changing World EconomiesEconomies
Changing DemographicsChanging Demographics
• Increasing globalization
• Higher level of worldwide economic & business integration
• Growing workforce & job mobility
• Increasingly diverse & multicultural societies and labor compositions
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3131
Defining Multiculturalism and Diversity…Defining Multiculturalism and Diversity…
There are definitional and operational differences between diversity and multiculturalism:
DIVERSITY: Thought of as gender, ethnic, and racial
proportionality and representation relative to a population.
Is statutorily defined.
DIVERSITY: Thought of as gender, ethnic, and racial
proportionality and representation relative to a population.
Is statutorily defined.
MULTICULURALISM: Encompasses more than ethnic, gender, and
racial diversity. Involves the concept of pluralism:
Includes diversity plus different life experiences, religion, age, income, customs, sexual preferences, physical and intellectual capabilities, and personal choices.
MULTICULURALISM: Encompasses more than ethnic, gender, and
racial diversity. Involves the concept of pluralism:
Includes diversity plus different life experiences, religion, age, income, customs, sexual preferences, physical and intellectual capabilities, and personal choices.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3232
Comparing Diversity and Comparing Diversity and Multiculturalism…Multiculturalism…
There are important differences between homogeneity, diversity, and multiculturalism as sources
of competitive advantage.
There are important differences between homogeneity, diversity, and multiculturalism as sources
of competitive advantage.
Low Source
Low Impact
Low Source
Low Impact
Medium Source
Medium Impact
Medium Source
Medium Impact
High Source
High Impact
High Source
High Impact
Strategic ImpactStrategic Impact Strategic ImpactStrategic Impact Strategic ImpactStrategic Impact
Uniform ethnic and social construct
Insular focus to the exclusion of others
Uniform ethnic and social construct
Insular focus to the exclusion of others
MulticulturalMulticultural
DiversityDiversity
Homogeneous
Homogeneous
Pluralistic
Inclusive and representative of society and institutions
Highly dynamic and energized
Socially mandated
Gender, race, age, and life experience focus
Inclusive of cultural heritage
Pluralistic
Inclusive and representative of society and institutions
Highly dynamic and energized
Socially mandated
Gender, race, age, and life experience focus
Inclusive of cultural heritage
Representative sample
Gender and race focused
Regulatory mandates
Improves sensitivity and understanding
Diverse ethnic and social construct
Representative sample
Gender and race focused
Regulatory mandates
Improves sensitivity and understanding
Diverse ethnic and social construct
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3333
Changing Workforce & Strategic RenewalChanging Workforce & Strategic Renewal
The Imperative Is Clear:
Depending on the given market, high performers incorporate in their cultures an appreciation and awareness of local:• Societal values• Social behaviors• Political situation• Religious convictions and customs• Cognitive and communication practices
Organizations that aggressively pursue diversity and multiculturalism are better
positioned for successfully competing in global environments and for continuous renewal.
Organizations that aggressively pursue diversity and multiculturalism are better
positioned for successfully competing in global environments and for continuous renewal.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3434
Cultural DexterityCultural Dexterity… Key to Successful Global … Key to Successful Global WorkforceWorkforce
To become successful as a global competitor and leader:
– Know the cultural rules and norms of each local market
– Appreciate and respect the nuances of local cultures
– Rely on signals, cues, and networks to establish informal and formal relationships
– Increase efforts and work harder, as driven by the local customs and demands
– Be patient while establishing presence in a new markets, especially if considerably different from the home environment
Although valid for all, these imperatives are especially critical for women and minority individuals
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3535
Technology and Workforce Impacts…Technology and Workforce Impacts…
IT has a significant impact on workforce and working processes:
– Enables worker and location interconnectivity• 4.5% of U.S. workers telecommuted in 1998…will be 8% in 2001
– Creates personal, intracorporate as well as intercorporate networks
– Provides for instantaneous communication and information transfer
– Obsoletes traditional ways and methods of management and leadership
Emerging workforces are:• More decentralized• Increasingly independent of traditional structures
and working processes• More knowledgeable• More empowered• Agile• “Closer” to clients and business partners despite
physical distances
Emerging workforces are:• More decentralized• Increasingly independent of traditional structures
and working processes• More knowledgeable• More empowered• Agile• “Closer” to clients and business partners despite
physical distances
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3636
Strategic Importance and Implications…Strategic Importance and Implications… Increasing income in all societal groups
translates into expanded and more sophisticated markets.
Creates new sources of revenue and growth.
Directly drives and impacts organizational renewal.
Increasing at a rate higher than for the general population…growing gap between top executive pay and worker salaries.
Frequent misalignment with organizational performance.
Strong correlation between education and earning potential and market power.
The percentage of population with college and advanced degrees is increasing.
INCOME & PURCHASING POWER:
INCOME & PURCHASING POWER:
High performers must attend to the communities to cultivate such markets and sources of talent.
High performers must attend to the communities to cultivate such markets and sources of talent.
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION:
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION:
Leaders must and should be compensated for making organizations great, expanding employment, and adding to the wealth of the stakeholders.
Leaders must and should be compensated for making organizations great, expanding employment, and adding to the wealth of the stakeholders.
EDUCATION AND EARNING POWER:
EDUCATION AND EARNING POWER:
High performers must attend to the education and learning needs of their workers, as these qualities/assets are directly linked to their strategic success.
High performers must attend to the education and learning needs of their workers, as these qualities/assets are directly linked to their strategic success.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3737
High-performance organizations define innovation with reference to creativity and the generation of new opportunities, products, and performance… thus, their (H-P’s) working definition of innovation is:
“The creation of new and different value generating products, services, processes, markets. and designs.”
Innovation is “multidimensional” and approached as a portfolio of simultaneous
activities…it includes new: Products/services Organizational designs Process designs Product development Market development Cultural advancement
Innovation is “multidimensional” and approached as a portfolio of simultaneous
activities…it includes new: Products/services Organizational designs Process designs Product development Market development Cultural advancement
Key ImplicationsKey Implications
Defining Innovation…Defining Innovation…
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3838
Major Advantages of Innovation…Major Advantages of Innovation…
High Performers Use Innovation to:
Gain competitive benefits
Gain financial benefits
Reinvent their organizations and environments
Attract and retain best talent
Stimulate learning and knowledge transfer
Provide personal latitude for growth and development
Establish high levels of multicultural and cross-functional
integration and achieve a high degree of collaboration
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-3939
Sources of InnovationSources of Innovation
There are three sources of innovation:1. Autonomous
External or internal
Incremental or discontinuous
Can occur in a number of forms and often comes from outside the company/industry (e.g. Post-it, Glide dental floss, Microsoft, Apple Computer…)
2. Systemic
Indigenous to an organization
Results from a planned and formally managed process with anticipated & monitored outcomes
Entail complex organizational interactions and alignments among a number of factors
3. Collaborative
Occurs at a group or interorganizational level with a clear goal to engage in innovation
Supported by common interest and/or the need to share resources, risk, talent, competencies…
Can lead to both incremental and discontinuous results
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4040
Energized and eclectic workforce
Institutional passions Creative and conducive
physical environment High learning and discovery
environment Active knowledge sharing High utility technology High ergonomics for technology Accessibility to technology Encourage experimentation
Emphasize learning and adaptation Use multifactor measurements Emphasize long-term results
Strong commitment to past practices
Inability to “unlearn” Lack of institutional priority Lack of proper incentives Inappropriate people Poor physical environment
Lack of appropriate technology Technology is unproven or too
difficult to use Technology can be too
threatening to establishment
Inappropriate or nonexistent measurements
Misplaced emphasis on measurements
Too much reliance on financial measurements
Culture
Technology
Measurements
Impediments Enablers
Impediments to InnovationImpediments to Innovation
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4141
Shift in emphasis from design to process efficiency
Product variations geared toward incremental innovation
Fluid Phase Transitional Phase Specific Phase
Highly turbulent
Very uncertain
Speculative outcomes Many competitors and
concepts—entrepreneurial nature
Rapid rates of change
Markets revolve around innovation
Switching costs are low Dominant design is
developed, but has not emerged
Emergence of a dominant design
Entrance of more established firms
Reduction in competing designs
Greater emphasis on formal organizational structures
Greater market specialization
Switching costs become high; sometimes prohibitive
Products become less differentiated
Reduction in the number of competitors
Branding becomes increasingly important
Strategic renewal must be emphasized to reinitiate the fluid phase to sustain competitive advantage
Dynamics of InnovationDynamics of Innovation
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4242
1. Innovation has been institutionalized as a way of life.
2. Leaderships foster innovation and build creative environments.
3. Hire, nurture, and covet innovative people.
4. Recognize and reward creativity.
5. Are not tied to preconceived outcomes, nor attached to a
predetermined answer—they let answers and outcomes evolve.
Five Common Characteristics of Successful Innovators:
1. More emphasis on probing and learning as opposed to analysis.
2. Successive approximation—each time striving to come closer to a
winning combination of product and market.
3. Strategically central to the needs and goals of the organization.
Three Essential Conditions for High-Performance Innovation Strategy:
Leading Innovation…Leading Innovation…
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4343
High Performers Recognize That Knowledge Is High Performers Recognize That Knowledge Is Dynamic…There Are:Dynamic…There Are:
Multiple Sources of Knowledge
A Number of Ways of Learning &
Changing Knowledge
Many Different Ways of
Interpreting Knowledge
Knowledge is constantly evolving and advancing KM process is extraordinarily complex & challenging
Knowledge is constantly evolving and advancing KM process is extraordinarily complex & challenging
… thus, organizations face three key challenges:… thus, organizations face three key challenges:
1. How to define the parameters for knowledge
2. How to identify relevant knowledge given various time horizons
3. How to best manage knowledge for competitive advantage
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4444
Defining Knowledge, Data, & Information…Defining Knowledge, Data, & Information…
Relevant intellectual capital that has strategic and operational value
Stimulates learning and action to enhance performance
Results in new behaviors, better decision making and further learning
Relevant intellectual capital that has strategic and operational value
Stimulates learning and action to enhance performance
Results in new behaviors, better decision making and further learning
Raw facts
“First” order facts
Lacks form and substance
Random points, loosely correlated
Raw facts
“First” order facts
Lacks form and substance
Random points, loosely correlated
DataData InformationInformation
KnowledgeKnowledgeKnowledgeKnowledge
InformationInformation
DataData
RelevancyFilters
RelevancyFilters
Strategic needs
Adaptability to needs
Appropriateness to operations
Importance to financial performance
Criticality to the advancement of the organization
Strategic needs
Adaptability to needs
Appropriateness to operations
Importance to financial performance
Criticality to the advancement of the organization
Data with “shape”
Data with context
Coherent assembly of data
Data readied for analysis
Data with “shape”
Data with context
Coherent assembly of data
Data readied for analysis
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4545
Knowledge Is Defined as:Knowledge Is Defined as:
“Any relevant intellectual capital, information, learning,
and personal perspective that stimulates or results in
deliberate action, modified behaviors, better decision
making, and further learning.”Mische: Strategic Renewal
“Any relevant intellectual capital, information, learning,
and personal perspective that stimulates or results in
deliberate action, modified behaviors, better decision
making, and further learning.”Mische: Strategic Renewal
Strategically…Strategically…
There must be a dimension of relevancy to knowledge.– A clear alignment with an organization’s strategies and operational
goals, and the developmental and functional needs of the individual
Data represents the “raw facts” —it is the first order of information.
Information represents the evolution of data into a logical and coherent presentation.
Knowledge is the final product of data and information it has dimensions of relevancy, context, and insightfulness.
Strategically…Strategically…
There must be a dimension of relevancy to knowledge.– A clear alignment with an organization’s strategies and operational
goals, and the developmental and functional needs of the individual
Data represents the “raw facts” —it is the first order of information.
Information represents the evolution of data into a logical and coherent presentation.
Knowledge is the final product of data and information it has dimensions of relevancy, context, and insightfulness.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4646
Elaborating on Knowledge Definition—Intellectual Elaborating on Knowledge Definition—Intellectual Capital from the High-Performance Perspective…Capital from the High-Performance Perspective…
1. Has a meaningful and appropriate connotation for the leader and the enterprise; that is, the knowledge must be relevant.
2. Fulfills an immediate or long-term need or emerging need of the leader and the organization.
3. Contributes intrinsic and/or explicit financial and performance value to the organization.
4. Contributes to the advancement and perpetuation of the organization and to its ability to adapt to new and changing environments and stimuli through continuous learning.
5. Enables individuals and their organizations to leverage operations and interactions with stakeholders (employees, shareholders, and customers) through learning, better communications, more enlightened perspectives and appropriate behaviors, actions, and decisions.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4747
Tacit versus Explicit Knowledge…Tacit versus Explicit Knowledge… Tacit knowledge is the information,
experiences...the “knowledge”...that each of us as individual human beings learn, develop, and accumulate over our lifetimes. It can be acquired through formal training, but is predominantly experientially oriented and learned through life’s experiences. Therefore, it almost always includes strong personal impressions, beliefs, biases, individual perspectives, and life’s lessons and values. This knowledge is unique and is
difficult to extract.
Tacit knowledge is the information, experiences...the “knowledge”...that each of us as individual human beings learn, develop, and accumulate over our lifetimes. It can be acquired through formal training, but is predominantly experientially oriented and learned through life’s experiences. Therefore, it almost always includes strong personal impressions, beliefs, biases, individual perspectives, and life’s lessons and values. This knowledge is unique and is
difficult to extract.
Explicit knowledge is the formal knowledge that is captured, codified, taught, and learned. This form of knowledge is the type that we learn in school, from others, or from company-sponsored training programs. This form of knowledge is usually codified in many different forms including books, curricula, training, software, multimedia, and open market product offerings from manufacturers and retailers. Consequently, explicit knowledge is usually readily accessible.
Explicit knowledge is the formal knowledge that is captured, codified, taught, and learned. This form of knowledge is the type that we learn in school, from others, or from company-sponsored training programs. This form of knowledge is usually codified in many different forms including books, curricula, training, software, multimedia, and open market product offerings from manufacturers and retailers. Consequently, explicit knowledge is usually readily accessible.
Key Conclusions…
Key Conclusions…
It is the capture and transfer of the unique and relevant tacit knowledge that leads to the greatest level of differentiation, and thus most contributes to sustaining high performance.
It is the capture and transfer of the unique and relevant tacit knowledge that leads to the greatest level of differentiation, and thus most contributes to sustaining high performance.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4848
The Knowledge Architecture…The Knowledge Architecture…
Knowledge Knowledge StrategyStrategy
DeterministiDeterministicc
EmergentEmergent
SynergisticSynergistic
ReservationReservation
Knowledge FiltersKnowledge Filters
StrategicStrategic
OperationalOperational
FinancialFinancial
ScenarioScenario
Knowledge Knowledge ManagementManagement
ProcessProcess
Discovery/ExtractionDiscovery/Extraction
Development/CodificationDevelopment/Codification
Dissemination/AccessibilityDissemination/Accessibility
Assimilation/EmbellishmentAssimilation/Embellishment
Application/LearningApplication/Learning
Renewal/RegenerationRenewal/Regeneration
Knowledge Management Knowledge Management Standards and Standards and
ProceduresProcedures
LeadershipLeadership
CommitmentCommitment
ManagementManagement
Learning/AdaptationLearning/Adaptation
Cause-and-effect relationshipCause-and-effect relationship
Distinct value propositionDistinct value proposition
Functional fitFunctional fit
Relevancy to immediate and long-term goalsRelevancy to immediate and long-term goals
Knowledge ArchitectureKnowledge Architecture
Strategic Strategic AlignmentAlignment
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-4949
Knowledge Strategy: Four Strategic Options Knowledge Strategy: Four Strategic Options
Deterministic Knowledge Deterministic Knowledge StrategiesStrategies Formed around highly specific and Formed around highly specific and
well- defined objectives/criteriawell- defined objectives/criteria Generally, a shorter time frame and Generally, a shorter time frame and
higher level of predictabilityhigher level of predictability e.g., data engineering, measuring e.g., data engineering, measuring
knowledge, assessing new knowledge knowledge, assessing new knowledge sources…sources…
May not leadMay not lead to a to a sustainable sustainable competitive advantagecompetitive advantage—they are short-—they are short-term focused and restricted by a term focused and restricted by a narrowly defined relevancy filtersnarrowly defined relevancy filters
Emergent Knowledge StrategiesEmergent Knowledge Strategies Rely on cultivation and development Rely on cultivation and development
techniques (e.g., experimentation, techniques (e.g., experimentation, discovery, learning…) discovery, learning…)
Longer-term orientedLonger-term oriented Far less predictabilityFar less predictability More evolutionaryMore evolutionary Developing a series of Developing a series of “loose “loose
relevancy filters”relevancy filters” that are variable that are variable and adaptable and adaptable knowledge can be knowledge can be used immediately or used immediately or “incubated”/deferred“incubated”/deferred
BetterBetter position an organization for position an organization for sustained sustained competitive advantagecompetitive advantage
Synergistic Knowledge StrategiesSynergistic Knowledge Strategies A A combination combination of the both of the both
deterministic and emergent deterministic and emergent frameworksframeworks
Multiple time framesMultiple time frames Involve specific filtering criteria as well Involve specific filtering criteria as well
as “incubators” of knowledgeas “incubators” of knowledge Focus on long-term as well as possible Focus on long-term as well as possible
and emerging strategic needsand emerging strategic needs Suitable for longer-term Suitable for longer-term
transformational strategiestransformational strategies BestBest positions an organization for positions an organization for
sustainable sustainable competitive advantagecompetitive advantage
Reservation Knowledge StrategiesReservation Knowledge Strategies ““Wait and see” Wait and see” postureposture Involves informal practices and/or Involves informal practices and/or
follower approachesfollower approaches Risk of signaling that knowledge is Risk of signaling that knowledge is
not an important or strategic initiative not an important or strategic initiative for an organizationfor an organization
Provide Provide little strategic advantagelittle strategic advantage with with respect to long-term objectivesrespect to long-term objectives
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5050
Collaboration: High-Performance Collaboration: High-Performance Characteristics…Characteristics…
1. Collaboration includes the appropriate mix of internal and external resources.
2. Collaborative work teams are formally and informally formed.
3. The work groups demonstrate: high levels of morale, the ability to constructively challenge one another, trust, esprit de corps, and a passion about their purpose.
4. The organization has a higher level of urgency and discovery about it.
5. The organization has more open and unfiltered communications among departments, functions, and personnel.
6. The organization develops exciting and innovative solutions that create competitive advantage and excitement.
7. Collaboration includes the appropriate mix of internal and
external resources.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5151
Learning & Knowledge: Inhibitors and Enablers to Knowledge and Learning & Knowledge: Inhibitors and Enablers to Knowledge and LearningLearning
KnowledgeKnowledge
Inhibitors
Environmental• Physical space is not inviting• Too many distractions• Restrictive/boring
Cultural• Culture has no passion for learning new
things• Culture fails to recognize that learning is
strategic• Low tolerance for failure
Human• Inappropriate staffing mix• Low learning capabilities• High compliance and “fitting-in”
Technological• Wrong technology• Unproven technology
Leadership• Inappropriate leadership• Disengaged leadership
Inhibitors
Environmental• Physical space is not inviting• Too many distractions• Restrictive/boring
Cultural• Culture has no passion for learning new
things• Culture fails to recognize that learning is
strategic• Low tolerance for failure
Human• Inappropriate staffing mix• Low learning capabilities• High compliance and “fitting-in”
Technological• Wrong technology• Unproven technology
Leadership• Inappropriate leadership• Disengaged leadership
Enablers
Environmental• Open, sunny, and pleasant• Public and “private spaces”• Interesting/inviting
Cultural• High energy and passion• Learning is “fun” and rewarding• Learning involves failure• High urgency
Human• High energy and intelligence• Extremely confident• Constructively confrontational and
individualistic Technological
• Accessible and effective• Intuitive and ergonomically inviting
Leadership• Protective, encouraging• Enabling
Enablers
Environmental• Open, sunny, and pleasant• Public and “private spaces”• Interesting/inviting
Cultural• High energy and passion• Learning is “fun” and rewarding• Learning involves failure• High urgency
Human• High energy and intelligence• Extremely confident• Constructively confrontational and
individualistic Technological
• Accessible and effective• Intuitive and ergonomically inviting
Leadership• Protective, encouraging• Enabling
Any relevant intellectual capital, information, learning, and perspective that stimulates or results in deliberate action, modified behaviors, better decision making, and further learning.
Any relevant intellectual capital, information, learning, and perspective that stimulates or results in deliberate action, modified behaviors, better decision making, and further learning.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5252
Knowledge: Summarized…Knowledge: Summarized…
1. High-performance organizations take
responsibility for creating and managing
knowledge as a source of competitive advantage
and differentiation.
2. Learning requires personal and organizational
dedication and unlearning.
3. Collaboration is the key to knowledge creation.
4. Leading knowledge demands an overall
architecture and a process.
5. Knowledge must be meaningful and relevant to
the organization.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5353
Traditional vs. Contemporary Traditional vs. Contemporary Leadership TraitsLeadership Traits
Compliance Authoritative Heroic/center of
attention Aloof/insulated Delegator/hierarchical Deep specialty skills in
traditional areas Extensive industry
knowledge Long-term company
tenure High control & command Domestic orientation Creates consensus Intimate knowledge of
the organization
Innovator Assimilator/learner Shares power & attention Approachable & accessible Conductor/network builder/
leverager Generalist with subject
matter expertise in several areas
Experience in several industries
Portfolio of diverse knowledge
Empowerment & sponsorship
Global perspective Creates coalitions &
sponsors collaboration Intimate knowledge of the
customer
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5454
The Five Essential Qualities of High-The Five Essential Qualities of High-Performance LeadershipPerformance Leadership
Character & Integrity Sense of Self
– Emotional Intelligence & Social Skills– Respect & Empathy for Others
Passion to Lead– Well-Defined Vision– Sense of Purpose & Mission for the
Organization Perspective & Insight
– Communication Skills Confidence, Courage, & Conviction
– Decision making & Judgment
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5555
Passion to Lead…Passion to Lead…
Demonstrates strong personal commitment to the organization on behalf of the leader
Induces trust, and credibility and presents a motivating force for employees
Accompanies a sense of purpose and urges organizational agility
Drives a leader’s vision and mission designed for the organization
Enables high-performance leaders to translate their visions into action-oriented strategies that present a distinct economic, societal, and competitive value proposition to involved stakeholders
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5656
Perspective & Insight…Perspective & Insight…
The ability to identify, analyze, interpret, and simplify
technically complex or politically charged issues and
solutions using a multidisciplined approach, leading to:
– Innovative perspectives & answers
– Unique approaches and solutions
– New standards & assessing criteria
Requires a great awareness and understanding of reality,
environmental dynamics, and faced situations as well as a
thorough knowledge of the organization
Demands the ability to function under uncertainty and to
make decisions facing high levels of ambiguity and
complexity
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5757
Leading for High-Performance Results: The Leading for High-Performance Results: The Ways in Which Leaders LeadWays in Which Leaders Lead
Conductor/Choreographer
“Stage managing & creative guidance”
Leaders are influencers, guides, catalysts, coaches, & teachers
Capability to best utilize & deploy resources
Appreciation for multiple competencies & diversified experiences
Coalition & Collaboration Builder
Recognize the benefits & opportunities of multiple talents, competencies, and perspectives
Appreciate and encourage innovation, operational excellence, and knowledge as a resource for competitive advantage
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5858
Leading for High-Performance Results: The Leading for High-Performance Results: The Ways In Which Leaders Lead, cont’d…Ways In Which Leaders Lead, cont’d… Change Agent/Catalyst
Recognize and encourage organizational agility
Effectively eliminate boundaries between competencies, functions, and structures
Achieve appropriate alignment of strategies, processes, structures, & resources
Establish business and social architecture—open & adaptable climate for better (high) performance
Champion of Operational Excellence
Accomplish effective utilization of knowledge
Continuously challenge their organization internally (set extraordinary performance levels, establish measurements & recognition systems) & establish a sense of urgency
Demand constant state of learning, discovery, & innovation
Create multicultural, diverse, & “mutlicapable” social architecture
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-5959
The Source of Leaders: Traditional vs. The Source of Leaders: Traditional vs. Temporary Approaches…Temporary Approaches…
Traditional Methods/Sources: Internal development Perpetuation of
organization-specific, historical qualities, behaviors, and experiences
Stress technical prowess Focus on short-term needs Limited linkage to long-term
strategic initiatives Emphasize limited skill set
with deep expertise in a single area
Traditional Methods/Sources: Internal development Perpetuation of
organization-specific, historical qualities, behaviors, and experiences
Stress technical prowess Focus on short-term needs Limited linkage to long-term
strategic initiatives Emphasize limited skill set
with deep expertise in a single area
Temporary Methods/Sources: Increasing number of leaders
developed outside an organization
More emphasis on professional diversification:
– Different jobs and positions– Geographical diversification– Multiple cultural experiences
and perspectives Broad referential base/portfolio
of problems, professional situations and experiences
Temporary Methods/Sources: Increasing number of leaders
developed outside an organization
More emphasis on professional diversification:
– Different jobs and positions– Geographical diversification– Multiple cultural experiences
and perspectives Broad referential base/portfolio
of problems, professional situations and experiences
Changing competitive dynamics, increasing interconnectivity, complexity and velocity of change are making traditional leadership training & development
obsolete and ineffective.
Changing competitive dynamics, increasing interconnectivity, complexity and velocity of change are making traditional leadership training & development
obsolete and ineffective.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6060
Operational Excellence Is Defined as…Operational Excellence Is Defined as…
“The design and performance of integrated systems
and processes that create superior strategic,
competitive, and operational value through speed,
flexibility, and cross-purpose adaptability.”
Mische: Strategic Renewal
“The design and performance of integrated systems
and processes that create superior strategic,
competitive, and operational value through speed,
flexibility, and cross-purpose adaptability.”
Mische: Strategic Renewal
SYSTEMSYSTEMSYSTEMSYSTEM PROCESSPROCESSPROCESSPROCESS
Key TermsKey Terms
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6161
OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE
Business Architecture for OEBusiness Architecture for OE
OVERALL BUSINESS ARCHITECTURE
KNOWLEDGEKNOWLEDGEINFORMATIO
N TECHNOLOGY
INFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY
HUMAN PERFORMANC
E
HUMAN PERFORMANC
ETECHNOLOGYTECHNOLOGY
OPERATIONS & DECISIONS
GREATER SPEED
GREATER SPEED
HIGHEST QUALITY
HIGHEST QUALITY
MIN. HUMAN INTERVENTION
MIN. HUMAN INTERVENTION
MINIMIZE TOTAL TRANSACTION
COSTS
MINIMIZE TOTAL TRANSACTION
COSTSMAXIMIZE
CREATED VALUE
MAXIMIZE CREATED VALUE
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6262
Benchmarking: An Overview—SummarizedBenchmarking: An Overview—Summarized
Benchmark is performed within the organization. Benchmark can be inter-divisional, intra-divisional or within a department.
Benchmark is performed among a select group of competitors within an industry.
Benchmarking is performed across industries using different companies.
Easy to perform
Inexpensive
Confined area of interest, limited insights
More complex process
Higher investment
Provides broader perspective and insight
Can be difficult to perform
Extremely complex, requires careful design and execution
Significant investment
Provides more comprehensive perspectives and greater insights
Very difficult and expensive to perform
Internal Intra-Industry (External) Cross Industry (External)
Defi
nit
ion
Ch
ara
cte
risti
cs
Step 1: Determine what to benchmark
Step 2 : Define benchmarking standards
Step 3 : Determine benchmarking strategy
Step 4 : Develop work and staffing plans
Step 5 : Perform the benchmark
Step 6 : Analyze results
Step 7 : Formulate insights
Approach to Benchmarking: 7 STEPS
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6363
Designing for Economic & Strategic ValueDesigning for Economic & Strategic Value
In the context of high performance, value is defined as:
The creation of tangible economic and operational benefits through: 1) Improved customer attraction and loyalty2) Increased revenues and profitability3) Reduced total transaction costs4) Increased competitive advantage.
M. Mische: Strategic Renewal
Economic Value Proposition must be developed:
– A representation or statement as to what a certain program, project, objective, or action is worth to the consumer, organization, and or employee.
M. Mische: Strategic Renewal
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6464
Designing for Value, cont’dDesigning for Value, cont’d
The design of the process must reflect the following characteristics:
1. Clear alignment and congruency with organizational strategic and operational objectives
2. Distinct cause-and-effect relationship between expected, needed, and produced outcomes
3. Optimization of competencies, resources, and organizational capabilities, especially IT, human resources, and knowledge
4. Creation of synergies of purpose and leveraging of human and IT performance
5. Appropriate integration of technology
6. Outcome-driven
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6565
Process Designs and Operations: OverviewProcess Designs and Operations: Overview
Singular Exist for a highly specialized purpose Relatively independent of other processes and
organizational competencies Little end-customer interactions Relatively low value-generating activities Can be performed by internal resources, external
resources, or outsourcing partners Examples: product testing for legal or regulatory
requirements, financial auditing, etc
Modular Represent a major subsystem, subassembly, or significant percentage of an overall process architecture or system
Typically integrated into an overall process architecture
Complete subsystems that are ready to be “plugged into” or readily adapted to an overall larger product or operation
The result of internal competencies and collaborative agreements with outsourcing partners, subject matter, or specialty providers
High customer and competitive value to the organization
Examples: computer industry (Intel chips, MS software), etc.
Vertically Integrated
Provide essentially for the entire process Related human and physical and natural
resources are owned and operated by the company executing the process
Examples: industrial giants such as GM
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6666
Designing for Flawless ExecutionDesigning for Flawless Execution
Achieves maximum efficiency in process execution through:
Simplicity of Design
Simplicity of Design
Accountability
Accountability
Design of Organizational Structure
Design of Organizational Structure
Effective Measuremen
ts
Effective Measuremen
ts
Design Flexibility
Design Flexibility
Meaningful Performance Targets
Meaningful Performance Targets
Flawless Execution &
Desired Outcomes
Flawless Execution &
Desired Outcomes
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6767
Designing for SustainabilityDesigning for Sustainability
Characteristics of sustainable designs:
1. Provide for the transfer of knowledge• No abundance of documentation and information• Reflect the unique tacit knowledge
2. Have embedded heuristics• Interrogate the process • Measure performance • Influence the behavioral aspects of the process • Communicate effectiveness
3. Ensure continuous improvement and innovation
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6868
OE and Organizational AgilityOE and Organizational Agility
Organizational agility is defined as:
Organizational agility is the essential enabler of operational excellence.
“The capacity to quickly and efficiently create, redeploy, reconstitute, and reallocate the resources of the
organization in a manner that optimizes their use in an environment or allows them to create new environments.”
Mische: Strategic Renewal
“The capacity to quickly and efficiently create, redeploy, reconstitute, and reallocate the resources of the
organization in a manner that optimizes their use in an environment or allows them to create new environments.”
Mische: Strategic Renewal
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-6969
Creating Organizational AgilityCreating Organizational Agility
Involves processes and structures for:1. Redeployment and reallocation of resources
Introduction of new technologies and processes Addition of new personnel Retraining of existing personnel
2. Selective integration of organizations and processes Organizing resources and actions around core
processes and competencies Selective integration of organizations through internal
consolidation of common infrastructure functions Selective use of key suppliers, alliance partners, and
outsourcing specialists Development of Shared Service Organization (SSO) for
extraordinary leverage of resources and common services
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-7070
Defining Business Architecture…Defining Business Architecture…
“… (architecture) a comprehensive plan for the realization of high performance through the integration of the organization’s resources and competencies in a manner that optimizes and leverages their use, deployment, and interactions.”
Mische: Strategic Renewal
– The architecture of a business demonstrates how the major components of the organization interact with one another to create synergy of purpose and high performance.
– A well-designed business architecture ensures that business initiatives are convergent with the organization’s strategies and value targets and that operational, organizational, and knowledge integration is achieved.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-7171
Designing High-Performance Designing High-Performance Architecture…Architecture…
Several “design rules” must be followed:
To be a high performer, an organization must have a strong life force and its business architecture must capture this “drive for survival.”
The value proposition must be directly aligned with, and supportive of, the overall vision and strategic intentions of the organization.
It must provide for the convergent integration of strategy, knowledge, process, technology, and human performance.
It must embody a set of core behaviors and values that transcend time and situations and advance them to new levels.
It must have operational excellence and the flawless execution of essential processes as objectives.
It must provide for the creation, adaptation, dissemination, and management of knowledge.
It must demonstrate a calibration to the existing competencies or an acknowledgment that new competencies are required.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-7272
Architecting for High Performance…Architecting for High Performance…
Architecture allows high-performance companies to:
– Be dynamic and adaptable to changing needs and environments
– Present the value proposition to their stakeholders
Framework for high-performance architecture consists of five progressive as well as iterative sets of activities:
1. Business Baselining and Assessment
2. Visioning and Strategy Setting
3. Organizational Integration
4. Operational Integration
5. Sustainability and Regeneration
– The process involves continuous learning, experimentation, adaptation, and calibration of the designs to the environment.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-7373
Segment 3: Organizational IntegrationSegment 3: Organizational Integration
Involves assessing and designing new organizational practices and internal competencies
Performed simultaneously with the design of new business processes and concepts related to operational excellence
Creates the blueprint and plan for the“to-be” state Activities involve:
– Designing and testing innovative designs for processes– Developing and testing organizational structures that
support identified and envisioned strategies, value propositions, and objectives
– All five dimensions of the architecting process: STRATEGIESSTRATEGIES
PROCESSESPROCESSES
MANAGEMENT PRACTICES
MANAGEMENT PRACTICES
TECHNOLOGIES
TECHNOLOGIES
HUMAN PERFORMANC
E
HUMAN PERFORMANC
E
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-7474
Segment 5: Sustainability and Segment 5: Sustainability and Regeneration…Regeneration…
High performers are in a constant state of change and experimentation.
Focuses on a continuous process designed to help keep the organization functioning as high performer.
Involves the replication of core values, knowledge, and concepts related to optimizing the genetic code for high performance.
Strategic RenewalStrategic Renewal
Competing at the Speed of Life©2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. 1-1-7575
Sustainability and Regeneration: Sustainability and Regeneration: Techniques and Outcomes…Techniques and Outcomes…
Some of the techniques include:
– Developing a series of organizational seminars related to strategic renewal.
– Having continuous renewal as a performance standard for all business units and those responsible for their performance.
– Conducting a series of executive briefings specifically dedicated to the results and processes used to achieve quantum gains for the projects just completed.
– Having the organization establish a “High-Performance University” where selected executives, mangers, and employees attend to learn more about the process and methods involved.
– Providing a compensation incentive program for high-performance employees who constantly challenge the standards and set new ones.
The key outcome is the perpetuation of high-performance culture, dedicated to competitive advantage and market dominance.