status of u.s. human rights policy, 1987 : hearing before the subcommittee on human rights and...

1
118 would critcize Indonesia's recent crackdown on opponents. In an interview in Tokyo shortly after leaving Indonesia, President Reagan responded to a reporter's question in a similar manner: "I will call attention to the fact ... that with all of the criticisms that are being made (of Indonesia's human rights record)... the progress that has been made by Indonesia, the fact that they have become totally self-sufficient in providing for for their 165 million people." This remark is not only a disservice to human rights, but has ironic significance in that the Reagan Administration has argued in other contexts, such as Helsinki review meetings, that economic rights cannot and should not be attained at the expense of civil and political rights. El Salvador: In spite of continuing serious abuses in El Salvador, the Reagan Administration maintained its past policy of denying or minimizing government violations, exculpating those responsible for abuses, and attacking human rights critics. Perhaps the most unfortunate feature of the Reagan Administration's policy in El Salvador is its consistent failure to acknowledge abuses against civilians by the military in the course of military operations. In the past year the State Department's several certification reports to Congress and its response to individual letters from Members of Congress were flawed by characterizations of victims as "guerrilla supporters," which tends to justify attacks against them. As you know, the applicable provisions of the Geneva Conventions extend protection to all noncombatants, regardless of their perceived sympathies. One example of this approach is Ambassador Edwin Corr's response to a letter from several Members of Congress about the Army's Generated on 2015-08-06 23:26 GMT / http://hdl.handle.net/2027/pst.000013049768 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www.hathitrust.org/access_use#pd-google

Upload: publicintel

Post on 02-Sep-2015

11 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

"In the past year the State Department's several certification reports to Congress and its response to individual letters from members of Congress were flawed by characterizations of victims as 'guerrilla supporters,' which tends to justify attacks against them."

TRANSCRIPT

  • 118

    would critcize Indonesia's recent crackdown on opponents. In aninterview in Tokyo shortly after leaving Indonesia, President

    Reagan responded to a reporter's question in a similar manner:"I will call attention to the fact ... that with all of thecriticisms that are being made (of Indonesia's human rights

    record)... the progress that has been made by Indonesia, the factthat they have become totally self-sufficient in providing forfor their 165 million people." This remark is not only adisservice to human rights, but has ironic significance in thatthe Reagan Administration has argued in other contexts, such as

    Helsinki review meetings, that economic rights cannot and should

    not be attained at the expense of civil and political rights.El Salvador: In spite of continuing serious abuses in El

    Salvador, the Reagan Administration maintained its past policy ofdenying or minimizing government violations, exculpating thoseresponsible for abuses, and attacking human rights critics.Perhaps the most unfortunate feature of the ReaganAdministration's policy in El Salvador is its consistent failureto acknowledge abuses against civilians by the military in thecourse of military operations. In the past year the StateDepartment's several certification reports to Congress and itsresponse to individual letters from Members of Congress wereflawed by characterizations of victims as "guerrilla supporters,"which tends to justify attacks against them. As you know, theapplicable provisions of the Geneva Conventions extend protection

    to all noncombatants, regardless of their perceived sympathies.One example of this approach is Ambassador Edwin Corr's responseto a letter from several Members of Congress about the Army's

    Gen

    erat

    ed o

    n 20

    15-0

    8-06

    23:

    26 G

    MT

    / h

    ttp:

    //hdl

    .han

    dle.

    net/

    2027

    /pst

    .000

    0130

    4976

    8Pu

    blic

    Dom

    ain,

    Goo

    gle-

    digi

    tized

    / h

    ttp:

    //ww

    w.h

    athi

    trus

    t.or

    g/ac

    cess

    _use

    #pd

    -goo

    gle