STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 1COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-1 ********************* 818 River Rd1.-1-1 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 12,500Horner Edward J Sull West Csd 484802-89 6,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 12,500676 River Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 61.00 12,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 12,500Callicoon, NY 12723 ACRES 0.11 AMB16 DEL AMB 12,500 TO EAST-0292370 NRTH-0654270 FD023 Callicoon fire 12,500 TO DEED BOOK 2105 PG-375 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,084******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-2 ********************* 822 River Rd1.-1-2 312 Vac w/imprv - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 17,300Horner Edward J Sull West Csd 484802-89 17,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 17,300676 River Rd FRNT 250.00 DPTH 131.00 17,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,300Callicoon, NY 12723 ACRES 0.65 AMB16 DEL AMB 17,300 TO EAST-0292420 NRTH-0654320 FD023 Callicoon fire 17,300 TO DEED BOOK 2105 PG-371 FULL MARKET VALUE 26,412******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-4 ********************* 832 River Rd1.-1-4 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 6,200Erts John Sull West Csd 484802-89 6,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 6,200PO Box 422 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 48.00 6,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,200Neversink, NY 12765 ACRES 0.14 AMB16 DEL AMB 6,200 TO EAST-0292550 NRTH-0654510 FD023 Callicoon fire 6,200 TO DEED BOOK 2017 PG-364 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,466******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-5 ********************* 836 River Rd1.-1-5 270 Mfg housing - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 11,200Rodzinak Robert Sull West Csd 484802-89 6,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 11,200Davis Michael A FRNT 50.00 DPTH 96.67 11,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 11,20015 Henry St ACRES 0.17 AMB16 DEL AMB 11,200 TOWilkes Barre, PA 18702 EAST-0292580 NRTH-0654550 FD023 Callicoon fire 11,200 TO DEED BOOK 1495 PG-697 FULL MARKET VALUE 17,099******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-6 ********************* 840 River Rd1.-1-6 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,908Luzier James Sull West Csd 484802-89 24,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,908Luzier Patricia FRNT 100.00 DPTH 92.33 56,908 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,90819 Auburn Ct ACRES 0.33 AMB16 DEL AMB 56,908 TOMiddletown, NJ 07701 EAST-0292620 NRTH-0654610 FD023 Callicoon fire 56,908 TO DEED BOOK 3463 PG-298 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,882************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 2COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-8 ********************* 850 River Rd1.-1-8 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VET WAR CT 41121 13,083 13,083 0Ferber Melanie L Sull West Csd 484802-89 18,000 STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010Fisher Melissa FRNT 50.00 DPTH 90.00 87,220 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 74,137Ferber, Adam & Fisher, Melanie ACRES 0.60 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 74,137850 River Rd EAST-0292678 NRTH-0654706 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,210PO Box 139 DEED BOOK 2189 PG-226 AMB16 DEL AMB 87,220 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 FULL MARKET VALUE 133,160 FD023 Callicoon fire 87,220 TO******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-9 ********************* 854 River Rd1.-1-9 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,900Sutherland Jon K Sull West Csd 484802-89 8,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,900Sutherland William F FRNT 50.00 DPTH 94.00 50,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,900108 Breezy Hill Rd ACRES 0.19 AMB16 DEL AMB 50,900 TOParksville, NY 12768 EAST-0292780 NRTH-0654770 FD023 Callicoon fire 50,900 TO DEED BOOK 2019 PG-326 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,710******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-10 ******************** 856 River Rd1.-1-10 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Bachkosky Michael G Sull West Csd 484802-89 14,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,300PO Box 92 ACRES 0.41 56,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,300Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0292820 NRTH-0654850 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,200 DEED BOOK 2216 PG-315 AMB16 DEL AMB 56,300 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 85,954 FD023 Callicoon fire 56,300 TO******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-13 ******************** 860 River Rd1.-1-13 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,000Riemer Charles Sull West Csd 484802-89 18,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,000Riemer Susan FRNT 150.00 DPTH 1105.00 50,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,00022 Benedict Dr ACRES 0.68 AMB16 DEL AMB 50,000 TOLake Hopatcong, NJ 07849 EAST-0292920 NRTH-0654980 FD023 Callicoon fire 50,000 TO DEED BOOK 1683 PG-614 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,336******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-14 ******************** 864 River Rd1.-1-14 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 66,100Lang Claire Sull West Csd 484802-89 10,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 66,100594 Willow Ave FRNT 50.00 DPTH 126.00 66,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,100Saddle Brook, NJ 07663 ACRES 0.23 AMB16 DEL AMB 66,100 TO EAST-0292960 NRTH-0655020 FD023 Callicoon fire 66,100 TO DEED BOOK 2276 PG-544 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,916************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 3COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-15 ******************** 868 River Rd1.-1-15 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,169Brown Stephen F Sull West Csd 484802-89 18,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,169Brown Mary T FRNT 100.00 DPTH 130.00 116,169 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,16934 Hopping Ave ACRES 0.30 AMB16 DEL AMB 116,169 TOStaten Island, NY 10307 EAST-0293006 NRTH-0655063 FD023 Callicoon fire 116,169 TO DEED BOOK 2388 PG-552 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,357******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-17 ******************** 872 River Rd1.-1-17 270 Mfg housing - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,600Knill James R Sull West Csd 484802-89 11,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,600Knill Heidi W FRNT 43.24 DPTH 264.19 19,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,6004160 Eby Dr ACRES 0.26 AMB16 DEL AMB 19,600 TODumfries, VA 22026 EAST-0293050 NRTH-0655140 FD023 Callicoon fire 19,600 TO DEED BOOK 938 PG-00278 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,924******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-19 ******************** 876 River Rd1.-1-19 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010Startsev Anatoly I Sull West Csd 484802-89 16,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,400Startseva Raisa D FRNT 143.75 DPTH 282.00 125,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,400876 River Rd ACRES 0.83 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,390Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0293128 NRTH-0655230 AMB16 DEL AMB 125,400 TO DEED BOOK 2311 PG-90 FD023 Callicoon fire 125,400 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 191,450******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-20 ******************** River Rd1.-1-20 312 Vac w/imprv - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,800Foley Joyce E Sull West Csd 484802-89 16,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,800131 Manhattan Ave FRNT 100.00 DPTH 150.00 16,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,800Jersey City, NJ 07307 ACRES 0.56 AMB16 DEL AMB 16,800 TO EAST-0293205 NRTH-0655300 FD023 Callicoon fire 16,800 TO DEED BOOK 1124 PG-00096 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,649******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-21 ******************** 882 River Rd1.-1-21 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,600Alukonis Vincent Sull West Csd 484802-89 23,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,600882 River Rd ACRES 1.70 120,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,600Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0293400 NRTH-0655430 AMB16 DEL AMB 120,600 TO DEED BOOK 638 PG-00293 FD023 Callicoon fire 120,600 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 184,122************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 4COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 1.-1-22 ******************** 885 River Rd1.-1-22 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010Sandin Florence J Sull West Csd 484802-89 26,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,000Sandin Harold G ACRES 1.78 126,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,000885 River Rd EAST-0293702 NRTH-0655598 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,990Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 919 PG-00121 AMB16 DEL AMB 126,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 192,366 FD023 Callicoon fire 126,000 TO************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 5COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware M A P S E C T I O N - 001 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 S U B - S E C T I O N - RPS150/V04/L015 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50 CURRENT DATE 6/18/2014

*** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y ***

TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLECODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE

AMB16 DEL AMB 16 TOTAL 939,197 939,197FD023 Callicoon fire 16 TOTAL 939,197 939,197

*** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y ***

TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL STAR STARCODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE AMOUNT TAXABLE

484802 Sull West Csd 16 241,900 939,197 939,197 149,130 790,067

S U B - T O T A L 16 241,900 939,197 939,197 149,130 790,067

484889 West Sull Lib 16 241,900 939,197 939,197 149,130 790,067

T O T A L 32 483,800 1878,394 1878,394 298,260 1580,134

*** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y ***

NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

*** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y ***

TOTALCODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN SCHOOL

41121 VET WAR CT 1 13,083 13,08341834 STAR EN 3 129,03041854 STAR B 1 20,100 T O T A L 5 13,083 13,083 149,130

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 6COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware M A P S E C T I O N - 001 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 S U B - S E C T I O N - RPS150/V04/L015 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50 CURRENT DATE 6/18/2014

*** G R A N D T O T A L S ***

ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE STARSEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL COUNTY TOWN SCHOOL TAXABLE

1 TAXABLE 16 241,900 939,197 926,114 926,114 939,197 790,067

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 7COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-2 ********************* 909 River Rd2.-1-2 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,500Munzel John Jr Sull West Csd 484802-89 25,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,500Munzel Barbara ACRES 2.25 67,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 67,500839 Elice Pl EAST-0293930 NRTH-0655340 AMB16 DEL AMB 67,500 TOBaldwin, NY 11510 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-541 FD023 Callicoon fire 67,500 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 103,053******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-3 ********************* 902 River Rd2.-1-3 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,000Murray Hugh A Sull West Csd 484802-89 19,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,000PO Box 153 FRNT 79.50 DPTH 83.00 77,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 77,000Callicoon, NY 12723 ACRES 0.80 AMB16 DEL AMB 77,000 TO EAST-0293780 NRTH-0655140 FD023 Callicoon fire 77,000 TO DEED BOOK 1689 PG-87 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,557******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-4 ********************* 894 River Rd2.-1-4 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,400Loreng Robert J Sull West Csd 484802-89 20,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,400Loreng Pauline ACRES 1.00 28,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,40071-12 72nd St EAST-0293660 NRTH-0655090 AMB16 DEL AMB 28,400 TOGlendale, NY 11385 DEED BOOK 1646 PG-370 FD023 Callicoon fire 28,400 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 43,359******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-5 ********************* River Rd2.-1-5 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,500Delaware Rod & Gun Club Inc. Sull West Csd 484802-89 69,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,500Attn: Robert Loreng ACRES 121.00 69,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,50071-12 72nd St EAST-0294850 NRTH-0654590 AMB16 DEL AMB 69,500 TOGlendale, NY 11385 DEED BOOK 541 PG-00498 FD023 Callicoon fire 69,500 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 106,107******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.1 ******************* State Route 97 06/20142.-1-6.1 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,000van Swol Eric Sull West Csd 484802-89 1,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,00071 Viaduct Rd FRNT 170.00 DPTH 200.00 1,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,000Long Eddy, NY 12760 ACRES 0.26 AMB16 DEL AMB 1,000 TO EAST-0298238 NRTH-0653019 FD023 Callicoon fire 1,000 TOPRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2014 DEED BOOK 2014 PG-1682VanSwol Noel W FULL MARKET VALUE 1,527************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 8COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.2 ******************* 9784 State Route 97 01/20142.-1-6.2 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Kelting Susan M Sull West Csd 484802-89 24,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 75,000PO Box 113 ACRES 2.22 75,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 75,000Hankins, NY 12741 EAST-0298600 NRTH-0655380 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,900 DEED BOOK 2013 PG-1410 AMB16 DEL AMB 75,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 114,504 FD023 Callicoon fire 75,000 TO******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.3 ******************* 9783 State Route 972.-1-6.3 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 152,000Demarest Carolyn Sull West Csd 484802-89 50,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 152,00079 Pierrepont St ACRES 28.00 152,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 152,000Brooklyn, NY 11201 EAST-0298120 NRTH-0655710 AMB16 DEL AMB 152,000 TO DEED BOOK 747 PG-01012 FD023 Callicoon fire 152,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 232,061******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.4 ******************* 9761 State Route 972.-1-6.4 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 210,100Curto Philip A Sull West Csd 484802-89 68,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 210,100Martinez Rita ACRES 90.69 210,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 210,10034-24 200th St EAST-0297310 NRTH-0654300 AMB16 DEL AMB 210,100 TOBayside, NY 11361 DEED BOOK 2013 PG-283 FD023 Callicoon fire 210,100 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 320,763******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.5 ******************* 22 Cross Rd 96 PCT OF VALUE USED FOR EXEMPTION PURPOSES2.-1-6.5 210 1 Family Res VET COM CT 41131 27,360 27,360 0Elflein Doris Sull West Csd 484802-89 24,000 STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010Elflein George ACRES 5.89 114,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 86,64022 Cross Rd EAST-0298611 NRTH-0653212 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 86,640Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 1790 PG-403 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,990 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,046 AMB16 DEL AMB 114,000 TO FD023 Callicoon fire 114,000 TO******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.7 ******************* 9729 State Route 972.-1-6.7 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Hahn Franklin P Sull West Csd 484802-89 24,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,800Hahn Carla ACRES 2.51 85,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,8009729 State Route 97 EAST-0298056 NRTH-0653758 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,700PO Box 73 DEED BOOK 1573 PG-626 AMB16 DEL AMB 85,800 TOCallicoon, NY 12723-2028 FULL MARKET VALUE 130,992 FD023 Callicoon fire 85,800 TO************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 9COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.8 ******************* 9739 State Route 972.-1-6.8 642 Health bldg COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,000Salzberg Paul D Sull West Csd 484802-89 24,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,000Salzberg Greta A ACRES 2.19 BANK 100075 104,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,000PO Box 247 EAST-0298053 NRTH-0654013 AMB16 DEL AMB 104,000 TOLake Huntington, NY 12752 DEED BOOK 2138 PG-600 FD023 Callicoon fire 104,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 158,779******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-6.9 ******************* 9748 State Route 972.-1-6.9 241 Rural res&ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,800Palumbo Michael C Sull West Csd 484802-89 55,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,800Palumbo Rita C ACRES 37.25 164,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 164,80068 Wyckoff Ave EAST-0298758 NRTH-0654673 AMB16 DEL AMB 164,800 TOWyckoff, NJ 07481 DEED BOOK 2013 PG-5395 FD023 Callicoon fire 164,800 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 251,603MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-8 ********************* 6 Tower Rd2.-1-8 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Mills Douglas Sull West Csd 484802-89 21,900 HOME IMP 44211 6,900 6,900 06 Tower Rd ACRES 1.02 145,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 139,000Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0298130 NRTH-0653140 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 139,000 DEED BOOK 1927 PG-57 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 125,800 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,748 AMB16 DEL AMB 139,000 TO 6,900 EX FD023 Callicoon fire 139,000 TO 6,900 EX******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-9.1 ******************* Baer Rd2.-1-9.1 322 Rural vac>10 AGRI DIST 41720 70,443 70,443 70,443Baer Naida M Sull West Csd 484802-89 140,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 70,057PO Box 614 ACRES 208.00 140,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 70,057Oxford, NY 13830 EAST-0300260 NRTH-0655760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,057 DEED BOOK 2011 PG-5835 AMB16 DEL AMB 140,500 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 214,504 FD023 Callicoon fire 140,500 TOUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 OTS13 Omitted School 2013 74.00 MT******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-9.2 ******************* 90 Baer Rd2.-1-9.2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,400Denver Molly Kathryn Sull West Csd 484802-89 23,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,400Smith Guy Brewster ACRES 5.05 BANKN140687 100,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 100,40090 Baer Rd EAST-0300260 NRTH-0655760 AMB16 DEL AMB 100,400 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2011 PG-4122 FD023 Callicoon fire 100,400 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 153,282MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2016************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 10COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-11.2 ****************** 77 Baer Rd2.-1-11.2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,100Rose Elizabeth Sull West Csd 484802-89 15,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,100Castellow Donald FRNT 81.66 DPTH 234.18 50,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,100315 E 68th St Apt 8C ACRES 0.63 BANKN140687 AMB16 DEL AMB 50,100 TONew York, NY 10065 EAST-0299090 NRTH-0654380 FD023 Callicoon fire 50,100 TO DEED BOOK 2011 PG-3729 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,489******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-12.1 ****************** 58 Baer Rd 78 PCT OF VALUE USED FOR EXEMPTION PURPOSES2.-1-12.1 241 Rural res&ag VET COM CT 41131 24,161 24,161 0Busch Walter J Sull West Csd 484802-89 56,000 AGRI DIST 41720 22,866 22,866 22,866Busch Vicki L ACRES 38.05 123,900 STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,01058 Baer Rd EAST-0299656 NRTH-0653332 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 76,873PO Box 32 DEED BOOK 1341 PG-297 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 76,873Callicoon, NY 12723 FULL MARKET VALUE 189,160 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,024 AMB16 DEL AMB 123,900 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FD023 Callicoon fire 123,900 TOUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 OTS13 Omitted School 2013 14.57 MT******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-12.2 ****************** Cross Rd2.-1-12.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 18,000Bush Imelda M Sull West Csd 484802-89 18,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 18,000605 John Ross Ct ACRES 6.15 18,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 18,000Woodstock, GA 30188 EAST-0298976 NRTH-0653281 AMB16 DEL AMB 18,000 TO DEED BOOK 1341 PG-301 FD023 Callicoon fire 18,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 27,481******************************************************************************************************* 2.-1-12.3 ****************** Old Hankins Rd2.-1-12.3 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,000Andrea Juanita M Sull West Csd 484802-89 16,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,000161 Austin Drive Apt 3 ACRES 6.00 16,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,000Burlington, VT 05401 EAST-0300572 NRTH-0652830 AMB16 DEL AMB 16,000 TO DEED BOOK 1341 PG-304 FD023 Callicoon fire 16,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 24,427************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 11COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware M A P S E C T I O N - 002 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 S U B - S E C T I O N - RPS150/V04/L015 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50 CURRENT DATE 6/18/2014

*** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y ***

TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLECODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE

OTS13 Omitted School 2 MOVTAX 88.57 88.57AMB16 DEL AMB 19 TOTAL 1743,900 6,900 1737,000FD023 Callicoon fire 19 TOTAL 1743,900 6,900 1737,000

*** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y ***

TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL STAR STARCODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE AMOUNT TAXABLE

484802 Sull West Csd 19 696,900 1743,900 93,309 1650,591 146,320 1504,271

S U B - T O T A L 19 696,900 1743,900 93,309 1650,591 146,320 1504,271

484889 West Sull Lib 19 696,900 1743,900 93,309 1650,591 146,320 1504,271

T O T A L 38 1393,800 3487,800 186,618 3301,182 292,640 3008,542

*** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y ***

NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

*** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y ***

TOTALCODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN SCHOOL

41131 VET COM CT 2 51,521 51,52141720 AGRI DIST 2 93,309 93,309 93,30941834 STAR EN 2 86,02041854 STAR B 3 60,30044211 HOME IMP 1 6,900 6,900 T O T A L 10 151,730 151,730 239,629

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 12COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware M A P S E C T I O N - 002 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 S U B - S E C T I O N - RPS150/V04/L015 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50 CURRENT DATE 6/18/2014

*** G R A N D T O T A L S ***

ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE STARSEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL COUNTY TOWN SCHOOL TAXABLE

1 TAXABLE 19 696,900 1743,900 1592,170 1592,170 1650,591 1504,271

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 13COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-1 ********************* 291 Lahm Rd3.-1-1 280 Res Multiple COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 187,325Hough James E Sull West Csd 484802-89 86,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 187,325291 Lahm Rd ACRES 99.03 187,325 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 187,325Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0302280 NRTH-0655840 AMB16 DEL AMB 187,325 TO DEED BOOK 1957 PG-312 FD023 Callicoon fire 187,325 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 285,992******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-2 ********************* T R 223.-1-2 105 Vac farmland AGRI DIST 41720 68,834 68,834 68,834Graby William Sull West Csd 484802-89 82,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 13,566Graby Marie C ACRES 52.00 82,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 13,56629 Ray Graby Rd EAST-0303770 NRTH-0655480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 13,566Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 929 PG-00024 AMB16 DEL AMB 82,400 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 125,802 FD023 Callicoon fire 82,400 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT OTS13 Omitted School 2013 27.28 MTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.1 ******************* Kautz Rd3.-1-3.1 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,400Reddish Norman J Sull West Csd 484802-89 21,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,400Reddish Beckyann ACRES 21.77 21,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,40090 Mesmer Hill Rd EAST-0305124 NRTH-0652665 AMB16 DEL AMB 21,400 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2194 PG-91 FD023 Callicoon fire 21,400 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 32,672******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.2 ******************* Kautz Rd3.-1-3.2 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 17,100Craig Stewart Living Trust Sull West Csd 484802-89 17,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 17,100288 River Rd ACRES 12.50 17,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,100Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0304620 NRTH-0654460 AMB16 DEL AMB 17,100 TO DEED BOOK 2013 PG-4466 FD023 Callicoon fire 17,100 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 26,107******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.3 ******************* 195 Kautz Rd3.-1-3.3 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Creegan George R Sull West Csd 484802-89 17,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 95,000Creegan Sally ACRES 1.77 95,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 95,000195 Kautz Rd EAST-0305110 NRTH-0654020 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,900Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 1366 PG-376 AMB16 DEL AMB 95,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 145,038 FD023 Callicoon fire 95,000 TO************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 14COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.4 ******************* Kautz Rd3.-1-3.4 105 Vac farmland AGRI DIST 41720 60,474 60,474 60,474Graby William R Sull West Csd 484802-89 86,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,226Graby Marie C ACRES 62.70 86,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,22629 Ray Graby Rd EAST-0305695 NRTH-0655201 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,226Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 1109 PG-73 AMB16 DEL AMB 86,700 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 132,366 FD023 Callicoon fire 86,700 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT OTS13 Omitted School 2013 25.17 MTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.5 ******************* 251 Kautz Rd3.-1-3.5 240 Rural res AGRI DIST 41720 25,002 25,002 25,002Bellino Stephen Sull West Csd 484802-89 51,080 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 93,798Bellino Mildred ACRES 22.72 118,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,7982637 Terrell Ave EAST-0304728 NRTH-0655136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,798Oceanside, NY 11572 DEED BOOK 1345 PG-229 AMB16 DEL AMB 118,800 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 181,374 FD023 Callicoon fire 118,800 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.6 ******************* 158 Kautz Rd3.-1-3.6 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,842Creegan George R Sull West Csd 484802-89 22,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,842Creegan Sally ACRES 4.70 36,842 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,842195 Kautz Rd EAST-0305808 NRTH-0653758 AMB16 DEL AMB 36,842 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 1198 PG-00207 FD023 Callicoon fire 36,842 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 56,247******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.7 ******************* 215 Kautz Rd3.-1-3.7 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Scott Mary K Sull West Csd 484802-89 26,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,300215 Kautz Rd ACRES 3.64 BANK C30217 100,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,300Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0305163 NRTH-0653612 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,200 DEED BOOK 2353 PG-661 AMB16 DEL AMB 100,300 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 153,130 FD023 Callicoon fire 100,300 TO******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-3.8 ******************* 147 Kautz Rd 90 PCT OF VALUE USED FOR EXEMPTION PURPOSES3.-1-3.8 270 Mfg housing VET WAR CT 41121 12,601 12,601 0Maxson Clare Sull West Csd 484802-89 29,500 AGED-CTS 41800 35,703 35,703 42,003Maxson Dennis ACRES 21.00 93,340 STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010147 Kautz Rd EAST-0305680 NRTH-0652672 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,036Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2194 PG-88 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,036 FULL MARKET VALUE 142,504 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,327 AMB16 DEL AMB 93,340 TO FD023 Callicoon fire 93,340 TO************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 15COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-4.1 ******************* Hillriegel Dr3.-1-4.1 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,200Hillriegel Philip Sull West Csd 484802-89 29,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,200Hillriegel Brian ACRES 29.20 29,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,20028 Hillriegel Dr EAST-0306544 NRTH-0654958 AMB16 DEL AMB 29,200 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 3211 PG-121 FD025 Hortonville fire 29,200 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 44,580******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-4.2 ******************* 66 Hillriegel Dr3.-1-4.2 241 Rural res&ag AGRI DIST 41720 10,508 10,508 10,508Hillriegel Brian M Sull West Csd 484802-89 44,400 STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Hillriegel Jeannie E ACRES 42.78 140,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,49266 Hillriegel Dr EAST-0307437 NRTH-0654634 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,492Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2007 PG-39 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,392 FULL MARKET VALUE 213,740 AMB16 DEL AMB 140,000 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FD025 Hortonville fire 140,000 TOUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 OTS13 Omitted School 2013 15.29 MT******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-4.3 ******************* 40 Hillriegel Dr3.-1-4.3 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Engle William M Sull West Csd 484802-89 25,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,500Engle Dina M ACRES 7.66 111,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,50040 Hillrigel Dr EAST-0307123 NRTH-0655231 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 91,400Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2007 PG-33 AMB16 DEL AMB 111,500 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 170,229 FD025 Hortonville fire 111,500 TO******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.1 ******************* 108 Kautz Rd3.-1-5.1 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Armstrong Gary Sull West Csd 484802-89 26,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 90,000Zieres Patricia A ACRES 5.91 90,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 90,000108 Kautz Rd EAST-0306630 NRTH-0653380 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,900Callicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 1798 PG-367 AMB16 DEL AMB 90,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 137,405 FD025 Hortonville fire 90,000 TO******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.2 ******************* 63 Kautz Rd3.-1-5.2 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 330,500Piccolo Trust Sull West Csd 484802-89 66,470 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 330,500C/O Mark Ruffalo ACRES 46.47 BANK C30614 330,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 330,50063 Kautz Rd EAST-0306670 NRTH-0652290 AMB16 DEL AMB 330,500 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2277 PG-50 FD025 Hortonville fire 330,500 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 504,580************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 16COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.3 ******************* 80 Kautz Rd3.-1-5.3 241 Rural res&ag VOL FIRE/A 41691 2,010 2,010 0Gorr Michael D Sull West Csd 484802-89 38,000 AGRI DIST 41720 11,709 11,709 11,709Gorr Karin M ACRES 20.19 195,000 STAR B 41854 0 0 20,10080 Kautz Rd EAST-0307410 NRTH-0653000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 181,281PO Box 38 DEED BOOK 1878 PG-628 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 181,281Hortonville, NY 12745 FULL MARKET VALUE 297,710 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,191 AMB16 DEL AMB 192,990 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 2,010 EXUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FD025 Hortonville fire 192,990 TO 2,010 EX OTS13 Omitted School 2013 8.70 MT******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.4 ******************* 136 Kautz Rd3.-1-5.4 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 99,300Troiola Alexander Sull West Csd 484802-89 21,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 99,300Troiola Sonya C ACRES 2.82 99,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,3002445 Jefferson St EAST-0306170 NRTH-0653560 AMB16 DEL AMB 99,300 TOEast Meadow, NY 11554 DEED BOOK 2531 PG-64 FD025 Hortonville fire 99,300 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 151,603******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.5 ******************* 118 Kautz Rd3.-1-5.5 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,100Martin Thomas Sull West Csd 484802-89 21,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,100Martin Martha ACRES 2.80 158,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 158,1005 Stone Gate Ct EAST-0306390 NRTH-0653560 AMB16 DEL AMB 158,100 TOSmithtown, NY 11787 DEED BOOK 1348 PG-405 FD025 Hortonville fire 158,100 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 241,374******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.6 ******************* Kautz Rd3.-1-5.6 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,200Garguilo Maria Elena Sull West Csd 484802-89 16,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,20025 86th St ACRES 2.83 16,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,200Brooklyn, NY 11209 EAST-0306840 NRTH-0653290 AMB16 DEL AMB 16,200 TO DEED BOOK 1899 PG-530 FD025 Hortonville fire 16,200 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 24,733******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-5.7 ******************* Kautz Rd3.-1-5.7 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,200Garguilo Maria Elena Sull West Csd 484802-89 16,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,20025 86th St ACRES 2.83 16,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,200Brooklyn, NY 11209 EAST-0306980 NRTH-0653260 AMB16 DEL AMB 16,200 TO DEED BOOK 1899 PG-530 FD025 Hortonville fire 16,200 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 24,733************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 17COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-6.1 ******************* 206 Kautz Rd3.-1-6.1 271 Mfg housings STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010Rosenberger Rosemary H Sull West Csd 484802-89 77,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 180,100206 Kautz Rd ACRES 60.10 180,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 180,100Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0304120 NRTH-0653630 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,090 DEED BOOK 1353 PG-43 AMB16 DEL AMB 180,100 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 274,962 FD023 Callicoon fire 180,100 TO******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-6.2 ******************* Kautz Rd3.-1-6.2 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 30,500Bauer Julie M Sull West Csd 484802-89 30,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 30,500Von Ahnen Erica H ACRES 30.87 30,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 30,500252 W Simmons Rd EAST-0303694 NRTH-0652547 AMB16 DEL AMB 30,500 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2053 PG-684 FD023 Callicoon fire 30,500 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 46,565******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-6.3 ******************* 279 Kautz Rd3.-1-6.3 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Chiru Ion V Sull West Csd 484802-89 24,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,000279 Kautz Rd ACRES 6.31 110,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 110,000Callicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0304602 NRTH-0652375 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,900 DEED BOOK 2114 PG-663 AMB16 DEL AMB 110,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 167,939 FD023 Callicoon fire 110,000 TO******************************************************************************************************* 3.-1-7 ********************* Old Hankins Rd 01/20143.-1-7 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 91,900Herbert Scott R Sull West Csd 484802-89 91,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 91,900Herbert Mark L ACRES 149.00 91,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 91,900487 Peters Rd EAST-0301680 NRTH-0653200 AMB16 DEL AMB 91,900 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 DEED BOOK 2014 PG-242 FD023 Callicoon fire 91,900 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 140,305************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 18COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware M A P S E C T I O N - 003 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 S U B - S E C T I O N - RPS150/V04/L015 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50 CURRENT DATE 6/18/2014

*** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y ***

TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLECODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE

OTS13 Omitted School 4 MOVTAX 76.44 76.44AMB16 DEL AMB 24 TOTAL 2437,707 2,010 2435,697FD023 Callicoon fire 14 TOTAL 1251,707 1251,707FD025 Hortonville fi 10 TOTAL 1186,000 2,010 1183,990

*** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y ***

TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL STAR STARCODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE AMOUNT TAXABLE

484802 Sull West Csd 24 968,150 2437,707 218,530 2219,177 226,720 1992,457

S U B - T O T A L 24 968,150 2437,707 218,530 2219,177 226,720 1992,457

484889 West Sull Lib 24 968,150 2437,707 218,530 2219,177 226,720 1992,457

T O T A L 48 1936,300 4875,414 437,060 4438,354 453,440 3984,914

*** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y ***

NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

*** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y ***

TOTALCODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN SCHOOL

41121 VET WAR CT 1 12,601 12,60141691 VOL FIRE/A 1 2,010 2,01041720 AGRI DIST 5 176,527 176,527 176,52741800 AGED-CTS 1 35,703 35,703 42,00341834 STAR EN 2 86,02041854 STAR B 7 140,700 T O T A L 17 226,841 226,841 445,250

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 19COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware M A P S E C T I O N - 003 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 S U B - S E C T I O N - RPS150/V04/L015 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50 CURRENT DATE 6/18/2014

*** G R A N D T O T A L S ***

ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE STARSEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL COUNTY TOWN SCHOOL TAXABLE

1 TAXABLE 24 968,150 2437,707 2210,866 2210,866 2219,177 1992,457

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 20COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-1.1 ******************* 408 Cty Rte 1314.-1-1.1 241 Rural res&ag AGRI DIST 41720 24,884 24,884 24,884Peters Sidney G Sull West Csd 484802-89 49,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,5163658 Route 34B ACRES 53.00 90,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,516Scipio Center, NY 13147 EAST-0309100 NRTH-0654740 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,516 DEED BOOK 722 PG-00728 AMB16 DEL AMB 90,400 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 138,015 FD025 Hortonville fire 90,400 TOUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 OTS13 Omitted School 2013 25.61 MT******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-1.2 ******************* 368 Cty Rte 1314.-1-1.2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,800Ocasio Peter Sull West Csd 484802-89 16,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,800Ocasio Yolanda FRNT 225.80 DPTH 107.20 49,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,800368 County Rte 131 ACRES 0.54 BANK C20161 AMB16 DEL AMB 49,800 TOCallicoon, NY 12723 EAST-0309007 NRTH-0653965 FD025 Hortonville fire 49,800 TO DEED BOOK 1890 PG-490 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,031******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-2 ********************* 140 Knack Hill Rd4.-1-2 113 Cattle farm AGRI DIST 41720 64,352 64,352 64,352Peters Sidney G Sull West Csd 484802-89 139,000 SILO EXEM 42100 3,000 3,000 3,0003658 Route 34B ACRES 140.00 270,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 203,248Scipio Center, NY 13147 EAST-0311440 NRTH-0653360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 203,248 DEED BOOK 722 PG-00728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 203,248MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 413,130 AMB16 DEL AMB 267,600 TOUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 3,000 EX FD025 Hortonville fire 267,600 TO 3,000 EX OTS13 Omitted School 2013 70.06 MT******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-3 ********************* Knack Hill Rd4.-1-3 105 Vac farmland AGRI DIST 41720 71,027 71,027 71,027Peters David Sull West Csd 484802-89 81,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 9,973Peters Cindy ACRES 40.00 81,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 9,973376 Cty Rte 121 EAST-0311050 NRTH-0651740 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 9,973Hortonville, NY 12745 DEED BOOK 1804 PG-40 AMB16 DEL AMB 81,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 123,664 FD025 Hortonville fire 81,000 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT OTS13 Omitted School 2013 20.14 MTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-4.1 ******************* Knack Hill Rd4.-1-4.1 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,500Roeder Harold G Sull West Csd 484802-89 36,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,500Roeder Donna L ACRES 17.17 36,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,500Knack Hill Rd EAST-0311529 NRTH-0650958 AMB16 DEL AMB 36,500 TOPO Box 80 DEED BOOK 3431 PG-445 FD025 Hortonville fire 36,500 TOHortonville, NY 12745 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,725************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 4 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L PAGE 21COUNTY - Sullivan T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013TOWN - Delaware TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014SWIS - 482600 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 065.50

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOLCURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUECURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO.******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-4.2 ******************* 29 Knack Hill Rd4.-1-4.2 210 1 Family Res STAR EN 41834 0 0 43,010Roeder Harold G Jr Sull West Csd 484802-89 22,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 144,000Roeder Donna L ACRES 1.28 144,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 144,000PO Box 80 EAST-0312180 NRTH-0651480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 100,990Hortonville, NY 12745 DEED BOOK 3049 PG-371 AMB16 DEL AMB 144,000 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 219,847 FD025 Hortonville fire 144,000 TO******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-4.3 ******************* Knack Hill Rd4.-1-4.3 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 6,200Roeder Harold G Sull West Csd 484802-89 6,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 6,200Roeder Donna L ACRES 1.16 6,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,200Knack Hill Rd EAST-0312241 NRTH-0651726 AMB16 DEL AMB 6,200 TOPO Box 80 DEED BOOK 3431 PG-445 FD025 Hortonville fire 6,200 TOHortonville, NY 12745 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,466******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-4.4 ******************* 33 Knack Hill Rd4.-1-4.4 210 1 Family Res STAR B 41854 0 0 20,100Peters Brandon Sull West Csd 484802-89 20,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 90,90033 Knack Hill Rd ACRES 2.11 90,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 90,900Hortonville, NY 12745 EAST-0312189 NRTH-0651062 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,800 DEED BOOK 2013 PG-7614 AMB15 Ambulance dist #1 90,900 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 138,779 FD025 Hortonville fire 90,900 TO******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-6.1 ******************* Cty Rte 1214.-1-6.1 105 Vac farmland AGRI DIST 41720 15,203 15,203 15,203Peters David Sull West Csd 484802-89 15,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 297Peters Cindy ACRES 2.10 15,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 297376 Cty Rte 121 EAST-0313733 NRTH-0652430 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 297Hortonville, NY 12745 DEED BOOK 1804 PG-40 AMB16 DEL AMB 15,500 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 23,664 FD025 Hortonville fire 15,500 TOMAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT OTS13 Omitted School 2013 .60 MTUNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018******************************************************************************************************* 4.-1-6.2 ******************* 376 Cty Rte 1214.-1-6.2