south branch | public meeting 2
TRANSCRIPT
Agenda
May 7, 2015
6:00 - 6:15pm Welcome & Introductions
6:15 - 6:45pm Overview of Community Engagement
6:45 - 7:15pm Design Alternatives Feedback
7:15 - 7:25pm Public Q & A
-- Short Refreshments Break --
7:30 - 8:00pm Public Feedback at Wall Stations
Cleveland Public Library calls obstacles, such as hunger, illiteracy, and unemployment: Community Deficits.
The People’s University
CPL embraces its responsibility to fight these deficits by taking a strong STEP for our community’s future and providing:
• Safety - Safe places to learn all year round • Technology - Free access to all types of new technology • Education - Extensive & inspirational communities of learning • Preservation - A commitment to capturing and honoring history
Community Vision Plan
An effort to determine the appropriate services that will be offered at the Cleveland Public Library’s branch locations by 2019 through authentic engagement and valued input from community residents.
Current branches in Group 1:• South• Fleet• Woodland• Sterling
Community Vision Plan
A report will be produced for each group with recommendations tailored to each branch, which may include:
• Exterior architectural renovations • Concepts for reprogramming interior spaces• Outdoor site improvements • Framework for prioritizing library services • Streetscape enhancements • Creative ideas for bridging the digital divide • Partnerships with community organizations
Community Vision Plan
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
• Library has not made a decision regarding the future use of the Carnegie building. This Community Vision Plan is the public engagement process to arrive at an answer.
• There is no budget set for the South Branch recommendations. The library wants to know what the community needs are first, then plan financial investments accordingly.
• The definition of "21st Century Library" will be co-created by each branch community. The Cleveland Public Library recognizes each community has different needs and priorities.
CPL COMMUNITY VISION PLAN : TIMELINESOUTH BRANCH
APRIL MAY
99 7
1
1920
2 3
22
16
JUNE
12
18
ADV MTG #2
ADV MTG #3
SUBMISSION
CPL BOARD MTG
PUBLIC MTG #2
23
4
Jaime Declet | Branch Manager, CPL South Branch
Adam Gifford | SCFBC Neighborhood Development Office
Trevor Hunt | Cleveland City Planning
Dr. Irene Javier | Lincoln-West High School
Rebecca Kempton | SCFBC Neighborhood Resident
Mark Pratt | Tremont Neighborhood Resident
Jeff Ramsey | SCFBC Neighborhood Development Office
Cory Riordan | Tremont West Development Corporation
Scott Rosenstein | Tremont West Development Corporation
David Roth | Luis Muñoz Marin Elementary School
Jesús Sanchez | Esperanza, Inc.
CoCo Sharod | SCFBC Neighborhood Resident
Sandy Smith | Tremont West Development Corporation
South Branch
Advisory Commitee:
Æc
Æc
Æc
Æc
Æc
ÆcÆcSouth
Fulton
Brooklyn
Jefferson
Carnegie West
Sources: Esri, DeLorme, HERE, USGS, Intermap, increment P Corp., NRCAN, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),Esri (Thailand), TomTom
SOUTH BRANCH SERVICE AREA
Prepared by: Cleveland Public Library, Knowledge Office ADONovember 19, 2014
Source: NODIS, 20110 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.80.1
Miles
Service Area | South Branch
Advisory Committee Members
Public Meeting 1 Attendees
Survey Responses (South)
Lincoln-West Focus Group
Library Youth Focus Group
1370+99116
SCRANTON RD
RESTROOMSKITCHEN
STATION 3Library Stories
CHILDREN’S AREA
STATION 5Branch(ing)
Conversations
STATION 6Survey
SIGN INREFRESHMENTS
&
BACKGROUNDINFORMATION
STATION 4Mapping Assets
STATION 2Defining the
Vision
STATION 1Discovering
Options
Public Meeting6 Engagement Stations
Wednesday, Dec. 10th6-8pm
Gruss Hall3115 Scranton Road
Survey Feedback
SOUTH:
99STERLING:
44WOODLAND:
13JEFFERSON:
8FLEET:
41
TOTAL SURVEYS:
284
"Please list the name of the CPL facility you identify as your local branch."
Q: Please offer 3 words that best capture your vision for the CPL experience in your area by 2019.homey | clean | GED | copying | original | old | accessibility | accessibility | resourceful | old | friendly | organized | open | books | location | safe | enlightened | ramp | exciiting | anime | children | books | dvds | preserve | bigger | location | silent | outdoors | clean | available | achievable | books | classes | helpful | extended | intellectual | comfortable | safe | growth | accessibility | space | accessibility | safe | safe | quiet | quiet | books | creative | colorful | dedication | community | outreach | learning | dvds | literacy | community | historic | restoration | free | traditional | community | dvds | interconnected | old | new | interactive | reading | books | technology | service | educational | clean | helpful | building | memories | handicapped | tablets | presentations | helpful | historic | community | safe | accessibility | accountability | educational | resourceful | educational | comfortable | books | jobs | new | technology | safe | diversity | service | service | close | close | privacy | friendly | clean | inspirational | accessibility | advertising | cds | programming | historic | renewal | clean | educational | meeting | open | global | new | new | colorful | friendly | art | sitting | service | positive | bright | safe | parking | computers | open | accessibility | music | integrity | quiet | educational | service | friendly | teaching | computers | trustworthy | focused | bigger | community | educational | reading | math | programming | availability | availability | comfortable | informational | helpful | friendly | educational | historic | visible | dedication | safe | rehabilitation | location | creative | inspirational | diversity
Survey Feedback : South Branch
Q: If you could suggest an additional resource for your local branch, what would it be?• more computers• free copying• ramp for handicapped• teen activities• more books• safer location
• more interaction w/ church groups / seniors• more seating• maker space• after-school tutoring• longer movie rentals
Survey Feedback : South Branch
Q: What kind of class or program would you like to see the library offer?• Diversity Training• Languages• Parenting• Fashion Design• Internet Safety• Transgender Help• Job Placement• Writing Workshops• Babysitting• Knitting• Fitness
• Self-Defense• Excel• Spanish• Photography• Cooking• IT Engineer• Nutrition• Sign language• Robotics• Poetry• Cultural Festivals
Survey Feedback : South Branch
"I wish the library would be more visible. I often forget it's an option. Be part of local festivals. Engage with local block clubs. Advertise in the local Tremont paper about community offerings."
"The Cleveland Public Library is a fine institution. It is a second home to many people using the facility. Keeping Branches in neighborhoods is important to the people living in the area since many people walk to their branches."
Survey Feedback : South Branch
"Update the interiors & furniture of the branches, most are stuck in the 1980s."
"Please bring back the Carnegie library, it is a public trust for preservation and use for the community."
Survey Feedback : South Branch
"The South Branch has many helpful, knowledgeable, and friendly staff members. You're doing a wonderful job."
W 5
3RD S
T
W 5
0TH S
T
W 4
4TH S
T
W 6
5TH S
T
1 5 M I N U T E W A L K
1 5 M I N
U T E W
A L K
1 5 M I N U T E W A L K
1 5 M I N
U T E W
A L K
81
45
45
45
DENISON AVE
KEY
15 MIN WALKING RADIUS
CLARK AVE
TRAIN AVE
STORER AVE
CLARK AVE
STARKWEATHER AVE
ABBEY AVE
LORAIN AVE
LORAIN AVE
FRANKLIN BLVD
DETROIT AVE
FULT
ON
RD
FULT
ON
RD
W 2
5TH S
T
W 25 TH ST
SCRA
NTO
N R
D
W 1
4TH S
TW
14TH
ST
I-90
I-90
I-71
I-490
W 4
4TH S
T
W 4
1ST S
T
QUIGLEY RD
VALENTINE AVE
COLU
MBU
S RD
TROWBRIDGE AVE
TREMONTOHIO CITY
CLARK-FULTON
STOCKYARDS
DETROIT-SHOREWAY
W 5
3RD S
T
W 5
0TH S
T
W 4
4TH S
T
W 6
5TH S
T
Garrett Morgan School
1 5 M I N U T E W A L K
1 5 M I N
U T E W
A L K
1 5 M I N U T E W A L K
1 5 M I N
U T E W
A L K
20
21
35
45A
51
81
81
81
81
81
21 45A
79A
79B
79A
79B
22
22
16
2
81
81
CLARK AVE
TRAIN AVE
STORER AVE
CLARK AVE
STARKWEATHER AVE
ABBEY AVE
LORAIN AVE
LORAIN AVE
FRANKLIN BLVD
DETROIT AVE
FULT
ON
RD
FULT
ON
RD
W 2
5TH S
T
W 25 TH ST
SCRA
NTO
N R
D
W 1
4TH S
TW
14TH
ST
I-90
I-90
I-71
I-490
W 4
4TH S
T
W 4
1ST S
T
QUIGLEY RD
VALENTINE AVE
COLU
MBU
S RD
TROWBRIDGE AVE
DENISON AVE
Munoz K-8
Buhrer K-8
Scranton K-8
Scranton Road Bible Church
Tremont Montessori School
Je�erson Branch Library
Carnegie West Branch Library
Grace Hospital
Dunbar K-8
Lincoln-West High School
Max Hayes High School
Thomas Je�erson K-12
MetroHealth Hospital
Steelyard Commons
St. Michael’s Church
Redeemer Church
Michael Zone Recreation Center
Clark Elementary
Clark Recreation Center
Booker PreK-8
Gallagher PreK-8
Walton PreK-8
Lincoln Park
Waverly Elementary
Metro Catholic School
Tremont Park
Fulton Branch Library
Esperanza, Inc.
S,C-F,BC Community Development O�ce
Hispanic Business Center
Volunteers of America
Hispanic UMADAOP
Hispanic Alliance
Tremont West Development Corp.
Ohio City, Inc.
St. Ignatius High School
Merrick House Settlement
Scranton Castle Senior Housing
W 25-Ohio City Rapid Station
W 65-Lorain Rapid Station
Scranton Road Historic District
Merrick House Fulton
Merrick House West
West Side Market26
TREMONTOHIO CITY
CLARK-FULTON
STOCKYARDS
DETROIT-SHOREWAY45
4526
26
45
45
45 KEYLIBRARY
SCHOOL
PARK/RECREATION CENTER
COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION
HOUSE OF WORSHIP
HOSPITAL
TRANSIT STATION
RETAIL DESTINATION
SPECIAL HOUSING
GROCERY/FOOD RETAILER
15 MIN WALKING 1 BUS ROUTES
Save-A-Lot
clev
elan
d pu
blic
libr
ary
SOU
TH B
RAN
CH
BR
AN
CH
(IN
G)
CO
NV
ER
SA
TIO
NS
INT
ER
NA
L
CP
L &
BR
AN
CH
POSITIVES NEGATIVES
EX
TE
RN
AL
NE
IGH
BO
RH
OO
D
Branch(ing) Conversations Feedback
EXTERNAL / NEIGHBORHOOD POSITIVES +
1. Safe, cozy on arrival in old location2. South Branch on Scranton is a safer corner3. Focal point. “It’s ours.”4. Space to feel pride5. Towpath coming through Scranton Rd. neighborhood 6. Security guard7. Old location safer8. Carnegie Branch has outdoor space9. “Living room”10. Walkability in old location11. Police cameras12. On-site & off-site activities a. Reading in schools13. CPL’s presence uplifting W. 25th / Clark corner14. Accessible to three elementary schools & churches a. Walking trips / field trips15. Respected. Not tagged.
Branch(ing) Conversations Feedback
INTERNAL / CPL BRANCH POSITIVES +
1. Carnegie building is asset to city (historic & inspiring)2. Lighting3. Potential for shared parking4. Computers5. After school programming well-received/attended6. Place for kids to meet (movies, etc.)7. Place of knowledge8. Feel at home9. Programming is positive (music, etc.)10. Public education - accessibility11. Historic collection about Cleveland12. Stacks, openness. Easy to browse.13. Current location is overcrowded (people talking to one another)14. Multiple types of spaces
Branch(ing) Conversations Feedback
EXTERNAL / NEIGHBORHOOD NEGATIVES -
1. Crime / vandalism2. Unsafe perception 3. Not enough parking at old Carnegie branch4. Scranton can’t cross road5. Not bikable, not walkable6. Not close enough to green spaces - opportunities for outdoor education7. Lack of additional “retail” programa. Look at Cuyahoga County Snow Rd. Branch8. Poor lighting on corner / corridors9. Crossing is not safe10. Redbox at County Library
Branch(ing) Conversations Feedback
INTERNAL / CPL BRANCH NEGATIVES -
1. No meeting rooms - hinders community exchange2. Tiny, not enough room for older teens (temp. branch too small)3. Doesn’t have enough variety, materials, periodicals4. Cost of renovation for Carnegie Branch5. Not safe from current parking6. No space for teens, programming7. Lacking guest space8. CPL struggles to keep up with digital / changing culture9. Historic collection not disseminated - could be housed in branches (by topics)
Branch(ing) Conversations Summary
INTERNAL
1. Need larger spaces for community programming & gathering2. Historic Carnegie library inspires strong local pride 3. More flexibility to manage competing uses (noise, crowds, etc.)
EXTERNAL
1. Actual & perceived safety surrounding library must be improved2. Better transportation accommodations for car & bike parking3. Opportunity for library to anchor surrounding development/identity
ACCESSIBLEDefining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
CPL South Branch Public Meeting - 12/10/14 - FEEDBACK
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Technology updated Safe Open dawn to
duskLocate UPK facilities
near libraries
Extended Hours Safe at old Scranton library
Open for all-season special
events
Kids must learn to love reading
WirelessOn a public transit line -
MUST!
Lighting/attractive landscaping
Reflects the neighborhood
(diverse)
Open to All Dangerous (unacceptable)
Extended Hours
Bilingual librarians - services & materials
should reflect ethnicity of
neighborhoodADA Compliant WalkableCarnegie South
Historic
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Align with CMSD school needs
State-of-the-art but no heavy emphasis on
bricks & mortar
Connecting assets like on a college
campus
walking/bike paths leading to library
Find a way to DO it! Save
South!
more access to new
technologies
South too small. Not enough on hand materials
adjacent to parks - like Eastman
Reading Garden
library should be the place to gather
tie into schools in community
Information sharing
green space / learning gardens
Not a good neighborhood
computer + internet
Think outside the box (in viewing
building assessment)
Parks are for playing. Libraries are for learning.
Library should reflect diversity of
community - cultural assets
Book selection Central to all Restore South branch Diverse
Safe + Quiet Place for children
Keep our historic building
Restore library to historic location
Community asset. Historic building is
centerpiece of historic district
work with other community
assets
Carnegie South building
Partner with Nestle Maltz Foundation
Save old library
ACCESSIBLE
COMMUNITY
ACCESSIBLEDefining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
CPL South Branch Public Meeting - 12/10/14 - FEEDBACK
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Technology updated Safe Open dawn to
duskLocate UPK facilities
near libraries
Extended Hours Safe at old Scranton library
Open for all-season special
events
Kids must learn to love reading
WirelessOn a public transit line -
MUST!
Lighting/attractive landscaping
Reflects the neighborhood
(diverse)
Open to All Dangerous (unacceptable)
Extended Hours
Bilingual librarians - services & materials
should reflect ethnicity of
neighborhoodADA Compliant WalkableCarnegie South
Historic
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Align with CMSD school needs
State-of-the-art but no heavy emphasis on
bricks & mortar
Connecting assets like on a college
campus
walking/bike paths leading to library
Find a way to DO it! Save
South!
more access to new
technologies
South too small. Not enough on hand materials
adjacent to parks - like Eastman
Reading Garden
library should be the place to gather
tie into schools in community
Information sharing
green space / learning gardens
Not a good neighborhood
computer + internet
Think outside the box (in viewing
building assessment)
Parks are for playing. Libraries are for learning.
Library should reflect diversity of
community - cultural assets
Book selection Central to all Restore South branch Diverse
Safe + Quiet Place for children
Keep our historic building
Restore library to historic location
Community asset. Historic building is
centerpiece of historic district
work with other community
assets
Carnegie South building
Partner with Nestle Maltz Foundation
Save old library
ACCESSIBLE
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITYDefining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
CPL South Branch Public Meeting - 12/10/14 - FEEDBACK
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Technology updated Safe Open dawn to
duskLocate UPK facilities
near libraries
Extended Hours Safe at old Scranton library
Open for all-season special
events
Kids must learn to love reading
WirelessOn a public transit line -
MUST!
Lighting/attractive landscaping
Reflects the neighborhood
(diverse)
Open to All Dangerous (unacceptable)
Extended Hours
Bilingual librarians - services & materials
should reflect ethnicity of
neighborhoodADA Compliant WalkableCarnegie South
Historic
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Align with CMSD school needs
State-of-the-art but no heavy emphasis on
bricks & mortar
Connecting assets like on a college
campus
walking/bike paths leading to library
Find a way to DO it! Save
South!
more access to new
technologies
South too small. Not enough on hand materials
adjacent to parks - like Eastman
Reading Garden
library should be the place to gather
tie into schools in community
Information sharing
green space / learning gardens
Not a good neighborhood
computer + internet
Think outside the box (in viewing
building assessment)
Parks are for playing. Libraries are for learning.
Library should reflect diversity of
community - cultural assets
Book selection Central to all Restore South branch Diverse
Safe + Quiet Place for children
Keep our historic building
Restore library to historic location
Community asset. Historic building is
centerpiece of historic district
work with other community
assets
Carnegie South building
Partner with Nestle Maltz Foundation
Save old library
ACCESSIBLE
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITYDefining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
CPL South Branch Public Meeting - 12/10/14 - FEEDBACK
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Technology updated Safe Open dawn to
duskLocate UPK facilities
near libraries
Extended Hours Safe at old Scranton library
Open for all-season special
events
Kids must learn to love reading
WirelessOn a public transit line -
MUST!
Lighting/attractive landscaping
Reflects the neighborhood
(diverse)
Open to All Dangerous (unacceptable)
Extended Hours
Bilingual librarians - services & materials
should reflect ethnicity of
neighborhoodADA Compliant WalkableCarnegie South
Historic
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Align with CMSD school needs
State-of-the-art but no heavy emphasis on
bricks & mortar
Connecting assets like on a college
campus
walking/bike paths leading to library
Find a way to DO it! Save
South!
more access to new
technologies
South too small. Not enough on hand materials
adjacent to parks - like Eastman
Reading Garden
library should be the place to gather
tie into schools in community
Information sharing
green space / learning gardens
Not a good neighborhood
computer + internet
Think outside the box (in viewing
building assessment)
Parks are for playing. Libraries are for learning.
Library should reflect diversity of
community - cultural assets
Book selection Central to all Restore South branch Diverse
Safe + Quiet Place for children
Keep our historic building
Restore library to historic location
Community asset. Historic building is
centerpiece of historic district
work with other community
assets
Carnegie South building
Partner with Nestle Maltz Foundation
Save old library
ACCESSIBLE
COMMUNITY
INSPIRATIONALDefining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Technology access; tools to connect to jobs
Carnegie building
provides an inspiring
environment and makes a
statement about preserving our
history.
Just like Eastman reading
garden...my favorite space in
the city!
Scranton/Clark Library - stay open to help all of Cleveland!
Public Access
Adult learning storylines for
kids
Historic connection
Who cares?! The Library is not a
park!Safe Community
Safe place
Modern. compact but with
park/meeting spaces
Partner with Scranton Road Baptist Church
Center of Scranton Road Historic District
Carnegie South building
Scranton Road Historic District
Beauty is inspriational,
building is beautiful
AtmosphereStay Open old
building!
INSPIRATIONAL
INSPIRATIONALDefining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
SERVICES LIBRARY FACILITY
LIBRARY GROUNDS
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD OTHER
Technology access; tools to connect to jobs
Carnegie building
provides an inspiring
environment and makes a
statement about preserving our
history.
Just like Eastman reading
garden...my favorite space in
the city!
Scranton/Clark Library - stay open to help all of Cleveland!
Public Access
Adult learning storylines for
kids
Historic connection
Who cares?! The Library is not a
park!Safe Community
Safe place
Modern. compact but with
park/meeting spaces
Partner with Scranton Road Baptist Church
Center of Scranton Road Historic District
Carnegie South building
Scranton Road Historic District
Beauty is inspriational,
building is beautiful
AtmosphereStay Open old
building!
INSPIRATIONAL
COMMUNITYACCESSIBLE INSPIRATIONAL
Defining the Vision | Public Meeting #1 Feedback
SERVICES1. Provide up-to-date technology access required for future jobs2. Collaborate more with local organizations & schools to align services3. Consider extending the library hours
LIBRARY FACILITY1. Renovation of historic Carnegie building could create inspiring place 2. Modern amenities needed, including meeting spaces3. Library must be in central location with transit access and feels safe
LIBRARY GROUNDS1. Connect library to surrounding assets; create campus experience2. Attractive exterior space to draw people in year-round
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD1. Library should be THE place for diverse neighbors to gather2. Walkable area surrounding the library, serving as historic district anchor
Lincoln-West High School | Focus Group
Observations1. Helpful service, appreciate engaging librarians2. Historic building's high ceilings & old interiors are cool 3. Enjoyed sitting in the Carnegie building's bay window, watching the street4. Loved children's section in old location, with coloring pages & toys5. Liked the experience of writing name on first library card
Desires1. Quiet space to concentrate2. Areas for teens to hang out 3. Comfortable chairs4. Want modern space to contrast with historic building (old & new)5. More intuitive organization of materials (ex. Marvel, Fantastic, Avengers)6. Separate sound-proof areas for different age groups7. Whiteboard, chalkboard wall for interaction8. More monthly programming (ex. teen & family nights, movies, open late)
Make the library cool again.
INTERNAL
Lincoln-West High School | Focus Group
Observations1. Clark is dirty, unsafe, and a busy street2. Clark is terrible for traffic3. Some students from Luis Muñoz Marin would fight in front of the library
Desires1. Outdoor seating area, like a reading garden (water, birds, trees)2. Ability to choose different spaces based on desired mood3. Get police officer to come by regularly, but welcoming to teens4. Big mural nearby to draw attention & tell story of the neighborhood
EXTERNAL The library was my rescue spot.
South Branch Library Youth | Focus Group
Observations1. Temporary location has bright colors, more welcoming than old building2. Carnegie building felt dark and gloomy inside3. At old library, there were books everywhere, now selection is limited4. Liked old library because there were separate sections for kids5. Teens are just charging cellphones when we want to use computers6. Love the couches--want more!
Desires1. More Manga book selection in future2. More "life learning" books, that teach you between right and wrong3. Japanese language section, because learning it at school4. Old building should have brighter colors inside5. Colorful murals or whiteboard wall to draw on6. Arts & crafts classes7. Softer headphones!8. There should be food here!
INTERNAL
South Branch Library Youth | Focus Group
Observations1. Glad that schools are nearby2. Glad they're fixing Clark Ave.3. Nice to be next to Family Dollar (to buy snacks), cornerstores aren't safe4. Not safe crossing the street (Clark Ave.)5. Gang bangers all around the neighborhood
Desires1. More crossing guards near Clark Ave. and W. 16th (near I-71 bridge)2. Want to walk to a park nearby3. Want a safe and friendly store to buy snacks4. Want a skate park nearby
EXTERNAL
W. 25th St. Corridor Initiative
2012The goal of the W 25th St Corridor Initiative was to build on the area’s existing assets, identify and leverage development opportunities along West 25th Street based on current plans and proposed investments, and to catalyze the revitalization of the corridor and its adjacent neighborhoods.
CENTRAL ATRIUM
2470 FT2
READING ROOM
1425 FT2
READING ROOM
1200 FT2READING ROOM
595 FT2
OFFICES/RESTROOMS
630 FT2
BREAK-OUTSPACE 250 FT2
BREAK-OUTSPACE 250 FT2
ENTRY 300 FT2
MEETINGROOM
690 FT2
C L A R K A V E N U E
S C
R A
N T
O N
R
O A
D
C L A R K A V E N U E
W E
S T
2
5 T
H
S T
R E
E T
W E
S T
3
0 T
H
S T
R E
E T
C O M P U T E R S
Y O U N G A D U L TB O O K S
D V D S
C H I L D R E N ‘ S A R E A S T A F F R O O M
R E S T R O O M S
C I R C U L A T I O N D E S K
19 76
N
South Branch Usage
2011 118,840 103,510 32,888(16 PCs)
22,567(16 PCs)
111,598 100,919 31,225 (15 PCs)
20,529 (15 PCs)
116,207 93,752 37,947 26,789
115,694 92,489 40,333 (27 PCs)
28,516 (27 PCs)
2012
2013(move year)
2014
CIRCULATION ATTENDANCE COMPUTER SESSIONS
COMPUTER USAGE (HOURS)
TWIN
KIE
SCRA
NTON
TWIN
KIE PRIVATE
OWNER #2PRIVATE OWNER #2
PRIVATE OWNER #3
PRIVATE OWNER #1
ST MICHAEL’S CHURCH
SCRANTON RD BIBLE CHURCH
UMADAOP
CLEVELAND METRO SCHOOL DISTRICT
CLARK
Property Ownership
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
USE CARNEGIE BUILDING NEW BRANCH BUILDING
NEIGHBORHOOD KIOSKS
TWO BRANCH BUILDINGS
Build
Lease
Full
Full +Addition
Partial
Carnegie+ Temp.
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
USE CARNEGIE BUILDING
Full
+ Preserve Carnegie library history+ Interior rooms may provide great flexibility+ Known neighborhood anchor+ Could support Scranton Rd. Historic District
- Significant renovation costs- Full library reuse may prevent historic tax credits- May not be as welcoming to patrons west of 25th- Limited parking
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
USE CARNEGIE BUILDING
Partial
+ Eligible for historic tax credits, less than 50% library+ Preserve Carnegie library history+ Interior rooms may provide great flexibility+ Known neighborhood anchor+ Could support Scranton Rd. Historic District
- Half the space available as in the past - Significant renovation costs- May not be as welcoming to patrons west of 25th- Limited parking
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
Full +Addition
USE CARNEGIE BUILDING
+ Improved connection to W. 25th Street+ Larger usable area to accommodate growth+ Preserve Carnegie library history+ Interior rooms may provide great flexibility+ Known neighborhood anchor+ Could support Scranton Rd. Historic District
- More costly than renovation costs alone- May create historic preservation concerns- May not be as welcoming to patrons west of 25th- Limited parking
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
+ Could fill vacant land in the neighborhood+ Potential strong connection to transit on W. 25th+ Larger usable area to accommodate growth+ May support neighborhood redevelopment efforts+ Flexibility in new design to meet specific needs+ Potential long-term savings through energy efficiency
- Creates unknown use for historic Carnegie building- New materials use rather than reuse of existing- Significant initial cost to build- May not be able to acquire appropriate site
NEW BRANCH BUILDING
Build
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
+ May support neighborhood redevelopment efforts+ Potential strong connection to transit on W. 25th+ Potential larger area to accommodate growth+ Flexibility in new design to meet specific needs+ Potential long-term savings through energy efficiency
- Creates unknown use for historic Carnegie building- New materials use rather than reuse of existing- Lack of site ownership- May not have clear identity for the library
NEW BRANCH BUILDING
Lease
+ Connection to Clark Fulton & Tremont+ Larger usable area to accommodate growth+ Preserve Carnegie library history+ Flexibility provided by two buildings+ Two known neighborhood anchors+ Could support Scranton Rd. Historic District+ Could support La Villa Hispana
- Very high costs to staff two buildings- More costly than renovation costs alone- May create patron confusion between buildings- May deter building sense of community- Concerns about equity and distribution of resources
SOUTH BRANCH FACILITY | FUTURE OPTIONS
TWO BRANCH BUILDINGS
Carnegie+ Temp.
South Branch History | 1911 letter
"Ground at the rear of the building will permit of adding an Auditorium if funds are available later."
Quiet Time Afterschool Time
Public Time• Side rooms closed off for
quiet reading + study space (red)
• Central area left open (purple)
• All areas open for children's programming, reading, etc.
• Some side rooms closed off for quiet reading + study
space (red)• Central area and some side
spaces left open (purple)
Partitioning the Space
1. How important is it to have QUIET STUDY ROOMS?1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
Plainsboro Public Library, New Jersey
2. How important is it to have LOUNGE SEATING AREAS?1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
Washoe County Library, New Jersey
3. How important is it to have INDOOR PLANTS & VEGETATION?1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
4. How important is it to have 3D PRINTERS?1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
TechCentral, Downtown Main Branch
TechEast, Fleet Main Branch
5. How important is it to have LAPTOPS?1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
Before I die..., Candy Chang
6. How important is it to have INTERACTIVE WALLS?1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
Bird’s Nest, Mark Reigelman
7. How important is it to have OUTDOOR ART INSTALLATIONS? 1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
Bench Bibliotheque, Russia
8. How important is it to have OUTDOOR READING AREA? 1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
9. How important is it to have OUTDOOR MURALS? 1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
10. How important is it to have LIBRARY KIOSKS? 1. Not important 2. Somewhat 3. Moderately 4. Important 5. Very important
Monday 10:00-7:00Tuesday 10:00-7:00Wednesday 10:00-6:00Thursday 10:00-7:00Friday 10:00-6:00Saturday 10:00-6:00Sunday Closed
South Branch Library Hours | Current
If library hours were extended, which day would you prefer?a. Mondayb. Tuesdayc. Wednesdayd. Thursdaye. Fridayf. Saturdayg. Open on Sunday
Add your comments in the space provided on the response card.
WOODLAND
00% 20
%10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
40
100%
WEST PARK
00% 20
%10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
100% WALZ
0
0%20
%
10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
40
100% UNION
0
0%20
%
10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
40
100% STERLING
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%80%
30
100%SO
UTH BROO
KLYN010
RO
CKPO
RT
00%20%
10 40%
20 60%80%
30 100%
RIC
E
0 0%20%1040%2060%3080%40100%
MO
UN
T PL
EASA
NT
00%20%
10
40%20
60%30
80%100%
MLK
0
0%10
20%
20
40%
30
60%
40
80%
50
100%
MEMORIAL N
OTTIN
GHAM
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%80%
30
100%0%
10%
20%
30%40%50%60%
70%
80%90
%100%LORAIN
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
100%
LANGSTON HUGHES
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
40
100%
HOUGH
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%
30
80%
40
100%
HARVAR
D LEE
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%80%
30
100%
GLEN
VILLE
0
0%20%
1040%
2060%80%
30100%
GA
RD
EN
VALLE
Y
0102030
FLEE
T
1020
EAST
MAN
0
0% 10
20%20
40%30
60%40
80%
50
100%
EAST131
0
0%
10
20%
20
40%
30
60%
40
80%
50
100%
COLLINWOOD
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%80%
30
100%
0
0%20%
10
40%
20
60%80%
30
100%
BROOKLYN
010
20
ADDISON
01020
CARNEGIE WEST
0
SOU
TH0
0%20%
1040%
2060%80%
30 100%
MAIN LIBRARY
JEFFERSON
1020
FULT
ON
01020
0
100
110120
130
14015016017018019
020
021
022
023
0
240
250260
0102030405060708090
South branch use