sinusitis: what the primary care practitioner should do in 2011: a review of new canadian guidelines...

100
SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian Guidelines in Sinusitis Project Clinical Professor Université de Montréal Montréal, Quebec, Canada

Upload: zoe-moody

Post on 25-Dec-2015

222 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

SINUSITIS: What the PrimaryCare Practitioner Should Do in 2011:

A Review of New Canadian Guidelines

SINUSITIS: What the PrimaryCare Practitioner Should Do in 2011:

A Review of New Canadian Guidelines

Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSCProject Lead: Canadian Guidelines in Sinusitis Project

Clinical ProfessorUniversité de Montréal

Montréal, Quebec, Canada

Page 2: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Learning ObjectivesLearning Objectives

1. Present burden of disease, diagnosis & classification of acute rhinosinusitis

2. Review data that pertains to a new way of treating acute rhinosinusitis

3. Review guidelines and future implications

4. Become familiar with the Canadian Clinical Practice Guidelines Committee recommendations for diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic rhinosinusitis

Page 3: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Management of Acute Rhinosinusitis

A Paradigm in Evolution

Management of Acute Rhinosinusitis

A Paradigm in Evolution

Page 4: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Management of Sinusitis: 1991 – 2010Management of Sinusitis: 1991 – 2010

1997

• Emphasis on differentiation between bacterial and viral sinusitis– ABRS as a clinical diagnosis

• Standardized diagnostic criteria• X-ray rarely required

– First-line therapy: Amoxicillin

– Duration of therapy: 10-14 days

Low DE, Desrosiers M, et al. Can Med Assoc J. 1997; 156: S1-S14.

Page 5: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Evolving issues in ABRSEvolving issues in ABRS

•Role of antibiotic therapy in ABRS is being questioned

– Recognition that URTI represent high % of episodes of ABRS

– Spontaneous improvement without antibiotics

– Complications of antibiotic therapy recognized• Individual (Colitis etc.)• Societal (Resistance)

•Suggests need for alternate therapy for management of ABRS

Page 6: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Case 1: Uncomplicated Acute Bacterial RhinosinusitisCase 1: Uncomplicated Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis

•Previously healthy 32-year-old non-smoking mother

•Recent onset of symptoms of an upper respiratory tract infection (URTI)

– Persistent nasal obstruction

– Right-sided maxillary facial pain

– Yellowish secretions

•Have all lasted 9 days from onset

•Has not responded to over-the-counter medication

Page 7: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Physical ExaminationPhysical Examination

• No apparent distress

• Yellowish secretions in right middle meatus

• Tenderness of her right maxillary sinus area on palpation

Page 8: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

AssessmentAssessment

•Typical symptoms of 7 days duration strongly suggest bacterial rhinosinusitis

– No x-ray is required to confirm diagnosis

•Symptom intensity is mild to moderate

•No signs of complications or systemic toxicity

Page 9: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

QuestionQuestion

•Diagnosis: Uncomplicated mild-moderate acute presumed bacterial sinusitis

•Are antibiotics required for management?

Page 10: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Rhinosinusitis:

Disease or Simple Nuisance?

Rhinosinusitis:

Disease or Simple Nuisance?

Page 11: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Respiratory Infections Are the # 1 Reason for Office VisitsRespiratory Infections Are the # 1 Reason for Office Visits

Page 12: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Therapeutic ProfileTherapeutic Profile

Page 13: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ARS Impairs QOLSF-36 Descriptive Stats: Bodily PainARS Impairs QOLSF-36 Descriptive Stats: Bodily Pain

Page 14: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Impact of CRS on PatientsImpact of CRS on Patients

•More bodily pain and worse social functioning than patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, congestive heart failure or back pain

•Quality of life is comparable in severity to that of other chronic conditions

•As a chronic condition, CRS should be proactively managed

•CRS is an inflammatory disease involving the nasal mucosa and paranasal sinuses

•Symptoms are usually of lesser intensity than those of ABRS

•Length of episode > 4 weeks

Gliklich RE, et al. Otolarygol Head Neck Surg. 1995;113:104-109.

Page 15: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Nearly Two-thirds of All Oral Solid Antibiotic Prescriptions Are for Sinusitis and BronchitisNearly Two-thirds of All Oral Solid Antibiotic Prescriptions Are for Sinusitis and Bronchitis

Page 16: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Does the World Need More Guidelines?Does the World Need More Guidelines?

•Canadian focus– Canadian incidence, socioeconomic, QOL data– Factors in Canadian issues (e.g. wait times for CTs)

•Addresses CRS, an area where controversy is unresolved and evidence is less with incorporation of expert opinion based on pathophysiology and current treatment regimens (Grade D)

Page 17: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Preparing a Complete Document for the Management of SinusitisPreparing a Complete Document for the Management of Sinusitis

• Principal thrust is a comprehensive guide to CRS and to address changes in the management of ABRS

• Practical focus: Directed at first-line practitioners with emphasis on patient-centric issues (e.g. facial pain NOT sinusitis)

• Involvement of multiple stakeholders for multidisciplinary input

• Brief, easily readable

Page 18: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

AGREE InstrumentAGREE Instrument

•Objectives clearly stated

•Target population indentified

•Stakeholders included in development

•Recommendations specific

•Additional educational materials

•Monitoring of uptake

•Regular revision

The AGREE Collaboration. Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation (AGREE) Instrument.Available at: www.agreecollaboration.org.

Page 19: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

What’s New?What’s New?

Page 20: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis 2011Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis 2011

A Major Change in Attitude

•Previously, emphasis on differentiating viral rhinosinusitis from acute bacterial sinusitis– Antibiotic therapy mandatory for all cases of ABRS

•Questions regarding efficacy of antibiotic therapy lead to new recommendations– Assess severity of sinusitis– Option of no antibiotic therapy for mild-to-moderate– Intranasal corticosteroids (INCS) as sole therapy without antibiotics

Page 21: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

When is Sinusitis Mild? Rating the Severity of ABRSWhen is Sinusitis Mild? Rating the Severity of ABRS

Page 22: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

When to Order an Antibiotic?Rating the Severity of ABRSWhen to Order an Antibiotic?Rating the Severity of ABRS

Page 23: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Chronic Rhinosinusitis (CRS)Chronic Rhinosinusitis (CRS)

• A complex disease with variable clinical presentations

• Inflammatory condition of the sinonasal mucosa interacting with

bacterial and/or fungi

• More than 10% of individuals in western countries affected*

• Genetic and environmental triggers likely play a significant role in

pathogenesis

*Bachert C, et al. Allergy. 2003;58:176-191.

Page 24: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Chronic Rhinosinusitis: New for 2011Chronic Rhinosinusitis: New for 2011

•Emphasis on role of inflammation in the pathogenesis of CRS

•Distinction between CRS with nasal polyposis (CRSwNP) and CRS without NP (CRSsNP)

•Management strategies for the Primary Care Provider

•Indications for referral

•Management of the post-surgical patient

Page 25: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Statements: Summary

Canadian Rhinosinusitis Guidelines 2011

Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis

Statements: Summary

Canadian Rhinosinusitis Guidelines 2011

Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis

Page 26: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (1 of 4)Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (1 of 4)

Strength of evidence integrates the grade of evidence with the potential for benefit and harm. Strength of recommendation indicates the level of endorsement of the statement by the panel of experts.

Page 27: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (2 of 4)Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (2 of 4)

Page 28: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (3 of 4)Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (3 of 4)

Page 29: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (4 of 4)Summary of Guideline Statements: ABRS (4 of 4)

Page 30: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Statements: Summary

Canadian Rhinosinusitis Guidelines 2011

Chronic Rhinosinusitis

Statements: Summary

Canadian Rhinosinusitis Guidelines 2011

Chronic Rhinosinusitis

Page 31: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: CRS (1 of 3)Summary of Guideline Statements: CRS (1 of 3)

Strength of evidence integrates the grade of evidence with the potential for benefit and harm. Strength of recommendation indicates the level of endorsement of the statement by the panel of experts.

Page 32: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: CRS (2 of 3)Summary of Guideline Statements: CRS (2 of 3)

Page 33: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Summary of Guideline Statements: CRS (3 of 3)Summary of Guideline Statements: CRS (3 of 3)

Page 34: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Acute Bacterial RhinosinusitisAcute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis

Page 35: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Definition and DiagnosisABRS: Definition and Diagnosis

•ABRS is a bacterial infection of the paranasal sinuses characterized by:– Sudden onset of symptomatic sinus infection– Symptom duration > 7 days– Length of episode < 4 weeks– Major symptoms (PODS)

• Facial Pain/Pressure/fullness• Nasal Obstruction• Nasal purulence/discoloured postnasal Discharge• Hyposmia/anosmia (Smell)

•Diagnosis requires the presence of > 2 PODS, one of which is either O or D and symptom duration of > 7 days without improvement.

Page 36: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Diagnosis (cont’d)ABRS: Diagnosis (cont’d)

•Diagnosis is based on history and physical examination:– Sinus aspirates or routine nasal culture are not recommended– Radiological imaging is not required for uncomplicated ABRS– Because complications of ABRS can elicit a medical emergency,

individuals with suspected complications should be urgently referred for specialist care

•Red flags for urgent referral include:– Systemic toxicity– Altered mental status– Severe headache– Swelling of the orbit or change in visual acuity

Page 37: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: MicrobiologyABRS: Microbiology

•Main causative bacteria:– Streptococcus pneumoniae– Haemophilus influenzae

•Minor causative bacteria:– Moraxella catarrhalis– Streptococcus pyogenes– Staphylococcus aureus– Gram-negative bacilli– Oral anaerobes

Page 38: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Role of AntibioticsABRS: Role of Antibiotics

•Antibiotics may be prescribed to improve rates of symptom resolution– Overall response rates are similar for antibiotic-treated and

untreated individuals

•Goal of treatment is to relieve symptoms by:– Controlling infection– Decreasing tissue edema– Reversing sinus ostial obstruction to allow drainage of pus

•Antibiotics should be considered for individuals:– With severe sinusitis or comorbidities– Where quality of life or productivity are issues

•Incidence of side effect mainly digestive, increases with antibiotic administration

Page 39: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Implications of Antibiotic ResistanceABRS: Implications of Antibiotic Resistance

•There are increasing rates of antibiotic resistance– Penicillin- macrolide- and multi-drug resistant– S. pneumoniae in community-acquired respiratory tract infections

•Be cognizant of local patterns of antibiotic resistance as regional variations exist

•Medical history influences treatment choice

•Identify patients at increased risk of bacterial resistance and complications– Those with underlying disease (eg diabetes, chronic renal failure,

immune deficiency)– Those with underlying systemic disorders

Page 40: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Considerations for Choosing an AntibioticABRS: Considerations for Choosing an Antibiotic

•Suspected or confirmed etiology

•Medical history

•Presence of complications

•Canadian patterns of antimicrobial resistance– Regional variations

•Risk of bacterial resistance

•Tolerability

•Convenience

•Cost

Page 41: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Antibiotic ConsiderationsABRS: Antibiotic Considerations

•Factors suggesting greater risk of penicillin- and macrolide-resistant streptococci

– Antibiotic use within the past 3 months• Choose an alternative class of antibiotic from that used in the

past 3 months– Chronic symptoms greater than 4 weeks– Parents of children in daycare

•When prescribed, antibiotics should be taken for 5-10 days as recommended by the product monograph

– Improvement in symptoms without complete disappearance of symptoms at the end of therapy should be expected and should not cause an immediate prescription of a second antibiotic

Page 42: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Choice of AntibioticABRS: Choice of Antibiotic

•First-line: amoxicillin– In beta-lactam allergy, TMP/SMX or macrolide

•Second-line: amoxicillin/clavulanic acid combination, or quinolones with enhanced gram positive activity

– For use where first-line therapy failed (no clinical response within 72 hours), risk of bacterial resistance is high, or where consequences of therapy failure are greatest (i.e. because of underlying systemic disease)

•For uncomplicated ABRS in otherwise healthy adults, antibiotics show comparable efficacy

Page 43: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: INCS as MonotherapyABRS: INCS as Monotherapy

•INCS may be explored based on limited evidence suggesting benefit– Promote drainage and reduce mucosal swelling

• Hasten resolution of sinus episode and clearance of infectious organisms

•No increased incidence of complications

Page 44: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: First-line Treatment FailureABRS: First-line Treatment Failure

•If symptoms do not at least partially attenuate by 72 hours after INCS administration– Administer antibiotic therapy

•If symptoms do not at least partially attenuate by 72 hours after antibiotic therapy– Bacterial resistance should be considered, and – Antibiotic class should be changed

• Switch to a second-line antibiotic (e.g. moxifloxacin or amoxicillin/clavulanic acid combination)

• In the case of a second-line failure, switch to another antibiotic class

Page 45: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Adjunct TherapyABRS: Adjunct Therapy

•Adjunct therapy may provide symptom relief and should be prescribed in individuals with ABRS:– Topical intranasal corticosteroids (INCS)– Analgesics (acetaminophen or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agents)– Oral decongestants– Topical decongestants– Saline irrigation

Page 46: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ABRS: Prevention and Contributing FactorsABRS: Prevention and Contributing Factors

•Prevention strategies aim to reduce the risk of acute viral infection (common precursor to ABRS)

– Techniques• Handwashing• Educating patients on common predisposing factors

•For patients with recurrent episodes of ABRS, consider underlying contributing factors

– Allergy testing to detect allergic rhinitis– In-depth assessment of immune function to detect immune deficiencies

Page 47: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Chronic RhinosinusitisChronic Rhinosinusitis

Page 48: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: DefinitionCRS: Definition

•CRS is an inflammatory disease involving the nasal mucosa and paranasal sinuses

– Symptoms are usually of lesser intensity than those of ABRS– Length of episode > 4 weeks

•Impact on patients– Significant bodily pain and impaired social functioning– Quality of life is comparable in severity to that of other chronic

conditions– As a chronic condition, CRS should be proactively managed

Page 49: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: PathophysiologyCRS: Pathophysiology

•Unclear origin, but contributors may include:– Bacterial colonization– Bacterial biofilms– Eosinophilic, neutrophilic, and lymphocytic infiltrations– Upregulation of the Th2-associated cytokines– Tissue Remodeling

• Epithelial changes• Increased extracellular matrix proteins• Growth factors• Profibrotic cytokines

•Atopy determines allergic vs. nonallergic classification

Page 50: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: BacteriologyCRS: Bacteriology

•Bacteriology differs from ABRS

•Not well understood

•Main pathogens– S aureus– Enterobacteriaceae spp– Pseudomonas spp

•Less common pathogens– S pneumoniae– H influenzae– Beta hemolytic streptococci– Coagulase-negative Staphylococci (CNS)

Page 51: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: DiagnosisCRS: Diagnosis

•Required > 2 major symptoms be present for > 8-12 weeks, plus documented inflammation of the paranasal sinuses or nasal mucosa

•Major symptoms:– Facial Congestion/ fullness– Facial Pain/ pressure/ fullness– Nasal Obstruction/ blockage– Purulent anterior/ posterior nasal Drainage (may be nonpurulent

nondiscoloured)– Hyposmia/ anosmia (Smell)

•Inflammation documented by endoscopy /CT

Page 52: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: SubtypesCRS: Subtypes

CRSwN

Characterized by:– Mucopurulent drainage– Nasal obstruction– Hyposmia

Diagnosis requires:– At least 2 major symptoms– Bilateral polyps in the middle

meatus (endoscopy)– Bilateral mucosal disease

(CT scan)

CRSsNP

Characterized by:– Mucopurulent drainage– Nasal obstruction– Facial pain/ pressure/ fullness

Diagnosis requires:– At least 2 major symptoms– Inflammation (endoscopy)– Absence of polyps

(endoscopy)– Purulence from osteomeatal

complex (endoscopy) or rhinosinusitis (CT scan)

Page 53: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Visual AssessmentsCRS: Visual Assessments

•Physical examination of the nasal cavity using:– Headlight and nasal speculum– Otoscope

•In the nasal septum:– Identify drying crusts, ulceration, bleeding ulceration, and perforation,

anatomic obstructions, unusual aspects of the nasal mucosa and/or presence of secretions or nasal masses

– Note significant septal deflections, colour of the nasal mucosa and presence of dryness or hypersecretion• Normal mucosa is pinkish-orange with a slight sheen demonstrating

hydration– Presence of an irregular surface, crusts, diffusely hemorrhagic areas,

vascular malformations or ectasias, or bleeding in response to minimal

trauma, is abnormal and should warrant specialist assessment

Page 54: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Visual Assessments (Cont’d)CRS: Visual Assessments (Cont’d)

•In the inferior turbinates– Assess for hypertrophy

•In the middle meatal area– Inspect the area of the middle turbinate and the middle meatus

adjacent between the septum and the lateral nasal wall for the presence of secretions or masses (e.g. nasal polyps)

– Visualization may be improved by performing• Vasoconstriction using a decongestant product (e.g. Dristan®

or Otrivin®)• Sinonasal endoscopy

Page 55: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Specialist ReferralCRS: Specialist Referral

•Referral to a specialist is warranted when a patient:– Fails > 1 course of maximal medical therapy or,– Has > 3 sinus infections per year

•URGENT consultation with otolaryngologist required if patient:– Has severe symptoms of pain/ swelling of the sinus areas or,– Is immunosuppressed

•Allergy testing– Identify allergic components that might respond to allergy

treatment ( e.g. avoiding environmental triggers, or taking appropriate pharmacotherapy or immunotherapy)

•Immune function testing– Not required in uncomplicated cases– May be appropriate for patients with resistant CRS

Page 56: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Environmental FactorsCRS: Environmental Factors

•Both environmental and physiologic factors that can predispose to, or be associated with CRS– Allergic rhinitis– Asthma– Ciliary dysfunction– Immune dysfunction– Aspirin-exacerbated respiratory disease– Defective mucociliary clearance– Lost ostia patency– Cystic fibrosis

Page 57: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: General Management StrategiesCRS: General Management Strategies

•Identify and address contributing or predisposing factors

•Oral or topical steroids with or without antibiotics– Antibiotic therapy should be broader spectrum than for ABRS

• Empiric therapy should target enteric Gram-negative organisms, S aureus and anaerobic in addition to the most common encapsulated organisms associated with an ABRS (S pneumoniae, H influenzae, M catarrhalis)

– Antibiotic therapy duration tends to be slightly longer than for ABRS

Page 58: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Initial Management is MedicalCRS: Initial Management is Medical

•In the absence of complication or severe illness– CRSsNP: nasal or oral corticosteroid and oral antibiotics– CRSwNP: topical intranasal steroids and short courses of

oral steroids• Simultaneous oral antibiotic therapy indicated only in the

presence of symptoms suggestion infection (e.g. pain or recurrent episodes of sinusitis, or when purulence is documented on rhinoscopy/endoscopy

Page 59: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRSsNP: TreatmentCRSsNP: Treatment

•INCS should be prescribed for all patients– Benefits include addressing the inflammatory component of CRS

•Antibiotics with or without a short course of oral steroids should be prescribed at the initiation of therapy

•Ancillary measures such as saline irrigation my be of help

•A short course of oral corticosteroids my be required for more severe symptoms or persistent disease

Page 60: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRSwNP: TreatmentCRSwNP: Treatment

•INCS are the mainstay of therapy– Benefits include

• Addressing the inflammatory component of CRS• Relieving nasal congestion• Shrinking nasal polyps

•A short course of oral steroids may be prescribed in symptomatic subjects– A 2-week course of prednisone may reduce polyp size in patients

unresponsive to INCS– Leukotriene receptor antagonists may warrant a trial especially in

patients with ASA sensitivity– Combined therapy with empiric or culture-directed antibiotics are

indicated in the presence of symptoms suggestion infection

Page 61: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Adjunct TherapiesCRS: Adjunct Therapies

•Approaches with consistent evidence of benefiting symptoms– Saline irrigation

•Approaches with limited evidence of benefiting symptoms– Mucolytics– Antihistamines– Leukotriene modifiers

Page 62: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Alternate DiagnosisCRS: Alternate Diagnosis

•Failure of response should prompt consideration of other possible or contributing diagnoses– Allergic fungal rhinosinusitis– Allergic rhinitis– Atypical facial pain– Invasive fungal rhinosinusitis– Migraine or other headache diagnosis– Nasal septal deformation– Nonallergic rhinitis– Temporomandibular joint dysfunction (TMG)– Trigeminal neuralgia– Vasomotor rhinitis

Page 63: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (ESS)CRS: Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (ESS)

•Indicated for patients who fail maximal medical therapy

•Provide specialist referral for assessment of disease

•The goals of ESS are to:– Clear diseased mucosa– Relieve obstruction– Restore ventilation

Page 64: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CRS: Post-surgical Follow-upCRS: Post-surgical Follow-up

•Immediate postoperative care involves antibiotics, topical/oral corticosteroids and saline irrigation

•Monitor patient for severe symptoms of pain, fever, or new-onset coloured secretions– Immediately refer to operating surgeon

•Continued care includes nasal saline irrigation and INCS with limited evidence

•CRS patients with high peripheral eosinophil counts, asthma, or mucosal eosinophil CRS should be followed closely and may require long-term treatment with anti-inflammatory agents (steroids)

Page 65: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Guidelines for the Management of ABRS and CRS

ABRS Algorithm

Guidelines for the Management of ABRS and CRS

ABRS Algorithm

Page 66: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Management of ABRS (1 of 2)Management of ABRS (1 of 2)

Page 67: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Management of ABRS (2 of 2)Management of ABRS (2 of 2)

Page 68: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Guidelines for the Management of ABRS and CRS

Chronic Rhinosinusitis Algorithm

Guidelines for the Management of ABRS and CRS

Chronic Rhinosinusitis Algorithm

Page 69: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Management of CRS (1 of 2)Management of CRS (1 of 2)

Page 70: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Management of CRS (2 of 2)Management of CRS (2 of 2)

Page 71: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Case Studies in RhinosinusitisCase Studies in Rhinosinusitis

Page 72: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Case 1: Uncomplicated Acute Bacterial RhinosinusitisCase 1: Uncomplicated Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis

•Previously healthy 32-year-old non-smoking mother

•Recent onset of symptoms of an upper respiratory tract infection (URTI)– Persistent nasal obstruction– Right-sided maxillary facial pain– Yellowish secretions

•Have all lasted 9 days from the outset

•Has not responded to over-the-counter medication

Page 73: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Nasal Examination: PurulenceNasal Examination: Purulence

Page 74: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

AssessmentAssessment

•This case suggests bacterial rhinosinusitis

•The presence of several typical symptoms accompanied by duration of symptoms for greater than 7 days, strongly supports this diagnosis

•Given the weight of evidence in favour of the clinical diagnosis of bacterial sinusitis, no x-ray is required to confirm diagnosis

•Symptom intensity is mild to moderate and there are no signs of local complications or of systemic toxicity

Page 75: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ManagementManagement

•Uncomplicated episode of bacterial sinusitis

•Symptoms are mild to moderate only– Therapy with an antibiotic is not mandatory

•Options for management include– Continuing her topical saline– Oral or topical decongestants– Analgesia for pain– Use of mometasone furoate

Page 76: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Are Antibiotics Required?Are Antibiotics Required?

•If INCS are not efficacious– Amoxicillin 500 mg TID– Macrolide for penicillin-allergy

•Symptoms are expected to improve, but not to resolve completely, within 72 hours

Page 77: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Second-line Therapy?Second-line Therapy?

•Risk factors for immunosuppression

•Symptoms suggesting frontal or sphenoid sinusitis

•Presence of risk factors for antibiotic resistance– Previous antibiotic < 3 months– Day care exposure– Failure of first-line antibiotic

•Initial therapy with a second-line antibiotic– Amoxicillin/ clavulanic acid 875 mg BID x 10-14 d– Moxifloxacin 400 mg QD x 10-14 d

Page 78: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Follow-upFollow-up

•Symptoms are expected to improve, but not to resolve completely within 72 hours of initiation of therapy

•As she is expected to have a complete recovery, follow up is only necessary if she has either– no improvement of symptoms after 72h, or– aggravation of symptoms

•If so,– assess for development of complications– initiate first- or second-line antibiotic depending on initial treatment

Page 79: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Case in Chronic RhinosinusitisCase in Chronic Rhinosinusitis

•46 year-old male

•9-month history of fluctuating symptoms– Nasal obstruction– Facial pain in a mask-like distribution– Occasional cough– Intermittent postnasal drip

•Symptoms fluctuate over time

•3-times yearly become sufficiently severe for a diagnosis of acute sinusitis, and an antibiotic administered

•Medical history is otherwise significant only for penicillin allergy

•Physical examination is noncontributory

Page 80: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Case in CRS with Nasal PolyposisCase in CRS with Nasal Polyposis

•45-year-old male patient

•Consults for nasal obstruction that has been increasing over the past 18 months

•Treated in the past for sinusitis

•Currently pain free, but has intermittent yellowish anterior nasal discharge present

•Review of symptoms– No shortness of breath or episodes of wheezing– Has received a salbutanol inhaler for a lingering cough

•Admits to be anosmic

•Nasal examination: Pale grayish masses present in the middle meatus bilaterally

Page 81: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CT of the Sinus: Pan SinusitisCT of the Sinus: Pan Sinusitis

Page 82: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Questions?Questions?

Page 83: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Additional Resources

Sinusitis in General

Additional Resources

Sinusitis in General

Page 84: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Estimated Number of Cases of Rhinosinusitis Incidence of Rhinosinusitis in Core EU CountriesEstimated Number of Cases of Rhinosinusitis Incidence of Rhinosinusitis in Core EU Countries

Page 85: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Health Care Utilization & Work Time MissedHealth Care Utilization & Work Time Missed

Page 86: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Implications of Antibiotic ResistanceImplications of Antibiotic Resistance

•Increased risk for delayed or inappropriate therapy

•Increase in clinical failures

•Increased morbidity and mortality

•Estimates of unnecessary cost of resistance per year* (US) vary – $4 - 6 billion– $100 million - $60 billion

*Adjusted for inflation at 3% per year

Saravolatz LD, et al. Ann Intern Med. 1982;96:11-6; ASM. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1995;(Suppl.):1-23; Phelps CE, et al. Med Care.1989;27:194-203

Page 87: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Antimicrobial ResistanceAntimicrobial Resistance

•Do physicians contribute to the development of antibiotic resistance?

•Can we help reduce antibiotic resistance?

Page 88: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Percentage of Penicillin Non-susceptibleS. pneumoniae in Canada: 1988-2008Percentage of Penicillin Non-susceptibleS. pneumoniae in Canada: 1988-2008

Page 89: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Macrolide-resistant Pneumococci: Canadian Bacterial Surveillance Network, 1988-2008Macrolide-resistant Pneumococci: Canadian Bacterial Surveillance Network, 1988-2008

Page 90: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Rates of Penicillin and Amoxicillin Resistance Canada: 1988-2008Rates of Penicillin and Amoxicillin Resistance Canada: 1988-2008

Page 91: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Antimicrobial Use and Resistance by Country (European Surveillance of Antimicrobial Consumption Project)

Antimicrobial Use and Resistance by Country (European Surveillance of Antimicrobial Consumption Project)

Page 92: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Antimicrobial Use and Resistance by Country (European Surveillance of Antimicrobial Consumption Project)

Antimicrobial Use and Resistance by Country (European Surveillance of Antimicrobial Consumption Project)

Page 93: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Nasal Examination: TechniqueSymptom Duration: 8-12 weeksNasal Examination: TechniqueSymptom Duration: 8-12 weeks

Middle turbinateMiddle meatus

SeptumInferior turbinate

Nasal airwayInferior meatus

Floor of nose

For examination of the left side: index finger should rest on the tip of the nose.

For examination of the right side: index finger should rest on the cheek.

Page 94: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Visualizing the Middle Meatus: Key To Sinus DiseaseVisualizing the Middle Meatus: Key To Sinus Disease

Page 95: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Complications of Acute SinusitisComplications of Acute Sinusitis

•Orbital complications– Preseptal cellulitis– Abscess– Phlegmona– Blindness

•Cerebral complications– Meningitis– Extadural abscess– Intradural abscess

•Osteomyelitis

Page 96: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

ComplicationsComplications

Page 97: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Nasal PolyposisNasal Polyposis

•Prevalence: 2 - 4%, increase > 40 years

•26 - 30% asthma

•Asthma: 7 - 15% nasal polyposis

•Nasal obstruction, reduced sense of smell

Larsen K. Allergy Asthma Proc. 1996;17:243-9. Johansson L et al. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2003;112:625-9. Demoly et al. Allergy 2003:58:233-238.Fokkens et al. Rhinol Suppl, 2007(20): 1-136.

Page 98: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

CT of the Sinus: NormalCT of the Sinus: Normal

Page 99: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Impact of INCS on CRS after ESSImpact of INCS on CRS after ESS

• Pre-op use of INCS associated with decreased rate of bacterial recovery at

ESS– Effect most pronounced for revision

cases, mainly for staphylococcal species– Corticosteroid may penetrate

sinus cavities better after ESS

• In individuals consulting for CRS persisting after surgical therapy, 61% had a

favourable response to irrigation with corticosteroid / saline solution

Desrosiers M, Hussain A, Frenkiel S, Kilty S, Marsan J, Witterick I, Wright E. Intranasal corticosteroid use is associated with lower rates of bacterial recovery in chronic rhinosinusitis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2007;136:605-9.

Nader ME, Abou-Jaoude P, Cabaluna M, Desrosiers M. Using response to a standardized treatment to identify phenotypes for genetic studies of chronic rhinosinusitis. J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010;39:69-75.

Page 100: SINUSITIS: What the Primary Care Practitioner Should Do in 2011: A Review of New Canadian Guidelines Martin Desrosiers, MD FRCSC Project Lead: Canadian

Prevalence of Erythromycin Resistance Among Pneumococci by Prior Macrolide UsePrevalence of Erythromycin Resistance Among Pneumococci by Prior Macrolide Use