simple shearing and ploughing cutting force model in turning operation with nose radius tool
DESCRIPTION
Simple semi-empirical approach to the modelling of cutting force, which is based on the shearing and ploughing theory is presented.TRANSCRIPT
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 1/17
University of RijekaFaculty of Engineering
Authors: Graciela Šterpin,
Zoran Jurković,Miran Brezočnik
15th International Scientific Conference on Production Engineering CIM 2015
June 10 ‐ 13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 2/17
,
shearing and ploughing model,
turning
2
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 3/17
1. INTRODUCTION
Cutting force is affected by: the tool edge geometry,tool wear rate,
cutting temperature and
cutting parameters.
Analytical models can be very complex in order to reach good accuracy in
representing the effective cutting mechanics.
The pure empirical models are more frequent than the analytical ones:
- e compu er a e s a s ca es gn o exper men me o o ogy n par cu ar
regression analysis),
- computational neural network,
- .
However, pure empirical approach is both time and cost consuming.
One of the most applied techniques in cutting force modelling
3
Mechanistic or semi-empirical approach, mainly the shearing and ploughing modelCIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 4/17
1. INTRODUCTION
The specific cutting force k s
-k cs and k cp - shearing and ploughing coefficientsh
k A
k cp
csc
s
The main cutting force F c
Lk Ak F cpcsc
The shearing term The ploughing term
4
A - uncut chip areaL - length of the cutting edge engaged in the workpiece
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 5/17
1. INTRODUCTION
The shearing term The ploughing term
The effect of the chip pressure on The friction between the flank of,
uncut chip area
surface, proportional to theengaged cutting edge length
n e con rary o ana y ca cu ng orce mo e s, e s ear ng an p oug ng
model considers the changing of tool edge geometry due to tool wear. However,
this phenomenon is beyond the scope of presented research.
5
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 6/17
2. CUTTING FORCE MODEL
ISO 3685 limits the maximum feed to 80% of the tool nose radius (i.e. f ≤ 0,8 r ε )
so that the end (or minor) cutting edge cannot be engaged in cutting.
There are two possible cases in practice:
–. p ε r
The uncut chip area can be divided into region (I) with curved cutting edge and
.
An ular limits:
ε r
f ζ
2arccos
1
6
κ r - approach angle
r κ ζ 902
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 7/17
2. CUTTING FORCE MODEL
The shearing and ploughing cutting force model is based on the assumption that
the resultant cutting force acting on the tool in region (I) is a sum of i = 1, 2, ..., N
.ˆddd
,ˆddd
l k Ak F
l k ζ Ak F cpi csci Local angle ζ i :
N
ζ ζ i ζ ζ i
121
The infinitesimal uncut chip area
d A(ζ ): product of the local uncut
After projection along the radial,
tangential and axial directions itcan be obtained:
chip thickness h(ζ i ) and theinfinitesimal cutting edge length
N
i
ci c y F F F
1
)I()I( ,dl d
i i
i ε i ε i ζ f r ζ f r ζ h 222 sincos
N
N
i
i r ni f z ζ κ F F F
1
)I()I( ,sind
7
d 12 π ζ ζ
r l ε
i
i r ni p x ζ κ F F F
1
)I()I( ,cosd
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
F p
- back forceF f - feed force
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 8/17
2. CUTTING FORCE MODEL
Local approach angle κ r (ζ i ): Region (II) derived geometry:
1 90i i r ζ ζ κ
r r ε p4
)II(
κ r al cos11 r κ s n
Cutting force components:
,sin
,
)II()II()II()II(
)II()II()II()II(
r npnsf z
cpcsc y
κ l k Ak F F
l k Ak F F
.cos)II()II()II()II( r npns p x κ l k Ak F F
8
, ,generated in regions (I) and (II):
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
qqq ,,,
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 9/17
2. CUTTING FORCE MODEL
Case 2. Cutting conditions: a p ≤ r ε (1 – cos κ r )
The uncut chip area for this case is again divided into two regions.
f aar
ar ζ
p pε
pε
22
2
arctan180
9ε
pε
r
ar ζ
arcsin1803
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
22)II( tan
2
ζ ζ h A
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 10/17
2. CUTTING FORCE MODEL
For a given k s, shearing and ploughing coefficients are usually located in the
following intervals:
,2,08,0 scs k k
,35,06,0
,04,005,0
,,,
npcp
csnp
csns
k k
k k
where the actual values ma in eneral de end on the local eometr of
cutting edge cross section (normal rake angle γ n, inclination angle λs, tool nose
radius r ε and other details) and on the actual thermo-mechanical conditions at
the chip.
10
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 11/17
3. EXPERIMENTAL VALIDATION
The instantaneous cutting forces predicted by the model have beencompared to cutting force signals measured during the turning operation.
The laboratory experiments:
The laboratory experiments
-"Georg Fisher NDM-16" lathe
-KISTLER 9257A dynamometer
-instantaneous cutting forces F c , F f and F p-were measured during the turning
-operation
-LabVIEW software
-wor p ece ma er a : an e
-SPK-DDJNL 3225P15 tool holder with the
-Sandvik Coromant DNMG 150608 PM4025
11
- -tool geometry
γ n λs κ r r ε
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
17 -8 93 0,8 mm
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 12/17
3. EXPERIMENTAL VALIDATION
The feed and the depth of cut were varied in order to compare the experimentaland estimated cutting forces on a larger variety of conditions.
Experimental results and model validation
Cutting parametersDynamometer
forcesEstimated forces Percentage error
v c m/min f mm a p
mm F c N F f N F pN F c
N F f N F pN F c % F f % F p%
1. 400 0,10 0,8 222,2 102,0 123,3 190,5 106,3 93,5 14,26 -4,19 24,22
2. 400 0,15 0,8 306,0 131,8 163,3 273,9 130,7 113,0 10,50 0,84 30,76
3. 400 0,20 0,8 372,7 156,2 199,9 361,6 155,6 134,2 2,97 0,42 32,89
4. 400 0,10 1,2 337,9 191,1 149,8 274,8 164,8 90,5 18,67 13,76 39,59
5. 400 0,15 1,2 435,6 208,5 171,7 394,9 203,9 109,3 9,34 2,24 36,32
6. 400 0,20 1,2 492,9 203,6 186,0 519,7 243,6 129,7 -5,42 -19,65 30,27
, - , ,
Analytical cutting forces were calculated by applying the model coefficients,
which were estimated in [3] and are similar to values reported in other
12
Coefficient Value
k cs 1809 N/mm2
publications and technical reports for Ck45.
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
k cp 28,47 N/mm
k Ns 723,1 N/mm2
k Np 73,51 N/mm
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 13/17
3. EXPERIMENTAL VALIDATION
There is a good agreement between the
experimental and predicted cutting force
.
Back force F p -considerably underestimated
The current model coefficients are not
ade uate for re resentin all the force
components at the same time with good
accuracy.
13
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
Predicted vs. measured forces
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 14/17
4. CONCLUSION
A simple semi-empirical approach to the modelling of cutting force, which is
based on the shearing and ploughing theory, is proposed and experimentally
validated for a turning operation.
Estimated cutting force components have been compared to measured onesand their good agreement was observed.
The comparison between the predicted and measured cutting force components
ver y e mo e rea ness or e cu ng orce es ma ons ur ng a rea urn ng
operation.
ur er n eres : o nc u e e n uence o oo wear n e presen e mo e .
14
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 15/17
5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
University of Rijeka, Croatia, contract. . . . .
15
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 16/17
REFERENCES
[1] Prosperi, F., 2014, Manufacturing of high precision mechanical
components, Doctorate Thesis, University of Udine.
, ., ,
Mechanics, Machine Tool Vibrations, and CNC Design,
Cambridge University Press., ., , ., , ., , ., ,
of cutting forces and cutting conditions in complex turning
operations, 12th International Scientific Conference on
-, , . .
[4] Totis, G., Sortino, M., 2011, Development of a modular dynamometer for triaxial cutting force measurement in turning,
International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture, Vol. 51,
pp. 34-42.
[5] ISO Standard 3685, 1993, Tool Life Testing with Single-Point
Turning Tools, pp. 1-48.
16
[6] Totis, G., Sortino, M., 2014, Robust Analysis of Stability in
Internal Turning, Procedia Engineering, Vol. 69, pp. 1306-1315.
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia
7/21/2019 Simple Shearing and Ploughing Cutting Force Model In Turning Operation with Nose Radius Tool
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/simple-shearing-and-ploughing-cutting-force-model-in-turning-operation-with 17/17
Thank you for your attention!!!
17
CIM 2015, June 10‐13, 2015, Vodice, Croatia