short fire run - fpa australiashort fire run › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular...

29
All slides © Copyright FPA Australia SHORT FIRE RUN ASSESSING BUSH FIRE RISK FROM SMALL AREAS OF VEGETATION John Delany and Stuart Matthews Community Resilience New South Wales Rural Fire Service

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jan-2020

49 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNASSESSING BUSH FIRE RISK FROM SMALL AREAS OF VEGETATION

John Delany and Stuart MatthewsCommunity Resilience

New South Wales Rural Fire Service

Page 2: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

To provide a robust methodology that identifies

the bush fire impact of lower risk bush fires

burning on the bushland interface.

Intent …

Page 3: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

1. the difference between a Short Fire Run (SFR) and a Fully Developed Fire (FDF)?

2. a deterministic model to ‘factor down’ APZ’s based on thelower risk provided by a partially developed bush fire.

To address the intent we need to identify …

Page 4: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

SFR’s are currently assessed as if they are;• large scale hazards;• have the existing vegetation downgraded to rain forest (lower fuel

load); or• by ‘expert’ judgement.

‘These practices can result in onerous bush fire protection measures and lead to inconsistent treatments’’.

Issues …

Page 5: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNWhat is a SFR …

Aerial picture not to scale and indicative only

Page 6: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNA SFR is …

Aerial picture not to scale and indicative only

Page 7: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNA SFR is …

Aerial picture not to scale and indicative only

Page 8: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNA SFR is …

Aerial picture not to scale and indicative only

Page 9: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNA SFR is not …

Aerial picture not to scale and indicative only

Has connectivity to vegetation that will support a FDF.

Page 10: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

For the purposes of modelling, a SFR is …› a small low risk fire not expected to crown (usually taken as not

exceeding a fire run of 150 metres and burning perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset).

› a small low risk fire having a calculated maximum head width not exceeding 100 metres;

› on downslope not exceeding 30 degrees;› on site slope not exceeding 20 degrees;› on up slope not exceeding 15 degrees;

How is SFR assessed …

Page 11: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

For development application purposes a SFR is considered to be a performance evaluation and as such site specifics need to be identified to model the design fire …

1. Assess site as per requirements of AS3959 Method 2 steps 1 > 5;

2. Calculate SFR flame height using Project Vesta methodology;

3. Calculate the SFR head width;

4. Calculate SFR radiation (kWm2);

How is SFR assessed … cont’d

Page 12: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

5. Calculate Bush Fire Attack Level (BAL).6. Apply appropriate construction requirements to mitigate the

calculated bush fire impact.

Note:2 models have been developed;

• Forest / Woodland developed using MacArthur 1973 and Noble et al. 1980 and Project Vesta.

• Heath – developed using Byram’s equation (Heath and Shrub Model).

How is SFR assessed … cont’d

Page 13: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR fire growth …

Point of origin

Wind direction

Downslope

Page 14: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR fire growth …

Wind direction

Downslope

Page 15: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR fire growth …

Wind direction

Downslope

Page 16: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR fire growth …

Wind direction

Downslope

Page 17: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR fire growth …

Wind direction

Downslope

Page 18: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR fire growth …

Wind direction

Measuredfire run

Site slope

CalculatedHead Width

Page 19: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

The SFR model has the following limitations and assumptions.

› wind direction and speed is constant in the direction of fire spread;› slope is considered uniform throughout the length of the fire run;› flaming is restricted to surface, near surface and elevated fuels only

for forest & woodland vegetation;› Heath, Shrub, Mallee & Tussock Moorland formations. Average

height is determined on site and by vegetation classification;

SFR limitations and assumptions …

Page 20: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

› fuel load is distributed equally and is continuous for the entire fire run length;

› The fire develops from a single ignition point and does not include ignition time, fire growth or fuel moisture;

› The fire is not expected to crown;

SFR limitations and assumptions … cont’d

Page 21: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

› calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity.

› limited to 150 metre fire run length (measured on the effective slope);

› limited to maximum input of 2 metres for elevated fuel (Project Vesta) in forest formations only.

SFR limitations and assumptions … cont’d

Page 22: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSFR development …

The size and shape of a bush fire hazard influences the behaviour of bush fire and the associated risk to the built environment.

Page 23: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNFire shape development…

Simple elliptical fire growth model (Van Wagner 1969).

Page 24: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNFire shape development…

RFS has adopted a wind speed of 30 kph for assessing SFR design fires

Page 25: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNFire shape development…

Speculative Head Width= 2/3rd of ellipse breadth

Page 26: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNBushfire fuel structure (Forest) … is presented in 3 tiers

Drawing courtesy ‘DSE Overall fuel Hazard guide’ 4th edition.

High

Medium

Low

2 metresmax. for Project Vesta

Page 27: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUNSurface, near surface & elevated fuel loads (Project Vesta) …

An additional input is required for fuel height. Those inputs represent the height value for the three fuel structure forms, surface, near surface & elevated fuels with a further sub classification of tall, medium and low being identified for each tier.

That is:Three defined fuel tiers;

• Surface (Low) = 0 - <0.9 metres;• Near surface (Medium ) = >0.9 - <1.4 metres• Elevated (Tall) = >1.4 – 2.0 metres

Page 28: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

• The SFR Methodology provides a more appropriate determination of the bush fire impact of lower risk vegetation located on the bushland interface.

• The SFR Methodology represents a combination of existing science and new data.

• This results in a more appropriate fire protection based on hazard.

Conclusion …

Page 29: SHORT FIRE RUN - FPA AustraliaSHORT FIRE RUN › calculated where the fire is running perpendicular to contours and directly at an asset whilst also not having direct connectivity

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SHORT FIRE RUN

Thank you …

QUESTIONS?