seminar on director’s duties and liabilities issues...
TRANSCRIPT
Ean Mac Pherson 13 April 2007Baker & McKenzie GJBJ Tokyo Aoyama Aoki Koma Law Office (Gaikokuho Joint Enterprise) is a member of Baker & McKenzie International, a Swiss Verein with member law firms around the world. In accordance with the common terminology used in professional service organizations, reference to a “partner” means a person who is a partner, or equivalent, in such a law firm. Similarly,reference to an “office” means an office of any such law firm.
Seminar on Director’s Duties and Liabilities Issues for Japanese companies investing overseas
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 2
Table of contents1. Case Study – Hollinger International2. What is a Fiduciary Duty?3. Who are the Directors?4. Who do the Directors owe duties to?5. What are the main Duties?6. Nominee Directors7. Criminal Penalties8. Listed Company Issues
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 3
Case study - Hollinger International
• Global media company• Owner of London Daily
Telegraph & Chicago Sun Times• Conrad Black – Chairman, CEO &
Shareholder• Listed on New York Stock Exchange
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 4
Hollinger International Inc.
(Delaware Company listed on New York Stock Exchange)
Hollinger Inc.(Listed on Toronto Stock Exchange)
20% + B Class Voting Shares
RavelstonCorporation
70%
The Hollinger Structure Conrad Black
65%
Project Companies A B C D Buyer
Sale of Business
CEO - Conrad Black
CEO - Conrad Black
Non Competition Payment
Non Competition Payment
Non Competition PaymentCEO - Conrad Black
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 6
The Allegations
US District Court Case alleging Conrad Black breached his Fiduciary duties to Hollinger International, including:
• Duty of loyalty• Duty to maximize transaction benefits to Hollinger• Duty to refrain from acting to Hollinger’s detriment• Duty to disclose Related Party Transactions• Duty to refrain from making false or fraudulently
misleading statements
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 7
The Penalties
If convicted Mr Black may face:• Imprisonment• Fines• Forfeiture of his property
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 8
Japanese Companies’ Perspective
Directors appointed by Japanese Companies unlikely to need to make decisions about private jet tripsbutSuch Directors may have to balance and/or choose between competing interests relating to their position as Directors
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 9
Common Issues for Japanese appointed Directors
1. Problems in 100% owned overseas subsidiaries of Japanese Companies
2. Problems in Joint Venture Companies
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 10
Comparison of Director duties in different countries
Directors must report to board or shareholders meeting if they intend to transact with the Company
Directors have a duty of loyalty (i.e. to operate the Company without regard for personal interests)
Directors’ duties and personal interest must not conflict with those of the Company
Directors must not have conflicts between their own interests and Company’s interests
Directors must not seize corporate opportunities for themselves
Director must not take part in transactions that are in competition with the Company
Directors must not misuse position for own benefit
Directors must perform their duties faithfully for the benefit of the Company
Directors have a duty of care to the Company
Directors must apply the diligence of a careful businessman
Directors must act honestly and with care and diligence
JapanUnited States(Delaware)
Thailand (Private Company)
Australia
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 11
What is a Fiduciary Duty? (忠実義務)
• Duty to act with loyalty and trust to the other person
• Duty to put the interests of the other person above the fiduciary’s own interests
• The duty arises when you are in a position of special trust or power over another person
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 12
Examples of Fiduciary Relationships
• Trustee/Beneficiary• Partner/Partner• Lawyer/Client• Agent/Principal• Doctor/Patient• Director/Company
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 13
Who are the Directors?• Executive/Non-executive Directors• Alternate Directors• Shadow Directors• Generally no distinction between full
time and part time Directors
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 14
To whom are Director duties owed?
• Directors owe their obligations to the Company• The “Company” means the shareholders (and
sometimes future shareholders) • Directors do not owe fiduciary duties to
employees or to society at large• Generally no duty to creditors but their interests
should be considered (especially if Company is near insolvency)
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 15
Specific Director Duties
• Duty to act honestly• Duty to act with care and diligence• Duty to avoid insolvent trading• Duty not to misuse position of Director• Duty to avoid conflicts of interest• Duty to act in accordance with Articles of
Association
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 16
Duty to Act Honestly
Directors must act:• (a) in good faith and (b) for a proper
purpose• in what they consider to be the bona fide
best interests of the Company• honestly in dealings with shareholders
and must not mislead shareholders
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 17
Duty to Act with Care and Diligence• Directors must give reasonable attention to the affairs of the
Company but they can delegate their duties to appropriate officers of the Company
• Directors must take reasonable steps to be in a position to guide and monitor the management of the Company
• Directors should attend all Directors’ meetings and be aware of Company’s overall financial situation
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 18
Business Judgment Rule (e.g. Delaware, Australia)
In Australia, Directors will satisfy duty of care and diligence if they:– exercise their judgment in good faith for a proper purpose– do not have a material personal interest in the transaction– inform themselves of the subject matter of the decision to the
extent they reasonably believe appropriate– rationally believe the judgment to be in the best interests of the
Company
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 19
Duty to avoid Insolvent Trading
• Company insolvency will affect employees, creditors, suppliers, customers etc
• Directors must sign off on accounts that the Company is solvent
• If the Company becomes insolvent, Directors have a duty to cease trading and put the Company into administration or liquidation
• Potential criminal liability for insolvent trading
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 20
Duty not to misuse position of Director
• Hollinger Case – Directors alleged to misuse position for personal gain
• Duty not to misuse position to obtain a private benefit for yourself or your related party to the detriment of the Company
• Duty not to make improper use of information
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 21
Duty to avoid conflicts of interest
• Duty generally requires interested Directors to step aside and let remainder of board decide the issue
• Duty is to inform the board and usually to step aside, does not generally require you to stop the Company entering into a contract with your related Company even if the deal advantages your related Company
• Some jurisdictions require you to notify the Company of your related parties on becoming a Director
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 22
Nominee Directors
Q. To what extent can a Director take into account the interests of his appointing shareholder?
A. Generally Director may take into account the interests of his appointing shareholder if:
- he honestly believes those interests are consistent with the interests of the Company as a whole
- such belief is not unreasonable
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 23
Nominee Directors
• Shareholders Agreement and Articles also relevant (e.g. may show Company is a vehicle for the joint venture, that shareholders will cause Directors to give effect to Shareholders Agreement etc)
• Japan Abrasive Materials Pty Ltd & Ors v. Australian Fused Materials Pty Ltd & Ors [1998] WASC 60 (Directors not acting for improper purpose)
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 24
Criminal Penalties
• Director can face criminal penalties (fine/imprisonment) for breach of Director duties (usually when fraud is involved)
• Other laws:- Health & safety laws - Environment laws- Private criminal actions (e.g. Thailand TPI case)
©2007 Baker & McKenzie 25
Listed Company Issues
• Insider trading (esp. on share sell down)• Continuous disclosure (market
announcements)• Share sale or purchase notifications• Shareholder approval for related party
transactions