sei whales - pandaassets.panda.org/downloads/sei_whales_brochure.pdf · what needs to be done sei...

2
The sei whale Balaenoptera borealis is in the same genus as the blue (B. musculus), fin (B. physalus), Bryde’s (B. edeni) and minke (B. acutorostrata) whales. These Balaenoptera species, along with the humpback whale Megaptera novaeangliae, are rorquals: that is to say, they have baleen plates rather than teeth, and also have pleated ventral grooves which enable them to distend their throats. The literal translation of the term “balaenoptera” refers to the fact that these species have a dorsal fin, and distinguishes the genus from other baleen whales such as gray whales and right whales, which do not. The name “sei whale” is derived from the Norwegian seje, for pollack or coalfish, because the two species used to arrive off Norwegian waters at the same time each year. In The Book of Whales, Richard Ellis notes that the sei whale has “been named for a fish by the two nations that hunted it most - sejhval by the Norwegians and Iwashi- kujira, or sardine whale, by the Japanese.” As Ellis notes, such nomenclature is ironic given that the sei whale is “not primarily a fish eater.” Sei whales tend to travel in groups of two to five individuals, although larger aggregations occur periodically. Fast swimmers in bursts - R.C. Andrews, writing in 1916, likened the sei whale to the cheetah in that respect - they may in fact be the fastest of all cetaceans. Sei whales are almost exclusively plankton feeders. In the North Pacific, a Japanese study (Nemoto and Kawamura, 1977) of the stomach contents of 21,713 seis that had been killed by whaling showed that 9,665, or 44.5%, had empty stomachs. Only 3% had been eating fish, and 82.7% of those with food in their stomachs had been feeding on planktonic animals called copepods. Their diet is reflected in their baleen plates, which have very fine hair on the inner surfaces, making the baleen better adapted to sieving smaller organisms from the water. Sei whales mostly inhabit offshore waters and rarely come inshore. This contributed to their not being described by science until two or three decades later than most of the other rorquals, and is a contributing factor to their being relatively little studied or understood to this day. Sei whales feed in cold water during summer, although they may not penetrate into as high latitudes as some other species. Their winter distribution is presumably dispersed in offshore waters of the tropics and subtropics. Genetic studies have determined the existence of separate populations in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres, but have failed to identify separate populations within ocean basins. In the North Pacific, two or three populations have been proposed; in the North Atlantic, as many as eight have been suggested, although for management purposes only three are recognized. Uniquely among whales, seis frequently appear suddenly in an area for days, weeks, or months, and then disappear completely for years. This is presumably a response to localized environmental factors enabling them to exploit temporarily abundant prey species on an opportunistic basis. Commercial hunting of sei whales did not begin until the late 19th century, when around 4,000 sei whales were hunted off North Norway between 1885 and 1900. Subsequently, seis were hunted in the North Atlantic from land stations in Canada, the Faeroe Islands, the Iberian Peninsula, Iceland, Ireland, Norway and Scotland; in the North Pacific by pelagic fleets and from land stations in California, Canada, Japan, Kamchatka, and Kuril; and in the Southern Hemisphere from Brazil, Chile, Peru, South Africa, and South Georgia. The largest catches by far, however, were by the Antarctic pelagic fleets. Initially the sei was not hunted much by these fleets: it was fast and hard to catch, its blubber was thin, and the larger blue whales and fin whales were preferred targets. But with the collapse of first blue and then fin whale populations in the Southern Hemisphere, the sei whale, as the next-largest species, became the focus of the commercial whaling industry and by the 1965/66 season accounted for 71.9 per cent of the Antarctic catch. According to International Whaling Commission (IWC) statistics, a total of 203,538 sei whales were killed in the Southern Hemisphere in the 20th century, with over half this total taken in the Antarctic in just 12 years, from 1959 to 1971. Not surprisingly, catches dwindled rapidly thereafter: the IWC quota for 1976/77 was 1,995 seis; for 1977/78 it was 855; and for 1978/79 it was 84. That was the last year of sei whaling in the Southern Ocean. The hunting of seis had ended in the North Pacific four years earlier, and here too the damage had been extensive: Japan killed about 29,400 seis along their coast between 1910 and 1975; the Soviets and Japanese together killed about 31,700 during pelagic operations between 1952 and 1975. Altogether, North Pacific whaling accounted for almost 75,000 sei whales. The consequent drastic decline in population numbers resulted in the IWC declaring North Pacific seis a protected stock from 1976. Commercial whaling for seis in the North Atlantic continued until the moratorium came into effect in 1986, although Iceland continued to hunt small numbers under the guise of “scientific research” for four years, and some subsistence catches took place off Greenland. Sei whale population numbers were not known with any confidence prior to exploitation and still are not. However, it is certain that commercial whaling caused considerable declines throughout the species’ range. In 1980, it was estimated that the Southern Hemisphere population had been reduced to around 24,000 from an initial level of 100,000 or so. In the North Pacific, the most recent study, in 1977, indicated a decline from 42,000 in 1963 to 8,600 in 1974. Figures in the North Atlantic are the most uncertain, although some surveys have suggested a figure of around 10,000. There have been no recent population estimates. The 2000 IUCN Red List of Threatened Species classifies the species as Endangered, meaning it faces a “very high risk of extinction in the wild in the near future.” This is based on the IUCN criterion that there has been an estimated total decline of at least 50% in worldwide abundance over the last three generations. Japan has submitted a proposal to the IWC Scientific Committee to expand its research whaling program in the North Pacific, beginning in 2002. In addition to increasing from 100 to 150 the number of Northern minke whales taken each year, the proposal calls for the taking of 50 sei whales a year. In a press release dated 1 March 2002, the Institute for Cetacean Research (ICR) stated that the increase is “based on urgent scientific need to collect data on the competition between whales and fisheries.” The release continues by claiming that “it is estimated whales consume three to five times the amount of marine resources as are caught for human consumption.” The species taken under the research program “are abundant in the North Pacific and they are very large animals - this means they consume huge amounts of marine resources.” This argument - that whales eat large amounts of fish that would otherwise be available to commercial fisheries - is becoming increasingly prevalent in statements from Japan’s whaling industry. In a recent book, Japan’s deputy IWC commissioner Masayuki Komatsu argues explicitly that “Humans and whales are competing for fish,” that “Whales are eating the fish to depletion,” and that “We need to cull whales in order to achieve sustainable use of the fish.” There is absolutely no evidence to support any of these contentions. The ICR figures of global fish consumption by whales are concocted by extrapolating flawed estimates of the percentage of body weight consumed by an individual whale daily, and have been repudiated by independent studies. The notion that whales are contributing to the decline of fish stocks fails to acknowledge the obvious: that both whale and fish populations were massively larger one hundred years ago, and that the real problem is the commercial fishing industry. The idea that “culling” whales would lead to an increase in fish for human consumption is far too simplistic, and fails even to consider the impacts of seabirds, other marine mammals, and, especially, predatory fish. It also disguises the fact that the vast majority of food consumed by baleen and sperm whales is, depending on the species, plankton or deep-sea squid - neither of which are commercially fished by humans. This last point is even more apposite with regard to sei whales. As we have seen, every single observation - of sei whale behavior, stomach contents, and even the nature of their baleen plates - shows categorically that seis are predominantly eaters of tiny plankton smaller even than the krill consumed by their relatives, and not of fish. The ICR further justifies its proposal by claiming that sei whales “are not endangered” - which, as we have seen is patently untrue. The aforementioned ICR press release claims that sei whale numbers in the North Pacific have grown to 30,000 in the last 25 years. This figure is stated as fact, even though it is based on no evidence whatsoever. Indeed, in 1999, ICR director Dr. Seiji Ohsumi submitted a paper to the IWC which claimed the population numbered just 9,110. Any criticism of, or challenge to, the IUCN classification of the species must be submitted through the formal IUCN review procedure. The IWC and its Scientific Committee have consistently criticized Japan's “research” whaling program. Japan's extension of this program to sei whales in the North Pacific is the most blatant misuse yet of the lethal research provision in the IWC convention. WWF works in the International Whaling Commission (IWC) to ensure that endangered species of whales, including sei whales, are never again threatened by whaling. WWF is also lobbying the IWC and its scientific committee to address the new threats to sei and other endangered whales, including the threats from marine pollution, prey depletion, climate change, and by-catch. The Japanese government's long- standing abuse of the provision in the 1946 International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling (ICRW) that allows IWC members to conduct lethal scientific research on whales, without the agreement of the IWC, must be ended. In particular, such “scientific whaling” should be ended in whale sanctuaries, on the high seas, and for all threatened species, including sei whales. The IWC should recognise that whaling countries’ proposals to “cull” whales because they are alleged to consume “too many commercial fish stocks” have no valid scientific foundation. Classification Sei whales Balaenoptera borealis Behavior, natural history and diet Distribution and movements Commercial whaling - a history of over-exploitation Population numbers and status Japan’s planned scientific whaling What is WWF doing What needs to be done Sei whales are almost exclusively plankton feeders. A total of 203,538 sei whales were killed in the Southern Hemisphere in the 20th century.

Upload: lamdan

Post on 18-Feb-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sei whales - Pandaassets.panda.org/downloads/SEI_Whales_Brochure.pdf · What needs to be done Sei whales are almost exclusively plankton feeders. ... whale was the “most graceful

The sei whale Balaenoptera borealis is in thesame genus as the blue (B. musculus), fin (B. physalus), Bryde’s (B. edeni) and minke(B. acutorostrata) whales. These Balaenopteraspecies, along with the humpback whaleMegaptera novaeangliae, are rorquals: that isto say, they have baleen plates rather than teeth,and also have pleated ventral grooves whichenable them to distend their throats. The literaltranslation of the term “balaenoptera” refers tothe fact that these species have a dorsal fin,and distinguishes the genus from other baleenwhales such as gray whales and right whales,which do not.

The name “sei whale” is derived fromthe Norwegian seje, for pollack or coalfish,because the two species used to arrive offNorwegian waters at the same time each year.In The Book of Whales, Richard Ellis notes thatthe sei whale has “been named for a fishby the two nations that hunted it most -sejhval by the Norwegians and Iwashi-kujira, or sardine whale, by theJapanese.” As Ellis notes, such nomenclatureis ironic given that the sei whale is “notprimarily a fish eater.”

Sei whales tend to travel in groups of two to fiveindividuals, although larger aggregations occurperiodically. Fast swimmers in bursts - R.C.Andrews, writing in 1916, likened the sei whaleto the cheetah in that respect - they may in factbe the fastest of all cetaceans.

Sei whales are almost exclusively planktonfeeders. In the North Pacific, a Japanese study(Nemoto and Kawamura, 1977) of the stomachcontents of 21,713 seis that had been killed bywhaling showed that 9,665, or 44.5%, had emptystomachs. Only 3% had been eating fish, and82.7% of those with food in their stomachs had

been feeding on planktonic animals calledcopepods. Their diet is reflected in their baleenplates, which have very fine hair on the innersurfaces, making the baleen better adapted tosieving smaller organisms from the water.

Sei whales mostly inhabit offshore watersand rarely come inshore. This contributed totheir not being described by science until twoor three decades later than most of the otherrorquals, and is a contributing factor to theirbeing relatively little studied or understoodto this day.

Sei whales feed in cold water during summer,although they may not penetrate into as highlatitudes as some other species. Their winterdistribution is presumably dispersed in offshorewaters of the tropics and subtropics. Geneticstudies have determined the existence of separatepopulations in the Northern and SouthernHemispheres, but have failed to identify separatepopulations within ocean basins. In the NorthPacific, two or three populations have beenproposed; in the North Atlantic, as many as eighthave been suggested, although for managementpurposes only three are recognized.

Uniquely among whales, seis frequentlyappear suddenly in an area for days, weeks, ormonths, and then disappear completely for years.This is presumably a response to localizedenvironmental factors enabling them to exploittemporarily abundant prey species on anopportunistic basis.

Commercial hunting of sei whales did not beginuntil the late 19th century, when around 4,000 seiwhales were hunted off North Norway between1885 and 1900. Subsequently, seis were huntedin the North Atlantic from land stations in Canada,the Faeroe Islands, the Iberian Peninsula, Iceland,Ireland, Norway and Scotland; in the North Pacificby pelagic fleets and from land stations in California,Canada, Japan, Kamchatka, and Kuril; and in theSouthern Hemisphere from Brazil, Chile, Peru,South Africa, and South Georgia.

The largest catches by far, however, were bythe Antarctic pelagic fleets. Initially the sei was nothunted much by these fleets: it was fast and hardto catch, its blubber was thin, and the larger bluewhales and fin whales were preferred targets. Butwith the collapse of first blue and then fin whalepopulations in the Southern Hemisphere, the seiwhale, as the next-largest species, became thefocus of the commercial whaling industry and bythe 1965/66 season accounted for 71.9 per cent ofthe Antarctic catch.

According to International WhalingCommission (IWC) statistics, a total of 203,538sei whales were killed in the Southern Hemispherein the 20th century, with over half this total takenin the Antarctic in just 12 years, from 1959 to1971. Not surprisingly, catches dwindled rapidlythereafter: the IWC quota for 1976/77 was 1,995seis; for 1977/78 it was 855; and for 1978/79 itwas 84. That was the last year of sei whaling inthe Southern Ocean. The hunting of seis hadended in the North Pacific four years earlier, andhere too the damage had been extensive: Japankilled about 29,400 seis along their coast between1910 and 1975; the Soviets and Japanese togetherkilled about 31,700 during pelagic operationsbetween 1952 and 1975. Altogether, North Pacificwhaling accounted for almost 75,000 sei whales.The consequent drastic decline in populationnumbers resulted in the IWC declaring NorthPacific seis a protected stock from 1976.Commercial whaling for seis in the North Atlanticcontinued until the moratorium came into effectin 1986, although Iceland continued to hunt smallnumbers under the guise of “scientific research”for four years, and some subsistence catches tookplace off Greenland.

Sei whale population numbers were not knownwith any confidence prior to exploitation andstill are not. However, it is certain that commercialwhaling caused considerable declines throughoutthe species’ range. In 1980, it was estimatedthat the Southern Hemisphere population hadbeen reduced to around 24,000 from an initiallevel of 100,000 or so. In the North Pacific, themost recent study, in 1977, indicated a declinefrom 42,000 in 1963 to 8,600 in 1974. Figuresin the North Atlantic are the most uncertain,although some surveys have suggested a figureof around 10,000.

There have been no recent populationestimates. The 2000 IUCN Red List of ThreatenedSpecies classifies the species as Endangered,meaning it faces a “very high risk of extinction inthe wild in the near future.” This is based on theIUCN criterion that there has been an estimatedtotal decline of at least 50% in worldwideabundance over the last three generations.

Japan has submitted a proposal to the IWCScientific Committee to expand its researchwhaling program in the North Pacific, beginningin 2002. In addition to increasing from 100 to150 the number of Northern minke whales takeneach year, the proposal calls for the taking of50 sei whales a year. In a press release dated 1March 2002, the Institute for Cetacean Research(ICR) stated that the increase is “based on urgentscientific need to collect data on the competitionbetween whales and fisheries.”

The release continues by claiming that “it is estimated whales consume three to fivetimes the amount of marine resources as arecaught for human consumption.” The speciestaken under the research program “are abundantin the North Pacific and they are very largeanimals - this means they consume hugeamounts of marine resources.”

This argument - that whales eat largeamounts of fish that would otherwise be availableto commercial fisheries - is becomingincreasingly prevalent in statements from Japan’swhaling industry. In a recent book, Japan’s

deputy IWC commissioner Masayuki Komatsuargues explicitly that “Humans and whalesare competing for fish,” that “Whales areeating the fish to depletion,” and that “Weneed to cull whales in order to achievesustainable use of the fish.”

There is absolutely no evidence to supportany of these contentions. The ICR figures ofglobal fish consumption by whales are concoctedby extrapolating flawed estimates of thepercentage of body weight consumed by anindividual whale daily, and have been repudiatedby independent studies. The notion that whalesare contributing to the decline of fish stocksfails to acknowledge the obvious: that both whaleand fish populations were massively larger onehundred years ago, and that the real problem isthe commercial fishing industry. The idea that“culling” whales would lead to an increase in fishfor human consumption is far too simplistic, andfails even to consider the impacts of seabirds,other marine mammals, and, especially,predatory fish. It also disguises the fact that thevast majority of food consumed by baleen andsperm whales is, depending on the species,plankton or deep-sea squid - neither of whichare commercially fished by humans.

This last point is even more apposite withregard to sei whales. As we have seen, everysingle observation - of sei whale behavior,stomach contents, and even the nature of theirbaleen plates - shows categorically that seis arepredominantly eaters of tiny plankton smallereven than the krill consumed by their relatives,and not of fish.

The ICR further justifies its proposal byclaiming that sei whales “are not endangered” -which, as we have seen is patently untrue. Theaforementioned ICR press release claims that seiwhale numbers in the North Pacific have grownto 30,000 in the last 25 years. This figure is statedas fact, even though it is based on no evidencewhatsoever. Indeed, in 1999, ICR director Dr. SeijiOhsumi submitted a paper to the IWC whichclaimed the population numbered just 9,110. Anycriticism of, or challenge to, the IUCN classificationof the species must be submitted through theformal IUCN review procedure.

The IWC and its Scientific Committee haveconsistently criticized Japan's “research” whalingprogram. Japan's extension of this program tosei whales in the North Pacific is the most blatantmisuse yet of the lethal research provision inthe IWC convention.

WWF works in the InternationalWhaling Commission (IWC) to ensurethat endangered species of whales,including sei whales, are never againthreatened by whaling. WWF is alsolobbying the IWC and its scientificcommittee to address the new threatsto sei and other endangered whales,including the threats from marinepollution, prey depletion, climatechange, and by-catch.

• The Japanese government's long-standing abuse of the provision in the1946 International Convention for theRegulation of Whaling (ICRW) that allowsIWC members to conduct lethal scientificresearch on whales, without theagreement of the IWC, must be ended.In particular, such “scientific whaling”should be ended in whale sanctuaries,on the high seas, and for all threatenedspecies, including sei whales.

• The IWC should recognise that whalingcountries’ proposals to “cull” whalesbecause they are alleged to consume“too many commercial fish stocks” haveno valid scientific foundation.

Classification

Sei whalesBalaenoptera borealis

Behavior, naturalhistory and diet

Distribution andmovements

Commercial whaling -a history ofover-exploitation

Population numbersand status

Japan’s plannedscientific whaling

What isWWF doing

What needs to be done

Sei whales are almost exclusivelyplankton feeders.

A total of 203,538 sei whales were killed inthe Southern Hemisphere in the 20th century.

Page 2: Sei whales - Pandaassets.panda.org/downloads/SEI_Whales_Brochure.pdf · What needs to be done Sei whales are almost exclusively plankton feeders. ... whale was the “most graceful

Sei whalesBalaenoptera borealis

The biologist R.C. Haldane, writing in 1909, opined that the sei

whale was the “most graceful of all whales, as its

proportions are so perfect.”

Sleek and slender, the sei is in fact similar in shape and

proportions to the blue and fin whales, although it is substantially

smaller than both: generally between 17 and 21m long, compared

with 24-27m for fin whales, and over 30m for blues. Despite the

size disparity, differentiating between the species is not easy,

particularly from a distance. Seis bear an even closer resemblance

to Bryde's whales, and are virtually indistinguishable from them

in the field.

Seis are a dark bluish-gray in color above, and this coloration

generally extends along the sides and under the flippers. The

ventral surface is mostly covered with irregular white patches.

Sei whales also frequently have round pitted scars on their body,

which apparently are the result of bites from the small cookie-

cutter shark (Isistius brasiliensis).

Sei whales

For further information on WWF’s Species Programme visitwww.panda.org/species

WWF International Species ProgrammePanda House, Weyside ParkGodalming Surrey GU7 1XR

United Kingdomemail: [email protected]: +44 (0) 1483 426 444

Species ProgrammeWWF InternationalAvenue du Mont Blanc1196 Gland, SwitzerlandTel: +41 22 364 91 11

WWF’s mission is to stop the degradation of the planet’s naturalenvironment and to build a future in which humans live inharmony with nature, by:

• conserving the world's biological diversity

• ensuring that the use of renewable resources is sustainable

• promoting the reduction of pollution and wasteful consumption

Imag

es a

nd p

hoto

s co

urte

sy o

f Cyb

erNa

tura

l Sof

twar

e - U

nive

rsity

of G

uelp

h an

d Th

e W

hale

Clu

b