sample answers 2 10- 5 10 etc

13
5/26/2018 SampleAnswers210-510Etc-slidepdf.com http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sample-answers-2-10-5-10-etc 1/13 7. Microeconomic What you should know Markets  You should be able to: dene markets and explain the importance of price as a signal and as an incentive in terms of resource allocation dene demand, explain the law of demand and its exceptions, identify the determinants of demand, distinguish between a movement along a demand curve and shift of the demand curve, and show all of the above in diagrams dene supply, explain the law of supply, identify the determinants of supply, explain the effects of taxes and subsidies on supply, distinguish between a movement along a supply curve and shift of the supply curve, and show all of the above in diagrams explain the causes and consequences of maximum and minimum prices, explain price support and/or buffer stock schemes and commodity agreements and show all of the above in diagrams. Elasticities  You should be able to: dene price elasticity of demand (PED), give the equation, explain the possible range of values, explain the determinants of PED, explain how PED varies along a straight-line demand curve, and show all of the above in diagrams dene cross elasticity of demand (XED), give the equation, explain the possible range of values in relation to substitutes and complements, and show all of the above in diagrams dene income elasticity of demand (YED), give the equation, explain the possible range of values in relation to luxury goods, normal goods, and inferior goods, and show all of the above in diagrams dene price elasticity of supply (PES), give the equation, explain the possible range of values, explain the determinants of PES, and show all of the above in diagrams explain how PED, XED, and YED may be of use to rms and the government when making economic decisions. 365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 17

Upload: yipadeeday

Post on 16-Oct-2015

45 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Economics sample answers

TRANSCRIPT

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    1/13

    7. Microeconomic

    What you should know

    Markets

    You should be able to:

    dene markets and explain the importance of price as a signal and as an

    incentive in terms of resource allocation

    dene demand, explain the law of demand and its exceptions, identify the

    determinants of demand, distinguish between a movement along a demand

    curve and shift of the demand curve, and show all of the above in diagrams

    dene supply, explain the law of supply, identify the determinants of supply,

    explain the effects of taxes and subsidies on supply, distinguish between a

    movement along a supply curve and shift of the supply curve, and show all of

    the above in diagrams

    explain the causes and consequences of maximum and minimum prices,

    explain price support and/or buffer stock schemes and commodity agreements

    and show all of the above in diagrams.

    Elasticities

    You should be able to:

    dene price elasticity of demand (PED), give the equation, explain the possible

    range of values, explain the determinants of PED, explain how PED varies

    along a straight-line demand curve, and show all of the above in diagrams

    dene cross elasticity of demand (XED), give the equation, explain the possible

    range of values in relation to substitutes and complements, and show all of the

    above in diagrams

    dene income elasticity of demand (YED), give the equation, explain the

    possible range of values in relation to luxury goods, normal goods, and inferior

    goods, and show all of the above in diagrams

    dene price elasticity of supply (PES), give the equation, explain the possible

    range of values, explain the determinants of PES, and show all of the above in

    diagrams

    explain how PED, XED, and YED may be of use to rms and the government

    when making economic decisions.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 17

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    2/13

    18

    7.M

    icroeconomics

    Essential definitions

    Market failure

    You should be able to:

    dene market failure, explain different reasons for market failure, including

    monopoly power, public goods, merit goods, demerit goods, positive and

    negative externalities, and show all of the above in diagrams

    explain sustainable development

    explain possible government responses to market failure, including legislation,

    direct provision of public and merit goods, taxation, subsidies, tradeable

    permits, extension of property rights, positive and negative advertising, and

    international cooperation among governments.

    Markets

    A marketis where buyers (consumers) and sellers (producers) come together to

    establish an equilibrium price and quantity for a good or service. It does not need

    to be an actual place. An example would be the market for MP3 players.

    Demandis the willingness and ability to purchase a quantity of a good or service

    at a certain price over a given time period.

    The law of demandstates that as the price of a good or service rises, the quantity

    demanded decreases, ceteris paribus.

    Ceteris paribusis a Latin expression that means let all other things remain

    equal. It is an assumption made by economists in order to construct economic

    models.

    The demand curveis a graphical representation of the law of demand. It is

    (usually) a downward-sloping curve (or line) illustrating the inverse relationship

    between price and quantity demanded.

    Supplyis the willingness and ability of a producer to produce a quantity of a good

    or service at a certain price over a given time period.

    The law of supplystates that as the price of a good rises, the quantity supplied

    increases, ceteris paribus.

    The supply curveis a graphical representation of the law of supply. It is an

    upward-sloping curve (or line) illustrating the direct relationship between price

    and quantity supplied.

    Equilibrium priceis the market clearing price. It occurs where demand is equal

    to supply.

    A maximum priceis also known as a ceiling price. It is a price set by the

    government, above which the market price is not allowed to rise. It may be set to

    protect consumers from high prices, and it may be used in markets for essential

    goods, such as rice or house rentals.Continued

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 18

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    3/13

    Markets (continued)

    A minimum priceis also known as a oor price. It is a price set by the

    government, below which the market price is not allowed to fall. It may be set to

    protect producers producing essential products from facing prices that are felt to

    be too low, such as many agricultural products in the European Union (EU).A buffer stock schemesets a maximum and a minimum price in a market to

    stabilize prices.

    Elasticities

    Price elasticity of demand (PED)is a measure of the responsiveness of the

    quantity demanded of a good or service to a change in its price.

    Elastic demandmeans that a change in the price of a good or service will cause

    a proportionately larger change in quantity demanded and inelastic demand

    means that a change in price of a good or service will cause a proportionately

    smaller change in quantity demanded.

    Cross elasticity of demand (XED)is a measure of the responsiveness of the

    demand for a good or service to a change in the price of a related good.

    Substitute goodsare goods that can be used instead of each other, such as butter

    and margarine. Substitute goods have positive cross elasticity of demand.

    Complement goodsare goods that are used together, such as DVD players and

    DVD discs. Complement goods have negative cross elasticity of demand.

    Income elasticity of demand (YED)is a measure of the responsiveness of

    demand for a good to a change in income.

    Anormal goodhas a positive income elasticity of demand. As income rises,

    demand increases.

    Inferior goodshave a negative income elasticity of demand. As income rises,

    demand decreases.

    Price elasticity of supply (PES)is a measure of the responsiveness of the quantity

    supplied of a good or service to a change in its price.

    An indirect taxis an expenditure tax on a good or service. An indirect tax is shown

    on a supply and demand diagram as an upward shift in the supply curve, where

    the vertical distance between the two supply curves represents the amount of the

    tax. A specific taxis shown as a parallel shift. An ad valoremtaxis shown as a

    divergent shift.

    Market failure

    Market failureis the failure of

    markets to produce at the socially

    efcient level of output.

    Positive externalitiesarebenecial effects that are enjoyed

    by a third party when a good or

    service is produced or consumed.

    Negative externalitiesare the bad

    effects that are suffered by a third

    party when a good or service is

    produced or consumed.

    Public goodsare goods or services

    that would not be provided at

    all by the market. They have the

    characteristics of non-rivalry and

    non-diminishability, for example,ood barriers.

    Merit goodsare goods or services

    considered as benecial for people

    and that would be under-provided

    by the market and so under-

    consumed, for example, education

    and health care.

    Demerit goodsare goods or

    services considered to be harmful

    to people and that would be over-

    provided by the market and so over-

    consumed, for example, cigarettes

    and alcohol.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 19

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    4/13

    20

    7.M

    icroeconomics

    Diagrams to remember

    Circular flow of income diagram

    Markets

    Equilibrium

    Quantity of tea (kg)0

    Price oftea ($)

    Pe

    Qe

    S

    D

    The equilibrium point is where the quantity demanded of a

    good or service at a given price is the same as the quantity

    supplied. In this case, at a price Pe, the quantity of tea

    demanded and supplied is Qe.

    An increase in demand

    Quantity of computergames (000s)

    S

    P2

    P1

    0Q

    1Q

    2

    D1

    D2

    Price of computergames ($)

    An increase in demand for computer games (D1to D

    2) could

    be caused by a change in any of the determinants of demand,

    for example, an increase in consumer incomes or a decrease

    in the price of computers, a complement. The result is

    an increase in quantity (Q1to Q

    2) and an increase in price

    (P1to P

    2).

    An increase in supply

    Quantity of computer

    games (000s)

    D

    P1

    P2

    0Q

    1Q

    2

    S1 S2

    Price ofcomputers ($)

    An increase in the supply of computers (S1to S

    2) could be

    caused by a change in any of the determinants of supply, for

    example, a fall in the cost of factors used to make computers

    or an improvement in technology. The result is an increase in

    quantity (Q1to Q

    2) and a fall in price (P

    1to P

    2).

    A maximum price

    Quantityof housing

    0

    Rent ($)

    Pe

    Qe

    S

    PMax

    Q1

    Q2

    Excessdemand D

    Maximumprice

    A maximum rent (a rent control) of PMax

    is placed upon rented

    accommodation. This keeps the rents low, but it means that

    there will be an excess demand for rented accommodation of

    Q1to

    Q

    2.

    Continued

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 20

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    5/13

    Markets (continued)

    A minimum price

    Quantity of corn(000s tonnes)

    0

    Price ofcorn($)

    Pe

    Qe

    S

    PMin

    Q1

    Q2

    Excess supply

    D

    Minimumprice

    A minimum price of PMin

    is placed upon the corn market. This

    keeps the price of corn high, but it means that there will be an

    excess supply of corn of Q1to Q

    2.

    A specific tax on a product

    Number of loavesof bread (000s)

    0

    D1

    Price ofbread ($)

    S1

    ST

    PT

    R

    P1

    QT

    Q1

    Indirect tax

    The imposition of an indirect tax of PTR shifts the supply curveupwards from S

    1to S

    Tand raises the price to consumers from

    P1to P

    T. The quantity demanded and supplied falls from Q

    1to

    QT. The revenue per unit received by the producers falls from

    P1to R. The government will receive tax revenue of P

    TR per

    unit for QTunits.

    Elasticities

    Price elasticity of demand (PED) values for a normal

    demand curve

    Quantity ofsh (tonnes)

    PED>1

    0

    D1

    Price ofsh ($)

    PED

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    6/13

    22

    7.M

    icroeconomics

    Circular flow of income diagram

    Market failure

    Negative externalities of production

    Quantity ofchemicals(tonnes)

    0

    Price of chemicals ($)

    MSB

    P*

    Q*

    Welfare lossMSC

    P1

    Q1

    MPC

    Negativeexternalitya

    The chemical rm is polluting the atmosphere as it produces.Thus the cost to society (MSC) is greater than the private cost

    (MPC). There is a loss of welfare for society as chemicals are

    overproduced. A negative externality, a cost to third parties,

    has been created. This is a market failure, as the market does

    not produce at the socially efcient level of output (Q*).

    Positive externalities of production

    Quantity ofchemicals(tonnes)

    0

    Price of chemicals ($)

    MSB

    P1

    Q1

    Potentialwelfare gain MSC

    P*

    Q*

    MPC

    Positive

    externality

    a

    The chemical rm is giving training to its workers. Thus the

    private cost (MPC) is greater than the cost to society (MSC).

    When the workers move on, there is a positive benet to the

    rms that employ them, the third parties. In a free market,

    the level of output is Q1; this is a market failure because the

    socially efcient level of output is Q*, and so the market is

    under-producing. The shaded area shows the potential welfare

    gain that could be achieved.

    Negative externalities of consumption

    Quantity ofair travel(miles)

    0

    Price of air travel ($)

    MSB

    P1

    Q*

    Welfare loss MSC

    P*

    Q1

    MPB

    Negativeexternality

    By consuming air travel there are more ights, and so thirdparties are affected by increased noise and air pollution. The

    benet to the individuals who are ying (MPB) is greater than the

    benet to society (MSB). There is a loss of welfare and a negative

    externality has been produced. In a free market, the level of

    output is Q1; this is a market failure because the socially efcient

    level of output Q* is not achieved and air travel is over-consumed

    Positive externalities of consumption

    Quantity ofvaccinations

    0

    Price of vaccinations ($)

    MSB

    P*

    Q1

    Potentialwelfare gain

    MSC

    P1

    Q*

    MPB

    Positiveexternality

    By paying for and being vaccinated, individuals gain benet

    for themselves (MPB). In addition third parties who have not

    been vaccinated stand less chance of getting the disease, since

    there are fewer carriers. Thus they also benet, and the totalbenet to society (MSB) is greater than MPB. In a free market,

    the level of output is Q1; this is a market failure because

    the socially efcient level of output Q* is not achieved, as

    vaccinations are under-consumed. The shaded area shows the

    potential welfare gain that could be achieved.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 22

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    7/13

    the advantages and disadvantages of minimum and maximum prices

    the likely success of a buffer stock scheme

    the effects of government subsidies given to cotton farmers

    the effects of government intervention in the markets for demerit goods

    the advantages and disadvantages of government policies to control pollution.

    Remember to make reasoned judgments or conclusions.

    You should be able to evaluate:

    Using supply and demand analysis, explain why the price of agricultural goods

    tends to fluctuate more than the price of manufactured goods.

    10 mark

    The following is a typical question from

    paper 1 part (a) and you should spend

    approximately 25 minutes on it.

    [Taken from SL paper 1(a) November 200

    How do I approach the question?

    Start by dening demand and supply and then draw a

    demand and supply curve diagram to explain how price is

    determined.

    Introduce the topic of agricultural goods and give an example,

    such as rice, which you can then use for the rest of the answer.

    Dene PED and PES and explain that the PED and the PES for

    agricultural goods tend to be relatively inelastic, particularly

    in the short run, due to the inability to increase quantity (PES)

    and the dependence on agricultural goods (PES). Draw and

    label a diagram for rice with steep, relatively inelastic demand

    curves and inelastic supply curves and show a shift in the supply

    curve. Explain that the supply of agricultural goods tends to be

    rather volatile, because they are dependent on the weather; use

    the diagram to explain that a change in supply with inelastic

    demand and supply will lead to relatively large changes in price.

    Introduce the topic of manufactured goods and give an

    example, which you will then use for the rest of the answer.

    Explain that the PED and the PES for manufactured goods

    tend to be relatively elastic. Draw and label a diagram for your

    example with at, relatively elastic demand and supply curves

    and show a shift in the supply or the demand curve.

    Explain that the PED for your example will be relatively elastic,

    because the industry is very competitive, and that the PES

    is relatively elastic because it is relatively simple to increase

    supply in response to price changes. Explain that a change in

    demand or supply with relatively elastic demand and supply

    will lead to relatively small changes in price.

    Explain that, as can be seen from the diagrams, the price

    of agricultural goods tends to uctuate more than the price

    of manufactured goods and that this is because of different

    elasticities of demand and supply. The unpredictable supply

    caused by the weather is also crucial for price instability.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 23

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    8/13

    24

    7.M

    icroeconomics

    What are the key areas from the syllabus?

    Interaction of demand and supply

    Elasticities

    Applications of concepts of elasticity

    What needs to be defined?

    Demand

    Supply

    Elasticity of demand Elasticity of supply

    What diagrams do I use?

    Basic demand and supply curve diagram

    Shifts in demand and supply curves for agricultural goods

    Shifts in demand and supply curves for manufactured goods

    This answer achieved 2/10

    In an economy the supply and demand depend on each other. It is important to have a stableeconomy. This can be shown or noticed if the market is in an equilibrium. However, the price changescontinuously for every good, so that the demand and supply side have to regulate and change in orderfor the markets to exist. The price of an agricultural good tends to fluctuate more than the price ofmanufactured goods. Agricultural goods depend on the season. It is a scarce resource land. Since itis not a stable product the demand and supply side change. As the productivity of the good increaseswhich means more supply the price will definatly increase as well.

    This can be seen on Figure 1.1.

    P

    P1

    Po

    S

    D

    QO Q1

    Supply Price

    Supply curve

    Q

    Fig 1.1

    This is only a move along the curve. However, as the price of productivity of the good increases thesupply will decrease.

    Demand, supply, and equilibrium

    could all have been defined. The

    student introduces the idea of

    seasonality, but the last sentence is a

    significant error. If supply increased, price

    would fall.

    The diagram does not tie in with

    the previous sentence. The change

    shown requires a shift of the demand

    curve and the statement as the price

    of productivity of the good increases the

    supply will decrease makes no sense in

    the circumstances.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 24

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    9/13

    D

    S0S1P

    P1PO

    Q1 QO Q

    price production supply

    Production costs

    Fig 1.2

    On the other side if the production price decreases there will be more supply. This is also dependable onthe if the good for example corn has been grown well this year. The more the farmer has for supplythe higher the prices can be. However it is quiet normal to storage agricultural goods in case of ashortage.

    Agricultural goods also depend on the demand of the buyers. If the demand for a seasonal good isweak because of a substitute for example the prices will decrease of that particular good.

    S

    DOD1Q1 QO Q

    POP1

    P

    substitute = demand price

    Fig 1.3

    This causes a shift to the left of the demand curve.

    However, if there is a shortage of an agricultural good and it is important to everyday life then theprices will increase. Shown on Figure 1.4

    S

    D2D1

    QQ2Q1

    P1

    PMore demand higher prices

    demand price

    Fig 1.4

    This diagram suggests that if

    production costs increase, supply will

    fall. While correct, it is hard to see

    the significance.

    The student makes another

    significant error in thinking that

    increased supply will lead to higher

    prices.

    The comment includes economic

    terminology, but makes little sense

    and has little to do with the question,

    so the diagram is redundant.

    The student mentions a shortage,

    and yet shows a shift of the demand

    curve, which makes no sense.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 25

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    10/13

    26

    7.M

    icroeconomics

    Manufactured goods are stable. They are always produced constantly and do not depend on weatheror a season. They are available throughout the whole year long. Thats why the demand depends onhow the product is advertised, on taste and preferences and on the joined demand. There are noshortages of surpluses in manufactured goods such as there are in agricultural goods.

    Surplus

    Floor

    Ceiling

    Shortage

    P

    Q1 Q

    P1

    min

    max

    D

    S Max + MinPrices

    Fig 1.5

    The student showed little understanding of the specific demands of the question. There was little recognition of relevant economic

    theory and none of the relevant terms were defined. There were significant errors. This puts the response into level 1 and explains the 2

    marks given.

    The student never seemed to understand the terms being used and this could be seen from the lack of definitions and the confusion

    between productivity of the good, price of productivity, production costs, and production price. The student also wrote away

    from the point and did not engage with the question being asked and so level 2 could not be awarded.

    Examiner report

    The first three sentences are relevant

    and correct, but then the student

    once again strays from the question

    asked.

    This answer achieved 5/10

    The student provides reasonable

    definitions and makes his or her

    understanding of the basic concept

    of elasticity clear.

    Supply is the amount that the producer is willing and is available to sell of a product. Demand is theamount consumers are willing to buy. When demand and supply intersect, there is an equilibriumpoint. This point sets the price for the product. It is the price set by the forces of demand and supply.Elasticity is the responsiveness of a change of price in the quantity demanded of a product. The morethe vertical the demand curve is, the more inelastic the product. This means that when the pricechanges, the quantity demanded will not be affected by much. On the other hand, if the product iselastic a change in price will bring about a much greater change in the quantity demanded. This ismainly because of the availability of substitutes of the product, the needs of the people and other thingssuch as if the product is addictive for example nicotine in cigarettes.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 26

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    11/13

    The student showed some understanding of the specific demands of the question and recognized some of the relevant theory. Some

    relevant terms were defined, but not all. There were errors in the explanation. This puts the response clearly into level 2 and explains

    the 5 marks given.

    The main weakness was a lack of planning and insufficient explanation. The diagrams were rather simplistic and there was no direct

    comparison of the relative elasticity values between manufactured and agricultural goods and so level 3 could not be awarded.

    Examiner report

    P1

    P$

    Pe

    S

    D

    q1 qe q

    In the diagram above we can see the price equilibrium (Pe) set by the forces of S and D. The quantitydemanded at that price will be Qe. With a change in price, the quantity demanded will fall drasticallyfrom Qe to Q1, a much greater change in quantity than in price. This would be the diagram formanufactured goods.

    On the other hand, we can say that the agricultural goods are inelastic because of the reasonsmentioned before. Agricultural goods dont have substitutes, you choose to consume or not consume,

    you cannot choose another option. This lets prices fluctuate much more than on manufacturedproducts that prices cannot fluctuate very much because people will choose the other substitutes.

    S

    q

    P$

    P1

    Pe

    p

    Dq1 q

    q

    In the diagram above one can see how a change in price will bring a much smaller change in thequantity demanded. This would definitely be the diagram for agricultural products.

    The diagram is incomplete. If the

    student wants to show a change away

    from the equilibrium, then he or she

    must show a shift of a curve, in this

    case a shift of supply to the left.

    This is a reasonable explanation,although it does tend to generalize

    about agricultural goods.

    The diagram is once again

    incomplete, in the same way as was

    the previous diagram. However, it

    does support the point made and,

    along with the brief explanation, infers

    some understanding of the question.

    The explanation does not say why

    the price may have changed. Also,

    the student does not explain why

    this would be the diagram for

    manufactured goods. There is no mention

    of elasticity.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 27

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    12/13

    28

    7.M

    icroeconomics

    This answer achieved 8/10

    A good definition of supply was

    followed by the introduction of

    supply elasticity and another good

    definition. The student refers to the

    diagram to follow and adds a definition

    of demand.

    The fluctuation in the price of agricultural produce may be due to the inelastic nature of its supply.Supply here refers to the quantity of a good or service that producers are willing to put on the marketat a given price over a specific period of time. This supply is inelastic in nature due to the process ofproduction of agricultural goods, the elasticity of supply referring to measure of responsiveness ofchanges in the supply of a good due to changes in the goods own price. Hence, given that farmproduce is inelastic in supply, a minor change in its demand can lead to a huge fall in price as shownin the following diagram. Demand referring to the amount of a good or service that consumers arewilling to buy at a given price over a specific period of time.

    Quantity of farm produceq3 q1 q2

    p2

    p1

    p3Price

    offarmp

    ro

    duce

    D''

    DD'

    S

    When demand rises to D, perhaps due to a favourable change in tastes and preferences, price ofagricultural produce rises to P

    2. When demand falls to D, perhaps due to the development of

    synthetic substitutes such as artificial sweeteners to replace real sugar, price falls to P3.

    Fluctuations in price can also be due to changes in supply. This may be due to weather or technologicaladvancements. Take for example, a sugar cane farm here in Swaziland. In a good year, withabundant rainfall, there is excess supply. In a year of drought however, supply will again fall. This

    can be represented in a diagram as shown on the following page.D S'' S

    S'

    P3P1P2

    q3 q1 q2

    Priceo

    ffarmp

    ro

    duce

    Quantity of farm produce

    S' good yearS'' year of drought

    As seen from the diagram, in a good year, supply shifts to the right causing equilibrium price to fall toP2while in a bad year (year of drought) supply shifts to the left causing equilibrium price to rise to P

    3.

    The previously discussed problems are not as prevelent in the manufacturing industry. Given thatsupply of manufactured goods is elastic due to the non-complexity of the production process, shifts indemand of manufactured products does not result in much of a change in price. Also, supply ofmanufactured products is more constant, again due to the nature of its production process.

    The student now uses another good

    diagram to explain and develop the

    answer in relation to how changes

    in supply will also lead to large

    fluctuations in prices for agricultural

    goods.

    The student suggests how the

    market for manufactured goods is

    different and why there would not

    be such large fluctuations in price.

    The student supplies an accurately

    drawn diagram and a good

    explanation of why the demandmay have changed, giving realistic

    factors, and using the diagram to

    illustrate the points made.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 28

  • 5/26/2018 Sample Answers 2 10- 5 10 Etc

    13/13

    The student understood the specific demands of the question and explained and developed relevant theory. Economic terms were

    defined in all cases and there were no significant errors. Some diagrams were introduced and explained. This puts the response clearly

    into level 3 and explains the mark of 8.

    The student concentrated too much upon agricultural goods and their prices and did not really go into enough detail regarding

    manufactured goods. No examples were given and there was no use of a diagram to show the relatively elastic demand, so level 4 could

    not be awarded.

    Examiner report

    Evaluate the proposition that government intervention in the market for tobacco is

    justified.

    15 mark

    The following is a typical question from

    paper 1 part (b) and you should spend

    approximately 35 minutes on it.

    [Taken from SL paper 1 May 200

    How do I approach the question?

    First, you need to identify what the question is asking you to

    evaluate, which in this case is the proposition that government

    intervention in the market for tobacco is justied. That is,

    should governments intervene in the tobacco market or not?

    So now you should explain that tobacco is a demerit good,

    in the form of cigarettes, and dene demerit goods. You may

    also explain that cigarettes are an example of a market failure

    in that they are over-provided and are over-consumed. Then

    draw a negative externalities (of consumption) diagram,showing that the marginal social benet (MSB) of cigarettes

    is less than the marginal private benet (MPB), and so the

    consumption of cigarettes causes a negative externality. Then

    you should explain the diagram.

    You may now explain the two main methods of government

    intervention in tobacco markets: indirect taxes on cigarettes,

    and increased regulation (such as bans, age restrictions, and

    health warnings). You may also draw a diagram to show the

    effect that these would have on the tobacco market.

    Now introduce and explain the arguments for government

    intervention, which may include reducing negative

    externalities and thus market failure, more socially efcient

    allocation of resources, improved health in the work force,

    and a source of government revenue.

    Now you should offer arguments against government

    intervention, which may include distorting the role of prices

    in the market, loss of employment in the tobacco industry,

    reduction of consumer choice, the creation of parallelmarkets, and the cost of negative advertising.

    Now evaluation can take place. You might compare the

    arguments for and against intervention and then decide that

    the arguments for are more weighty than the arguments

    against, since the intervention will affect more people

    positively than negatively and will lead to a more socially

    efcient allocation of resources.

    365_IB Prep Econ SL ch07.indd 29