rt in patients with cns germ cell tumors - qarc · rt in patients with cns germ cell tumors paul j...
TRANSCRIPT
RT in Patients with CNS Germ Cell Tumors
Paul J Chuba St John Providence Health SystemsDetroit and Warren MI
Germ Cell Tumors
Variety of Histologies Common Origin: Primordial Germ Cell Gonadal and Non-Gonadal Presentation
Testis, Ovary Mediastinum Retroperitoneum Pineal/Suprasellar
Definitions
Dysgerminoma: A malignant neoplasm of the ovary (counterpart of seminoma of the testis) composed of undifferentiated gonadal germinal cells
Seminoma: A malignant neoplasm of the testis of young males
Germinoma: A neoplasm of the germinal tissue of the gonads, mediastinum, or pineal region
Malignant CNS Germ Cell Tumors
Germ cell tumors (GCTs) make up about 3% of childhood malignancies.
Germ cell neoplasia : Requires formation of a transformed pluri-potential cell from a toti-
potential precursor germ cell which would otherwise be destined to gametogenesis.
Differentiation into embryonal-like (somatically differentiated) tumors, as well as extra-embryonally differentiated (choroid and yolk sac) tumors.
Occurs without fertilization and requires “erasing” of imprinting. Overexpression of cyclin D2 cell cycle G1/S checkpoint regulator.
Overview
What we have learned Background GCT and NGGCT
Some Results of Trials Europe and Japan POG and Single Institutions ACNS0122 for NGGCT ACNS0232 for GCT
Where we are going Newly opened COG trial
ACNS1123 response adapted RT for NGGCT and pure GCT
37%
41%
22%
suprasellapinealbifocal
33%
62%
5%
suprasellapinealbifocal
CNS GCT Location
GCT Secreting GCT
58%
37%
5%
germinomasGCTpure teratoma
PRIMARY CNS GCTHistopathology (SIOP)
Incidence (per million)
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
<1
1-4
5
-9
10-1
415
-19
20-2
4 25
-29
30-3
4 35
-39
40-4
4 45
-49
50-5
4 55
-59
60-6
4 65
-69
70-7
4 75
-79
80-8
4 85
+
Age at Diagnosis
Inci
denc
eCNS Germ Cell Tumors
Germinoma Touch Prep: High N/C Ratio
PAP Beta-HCG
Pineal Choriocarcinoma from 12 yo Female
HCG ReactivityTendency to Hemorrhage
Choriocarcinoma (HCG)
Yolk sac tumour (FP
embryonal carcinoma (FP + HCG)
PRIMARY CNS GCTNGGCTs
Immature Pineal Teratoma12 yo Male
Cartilage,Mucin Producing Columnar Epithelium.,Spindle Cell Stroma
Mature TeratomaResembles Benign Adult Cartilage,Respiratory Epithelium, Loose Fibrous Stroma
High Tech Radiation?
CSI WVRT
The Eye of Horus: Symbol of Power and Good HealthHorus Was Ancient Sky God Depicted as A Falcon (Mirror Image or Left Eye Sometime Represented the Moon)
A Phase II ConsortiumRobertson et al 2005 (U of M, Beth Israel, CHOP, Vancouver)
CNS NGGCT or Secretor (n=27) CDDP, IFOS, VP-16 RT 36 Gy CSI Except Localized Disease With CR After
Surgery or CHT (WV RT + Boost) For Less than CR, 2nd Look Sx plus Carbo/CTX x 2 with
PBSC Support Better PFS in Cases Achieving Initial CR 9/27 Relapsed 3/6 Relapsed Outside RT Field
“Emphasizes Need for CSI”
Amulets
POG 9530Wharam/Kretschmar et al
A Phase II Study of Chemotherapy/XRT for Primary Malignant Germ Cell Tumors of the Central Nervous System (i.e. both GCT and NGGCT)
Rationale Safer Biopsy Available to Identify Histologic Subtype Platinum Based Chemotherapy Found to Be Effective
Objectives Reduce Radiotherapy Dose by Using Chemo for Good Risk Patients (i.e. GCT) Improve Prognosis for Poor Risk Patients
(i.e. Non-germinoma histology, elevated AFP, HCG >50)
Four Courses CDDP/VP-16 alternating with Cytoxan/VCR followed by Radiation CDDP 40 mg/m2/d IV and VP-16 100 mg/m2/d IV x 5 days alternating with Cyt
2g/m2 for 2 days and VCR 1.5 mg/m2 IV days 1,8,15.
POG 9530 Schema
POG 9530 Results
11 of 14 NGGCT Patients Were Progression Free at Median 58 Mos (Range 42-71 Mos).
One Inevaluable Patient Received Only One Course of Chemo and Died During RT
One Patient With SD Died at 21 Mos of a Seizure at Home One Patient With Mixed Yolk-sac Tumor Developed PD Before RT
and Died of Disease 9 Months Later
EFS Was 79% +/-11 % for High-risk or NGGCT (N=14). Accrual Response Rate (5 of 9) and PFS Comparable to Previous
Reports
no sex age path site hcg hcg csf afp afp csf sx Matsut. Class rr status1 m 12.5 terato-choriocarcioma pineal 2424 220 10.5 4.5 gtr Poor not eval. PFS 67 mos2 f 13.9 germinoma pituitary 5496 nd nl nd pr interm PR 96% PFS 71 mos3 m 16.3 none pineal nl nl 286 314 shunt only ?int/poor PR PFS 61 mos4 m 16.9 yolk-sac teratoma pineal 13 nl 5190 26 75% poor early death DOD 2 mos5 m 18.1 mixed yolk-sac teratoma pineal 13 nd 274 nd pr poor PD DOD 15 mos6 f 11.2 germinoma met ineal/frontal 9990 9800 1141 153 biopsy interm PR PFS 64 mos7 m 10.4 adenoca-teratoma pineal nl nl nl nl gtr interm not eval. PFS 61 mos8 m 11.6 germinoma met pineal/csf 74 59 nl nl biopsy interm? CR PFS 58 mos9 m 7.1 none pineal 165 1550 14 8 none interm? SD PFS 43 mos
10 m 10.7 germ-chorio pineal nl 471 nl nl gtr poor not eval. PFS 52 mos11 f 6.5 germ-chorio suprasellar nl 2392 nl nl pr poor SD died of sz 21 mos12 m 16.2 none pineal 200 74 80 12 none poor? SD PFS 51 mos13 f 14 mixed suprasellar 719 3247 pr interm CR PFS 50 mos14 m 10.4 mixed yolk sac teratoma pineal 4 156 nl gtr poor not eval. PFS 50 mos
POG 9530: Results for NGGCT
SFOP without RTBaranzelli et al J Neurooncol 37 229-39. 1998
18 Secretors 10 AFP, 2 HCG, 6 Both 6 Cycles of Chemotherapy
Vinblastine-bleomycin - Carboplatin or Etoposide - Carboplatin/ifosfamide –Etoposide
Fifteen Patients Were Treated According to the Protocol By: Chemotherapy Alone (N=13) Or Chemotherapy and Radiation of Residue (2).
Twelve of the 13 Non Irradiated Patients Relapsed 8 in Local And/or Regional Area, 3 in Cerebrospinal Area and 1 Undetermined
12/18 Patients Alive With a Median Follow up of 68 Months. All but One Had Focal Radiation As Part of Treatment.
Six Patients in 2nd CR Chemotherapy And/or Surgery, Then Consolidation With Radiation
And/or High Dose Chemotherapy or Craniospinal Radiation ‘Focal Radiotherapy Should Be Part of the Treatment”
SFOP with Focal RTBarenzelli et al
27 Secreting GCT 15 AFP, 7 HCG, 5 Both Rx Carbo/VP Alt. IFOS (6-8 Courses) Focal RT 55 Gy, CSI for Mets (n=3) 14/27 Had Sx for Residual
Median F/U 53 Mos 20/27 Alive, 8/27 Relapsed
SIOP CNS GCT Study 96SIOP 2005 Report
13 CNS NGGCT CDDP,VP-16,Ifos x 4 Local Disease IF RT 54 Gy Met Disease 30 Gy CSI + 24 Gy Boost
Median F/U 39 Mos PFS 67% for Localized 72% for Metastatic
Residual After Induction and AFP >1000 Poor Prognosticators
Spinal Failure Rate?
SIOP CNS GCT Perilongo PROS 2007 Report
26 Of 123 NGGCT Were Metastatic Metastatic divided into CSF positive and Macroscopic. Non-metastatic includes Bifocal
Relapses “Mostly Ventricular” Survival
77% at 72 months for localized 66% at 72 months for metastatic
Residual disease at end of therapy? EFS 82% vs 45%
MatstutaniMatsutani et al J. Neurosurg 86:446 1997
“Pure” Malignant Choriocarcinoma, Endodermal Sinus Tumor or Embryonal Carcinoma 5 year OS of Less than 10 percent Greater than 70% OS for Mixed Tumors
Concluded: Treat Germinoma With Combination Chemotherapy and Reduced Dose
Radiation Therapy Intermediate risk NGGCT Cis or Carbo Combination with Radiation Poor Risk: Need More Aggressive Chemotherapy
Matsutani 12th Peds Neuro-Onc Symposium
38 HCG Secreting Germinoma (Treated As Pure Germinoma) CARE followed by local RT 24 Gy 5/38 Recurrences 5 yr OS 100%
40 NGGCT Intermediate Prognosis Group (n=40)
Malignant Teratoma and Mixed Tumor Mainly composed of germinoma or Teratoma)
CARE (Carbo/VP-16) Followed by Local RT 50 Gy 5 Yr OS 97%
Poor Prognosis Group (n=27): Choriocarcinoma, Yolk Sac, Embryonal, Mixed
ICE followed by CSI then ICE x 5 5 Yr OS 56%
Histology n= 1-yr 3-yr 5-yr 10 yr 15 yrGerminoma 50 100 95.4 95.4 92.7 87.9Germinoma with STGC 7 100 100 83.3 83.3 NCMature Teratoma 16 100 92.9 92.9 92.9 NCMalignant Teratoma 11 100 70.7 70.7 70.7 NCPure Malignant Germ Cell Tumor 11 45.5 27.3 27.3 NC NCMixed Tumor 39 87.2 61 57.1 40.1 NCGerminoma nd Teratoma (MGT) 17 94.1 94.1 84.7 70.6 NCGerminoma or Teratoma (MXB) 10 80 70 52.5 35 NCMainly Pure Elements (MXM) 12 83.3 9.3 9.3 NC NC
NC= not calculable
Matsutani et al 1997 J. Neurosurg 86:446 1997
The Questions?
Is Chemotherapy Effective and Are Responses Durable? YES cf Testicular Tumors
Is RT Needed? YES SFOP: 6 Cycles of Chemotherapy (with Surgery and Focal Radiation
for Viable Residual. 12 of 13 non-irradiated patients relapsed Kellie et al: Intensive chemo w/o RT effective in about 1/3 of
patients If RT then how much? Dose and Field Size
CSI Popularity Neurocognitive Function and Bone Growth Delay Second Malignancy? Endocrine ?
What Are the Spinal failure Rates? Predilection to Involve CNS
COG ACNS0122A Phase II Study to Assess the Ability
Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy and Second Look Surgery to Eliminate All Measurable Disease
Prior to Radiotherapy for NGGCT
ACNS0122 Eligibility
Age 3 to <25 yrs Histological Diagnosis
Yolk Sac Embryonal Carcinoma Choriocarcinoma Immature Teratoma & Teratoma With Malignant Transformation Mixed Germ Cell tumor
Histologically confirmed Germinoma with serum &/or CSF ß-HCG >50Iu/l
Pineal &/or suprasellar tumors with serum &/or CSF ß-HCG >50Iu/l; or AFP > 10
ACNS0122 NGGCT All patients received 6 cycles of chemotherapy (alternating
Carboplatin/Etoposide & Ifosfamide/Etoposide Patients with radiographic response and marker
normalization treated with CSI 36 Gy f/b IFRT to primary tumor to total dose of 54 Gy
Second look surgery was encouraged for residual disease Thiotepa/Etoposide f/b PBSC rescue was encouraged for
patients with viable disease
ACNS0122 NGGCT
104 patients enrolled 15 recurrences, 6 deaths Median f/u 2.8 years
Courtesy of Stewart Goldman, MD
ACNS0122
2 year EFS 84% + 4%OS 94% + 3%
Courtesy of Stewart Goldman, MD
Median TTP 0.4 yearsMedian TTD 0.77 years
ACNS0122
Relapses mainly local9 local recurrences4 distant
2 spinal1 spine and distant brain1 abdominal carcinomatosis
2 markers only
ACNS0122
Second look surgery for poor response (15) Teratoma (6) Malignant teratoma (3) Fibrosis (4) NGGCT (2)
Second look surgery for progressive disease (6) Growing Teratoma Syndrome (4) Embryonal (2)
Too few patients went on to HD chemotherapy f/b PBSC to assess efficacy
Pure Germinoma/ACNS 0232
ACNS0232 randomized trial comparing:
1) RT alone (WVRT 24 Gy f/b IFRT to total 45 Gy) –STANDARD ARM
2) Chemotherapy followed by response-based RT (2-4 cycles* f/b IFRT to 30 Gy).
*carboplatin/etoposide x2 f/b response assessment;If CR no further therapy & if < CR cisplatin/cyclophosphamide x 2
Ventricular Relapse
Reports of high rates of ventricular relapse led several cooperative groups to abandon IFRT as a treatment option
ACNS0232 closed to poor accrual
Alapetite, C, Neuro-oncology 2012
Conclusions
1 Increased risk of relapse with chemotherapy followed by IFRT
2 Radiation volume cannot be reduced from WVRT to IFRT
Can we reduce radiation dose for patients who are responding to chemotherapy?
WVRT
non-metast.TU 54 Gy
metastaticCSI 30 Gy+TU 24 Gy
non-metast.TU 54 Gy
metastaticCSI 30 Gy+TU 24 Gy
3 x PEI
3 x PEI
Res.
1 x PEI
Res.
HD PEIwith PBSC
only ifage > 5 y.
elseSTOP
EVALUATION
CR
PR
EVALUATION
CR
PR
PLANNED STRATEGY IN SIOP CNS GCT 2003- SECRETING GCTs -
AFP>25 ng/ml or ßHCG>50 IU/l in serum or CSF
standard riskAFP < 1000 ng/mland age > 5 yearsand completeworkup
high riskAFP > 1000 ng/mlor age < 5 yearsor incomplete workup
ACNS1123Phase 2 Trial of Response-Based Radiation Therapy for Patients with Localized
Central Nervous System Germ Cell Tumors
Germinoma
NGGCT
ACNS1123
Combines NGGCT and pure GCT (2 strata) Primary objectives:
1 To determine, as measured by 3 year PFS if volume/dose of RT can be reduced for NGGCT and if chemotherapy f/b low dose WVRT plus IF RT is effective for pure GCT
2 To prospectively evaluate the cognitive, social, and behavioral functioning of children and young adults who are treated with reduced RT dose/volume
Eligibility
Only for patients with localized disease
Bifocal tumors eligible
Patients with disease found on endoscopic examination of ventricles eligible
Eligibility
Stratum 1 (NGGCT) Patients with identified levels:
Serum and/or CSF ß-HCG >100 mIU/mL, or, Any elevation of serum and CSF AFP > 10 ng/mL, or,
institutional norm Biopsy not required
Patients with any of the following elements on biopsy/resection, irrespective of serum and/or CSF ß-HCG and AFP levels:
endodermal sinus tumor (yolk sac), embryonal carcinoma, choriocarcinoma, malignant/immature teratoma, mixed GCT with malignant GCT elements.
Eligibility
Stratum 2 (Germinoma) Patients with institutional normal AFP and ß-HCG 5 - ≤ 50 mIU/mL in
serum and/or CSF (biopsy not required) Patients with bifocal involvement or pineal lesion with DI and ß-HCG ≤
100 mIU/mL and institutional normal AFP in serum/CSF (biopsy not required)
Patients with histologically confirmed germinoma or germinoma mixed with mature teratoma and ß-HCG ≤ 100 mIU/mL and institutional normal AFP in serum/CSF
ACNS1123- pure GCT
Chemotherapy 4 cycles of Carboplatin/Etoposide
Radiation WVRT to 18 Gy IFRT to bring primary disease to total 30 Gy
RT Guidelines
3D planning required 3D photons, IMRT, protons allowed 2 CTV’s
Whole Ventricles Involved Field
Involved field CTV must be contoured upfront and added to whole ventricle volume to ensure full coverage
WVRT
While few patients were treated with WVRT on prior studies, all patients enrolled on ACN1123 will receive WVRT
Difficult volume to contour with variability among clinicians
Review of volumes from ACNS0232 demonstrated need for clear guidelines
ACNS1123 will allow for smaller margins and more conformal techniques
+Whole ventricle atlas
To improve consistency Provide a visual guide Decrease protocol violations
Will be available on QARC website
Stem Cell Research Points The Way To The Cell of Origin For Intracranial Germ Cell Tumors
Tan C, Scotting P. J. Pathol. 229:4-11 2013.
Neural Stem Cell leads to GCT?
Parental Chromosome DuplicationsImplies Possible Pre-Meiotic Event
Proposed Cell of Origin, the Germ Cell Progenitor, Would Not Normally Be Found In The Brain
No Other Class Of Primary Cancer Arises From A Cell From A Distant Organ
Evidence For Model Of Transformation Of Endogenous Brain Cells
Conclusions: North American Approach to CNS GCTs
Incremental Progress? Different Strategies Compared
Europe Japan
ACNS 0122, ACNS 1123 Goal: Define Risk – Tailor Treatment Future:
Radiation Questions? Achieve Consensus?