revolt of 1857 analysis
TRANSCRIPT
Indian Response to British Rule
Javab dena Padega......!
Indian Response
Traditional Modern
Traditional ResponseNature
Civilian Revolt
Peasant Revolt
Tribal Revolt
Leadership
Area
Chronology
Social Base
British Attitude
Hamri zameen cheen li....!!!!
Dhoka ho gaya...Kuch
karna padega
Traditional ResponseAb hogi aar paar ki ladai
1857 Revolt
Background
Morning of 11 May 1857. The city of Delhi had not yet woken up when a band of Sepoys from Meerut, who had defied and killed the European officers the previous day, crossed the Jamuna, set the toll house on fire and marched to the Red Fort
Revolt began at Meerut, 58 km from Delhi, on May 10, 1857
Before the Meerut incident
19th Native Infantry at Berhampur, which refused to use the newly introduced Enfield rifle and broke out in mutiny in February 1857
34th Native Infantry Mangal Pandeexecuted on April 6
Background
Introduction of the Enfield rifle
cartridge of the new rifle
bitten off before loading
Reports about the mixing of bone dust in atta (flour)
Grease was reportedly made of beef and pig fat
Administration did nothing to allay these fears
Sepoys felt their religion was in grave danger
General Reason
BackgroundApril 24, ninety men of 3rd Native Cavalry refused to accept the greased cartridgesMay 3,Awadh Regiment defied its officers order on rifle
May 9,eighty-five of them were dismissed, sentenced to 10 years imprisonment
May 10, the soldiers released their imprisoned comrades, killed their officers and unfurled the banner of revolt
All started moving towards Delhi
Aged and powerless Bahadur Shah Zafar was proclaimed the emperor of IndiaSpreading of the revolt to different parts of the country
Background
Kings, Queens
Participation seen from :
Zamindaars
Clerics of Muslims Community
Civilians, Peasants, Workers etc.
Angreezo ko bhagao yahan seHum bhi ladenge
Angrezo seJai Jawan...Jai Kisan
Area of Revolt
Reasons for the Revolt
Greased Cartridges
Reasons for the revolt of 1857
Political
Immediate Reason Fundamental Reason
Economic & Administration
Social & CulturalMilitary
Influence of outside events
Subsidiary Alliance
Fundamental Reasons
1. Political Causes
EIC’s Policy of Effective Control
Feelings of Muslims getting hurt due to ill treatment given to Bahardur Shah II
Extinction of Native Indian States
Reasons for the Revolt
Policy of Annexation & Doctrine of Lapse
I want to rule over Whole
India
Meri Jhansi nahin Dungi
Heavy Taxation Peasant
Fundamental Reasons2.Economic & Administrative Reasons
Land Revenue Settlement
Confiscation of their estatesTalukdars & Zamindars getting Deprived
Reasons for the Revolt
New Policies Ryotwari,Mahalwari
Exploitation of peasants by the money lenders
Breaking up of Indian Handicraft Industry due to British Economic Policies
Unilateral Free Trade Policy
Doogna Lagan
Zameen nahi rahi hamari ab!
50% interest pe paise milenge
Indian Soldiers & Civil Servants Less Salary
Fundamental Reasons2.Economic & Administrative Reasons
Rampant Corruption
Reasons for the Revolt
No higher Posts for them
Karl Marx (1853) It was the British intruder who broke up the Indian Handloom & destroyed the spinning wheel
Itna kaam karate ho...paisa bhi nahi dete
Policy of Contempt towards Hindus & Muslims
Fundamental Reasons3. Social & Religious Causes
English Infested with the spirit of Racialism
Reasons for the Revolt
Interference in Customs & Religious PracticesLex Loci Act 1850
Spreading Christianity Free Hand to Missionaries
Sati, Women Remarriage, Education
Hindu Gods & Goddesses RidiculedTaxation on Mosques & temple lands
We have WHITE Skin
Indian people are White man’s Burden
Discrimination to Indian Soldiers
Fundamental Reasons4. Military CausesReligious Interference
Reasons for the Revolt
Low Salary, No High Post, No Pension
Made to Serve away from home without paying extra ‘Bhatta’Overseas Campaign Eating & Drinking whatever that comes into wayCrossing the sea Bad for ReligionSinful for soldiers Once back, not taken into caste & even their barrack/regimentsExtensive Military CampaignsSoldier Peasant in UniformWould Empathize with the peasants in his village
Itna kaam karate ho...paisa bhi nahi dete
Jai Jawan...Jai Kisan
First Afghan War (1839-42)
Fundamental Reasons5.Influence of outside eventsBritish suffered serious losses
Reasons for the Revolt
Punjab Wars (1845-49)Crimean Wars (1854-56)Santhal rebellion (1855-57)
psychological repercussions
Aavo do Angrezo ne...Padi dais aaje
to...! :P
Views of Nationalist Historians Constantly Changing
Perceived differently by nationalists & colonial historians
Depending upon their socio-ideological beliefs
Nature of the Revolt
Colonial Historians General Tendency
Deny its patriotic & popular character
Highlight the elements of disunity, disorganisation & selfish character of the revolt
In doing so, they do not accept the elements of general discontent & grevieances of the Indian People accumulated over a period of time as a result of exploitative nature of British rule
Nature of the RevoltSir John Lawrence & Seely Sepoy Mutiny, Over patriotic & Selfish
LER Rees It was a war of religious fanatics. Both Hindus & Muslims against the Christians
TR Holmes It was a war between civilisation & barbarism
Nature of the RevoltSir Syed Ahmed Khan He held British responsible for the revoltAccepted general discontent among people
VD Savarkar First war of Indian National Independence
RC Majumdar It was neither first nor national nor war of Independence
Surendranath Sen It was a war which started for the protection of religion but got converted into war of independence
JL Nehru It was a feudal outburst headed by feudal chiefs
Causes of Failure of the Revolt
Limited territorial and social base
Crucial support of certain sections of Indian public to British authorities
Lack of resources as compared to those of the British
Bombay & Madras Armies remained loyal
Outburst only in Western Bihar, Awadh, Rohilkhand, Delhi etc.
Superiority of British Army, Disciplined force, Use of Modern Means of Communication
Causes of Failure of the RevoltFeudal in Character, Headed by Feudal Elements
Lack of a coherent ideology and a political perspective
Lack of coordination and a central leadership
Bahadurshah Emperor Nanasaheb Peshwa
Shahenshah bana diya humko re...!
Hum bhi Raja banege...!
Leaders of the Revolt
Begum Hazrat Mahal took over the reigns at Lucknow
Kanpur, the natural choice was Nana Saheb
At Bareilly, Khan Bahadur, a descendant of the former ruler ofRohilkhandRoyal Ujjaini House, the revolt was led by Kunwar Singh, the zamindar of JagdishpurMaulvi Ahmadullah of Faizabad
Rani Laxmibai, who assumed the leadership of the sepoys at Jhansi
Impact of the Revolt
Power transfer from EIC Crown, Hence British ParliamentGovernment of India Act 1858
Ab no more East India Co. Ki Sarkar
Ab ki baar Queen ki Sarkaar
Impact of the Revolt
Governor General of India Viceroy Lord Canning
Offices of Board of Control & Court of Directors were abolished
Instituted office of Secretary of State for India with council of 15 members
Members of the Indian Civil Service to be appointed on basis of Competition
Government of India Act 1858
Land of the zamindars was reinstated
No more annexations
Hum yahan ke Viceroy Hain !
Naye Rajyo ko British India mein nahin Milayenge
Question UPSC Pre 2014Q. What was/were the object/objects of Queen Victoria’s Proclamation (1858)1. To Disclaim any intention to annex Indian States
2. To place the Indian administration under British Crown
Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?
(a) 1 and 2
(b) Only 2
(c) 1 and 3
(d) All of these
2. To regulate East India Company’s trade with India
Question UPSC Pre 2006Q. Who was the governor general of India during Sepoy Mutiny?
(a) Lord Canning
(b) Lord Hardinge
(c) Lord Dalhousie
(d) Lord Lyton
Question UPSC Pre 2005Q. Which one of the following places did Kunwar Singh, a prominent leader of the Revolt of 1857 belong to?
(a) Bihar
(b) Rajasthan
(c) Madhya Pradesh
(d) Uttarpradesh
Question UPSC Pre 2005Q. Which one of the following territories was not affected by the revolt of 1857?
(a) Jhansi
(b) Jagdishpur
(c) Chittor
(d) Lucknow
Indian Response
Traditional Modern
Freedom Struggle Indian National Movement
Development of Nationalism
Politics of Association
Formation of CongressEarly Nationalists-Moderates
Development of Nationalism
What is a State?
What is a Nation-State?
What do you mean by Nationalism?
What is Nation?
StateWhat do you mean by State?
The term ‘State’ in its modern sense was first used by Machiavelli (1469-1527), the Italian statesman
The State consists of four elements
(a) the people
(b) the territory on which they live
(c) the government to rule and regulate the lives of the people
(d) sovereignty
Thank You