review article -based photocatalytic process for purification of...
TRANSCRIPT
Hindawi Publishing CorporationJournal of NanomaterialsVolume 2013 Article ID 319637 14 pageshttpdxdoiorg1011552013319637
Review ArticleTiO2-Based Photocatalytic Process for Purification of PollutedWater Bridging Fundamentals to Applications
Chuan Wang Hong Liu and Yanzhen Qu
Key Laboratory of Reservoir Aquatic Environment Chinese Academy of Sciences Chongqing Institute of Green andIntelligent Technology Chongqing 401122 China
Correspondence should be addressed to Hong Liu liuhongcigitaccn
Received 19 June 2013 Revised 6 July 2013 Accepted 7 July 2013
Academic Editor Jiaguo Yu
Copyright copy 2013 Chuan Wang et al This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution Licensewhich permits unrestricted use distribution and reproduction in any medium provided the original work is properly cited
Recent years have witnessed a rapid accumulation of investigations on TiO2-based photocatalysis which poses as a greatly
promising advanced oxidation technology for water purification As the ability of this advanced oxidation process is welldemonstrated in lab and pilot scales to decompose numerous recalcitrant organic compounds and microorganism as well in waterfurther overpass of the hurdles that stand before the real application has become increasingly importantThis review focuses on thefundamentals that govern the actual water purification process including the fabrication of engineered TiO
2-based photocatalysts
process optimization reactor design and economic consideration The state of the art of photocatalyst preparation strategies forprocess optimization and reactor design determines the enhanced separation of photo-excited electron-hole (e-h) pairs on the TiO
2
surface For the process optimization the kinetic analysis including the rate-determining steps is in need For large-scale applicationof the TiO
2-based photocatalysis economics is vital to balance the fundamentals and the applied factors The fundamentals in this
review are addressed from the perspective of a bridge to the real applicationsThis reviewwould bring valuably alternative paradigmto the scientists and engineers for their associated research and development activities with an attempt to push the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis towards industrially feasible applications
1 Introduction
Heterogeneous photocatalysis based on semiconductors haswitnessed rapid progress in the last decades [1ndash3] The semi-conductor photocatalyst of which the electrons in the valenceband can be promoted to the conduction band when beingexcited by adequate photoenergy possesses photogeneratedelectron-hole (e-h) pairs The e-h pairs enable a series ofreductive and oxidative reactions [4ndash6] and some of themfurther result in valuable reactions This method has beeninitially put forward for the extraction of hydrogen energyfrom water via the conversion of photoenergy in the 1970swhen the energy crises has emerged [7] Later in the 1980s ithas been tested as an environmental purification alternativefor water [8 9] and gas [10] as wellThis review focuses on thewater purification by addressing the fundamentals that servesas a connection with the real-time application
Many reports have evidenced that numerous organictoxic compounds often present in water can be removed bythe photocatalyticmethod Chlorinated compounds alkenes
alkanes aromatics dyes and so forth have been tested asthe model pollutants [2 3 11 12] The rationale for TiO
2
photocatalytic method is predominantly based on the oxida-tion of pollutants by means of hydroxyl radicals (HO∙) thatfeature the advanced oxidation technologies (AOTs) [13 14]The HO∙ production can be expressed as follows
H2O + h ℎ]997888rarr ∙OH+H+ (1)
The h (hole) is highly oxidative and the oxidation of water byh leads to a formation of HO∙ radicals which are extremelyactive and nonselective in attacking the substrates in aqueoussolution Meanwhile the electron (e) needs to be scavengedby an electron acceptor Accordingly the photogeneratede-h pairs are separated leading to the transformation ofpollutants Otherwise the photogenerated e-h pairs will beself-combined with an undesired release of thermal energyAs desired the photogenerated e-h pairs should be separatedas far as possible to improve the process performance ofphotocatalysis
2 Journal of Nanomaterials
The TiO2photocatalysis has attracted great attention as
a promising water treatment technology due to quite a fewintrinsic advantages (i) Powerful ability to decompose thepollutants the organic pollutants can be decomposed andeven mineralized due to the dramatic powerful oxidationability of HO∙ Consequently this technique can be utilizedwidely in the cases once the advanced treatment of waterparticularly containing the recalcitrant organic compoundsis demanded (ii) Ambient operating conditions the processcan be realized under ambient operating conditions and thusis acknowledged as quite safe (iii) Low cost the sunlightcan be employed as the energy source and the oxidant isambient O
2 Meanwhile as the TiO
2photocatalyst can be
recycled the cost can be further cut off to run the process(iv) Environmentally friendliness TiO
2are chemically sta-
ble nearly non-toxic or relatively safe even in the harshconditions Thus the TiO
2photocatalysis is thought as an
environmentally-friendly approach even if recent concernsarise on its environmental risks as it is released into theenvironment [15]
Many reports available in recent years have evidencedthat numerous organic contaminants can be decomposed oreven mineralized [16] by photocatalysis and the mechanismgoverning the photocatalytic process on the TiO
2surface has
been disclosed in depth [17] Also efforts for preparationof photocatalytic materials [7ndash9 18ndash22] which include themodification of the commonly used TiO
2photocatalyst
and the design and preparation of new photocatalysts areintensively exerted These efforts inclusively have attemptsto accelerate the degradation process of target substrates byenhancing the separation efficiency of e-h pairs or to extendthe wavelength of excitation light from ultraviolet (UV)regime to visible regime
Along with the lab-scale investigation of simulated waste-water some pilot-scale tests have been performed [23 24]It could be understood that although the results served todemonstrate the technical feasibility for water purificationtheTiO
2photocatalysis is still facing a series of technical chal-
lenges for a large-scale installment in wastewater treatmentplants (WWTPs) It must be noted that challenges such asfabrication of active TiO
2photocatalyst rapid separation and
recycling of TiO2after use and optimization of the overall
process are determined by the fundamentals In particularthe connection between the fundamentals and the actualscenario should be well understood by both the scientistsand engineers as they are performing their own individualtasks
However the fundamentals which have been well estab-lished in the literature are far from being fully understoodor sophisticatedly applied in the actual application Also theoperating parameters optimized in laboratory often suffera mismatching with the actual scenario In view of theproblem this review highlights the connection between thetwo tasks which is expected to bring valuable informationfor the academia and industry Along with this highlight theeconomic consideration was covered which eventually leadsto a balance between the various variables working in theTiO2photocatalytic process
2 Water Purification of TiO2
Photocatalysis
With the increasing demand of the water sources novel tech-nologies which serve to purify the polluted water with pow-erful ability to decompose the pollutants in energy-saving andenvironmentally-benignmanners are becoming essential Aswell known conventional technologies such as filtrationcoagulation adsorption and precipitation principally serveto transfer the pollutants from one phase to another Thenewly emerging membrane separation technology [25] alsobelongs to such category Following them further steps mustbe taken to treat or dispose the transferred pollutants In thisregard chemical oxidation featured by their ability to destroythe molecular structures of pollutants is an indispensibleoption During the processes the toxicity of the involvedorganic moieties is likely to extenuate or aggravate and thusthe degree of pollutant degradation should be in controlMoreover the concept of wastewater will become out of datesince the so-called wastewater is just staying at a stage duringthe overall recycling of water as a resource The TiO
2-based
photocatalytic process harnessing the sunlight as an energysource and ambient O
2as an oxidant for water purification
is capable of exhaustively mineralizing the organic pollutantsand eliminating the toxicity Thus the TiO
2-based photo-
catalysis is accepted as an effective tool to purify the pollutedwater
As listed in Table 1 the water which is polluted by textilepesticides medicine and so forth can be treated by theTiO2-based photocatalysis It should be pointed out that the
TiO2-based photocatalysis is just employed as an individ-
ual method herein Actually however effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes commonly contain recalcitrant ornonbiodegradable pollutants and thus an integrated processcontaining biological and physicochemical units will bemoreapplicable Basically in the front of integrated process theinfluent can be subjected to a physical unit such as filtration orgrilling to separate the solids Following is a physicochemicalunit such as coagulation to remove the colloidal substancesSubsequently a biological unit including aerobic or inaero-bic oxidation serves to degrade most of the biodegradableorganic molecules and thus the water quality is usuallyimproved in terms of the indexes such as chemical oxygendemand (COD) and NH
3-N Finally a chemical means such
as the TiO2-based photocatalytical process is incorporated to
purify the water by finally removing the recalcitrant organicpollutants
From the technical point of view the TiO2-based pho-
tocatalytical process is applicable as one prerequisite issatisfied which is the transparency of water The transpa-rency ensures the transmission of the light The TiO
2-based
photocatalytical process can be installed as a pretreatmentunit or an advanced unit If the effluent is in need of furtherpurification to destroy the nondegradable organic pollutantsthe TiO
2-based photocatalytical process follows the bio-
logical unit Alternatively the TiO2-based photocatalytical
process is put in front of the biochemical unit to improvebiodegradability for a better biological oxidization of theorganic substrates
Journal of Nanomaterials 3
Table 1 Engineered TiO2 the associated treated targets reactors and principal operation parameters
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2 P25 Pharmaceutical wastewater Sequencingbatch biological reactor
H2O2 dosage TiO2 dosage pHirradiation time and hydraulic
retention time[73]
TiO2carbonaerogel
High-concentration dyewastewater
Photocatalysis-enhancedelectrosorption reactor
Electrochemical adsorptionpotential temperature initial pH
and wavelength[74]
TiO2 P25Wastewater treatment plant
effluentsLab-scale solarphotoreactor
Temperature pH and lightwavelength
[75]
TiO2 nanofiber Hospital wastewater Batch annular slurryphotoreactor (ASP)
Fine bubble aeration lightwavelength and pH
[76]
Nano TiO2 Paper mill wastewater Solar reactor TiO2 dosage pH [59]
C-TiO2 Antibiotics wastewaterA computerized LuzchemCCP-4V photochemical
reactorpH wastewater flow rate [77]
TiO2 P25 Antibiotics wastewater Capacity cylindrical acrylicphotoreactor
pH gas rate light intensity andTiO2 dosage
[78]
TiO2SiO2 beadsOrganic
compounds-containingwastewater
Batch recirculation typephotocatalytic reactor pH wastewater flow rate [79]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Pebble bed photocatalyticreactor
TiO2 pebbles water treatment afterabsorption of reflow exhaust gas
[80]
TiO2 P25 Industrial wastewater A hermetically sealedphotoreactor
Pressure adsorption time andtemperature
[81]
PFTTiO2Toxic heavy metals
wastewaterA column glassphotoreactor Wavelength [82]
TiO2 P25 Secondary effluent A cylindrical glass reactor Amount of TiO2 loaded maximumemission peak
[83]
TiO2Ti anode Textile wastewaterA thin-film
photoelectrocatalyticreactor
pH lamp position and lightintensity
[84 85]
TiO2 P25Pharmaceutical andcosmetic wastewater Common photoreactor pH time catalysts and H2O2
concentration[86]
TiO2 P25 Olive mill wastewater Common photoreactor Light wavelength pH [87]
TiO2 P25Textile dyehouse
wastewaterImmersion well batch-type
photoreactorpH light wavelength temperature
and H2O2 concentration[22]
TiO2SiO2DNP and municipal
wastewaterFixed bed circulation type
reactor Water flow rate residence time [88]
AgndashTiO2 Seawaterpoly (methyl methacrylate)
reactors temperature dosage of bacterialsuspension and O3
[89]
SndashTiO2 MC-LR in surface water Borosilicate glass dish pH light wavelength [90]
nano TiO2 Drinking water Tank-style reactor Permeate flux with a membrane [91]
TiO2 P25 Surface water Photovoltaic reactor Temperature [92]
TiO2 P25 Benzalkonium chloride Annular glass reactor Light wavelength TiO2 dosage [93]NF-TiO2-P25films Drinking water Glass
vessel reactor Light intensity pH [94]
TiO2microsphere
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCylindrical photoreactor Light wavelength concentration of
TiO2 suspensions[66]
TiO2 films MC-LR in surface water Sealed round pyrex reactorTemperature water flow rate pHTiO2 coating surface area and
thickness[95]
4 Journal of Nanomaterials
Table 1 Continued
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2(P25)-AGSToxic heavy metal
wastewater A photocatalytic bath pH dosage of catalyst andtemperature
[96]
TiO2 P25 Drinking water Cylindrical Pyrex reactionvessel Catalyst loading light wavelength [97]
TiO2 P25Organic
compounds-containingwastewater
A thermostated reactor Temperature dissolved oxygenconcentration
[60]
TiO2-modifiednanofiltrationmembranes
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCell reactor Light intensity temperatures [98]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Immersion well reactor Dosage of TiO2 and H2O2 pH [99]
TiO2 filmsupported on aporous nickelnet
Pesticides Reactor with ozonegenerator
pH ozone dosage treatment timeand temperature
[100]
TiO2nanotubulararrays
Swimming pool water Cylindrical glass reactor pH potential [101]
VB
Self-combination
Ligh
t
OrganiccompoundEnergy
level
O2
CB
HOO∙
HO∙
HO∙
CO2 + H2OH2O OHminus
O2
H2O2
H+
Eg
h+
h+
eminus
∙O2
minus
Figure 1 The scheme of TiO2photocatalytic process
3 Fundamentals
To develop a real TiO2-based photocatalytical process opti-
mization of the operating parameters is of importanceHowever the fundamentals that have been well establishedin laboratory are not utilized sophisticatedly or even over-looked in real application Also the parameters that areoptimized in the laboratory test which has only one substrateare not applicable in the full-scale process The presenceof cosubstrates in wastewater may significantly influencethe degradation of target substrate C Lin and K S Linhave observed that the presence of humic acid (HA) reta-rded the photocatalytic degradation of 4-chlorophenol [26]
Consequently the fundamentals that closely connect the realscenario should be focused on Herein the e-h pair gener-ation and separation adsorption of organic substrate andrate determining step (RDS) of the photocatalytic reactionare addressed These fundaments are analyzed on how todefine amaximized efficiency in real application whereas anysuccessful and competitive real process should get a balancebetween efficiency and economics
31 Importance of Photogenerated e-h Pair Separation TheTiO2photocatalytic process starts with the generation and
separation of e-h pairs which are illustrated in Figure 1 Based
Journal of Nanomaterials 5
on the mechanism of photocatalytic oxidation proposed byHoffmann et al [27] the reactions on the TiO
2can be
correspondingly expressed as follows
TiO2+ ℎ]lArrrArr (TiO
2minus h) + (TiO
2minus e) (2a)
Redinterface1198961
lArrrArr
119896minus1
(TiO2minus Red)surface (2b)
∙OH+ (TiO2minus h)
1198962
lArrrArr
119896minus2
(TiO2minus∙OH) (2c)
(TiO2minus∙OH) + (TiO
2minus Red)surface
1198963
lArrrArr
119896minus3
(TiO2minusO119909)surface + e
(2d)
It could be understood that upon the photo-excitation theelectrons on the valence band (VB) jump to the conductionband (CB) generating h left on the VB As the electrons andholes initially separate and interact with substrates in thesolution and then combine together an effective conversionof substances is thus resulted in As recombination occursthere is no any conversion of substances
Following the generation of holes and electrons radicalsof HO∙ are generated and considered to work as the principaloxidative species during the photocatalytic process Xiang etal have proposed a concept of ldquoOH-indexrdquo to quantitativelycharacterize the production of HO∙ on different photocat-alytic systems [28] Such index which can bemeasured easilyby photoluminescence technique is using coumarin as aprobe molecule It appears that this index is quite adequateto explain the activity difference in different systems Forexample P25 TiO
2 which is a most available commercial
photocatalyst has the highest ldquoOH-indexrdquo as illustrated inFigure 2
The photoenergy plays an important role in the e-hseparation The energy that is sufficient to generate the e-h pairs must surpass the energy of TiO
2band gap The
equation 119864 = h120582 designates the relationship between theenergy and the associated light wavelength TiO
2(119899-type)
has a band gap of 32 eV Accordingly the light wavelengthmust be shorter than 380 nm which falls into the range ofUV light This requirement determines that a full illumi-nation of the photocatalyst is an indispensible factor whendesigning a real photocatalyticmatrix First an artificial lampmust be installed Lamps with 254 nm and 365 nm as themain wavelength are well commercialized A more powerfulillumination of the photocatalyst certainly accelerates thee-h pair generation High-pressure mercury lamp is alsopowerful whereas its illumination is not stable and thusnot recommended for real application Many lamps can beinstalled together in the photocatalytic reactor to ensurea full illumination while the heat release should also betaken into account as the illumination time lasts a long timeSecond the target water must be sufficiently transparentfor the transmission of the light Accordingly following thepretreatment that serves to remove the particles or speciesthat shadow the light the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process
can bewell employedThird only theUV lamps that aremade
Photocatalysts
OH
-inde
x
100
60
40
80
20
0 21 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
(1) P25
(2) Am
(3) A
(4) R
(5) ZnO
(6) SnO2
(7) SrTiO3
(8) BaTiO3
(10) V2O5
(13) CdS
(14) CuS
(15) BiOCl
(16) BiOI
(17) ZnS
(19) BiOBr
(20) CuO
(26) NiO
(11) Bi2WO4
(12) CeO2
(18) Cr2O3
(21) MnO2
(22) Fe2O3
(23) BiVO4
(24) ZrO2
(25) La2O3
(9) WO3 (27) Bi2O3
Figure 2 Comparison of OH-index of various photocatalystsArrows represent OH-index = 0 Am A and R denote amorphousanatase and rutile of TiO
2 respectivelyThis figure is taken from the
article of Xiang et al [28]
from quartz glass can be immersed in water Fourth even ifan immobilization of the TiO
2photocatalyst serves to recover
the TiO2 it may bring about a decrease in the e-h generation
due to the decrease in the illumination intensity caused by thewater shadow As a result in real application the suspendedTiO2instead of the immobilized TiO
2is more efficient
Li et al have reported a type of suspended TiO2micro-
sphere which allows both the TiO2suspension and recovery
[29]
32Measure for e-h Pair Separation Following the photogen-eration of e-h pairs a fast recombination of charge carries isthermodynamically favorable and thus yields a low quantumyield of the reactive species for organic degradation Obvi-ously any effort to facilitate the e-h separation and inhibitits recombination is encouraged Many measures includingTiO2modification scavenge of electrons and imposition of
external force are allowed to enhance the e-h separation
321 TiO2Preparation The TiO
2is a cornerstone of the
photocatalytic process In laboratory it is often prepared bymethods such as sol-gel method and hydrothermal methodThe physical morphology is controllable through hydrother-mal preparation while the TiO
2is chemically composed of
two crystalline types of anatase and rutile The rutile type
6 Journal of Nanomaterials
is more stable and the thermal treatment of anatase typeleads to a transformation to rutile The difference in thedistribution of the two types is considered to determine theassociated catalytic activity Basically pure rutile is found toexhibit a poor activity while a suitable composition may bemore active than the pure anatase type [30] The preassumedcorrelation between the composition of crystal phase andthe e-h pair separation has been clearly evidenced Recentlyhowever Xu and coworkers have found that the anataseand rutile have the same activity in the degradation of 4-chlorophenol and the difference just lies in their differentadsorption ability towards O
2[31 32] Thus as the TiO
2
with different crystal phases is fabricated the O2adsorption
ability on the individual crystal phase needs to be takeninto account The composition of TiO
2photocatalyst can be
adjusted through thermal treatment by means of the increasein temperature
322 TiO2Doping To overcome the drawback of low photo-
catalytic efficiency brought by the e-h self-combination thebare TiO
2can be further modified by doping a foreign ion
Table 2 shows that various metal ions metal oxides and afew nonmetal elements such as nitrogen sulfur fluorine andsilicon can be employed as the dopants
Gurkan et al [33] have reported the density functiontheory (DFT) calculation of the Se(IV)-doping of TiO
2
sample showing that the doping does not cause a significantchange in the positions of the band edges whereas producesadditional electronic states originating from the Se 3p orbitalsin the band-gap Accordingly the electrons can be excitedfrom the defect state to the conduction band by a relativelylower energy and thus visible light can be utilized Furtherthe benefit of the doped transition metal lies in the improvedtrapping of electrons to inhibit e-h recombination duringirradiation
In real application for water purification special attentionshould be paid to the potential leakage of the doped ionswhich may result in a secondary pollution in the treatedwater In this regard the N-doped TiO
2appears to be a
promising method due to the cleanness brought by thenitrogen and has attracted great attention in recent yearsIn particular the photocatalytic activity under visible lightillumination has been well evidenced [34ndash40] Howeverthe unanimity exists for the photocatalytic mechanism Forexample Irie et al have stated that the irradiation with UVlight excites the electrons in both the VB and the impurityenergy levels but illumination with visible light only exciteselectrons in the impurity energy level [41] Ihara et al haveconcluded that the oxygen-deficient sites formed in the grainboundaries are importantly attributed to the visible lightactivity while the doped nitrogen in part of the oxygen-deficient sites is important as a blocker for reoxidation[42]
Also for the application of the fabricated TiO2 the
intrinsic advantages brought by the preparation methodsshould be accurately analyzed so as to appropriately ascribethe accelerated activities to the e-h separation For exampleLiu et al [43] have reported that a heat treatment of TiO
2
by hydrogen does not lead to any change in the physical
Table 2 Doping of TiO2 for the enhanced photocatalytic activity
Doped TiO2 Doping method References
N-doped TiO2Sol-gel method microwave
hydrothermal method [34ndash36]
Si-doped TiO2Hydrolysis of titanium
isopropoxide [102 103]
Si-doped TiO2ZrO2 Sol-gel method [37]S-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Hydrothermal method [38]
SiO3
2minus doped TiO2films Hydrothermal method [39]
NS co-doped TiO2Manual grinding ofthiourea and urea [104]
S-doped TiO2Tielectrode Anodization method [105]
S-doped TiO2-ZrO2nanoparticles Sol-gel method [40]
CndashN-doped TiO2nanotube
Chemical vapor deposition(CVD) [61]
Se(IV) on DegussaP25 Wet impregnation [33]
Al(III)-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [106]V-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [107]Fe-doped TiO2 Hydrothermal method [62]PolypyrroleFe-dopedTiO2
Sol-gel method emulsionpolymerization [108]
Er3+ YAlO3Fe- andCo-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [109]
Cu2+-dopedTiO2SiO2
Sol-gel method [110]
ZnFe2O4 on TiO2 Sol-gel method [111]
Ag doped TiO2Photoreduction using the
sacrificial acid [112]
AgF-TiO2Sol-gel method
photoreduction method [113]
Ag-TiO2-xNx Sol-gel method [114]Sn-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [115]Lanthanideions-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [116]
La3+Zr4+ co-dopedTiO2
Sol-microwave methodoil-bath condition synthesis [117]
Ce-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [118]Ce-doped TiO2microspheres solvothermal method [67]
NdF doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [119]W-doped TiO2 Solvothermal method [120]
W-TiO2 films Liquid phase deposition(LPD) [121]
WN co-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Sol-hydrothermal method [122]
Bi-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [123]C-dope TiO2 powders Oxidative annealing of TiC [41]
properties including the crystal phase specific surface areaand particle size However results of electron paramagnetic
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
2 Journal of Nanomaterials
The TiO2photocatalysis has attracted great attention as
a promising water treatment technology due to quite a fewintrinsic advantages (i) Powerful ability to decompose thepollutants the organic pollutants can be decomposed andeven mineralized due to the dramatic powerful oxidationability of HO∙ Consequently this technique can be utilizedwidely in the cases once the advanced treatment of waterparticularly containing the recalcitrant organic compoundsis demanded (ii) Ambient operating conditions the processcan be realized under ambient operating conditions and thusis acknowledged as quite safe (iii) Low cost the sunlightcan be employed as the energy source and the oxidant isambient O
2 Meanwhile as the TiO
2photocatalyst can be
recycled the cost can be further cut off to run the process(iv) Environmentally friendliness TiO
2are chemically sta-
ble nearly non-toxic or relatively safe even in the harshconditions Thus the TiO
2photocatalysis is thought as an
environmentally-friendly approach even if recent concernsarise on its environmental risks as it is released into theenvironment [15]
Many reports available in recent years have evidencedthat numerous organic contaminants can be decomposed oreven mineralized [16] by photocatalysis and the mechanismgoverning the photocatalytic process on the TiO
2surface has
been disclosed in depth [17] Also efforts for preparationof photocatalytic materials [7ndash9 18ndash22] which include themodification of the commonly used TiO
2photocatalyst
and the design and preparation of new photocatalysts areintensively exerted These efforts inclusively have attemptsto accelerate the degradation process of target substrates byenhancing the separation efficiency of e-h pairs or to extendthe wavelength of excitation light from ultraviolet (UV)regime to visible regime
Along with the lab-scale investigation of simulated waste-water some pilot-scale tests have been performed [23 24]It could be understood that although the results served todemonstrate the technical feasibility for water purificationtheTiO
2photocatalysis is still facing a series of technical chal-
lenges for a large-scale installment in wastewater treatmentplants (WWTPs) It must be noted that challenges such asfabrication of active TiO
2photocatalyst rapid separation and
recycling of TiO2after use and optimization of the overall
process are determined by the fundamentals In particularthe connection between the fundamentals and the actualscenario should be well understood by both the scientistsand engineers as they are performing their own individualtasks
However the fundamentals which have been well estab-lished in the literature are far from being fully understoodor sophisticatedly applied in the actual application Also theoperating parameters optimized in laboratory often suffera mismatching with the actual scenario In view of theproblem this review highlights the connection between thetwo tasks which is expected to bring valuable informationfor the academia and industry Along with this highlight theeconomic consideration was covered which eventually leadsto a balance between the various variables working in theTiO2photocatalytic process
2 Water Purification of TiO2
Photocatalysis
With the increasing demand of the water sources novel tech-nologies which serve to purify the polluted water with pow-erful ability to decompose the pollutants in energy-saving andenvironmentally-benignmanners are becoming essential Aswell known conventional technologies such as filtrationcoagulation adsorption and precipitation principally serveto transfer the pollutants from one phase to another Thenewly emerging membrane separation technology [25] alsobelongs to such category Following them further steps mustbe taken to treat or dispose the transferred pollutants In thisregard chemical oxidation featured by their ability to destroythe molecular structures of pollutants is an indispensibleoption During the processes the toxicity of the involvedorganic moieties is likely to extenuate or aggravate and thusthe degree of pollutant degradation should be in controlMoreover the concept of wastewater will become out of datesince the so-called wastewater is just staying at a stage duringthe overall recycling of water as a resource The TiO
2-based
photocatalytic process harnessing the sunlight as an energysource and ambient O
2as an oxidant for water purification
is capable of exhaustively mineralizing the organic pollutantsand eliminating the toxicity Thus the TiO
2-based photo-
catalysis is accepted as an effective tool to purify the pollutedwater
As listed in Table 1 the water which is polluted by textilepesticides medicine and so forth can be treated by theTiO2-based photocatalysis It should be pointed out that the
TiO2-based photocatalysis is just employed as an individ-
ual method herein Actually however effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes commonly contain recalcitrant ornonbiodegradable pollutants and thus an integrated processcontaining biological and physicochemical units will bemoreapplicable Basically in the front of integrated process theinfluent can be subjected to a physical unit such as filtration orgrilling to separate the solids Following is a physicochemicalunit such as coagulation to remove the colloidal substancesSubsequently a biological unit including aerobic or inaero-bic oxidation serves to degrade most of the biodegradableorganic molecules and thus the water quality is usuallyimproved in terms of the indexes such as chemical oxygendemand (COD) and NH
3-N Finally a chemical means such
as the TiO2-based photocatalytical process is incorporated to
purify the water by finally removing the recalcitrant organicpollutants
From the technical point of view the TiO2-based pho-
tocatalytical process is applicable as one prerequisite issatisfied which is the transparency of water The transpa-rency ensures the transmission of the light The TiO
2-based
photocatalytical process can be installed as a pretreatmentunit or an advanced unit If the effluent is in need of furtherpurification to destroy the nondegradable organic pollutantsthe TiO
2-based photocatalytical process follows the bio-
logical unit Alternatively the TiO2-based photocatalytical
process is put in front of the biochemical unit to improvebiodegradability for a better biological oxidization of theorganic substrates
Journal of Nanomaterials 3
Table 1 Engineered TiO2 the associated treated targets reactors and principal operation parameters
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2 P25 Pharmaceutical wastewater Sequencingbatch biological reactor
H2O2 dosage TiO2 dosage pHirradiation time and hydraulic
retention time[73]
TiO2carbonaerogel
High-concentration dyewastewater
Photocatalysis-enhancedelectrosorption reactor
Electrochemical adsorptionpotential temperature initial pH
and wavelength[74]
TiO2 P25Wastewater treatment plant
effluentsLab-scale solarphotoreactor
Temperature pH and lightwavelength
[75]
TiO2 nanofiber Hospital wastewater Batch annular slurryphotoreactor (ASP)
Fine bubble aeration lightwavelength and pH
[76]
Nano TiO2 Paper mill wastewater Solar reactor TiO2 dosage pH [59]
C-TiO2 Antibiotics wastewaterA computerized LuzchemCCP-4V photochemical
reactorpH wastewater flow rate [77]
TiO2 P25 Antibiotics wastewater Capacity cylindrical acrylicphotoreactor
pH gas rate light intensity andTiO2 dosage
[78]
TiO2SiO2 beadsOrganic
compounds-containingwastewater
Batch recirculation typephotocatalytic reactor pH wastewater flow rate [79]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Pebble bed photocatalyticreactor
TiO2 pebbles water treatment afterabsorption of reflow exhaust gas
[80]
TiO2 P25 Industrial wastewater A hermetically sealedphotoreactor
Pressure adsorption time andtemperature
[81]
PFTTiO2Toxic heavy metals
wastewaterA column glassphotoreactor Wavelength [82]
TiO2 P25 Secondary effluent A cylindrical glass reactor Amount of TiO2 loaded maximumemission peak
[83]
TiO2Ti anode Textile wastewaterA thin-film
photoelectrocatalyticreactor
pH lamp position and lightintensity
[84 85]
TiO2 P25Pharmaceutical andcosmetic wastewater Common photoreactor pH time catalysts and H2O2
concentration[86]
TiO2 P25 Olive mill wastewater Common photoreactor Light wavelength pH [87]
TiO2 P25Textile dyehouse
wastewaterImmersion well batch-type
photoreactorpH light wavelength temperature
and H2O2 concentration[22]
TiO2SiO2DNP and municipal
wastewaterFixed bed circulation type
reactor Water flow rate residence time [88]
AgndashTiO2 Seawaterpoly (methyl methacrylate)
reactors temperature dosage of bacterialsuspension and O3
[89]
SndashTiO2 MC-LR in surface water Borosilicate glass dish pH light wavelength [90]
nano TiO2 Drinking water Tank-style reactor Permeate flux with a membrane [91]
TiO2 P25 Surface water Photovoltaic reactor Temperature [92]
TiO2 P25 Benzalkonium chloride Annular glass reactor Light wavelength TiO2 dosage [93]NF-TiO2-P25films Drinking water Glass
vessel reactor Light intensity pH [94]
TiO2microsphere
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCylindrical photoreactor Light wavelength concentration of
TiO2 suspensions[66]
TiO2 films MC-LR in surface water Sealed round pyrex reactorTemperature water flow rate pHTiO2 coating surface area and
thickness[95]
4 Journal of Nanomaterials
Table 1 Continued
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2(P25)-AGSToxic heavy metal
wastewater A photocatalytic bath pH dosage of catalyst andtemperature
[96]
TiO2 P25 Drinking water Cylindrical Pyrex reactionvessel Catalyst loading light wavelength [97]
TiO2 P25Organic
compounds-containingwastewater
A thermostated reactor Temperature dissolved oxygenconcentration
[60]
TiO2-modifiednanofiltrationmembranes
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCell reactor Light intensity temperatures [98]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Immersion well reactor Dosage of TiO2 and H2O2 pH [99]
TiO2 filmsupported on aporous nickelnet
Pesticides Reactor with ozonegenerator
pH ozone dosage treatment timeand temperature
[100]
TiO2nanotubulararrays
Swimming pool water Cylindrical glass reactor pH potential [101]
VB
Self-combination
Ligh
t
OrganiccompoundEnergy
level
O2
CB
HOO∙
HO∙
HO∙
CO2 + H2OH2O OHminus
O2
H2O2
H+
Eg
h+
h+
eminus
∙O2
minus
Figure 1 The scheme of TiO2photocatalytic process
3 Fundamentals
To develop a real TiO2-based photocatalytical process opti-
mization of the operating parameters is of importanceHowever the fundamentals that have been well establishedin laboratory are not utilized sophisticatedly or even over-looked in real application Also the parameters that areoptimized in the laboratory test which has only one substrateare not applicable in the full-scale process The presenceof cosubstrates in wastewater may significantly influencethe degradation of target substrate C Lin and K S Linhave observed that the presence of humic acid (HA) reta-rded the photocatalytic degradation of 4-chlorophenol [26]
Consequently the fundamentals that closely connect the realscenario should be focused on Herein the e-h pair gener-ation and separation adsorption of organic substrate andrate determining step (RDS) of the photocatalytic reactionare addressed These fundaments are analyzed on how todefine amaximized efficiency in real application whereas anysuccessful and competitive real process should get a balancebetween efficiency and economics
31 Importance of Photogenerated e-h Pair Separation TheTiO2photocatalytic process starts with the generation and
separation of e-h pairs which are illustrated in Figure 1 Based
Journal of Nanomaterials 5
on the mechanism of photocatalytic oxidation proposed byHoffmann et al [27] the reactions on the TiO
2can be
correspondingly expressed as follows
TiO2+ ℎ]lArrrArr (TiO
2minus h) + (TiO
2minus e) (2a)
Redinterface1198961
lArrrArr
119896minus1
(TiO2minus Red)surface (2b)
∙OH+ (TiO2minus h)
1198962
lArrrArr
119896minus2
(TiO2minus∙OH) (2c)
(TiO2minus∙OH) + (TiO
2minus Red)surface
1198963
lArrrArr
119896minus3
(TiO2minusO119909)surface + e
(2d)
It could be understood that upon the photo-excitation theelectrons on the valence band (VB) jump to the conductionband (CB) generating h left on the VB As the electrons andholes initially separate and interact with substrates in thesolution and then combine together an effective conversionof substances is thus resulted in As recombination occursthere is no any conversion of substances
Following the generation of holes and electrons radicalsof HO∙ are generated and considered to work as the principaloxidative species during the photocatalytic process Xiang etal have proposed a concept of ldquoOH-indexrdquo to quantitativelycharacterize the production of HO∙ on different photocat-alytic systems [28] Such index which can bemeasured easilyby photoluminescence technique is using coumarin as aprobe molecule It appears that this index is quite adequateto explain the activity difference in different systems Forexample P25 TiO
2 which is a most available commercial
photocatalyst has the highest ldquoOH-indexrdquo as illustrated inFigure 2
The photoenergy plays an important role in the e-hseparation The energy that is sufficient to generate the e-h pairs must surpass the energy of TiO
2band gap The
equation 119864 = h120582 designates the relationship between theenergy and the associated light wavelength TiO
2(119899-type)
has a band gap of 32 eV Accordingly the light wavelengthmust be shorter than 380 nm which falls into the range ofUV light This requirement determines that a full illumi-nation of the photocatalyst is an indispensible factor whendesigning a real photocatalyticmatrix First an artificial lampmust be installed Lamps with 254 nm and 365 nm as themain wavelength are well commercialized A more powerfulillumination of the photocatalyst certainly accelerates thee-h pair generation High-pressure mercury lamp is alsopowerful whereas its illumination is not stable and thusnot recommended for real application Many lamps can beinstalled together in the photocatalytic reactor to ensurea full illumination while the heat release should also betaken into account as the illumination time lasts a long timeSecond the target water must be sufficiently transparentfor the transmission of the light Accordingly following thepretreatment that serves to remove the particles or speciesthat shadow the light the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process
can bewell employedThird only theUV lamps that aremade
Photocatalysts
OH
-inde
x
100
60
40
80
20
0 21 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
(1) P25
(2) Am
(3) A
(4) R
(5) ZnO
(6) SnO2
(7) SrTiO3
(8) BaTiO3
(10) V2O5
(13) CdS
(14) CuS
(15) BiOCl
(16) BiOI
(17) ZnS
(19) BiOBr
(20) CuO
(26) NiO
(11) Bi2WO4
(12) CeO2
(18) Cr2O3
(21) MnO2
(22) Fe2O3
(23) BiVO4
(24) ZrO2
(25) La2O3
(9) WO3 (27) Bi2O3
Figure 2 Comparison of OH-index of various photocatalystsArrows represent OH-index = 0 Am A and R denote amorphousanatase and rutile of TiO
2 respectivelyThis figure is taken from the
article of Xiang et al [28]
from quartz glass can be immersed in water Fourth even ifan immobilization of the TiO
2photocatalyst serves to recover
the TiO2 it may bring about a decrease in the e-h generation
due to the decrease in the illumination intensity caused by thewater shadow As a result in real application the suspendedTiO2instead of the immobilized TiO
2is more efficient
Li et al have reported a type of suspended TiO2micro-
sphere which allows both the TiO2suspension and recovery
[29]
32Measure for e-h Pair Separation Following the photogen-eration of e-h pairs a fast recombination of charge carries isthermodynamically favorable and thus yields a low quantumyield of the reactive species for organic degradation Obvi-ously any effort to facilitate the e-h separation and inhibitits recombination is encouraged Many measures includingTiO2modification scavenge of electrons and imposition of
external force are allowed to enhance the e-h separation
321 TiO2Preparation The TiO
2is a cornerstone of the
photocatalytic process In laboratory it is often prepared bymethods such as sol-gel method and hydrothermal methodThe physical morphology is controllable through hydrother-mal preparation while the TiO
2is chemically composed of
two crystalline types of anatase and rutile The rutile type
6 Journal of Nanomaterials
is more stable and the thermal treatment of anatase typeleads to a transformation to rutile The difference in thedistribution of the two types is considered to determine theassociated catalytic activity Basically pure rutile is found toexhibit a poor activity while a suitable composition may bemore active than the pure anatase type [30] The preassumedcorrelation between the composition of crystal phase andthe e-h pair separation has been clearly evidenced Recentlyhowever Xu and coworkers have found that the anataseand rutile have the same activity in the degradation of 4-chlorophenol and the difference just lies in their differentadsorption ability towards O
2[31 32] Thus as the TiO
2
with different crystal phases is fabricated the O2adsorption
ability on the individual crystal phase needs to be takeninto account The composition of TiO
2photocatalyst can be
adjusted through thermal treatment by means of the increasein temperature
322 TiO2Doping To overcome the drawback of low photo-
catalytic efficiency brought by the e-h self-combination thebare TiO
2can be further modified by doping a foreign ion
Table 2 shows that various metal ions metal oxides and afew nonmetal elements such as nitrogen sulfur fluorine andsilicon can be employed as the dopants
Gurkan et al [33] have reported the density functiontheory (DFT) calculation of the Se(IV)-doping of TiO
2
sample showing that the doping does not cause a significantchange in the positions of the band edges whereas producesadditional electronic states originating from the Se 3p orbitalsin the band-gap Accordingly the electrons can be excitedfrom the defect state to the conduction band by a relativelylower energy and thus visible light can be utilized Furtherthe benefit of the doped transition metal lies in the improvedtrapping of electrons to inhibit e-h recombination duringirradiation
In real application for water purification special attentionshould be paid to the potential leakage of the doped ionswhich may result in a secondary pollution in the treatedwater In this regard the N-doped TiO
2appears to be a
promising method due to the cleanness brought by thenitrogen and has attracted great attention in recent yearsIn particular the photocatalytic activity under visible lightillumination has been well evidenced [34ndash40] Howeverthe unanimity exists for the photocatalytic mechanism Forexample Irie et al have stated that the irradiation with UVlight excites the electrons in both the VB and the impurityenergy levels but illumination with visible light only exciteselectrons in the impurity energy level [41] Ihara et al haveconcluded that the oxygen-deficient sites formed in the grainboundaries are importantly attributed to the visible lightactivity while the doped nitrogen in part of the oxygen-deficient sites is important as a blocker for reoxidation[42]
Also for the application of the fabricated TiO2 the
intrinsic advantages brought by the preparation methodsshould be accurately analyzed so as to appropriately ascribethe accelerated activities to the e-h separation For exampleLiu et al [43] have reported that a heat treatment of TiO
2
by hydrogen does not lead to any change in the physical
Table 2 Doping of TiO2 for the enhanced photocatalytic activity
Doped TiO2 Doping method References
N-doped TiO2Sol-gel method microwave
hydrothermal method [34ndash36]
Si-doped TiO2Hydrolysis of titanium
isopropoxide [102 103]
Si-doped TiO2ZrO2 Sol-gel method [37]S-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Hydrothermal method [38]
SiO3
2minus doped TiO2films Hydrothermal method [39]
NS co-doped TiO2Manual grinding ofthiourea and urea [104]
S-doped TiO2Tielectrode Anodization method [105]
S-doped TiO2-ZrO2nanoparticles Sol-gel method [40]
CndashN-doped TiO2nanotube
Chemical vapor deposition(CVD) [61]
Se(IV) on DegussaP25 Wet impregnation [33]
Al(III)-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [106]V-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [107]Fe-doped TiO2 Hydrothermal method [62]PolypyrroleFe-dopedTiO2
Sol-gel method emulsionpolymerization [108]
Er3+ YAlO3Fe- andCo-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [109]
Cu2+-dopedTiO2SiO2
Sol-gel method [110]
ZnFe2O4 on TiO2 Sol-gel method [111]
Ag doped TiO2Photoreduction using the
sacrificial acid [112]
AgF-TiO2Sol-gel method
photoreduction method [113]
Ag-TiO2-xNx Sol-gel method [114]Sn-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [115]Lanthanideions-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [116]
La3+Zr4+ co-dopedTiO2
Sol-microwave methodoil-bath condition synthesis [117]
Ce-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [118]Ce-doped TiO2microspheres solvothermal method [67]
NdF doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [119]W-doped TiO2 Solvothermal method [120]
W-TiO2 films Liquid phase deposition(LPD) [121]
WN co-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Sol-hydrothermal method [122]
Bi-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [123]C-dope TiO2 powders Oxidative annealing of TiC [41]
properties including the crystal phase specific surface areaand particle size However results of electron paramagnetic
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Journal of Nanomaterials 3
Table 1 Engineered TiO2 the associated treated targets reactors and principal operation parameters
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2 P25 Pharmaceutical wastewater Sequencingbatch biological reactor
H2O2 dosage TiO2 dosage pHirradiation time and hydraulic
retention time[73]
TiO2carbonaerogel
High-concentration dyewastewater
Photocatalysis-enhancedelectrosorption reactor
Electrochemical adsorptionpotential temperature initial pH
and wavelength[74]
TiO2 P25Wastewater treatment plant
effluentsLab-scale solarphotoreactor
Temperature pH and lightwavelength
[75]
TiO2 nanofiber Hospital wastewater Batch annular slurryphotoreactor (ASP)
Fine bubble aeration lightwavelength and pH
[76]
Nano TiO2 Paper mill wastewater Solar reactor TiO2 dosage pH [59]
C-TiO2 Antibiotics wastewaterA computerized LuzchemCCP-4V photochemical
reactorpH wastewater flow rate [77]
TiO2 P25 Antibiotics wastewater Capacity cylindrical acrylicphotoreactor
pH gas rate light intensity andTiO2 dosage
[78]
TiO2SiO2 beadsOrganic
compounds-containingwastewater
Batch recirculation typephotocatalytic reactor pH wastewater flow rate [79]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Pebble bed photocatalyticreactor
TiO2 pebbles water treatment afterabsorption of reflow exhaust gas
[80]
TiO2 P25 Industrial wastewater A hermetically sealedphotoreactor
Pressure adsorption time andtemperature
[81]
PFTTiO2Toxic heavy metals
wastewaterA column glassphotoreactor Wavelength [82]
TiO2 P25 Secondary effluent A cylindrical glass reactor Amount of TiO2 loaded maximumemission peak
[83]
TiO2Ti anode Textile wastewaterA thin-film
photoelectrocatalyticreactor
pH lamp position and lightintensity
[84 85]
TiO2 P25Pharmaceutical andcosmetic wastewater Common photoreactor pH time catalysts and H2O2
concentration[86]
TiO2 P25 Olive mill wastewater Common photoreactor Light wavelength pH [87]
TiO2 P25Textile dyehouse
wastewaterImmersion well batch-type
photoreactorpH light wavelength temperature
and H2O2 concentration[22]
TiO2SiO2DNP and municipal
wastewaterFixed bed circulation type
reactor Water flow rate residence time [88]
AgndashTiO2 Seawaterpoly (methyl methacrylate)
reactors temperature dosage of bacterialsuspension and O3
[89]
SndashTiO2 MC-LR in surface water Borosilicate glass dish pH light wavelength [90]
nano TiO2 Drinking water Tank-style reactor Permeate flux with a membrane [91]
TiO2 P25 Surface water Photovoltaic reactor Temperature [92]
TiO2 P25 Benzalkonium chloride Annular glass reactor Light wavelength TiO2 dosage [93]NF-TiO2-P25films Drinking water Glass
vessel reactor Light intensity pH [94]
TiO2microsphere
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCylindrical photoreactor Light wavelength concentration of
TiO2 suspensions[66]
TiO2 films MC-LR in surface water Sealed round pyrex reactorTemperature water flow rate pHTiO2 coating surface area and
thickness[95]
4 Journal of Nanomaterials
Table 1 Continued
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2(P25)-AGSToxic heavy metal
wastewater A photocatalytic bath pH dosage of catalyst andtemperature
[96]
TiO2 P25 Drinking water Cylindrical Pyrex reactionvessel Catalyst loading light wavelength [97]
TiO2 P25Organic
compounds-containingwastewater
A thermostated reactor Temperature dissolved oxygenconcentration
[60]
TiO2-modifiednanofiltrationmembranes
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCell reactor Light intensity temperatures [98]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Immersion well reactor Dosage of TiO2 and H2O2 pH [99]
TiO2 filmsupported on aporous nickelnet
Pesticides Reactor with ozonegenerator
pH ozone dosage treatment timeand temperature
[100]
TiO2nanotubulararrays
Swimming pool water Cylindrical glass reactor pH potential [101]
VB
Self-combination
Ligh
t
OrganiccompoundEnergy
level
O2
CB
HOO∙
HO∙
HO∙
CO2 + H2OH2O OHminus
O2
H2O2
H+
Eg
h+
h+
eminus
∙O2
minus
Figure 1 The scheme of TiO2photocatalytic process
3 Fundamentals
To develop a real TiO2-based photocatalytical process opti-
mization of the operating parameters is of importanceHowever the fundamentals that have been well establishedin laboratory are not utilized sophisticatedly or even over-looked in real application Also the parameters that areoptimized in the laboratory test which has only one substrateare not applicable in the full-scale process The presenceof cosubstrates in wastewater may significantly influencethe degradation of target substrate C Lin and K S Linhave observed that the presence of humic acid (HA) reta-rded the photocatalytic degradation of 4-chlorophenol [26]
Consequently the fundamentals that closely connect the realscenario should be focused on Herein the e-h pair gener-ation and separation adsorption of organic substrate andrate determining step (RDS) of the photocatalytic reactionare addressed These fundaments are analyzed on how todefine amaximized efficiency in real application whereas anysuccessful and competitive real process should get a balancebetween efficiency and economics
31 Importance of Photogenerated e-h Pair Separation TheTiO2photocatalytic process starts with the generation and
separation of e-h pairs which are illustrated in Figure 1 Based
Journal of Nanomaterials 5
on the mechanism of photocatalytic oxidation proposed byHoffmann et al [27] the reactions on the TiO
2can be
correspondingly expressed as follows
TiO2+ ℎ]lArrrArr (TiO
2minus h) + (TiO
2minus e) (2a)
Redinterface1198961
lArrrArr
119896minus1
(TiO2minus Red)surface (2b)
∙OH+ (TiO2minus h)
1198962
lArrrArr
119896minus2
(TiO2minus∙OH) (2c)
(TiO2minus∙OH) + (TiO
2minus Red)surface
1198963
lArrrArr
119896minus3
(TiO2minusO119909)surface + e
(2d)
It could be understood that upon the photo-excitation theelectrons on the valence band (VB) jump to the conductionband (CB) generating h left on the VB As the electrons andholes initially separate and interact with substrates in thesolution and then combine together an effective conversionof substances is thus resulted in As recombination occursthere is no any conversion of substances
Following the generation of holes and electrons radicalsof HO∙ are generated and considered to work as the principaloxidative species during the photocatalytic process Xiang etal have proposed a concept of ldquoOH-indexrdquo to quantitativelycharacterize the production of HO∙ on different photocat-alytic systems [28] Such index which can bemeasured easilyby photoluminescence technique is using coumarin as aprobe molecule It appears that this index is quite adequateto explain the activity difference in different systems Forexample P25 TiO
2 which is a most available commercial
photocatalyst has the highest ldquoOH-indexrdquo as illustrated inFigure 2
The photoenergy plays an important role in the e-hseparation The energy that is sufficient to generate the e-h pairs must surpass the energy of TiO
2band gap The
equation 119864 = h120582 designates the relationship between theenergy and the associated light wavelength TiO
2(119899-type)
has a band gap of 32 eV Accordingly the light wavelengthmust be shorter than 380 nm which falls into the range ofUV light This requirement determines that a full illumi-nation of the photocatalyst is an indispensible factor whendesigning a real photocatalyticmatrix First an artificial lampmust be installed Lamps with 254 nm and 365 nm as themain wavelength are well commercialized A more powerfulillumination of the photocatalyst certainly accelerates thee-h pair generation High-pressure mercury lamp is alsopowerful whereas its illumination is not stable and thusnot recommended for real application Many lamps can beinstalled together in the photocatalytic reactor to ensurea full illumination while the heat release should also betaken into account as the illumination time lasts a long timeSecond the target water must be sufficiently transparentfor the transmission of the light Accordingly following thepretreatment that serves to remove the particles or speciesthat shadow the light the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process
can bewell employedThird only theUV lamps that aremade
Photocatalysts
OH
-inde
x
100
60
40
80
20
0 21 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
(1) P25
(2) Am
(3) A
(4) R
(5) ZnO
(6) SnO2
(7) SrTiO3
(8) BaTiO3
(10) V2O5
(13) CdS
(14) CuS
(15) BiOCl
(16) BiOI
(17) ZnS
(19) BiOBr
(20) CuO
(26) NiO
(11) Bi2WO4
(12) CeO2
(18) Cr2O3
(21) MnO2
(22) Fe2O3
(23) BiVO4
(24) ZrO2
(25) La2O3
(9) WO3 (27) Bi2O3
Figure 2 Comparison of OH-index of various photocatalystsArrows represent OH-index = 0 Am A and R denote amorphousanatase and rutile of TiO
2 respectivelyThis figure is taken from the
article of Xiang et al [28]
from quartz glass can be immersed in water Fourth even ifan immobilization of the TiO
2photocatalyst serves to recover
the TiO2 it may bring about a decrease in the e-h generation
due to the decrease in the illumination intensity caused by thewater shadow As a result in real application the suspendedTiO2instead of the immobilized TiO
2is more efficient
Li et al have reported a type of suspended TiO2micro-
sphere which allows both the TiO2suspension and recovery
[29]
32Measure for e-h Pair Separation Following the photogen-eration of e-h pairs a fast recombination of charge carries isthermodynamically favorable and thus yields a low quantumyield of the reactive species for organic degradation Obvi-ously any effort to facilitate the e-h separation and inhibitits recombination is encouraged Many measures includingTiO2modification scavenge of electrons and imposition of
external force are allowed to enhance the e-h separation
321 TiO2Preparation The TiO
2is a cornerstone of the
photocatalytic process In laboratory it is often prepared bymethods such as sol-gel method and hydrothermal methodThe physical morphology is controllable through hydrother-mal preparation while the TiO
2is chemically composed of
two crystalline types of anatase and rutile The rutile type
6 Journal of Nanomaterials
is more stable and the thermal treatment of anatase typeleads to a transformation to rutile The difference in thedistribution of the two types is considered to determine theassociated catalytic activity Basically pure rutile is found toexhibit a poor activity while a suitable composition may bemore active than the pure anatase type [30] The preassumedcorrelation between the composition of crystal phase andthe e-h pair separation has been clearly evidenced Recentlyhowever Xu and coworkers have found that the anataseand rutile have the same activity in the degradation of 4-chlorophenol and the difference just lies in their differentadsorption ability towards O
2[31 32] Thus as the TiO
2
with different crystal phases is fabricated the O2adsorption
ability on the individual crystal phase needs to be takeninto account The composition of TiO
2photocatalyst can be
adjusted through thermal treatment by means of the increasein temperature
322 TiO2Doping To overcome the drawback of low photo-
catalytic efficiency brought by the e-h self-combination thebare TiO
2can be further modified by doping a foreign ion
Table 2 shows that various metal ions metal oxides and afew nonmetal elements such as nitrogen sulfur fluorine andsilicon can be employed as the dopants
Gurkan et al [33] have reported the density functiontheory (DFT) calculation of the Se(IV)-doping of TiO
2
sample showing that the doping does not cause a significantchange in the positions of the band edges whereas producesadditional electronic states originating from the Se 3p orbitalsin the band-gap Accordingly the electrons can be excitedfrom the defect state to the conduction band by a relativelylower energy and thus visible light can be utilized Furtherthe benefit of the doped transition metal lies in the improvedtrapping of electrons to inhibit e-h recombination duringirradiation
In real application for water purification special attentionshould be paid to the potential leakage of the doped ionswhich may result in a secondary pollution in the treatedwater In this regard the N-doped TiO
2appears to be a
promising method due to the cleanness brought by thenitrogen and has attracted great attention in recent yearsIn particular the photocatalytic activity under visible lightillumination has been well evidenced [34ndash40] Howeverthe unanimity exists for the photocatalytic mechanism Forexample Irie et al have stated that the irradiation with UVlight excites the electrons in both the VB and the impurityenergy levels but illumination with visible light only exciteselectrons in the impurity energy level [41] Ihara et al haveconcluded that the oxygen-deficient sites formed in the grainboundaries are importantly attributed to the visible lightactivity while the doped nitrogen in part of the oxygen-deficient sites is important as a blocker for reoxidation[42]
Also for the application of the fabricated TiO2 the
intrinsic advantages brought by the preparation methodsshould be accurately analyzed so as to appropriately ascribethe accelerated activities to the e-h separation For exampleLiu et al [43] have reported that a heat treatment of TiO
2
by hydrogen does not lead to any change in the physical
Table 2 Doping of TiO2 for the enhanced photocatalytic activity
Doped TiO2 Doping method References
N-doped TiO2Sol-gel method microwave
hydrothermal method [34ndash36]
Si-doped TiO2Hydrolysis of titanium
isopropoxide [102 103]
Si-doped TiO2ZrO2 Sol-gel method [37]S-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Hydrothermal method [38]
SiO3
2minus doped TiO2films Hydrothermal method [39]
NS co-doped TiO2Manual grinding ofthiourea and urea [104]
S-doped TiO2Tielectrode Anodization method [105]
S-doped TiO2-ZrO2nanoparticles Sol-gel method [40]
CndashN-doped TiO2nanotube
Chemical vapor deposition(CVD) [61]
Se(IV) on DegussaP25 Wet impregnation [33]
Al(III)-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [106]V-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [107]Fe-doped TiO2 Hydrothermal method [62]PolypyrroleFe-dopedTiO2
Sol-gel method emulsionpolymerization [108]
Er3+ YAlO3Fe- andCo-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [109]
Cu2+-dopedTiO2SiO2
Sol-gel method [110]
ZnFe2O4 on TiO2 Sol-gel method [111]
Ag doped TiO2Photoreduction using the
sacrificial acid [112]
AgF-TiO2Sol-gel method
photoreduction method [113]
Ag-TiO2-xNx Sol-gel method [114]Sn-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [115]Lanthanideions-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [116]
La3+Zr4+ co-dopedTiO2
Sol-microwave methodoil-bath condition synthesis [117]
Ce-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [118]Ce-doped TiO2microspheres solvothermal method [67]
NdF doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [119]W-doped TiO2 Solvothermal method [120]
W-TiO2 films Liquid phase deposition(LPD) [121]
WN co-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Sol-hydrothermal method [122]
Bi-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [123]C-dope TiO2 powders Oxidative annealing of TiC [41]
properties including the crystal phase specific surface areaand particle size However results of electron paramagnetic
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
4 Journal of Nanomaterials
Table 1 Continued
TiO2 Water Reactor Principal operation parametersinvestigated
References
TiO2(P25)-AGSToxic heavy metal
wastewater A photocatalytic bath pH dosage of catalyst andtemperature
[96]
TiO2 P25 Drinking water Cylindrical Pyrex reactionvessel Catalyst loading light wavelength [97]
TiO2 P25Organic
compounds-containingwastewater
A thermostated reactor Temperature dissolved oxygenconcentration
[60]
TiO2-modifiednanofiltrationmembranes
Organiccompounds-containing
wastewaterCell reactor Light intensity temperatures [98]
TiO2 P25 Textile wastewater Immersion well reactor Dosage of TiO2 and H2O2 pH [99]
TiO2 filmsupported on aporous nickelnet
Pesticides Reactor with ozonegenerator
pH ozone dosage treatment timeand temperature
[100]
TiO2nanotubulararrays
Swimming pool water Cylindrical glass reactor pH potential [101]
VB
Self-combination
Ligh
t
OrganiccompoundEnergy
level
O2
CB
HOO∙
HO∙
HO∙
CO2 + H2OH2O OHminus
O2
H2O2
H+
Eg
h+
h+
eminus
∙O2
minus
Figure 1 The scheme of TiO2photocatalytic process
3 Fundamentals
To develop a real TiO2-based photocatalytical process opti-
mization of the operating parameters is of importanceHowever the fundamentals that have been well establishedin laboratory are not utilized sophisticatedly or even over-looked in real application Also the parameters that areoptimized in the laboratory test which has only one substrateare not applicable in the full-scale process The presenceof cosubstrates in wastewater may significantly influencethe degradation of target substrate C Lin and K S Linhave observed that the presence of humic acid (HA) reta-rded the photocatalytic degradation of 4-chlorophenol [26]
Consequently the fundamentals that closely connect the realscenario should be focused on Herein the e-h pair gener-ation and separation adsorption of organic substrate andrate determining step (RDS) of the photocatalytic reactionare addressed These fundaments are analyzed on how todefine amaximized efficiency in real application whereas anysuccessful and competitive real process should get a balancebetween efficiency and economics
31 Importance of Photogenerated e-h Pair Separation TheTiO2photocatalytic process starts with the generation and
separation of e-h pairs which are illustrated in Figure 1 Based
Journal of Nanomaterials 5
on the mechanism of photocatalytic oxidation proposed byHoffmann et al [27] the reactions on the TiO
2can be
correspondingly expressed as follows
TiO2+ ℎ]lArrrArr (TiO
2minus h) + (TiO
2minus e) (2a)
Redinterface1198961
lArrrArr
119896minus1
(TiO2minus Red)surface (2b)
∙OH+ (TiO2minus h)
1198962
lArrrArr
119896minus2
(TiO2minus∙OH) (2c)
(TiO2minus∙OH) + (TiO
2minus Red)surface
1198963
lArrrArr
119896minus3
(TiO2minusO119909)surface + e
(2d)
It could be understood that upon the photo-excitation theelectrons on the valence band (VB) jump to the conductionband (CB) generating h left on the VB As the electrons andholes initially separate and interact with substrates in thesolution and then combine together an effective conversionof substances is thus resulted in As recombination occursthere is no any conversion of substances
Following the generation of holes and electrons radicalsof HO∙ are generated and considered to work as the principaloxidative species during the photocatalytic process Xiang etal have proposed a concept of ldquoOH-indexrdquo to quantitativelycharacterize the production of HO∙ on different photocat-alytic systems [28] Such index which can bemeasured easilyby photoluminescence technique is using coumarin as aprobe molecule It appears that this index is quite adequateto explain the activity difference in different systems Forexample P25 TiO
2 which is a most available commercial
photocatalyst has the highest ldquoOH-indexrdquo as illustrated inFigure 2
The photoenergy plays an important role in the e-hseparation The energy that is sufficient to generate the e-h pairs must surpass the energy of TiO
2band gap The
equation 119864 = h120582 designates the relationship between theenergy and the associated light wavelength TiO
2(119899-type)
has a band gap of 32 eV Accordingly the light wavelengthmust be shorter than 380 nm which falls into the range ofUV light This requirement determines that a full illumi-nation of the photocatalyst is an indispensible factor whendesigning a real photocatalyticmatrix First an artificial lampmust be installed Lamps with 254 nm and 365 nm as themain wavelength are well commercialized A more powerfulillumination of the photocatalyst certainly accelerates thee-h pair generation High-pressure mercury lamp is alsopowerful whereas its illumination is not stable and thusnot recommended for real application Many lamps can beinstalled together in the photocatalytic reactor to ensurea full illumination while the heat release should also betaken into account as the illumination time lasts a long timeSecond the target water must be sufficiently transparentfor the transmission of the light Accordingly following thepretreatment that serves to remove the particles or speciesthat shadow the light the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process
can bewell employedThird only theUV lamps that aremade
Photocatalysts
OH
-inde
x
100
60
40
80
20
0 21 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
(1) P25
(2) Am
(3) A
(4) R
(5) ZnO
(6) SnO2
(7) SrTiO3
(8) BaTiO3
(10) V2O5
(13) CdS
(14) CuS
(15) BiOCl
(16) BiOI
(17) ZnS
(19) BiOBr
(20) CuO
(26) NiO
(11) Bi2WO4
(12) CeO2
(18) Cr2O3
(21) MnO2
(22) Fe2O3
(23) BiVO4
(24) ZrO2
(25) La2O3
(9) WO3 (27) Bi2O3
Figure 2 Comparison of OH-index of various photocatalystsArrows represent OH-index = 0 Am A and R denote amorphousanatase and rutile of TiO
2 respectivelyThis figure is taken from the
article of Xiang et al [28]
from quartz glass can be immersed in water Fourth even ifan immobilization of the TiO
2photocatalyst serves to recover
the TiO2 it may bring about a decrease in the e-h generation
due to the decrease in the illumination intensity caused by thewater shadow As a result in real application the suspendedTiO2instead of the immobilized TiO
2is more efficient
Li et al have reported a type of suspended TiO2micro-
sphere which allows both the TiO2suspension and recovery
[29]
32Measure for e-h Pair Separation Following the photogen-eration of e-h pairs a fast recombination of charge carries isthermodynamically favorable and thus yields a low quantumyield of the reactive species for organic degradation Obvi-ously any effort to facilitate the e-h separation and inhibitits recombination is encouraged Many measures includingTiO2modification scavenge of electrons and imposition of
external force are allowed to enhance the e-h separation
321 TiO2Preparation The TiO
2is a cornerstone of the
photocatalytic process In laboratory it is often prepared bymethods such as sol-gel method and hydrothermal methodThe physical morphology is controllable through hydrother-mal preparation while the TiO
2is chemically composed of
two crystalline types of anatase and rutile The rutile type
6 Journal of Nanomaterials
is more stable and the thermal treatment of anatase typeleads to a transformation to rutile The difference in thedistribution of the two types is considered to determine theassociated catalytic activity Basically pure rutile is found toexhibit a poor activity while a suitable composition may bemore active than the pure anatase type [30] The preassumedcorrelation between the composition of crystal phase andthe e-h pair separation has been clearly evidenced Recentlyhowever Xu and coworkers have found that the anataseand rutile have the same activity in the degradation of 4-chlorophenol and the difference just lies in their differentadsorption ability towards O
2[31 32] Thus as the TiO
2
with different crystal phases is fabricated the O2adsorption
ability on the individual crystal phase needs to be takeninto account The composition of TiO
2photocatalyst can be
adjusted through thermal treatment by means of the increasein temperature
322 TiO2Doping To overcome the drawback of low photo-
catalytic efficiency brought by the e-h self-combination thebare TiO
2can be further modified by doping a foreign ion
Table 2 shows that various metal ions metal oxides and afew nonmetal elements such as nitrogen sulfur fluorine andsilicon can be employed as the dopants
Gurkan et al [33] have reported the density functiontheory (DFT) calculation of the Se(IV)-doping of TiO
2
sample showing that the doping does not cause a significantchange in the positions of the band edges whereas producesadditional electronic states originating from the Se 3p orbitalsin the band-gap Accordingly the electrons can be excitedfrom the defect state to the conduction band by a relativelylower energy and thus visible light can be utilized Furtherthe benefit of the doped transition metal lies in the improvedtrapping of electrons to inhibit e-h recombination duringirradiation
In real application for water purification special attentionshould be paid to the potential leakage of the doped ionswhich may result in a secondary pollution in the treatedwater In this regard the N-doped TiO
2appears to be a
promising method due to the cleanness brought by thenitrogen and has attracted great attention in recent yearsIn particular the photocatalytic activity under visible lightillumination has been well evidenced [34ndash40] Howeverthe unanimity exists for the photocatalytic mechanism Forexample Irie et al have stated that the irradiation with UVlight excites the electrons in both the VB and the impurityenergy levels but illumination with visible light only exciteselectrons in the impurity energy level [41] Ihara et al haveconcluded that the oxygen-deficient sites formed in the grainboundaries are importantly attributed to the visible lightactivity while the doped nitrogen in part of the oxygen-deficient sites is important as a blocker for reoxidation[42]
Also for the application of the fabricated TiO2 the
intrinsic advantages brought by the preparation methodsshould be accurately analyzed so as to appropriately ascribethe accelerated activities to the e-h separation For exampleLiu et al [43] have reported that a heat treatment of TiO
2
by hydrogen does not lead to any change in the physical
Table 2 Doping of TiO2 for the enhanced photocatalytic activity
Doped TiO2 Doping method References
N-doped TiO2Sol-gel method microwave
hydrothermal method [34ndash36]
Si-doped TiO2Hydrolysis of titanium
isopropoxide [102 103]
Si-doped TiO2ZrO2 Sol-gel method [37]S-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Hydrothermal method [38]
SiO3
2minus doped TiO2films Hydrothermal method [39]
NS co-doped TiO2Manual grinding ofthiourea and urea [104]
S-doped TiO2Tielectrode Anodization method [105]
S-doped TiO2-ZrO2nanoparticles Sol-gel method [40]
CndashN-doped TiO2nanotube
Chemical vapor deposition(CVD) [61]
Se(IV) on DegussaP25 Wet impregnation [33]
Al(III)-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [106]V-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [107]Fe-doped TiO2 Hydrothermal method [62]PolypyrroleFe-dopedTiO2
Sol-gel method emulsionpolymerization [108]
Er3+ YAlO3Fe- andCo-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [109]
Cu2+-dopedTiO2SiO2
Sol-gel method [110]
ZnFe2O4 on TiO2 Sol-gel method [111]
Ag doped TiO2Photoreduction using the
sacrificial acid [112]
AgF-TiO2Sol-gel method
photoreduction method [113]
Ag-TiO2-xNx Sol-gel method [114]Sn-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [115]Lanthanideions-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [116]
La3+Zr4+ co-dopedTiO2
Sol-microwave methodoil-bath condition synthesis [117]
Ce-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [118]Ce-doped TiO2microspheres solvothermal method [67]
NdF doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [119]W-doped TiO2 Solvothermal method [120]
W-TiO2 films Liquid phase deposition(LPD) [121]
WN co-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Sol-hydrothermal method [122]
Bi-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [123]C-dope TiO2 powders Oxidative annealing of TiC [41]
properties including the crystal phase specific surface areaand particle size However results of electron paramagnetic
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Journal of Nanomaterials 5
on the mechanism of photocatalytic oxidation proposed byHoffmann et al [27] the reactions on the TiO
2can be
correspondingly expressed as follows
TiO2+ ℎ]lArrrArr (TiO
2minus h) + (TiO
2minus e) (2a)
Redinterface1198961
lArrrArr
119896minus1
(TiO2minus Red)surface (2b)
∙OH+ (TiO2minus h)
1198962
lArrrArr
119896minus2
(TiO2minus∙OH) (2c)
(TiO2minus∙OH) + (TiO
2minus Red)surface
1198963
lArrrArr
119896minus3
(TiO2minusO119909)surface + e
(2d)
It could be understood that upon the photo-excitation theelectrons on the valence band (VB) jump to the conductionband (CB) generating h left on the VB As the electrons andholes initially separate and interact with substrates in thesolution and then combine together an effective conversionof substances is thus resulted in As recombination occursthere is no any conversion of substances
Following the generation of holes and electrons radicalsof HO∙ are generated and considered to work as the principaloxidative species during the photocatalytic process Xiang etal have proposed a concept of ldquoOH-indexrdquo to quantitativelycharacterize the production of HO∙ on different photocat-alytic systems [28] Such index which can bemeasured easilyby photoluminescence technique is using coumarin as aprobe molecule It appears that this index is quite adequateto explain the activity difference in different systems Forexample P25 TiO
2 which is a most available commercial
photocatalyst has the highest ldquoOH-indexrdquo as illustrated inFigure 2
The photoenergy plays an important role in the e-hseparation The energy that is sufficient to generate the e-h pairs must surpass the energy of TiO
2band gap The
equation 119864 = h120582 designates the relationship between theenergy and the associated light wavelength TiO
2(119899-type)
has a band gap of 32 eV Accordingly the light wavelengthmust be shorter than 380 nm which falls into the range ofUV light This requirement determines that a full illumi-nation of the photocatalyst is an indispensible factor whendesigning a real photocatalyticmatrix First an artificial lampmust be installed Lamps with 254 nm and 365 nm as themain wavelength are well commercialized A more powerfulillumination of the photocatalyst certainly accelerates thee-h pair generation High-pressure mercury lamp is alsopowerful whereas its illumination is not stable and thusnot recommended for real application Many lamps can beinstalled together in the photocatalytic reactor to ensurea full illumination while the heat release should also betaken into account as the illumination time lasts a long timeSecond the target water must be sufficiently transparentfor the transmission of the light Accordingly following thepretreatment that serves to remove the particles or speciesthat shadow the light the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process
can bewell employedThird only theUV lamps that aremade
Photocatalysts
OH
-inde
x
100
60
40
80
20
0 21 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
(1) P25
(2) Am
(3) A
(4) R
(5) ZnO
(6) SnO2
(7) SrTiO3
(8) BaTiO3
(10) V2O5
(13) CdS
(14) CuS
(15) BiOCl
(16) BiOI
(17) ZnS
(19) BiOBr
(20) CuO
(26) NiO
(11) Bi2WO4
(12) CeO2
(18) Cr2O3
(21) MnO2
(22) Fe2O3
(23) BiVO4
(24) ZrO2
(25) La2O3
(9) WO3 (27) Bi2O3
Figure 2 Comparison of OH-index of various photocatalystsArrows represent OH-index = 0 Am A and R denote amorphousanatase and rutile of TiO
2 respectivelyThis figure is taken from the
article of Xiang et al [28]
from quartz glass can be immersed in water Fourth even ifan immobilization of the TiO
2photocatalyst serves to recover
the TiO2 it may bring about a decrease in the e-h generation
due to the decrease in the illumination intensity caused by thewater shadow As a result in real application the suspendedTiO2instead of the immobilized TiO
2is more efficient
Li et al have reported a type of suspended TiO2micro-
sphere which allows both the TiO2suspension and recovery
[29]
32Measure for e-h Pair Separation Following the photogen-eration of e-h pairs a fast recombination of charge carries isthermodynamically favorable and thus yields a low quantumyield of the reactive species for organic degradation Obvi-ously any effort to facilitate the e-h separation and inhibitits recombination is encouraged Many measures includingTiO2modification scavenge of electrons and imposition of
external force are allowed to enhance the e-h separation
321 TiO2Preparation The TiO
2is a cornerstone of the
photocatalytic process In laboratory it is often prepared bymethods such as sol-gel method and hydrothermal methodThe physical morphology is controllable through hydrother-mal preparation while the TiO
2is chemically composed of
two crystalline types of anatase and rutile The rutile type
6 Journal of Nanomaterials
is more stable and the thermal treatment of anatase typeleads to a transformation to rutile The difference in thedistribution of the two types is considered to determine theassociated catalytic activity Basically pure rutile is found toexhibit a poor activity while a suitable composition may bemore active than the pure anatase type [30] The preassumedcorrelation between the composition of crystal phase andthe e-h pair separation has been clearly evidenced Recentlyhowever Xu and coworkers have found that the anataseand rutile have the same activity in the degradation of 4-chlorophenol and the difference just lies in their differentadsorption ability towards O
2[31 32] Thus as the TiO
2
with different crystal phases is fabricated the O2adsorption
ability on the individual crystal phase needs to be takeninto account The composition of TiO
2photocatalyst can be
adjusted through thermal treatment by means of the increasein temperature
322 TiO2Doping To overcome the drawback of low photo-
catalytic efficiency brought by the e-h self-combination thebare TiO
2can be further modified by doping a foreign ion
Table 2 shows that various metal ions metal oxides and afew nonmetal elements such as nitrogen sulfur fluorine andsilicon can be employed as the dopants
Gurkan et al [33] have reported the density functiontheory (DFT) calculation of the Se(IV)-doping of TiO
2
sample showing that the doping does not cause a significantchange in the positions of the band edges whereas producesadditional electronic states originating from the Se 3p orbitalsin the band-gap Accordingly the electrons can be excitedfrom the defect state to the conduction band by a relativelylower energy and thus visible light can be utilized Furtherthe benefit of the doped transition metal lies in the improvedtrapping of electrons to inhibit e-h recombination duringirradiation
In real application for water purification special attentionshould be paid to the potential leakage of the doped ionswhich may result in a secondary pollution in the treatedwater In this regard the N-doped TiO
2appears to be a
promising method due to the cleanness brought by thenitrogen and has attracted great attention in recent yearsIn particular the photocatalytic activity under visible lightillumination has been well evidenced [34ndash40] Howeverthe unanimity exists for the photocatalytic mechanism Forexample Irie et al have stated that the irradiation with UVlight excites the electrons in both the VB and the impurityenergy levels but illumination with visible light only exciteselectrons in the impurity energy level [41] Ihara et al haveconcluded that the oxygen-deficient sites formed in the grainboundaries are importantly attributed to the visible lightactivity while the doped nitrogen in part of the oxygen-deficient sites is important as a blocker for reoxidation[42]
Also for the application of the fabricated TiO2 the
intrinsic advantages brought by the preparation methodsshould be accurately analyzed so as to appropriately ascribethe accelerated activities to the e-h separation For exampleLiu et al [43] have reported that a heat treatment of TiO
2
by hydrogen does not lead to any change in the physical
Table 2 Doping of TiO2 for the enhanced photocatalytic activity
Doped TiO2 Doping method References
N-doped TiO2Sol-gel method microwave
hydrothermal method [34ndash36]
Si-doped TiO2Hydrolysis of titanium
isopropoxide [102 103]
Si-doped TiO2ZrO2 Sol-gel method [37]S-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Hydrothermal method [38]
SiO3
2minus doped TiO2films Hydrothermal method [39]
NS co-doped TiO2Manual grinding ofthiourea and urea [104]
S-doped TiO2Tielectrode Anodization method [105]
S-doped TiO2-ZrO2nanoparticles Sol-gel method [40]
CndashN-doped TiO2nanotube
Chemical vapor deposition(CVD) [61]
Se(IV) on DegussaP25 Wet impregnation [33]
Al(III)-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [106]V-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [107]Fe-doped TiO2 Hydrothermal method [62]PolypyrroleFe-dopedTiO2
Sol-gel method emulsionpolymerization [108]
Er3+ YAlO3Fe- andCo-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [109]
Cu2+-dopedTiO2SiO2
Sol-gel method [110]
ZnFe2O4 on TiO2 Sol-gel method [111]
Ag doped TiO2Photoreduction using the
sacrificial acid [112]
AgF-TiO2Sol-gel method
photoreduction method [113]
Ag-TiO2-xNx Sol-gel method [114]Sn-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [115]Lanthanideions-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [116]
La3+Zr4+ co-dopedTiO2
Sol-microwave methodoil-bath condition synthesis [117]
Ce-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [118]Ce-doped TiO2microspheres solvothermal method [67]
NdF doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [119]W-doped TiO2 Solvothermal method [120]
W-TiO2 films Liquid phase deposition(LPD) [121]
WN co-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Sol-hydrothermal method [122]
Bi-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [123]C-dope TiO2 powders Oxidative annealing of TiC [41]
properties including the crystal phase specific surface areaand particle size However results of electron paramagnetic
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
6 Journal of Nanomaterials
is more stable and the thermal treatment of anatase typeleads to a transformation to rutile The difference in thedistribution of the two types is considered to determine theassociated catalytic activity Basically pure rutile is found toexhibit a poor activity while a suitable composition may bemore active than the pure anatase type [30] The preassumedcorrelation between the composition of crystal phase andthe e-h pair separation has been clearly evidenced Recentlyhowever Xu and coworkers have found that the anataseand rutile have the same activity in the degradation of 4-chlorophenol and the difference just lies in their differentadsorption ability towards O
2[31 32] Thus as the TiO
2
with different crystal phases is fabricated the O2adsorption
ability on the individual crystal phase needs to be takeninto account The composition of TiO
2photocatalyst can be
adjusted through thermal treatment by means of the increasein temperature
322 TiO2Doping To overcome the drawback of low photo-
catalytic efficiency brought by the e-h self-combination thebare TiO
2can be further modified by doping a foreign ion
Table 2 shows that various metal ions metal oxides and afew nonmetal elements such as nitrogen sulfur fluorine andsilicon can be employed as the dopants
Gurkan et al [33] have reported the density functiontheory (DFT) calculation of the Se(IV)-doping of TiO
2
sample showing that the doping does not cause a significantchange in the positions of the band edges whereas producesadditional electronic states originating from the Se 3p orbitalsin the band-gap Accordingly the electrons can be excitedfrom the defect state to the conduction band by a relativelylower energy and thus visible light can be utilized Furtherthe benefit of the doped transition metal lies in the improvedtrapping of electrons to inhibit e-h recombination duringirradiation
In real application for water purification special attentionshould be paid to the potential leakage of the doped ionswhich may result in a secondary pollution in the treatedwater In this regard the N-doped TiO
2appears to be a
promising method due to the cleanness brought by thenitrogen and has attracted great attention in recent yearsIn particular the photocatalytic activity under visible lightillumination has been well evidenced [34ndash40] Howeverthe unanimity exists for the photocatalytic mechanism Forexample Irie et al have stated that the irradiation with UVlight excites the electrons in both the VB and the impurityenergy levels but illumination with visible light only exciteselectrons in the impurity energy level [41] Ihara et al haveconcluded that the oxygen-deficient sites formed in the grainboundaries are importantly attributed to the visible lightactivity while the doped nitrogen in part of the oxygen-deficient sites is important as a blocker for reoxidation[42]
Also for the application of the fabricated TiO2 the
intrinsic advantages brought by the preparation methodsshould be accurately analyzed so as to appropriately ascribethe accelerated activities to the e-h separation For exampleLiu et al [43] have reported that a heat treatment of TiO
2
by hydrogen does not lead to any change in the physical
Table 2 Doping of TiO2 for the enhanced photocatalytic activity
Doped TiO2 Doping method References
N-doped TiO2Sol-gel method microwave
hydrothermal method [34ndash36]
Si-doped TiO2Hydrolysis of titanium
isopropoxide [102 103]
Si-doped TiO2ZrO2 Sol-gel method [37]S-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Hydrothermal method [38]
SiO3
2minus doped TiO2films Hydrothermal method [39]
NS co-doped TiO2Manual grinding ofthiourea and urea [104]
S-doped TiO2Tielectrode Anodization method [105]
S-doped TiO2-ZrO2nanoparticles Sol-gel method [40]
CndashN-doped TiO2nanotube
Chemical vapor deposition(CVD) [61]
Se(IV) on DegussaP25 Wet impregnation [33]
Al(III)-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [106]V-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [107]Fe-doped TiO2 Hydrothermal method [62]PolypyrroleFe-dopedTiO2
Sol-gel method emulsionpolymerization [108]
Er3+ YAlO3Fe- andCo-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [109]
Cu2+-dopedTiO2SiO2
Sol-gel method [110]
ZnFe2O4 on TiO2 Sol-gel method [111]
Ag doped TiO2Photoreduction using the
sacrificial acid [112]
AgF-TiO2Sol-gel method
photoreduction method [113]
Ag-TiO2-xNx Sol-gel method [114]Sn-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [115]Lanthanideions-doped TiO2
Sol-gel method [116]
La3+Zr4+ co-dopedTiO2
Sol-microwave methodoil-bath condition synthesis [117]
Ce-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [118]Ce-doped TiO2microspheres solvothermal method [67]
NdF doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [119]W-doped TiO2 Solvothermal method [120]
W-TiO2 films Liquid phase deposition(LPD) [121]
WN co-dopedTiO2 nanoparticles
Sol-hydrothermal method [122]
Bi-doped TiO2 Sol-gel method [123]C-dope TiO2 powders Oxidative annealing of TiC [41]
properties including the crystal phase specific surface areaand particle size However results of electron paramagnetic
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Journal of Nanomaterials 7
resonance (EPR) detection show that the H2treatment leads
to formation of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species on theTiO2 Moreover the kinetic constants of phenol degradation
increased with the H2treatment temperatures lower than
800∘CTherefore the production of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+species which are relatively stable as exposure to ambientair is considered to extend the lifetime of the e-h pairsThe oxygen vacancy and Ti3+ species act as holes traps andoxygen vacancy acts as an electron scavenger Further thetrapped holes transfer to the organic substrate leading to adegradation reaction and charged defects recover to theiroriginal states of oxygen vacancy and Ti3+
323 Scavenging of the Photogenerated Electrons To effec-tively separate the e-h pairs the electrons need to be scav-enged along with the trapping of holes by H
2O to form ∙OH
Otherwise the electrons will recombine together with theholes without any transformation of pollutants The mostcommonly available scavenger is the dissolved oxygen (DO)and thus the TiO
2-based photocatalytic reactions are most
often performed in an aerated aqueous system It has beenobserved that the reaction rate increases toward a plateauwith the partial pressure of O
2in a gas phase [44] Actually
before the electron scavenging an adsorption process of DOoccurs and the adsorption model may be described by atypical Langmuir adsorption
Besides DO H2O2is often added as an environmental
benign electron scavenger to aid the DO H2O2 being a
stronger electron acceptor than oxygen reacts with theelectrons in the valence band of the photocatalyst to generate∙OH Chu et al have observed that the degradation rateof chlorinated aniline can be improved by adding 001mMH2O2to the reaction solution [45] However as the H
2O2
is overdosed at 100mM a retardation of approximately 26rate is caused The rate retardation can be accounted for asfollowsThe H
2O2does scavenge the valuable HO∙ while the
H2O2in excess consumes the oxidative holes on the TiO
2
catalyst surface (3) where the overall oxidation capabilitiesof the system are significantly reduced [46]
HO2
∙+∙OH 997888rarr H
2O +O
2(3)
H2O2+ 2h 997888rarr O
2+ 2H+ (4)
Additionally alternative oxidative species such as Cr(VI) ionscan be employed as the electron scavenger in the TiO
2-based
photocatalysis [47] The Cr(VI) ions are also a type of pollu-tant and the photocatalysis is sometimes employed to removethe Cr(VI) ions as a reductive process using the electrons[48] As the Cr(VI) ions coexist with organic pollutant aspecial supply of DO as the electron scavenger appears to beunnecessary [49] Compared to the conventional process ofCr(VI) removal using ferrous reduction the competition ofTiO2-based photocatalysis may be impeded as the economics
is taken into account because the former appears to be a quiterapid process
324 Imposition of Bias to Separate the e-h Pairs Externalforces such as electric bias can be employed to accelerate
the separation of e-h pairs which is realized in an electrodesystem In this system the TiO
2is employed as the anode
where the organic substrate is oxidized by the radicalsgenerated from the interaction between the holes and H
2O
The photogenerated electrons flow through the externalcircuit and arrive at the cathode where they are scavengedby oxidative species In this system an externally imposedanodic bias serves to drive the electrons away from theanode to the cathode and thus the e-h self-combination ofTiO2can be efficiently inhibited on the anode Some reports
have shown that a bias of around 05V is efficient to leadto a significant increase in the organic degradation on theanode by means of enhancing the e-h separation [50 51]Additional advantage brought by this system leads to the easyrecovery of TiO
2compared to the conventional suspended
systemThe lab-scaled prototype of this system however may
find difficulty in the scale-up for actual water purificationlikely because of the utilization of the electrode As the TiO
2
powder is attached to the anode support a binder withpowerful binding strength is indispensible to anchor the TiO
2
particles on the electrode surface The binder making ofpolymer may be degraded after a long-time photocatalyticprocess which decreases the lifetime of electrode Despitethis challenge the photoelectrochemical system can beemployed as a powerful platform for the probing of photocat-alytic mechanism In essence the TiO
2-based photocatalytic
process is such one involving electron transfer which canbe exactly investigated by electrochemical means Liu et alhave employed electrochemical impedance spectroscopy toascertain the TiO
2-based photocatalytic process and thus the
reaction phenomenon can be accounted for [52] Bymeans ofthis powerful tool the rate-determining steps have been wellascertained
33 Adsorption of Organics onto TiO2Surface and Organic
Degradation Reaction Accompanied with the successful e-h separation is the organic degradation reaction Majorityof the reports on the water purification are to investi-gate the degradation reaction of an individual substrateThe substrate is initially adsorbed onto the TiO
2surface
and the adsorption ability is often observed to determinethe overall degradation efficiency [1] A large specific sur-face area of TiO
2photocatalyst benefits the accumulation
of organic substrate on the TiO2 and thus more active
sites are available for the subsequent degradation reaction[53] Generally the adsorption behavior can be describedby the Langmuir adsorption isotherm and the kineticmodel of organic degradation rate can be described asfollows
119889119862
119889119905
= 119870119886119870119903
119862
1 + 119870119886119862
(5)
In (5)119870119903designates the contribution of organic degradation
and 119870119886is the contribution of organic adsorption [54]
Obviously large values of 119870119886and 119870
119904are beneficial for the
acceleration of reaction rate As the119870119886value is small enough
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
8 Journal of Nanomaterials
to be neglected (5) can be considered as the first-orderreaction rate as follows
Ln(1198620
119862
) = 119870ap119905 (6a)
where119870ap equals119870119903119870119886 as the apparent reaction rate constantIn real application it is noteworthy that the chemisorp-
tion occurring through a formation of chemical bond con-tributes to the acceleration of degradation reaction In somecases a great number of the organic substrate is adsorbedwhile the degradation reaction of organic substrate doesnot become more rapid just because of the physisorptioninstead of chemisorption It has been disclosed by FT-IR thatthe organic substrate is chemically adsorbed in the form ofcomplex with the TiO
2[55] This complex likely leads to a
deviation of the first-order rate model of the degradationreaction because the large 119870
119886value cannot be neglected in
(5) In this scenario the reaction rate can be described asfollows [29 56 57]
Ln(1198620
119862
) + (1198620minus 119862) = 119896ap119905 (6b)
Certainly in real application the reaction kinetics involvingthe adsorption should be kept in mind to solve someproblems For example as the water containing textile as apollutant is treated a great number of textile molecules areadsorbed while physically onto the TiO
2 Obviously such
type of adsorption does not contribute to the degradationOn the other hand as the chemisorption predominates witha large 119870
119886value the first-order rate reaction model that is
commonly applied to describe the reaction is not applicableand (6b) is more adequate to fit the degradation data of targetpollutants
34 Rate-Determining Steps Besides the steps of adsorptionand degradation reaction mass transfer and desorption ofthe reaction products are also the main steps involved inthe heterogeneous catalytic reaction Among these steps theslowest step determines the overall reaction rate while whichone is the rate-determining step (RDS) As the aqueoussystem is commonly fully stirred by means of air bubblingto form a suspension the step of mass transfer is generallyconsidered as a fast step and the adsorption and degradationreactions are potentially the RDS
In real application the ascertainment of RDS is ofimportance Clearly only manipulation of the RDS leads toan alteration of the overall reaction rate For example as theadsorption step is RDS increase in the specific surface areato improve the adsorption ability enables the acceleration ofthe overall reaction rate Otherwise the associated efforts arein vain Liu et al have employed electrochemical impedancespectroscopy (EIS) to ascertain the RDS of TiO
2photo-
catalytic process [52] Their results show that the surfacedegradation reaction of organic pollutant is commonly anRDS while the adsorption step is another RDS once thesurface degradation reaction becomes quite rapid In essencethe acceleration of organic degradation reaction can beconsidered as the acceleration of the e-h separation To date
the TiO2photocatalysis is suffering from the low quantum
yield and TiO2that has a sufficiently rapid e-h separation is
not available Accordingly any effort in the acceleration of thee-h separation is valuable
4 Balance of the Efficacy and Economics
41 Economic Estimation of TiO2Photocatalysis for Water
Purification The organic pollutants experience an oxidationpathway during the photocatalytical process and thus a typ-ical TiO
2-based photocatalytical matrix is composed of four
indispensible elements light source photocatalyst oxidant asan electron acceptor and reactor The light source suppliesenergy that excites the electrons on the valence band of TiO
2
to jump to the conduction band and then holes are left onthe conduction bandThe TiO
2-based photocatalyst works as
a catalyst which adsorbs organic substrate onto the surfaceand then the degradation reaction occurs As the oxidativeholes are consumed to generate ∙OH via the interaction withH2O the electrons are left and must be scavenged by an
oxidant mostly by ambient O2 The ambient O
2has an
additional function to buoyant the TiO2particles to form a
suspension and thus themass transfer limit can be precludedThe reactor is the place where the photocatalytic process isrealized
Todevelop an effectiveTiO2-based photocatalytic process
for water purification the operating parameters should bewell optimized for the full utilization of the light illuminationability of catalyst and ambient O
2in the reactorWhen doing
this work the fundamentals that have been established in thelaboratory should be used sophisticatedly In addition sincethe solution chemistry varies significantly the experiencein one place even if quite successful is not applicable inanother place Particular the optimized parameters cannot beimplemented in some real applications due to the limitationof operating cost
Basically the operation cost of photocatalytic reactionmatrix includes the cost of photocatalytic materials elec-tricity and aging of equipment while the cost of TiO
2
photocatalyst shares the major part and is discussed hereinThe cost of TiO
2photocatalyst depends on its dosage For
example 01ndash2wtTiO2 as usually dosed inwater treatment
costs too much if it is used one time It is estimated that thecost of the TiO
2photocatalyst in treating 1m3 of water at this
dosage level varies from 3 to 60USD under the conditionthat the price of TiO
2powders is as low as approximately
3000USD per ton This cost is undoubtedly unaffordablefor most consumers particularly in the developing countries[58]
42 Recovering of the TiO2Photocatalyst This economic
estimation implies that the progress obtained in the reactionefficiency must be balanced by the economic considerationThus the stability of TiO
2photocatalyst may outweigh its
temporary activity even if quite high Also the recycling ofthe TiO
2powders which are commonly employed is also
vital In particular the TiO2particles are often prepared in
a scale of nanosize and it has been well recognized that thenanosizedTiO
2particles exhibit unique photocatalytic ability
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Journal of Nanomaterials 9
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)Figure 3 SEM image of the TiO
2microspheres samples ((a) has 600 multiple and (b) has 50000 multiple magnifications) Taken from [57]
[3 13 59ndash63] Obviously these nanosized TiO2powders
can be well suspended to form a fine contact between thecatalyst particles and the substrate and thus the illuminationof the particles is ensured Accordingly the organic substratescan be rapidly destroyed in the photocatalytic matrix withnanosized TiO
2powders
However this nanosized TiO2
is often synthesizedthrough hydrothermal method that demands high tempera-ture and pressure and thus is quite costly once the preparationis practiced in a large scale In view of the economic consi-deration as previously mentioned these TiO
2particles will
encounter a difficulty in separation from the aqueous phaseand recycling after use An addition of a chemical such ascoagulant enables the TiO
2sedimentation and separation
whereas the reuse of TiO2becomes impossible due to the
TiO2fouling Mostly the TiO
2powders are immobilized
onto a support [16] to preclude the postseparation and theTiO2can be reused Moreover as the TiO
2powders are
immobilized onto a support such as porous nickel [64] or Timesh [65] to form an electrode a bias can be convenientlyapplied to the anode TiO
2to enhance the e-h separation
It is noted that in both cases however a significant loss inthe contact area between the immobilized photocatalyst andthe light source exists which lowers the global efficiency ofphotocatalytic degradation of organic substrate Thereforethe efficacy sometimes must be sacrificed for the sake of costcutting and a balance between the efficacy of TiO
2and the
running cost is of significanceThis balance requires a novel concept of design of the
photocatalyst matrix in which the advantage of the suspen-sion system should be kept while the easy recycling of thephotocatalyst should be simultaneously realized Thereforea microsphere photocalyst appears to be an ideal option Ifthe size of microspheres can be designed at a suitable scalein size they can be well suspended by the air bubbling Theambient oxygen works as an electron scavenger and thus isinevitably supplied This way the suspended TiO
2can be
finely illuminated Upon the task of photodegradation the airbubbling stops Consequently the microspheres settle at thereactor bottom quickly by the aid of gravity and thus can bereadily reused
Such microsphere photocatalysts have been successfullyfabricated [29 56 57 66ndash70] For example as illustrated
in Figure 3 a TiO2microsphere photocatalyst with a size
regime of 30ndash160 120583m and an average size of around 80 m hasbeen prepared by reconstructing the mixture of TiO
2sol and
TiO2nanosized powders with a spray drier [29 57] After
that the as-prepared microspheres are thermally treated toobtain the anatase-dominant sample TiO
2microspheresThe
experimental results showed that the photoreaction rate usingthe TiO
2microspheres was comparable to that using the
TiO2powder counterparts Moreover the TiO
2microsphere
samples could be reused in the photocatalytic oxidationreaction for more than 50 times without obvious destructionof the physical structure and significant loss in its activity
43 Coupling of Diverse Technologies Effluents dischargedfrom industrial processes usually contain various pollutantsAccordingly diverse technologies including physical bio-logical and chemical ones are needed to be chosen totreat them in light of such properties Pollutants in theform of colloids or biodegradable solutes are treated byconventional approaches such as coagulation or biologicalprocess The TiO
2photocatalyst is specially designed to
destroy the recalcitrant pollutants that are nonbiodegradableThe ∙OH involved in the TiO
2photocatalytic process is
extremely powerful to destroy the molecular structures andlead to partial or complete mineralization Generally theTiO2photocatalysis is particularly fitful for the advance
treatment of water with an attempt of final discharge of theeffluent or reuse of the purified water Clearly it appearsinfeasible to purify the seriously contaminated water solelyby the TiO
2photocatalytic process Without surprise the
TiO2photocatalysis has its intrinsic drawbacks in treating
actual water For example the water should be transparentfor the light transmission and the extremely polluted wateroften shadows the light Second the biological processes arecost effective in the decomposition of a great number ofbiodegradable pollutants at low concentrations Thereforethe balance between the efficacy of TiO
2photocalytic process
and economics requites a smart coupling of it with otherconventional process
In real application a successful process for water purifi-cation is commonly an integrated one including quite a fewtechnologies for the sake of both technical efficacy and costeffectiveness Basically a physical unit such as filtration or
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
10 Journal of Nanomaterials
grilling unit goes first to separate the solids Then a physic-ochemical process such as coagulation follows to remove thecolloidal substances Further a biological process is installedto degrade most of the biodegradable organic moleculesFinally if the effluent requires further purification to destroythe nondegradable organic pollutants the TiO
2photocalytic
process is desirable In addition TiO2photocatalytic process
is expected to improve the biodegradability of pollutedwater as a pretreatment unit by decomposing the recalcitrantpollutants Anyway any pilot-scale test is usually extremelynecessary to verify the technique and economic feasibility[71] and more fundamental research is also in need tounderstand the enhancing mechanism of the photocatalyticactivity [72] while associated reports are very limited
5 Concluding Remarks
With the rapid accumulation of reports on the TiO2-based
photocatalysis for water purification its application becomesa task with great importance In view of the fact that thefundaments of the TiO
2-based photocatalysis have been
well established a link with the actual application in waterpurification should be followed Analysis in this review showsthat it is of significance to keep in mind that the fundamentsclarified in laboratory sometimes find it difficult to solvethe problems that are encountered in practice Consequentlysome TiO
2-based catalysts which possess high activity in
the degradation of model pollutants in the laboratory are ingreat need of further investigation to improve their applicableability such as separation and recycling During the furtherinvestigation apart from the fundamentals economics isbelieved to play a vital role in actual application indi-cating that a balance between the reaction efficiency andthe operating cost should also be considered Moreover aflexible coupling of TiO
2-based photocatalysis with other
technologies is equally important to push it towards realapplication of water purification
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National NaturalScience Foundation of China (nos 21067004 and 51208539)and Chongqing Science and Technology Commission (nocstc2011ggC20013)
References
[1] J Zhao T Wu K Wu K Oikawa H Hidaka and N SerponeldquoPhotoassisted degradation of dye pollutants 3 Degradation ofthe cationic dye rhodamine B in aqueous anionic surfactantTiO2dispersions under visible light irradiation evidence for the
need of substrate adsorption on TiO2particlesrdquo Environmental
Science and Technology vol 32 no 16 pp 2394ndash2400 1998[2] J G Yu M Jaroniec and G X Lu ldquoTiO
2photocatalytic
materialsrdquo Internation Journal of Photoenergy vol 2012 ArticleID 206183 5 pages 2012
[3] J Yu J Xiong B Cheng and S Liu ldquoFabrication and character-ization of Ag-TiO
2multiphase nanocomposite thin films with
enhanced photocatalytic activityrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 60no 3-4 pp 211ndash221 2005
[4] S Wen J Zhao G Sheng J Fu and P Peng ldquoPhotocatalyticreactions of phenanthrene at TiO
2water interfacesrdquo Chemo-
sphere vol 46 no 6 pp 871ndash877 2002[5] H Chun W Yizhong and T Hongxiao ldquoInfluence of adsorp-
tion on the photodegradation of various dyes using surfacebond-conjugated TiO
2SiO2photocatalystrdquoApplied Catalysis B
vol 35 no 2 pp 95ndash105 2001[6] S Kaneco Y Shimizu K Ohta and T Mizuno ldquoPhotocatalytic
reduction of high pressure carbon dioxide using TiO2powders
with a positive hole scavengerrdquo Journal of Photochemistry andPhotobiology A vol 115 no 3 pp 223ndash226 1998
[7] F Moellers H J Tolle and R Memming ldquoOn the origin of thephotocatalytic deposition of noble metals on TiO
2rdquo Journal of
the Electrochemical Society vol 121 no 9 pp 1160ndash1167 1974[8] H J Hovel ldquoTiO
2antireflection coatings by a low temperature
spray processrdquo Journal of the Electrochemical Society vol 125no 6 pp 983ndash985 1978
[9] R W Matthews ldquoSolar-electric water purification using pho-tocatalytic oxidation with TiO
2as a stationary phaserdquo Solar
Energy vol 38 no 6 pp 405ndash413 1987[10] W Behnke F Nolting and C Zetzsch ldquoA smog chamber study
on the impact of aerosols on the photodegradation of chemicalsin the troposphererdquo Journal of Aerosol Science vol 18 no 1 pp65ndash71 1987
[11] Y Tominaga T Kubo and K Hosoya ldquoSurface modificationof TiO
2for selective photodegradation of toxic compoundsrdquo
Catalysis Communications vol 12 no 9 pp 785ndash789 2011[12] C Hu J C Yu Z Hao and P K Wong ldquoPhotocatalytic
degradation of triazine-containing azo dyes in aqueous TiO2
suspensionsrdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 42 no 1 pp 47ndash55 2003[13] J Saien Z Ojaghloo A R Soleymani and M H Rasoulifard
ldquoHomogeneous and heterogeneous AOPs for rapid degradationof Triton X-100 in aqueous media via UV light nano titaniahydrogen peroxide and potassium persulfaterdquo Chemical Engi-neering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 172ndash182 2011
[14] Z Ai J Li L Zhang and S Lee ldquoRapid decolorization of azodyes in aqueous solution by an ultrasound-assisted electrocat-alytic oxidation processrdquo Ultrasonics Sonochemistry vol 17 no2 pp 370ndash375 2010
[15] W Fan M Cui H Liu et al ldquoNano-TiO2enhances the toxicity
of copper in natural water to Daphnia magnardquo EnvironmentalPollution vol 159 no 3 pp 729ndash734 2011
[16] B Tryba ldquoImmobilization of TiO2and Fe-C-TiO
2photocata-
lysts on the cotton material for application in a flow photocat-alytic reactor for decomposition of phenol in waterrdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 151 no 2-3 pp 623ndash627 2008
[17] J T Yates Jr ldquoPhotochemistry on TiO2 mechanisms behind the
surface chemistryrdquo Surface Science vol 603 no 10ndash12 pp 1605ndash1612 2009
[18] C Liang C Liu F Li and F Wu ldquoThe effect of Praseodymiumon the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of azo dye inaqueous Pr3+-TiO
2suspensionrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal
vol 147 no 2-3 pp 219ndash225 2009[19] Y Yu J Wang and J F Parr ldquoPreparation and properties of
TiO2fumed silica composite photocatalytic materialsrdquo Proce-
dia Engineering vol 27 pp 448ndash456 2012[20] L F Qi J G Yu and M Jaroniec ldquoEnhanced and suppressed
effects of ionic liquid on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2rdquo
Adsorption vol 19 pp 557ndash561 2013[21] H Zhang R Zong J Zhao and Y Zhu ldquoDramatic visible pho-
tocatalytic degradation performances due to synergetic effect of
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Journal of Nanomaterials 11
TiO2with PANIrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol
42 no 10 pp 3803ndash3807 2008[22] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D Mantzavinos
ldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[23] M N Chong B Jin C W K Chow and C Saint ldquoRecent
developments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 10 pp 2997ndash3027 2010
[24] H Xu Z Zheng L Z Zhang H L Zhang and F Deng ldquoRecentdevelopments in photocatalytic water treatment technology areviewrdquo Journal of Solid State Chemistry vol 181 no 9 pp 2516ndash2522 2008
[25] A A Merdaw A O Sharif and G A W Derwish ldquoMasstransfer in pressure-driven membrane separation processespart Irdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 215ndash228 2011
[26] C Lin and K S Lin ldquoPhotocatalytic oxidation of toxicorganohalides with TiO
2UV the effects of humic substances
and organic mixturesrdquo Chemosphere vol 66 no 10 pp 1872ndash1877 2007
[27] M R Hoffmann S T Martin W Choi and D W BahnemannldquoEnvironmental applications of semiconductor photocatalysisrdquoChemical Reviews vol 95 no 1 pp 69ndash96 1995
[28] Q Xiang J Yu and P K Wong ldquoQuantitative characterizationof hydroxyl radicals produced by various photocatalystsrdquo Jour-nal of Colloid and Interface Science vol 357 no 1 pp 163ndash1672011
[29] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng andH J Tong ldquoPhotocatalytic oxi-dation using a new catalystmdashTiO
2microspheremdashfor water and
wastewater treatmentrdquo Environmental Science and Technologyvol 37 no 17 pp 3989ndash3994 2003
[30] T Ohno K Tokieda S Higashida and M Matsumura ldquoSyner-gismbetween rutile and anatase TiO
2particles in photocatalytic
oxidation of naphthalenerdquo Applied Catalysis A vol 244 no 2pp 383ndash391 2003
[31] S Cong and Y Xu ldquoExplaining the high photocatalytic activityof a mixed phase TiO
2 a combined effect of O
2and crys-
tallinityrdquo Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 115 no 43 pp21161ndash21168 2011
[32] Q Sun and Y Xu ldquoEvaluating intrinsic photocatalytic activitiesof anatase and rutile TiO
2for organic degradation in waterrdquo
Journal of Physical Chemistry C vol 114 no 44 pp 18911ndash189182010
[33] Y Y Gurkan E Kasapbasi and Z Cinar ldquoEnhanced solar pho-tocatalytic activity of TiO
2by selenium(IV) ion-doping char-
acterization and DFT modeling of the surfacerdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 214 pp 34ndash44 2013
[34] J Ananpattarachai P Kajitvichyanukul and S Seraphin ldquoVisi-ble light absorption ability and photocatalytic oxidation activityof various interstitial N-doped TiO
2prepared from different
nitrogen dopantsrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 168 no1 pp 253ndash261 2009
[35] J Senthilnathan and L Philip ldquoPhotodegradation of methylparathion and dichlorvos from drinking water with N-dopedTiO2under solar radiationrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol
172 no 2-3 pp 678ndash688 2011[36] J A Cha SHAnHD Jang C S KimD K Song andT Kim
ldquoSynthesis and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2ZrO2
visible-light photocatalystsrdquo Advanced Powder Technology vol23 no 6 pp 717ndash723 2012
[37] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[38] Y Liu J Liu Y Lin Y Zhang and Y Wei ldquoSimple fabricationand photocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2under low power
LED visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 35no 8 pp 3061ndash3065 2009
[39] X Xu D Yin SWu JWang and J Lu ldquoPreparation of orientedSiO3
2minus-doped TiO2film and degradation of methylene blue
under visible light irradiationrdquo Ceramics International vol 36no 2 pp 443ndash450 2010
[40] G Tian K Pan H Fu L Jing and W Zhou ldquoEnhancedphotocatalytic activity of S-doped TiO
2-ZrO2nanoparticles
under visible-light irradiationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materialsvol 166 no 2-3 pp 939ndash944 2009
[41] H Irie Y Watanabe and K Hashimoto ldquoCarbon-dopedanatase TiO
2powders as a visible-light sensitive photocatalystrdquo
Chemistry Letters vol 32 no 8 pp 772ndash773 2003[42] T IharaMMiyoshi Y IriyamaOMatsumoto and S Sugihara
ldquoVisible-light-active titanium oxide photocatalyst realized byan oxygen-deficient structure and by nitrogen dopingrdquo AppliedCatalysis B vol 42 no 4 pp 403ndash409 2003
[43] H Liu H T Ma X Z Li W Z Li M Wu and X H BaoldquoThe enhancement of TiO
2photocatalytic activity by hydrogen
thermal treatmentrdquoChemosphere vol 50 no 1 pp 39ndash46 2003[44] A Mills and S Le Hunte ldquoAn overview of semiconductor
photocatalysisrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology Avol 108 no 1 pp 1ndash35 1997
[45] W Chu W K Choy and T Y So ldquoThe effect of solution pHand peroxide in the TiO
2-induced photocatalysis of chlorinated
anilinerdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 141 no 1 pp 86ndash91 2007
[46] J Marsh and D Gorse ldquoA photoelectrochemical and acimpedance study of anodic titaniumoxide filmsrdquoElectrochimicaActa vol 43 no 7 pp 659ndash670 1997
[47] H Yu S Chen X Quan H Zhao and Y Zhang ldquoFabrication ofa TiO
2-BDD heterojunction and its application as a photocata-
lyst for the simultaneous oxidation of an azo dye and reductionof Cr(VI)rdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 42 no10 pp 3791ndash3796 2008
[48] J J Testa M A Grela and M I Litter ldquoHeterogeneousphotocatalytic reduction of chromium(VI) over TiO
2particles
in the presence of oxalate involvement of Cr(V) speciesrdquo Envi-ronmental Science and Technology vol 38 no 5 pp 1589ndash15942004
[49] L Wang N Wang L Zhu H Yu and H Tang ldquoPhotocatalyticreduction of Cr(VI) over different TiO
2photocatalysts and
the effects of dissolved organic speciesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 152 no 1 pp 93ndash99 2008
[50] Y S Sohn Y R Smith M Misra and V (Ravi) Subrama-nian ldquoElectrochemically assisted photocatalytic degradation ofmethyl orange using anodized titanium dioxide nanotubesrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 84 no 3-4 pp 372ndash378 2008
[51] R K Quinn R D Nasby and R J Baughman ldquoPhotoassistedelectrolysis of water using single crystal 120572-Fe
2O3anodesrdquo
Materials Research Bulletin vol 11 no 8 pp 1011ndash1017 1976[52] H Liu X Z Li Y J Leng andW Z Li ldquoAn alternative approach
to ascertain the rate-determining steps of TiO2photoelectro-
catalytic reaction by electrochemical impedance spectroscopyrdquoJournal of Physical Chemistry B vol 107 no 34 pp 8988ndash89962003
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
12 Journal of Nanomaterials
[53] H Tada A Hattori Y Tokihisa K Imai N Tohge and S ItoldquoA patterned-TiO
2SnO2bilayer type photocatalystrdquo Journal of
Physical Chemistry B vol 104 no 19 pp 4586ndash4587 2000[54] C S Turchi and D F Ollis ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of
organic water contaminants mechanisms involving hydroxylradical attackrdquo Journal of Catalysis vol 122 no 1 pp 178ndash1921990
[55] M Ivanda S Music S Popovic and M Gotic ldquoXRD Ramanand FT-IR spectroscopic observations of nanosized TiO
2syn-
thesized by the sol-gel method based on an esterificationreactionrdquo Journal of Molecular Structure vol 480-481 pp 645ndash649 1999
[56] C Wang X Zhang H Liu X Li W Li and H Xu ldquoReactionkinetics of photocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidusing TiO
2microspheresrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol
163 no 2-3 pp 1101ndash1106 2009[57] X Z Li H Liu L F Cheng and H J Tong ldquoKinetic behaviour
of the adsorption and photocatalytic degradation of salicylicacid in aqueous TiO
2microsphere suspensionrdquo Journal of
Chemical Technology and Biotechnology vol 79 no 7 pp 774ndash781 2004
[58] H Liu C L Yu and C Wang ldquoEconomics and its implicationof photocatalyst recycling for water purificationrdquo in Handbookof Photocatalysts pp 527ndash534 Nova Science Publishers 2009
[59] M Y Ghaly T S Jamil I E El-Seesy E R Souaya and RA Nasr ldquoTreatment of highly polluted paper mill wastewaterby solar photocatalytic oxidation with synthesized nano TiO
2rdquo
Chemical Engineering Journal vol 168 no 1 pp 446ndash454 2011[60] J G Yu Q Li S W Liu and M Jaroniec ldquoIonic-liquie-
assisted synthesis of uniform fluorinated BC-codoped TiO2
nanocrystals and their enhanced visble-light photocatalyticactivityrdquo Chemistry A European Journal vol 19 pp 2433ndash24412013
[61] S Liu L Yang S Xu S Luo and Q Cai ldquoPhotocatalyticactivities of C-N-doped TiO
2nanotube arraycarbon nanorod
compositerdquo Electrochemistry Communications vol 11 no 9 pp1748ndash1751 2009
[62] H Zhang andH Zhu ldquoPreparation of Fe-doped TiO2nanopar-
ticles immobilized on polyamide fabricrdquo Applied Surface Sci-ence vol 258 no 24 pp 10034ndash10041 2012
[63] S H Othman S A Rashid T I M Ghazi and N AbdulahldquoDispersion and stabilization of photocatalytic TiO
2nanoparti-
cles in aqueous suspension for coatings applicationsrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012 Article ID 718214 10 pages 2012
[64] H Liu S Cheng J Zhang C Cao and S Zhang ldquoTitaniumdioxide as photocatalyst on porous nickel adsorption and thephotocatalytic degradation of sulfosalicylic acidrdquo Chemospherevol 38 no 2 pp 283ndash292 1999
[65] X Z Li H L Liu P T Yue and Y P Sun ldquoPhotoelectrocatalyticoxidation of rose Bengal in aqueous solution using a TiTiO
2
mesh electroderdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol 34no 20 pp 4401ndash4406 2000
[66] P F Lee X Zhang D D Sun J Du and J O LeckieldquoSynthesis of bimodal porous structuredTiO
2microspherewith
high photocatalytic activity for water treatmentrdquo Colloids andSurfaces A vol 324 no 1ndash3 pp 202ndash207 2008
[67] J Xie D Jiang M Chen et al ldquoPreparation and characteriza-tion ofmonodisperse Ce-doped TiO
2microspheres with visible
light photocatalytic activityrdquo Colloids and Surfaces A vol 372no 1ndash3 pp 107ndash114 2010
[68] H Nemec C Kadlec F Kadlec et al ldquoResonant mag-netic response of TiO
2microspheres at terahertz frequenciesrdquo
Applied Physics Letters vol 100 no 6 Article ID 061117 pp 891ndash894 2012
[69] F Cesano D Pellerej D Scarano G Ricchiardi and AZecchina ldquoRadially organized pillars in TiO
2and in TiO
2C
microspheres synthesis characterization and photocatalytictestsrdquo Journal of Photochemistry and Photobilogy A vol 242 pp51ndash58 2012
[70] M Ye Y Yang Y Zhang T Zhang andW Shao ldquoHydrothermalsynthesis of hydrangea-like F-doped titania microspheres forthe photocatalytic degradation of carbamazepine underUVandvisible light irradiationrdquo Journal of Nanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 583417 8 pages 2012
[71] S Mozia P Brozek J Przepiorski B Tryba and A W Mora-wski ldquoImmobilized TiO
2for phenol degrdation in a pilot-
scale photocatalytic reactorrdquo Journal ofNanomaterials vol 2012Article ID 949764 10 pages 2012
[72] P Zhou J G Yu and Y X Wang ldquoThe new understandingon photocatalytic mechanism of visible-light response N-Scodoped anatase TiO
2by first-principlesrdquo Applied Catalysis B
vol 142-143 pp 45ndash53 2013[73] E S Elmolla and M Chaudhuri ldquoThe feasibility of using com-
bined TiO2photocatalysis-SBR process for antibiotic wastewa-
ter treatmentrdquo Desalination vol 272 no 1ndash3 pp 218ndash224 2011[74] Y Jin M Wu G Zhao and M Li ldquoPhotocatalysis-enhanced
electrosorption process for degradation of high-concentrationdye wastewater on TiO
2carbon aerogelrdquo Chemical Engineering
Journal vol 168 no 3 pp 1248ndash1255 2011[75] L Prieto-Rodriguez S Miralles-Cuevas I Oller A Aguera
G L Puma and S Malato ldquoTreatment of emerging contam-inants in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) effluents bysolar photocatalysis using low TiO
2concentrationsrdquo Journal of
Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp 131ndash137 2012[76] M N Chong and B Jin ldquoPhotocatalytic treatment of high
concentration carbamazepine in synthetic hospital wastewaterrdquoJournal of Hazardous Materials vol 199-200 pp 135ndash142 2012
[77] M Chen andW Chu ldquoDegradation of antibiotic norfloxacin inaqueous solution by visible-light-mediated C-TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 219-220 pp 183ndash1892012
[78] D Nasuhoglu A Rodayan D Berk and V Yargeau ldquoRemovalof the antibiotic levofloxacin (LEVO) in water by ozonation andTiO2photocatalysisrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 189-
190 pp 41ndash48 2012[79] R Nakano R Chand E Obuchi K Katoh and K Nakano
ldquoPerformance of TiO2photocatalyst supported on silica beads
for purification of wastewater after absorption of reflow exhaustgasrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 176-177 pp 260ndash2642011
[80] N N Rao V Chaturvedi and G Li Puma ldquoNovel pebble bedphotocatalytic reactor for solar treatment of textile wastewaterrdquoChemical Engineering Journal vol 184 pp 90ndash97 2012
[81] I Catanzaro G Avellone G Marcı et al ldquoBiological effectsand photodegradation by TiO
2of terpenes present in industrial
wastewaterrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 185 no 2-3pp 591ndash597 2011
[82] R Qiu D Zhang Z Diao et al ldquoVisible light induced photocat-alytic reduction of Cr(VI) over polymer-sensitized TiO
2and its
synergism with phenol oxidationrdquo Water Research vol 46 no7 pp 2299ndash2306 2012
[83] W Zhang Y Li Y Su K Mao and Q Wang ldquoEffect of watercomposition on TiO
2photocatalytic removal of endocrine
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Journal of Nanomaterials 13
disrupting compounds (EDCs) and estrogenic activity fromsecondary effluentrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 215-216 pp 252ndash258 2012
[84] Y Xu J Jia D Zhong and Y Wang ldquoDegradation of dyewastewater in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) reactorwith slant-placed TiO
2Ti anoderdquo Chemical Engineering Jour-
nal vol 150 no 2-3 pp 302ndash307 2009[85] Y Yao K Li S Chen J Jia YWang andHWang ldquoDecoloriza-
tion of Rhodamine B in a thin-film photoelectrocatalytic (PEC)reactor with slant-placed TiO
2nanotubes electroderdquo Chemical
Engineering Journal vol 187 pp 29ndash35 2012[86] M Boroski A C Rodrigues J C Garcia L C Sampaio J
Nozaki andN Hioka ldquoCombined electrocoagulation and TiO2
photoassisted treatment applied to wastewater effluents frompharmaceutical and cosmetic industriesrdquo Journal of HazardousMaterials vol 162 no 1 pp 448ndash454 2009
[87] H El Hajjouji F Barje E Pinelli et al ldquoPhotochemicalUVTiO
2treatment of olive mill wastewater (OMW)rdquo Biore-
source Technology vol 99 no 15 pp 7264ndash7269 2008[88] K Nakano E Obuchi S Takagi et al ldquoPhotocatalytic treat-
ment of water containing dinitrophenol and city water overTiO2SiO2rdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 34 no
1ndash3 pp 67ndash72 2004[89] DWu H You R Zhang C Chen and D J Lee ldquoBallast waters
treatment using UVAg-TiO2+O3advanced oxidation process
with Escherichia coli and Vibrio alginolyticus as indicatormicroorganismsrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 2-3 pp 714ndash718 2011
[90] C Han M Pelaez V Likodimos et al ldquoInnovative visible light-activated sulfur doped TiO
2films for water treatmentrdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 107 no 1-2 pp 77ndash87 2011[91] R Bergamasco F V da Silva F S Arakawa et al ldquoDrinking
water treatment in a gravimetric flow system with TiO2coated
membranesrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 174 no 1 pp102ndash109 2011
[92] T Ochiai K Nakata TMurakami et al ldquoDevelopment of solar-driven electrochemical and photocatalytic water treatmentsystem using a boron-doped diamond electrode and TiO
2
photocatalystrdquoWater Research vol 44 no 3 pp 904ndash910 2010[93] E Lopez Loveira P S Fiol A Senn G Curutchet R Candal
and M I Litter ldquoTiO2-photocatalytic treatment coupled with
biological systems for the elimination of benzalkonium chloridein waterrdquo Separation and Purification Technology vol 91 pp108ndash116 2012
[94] M Pelaez P Falaras A G Kontos et al ldquoA comparative studyon the removal of cylindrospermopsin and microcystins fromwater with NF-TiO
2-P25 composite films with visible and UV-
vis light photocatalytic activityrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 121 pp30ndash39 2012
[95] M G Antoniou P A Nicolaou J A Shoemaker A A de laCruz and D D Dionysiou ldquoImpact of themorphological prop-erties of thin TiO
2photocatalytic films on the detoxification
of water contaminated with the cyanotoxin microcystin-LRrdquoApplied Catalysis B vol 91 no 1-2 pp 165ndash173 2009
[96] K Zhang K C Kemp andV Chandra ldquoHomogeneous anchor-ing of TiO
2nanoparticles on graphene sheets for waste water
treatmentrdquoMaterials Letters vol 81 pp 127ndash130 2012[97] L Rizzo ldquoInactivation and injury of total coliform bacteria after
primary disinfection of drinking water by TiO2photocatalysisrdquo
Journal ofHazardousMaterials vol 165 no 1ndash3 pp 48ndash51 2009[98] G E Romanos C P Athanasekou F K Katsaros et al
ldquoDouble-side active TiO2-modified nanofiltration membranes
in continuous flow photocatalytic reactors for effective waterpurificationrdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol 211-212 pp304ndash316 2012
[99] P A Pekakis N P Xekoukoulotakis and D MantzavinosldquoTreatment of textile dyehouse wastewater by TiO
2photocatal-
ysisrdquoWater Research vol 40 no 6 pp 1276ndash1286 2006[100] L Lin M N Xie Y M Liang Y Q He G Y S Chan
and T G Luan ldquoDegradation of cypermethrin malathionand dichlorovos in water and on tea leaves with O
3UVTiO
2
treatmentrdquo Food Control vol 28 no 2 pp 374ndash379 2012[101] J L Esbenshade J C Cardoso and M V B Zanoni ldquoRemoval
of sunscreen compounds from swimming pool water usingself-organized TiO
2nanotubular array electrodesrdquo Journal of
Photochemistry and Photobiology A vol 214 no 2-3 pp 257ndash263 2010
[102] N Ma X Quan Y Zhang S Chen and H Zhao ldquoIntegrationof separation and photocatalysis using an inorganic membranemodified with Si-doped TiO
2for water purificationrdquo Journal of
Membrane Science vol 335 no 1-2 pp 58ndash67 2009[103] D N Bui S Z Kang X Li and J Mu ldquoEffect of Si doping on
the photocatalytic activity and photoelectrochemical propertyof TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Catalysis Communications vol 13 no 1
pp 14ndash17 2011[104] J A Rengifo-Herrera and C Pulgarin ldquoPhotocatalytic activity
of N S co-doped and N-doped commercial anatase TiO2
powders towards phenol oxidation and E coli inactivationunder simulated solar light irradiationrdquo Solar Energy vol 84no 1 pp 37ndash43 2010
[105] H Sun H Liu J Ma X Wang B Wang and L Han ldquoPrepa-ration and characterization of sulfur-doped TiO
2Ti photoelec-
trodes and their photoelectrocatalytic performancerdquo Journal ofHazardous Materials vol 156 no 1ndash3 pp 552ndash559 2008
[106] D Zhao C Chen Y Wang et al ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticdegradation of dye pollutants under visible irradiation onAl(III)-modified TiO
2 structure interaction and interfacial
electron transferrdquo Environmental Science and Technology vol42 no 1 pp 308ndash314 2008
[107] S M Chang and W S Liu ldquoSurface doping is more beneficialthan bulk doping to the photocatalytic activity of vanadium-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied Catalysis B vol 101 no 3-4 pp 333ndash342
2011[108] Q Li C Zhang and J Li ldquoPhotocatalytic and microwave
absorbing properties of polypyrroleFe-doped TiO2composite
by in situ polymerization methodrdquo Journal of Alloys andCompounds vol 509 no 5 pp 1953ndash1957 2011
[109] R Xu J Li J Wang et al ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation oforganic dyes under solar light irradiation combined withEr3+YAlO
3Fe- and Co-doped TiO
2coated compositesrdquo Solar
Energy Materials and Solar Cells vol 94 no 6 pp 1157ndash11652010
[110] R F Chen C X Zhang J Deng and G Q Song ldquoPreparationand photocatalytic activity of Cu2+-doped TiO
2SiO2rdquo Interna-
tional Journal of Minerals Metallurgy and Materials vol 16 no2 pp 220ndash225 2009
[111] G G Liu X Z Zhang Y J Xu X S Niu L Q Zheng and X JDing ldquoEffect of ZnFe
2O4doping on the photocatalytic activity
of TiO2rdquo Chemosphere vol 55 no 9 pp 1287ndash1291 2004
[112] E Pipelzadeh A A Babaluo M Haghighi A Tavakoli MV Derakhshan and A K Behnami ldquoSilver doping on TiO
2
nanoparticles using a sacrificial acid and its photocatalytic per-formance undermediumpressuremercuryUV lamprdquoChemicalEngineering Journal vol 155 no 3 pp 660ndash665 2009
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
14 Journal of Nanomaterials
[113] X Lin F Rong D Fu and C Yuan ldquoEnhanced photocatalyticactivity of fluorine doped TiO
2by loaded with Ag for degra-
dation of organic pollutantsrdquo Powder Technology vol 219 pp173ndash178 2012
[114] L G Devi B Nagaraj and K E Rajashekhar ldquoSynergisticeffect of Ag deposition and nitrogen doping in TiO
2for the
degradation of phenol under solar irradiation in presence ofelectron acceptorrdquo Chemical Engineering Journal vol 181-182pp 259ndash266 2012
[115] X Li R Xiong and G Wei ldquoPreparation and photocatalyticactivity of nanoglued Sn-doped TiO
2rdquo Journal of Hazardous
Materials vol 164 no 2-3 pp 587ndash591 2009[116] Z M El-Bahy A A Ismail and R M Mohamed ldquoEnhance-
ment of titania by doping rare earth for photodegradation oforganic dye (Direct Blue)rdquo Journal of Hazardous Materials vol166 no 1 pp 138ndash143 2009
[117] A F Shojaie and M H Loghmani ldquoLa3+ and Zr4+ co-dopedanatase nano TiO
2by sol-microwave methodrdquo Chemical Engi-
neering Journal vol 157 no 1 pp 263ndash269 2010[118] C Fan P Xue and Y Sun ldquoPreparation of Nano-TiO
2doped
with cerium and its photocatalytic activityrdquo Journal of RareEarths vol 24 no 3 pp 309ndash313 2006
[119] L Yang P Liu X Li and S Li ldquoThe photo-catalytic activities ofneodymium and fluorine doped TiO
2nanoparticlesrdquo Ceramics
International vol 38 no 6 pp 4791ndash4796 2012[120] W Sangkhun L Laokiat V Tanboonchuy P Khamdahsag and
N Grisdanurak ldquoPhotocatalytic degradation of BTEX usingW-doped TiO
2immobilized on fiberglass cloth under visible lightrdquo
Superlattices and Microstructures vol 52 no 4 pp 632ndash6422012
[121] J Gong C YangW Pu and J Zhang ldquoLiquid phase depositionof tungsten doped TiO
2films for visible light photoelectro-
catalytic degradation of dodecyl-benzenesulfonaterdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 167 no 1 pp 190ndash197 2011
[122] J Y Gong W H Pu C Z Yang and J D Zhang ldquoTungstenand nitrogen co-doped TiO
2electrode sensitized with Fe-
chlorophyllin for visible light photoelectrocatalysisrdquo ChemicalEngineering Journal vol 209 pp 94ndash101 2012
[123] Y Hu Y T Cao P X Wang et al ldquoA new perspective for effectof Bi on the photocatalytic activity of Bi-doped TiO
2rdquo Applied
Catalysis B vol 125 pp 294ndash303 2012
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CorrosionInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Polymer ScienceInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CeramicsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CompositesJournal of
NanoparticlesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Biomaterials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
NanoscienceJournal of
TextilesHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
NanotechnologyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
CrystallographyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
CoatingsJournal of
Advances in
Materials Science and EngineeringHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Smart Materials Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MetallurgyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
MaterialsJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Nano
materials
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofNanomaterials