refresher training - reconcile international...3 | p a g e 1. introduction and background the key...
TRANSCRIPT
REPORT ON KEY MOBILIZERS’
REFRESHER TRAINING
at RECONCILE CENTRE, YEI
16th-26th AUGUST 2011
Group photo of part icipants
2 | P a g e
Facilitated by:
Milcah Lalam; Program Manager, RECONCILE
Sebit Nicholas; Peacebuilding Officer, RECONCILE
Bakata Peter Martin; Peacebuilding Officer, RECONCILE
Abanzi Elisa Michaelson; Education Inclusion Officer, ACROSS.
Table of contents:
1. Introduction and background
2. Objective of the training
3. Training process
4. Results of the workshop
5. Challenges
6. Recommendations
7. Conclusions
3 | P a g e
1. Introduction and background
The Key Mobilizers’ training, which was conducted for two weeks, is a refresher aimed
at mentoring them and increasing their knowledge on how they can best improve their
work in the community.
The workshop drew seventeen participants from five states of Jonglei, Upper Nile,
Eastern Equatoria, Central Equatoria and Western Equatoria.
2. Objective of the training
The objectives of the training include:
To help key mobilizers understand what the most important needs are in your
community for building the peace and trauma healing.
To improve their facilitation skills in carrying out community activities by using
integrated participatory methods
To equip them with tools on how to report on the impact of our intervention in
their local communities
3. Scope of the Training content:
This follow up training is aimed at increasing the capacities of key mobilizers in the
following areas;
Community Mobilization
Planning, Monitoring & Reporting
Participatory Integrated Community Development (PICD)
Facilitation Skills
4 | P a g e
DAY ONE:
Who is a Key Mobilizer?
Key Mobilizers are RECONCILE volunteers, who are committed to the task of
promoting Civic Education and Trauma Healing in their local communities.
As key mobilizers; it is your job to “make things happen” in the community. Remember
that mobilize has the root “mobile.”
Roles of Key Mobilizers:
Assisting and supporting you in providing/organizing training
Monitoring the progress/process of program implementation where workshops
have been held; sharing resources and consultation
Providing basic trauma counseling and referral of serious cases
Organizing and leading seminars and workshops
Provide training in the form of seminars and community forums in their
respective communities on the topics of Trauma Healing/Civic Education
Provide information to community institutions (such as schools and clinics),
community organizations and religious institutions on the topics of Trauma
Healing and Civic Education
Provide monthly reports of their activities to the Field Coordinators they are
assigned to work under
Devote an average of one day per week to carrying out these tasks.
Issues, Approaches and Challenges in Peacebuilding:
This was an exercise given to participants’ to reflect into their different areas and
identify the major issues that trigger conflicts and psychosocial problem prompting
intervention. The participants were divided into different groups according to their
states to discuss the following issues. These were the findings in the all the groups:
Jonglei, Western, Central and Eastern Equatoria States
5 | P a g e
1. Major issues: Peacebuilding, trauma
2. What approaches or interventions have you tried?
3. Challenges
Issues:
Cattle raiding
Child abduction
Land/Border disputes
Grumbling over grazing land and water for cattle
Girls’ enrollment
Gender Based Violence’s (GBV)
LRA atrocities
Land lease conflict
Alcoholism
Early marriage
Tribalism/ nepotism
Corruption
Poor health services
Tribal conflict
Practicing of witchcraft (birds, Sora and ngasa
HIV/AIDs
Safe drinking water
Approaches
Peace conferences
Training on GBV (Gender-Based Violence)
Training on peace and conflict management
Training on human rights
Cattle camp initiative
Guidance counseling
Creating awareness on human rights in churches, rallies and public gather ing
Warning communities about HIV/AIDs
Challenges
Lack of communication
No cooperation between local community
Lack of funds
Training manuals and stationeries are limited
Lack of the skill
6 | P a g e
Bad roads: Transportation of key mobilizers to different communities to facilitate
meetings…
…Seasons: for instance, during the rainy season, travel is difficult
Some of the communities are resistant to reconciliation
DAY TWO:
Community Mobilization
The Participants came up with these definitions:
Community: community is a group of people who live together and share similar ideas,
resources, norms, value, attitude and cultures.
Mobilization:- is the process of bring people together for specific purpose in order to
achieve a certain goal.
If we are doing community mobilization, we need to involve all people together.
Because each person has an important role to play in the community, we need to
involve people.
The most important in the community is a family, because some of the problems start
from the family, and also if there is no fighting in the family it will bring peace to the
community all at large.
Community structures
Social institutions:
Church, mosque, hospital, youth/women, farmers association
Cultural institutions:
Family, elders, traditional leaders, clan, youth/women
Government institution:
Headmen/women/ school, hospital, army and organized forces
Non- governmental institutions
7 | P a g e
CBO, INGOs, National NGOs, Youth and women Assoc.
The importance of the community mobilization as a process:
Community mobilization is agenda of its own change if we need to build peace we need
to start from the ground roots instead of starting from the high level. Above all,
participation is voluntary, so we need to influence community members to participate.
One of the examples for the important of the community mobilization was given by the
key Mobilizer of Maridi County. He said when we organized the workshop on trauma
healing things in Maridi, the first thing we did was the mobilization of the community
leader through meetings with them and agreed to hold a workshop. Other additions
was also added by the key Mobilizer of Yei River County on the importance of meeting
the community first before the activity takes place.
Challenges in Community Mobilization
Here participants went for group work to discuss the different challenges they face in
community mobilization. Here are some examples of what they came up with.
What are the challenges in community mobilization approach?
Poor communication system
Lack of transportation, bad roads, distance
Lack of skill
Lack of funds
Insecurity
Weather, season
Lack of good cooperation between key mobilizers and local government
Hunger
Ignorance
Politicians
Language barriers
If you yourself cannot change , how can you change the others?
Culture of salience, domination of the local elite, or gender inequality militate
against people’s participation
8 | P a g e
Analysis
How do you bring together young people in your community for a common purpose?
Mapping communication system
Map all the communication means and which of them are most effective
For whom is this activity designed? Youth, Women, Children, Church
leaders/Religions, Organized forces, Traditional leaders, Widow/orphan,
IDPs/Returnees, Host community
How do we mobilize them?
Through local authority
Media, megaphone
Verbal information
Face to face discussions
Season
Analyze which season is appropriate for community activities
November, December, January, February, March etc
What kind of activities are on going
DAYS THREE, FOUR & FIVE:
These days focused on planning and reporting.
Planning:
What is planning? It is all about answering the five W’s:
What, Why, When, Where, Who?
Two types of plans: Short and long term
Three types of short term planning tools: Activity, Weekly, and Monthly plans
Questions and sharing:
9 | P a g e
Projects aimed at changing harmful beliefs and practices in a community must engage
and be lead by members of that community organization changes can facilitate and
support change, yet the changes must occur in the hearts and minds of community
members themselves
Okot shared one of the events which took place in Eastern Equatorial State, where the
government built the school without mobilizing the community. That school ended up
with no people going in, and it is to become a place for the cattle. Another example was
given by Isaiah Ayuen on the one project in Anyidi Payam Bor county, Jonglei state.
The community needed water to be drill in the area, but an organization came to build a
school, which is not the greatest need in the community. That brought
misunderstanding between the community and organization because the community
needed water.
Monitoring and Evaluation
What is monitoring?
Definition of monitoring by participants:
Monitoring is a continuous follow-up checking collection of information and
controlling the steps of activities, success achieving and challenges in a
systematic manner within a given time frame.
There are two levels of monitoring:
1. Organization level
2. Field or community level
In the organization level we monitor three things:
1. Activities: whether done
2. Outputs/ results
3. Inputs the material which we have put in work
At the community level/field:
1. Outcome
2. Input
3. Sustainability
Why monitoring? To ensure that the planned activity is done as was intended
10 | P a g e
Facilitator role
What are the roles of facilitator?
Guide the learning process, to give knowledge and skill
To lead the discussion
To encourage the participants
To provide materials for the workshop
To make reports and evaluate the activity
Passing questions to the participants
WEEK TWO:
Week two was entirely on PICD:
Participatory Integrated Community Development (PICD)
Lessons from the above process
- Though participatory, the community was never fully involved in the planning
process
- The planning was left to the local elites
- A combination of what worked well from all the approaches was seen as better
and it filled in the gaps existing in other processes
- Thus PICD was born
PICD calls for:
- Positive change within communities
- The change must be integrated and participatory
PICD is a participatory planning process which is all inclusive. It includes the
marginalized women, different tribes, and youth, elderly all coming together and
making decisions. When a community is not contributing towards a program run by an
organization, there is no sustainability.
PICD phases and process:
11 | P a g e
Phase 1: Community Entry Process
Phase 2: Initiation stage/ awareness creation and attitude change
River code
Secret in the box
The boat is sinking
Phase 3: Data gathering and Situation Analysis
Phase 4: Design (planning phase)
Phase 5: Implementation
Phase 6: Evaluation
The planning cycle in PICD
As a part of PICD in the “Initiation stage, awareness creation and attitude change,” the
participants were involved in different role plays. These were used as “attitude changing tools.”
Here are some examples of the roles plays, the questions asked and lessons learned:
RIVER CODE: This role-play that depicts three people, two men and one woman walking
together and discussing issues. They suddenly meet a flooded river. They find a man working
Re-Plan
Gathering Data
Evaluate Analyze
Plan
Implementation
Monitor
12 | P a g e
near the swollen river on his farm. Feeling trapped and unable to go over to the other side of
the river where they have a function, they ask the man how they can cross the river. The man
offers to help them. He offers his free services and carries the first two people, the men, across
the swollen river. The woman refuses to be carried and requests to be guided to walk across the
river.
This role-play should be done outside the room. The participants should be asked to use their
two senses of seeing and hearing only.
Which of the characteristics would you want to be?
Man who helped the people cross the river
A woman who want to be learn something
Stone to provide a pathway
What advice can you give to the man helping the people?
Is better to teach people cross the river than carrying them
Give the person chance to tell what the person need help in.
Do not overload yourself
Mobilize the community build a bridge
What advice would you give to those being carried?
Try to learn on how to do things on your own
Bear the conditions according to where they are
Learn by seeing what others are doing
Ask how it’s done
Learn to struggle and cross
Avoid laziness
Appreciate the man who carried them
Experience the process of crossing the river
Learn how to swim
Examples of projects which represent the failed community projects in the South Sudan
communities
CBO in Mugwo payam-Yei County called PASS
Farmers association in Tombura county
Balanda students association community
Why did these projects fail?
Reliance on external funding
13 | P a g e
No local ownership
Lack of community participation
Lack of accountability
Lack of commitment
Ignorance
Greed
What should we do?
Create transparency
Share the idea with the local community
Building grassroots relationship
Encourage local ownership
What lessons did we learn from this role play?
Adopting positive attitude
Not relying on outsiders
Ask for help from somebody
Community involvement in all levels
SECRET IN THE BOX: Three people are chosen from among the participants. One who had
most widely traveled (Internationally), one who had traveled moderately (within Africa) and
one who was locally traveled in Sudan (within their own home area). A box containing various
items but sealed is given to the most widely traveled and asked to name the items in the box by
shaking and hearing the sounds and guessing. The second one who was moderately traveled is
blind folded and asked to touch the items in the box and name them without removing them
from the box. The box is opened, the third person who was locally traveled is asked to look at
what is in the box, consulting with other participants and naming the items, even reading the
labels (as the people mention the items, they are listed on the flip chart).
After the role play, the different people were likened to different actors in development. The
most widely traveled represented INGOs and government, the moderately traveled to churches,
and the least traveled to community leaders.
Why did the person who travelled least get all the marks?
He can see and touch all the things
Has enough time to look into the boxes
Help from the other group members
14 | P a g e
Why did the person who moderately travelled get more than the most travelled?
Able to feel
Made an effort to know what is in the box
By touching enable him/her to identify
Why the most travelled get little marks?
Did not care to know have little time to check
He did not ask for the box to be open
What should we do?
Ask the community what their needs are
Share the idea with the community on how to solve their problems
Build the capacity of the community members
Carry awareness for both the community and government and NGOs
Lessons learned:
international organizations do not know what the community knows
Consult the community and know their priorities and problems
Community involvement is needed in order to reach your goal
THE BOAT IS SINKING: The role play has 8 people in the boat in the middle of a lake.
Inside the boat there is a doctor, soldier, farmer, woman with a child, student, headmaster,
businessman and the boat rider. Each one of them has a luggage. As they sail along, a storm
breaks out, the wind is too much and the boat begins to sink. The crew and the passengers get
worried and decide to throw out luggage. People cry about their luggage but they have to do it,
the student cries about his books. The boat continues to sink and the boatman says he has to
throw out someone. Each person tries to explain why he or she cannot be thrown. The
headmaster claims he cannot be thrown because he is in charge of the students, the doctor says
he is important because the sick people need him, the farmer brings the supplies and the
community needs them, the woman has children and she has to take care of them. The student
is the new generation; while the soldier also says he should not be thrown out. However, they
begin by throwing out the student, the farmer, and the soldier whom they think are not very
important. They follow up with the woman with a child. Finally only the crew, the
businessman, headmaster and the doctor survive.
Does this scenario happen in our community in South Sudan? - Yes
15 | P a g e
How do we compare what happen in the role play to community development?
Scholarships from other countries which are not given to the needy
Opportunities for orphans scholarships
Road constructions in Jonglei state
Local chiefs neglected from the government pay list
Exclusion of minority groups in church women activity in malakal
Why these things happened?
Greediness, Selfishness
Lack of transparency
Lack of accountability
Over looting
Segregations/discrimination
What should we do?
Talk to their MPs
Awareness/advocacy: Let the community know their rights
Formation of a committee in the community
Selection or election of leaders who the communities trust in
Negotiate in a good and peaceful way
What lessons can we draw?
Every member of the community is equally important
Listen to the voices of each person
Persist on what you have planned
Community participation in all actions
Less privileged people are left out
We should not throw out a member of the community
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT: The participants also learned about basics to financial
management and planning, including creating a budget.
What is financial management?
- Financial management entails planning, organizing, controlling and monitoring
the financial resources of an organization to achieve objectives
16 | P a g e
FINANCIAL CONTROL
Financial control occur when systems and procedures are established to make sure
that the financial resources of an organization are being properly handled
Seven principles of financial management: (CATVISA)
1. Consistency
2. Accountability
3. Transparency
4. Viability
5. Integrity
6. Stewardship
7. Accounting standard
Why is financial management important to NGOs?
- Helps managers make effective and efficient use of resources to achieve
objectives
- Helps NGOs to be more accountable to donors and other stake holders
- Gain respect and confidence of the funding organization, partiers and
beneficiaries
- Gives the NGO, the advantage in competition for increasing scarce resources
- Helps the NGO prepare themselves for long term financial sustainability
17 | P a g e
5. Challenges faced in the course of the training
The content of the training topics was too big to finish within two weeks
Some areas were rushed because time was not enough
People were exhausted because the training was intensive
Travel of some participants was very difficult especially Jonglei
6. Recommendations
Prepare before time
Increase the number of training days to cover such topics into details
Divide the training into two phases to avoid exhaustion of participants
7. Conclusion
Despite challenges faced during the two week training, there was a high level of
participation. It was an enjoyable training in terms of its content and in supplementing
the capacity of key mobilizers in their communities.