reducing medications in persons with dementia helping to brighten someones day!! session w24 amda...
TRANSCRIPT
Reducing Medications in Persons with Dementia
Helping to Brighten Someone’s Day!!
Session W24AMDA Annual Symposium
March 7, 2003
Alva S. “Buzz” Baker, MD, CMDArthur Riley, MS, PD
2
Why Medications are Used in Persons with Dementiatreatment of the dementing
disease processtreatment of the side effects or
consequences of the dementing illness
treatment of medical co-morbidities
6
Institutional Philosophy of Medication Use in Dementia“tie ‘em up or drug ‘em down”
– low tolerance for• the “un-cooperative” or hard-to-handle
resident• the wandering resident• crying out
– zero tolerance for resident-to-resident negative interactions
“attain or maintain the highest practicable physical, mental, and psychosocial well-being of each resident”
F490CFR §483.75
7
Institutional Philosophy of Medication Use in Dementia“tie ‘em up or drug ‘em down”
– lack of knowledge or understanding of dementia syndromes as an illness
– lack of knowledge and skills in how to manage behavioral issues in persons with cognitive impairment
– it takes less staff time and effort to use this approach as opposed to making every effort to optimize abilities
“attain or maintain the highest practicable physical, mental, and psychosocial well-being of each resident”
F490CFR §483.75
8
Institutional Philosophy of Medication Use in Dementia“But, these people need these
medicines, don’t they?”– the Hospice experience: enter a near-
dead dementia patient into Hospice• (all) medicines stopped• patient improves – 10 - 20% to where they
no longer meet Hospice criteria (at least for a while…)
• subsequent care not an issue for caregivers
“attain or maintain the highest practicable physical, mental, and psychosocial well-being of each resident”
F490CFR §483.75
9
Medication reduction
Basic Questions– Do all persons with dementia need all the
medications they are receiving?• benefits of medication use:
– ethical quality-of-life issues– bothersome (to resident) symptom control
• burdens of medication use:– deterioration in overall health status– decreased quality of life– medication side-effects, drug interactions– possible earlier death
10
Medication reduction program
process: medical directorprocess: working to achieve
reductioneducation
– medical staff– nursing staff– residents and families
14
Benefits of medication reduction program
to residents/familiesto caregiversto facility
18
Medication Reduction Program: Example in actiondesign program, do educationdo resident reviewsconference: pharmacist and
medical director, develop recommendations
present recommendations to attending physician
monitor results
19
Results
resident profilemedication use in this cohortrecommendations made and how
received by attending physiciansmedication reduction
– accomplished– failed
examples
20
Resident profile
Item Mean Range Comment
Age (yrs) 82 69-92 excl. 4 <65 (80)
MMSE 3 0-10 excl. 2 >20 (4)
Gender: male – 16% female – 84%
21
Resident profile: dementia diagnosis
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
70.0
80.0
Per
ce
nt
of
Re
sid
en
ts
AD VAD other mixed
22
Medication use in this cohort
Mean # of Rx’s: 7.29Least # of Rx: 1 Highest # of Rx: 15
number of rx's per resident
number of rx's per resident
1514131210987654321
Fre
qu
en
cy
10
8
6
4
2
0
23
Classes of medications in use and ID’d
Class/use
# of Rx’s # ID’d
Parkinson’s
15 5
Gut 33 18
Brain 121 17
CVS 80 20
Arthritis 19 5
Diabetes 13 0
Anticoags 14 0
Other 106 19
24
“Brain” drugs
Type # of Rx’s(# of Res.)
# ID’d
CNI 21 (20) 10
neuroleptic
26 (21) 0
anti-depr 51 (38) 6
benzo 22 (18) 1
hypnotic 1 0
25
CVS drugs
Type # of Rx’s
(# of Res.)
# ID’d
HTN 17 (16) 5
‘cardiac’ 35 (24) 5
diuretic 15 (14) 0
hyperlipidemia
13 (13) 10
26
Program at work: reduction
Item Number
Per Res.
Comment
Residents 56 --
Rx’s 401 7.29
ID’d forReduction
82 meds(44 Res.)
1.9 (per Res. ID’d)
20% of total Rx’s
Rx Reduced 15 meds(14 Res.)
.34 Rx (per Res. ID’d)
18% of ID’d Rx’s
4% of total Rx’s
$$ Reduced 1,079.00
19.27
27
Medications reduced, by class
Class/use # of Rx’s
# ID’d
# DC’d
Parkinson’s 15 5 1
Gut 33 18 1
Brain 121 17 1
CVS 80 20 8*
Arthritis 19 5 1
Diabetes 13 0 0
Anticoags 14 0 0
Other 106 19 3* 7 = lipid lowering agents
28
Reason for medication not being changed (82% of ID’d)
2% 6%6%
18%
2%66%
Insurance mandated therapy Physician agrees, no order Family refusal
Neuropsychiatry control Physician opinion Physician refusal/history
29
Discussion
Considering the ethical, economic and operational aspects of a comprehensive medication-reduction program: Is it worth it?
30
Think about it: maybe
YOUcould brighten someone’s
day!
Thank You!!