re-imagining burke lakefront airport · an exploration of alternative land uses presentation for...

40
1

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

1

Page 2: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront AirportAN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES

P R E S E N TAT I O N F O R T H E G R E E N R I B B O N C O A L I T I O N

J U LY 2 0 1 9

M AT T B U S A , P L A , A S L AL A N D S C A P E A R C H I T E C T, A E C O M

2

Page 3: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

3Image Credit: Aerial Agents

Page 4: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Site Facts• 450 Acres

• 3.1 Miles of Shoreline

• Airport Owned and Operated by the City of Cleveland

• Opened in 1947

• Serves primarily small aircraft, corporate jets, air taxis, flight school, & helicopters

• 34,407 flight operations (2017); down from 90,000 (1990s average)

4

Page 5: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Why Is Waterfront Land Use Important?

5

Health Commerce Entertainment

WaterQuality

Real EstateValue Jobs

Page 6: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Why is waterfront land use important?

It Directly Affects…

QUALITY OF LIFE

6

Page 7: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Improving Quality of Life?

7

Page 8: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

A History of Dredging

8

Page 9: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Historic Shoreline Changes

9

1850s Railroad Built on Lake Erie Shoreline

1877 Entire Site Covered By Water

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

1877

1945

Image Source: Library of Congress

Page 10: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

10

1931 Cleveland Municipal Stadium Opens

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

1932

1945

Image Source: Cleveland Public Library

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 11: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

11

1936 First Segment of Shoreway Opens

1936- Great Lakes 1937 Exposition

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

1936

1945

Image Credit: Donald Cole

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 12: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

12

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

1945

Image Source: Cleveland Public Library

1945

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 13: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

13Image Credit: J.H. Doyle

1940 Maine Ave Bridge Opens Shoreway Extended West to Edgewater Park

1947 Burke Airport Opens

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

1959

1945

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 14: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

14

1960s- Airport Expansion1970s

Image Credit: Michael A. Fuerst

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

1974

1945

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 15: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

15

1988 Voinovich Park Opens

2000s- Dredge CDFs2010s Expanded on

North and East Sides of Airport

Image Credit: Google Earth

1877 20181932 1936 1959 20001974

2000

1945

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 16: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

16

1877 20181932 1936 1959

2000s- Dredge Sites2010s Filled In

Image Credit: Google Earth

20001974

2018

1945

Historic Shoreline Changes

Page 17: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

A History of Dredging

17

Page 18: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Scale Comparisons

18

Burke Lakefront Airport450 Acres

Edgewater Park147 Acres

Cedar Point364 Acres

Big Met Golf Course150 Acres

Crocker Park106 Acres

Page 19: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Existing Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs)

19

Page 20: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Existing Poor Waterfront Access

20

Page 21: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

…So What if The Airport Wasn’t There?

21

Page 22: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Concept

22

Existing Proposed

IntegrationCity and Waterfront

SeparationCity and Waterfront

Page 23: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Design Goals & Objectives

23

• Improve Connectivity to the waterfront

• Encourage Development within walking range of downtown and transit

• Create Productive Green Space that:• Improves Public Waterfront Access • Provides Opportunities for Recreation• Disposes of Dredge• Cleans Water• Creates Wildlife Habitat

Connectivity

Infill Development

Recreation

Dredge Mounds

Green Infrastructure

Page 24: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Land Use Plan

24

Page 25: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Site Organization

25

ProductiveGreen Space

TransitOriented

Development

Page 26: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Transit-Oriented Development

26

T T

T TExisting RTAStation

Proposed RTAStation

Page 27: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Shoreway Boulevard

27

Page 28: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Complete Street Connections

28

Page 29: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Waterfront Trail Network

29

Page 30: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Stormwater Treatment Wetlands

30

Page 31: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Dredge Mounds

31

Page 32: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Bird’s Eye View

32

Page 33: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Public Park & Beach

33

Page 34: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Adventure Park & Overlook Mound

34

Existing Grade of AirportExisting Grade of Airport3 Years6 Years9 Years

12 Years

15 Years

DredgeAccumulation

Page 35: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Boardwalks & Habitat Restoration

35

Page 36: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Proposed Land Use Plan

36

Page 37: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

Key Take-Aways

37

1. Every Great Project Begins with a Vision.

2. The Burke Airport Site Has Tremendous Potential To:• Improve Quality of Life • Promote Economic Development• Protect The Environment.

3. This vision was an academic exercise. Public and stakeholder engagement and discourse is critical to any future land use planning.

Page 38: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

One Final Thought…

38

Vertical Takeoff Aircraft May Be The Future of Aviation.

Could The Airport Footprint Shrink In The Future?

Page 39: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

End of Presentation

39

Thank You!

Page 40: Re-Imagining Burke Lakefront Airport · AN EXPLORATION OF ALTERNATIVE LAND USES PRESENTATION FOR THE GREEN RIBBON COALITION. JULY 2019. MATT BUSA, PLA, ASLA ... to Edgewater Park

40Image Credit: Aerial Agents