public hearing ~ on cape vincent's proposed st. lawrence wind project
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
1/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PROPOSED
ST. LAWRENCE WIND ENERGY PROJECT
Held on May 16, 2009, at 10:00 AM, at the Cape Vincent
Recreation Center, South James Street, Cape Vincent,
New York, before Town of Cape Vincent Planning Board Members
Richard Edsall, Chairman, Tom Ingersoll, and George Mingle.
Also Present were Todd Mathes, Esq., and Kris Dimmick, PE.
Court Reporter was Sally B. Maiorano, Registered Merit
Reporter, Certified Realtime Reporter, Certified CARTProvider, Certified Shorthand Reporter, and Notary Public in
and for the State of New York.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
2
Page 1
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
2/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
1 MR. MATHES: Good morning. I'd like to
2 introduce myself. My name is Todd Mathes, I'm an
3 attorney from a law firm --
4 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Can't hear you.
5 MR. MATHES: If we can quiet down so we can
6 use the three hours we have today.
7 My name is Todd Mathes, I'm an attorney from a
8 law firm at Whiteman, Osterman & Hanna in Albany. We
9 were engaged by the town about a year ago to assist the
10 town with the administration of their responsibilities
11 under the State Environmental Quality Review Act.
12 The Planning Board today -- Rich Edsall is the
13 chairman, he's here, we have Tom Ingersoll and George
14 Mingle, the town's engineer is here, Kris Dimmick, we
15 have a stenographer here today -- has asked me to
16 administer today's public hearing. I wanted to set a
17 few ground rules really quickly so everyone has
18 expectations in terms of how this can run.
19 As of right now I only have 37 people signed
20 up, so I think that given the three hours, we can allot
21 for five minutes of time to speak. I would ask that no
22 one delegate their time to another person, but certainly
23 if you yourself would like to speak in excess of the
24 five-minute period, to the extent everyone has an
25 opportunity to speak before 1:00 and we have additional
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
3
1 remaining time, you can certainly go again.Page 2
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
3/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
2 Just in terms of the purpose of today's
3 hearing, today's hearing is a discretionary public
4 hearing, which the Planning Board decided to hold as the
5 State Environmental Quality Review Act lead agency for
6 this project.
7 The purpose of the hearing is to gather
8 substantive comment on the Supplemental Draft
9 Environmental Impact Statement, which was prepared by
10 St. Lawrence Wind Power, the project applicant for the
11 wind project, and submitted to the Planning Board in
12 which the Planning Board deemed complete at a March 2009
13 Planning Board meeting.
14 Publication and notice of the hearing was
15 posted in the environmental notice bulletin online on
16 DEC's website; it was also posted in the newspaper.
17 I'll just add, you know, in sort of further
18 elaboration of the purpose of the hearing, what happens
19 in this process is during the public hearing and during
20 the public comment period, the public comment period is21 going to end May 30th, so if you want to submit
22 written comments you can up until that date. Your
23 comments today, your verbal comments, which will be
24 transcribed, and your written comments will be responded
25 to in a final Environmental Impact Statement, to the
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
4
1 extent they pertain to substantive matter in the SDEIS.
2 To the extent they don't pertain to actual
Page 3
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
4/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt3 environmental impacts, the physical project site, the
4 potential impacts of the project, the characterization
5 of those impacts based on your review of the SDEIS or
6 the mitigation measures proposed in the SDEIS, they may
7 not be responded to. There's no obligation under the
8 SEQRA regulations to respond to non-substantive comments
9 on actual visual and environmental impacts to project.
10 So to the extent that you have comment to make
11 about that, those are very helpful. There's plenty of
12 municipalities throughout New York, and they've been at
13 it for about 30 years under SEQRA and have engaged in
14 this process, and it's a very productive process to the
15 extent you have something to offer, because certainly
16 you as the public have knowledge about the physical
17 project site and things which consultants and planners
18 just can't know.
19 So that's the purpose of incorporating your
20 comments, and we hope that you will offer those
21 substantive comments.
22 With that said, there's some representatives
23 from St. Lawrence Wind Power, they have a couple of
24 maps, and they're going to make a very brief
25 presentation of the project for those of you who are
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
5
1 unfamiliar with it. And I'd ask them to come up now and
2 make that brief presentation.
3 MR. ERIC SCHNEIDER: So thank you very much.
4 My name is Eric Schneider. I'm director ofPage 4
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
5/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
5 communications for Acciona Energy North America. And I
6 want to thank you all very much for coming out today and
7 for giving us the opportunity to introduce this project
8 to you in a little bit greater detail. I'm very honored
9 to be here and honored to have the chance to talk about
10 a company that I'm very proud to work for.
11 Acciona is a 100-year-old global company. We
12 have more than 35,000 employees. We operate on five
13 continents and in 30 countries. And a pioneering in
14 global energy solutions for 20 years.
15 In 2008 Acciona produced almost 9,000 gigawatt
16 hours of electricity from renewable energy sources,
17 which avoided nearly 5.5 million tons of CO2 emissions
18 from conventional power plants.
19 We're the second largest developer of wind
20 farms in the world. And we're the second largest
21 producer of renewable energy. We're well diversified in
22 renewable energies with experience and presence in eight
23 renewable energy technologies, but we don't currently24 have any operations in fossil fuel technologies.
25 For wind Acciona has more than 6,000 megawatts
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
6
1 installed as of January 2009, which amounts to about 5%
2 of the world's total capacity. Those 6,000 megawatts
3 are spread across 208 wind farms located in 14 countries
4 that we've built over the past 20 years.
5 And in North America Acciona has ownership in
Page 5
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
6/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt6 seven wind farms -- seven operational wind farms
7 totaling 525 megawatts, including two wind farms which
8 are opening this summer in Illinois and Oklahoma.
9 To add more information on the St. Lawrence
10 project I'm going to turn it over to Pete Zedick, who's
11 the project developer.
12 MR. ZEDICK: Hi. As Eric said, I'm Pete
13 Zedick, the developer for this project. Just to give a
14 little background on the project, it's a 79.5-megawatt
15 wind power project consisting of 53 wind turbines. The
16 wind turbines we're going it use thorough this project
17 are Acciona turbines rated at 1.5 megawatts.
18 The project also includes a collection
19 substation, which will have a 115 kV transmission line
20 that runs from the collection substation on Wilson Road
21 to Route 179 in the town of Lyme.
22 Just for background on a little bit more of
23 what Todd said, is the project submitted a site plan
24 application to the town of Cape Vincent Planning Board
25 back in November 2006, that was followed with a Draft
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
7
1 Environmental Impact Statement in January 2007. And
2 there was a public hearing held on that draft in March
3 of 2007.
4 January 14th, 2009, the project submitted
5 its Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement,
6 and that was accepted as complete by the town of Cape
7 Vincent Planning Board on March 25th, 2009, where aPage 6
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
7/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
8 hearing was scheduled for today.
9 So those are the project details. I would
10 just like to say we appreciate you coming out today, and
11 we look forward to all the comment, public input. And
12 thank you all very much.
13 MR. MATHES: Thanks. The thing I neglected to
14 say is if you've written down your comments today, you
15 can do one of two things: If you've just jotted down
16 your comments and you want to submit them to the
17 stenographer today, she'll take those, and they'll
18 certainly assist her in preparation of the transcript.
19 To the extent you've written out comments
20 which you want to make as a formal written submission,
21 you can hand those to me today; you can also mail those
22 to the town supervisor. So certainly if you just have,
23 you know, handwritten comments or whatever, and you want
24 to give those to the stenographer, please do, they're
25 helpful to her, and we'll bundle those separately and
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
8
1 just treat those as actual verbal comments.
2 The first person who signed up today is Cindy
3 Grant. If Cindy could come up.
4 MS. GRANT: I have read the DEIS for the
5 St. Lawrence Wind Energy Project, and I have some
6 serious concerns for the health and the safety of the
7 residents who live within a two-mile area of this
8 project.
Page 7
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
8/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt9 I am for green energy. And in fact, at my
10 house we recycle everything; we don't burn. But this is
11 going to hurt people here. But these industrial wind
12 turbines must be placed in a responsible and regulated
13 manner so that the people that live there right now will
14 not be hurt and made to suffer. The area in question is
15 very populated, and I believe the residents will be
16 harmed by low frequency noise, or infrasound, that this
17 project will produce.
18 The submitted DEIS does not mention low
19 frequency noise, that's dBC, it's a weighting, which is
20 an injustice. All noise is vibration, and the audible
21 sound you hear coming from my lips right now, this is
22 high frequency, or dBA, which was what St. Lawrence Wind
23 chose to use here.
24 If you do your research, you'll find out that
25 noise for this project should be measured using dBA and
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775 9
1 dBC to accurately see what the proposed noise and health
2 effects will be to the people that live here.
3 Even the independent acoustical report
4 requested about your town, the Tocci report, said that
5 you must also -- that you also must use dBC to measure
6 for low frequency noise.
7 To understand low frequency noise, consider
8 what happens when a young person pulls up next to you at
9 a traffic light and they have their music up loud in
10 their car. You can feel the boom, boom, boom of theirPage 8
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
9/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
11 music vibrate right through their car windows right into
12 your car. If you have a pen sitting on your dashboard,
13 it even vibrates, and that vibration doesn't stop there,
14 that vibration continues on through your body.
15 The vibration or rumble and the boom, boom,
16 boom effect is low frequency noise, or infrasound. The
17 metal and the glass of your car blocked out a lot of the
18 high frequency noise, but it did not block out the low
19 frequency noise. And low frequency noise can easily
20 travel through the walls and the roof of neighbors'
21 homes in this project. It is why there must be proper
22 measurements taken using a combination of dBC and dBA to
23 find out what the true impacts to the citizens here will
24 be.
25 This project area is highly populated. If you
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
10
1 look at other wind projects around the world and around
2 the U.S., industrial wind turbines are placed away from
3 people, far enough away so people aren't harmed.
4 Typically industrial wind turbines cause the
5 most disturbance at night, when the winds at ground
6 level are still but the wind up at the hub height are
7 still blowing, and the noise from the turbine will be
8 very noticeable in the home.
9 Noise studies done at an industrial wind
10 project sites after they have been up and running often
11 show that they are making much more noise than the
Page 9
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
10/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt12 developers said they would, but by then it's too late.
13 Low frequency noise, or infrasound, can be
14 especially dangerous to children whose bodies are still
15 developing, but it can also cause severe problems for
16 anyone living too close.
17 I also believe that the residents will be
18 harmed by the shadow flicker effect, especially people
19 who already suffer from migraines, epilepsy and vertigo.
20 Over 20 years ago the Exxon Valdez ran aground
21 in Alaska -- and I'm not talking about the oil here,
22 okay, I know this is an energy giant, and Exxon Valdez
23 is an energy giant, I'm talking about what happens when
24 you try to do business with a giant energy company. We
25 have no recourse. But over 20 years ago the Exxon
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
11
1 Valdez ran aground in Alaska, but the citizens there
2 have never received just compensation. Even the U.S.
3 Federal Government went after the energy giant Exxon.
4 They couldn't get their money.
5 There is also no way that the town of Cape
6 Vincent residents will ever be able force this developer
7 to make right any violations against the innocent
8 residents that live near this project unless proper
9 regulations are put into effect now. Before this
10 project is allowed, please put more safeguards in place
11 now to protect your citizens because you cannot do it
12 afterwards. The health and the safety of your citizens
13 should be the number one concern.Page 10
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
11/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
14 And please, if you go online at Wind Watch,
15 any of you, I know you might not believe what I'm
16 saying.
17 MR. MATHES: Cindy.
18 MS. GRANT: Go online and -- sorry -- and
19 you'll see Wind Watch.
20 MR. MATHES: Gerry Smith. The one other thing
21 I neglected to say --
22 [Applause]
23 MR. MATHES: -- we tried to orient the table
24 today -- two things: If we applaud you won't make it
25 through the hearing. So yea or nay, wherever you stand,
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
12
1 if you could just refrain from applauding.
2 The other thing is we tried orient the table3 so that you can address the board but so that everyone
4 else will also be able to see and hear you. If you can
5 address the board, that's helpful.
6 MR. SMITH: Thank you. I don't think I
7 usually need a microphone, so --
8 MR. MATHES: Mr. Smith, if you could. Thank
9 you.
10 MR. SMITH: I'm Gerry Smith. I'm an avian
11 ecologist. You all on the Planning Board have heard
12 from me before. And our concern -- my concern is
13 related to wildlife, et cetera.
14 Basically, my comments on the DEIS previously
Page 11
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
12/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt15 submitted remain valid. The SDEIS was an opportunity to
16 upgrade a very important DEIS, and frankly, the
17 consultants failed miserably.
18 The SDIS is in no way adequate. This part of
19 the world is an extremely important raptor area for much
20 of the year, ranging between August and well into June.
21 These issues are barely addressed, and they are not
22 addressed significantly. Let's put it this way: One
23 has to question the level of effort and competence on
24 the part of the field teams that were out looking at
25 these birds and bats.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
13
1 Let's put it this way: During the winter of
2 2006-2007 I had dozens of short-eared owls, a state
3 endangered species, within the Acciona wind footprint.
4 The consultants for the company, by their own admission,
5 failed to define a single short-eared owl and apparently
6 have not seen one since, even though they've been here
7 each of the last three winters.
8 That strongly suggests to me that there is a
9 problem even -- again, it's a little hard to come up
10 with conclusions and potential impacts when you can't
11 even find what you're supposed to be assessing.
12 There are lots of potential problems with the
13 lack of information on short-eared owl; the impacts of
14 turbine noise on acoustic hunting are not addressed; and
15 if such a large assemblage of a New York State
16 endangered species is not considered significant -- toPage 12
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
13/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
17 be at significant risk from an industrial wind complex,
18 then I'd basically like to know what is.
19 I have to question the level of competence as
20 well as the amount of time put into the field.
21 Basically, when you have a report that talks about
22 unidentified geese, and my favorite, woodpeckers. I
23 would like to ask the consultant what in heaven's name
24 are using for field people? That's rather poor, to put
25 it mildly.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
14
1 They draw conclusions from raptor migration
2 studies through the area. Now, I have spent hundreds,
3 indeed thousands of hours looking at raptors in this
4 area. They have a total of 63 hours. They assume there
5 is no raptor migration in this area.6 Well, I'd be interested to know where the
7 raptors that I see coming in, and I have seen an active
8 migration, are coming from. Perhaps there's a black
9 hole that goes around the survey sites, I don't know.
10 But these conclusions are not viable.
11 The breeding bird summary -- breeding bird
12 survey, 20 points in 20 square miles covered for a total
13 of ten minutes. Absolutely ludicrous, folks. You can't
14 draw conclusions based on that kind of information. It
15 is simply not possible. And any ornithologist worth
16 their salt will tell you that.
17 No surveys were conducted for rare species
Page 13
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
14/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt18 such as Henslow's sparrow, which require targeted field
19 surveys. As for the winter raptor study, let's put it
20 this way, their entire study effort is far less than
21 mine in one single year, let alone all the years I've
22 been doing this, and in the three years that I've been
23 doing this since the wind farm was proposed.
24 The basic point in all this is --
25 MR. MATHES: One minute, Gerry.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
15
1 MR. SMITH: Okay. Basic point in all of this
2 is that the information being provided and the
3 conclusions cannot be considered valid. Essentially,
4 the level of effort is insufficient. Citing studies
5 from other locations is basically not useful. There is
6 all sorts of fill information, such as breeding bird
7 surveys and stuff from other areas that are not
8 relevant.
9 Basically, what this is all about, folks, is
10 this is not about protecting or assessing the raptor or
11 any other resources. Perhaps this DEIS is acceptable
12 for surface strip mines in Wyoming or other projects in
13 the back woods of Wyoming. It is certainly not
14 acceptable by the standards of DEIS work in the state of
15 New York. Thank you.
16 MR. MATHES: Don Metzger.
17 [Applause]
18 MR. MATHES: Folks, I appreciate that people
19 have substantive comments and you want to applaud, butPage 14
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
15/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
20 if you could refrain from applauding, it's helpful in
21 terms of getting through the hearing. And also if you
22 could address the Board. Don?
23 MR. METZGER: Good morning, Mr. Chairman.
24 Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak here
25 today. Fellow Board members, Todd.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
16
1 MR. MATHES: Can everyone hear him?
2 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: No.
3 MR. MATHES: Can you use the microphone, Don?
4 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Why doesn't he get to
5 the middle so everyone can hear him?
6 MR. METZGER: Good morning, Mr. Chairman,
7 fellow Board members, Todd. Thank you for the
8 opportunity to speak this morning.9 For the record, my name is Don Metzger, and
10 for the past 32 years I have been a resident --
11 year-round resident of the town of Lyme, one of the
12 towns that will be affected by this project.
13 I am a property owner there, taxpayer there,
14 and registered voter there. The town of Cape Vincent --
15 in the village of Cape Vincent for past 32 years
16 concurrent I have been an operator, owner, and manager
17 of a business here in Cape Vincent paying taxes here in
18 Cape Vincent.
19 With that as a background, I'd like to state
20 that my comments today will be to you concerning the
Page 15
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
16/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt21 Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement that
22 was just released a little less than two months ago.
23 I will present my concerns and my questions
24 that I have on it, and I will go in numerical order in
25 the draft. So my order of presentation isn't
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
17
1 necessarily my order of concern or importance.
2 In Volume 1, Section 2, Page 3, it says that
3 after the public comment period on the SDEIS two
4 alternative procedural pathways will be available to the
5 lead agency, the Cape Vincent -- the Cape Vincent
6 Planning Board is the lead agency for the two towns,
7 here, for the town of Lyme and the town of Cape Vincent.
8 The town of Cape Vincent Planning Board could
9 require preparation of a final Environmental Impact
10 Statement. If that alternative policy is chosen, the
11 following steps would be taken. And then it delineates
12 the following steps.
13 What my question would be to the Board in
14 hopes that it could be in the final impact statement is
15 what about alternative two? It doesn't state anything
16 about alternative two.
17 And my other concern is that if you take
18 alternative one, it gives the public only ten days in
19 which to consider the final Environmental Impact
20 Statement. I believe that ten days to consider a
21 project of that size is insufficient for the community.
22 I would ask that the Board have in the finalPage 16
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
17/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
23 draft a clarification on decommissioning. There seems
24 to be -- if you read closely, Volume 1, Section 2,
25 Page 20 and 21, it leaves a little bit of confusion as
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
18
1 to what will be or will not be taken down. Do the
2 foundations go, the collection cables, the 37 miles of
3 underground collection cables? They talk about a
4 permanent easement for those cables, and they talk about
5 greater than 48 inches, less than 48, at one point they
6 use the depth of 44 inches. I believe that's a
7 misprint, but -- one minute left? At this point I would
8 like to request time at the end if it's available.
9 I have big concerns about the safety and
10 integrity of the Development Authority of the North
11 Country's western Jefferson County regional water line,12 the 12-inch interior diameter water line that goes for
13 25 miles from Cape Vincent to Glen Park, serving four
14 towns, five villages, the General Brown School, and
15 many, many water hydrants. That is a potential -- with
16 the poles there being set 15 feet into the ground, there
17 is a physical integrity, physical security problem. I
18 think the engineers have been working on it, but I would
19 request, Mr. Chairman, that if there is a DANC,
20 Development Authority of the North Country, engineer
21 here today, that he might be able to address some of our
22 concerns and fears in that matter, because that line has
23 been here for ten years now serving this community and
Page 17
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
18/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt24 all the communities all the way to Glen Park very well
25 with fresh water. We can deal --
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
19
1 MR. MATHES: Don, that's your time.
2 MR. METZGER: We can't go without fresh water.
3 We can go without electricity, but we can't go without
4 fresh water, Mr. Chairman. Thanks. If I have more
5 time, I would appreciate it later.
6 MR. MATHES: Beth White. And you don't need
7 to reserve time. To the extent there's time and people
8 raise hands, that's fine. Beth White?
9 MS. WHITE: I'm Beth White. I'm in favor of
10 accepting the DEIS. The DEIS includes the project
11 description, environmental impacts, the layout and
12 design of the wind farm, as well as the decommissioning
13 process. The lease agreements also contain contingency
14 plans for the decommissioning. Sections 2.8, one
15 through three, detail this process. The process will be
16 in accord with all applicable state and federal and
17 local permits.
18 The restoration process is also explained,
19 including a two-year monitoring and remediation period.
20 The decommissioning includes aboveground and
21 below-ground structures, and the sequence for their
22 removal has turbines, foundations, collection cables,
23 substations, roadways, and paths.
24 The actual removal of the turbine is described
25 in Section 2.8.1.1. Then the removal of the foundationPage 18
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
19/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
20
1 is described in Section 2.8.1.1. As you read the DEIS,
2 each element of the process is described in great
3 detail, leaving nothing to chance and covering every
4 possible angle.
5 I believe the wind company has gone to great
6 lengths to go above and beyond the ordinary scope of an
7 EIS.
8 I trust the Cape Vincent Town Board and
9 Planning Board to review this document and to approve it
10 as it deems appropriate.
11 I am in favor of the wind farm. Thousands of
12 turbines across the U.S. and the world are producing
13 energy safely. Control systems continually monitor the
14 turbines to assure safe and efficient operations. Like15 many Upstate New York communities, Cape Vincent faces
16 economic challenges. The wind farm can be our solution.
17 MR. MATHES: Melodee Doull. I apologize if I
18 mispronounce your name. And feel free to pronounce it
19 for the stenographer too.
20 MS. DOULL: In several places the Supplemental
21 Draft Environmental Impact Statement proposed for the
22 St. Lawrence Wind Power Project states that the Acciona
23 project is in compliance with the local zoning ordinance
24 and land use regulations. This is not true. Cape
25 Vincent does not have a zoning law with regulations
Page 19
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
20/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
21
1 pertaining to commercial wind turbines.
2 The joint comprehensive plan was adopted in
3 2003 by Cape Vincent to regulate land use in the town
4 and village. This document clearly discouraged the
5 scale of a monumental turbine industry by specifically
6 mentioning towers or utilities.
7 The setbacks that the project claims to adhere
8 to in Section 3.5.1.3 are not criteria that have been
9 legally adopted by the Town or the Planning Board. The
10 report states that these setbacks were determined by
11 considering public comments after the public hearing on
12 the draft EIS. This is not how zoning regulations are
13 legislated.
14 This community is mired in a controversy over
15 conflicts of interest which have prohibited our local
16 government from adopting a fair and legal wind
17 ordinance.
18 In Section 3.8.3 mitigation measures are
19 discussed. Acciona believes reducing the number of
20 turbines from 96 to 53 will reduce the number of
21 turbines visible from a given location.
22 There is insufficient documentation to back up
23 the claim that downsizing the project is a viable
24 solution. Acciona also believes that reducing the
25 height of each turbine from 425 feet to 390.5 feet is an
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
Page 20
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
21/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt 22
1 answer to mitigation. Turbines that are 390.5 feet tall
2 cannot be mitigated by the color they are painted or the
3 lack of commercial advertising, as stated by Acciona.
4 In the visual impact conclusion, 3.8.4,
5 Acciona states that since renewable energy sources such
6 as wind turbines are so important, that the residents
7 need to live with these large and visible facilities.
8 This is an arrogant and callous disregard for the rights
9 of nonparticipating residents. Natural or manmade
10 devices to mitigate the negative visual and auditory
11 impact of wind turbines do not exist. This is an
12 unacceptable living environment.
13 Where is the logic in offering this
14 questionable asset and ruining one of the most scenic
15 vistas in America? In several European countries, such
16 as Denmark and Germany, they are already reconsidering
17 the wisdom of their investment in large-scale wind18 power.
19 In Paragraph 2.8 Acciona describes their
20 decommissioning plan. There is no mention of the
21 transmission lines; there is no mention of secure funds
22 to implement the plan. Will there be bonding? What
23 happens when the wind farm is sold to another company?
24 Will the new company adhere to the decommissioning plan
25 as described in the SDEIS? These questions need
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
23
Page 21
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
22/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
1 answers.
2 In Appendix J, supplemental shadow flicker
3 analysis, it states that the distance between a wind
4 turbine and a receptor affects the intensity of the
5 shadows cast by the blades, and therefore the intensity
6 of flickering.
7 One can assume similar effects relative to the
8 noise and low frequency vibration issues can be based on
9 the proximity of a receptor to a turbine.
10 A logical mitigation solution would be --
11 MR. MATHES: One minute left.
12 MS. DOULL: A logical mitigation solution
13 would be to increase turbine setbacks in order to lessen
14 the effects of flicker, noise, and vibration concerns.
15 MR. MATHES: Thank you. Urban Hershey?
16 MR. HIRSCHEY: Thank you and good morning.
17 Urban Hirschey, Cape Vincent, New York.
18 I'm going to confine my remarks today on the
19 cumulative effects, which was Section 4, and on the
20 alternative analysis on Section 7.
21 I think it's instructive and interesting that
22 the original DEIS on both of these -- on the -- the
23 number of pages on the cumulative effects was three, and
24 on the D -- on the supplemental DEIS it was 20.
25 Basically the same goes with the alternative analysis,
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
24
1 there were four pages, and on the supplemental there arePage 22
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
23/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
2 41 pages.
3 And as you look over here at the -- I think
4 there are two big volumes versus one smaller volume on
5 the original DEIS. So there's a lot more data and a lot
6 more words to look at and to study.
7 And it's also interesting that the DEIS
8 original was presented on January -- accepted on
9 January 24th, and the comment period closed
10 June 15th. Almost five months. This -- the
11 supplemental was submitted March 25th, accepted
12 March 25th, and May 30th is the comment.
13 Given the volume of information, it would seem
14 to me that it should be at least five months, which was
15 the original DEIS comment period.
16 Getting into some of the detail, in the -- on
17 Page 4-1 it reads, the SEQRA process requires that
18 reasonable related cumulative impacts be evaluated where
19 other projects have been specifically identified and
20 either are part of a single plan or program or21 sufficient nexus of common or interactive impacts
22 warrant assessing such impacts together.
23 This is pretty interesting because, you know,
24 what does common mean? BP and Acciona are both projects
25 for Cape Vincent. They're within the bounds of Cape
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
25
1 Vincent, and they share a transmission line, or they're
2 talking about sharing a transmission line. Clearly they
Page 23
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
24/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt3 are common, and they should be viewed as one. And it
4 seems to me that it's -- it's rather convenient that
5 they divided this township in two so that each one could
6 be considered separately, and therefore it wouldn't have
7 the cumulative effect of having considering 140 or 150
8 turbines versus 50.
9 Towards the bottom of the Page 4-1 it lists a
10 number of projects within 13 miles, I believe. And it
11 lists the BP Cape Vincent wind, it listed the
12 Hounsfield, which is Galloo Island, Horse Creek Farm in
13 Clayton, and the Wolfe Island project.
14 What it does fail to mention, though, is that
15 BP also has a project which is currently dormant in the
16 town of Lyme. But clearly the -- this project has not
17 been abandoned, the -- I would guess that the contracts
18 are still alive, and when this thing goes through, if it
19 goes through, Lyme is going to fire up again, and there
20 are going to be an additional amount of turbines that
21 are considered.
22 MR. MATHES: One minute.
23 MR. HIRSCHEY: 4.1.3, ecological resources.
24 They talk about significant cumulative adverse effects
25 are not anticipated because none of the projects when
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
26
1 considered individually are anticipated to cause
2 significant impacts to wildlife or wildlife habitants of
3 the project taken together. It will not cause impacts
4 that interact with or increase the extent of the impactsPage 24
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
25/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
5 of other projects.
6 This is pretty interesting because if you
7 consider some -- the migrating birds fly along the
8 eastern shore of Lake Ontario. And if you get a flock
9 of ducks or geese or whatever flying through, let's say
10 50. If -- am I going too --
11 MR. MATHES: It's time.
12 MR. HIRSCHEY: Okay. I'm going to forget that
13 part. Let's go to the last one, which is alternative --
14 this is the section that talks about what happens if
15 there are no turbines.
16 MR. MATHES: I'm going to have to ask you to
17 stop because we're past five minutes.
18 MR. HIRSCHEY: I'll come back later.
19 MR. MATHES: Okay. Theresa Ciocci? Do you
20 want to submit anything?
21 MR. HIRSCHEY: No, I'll do it later.
22 MS. CIOCCI: Ladies and gentlemen. Thank you.
23 Precaution is the principle of justice that no one24 should live with fear of harm to their health and
25 environment.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
27
1 I am Theresa Ciocci, a property owner,
2 taxpayer, and registered voter in the town of Cape
3 Vincent. I'm a registered nurse, master's prepared in
4 nursing administration, and certified in education.
5 In my current job I am a member of a medical
Page 25
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
26/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt6 planning board with similar responsibilities to this
7 Board. The responsibilities include reviewing all
8 research prior to implementation for potential risk of
9 human harm. My role demands that I perform ethically,
10 unbiased, and without real or the potential for
11 financial gain to determine risk and to inform those
12 potential participants of those risks or to deny the
13 research in the face of unresolved risk uncertainty.
14 Most of my statements are excerpts from the
15 Precautionary Principle in Action Handbook written for
16 the Science and Environmental Network from the
17 January 1998 Wingspread Statement on the Precautionary
18 Principle. In order to accurately report their words, I
19 will be reading much of my presentation.
20 The public has typically carried the burden of
21 proving that a particular activity or substance is
22 dangerous. Well, those undertaking potentially
23 dangerous activities and the products of those
24 activities are considered innocent until proven guilty.
25 Chemicals, dangerous practices, and companies often seem
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
28
1 to have more rights than the citizens and the
2 environment.
3 When citizen groups base their calls for a
4 stop to a particular activity on experience,
5 observation, or anything less than scientific proof,
6 they're accused of being emotional and hysterical. We
7 do not have to accept business as usual. Precaution isPage 26
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
27/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
8 a guiding principle we can use to stop environmental
9 degradation.
10 The precautionary principle has become a
11 critical aspect of environmental agreements and
12 environmental activism throughout the world. It offers
13 the public and decision makers a forceful, common sense
14 approach to the environment and public health problems.
15 The National Environmental Policy Act requires
16 that any project receiving federal funding and which may
17 pose serious harm to the environment undergo
18 environmental impact study, demonstrating that there are
19 no safer alternatives. Risk assessment is fundamentally
20 undemocratic. Those exposed to harm are rarely asked
21 whether the exposure is acceptable to them.
22 The President's Council on Sustainable
23 Development expressed support for the precautionary
24 principle in the form of a core belief that even in the
25 face of scientific uncertainty, society should take
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
29
1 responsible actions to avert risks to the potential harm
2 to human health or the environment is thought -- when
3 the potential for harm to human health or the
4 environment is thought to be serious or irreparable.
5 It is evident that this EIS has been guided by
6 ignorance, arrogance, and agreed on the part of this
7 planning committee and those who have the power,
8 control, and resources to act and prevent undue harm to
Page 27
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
28/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt9 human health and ecosystems in relation to the following
10 list of health and wellness insults: Noise emission
11 pollution, visual assault pollution, airborne toxin
12 pollution.
13 Ignorance and uncertainty are no longer
14 excuses for postponing actions to prevent harm. At this
15 time I can only question why arrogance and greed have
16 not been emergently dealt with by the New York Attorney
17 General Office for Public Integrity.
18 The precautionary approach requires that the
19 public be involved initially and intimately in the
20 ongoing decision making process. The public needs to
21 determine if we are dealing with something unknowable or
22 about which we are totally ignorant. High uncertainty
23 about possible harm is a good reason not to proceed with
24 a project.
25 The uncertainty surrounding noise emissions,
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775 30
1 visual assault, and airborne toxin pollution includes
2 but is not limited to the long- and short-term effects
3 of sleep deprivation, potentially leading to chronic
4 stress, increased rates of suicide attempts --
5 MR. MATHES: One minute.
6 MS. CIOCCI: -- and their successes, smoking
7 and alcohol abuse in vulnerable populations, for
8 example, children and the elderly, which comprise
9 one-third of this community, as published in your Joint
10 Commission Comprehensive Plan for village, the town ofPage 28
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
29/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
11 Cape Vincent, a document also largely ignored by the
12 Planning Board, and soldiers and others suffering from
13 PTSD, ADHD, autism, depression and chronic fatigue
14 syndrome.
15 Potential for increased frequency and severity
16 of headaches, seizures, dizziness, irritability
17 disturbances in and child learning capability.
18 Potential for increased rates of respiratory
19 distress and disease, including lung cancer due to the
20 inhalation of dirt and dust during the unregulated or
21 ignored regulations during the installation phase of
22 such projects.
23 This is just one more airborne assault on our
24 lungs in addition to rather than protecting us from
25 other toxic airborne emissions.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
31
1 MR. MATHES: That's your time.
2 MS. CIOCCI: I'll finish at the end. Thank
3 you.
4 MR. MATHES: John Byrne?
5 In the back when people speak into the
6 microphone do you hear them?
7 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Not very well.
8 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Can you turn the volume
9 up?
10 MR. MATHES: That's all we've got. It's up
11 now.
Page 29
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
30/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt12 MR. BYRNE: Okay, I'll speak up for you, I'm
13 sorry. Thank you, Board members, for letting me speak
14 and letting the community have the opportunity to speak.
15 Thank you, fellow citizens, for listening.
16 We're here today to comment on a DEIS for a
17 wind power project in Cape Vincent. And in looking
18 through this DEIS I have noticed that it's extremely
19 inadequate in the sound studies in there. We're
20 supposed to be dealing with a project where the
21 developer is going to come in and give us an honest
22 assessment of what's going on in Cape Vincent, and
23 he's -- it's his job to determine what our ambient
24 background noise level is.
25 This is an extremely important topic because
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
32
1 this is -- when you have an ambient noise background
2 you're going to have an increase over that. He's
3 already told us it's going to be louder in Cape Vincent
4 after the development than prior to. So that's
5 something I think everybody should get used to.
6 He's allowed to go 5 decibels above ambient,
7 according to what the DEC guidelines are going to allow
8 him. So in determining the ambient background noise
9 level it's going to determine what noise level we're
10 going to listen to afterwards.
11 Hessler & Associates, who represents both
12 developers in Cape Vincent in their noise studies, has
13 gone around town and taken some noise assessments. ThisPage 30
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
31/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
14 is a typical site of what he's studying, okay? Now, I'm
15 going to hold this up if I can, Chuck. This is supposed
16 to be your typical farmhouse in Cape Vincent, okay?
17 Now, this looks lovely, I see a farmhouse over here, but
18 if you notice, over here there's a construction trailer.
19 You can show the audience this as well; I
20 think they should be entitled to see this. This looks
21 straight now. If anyone goes out to this site, which is
22 on Route 12, and they stand here and look at their noise
23 monitoring equipment and they look over their shoulder,
24 they see this, which is your staging yard for a
25 construction operation. If they think this is fair, I
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
33
1 don't know what is fair.
2 This is dishonest, at the least. And it3 borders on being fraudulent. And this is what we're
4 going to have to live with. 5 decibels above this noise
5 level for the rest of our lives, folks. Or at least 20
6 or 30 years. If you're comfortable with living with
7 this, it's good for you. I'm not comfortable with it.
8 That's why I'm speaking out on this.
9 And I think anyone that's here that cares
10 about what's going to happen in the future of Cape
11 Vincent needs to speak out on this. We can't allow
12 these guys to come in and do this. Pro wind people,
13 non-pro wind people, we're going to have to live with it
14 for the rest of our lives. I'm here to tell you you're
Page 31
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
32/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt15 going to have to deal with this noise. If you want to
16 deal with it, that's fine. I don't want to deal with
17 that. Thank you.
18 [Applause]
19 MR. MATHES: Dave Docteur.
20 MR. DOCTEUR: My comments as related to the
21 SDEIS under D, alternative analysis, St. Lawrence Wind
22 says that the project will meet all of the following
23 setbacks required by the Planning Board of Cape Vincent.
24 They are as follows: 1500 feet from the village of Cape
25 Vincent; 1,000 feet from a nonparticipating property
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
34
1 line; 1250 feet from a nonparticipating residence; and
2 750 feet from a participating residence.
3 My question is why does St. Lawrence Wind even
4 consider coming within 1500 feet of this beautiful,
5 quaint, quiet, one-of-a-kind village located on the
6 St. Lawrence River when it's common knowledge that these
7 huge generating plants radiate sweeping shadows,
8 excessive noise, flicker, and in addition to this a
9 sickness called vibroacoustic disease that makes life
10 intolerable for the people living there.
11 The recommendation of the scientific community
12 is a setback of one and a half miles from a residence to
13 avoid the debilitating sickness called vibroacoustic
14 disease. Vibroacoustic disease is a result of the
15 inaudible low frequency energy transmitted from the
16 turbine generator causing body cavities such as the headPage 32
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
33/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
17 and chest to resonate or vibrate. This can cause
18 sickness in the form of headaches, sleep deprivation,
19 nausea, dizziness, depression, palpitations, et cetera.
20 Why does St. Lawrence Wind propose to destroy
21 our little village like this? Other nearby towns are
22 proposing ordinances that will require a setback of
23 close to a mile from their villages. Anyone can spend
24 some time at Maple Ridge Wind Farm near Lowville to
25 verify these harmful effects. And I have included
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
35
1 scientific evidence on vibroacoustic disease as a
2 reference.
3 A 1250-foot setback from a nonparticipating
4 residence results in putting the generating plant
5 practically on top of them and will cause intolerable6 conditions with the shadows, flicker, and noise.
7 Especially the noise. Remember, it is recommended that
8 there be a one-and-a-half-mile setback, not two-tenths
9 of a mile.
10 Why should people have to abandon their homes
11 in Cape Vincent to satisfy some wealthy investors in the
12 country of Spain? Why does St. Lawrence Wind want to do
13 this? They know all too well the harm this can cause.
14 Don't they have any sense of common decency?
15 I have included written statements from people
16 in other parts of the country that are being driven from
17 their home because of this very situation.
Page 33
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
34/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt18 Also, a 1,000 setback from a nonparticipating
19 property line renders that property uninhabitable,
20 undevelopable, and for many causes unusable. Why does
21 St. Lawrence Wind want to do this? They are fully
22 knowledgeable of the harmful effects of doing this.
23 As far as a 750-foot setback to a
24 participating residence is concerned, you just have to
25 feel sorry for the innocent nonparticipants, the
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
36
1 children, and uninformed adults who live there.
2 Why does this Spanish-owned company, Acciona,
3 St. Lawrence Wind want to destroy our beautiful
4 one-of-a-kind area where Lake Ontario meets the
5 St. Lawrence River with these unconscionable setbacks?
6 The reference for vibroacoustic disease and
7 the letter from one of the soon-to-be-displaced persons
8 is on the internet at WindTurbineSyndrome.com. A letter
9 to the editor written by Jessica Nuhn of Strykersville,
10 New York, is included as the other family whose life has
11 been intolerably interrupted by living too close to
12 industrial wind turbines.
13 MR. MATHES: Kenneth White.
14 MR. WHITE: Hi. I'm Ken White. I'm in favor
15 of the wind farms in the town of Cape Vincent. The
16 process of building a wind farm is not easy. There are
17 very many environmental and geological concerns. The
18 Town Board and the Planning Board have done a superior
19 job in handling the many aspects of the project withPage 34
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
35/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
20 professionalism and diligence.
21 The Supplemental DEIS describes the entire
22 wind project from start to finish. It includes a scope
23 of project, including the description of layout and
24 design, the turbines, the transmission lines, and
25 geological concerns. The turbines will be grouped along
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
37
1 individual electrical circuits and will be monitored by
2 sophisticated computer control systems.
3 The decommissioning process is described in
4 Section 2.8 and adheres to all applicable local, state,
5 and federal permits. Not only is decommissioning of the
6 turbines discussed in detail, but also the removal of
7 the underground cables, collection lines, substations,
8 roadways, and pads.9 In effect, every possible aspect of the wind
10 power project has been addressed. The wind turbines are
11 a clean, renewable resource that we can take advantage
12 of in the town of Cape Vincent. The Town Board should
13 review the document and approve the Supplemental DEIS.
14 Cape Vincent is known for the abundant natural
15 resources we have, and one of these resources is wind.
16 Across the country and the world thousands of wind
17 turbines are producing power affordably without
18 polluting emissions and, most importantly, safely. The
19 development of wind farms brings solutions to our
20 present economy and curbs the pollution from
Page 35
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
36/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt21 coal-producing power plants, which will be part of the
22 solution.
23 The benefits of the projects far outweigh any
24 impact -- negative impact. The town should take
25 advantage of this windfall opportunity. I recommend the
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
38
1 town accept the document as presented. Thank you.
2 MR. MATHES: Gary King.
3 MR. KING: Good morning, everybody. I trust
4 you can hear me. It's interesting, I have friends on
5 both sides of this issue, so consequently I took it upon
6 myself to do a little bit of studying about a little bit
7 of the rigmarole that's going on. And I went to five
8 wind farms throughout the United States and put my ear
9 not to the ground, but to the wind towers. The actual
10 transformer made more noise than the turbine as it was
11 running.
12 I believe there's a group of people, I don't
13 care what you're doing, if you were giving away $100
14 bills, somebody would complain and say oh, gee, mine is
15 bigger than yours or yours is bigger than mine. But
16 it's an important issue and, I hate to see the village
17 and the town divided.
18 I've lived here for 25 plus years, and I've
19 lived on this earth for 68, almost 69 years, and I
20 remember so many times and so many different things that
21 were going to kill me. The very first one I remember,
22 this is off the beaten path maybe, but it's important toPage 36
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
37/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
23 me -- she agrees with me it's off the beaten path -- but
24 I remember when oleo first came out; oh, that's going to
25 kill you. I remember when cranberries were deadly.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
39
1 But I'll bet there isn't a person in here that
2 hasn't crossed in their life a dozen different things
3 that's going to kill them that later on turned out to be
4 a good thing.
5 Wind turbines are used all over the world. I
6 feel that this Board and the elected officials that were
7 elected by the majority of the residents of Cape
8 Vincent, knowing full well that they were going to be
9 voting, my only gripe is some of people elected not to
10 vote because it would pretend -- whatever the big word
11 is -- to be a conflict of interest. I believe it's a12 conflict of interest when they don't vote when they were
13 elected to do the people's work.
14 MR. MATHES: Gary, if you can confine your
15 comments to the SDIS.
16 MR. KING: I don't know what he says because I
17 can't hear him.
18 MR. MATHES: If you can confine your comments
19 to the physical document.
20 MR. KING: I'm sorry. I'm all done. But I
21 thank the Board for a good job well done. And thank you
22 for all your efforts, and I'm sorry you had to take so
23 much abuse that I think is unnecessary.
Page 37
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
38/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt24 MR. MATHES: Tom Chapman.
25 MR. CHAPMAN: I'm a member of Crowe & Hammond.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
40
1 We have been through hell, like a lot of you have. And
2 I planned on talking maybe a little bit about the dBC
3 levels which the wind companies don't want to seem to
4 talk to you about, they just deal in dBAs. But that has
5 been covered pretty well. The gentleman back there was
6 right on when he talked about ambient noise. But if you
7 go to the wind companies they'll probably tell you it's
8 40 here when you're going to find if you get an honest
9 test it's probably about 25.
10 So I don't get a -- very often get a chance to
11 chew on wind companies, but seeing as they told us what
12 a wonderful job they've been doing in Europe and places
13 like that, I will address you. And for your people that
14 are dressed in green and think this is green energy, you
15 should be looking at things a little closer.
16 They talk about what a wonderful job they have
17 been doing in Europe with all these wind companies that
18 have been established, but they failed to tell you how
19 many fossil fuel plants have had to go up because wind
20 is so unreliable there. In fact, in Denmark, Spain,
21 Germany, they're doing away with the subsidies that they
22 get here because it's been such a failure.
23 And up in Denmark, for example, where they
24 have 6,000 turbines up already, the carbon emissions
25 have gone up 36%. They don't tell you that. I'll betPage 38
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
39/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
41
1 you the wind company representatives cannot tell me
2 anywhere where any coal-fired or fossil fuel generated
3 plant has shut down because they have erected a wind
4 tower farm anywhere.
5 I don't hear any -- another thing, I don't
6 know, I don't understand why you don't sign onto the
7 Attorney General's code of ethics.
8 MR. MATHES: Tom, if you can address the Board
9 and stay on the topic.
10 MR. CHAPMAN: Okay. I know what the Board has
11 gone through, they got misrepresented by some of the
12 statistics that are out there from the wind companies.
13 And most of the County Planning Boards were misled. And
14 you probably copied your plan from the County Planning15 Board. And we had the same problem in St. Lawrence
16 County.
17 Now, we talk about how -- the jobs that will
18 be created by this wind energy business. Seeing this
19 company is from Spain, I'll go there. For every job
20 that was created by wind power, 2.2 jobs were lost. And
21 you know how much it cost to produce those jobs? They
22 got $2 million in subsidies for every job that was
23 produced.
24 Now, if you don't think -- you people that are
25 dressed in green think this is a green energy, you
Page 39
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
40/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
42
1 better do a little more looking into it because you may
2 going to find that it's not. Thank you.
3 MR. MATHES: Rick Lawrence.
4 MR. LAWRENCE: I'm Rick Lawrence. I'm -- my
5 wife and I are property owners in the project. Our son
6 works for St. Lawrence Wind, and I've seen the hundreds
7 of hours they've put into this -- these studies, and
8 they have done a very thorough job in my opinion.
9 And I want to thank the Planning Board and the
10 Town Board for all the hard work and countless hours
11 that they've put into this. And they are looking to the
12 future, and that's the important thing.
13 And I will add that wind turbines have much
14 fewer negative impacts than a nuclear plant somewhere on
15 the St. Lawrence River. Thank you.
16 MR. MATHES: Warren Johnson.
17 MR. JOHNSON: My name is Warren Johnson, and
18 I'm a councilman in the town of Lyme. And I'm here to
19 deliver a letter from our Supervisor, Scott Aubertine.
20 Dear Supervisor Reinbeck and Cape Vincent Town
21 Board: At our May meeting the town of Lyme Board
22 approved a motion to contact you regarding concerns it
23 has with the proposed wind project in the town of Cape
24 Vincent. The concerns of the Board are in relation to
25 the transmission lines and their location in the town of
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
Page 40
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
41/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt 43
1 Lyme.
2 We as a Town Board would like to respectfully
3 request that you -- that your project comply with the
4 proposed town of Lyme Wind Energy Facilities Zoning Law,
5 presently in litigation, Article II, Section 4,
6 Standards for WECS, which reads: The following
7 standards shall apply to all WECS, unless specifically
8 waived by the Zoning Board as a part of a permit. A:
9 All power transmission lines from the tower to any
10 building or other structure shall be located underground
11 to the maximum extent possible and to the maximum extent
12 allowed by law, including all transmission lines
13 transiting the town of Lyme from wind farms originating
14 in other jurisdictions. Respectfully, Scott Aubertine.
15 I'd like everyone in this room to reflect on
16 the last ice storm we had. That was a horror story. We
17 replaced 6,000 telephone poles aboveground and 123 miles18 of electrical wire. Let's do it right the first time.
19 Thank you.
20 MR. MATHES: Jerry LeTendre.
21 MR. LeTENDRE: I'm Jerry LeTendre. I've been
22 a resident of Cape Vincent since 1965. I love Cape
23 Vincent. I travel around the country, and the last
24 couple years I've driven all the way to the West Coast
25 each year. And on my trip I noticed lots of wind
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
44
Page 41
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
42/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
1 towers. Kansas has them by the hundreds, thousands
2 maybe even. Iowa has them by the hundreds and
3 thousands.
4 And you know what, the only person that's
5 going to bother in any of those wind tower projects is
6 the person that owns the land. Whereas we're living in
7 a place that's completely different. Cape Vincent is a
8 residential community, and any of you that drove into
9 town that haven't been here lately that looked across
10 the wonderful St. Lawrence River saw what Cape Vincent
11 will look like once this project is completed.
12 Okay. Anyway, so I've been around doing that.
13 My only question here today is going to be concerning
14 birds. I'm involved and interested in the whole
15 project, I've written comments several times and will
16 continue to do that. But a year ago yesterday I was
17 birding in my backyard and had 14 species of birds that
18 were migrating through. This is a high migration area.
19 Somebody started talking earlier, birds come
20 up migrating in the eastern corridor, and they get to
21 Lake Ontario, they come around, they come through Cape
22 Vincent.
23 Somebody seems to think that birds don't come
24 here. Well, anybody that's played tennis with me up
25 here at these courts knows I'm calling out every eagle,
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
45
1 hawk, and vulture that comes by. There are lots ofPage 42
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
43/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
2 birds that migrate through; there are a lot of raptors
3 that migrate through. Somehow these people don't see
4 that.
5 But the worst thing I think is in 2005 there
6 was a great gray owl in Cape Vincent. I showed that
7 bird to over 3,000 people, and over 500 of them had
8 never seen that bird before. And when they were here I
9 always send them over to see a very interesting bird
10 that we had called the short-eared owl. Before they
11 left, they were here somewhere near evening, they went
12 over and looked at that.
13 The short-eared owl is a very important bird
14 in Cape Vincent. These guys have not found one. Not
15 one. It's a threatened New York State bird.
16 That's how they do their whole study. Sure,
17 they went from four pages to 21. They can go to 400.
18 They don't answer the question and they can't mitigate
19 problems with birds, they're wasting our time.
20 And that's how the whole project is. I'm21 sorry, I could go through other parts of it, but -- it's
22 unconscionable what they're trying to do. That's the
23 end of my statement. Thank you.
24 MR. MATHES: Paul Sirianni.
25 MR. SIRIANNI: Good morning. My name is Paul
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
46
1 Sirianni. I am a representative of the New York State
2 Ironworkers District Council.
Page 43
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
44/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt3 I have attended a lot of these meetings
4 throughout New York State, have given some opinions on
5 their Environmental Impact Statements, I give some
6 opinions in regards to economic development.
7 I'm here today, number one, to thank this
8 Board for having this meeting on a Saturday morning at
9 10:00. You do not know how many countless meetings I've
10 been to that have been held on a Tuesday at 8:00 in the
11 morning with a community that's not been given the
12 opportunity to speak as you are, and I commend this
13 Board for that.
14 In reviewing the impact statement here that's
15 put forth on this particular project, looking at the
16 construction portion of it, because I am a construction
17 worker and do represent the workers that potentially
18 would work on this project if you were to allow this
19 project to go through, and I'll make it very clear, that
20 I obviously -- I'm a construction worker, we like to do
21 the work, but whatever this town decides and your people
22 decide, that's truly up to you.
23 But I am here to say that in reviewing what
24 they have written down, what their procedures are in the
25 aspects of the construction of these projects and
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
47
1 knowing full well how these projects pan out, because
2 the New York State Ironworkers District Council has done
3 every single one in the state of New York to date, we
4 have represented, put our people on these projects. SoPage 44
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
45/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
5 we do know how they are done and how they're done
6 properly. And from what I can see, I can honestly say
7 that it looks like their procedures fall right directly
8 in line with procedures that have been used in the past,
9 that have been used here successfully.
10 It's a kind of a quick impact at first, but
11 everything melts back into the norm. If you've visited
12 wind farms, I heard a gentleman say he did go out and
13 visit, I would -- if you're skeptical, I would suggest
14 that you do visit because some of the things you hear
15 maybe aren't what you're told.
16 But they -- their procedures for digging the
17 foundation are very adequate; the same type of
18 procedures that we've used on Maple Ridge and up in
19 Ellenville. Down in the Southern Tier south of Buffalo
20 and Rochester now there's farms that are going. I'm
21 understanding that their components that they use are
22 state of the art, very good components from that aspect.
23 What I would ask this community if you do24 decide to move forward with this project, of great
25 concern to us is that we -- on the economic side of
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
48
1 this, that the economic development a lot of it happens
2 with the construction portion of the project. There's a
3 lot of economic development that comes back to the town
4 through the developer as the stages go, as it goes on
5 and the farm is in operation, but the construction
Page 45
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
46/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt6 portion of it is a huge portion of economic development,
7 and I ask one thing: That they hire the local worker.
8 And the town should demand that the developer commit to
9 using local labor.
10 And that's what I'm about, that's what we're
11 about. It's -- it makes perfect sense to have the
12 people that live and work in the community, pay their
13 taxes, buy their groceries and their gas, be afforded
14 the jobs that are going to become available through the
15 construction.
16 MR. MATHES: One minute.
17 MR. SIRIANNI: Thank you.
18 MR. MATHES: John Clark.
19 MR. CLARK: Good morning, my name is John
20 Clark. And thank you for having -- giving us the
21 opportunity to come here and speak this morning.
22 I'm a construction worker, and I am here to
23 speak in favor of the St. Lawrence Wind Farm. This
24 project will provide much-needed jobs for the
25 construction worker in this area.
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
49
1 As a construction worker, I am in favor of
2 projects that will provide an income for me and my
3 family. We need these projects for power we consume.
4 As an outdoorsman and an avid fisherman, I would much
5 rather build wind farm windmills for power that we need
6 than I would to build coal-burning plants that continue
7 to affect our lakes and rivers with acid rain. WePage 46
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
47/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
8 cannot continue to pollute our waterways.
9 I see this project as a win-win for
10 construction worker and for the environment. During the
11 construction of the wind farm in Lowville the
12 contractors and the workers made every effort to
13 preserve the land around their construction site. And
14 as this report indicates, this project would provide the
15 same. Thank you.
16 MR. MATHES: Bob Gauthier.
17 MR. GAUTHIER: First of all, I must apologize
18 because my show-and-tell guy didn't show up. I don't
19 know, I think he's over on Wolfe looking at birds or
20 noise or something.
21 But anyway, I would like to thank the Town
22 Board, Tom Reinbeck, and all the guys on there for all
23 their hard work that they've done. And especially I'd
24 like it thank Richie Edsall; the man has been through
25 pure hell. And the rest of his town and the rest of his
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
50
1 members as well.
2 I'm all in favor of this project, as you can
3 tell, and I would just like to end by saying that
4 Mr. Reinbeck and Mr. Edsall, you guys look really cool
5 on YouTube.
6 MR. MATHES: Paul Mason.
7 MR. MASON: Paul Mason. I've been a resident
8 of this town for 69 years. I have helped feed the
Page 47
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
48/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt9 American people for probably the last 50 some years. I
10 have a dairy farm down on the St. Lawrence River, which
11 I enjoy just as much as anybody here in the town of Cape
12 Vincent or all the world.
13 I have a dairy distinction; I am a
14 conservation dairy farmer of the year. I have been
15 selected as environmental stewardship of the year for
16 New York State, which there's only one per year. So
17 don't call me I'm not an environmentalist, I am.
18 And I think this project, as all the studies
19 show, the birds, I work around the birds, I work around
20 the deer, the turkeys. I have a scope in my backyard
21 that looks out onto the environment. And I don't think
22 this environment is going to be hurt in any way.
23 Because I have talked with other farmers in these same
24 situations that we're going to be in, which the dairy
25 industry is one of the biggest industries in the town of
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775 51
1 Cape Vincent. But it's gradually diminishing, and it
2 will continue to diminish. And this is one thing that
3 could help the landowners, which I'm sure most of these
4 environmental people aren't concerned about.
5 Visual impact. That's a matter of opinion,
6 the studies show. I was actually -- had an impact when
7 I arrived at this building today. That's a visual
8 impact to me. Cell towers, we just was approved a cell
9 tower, another one going up in the town of Cape Vincent.
10 They're going up all over. That's visual impact.Page 48
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
49/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
11 The other thing in here is the flicker effect.
12 Like I stated, I have many, many acres looking out my
13 back window, and this is my best view. I don't look at
14 the river, I love the river, but I have a visual impact
15 because of trees across from me that's been planted
16 there that I can't see the river that I used to be able
17 to see back when I was a little kid.
18 Okay? And when -- and this flicker effect,
19 I've been keeping track of it because there is a test
20 tower back of my farm. The sun rise is only a very few
21 days in the morning that I would ever get a flicker
22 effect. And you know what, about half of those mornings
23 or more are cloudy.
24 So I'm not sure, they say in this impact here
25 that on a cloudy day you don't get a visual impact -- or
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
52
1 a flicker effect. We have 8,760 hours a year, and most
2 of these sites, 75, they say are going to have one hour.
3 MR. MATHES: One minute, Paul.
4 MR. MASON: 87 is going to have between an
5 hour and ten hours a year out of 8,760.
6 I would like to thank the Planning Board, the
7 Town Board, Richie, and Tom. You guys have done a great
8 job in spite of all of the abuse that you have taken.
9 Thank you.
10 MR. MATHES: Gail Kenney. I might be
11 mispronouncing that.
Page 49
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
50/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt12 MS. KENNEY: I'm not sure that I can't do
13 better without the microphone, so if you can hear me
14 I'll proceed that way and I'll feel much more
15 comfortable. Is that all right with everyone?
16 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Of course.
17 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Yeah, sure.
18 MS. KENNEY: Okay. I want to thank you to
19 giving me this time to come up and speak here. I'm not
20 comfortable speaking. But my name is Gail Kenney. I
21 come from Wolfe Island. I'm chair of WIRE, the Wolfe
22 Island Residents for the Environment.
23 I put my name down on the sheet wondering if I
24 should take this opportunity, since this is your
25 project, it is not Wolfe Island's. But you have seen
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
53
1 Wolfe Island's project, and I don't know if you have
2 been to Wolfe Island to see it close-up.
3 But there are many things that I've heard here
4 now that I think that the Board and the people here
5 should consider after having the experience that we have
6 had. And please, please bear with me because, as I say,
7 I'm not really comfortable speaking.
8 But first of all, I want -- just want to make
9 the comment that in -- we called it an environmental
10 review, the people who were not proponents, not
11 landowners that were going to have turbines were named
12 as nonparticipating receptors. So immediately what you
13 felt like was you weren't counting because you weren'tPage 50
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
51/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
14 really human.
15 Now, the nonparticipating receptors weren't
16 really people, that were the houses and buildings that
17 were going to receive the negative impact. So it was
18 definitely a negative name to have.
19 Now, these people aren't benefiting
20 financially in any way, nonparticipate from the project,
21 but they will definitely, along with the proponents, be
22 recepting [sic] or receiving any negative impact.
23 And I think that's one thing when I look at
24 this group and I see exactly what I saw on Wolfe Island,
25 here is one group and here is another group. And before
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
54
1 this project came to Wolfe Island we were one group.
2 And people say nevermind, it will go away,3 you'll get used to it. I -- I don't see that happening
4 yet on Wolfe Island.
5 So you need to be very careful. When the
6 gentleman said I have friends on both sides, you really
7 need to hold onto those friends on both sides and
8 understand -- try to understand where everybody is
9 coming from.
10 And I didn't mean to come to lecture, I'm
11 just -- whatever is coming into my head. But that --
12 tearing the community apart is what is happening with
13 these projects, and tearing families apart. And we have
14 to have more understanding there.
Page 51
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
52/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt15 Anyway, I'm a nonparticipating receptor. In
16 front of my home I see 28 turbines. A couple of them
17 are turning now. They're in the testing process.
18 We went through a year of construction period
19 that was very difficult. I don't see it getting better
20 at this point. The gentleman who mentioned noise and
21 said that he has stood beside them and he -- I did the
22 same thing, I went to Lowville, I stood under them, I
23 walked around them. I went to the conference that your
24 bird specialist talk about.
25 I also walk down my lane way in the evening
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
55
1 when three or four are turning now with my dog. And
2 it's a lot different than what I heard in Lowville.
3 Because it's evening, the atmosphere is just right for
4 it, and they're pounding.
5 Sometimes in the daytime I go to my garden, I
6 hardly hear them, they sound like a little bit of a jet
7 going overhead. And these are only a few getting
8 started now.
9 MR. MATHES: One minute.
10 MS. KENNEY: Okay. Sorry. I want to just say
11 about an environmental assessment, we went through
12 struggling through this issue. And I just want to say
13 that there isn't an environmental assessment that can
14 deal with everything you're going to deal with.
15 And even if you say oh, it's complete, there's
16 no way it could possibly be complete. But you need toPage 52
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
53/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
17 have a protocol so that people who have concerns when
18 issues come up, people can go and say this is the issue
19 that I have.
20 So we've got one of those; we got what we
21 called a Community Liaison Committee. But they have no
22 authority. So we go and we say we have an issue with
23 this, this wetland is being intruded on or it was dumped
24 into or whatever, and they say oh, that is really too
25 bad, the community listens, we walk away, and nothing is
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
56
1 done.
2 So you need to look into this environmental
3 assessment and see who has the authority to say to this
4 company, okay, you've got a contract with us, are you
5 keeping it? Who's monitoring them daily? Because the6 proponents need that as much as the nonparticipating
7 receptors. If you've got a company on your land you
8 want to know that -- who's monitoring it, who's
9 responsible.
10 MR. MATHES: That's your time, Gail.
11 MS. KENNEY: I'm sorry, I'll stop. I would
12 like to invite you to come to Wolfe Island and see not
13 from a distance, but up close the turbines and talk to
14 the people on Wolfe Island. Thank you.
15 [Applause]
16 MR. MATHES: Tom Brown?
17 Oh, I apologize, I accidentally skipped Chuck
Page 53
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
54/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt18 Ebbing. But Chuck, you can go next and we'll be back in
19 order. Sorry about that.
20 MR. BROWN: Good morning. I think it's still
21 morning. My name is Tom Brown. I'm a resident with the
22 village and have been for a number of years.
23 I spent a career in the field of environmental
24 science. And I too love this community, and I love
25 living here. And what I would like to do today is among
PROFESSIONAL REPORTING SERVICES, INC.315-436-7775
57
1 the number of comments that I had on the Supplemental
2 Draft Environmental Impact Statement, I've selected a
3 couple that I think are pretty pertinent, and I would
4 like to express those comments here today. And I have a
5 copy I can leave with your secretary.
6 The Thousand Island region is well recognized
7 for its unique beauty and holds a position of both state
8 and national environmental significance. Yet the
9 Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement fails
10 to assess what impact converting the Cape Vincent
11 landscape to an industrial wind energy site will have on
12 this unique quality and national standing.
13 The Supplemental Draft states the visual
14 impacts are unavoidable but necessary to achieve
15 renewable energy requirements. Yet I haven't found in
16 the environmental is assessment an effort to evaluate
17 other less alternative visually intrusive project sites.
18 Evaluation of alternative project sites has
19 always been a central requirement of the SEQRA planningPage 54
-
8/9/2019 Public Hearing ~ on Cape Vincent's Proposed St. Lawrence Wind Project
55/117
051609pubhrg-2.txt
20 process. Yet in this case the developer appears to be
21 relying on a law provision that may, and I und