project procurement management prof. dr. attaullah shah

88

Upload: stewart-brown

Post on 28-Dec-2015

246 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah
Page 2: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Page 3: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

O you who have believed, avoid much [negative] assumption. Indeed, some assumption is sin. And do not spy or backbite each other. Would one of you like to eat the flesh of his brother when dead? You would detest it. And fear Allah ; indeed, Allah is Accepting of repentance and Merciful.

O mankind, indeed We have created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Acquainted.

Page 4: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Some quotes about procurement Labor was the first price, the original purchase - money that was paid for all

things. It was not by gold or by silver, but by labor, that all wealth of the world was originally purchased. Adam Smith

“Property may be destroyed and money may lose its purchasing power; but character, health, knowledge and good judgment will always be in demand under all conditions.”  Roger Babson

“Men use care in purchasing a horse, and are neglectful in choosing friends”  John Muir.

Purchasing power is a license to purchase power.”  Raoul Vaneigem

“Excellence in any department can be attained only by the labor of a lifetime; it is not to be purchased at a lesser price.”  Samuel Johnson

Page 5: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Some quotes…..

Passion can never purchase what true love desires: true intimacy, self-giving, and commitment”

“Experts agree that the best type of computer for your individual needs is one that comes on the market about two days after you actually purchase some other computer.”  Dave Barry

It takes me a long time to make a big purchase. Jessica Chastain

If a man will make a purchase of a chance he must abide by the consequences. Richard Richards

Page 6: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

6

“Self-pity is our worst enemy &

if we yield to it,

we can never do anything wise in this world”

- Helen Keller

Page 7: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

CITY UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND CITY UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, PESHAWARINFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, PESHAWAR

Page 8: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Bio details of the Speaker

Dr. Attaullah Shah Vice Chancellor City University of Science and IT Peshawar Previously Director ( Planning and Projects AIOU)

[email protected]. [email protected], www.drshahpak.weebly.com +92-333-5729809, +92-51-9057212

Qualification PhD Civil Engineering ,M.Phil Eco ,MSc Structure Engg MBA, MA Eco, MSc Envir Design,BSc Civil Engg (Gold

Medal), Post Grad Dip Comp (Gold Medal) Professional and Field experience:

25+ Years Research Publications in refereed journals and conferences:

25 Journals publications+55 Conference publications Areas of interests

Structural Engineering Sustainable built Environment Construction project Management

Page 9: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Engineering Programs: Fall 2015 (Aug-Feb)BS Electrical Engineering – Telecom – Power- Electronics BS Civil Engineering MS Electrical Engineering MS Engineering Management MS Civil Engineering PhD Electrical Engineering

Page 10: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Faculty of Engineering (PhD faculty Prof. Dr. Nauman Khan Dean F/O Engineering Electrical Engineering

Prof. Dr. Sahibzada Fayyaz Noor Associate Professor Dr. Nasimullah Khan Assistant Anisullah Khan Asstt. Prof. Engr. Abraiz Khattak ( PhD Comp/Defense awaited) Asstt. Prof. Fazal Mohd ( PhD Scholar GIK/CityU sponsored)

Civil Engineering: Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah Assistant Prof. Shahab Samad

Shared faculty Prof. Dr. Anwar Fazil Chishti (Economics/Management) Prof. Dr. Jehanzeb (Economics/Management) Asstt. Prof. Muhammad Tahir ( Computer Science) Asstt. Prof. Ghufranullah Khan ( Computer Science)

Page 11: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

What is a Project?

An temporary endeavor to create a Unique Product or Service.

A unique one time effort bound by cost, time and resources/technical performance ( CST) and has defined objectives to satisfy the customer needs.

Project is an undertaking having definite objectives, and specific beginning and ending points, limited budgets, defined scope.

Sum of certain activities and tasks required to be performed in a specified period of time with human and non-human resources for specified objectives.

( Is your training a project? )

Page 12: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

What is a Project?

Project is a one time non-routine opportunity to develop a new product. To satisfy the customer to achieve the organizational objectives.To be completed with in Allocated budget. Scheduled Time. Approved Technical Performance. Approved and agreed Scope of Work. Without any change in the existing culture.

Page 13: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

What is management? The process of Planning, Organizing, Staffing, controlling and leading.

Project management: The art of Directing and coordinating the human and non humanResources throughout the life of project by using modernManagement techniques to achieve pre-determined objectives ofscope, cost, time, quality and participants satisfaction.

( Project Management Institute America)

Project management includes:- Project Appraisal ( Before Commencement of Project PC-I, PC-II).- Project monitoring. ( During Execution of the Projects PC-III)- Project Evaluation ( After Completion of the projects. PC-IV,PC-V)

Page 14: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Life Cycle: Three Stages of a Project

Establish

Execute Complete

Define project objectives, scope and approach, mobilise project team

Execute the work plan to achieve desired outcome

Wrap up and transition

Page 15: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Organise Resources

Control the Work

Report Status

Plan the Executio

n

Complete Project

Establish

Execute Complete

Define project objectives, scope & approach, mobilise project team

Execute the work plan to achieve desired outcome

Wrap up and transition

Confirm Definition

Project Selection

Page 16: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Establish

Confirm Definition

Project Selection

Project Selection• Define Project Scope• Define Project Objectives• Define Approach• Define Business Case• Select Best Projects

Page 17: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Establish

Confirm Definition

Project Selection

Confirm Definition• Understand Project Sponsor expectations

• Understand Project Scope

• Understand Project Objectives

• Confirm any assumptions

• Identify Project Risks

Page 18: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Organise Resources

Control the Work

Report Status

Plan the Executio

n

Execute

Plan the Execution

• Define Project Deliverables

• Develop Work Plans

• Develop Scope, Change Control, Issue Management and Sign-off Processes

• Develop Risk Mitigation Plan

• Develop Quality Plan

Page 19: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Organise Resources

Control the Work

Report Status

Plan the Executio

n

Execute

Organise Resources

• Identify Project Team Roles / Responsibilities

• Assign Team Members to Work Plan tasks

• Communicate responsibilities, target dates, deliverables

• Train Team Members

• Organise physical resources

Page 20: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Organise Resources

Control the Work

Report Status

Plan the Executio

n

Execute

Control the Work• Monitor work progress

• Resolve issues

• Measure performance

Page 21: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Organise Resources

Control the Work

Report Status

Plan the Executio

n

Execute

Report Status• Assess project progress

• Prepare status reports

• Communicate progress to relevant audience group

• Follow up any issues resulting from status meeting

Page 22: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Stages & Project Management Model

Complete Project

Complete

Complete Project

• Complete any development / administrative activities

• Obtain sign-off of final project deliverables

• Transition to maintenance team where appropriate

Page 23: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Information Technology Project Management, Fourth Edition

23 of 49

Page 24: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

24 of 54

Suggested Skills for Project Managers Project managers need a wide variety of skills.

They should:

Be comfortable with change.

Understand the organizations they work in and with.

(who to go to, SOP, etc)

Lead teams to accomplish project goals.

Page 25: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

25 of 54

Suggested Skills for Project Managers Project managers need both “hard” and

“soft” skills.

Hard skills include product knowledge and knowing how to use various project management tools and techniques.

Soft skills include being able to work with various types of people.

Page 26: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

26 of 54

Suggested Skills for Project Managers

Communication skills: Listens, persuades. Organizational skills: Plans, sets goals, analyzes. Team-building skills: Shows empathy, motivates,

promotes esprit de corps. Leadership skills: Sets examples, provides vision (big

picture), delegates, positive, energetic. Coping skills: Flexible, creative, patient, persistent. Technology skills: Experience, project knowledge.

Successful

^

Page 27: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

27 of 54

Media Snapshot – Good Project Management Skills from The Apprentice

Leadership and professionalism are crucial.

Know what your sponsor expects from the project, and learn from your mistakes.

Trust your team and delegate decisions.

Know the business. Stand up for yourself.

Be a team player. Stay organized and don’t

be overly emotional. Work on projects and for

people you believe in. Think outside the box. There is some luck

involved in project management, and you should always aim high.

Page 28: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

28 of 54

The Project Management Profession

Professional societies such as the Project Management Institute (PMI) have grown significantly. PMI

There are specific interest groups in many areas, such as engineering, financial services, health care, and IT.

Project management research and certification programs continue to grow.

Page 29: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

29 of 54

Project Management Certification PMI provides certification as a Project

Management Professional (PMP). A PMP has documented sufficient project

experience, agreed to follow a code of ethics, and passed the PMP exam.

The number of people earning PMP certification is increasing quickly.

PMI and other organizations are offering new certification programs

Page 30: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

30 of 54

Growth in PMP Certification, 1993-2003

1,000 1,900 2,800 4,4006,415

10,086

18,184

27,052

40,343

52,443

76,550

0

10,000

20,000

30,000

40,000

50,000

60,000

70,000

80,000

1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003

Year

# P

MP

s

Page 31: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project management ProcessesPMI approach

Five Processes. Initiating: Authorizing the project or phase Planning: Defining Objectives and selecting

approach Execution: Managing human and non human

resources to execute the project.Controlling: Monitoring, evaluation and

correcting Closing: Formal acceptance and close out.

Page 32: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

32 of 54

Nine Project Management Knowledge Areas

Knowledge areas describe the key competencies that project managers must develop. Four core knowledge areas lead to specific project

objectives (scope, time, cost, and quality). Four facilitating knowledge areas are the means

through which the project objectives are achieved (human resources, communication, risk, and procurement management).

One knowledge area (project integration management) affects and is affected by all of the other knowledge areas.

All knowledge areas are important!

Page 33: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

A Framework for Project Management

Page 34: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Construction Project Lifecycle

Page 35: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Procurement Management Procurement is acquisition of goods and services.

Project Procurement Management includes the contract management and change control processes required to administer contracts or purchase orders issued by authorized project team members.

Page 36: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Procurement means the activities related to purchase, subcontracted items

Procurement items are usually classified as goods, work or services (GWS) Goods represent raw material or produced items Work means contracted labor Service means consultation

Planning, budgeting, scheduling and follow-up control of all fall under procurement management

Logistics plan includes everything related to the transport and storage of materials for the projects. GWS items cannot be scheduled to arrive just-in-time (JIT). Provision must be made to store and protect them until they are needed.

Procurement of Items

Page 37: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Procurement management refers to planning and control of the following Equipment , material or components designed and

provided by vendors specifically for the project It may be a portion of a work package or entire work

package It may be off-the-shelf (OTS) equipment and

components bulk material, like cement, metal piping etc. Consumables items; nails, bolts, lubricants Support equipment for construction, cranes, lifts etc Administrative equipment, computers, project office

facilities

Procurement Management

Page 38: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

38

Industrial Project Cost Distribution

Item Description Weight

1 Engineering 5%

22 Equipment / Material Equipment / Material 65%65%

33 Construction Construction 15%15%

4 Testing and Commissioning 10%

Page 39: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Procurement Management Processes and Key Outputs

Page 40: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Plan Purchases and Acquisitions. Determining what to purchase or acquire and determining when and how. Purchase of equipment Procurement of works Procurement of supplies etc

Plan Contracting – documenting products, services, and results requirements and identifying potential sellers. Developing the requisite documents Specification No and make etc.

Procurement Cycle

Page 41: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Request Seller Responses. obtaining information, quotations, bids, offers ,or proposals, as

appropriate. Inviting bids Inviting quotations Request for Proposals ( RPFs) Expression of Interest ( EOI) etc.

Select Sellers. Reviewing offers, choosing among potential sellers, and

negotiating a written contract with each seller. Tender/bids opening Evaluation and Assessment of bids Negotiation if required and allowed Selection of the seller/contractor

Page 42: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Contract Administration – Managing the contract and relationship between the buyer and

seller. Reviewing and documenting how a seller is performing or has

performed to establish required corrective actions Provide a basis for future relationships with the seller, Managing contract-related changes and, when appropriate, Managing the contractual relationship with the outside buyer. Contract Agreement

Contract Closure – completing and settling each contract, including the resolution

of any open items, Closing each contract applicable to the project or a project

phase.

Page 43: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

43

Procurement Planning Procurement planning involves identifying

which project needs can be best met by using products or services outside the organization. It includes deciding whether to procure how to procure what to procure how much to procure when to procure

Page 44: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Procurement Planning Contract Types Different types of contracts are more or less appropriate for Different types of

purchases. Fixed-price or lump-sum contracts. Cost-reimbursable contracts.( cost Plus) Time and Material (T&M) contracts.

Fixed Price contracts Fixed price or lump sum - Cost price with re-determination Fixed price plus incentive fee. Fixed price plus economic price adjustment Fixed price with successive targets incentives Fixed price for service material and labor at cost. Time and material labor hours only.

Others methods: Turnkey Bonus - Penalty Joint venture Combination of the above BOOT ( Build Operate Own and Transfer BOT ( Build Operate and Transfer) Build Lease and Transfer ( BLT)

Page 45: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Selection of project delivery system All project delivery systems include three participants

Owner, designer and construction organization Their relationships vary according to the different

systems and ownerships. Project delivery systems

Traditional design–tender–build ( Design Bid Build) choice for owners of most construction projects during many

centuries

Page 46: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Design–build Single contract with an organization that becomes

responsible for both the design and the construction of the project

One of the primary reasons for low productivity in the construction industry is the lack of integration of activities across the project life cycle.

The Design–Build Institute of America (1994) lists potential benefits from the design–build method as follows.

Singular responsibility. - Quality. - Cost savings. Time savings. - Potential for reduced administrative burden Early knowledge of firm costs. - Balanced award criteria. Risk Management

Page 47: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah
Page 48: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Disadvantages of Design and Build: Importance of the project brief: Difficult when scope

not defined Difficulty of establishing a price for the work. Costly tendering Short tender periods Potential low quality. Less control over subcontractor and consultant

selection. Generally less control by the owner over both project

definition and execution than design–tender–build projects.

Page 49: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project manager Adding a project manager between the owner and the

architect/engineer and general contractor This arrangement implies that the project manager contracts

with the designer and the general contractor.

Page 50: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Separate prime contracts The owner contracts directly with individual specialty

contractors, each of whom can be considered as a ‘prime’ contractor.

There is no single general contractor to coordinate their work. An ‘agency’ construction manager may be engaged , who will

assist the owner in this coordination, but the chart makes it clear that the construction Manager is not related contractually to the several prime contractors.

Page 51: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Turnkey The owner and contractor agree on a fixed contract sum for a

contract under which the contractor will take responsibility for the entire project.

Agreements are often designated as EPC contracts, because of the prime responsibilities for engineering – providing basic and detailed design, procurement – supplying parts and other goods required for the project and construction – erecting and commissioning the project

Seems more like D&B. However, the scope of the contractor’s responsibility is typically broader than basic design, procurement and construction

In the UK, a recent turnkey example is the completion of the world’s first commercial digital terrestrial television network for the British Broadcasting Corporation and ONdigital.

Page 52: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Build–own–operate–transfer (BOOT) The build–own–operate–transfer (BOOT) type of project has

evolved as a means of involving the private sector in the development of the public infrastructure.

The term BOT, for build–operate–transfer, was first coined by the Turkish Prime Minister in 1984 in connection with the privatization of that country’s public-sector projects.

Examples of projects that have used the BOOT approach include power stations, toll roads, parking structures, tunnels, bridges and water supply and sewage treatment plants.

It is apparent that such an approach requires a complex organizational structure and carries considerable long-term risk for the project sponsor, while minimizing such risk for the governmental owner.

Page 53: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Joint venture

A voluntary association of two or more parties formed to conduct a single project with a limited duration

Joint venture agreements are formed between construction firms or between design firms and construction firms; they do not include owners.

The usual purpose of such an arrangement is to spread the risks inherent in large projects and to pool resources in a way that permits the joint venture to execute a project that would be beyond the capabilities of one of the parties individually.

Page 54: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Force account project owner acts as the prime contractor and carries out

the work with its own forces by providing field supervision, materials, equipment and labor

This method is usually confined to relatively small, uncomplicated projects that are built for the owner’s use rather than sold to another party upon completion.

They must consider the tradeoffs among the extra time and expense of the formal contracting process and the possible construction cost savings, potential time savings and improved quality resulting from these competitive or negotiated contracts

Page 55: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Delivery Options System Features Advantages Limitations

Traditional design–tender–build

Separation of design and construction responsibilitiesCompletion of design prior to selection of contractor

Certainty of priceClarity of rolesNo coordination risk to ownerEasy to accomplish changes during design

No opportunity for phased constructionFixed price established late in processOwner administers all design and construction contractsNo contractor input to design

Design–build

Single organization responsible for design and construction

Single point of responsibilityConstructability input during designFixed price early in processOpportunity for phased construction

Difficulty of formulating price prior to designLack of oversight by designerCostly tendering processLess control by owner

Construction manager

Professional manager to advise owner and designer on construction aspectsMay be agency type (advisory role only) or at- risk type (more responsibility for on-site performance)

Construction expertise available during design phaseConstruction manager provides advice to owner during construction phaseUnder ‘at risk’, some risk is removed from owner

Increased overhead costsOwner may take on greater risks under‘agency’ type, especially if multiple primes are usedOwner relinquishes some control

Project manager

Professional manager to advise owner anddesigner on all aspects of project

Owner relies on project manager for coordination of most aspects of projectPotential for rapid project start-up and prosecution

Owner relinquishes considerable controlIncreased overhead

Page 56: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Delivery Options System Features Advantages Limitations

Document and construct

Early design performed under contract to ownerLater design performed (possibly by same designer) under contract to contractor

Fixed-price contract and complete documentation before construction begins Centralized responsibilityConstructability considered during design

Designer may not control whom it ultimately works forNew and unfamiliar methodLimitations similar to design–build

Separate prime contracts

Owner contracts with individual specialty contractorsSavings in cost of engaging general contractorPotential for effective phased construction

High degree of control by owner Requires owner construction expertise 

General contractor risks assumed by ownerLess clear relationship between designer and on- site activities

Turnkey

 

Single organization responsible for all aspects of project including, but not limited to, design and construction

Owner relies on turnkey contractor for entire projectPotential cost and time savings

Requires clear and detailed scope and needs statement at beginning of project Owner relinquishes almost all control

Build–own–operate–transfer

 

Single organisation responsible for designing, building and operating facility for a certain time period, after which it is transferred to owner

Owner transfers most risk to project sponsorDesign tends to recognise long-term cost impactsConstructability considered during design

Major risks to project sponsorComplexity due to large number of parties Long lead time Large up-front costs

Page 57: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Project Delivery Options System Features Advantages Limitations

Joint venture Two

contractors in a temporary partnership to build a single project

Takes advantage of strengths of each joint ventureAllows combined expertise to build large projectsAllows each contractor to gain experience in new area or with new type of work

 

Coordination challenges Like a partnership, requires very clear agreement between the co-vertures

Force account Construction project carried out by owner’s own forces

Avoids time and expense of tendering Owner can exercise more direct control

Workforce may lack needed skills Owner may lack needed managerial expertiseNo price competition

Page 58: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

58

Statement of Work (SOW)

A statement of work is a description of the work required for the procurement

Many contracts, or mutually binding agreements, include SOWs

A good SOW gives bidders a better understanding of the buyer’s expectations

Page 59: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

59

I. Scope of Work: Describe the work to be done to detail. Specify the hardware andsoftware involved and the exact nature of the work.

II. Location of Work: Describe where the work must be performed. Specify thelocation of hardware and software and where the people must perform the work

III. Period of Performance: Specify when the work is expected to start and end,working hours, number of hours that can be billed per week, where the work mustbe performed, and related schedule information.

IV. Deliverables Schedule: List specific deliverables, describe them in detail, andspecify when they are due.

V. Applicable Standards: Specify any company or industry-specific standards thatare relevant to performing the work.

VI. Acceptance Criteria: Describe how the buyer organization will determine if thework is acceptable.

VII. Special Requirements: Specify any special requirements such as hardware orsoftware certifications, minimum degree or experience level of personnel, travelrequirements, and so on.

Statement of Work (SoW)

Page 60: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

60

Solicitation Planning Solicitation planning involves preparing

several documents: Request for Proposals: used to solicit

proposals from prospective sellers Requests for Quotes: used to solicit quotes

for well-defined procurements Invitations for bid or negotiation and initial

contractor responses are also part of solicitation planning

Page 61: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Plan Contracting: Outputs Procurement /Tender Documents

Procurement documents are used to seek proposals from prospective sellers.

A term such as bid, tender, or quotation is generally used when the seller selection decision will be based on price (as when buying commercial or standard items),

A term such as proposal is generally used when other considerations, such as technical skills or technical approach, are paramount.

Page 62: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Components of RFP Introduction. Provide a brief summary of your project and describe

the process and rules for submitting a proposal. Company. List the information you need to know about the suppliers

Company such as their vision, objectives, market share, customers, expertise and experience.

Solution. List the information needed to understand the solutions proposed by the supplier, including the total quantity of each solution proposed.

Implementation. List the information you need to understand the price of each of the solutions proposed by the supplier. This will allow you to compare the total price of solutions offered by suppliers.

Other Information. List any other information needed to enable a supplier to complete a detailed proposal for the supply of goods and services to the project,

Page 63: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Evaluation Criteria Evaluation criteria are developed and used to rate or score proposals.

They can be objective or subjective Evaluation criteria are often included as part of the procurement documents.

Other Selection criteria Understanding of need. How well does the seller’s proposal address the

contract statement of work?

Overall or life-cycle cost. Will the selected seller produce the lowest total cost (purchase cost plus operating cost)?

Technical capability.

Management approach.

• Technical approach.

Financial capacity. Does the seller have, or can the seller reasonably be expected to obtain, the necessary financial resources?

Production capacity and interest. Does the seller have the capacity and interest to meet potential future requirements?

Page 64: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Business size and type.

References. Can the seller provide references from prior customers verifying the seller’s work experience and compliance with contractual requirements?

Intellectual property rights. Does the seller assert intellectual property rights in the work processes or services they will use or in the products they will produce for the project?

Proprietary rights. Does the seller assert proprietary rights in the work processes or services they will use or in the products they will produce for the project?

Page 65: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

65

Solicitation Solicitation involves obtaining proposals

or bids from prospective sellers Organizations can advertise to procure

goods and services in several ways approaching the preferred vendor approaching several potential vendors advertising to anyone interested

A bidders’ conference can help clarify the buyer’s expectations

Page 66: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Request Seller Responses: Tools and Techniques

Bidder Conferences Meetings with prospective sellers prior to preparation

of a bid or proposal. To have a clear, common understanding of the

procurement All potential sellers are given equal standing during

this initial buyer and seller interaction to produce the best bid.

Advertising

Develop Qualified Sellers List Qualified sellers lists can be developed from the

organizational assets if such lists or information are readily available. Whether or not that data is available, the project team can also develop its own sources.

Page 67: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

67

Outline for a Request for Proposal (RFP)I. Purpose of RFP

II. Organization’s Background

III. Basic Requirements

IV. Hardware and Software Environment

V. Description of RFP Process

VI. Statement of Work and Schedule Information

VII. Possible Appendices

A. Current System Overview

B. System Requirements

C. Volume and Size Data

D. Required Contents of Vendor’s Response to RFP

E. Sample Contract

Page 68: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah
Page 69: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Planning for land Procurement

Page 70: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Consultancy Procurement

Page 71: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Civil Works Planning

Page 72: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Road Construction Planning

Page 73: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Procurement of Equipment and Goods

Page 74: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

74

Source Selection Source selection involves

evaluating bidders’ proposals choosing the best one negotiating the contract where allowed awarding the contract

It is helpful to prepare formal evaluation procedures for selecting vendors

Buyers often create a “short list”

Page 75: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Select Sellers

Selection decision process: cost can be the primary determinant for an off-the-shelf

item, Proposals are often separated into technical

(approach) and commercial (price) sections, with each evaluated separately.

Multiple sources could be required for critical products, services, and results to mitigate risks that can be associated with issues such as delivery schedules and quality requirements.

Select a single seller that will be asked to sign a standard contract.

Page 76: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Select Sellers

Establish a negotiating sequence by ranking all proposals by the weighed evaluation scores assigned to each proposal.

On major procurement items, the overall process of requesting responses from sellers and evaluating sellers’ responses can be repeated.

A short list of qualified sellers can be established based on a preliminary proposal. A more detailed evaluation can then be conducted based on a more detailed and comprehensive proposal that is requested from the sellers on the short list.

Page 77: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Select Seller Techniques Weighting System Independent Estimates Screening System Contract Negotiation (Not under PPRA) Seller Rating Systems Expert Judgment

Page 78: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

78

Sample Proposal Evaluation Sheet

Page 79: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

79

Be Careful in Selecting Suppliers and Writing Their Contracts Many dot-com companies were created to meet potential

market needs, but many went out of business, mainly due to poor business planning, lack of senior management operations experience, lack of leadership, and lack of visions. Check the stability of suppliers

Even well-known suppliers can impede project success. Be sure to write and manage contracts well with all suppliers (see What Went Wrong?)

Page 80: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

80

Contract Administration Contract administration ensures that the

seller’s performance meets contractual requirements

Contracts are legal relationships, so it is important that legal and contracting professionals be involved in writing and administering contracts

Many project managers ignore contractual issues, which can result in serious problems

Page 81: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Contract• An agreement enforceable by Law

•A contract is awarded to each selected seller.

•The contract can be in the form of a complex document or a simple purchase order.

• Regardless of the document’s complexity, a contract is a mutually binding legal agreement that obligates the seller to provide the specified products, services, or results, and obligates the buyer to pay the seller.

Page 82: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Contract Administration: Tools and Techniques

Contract Change Control System A contract change control system defines the process by

which the contract can be modified.

Buyer-Conducted Performance Review

Inspections and Audits

Performance Reporting

Page 83: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

83

Suggestions on Change Control for Contracts

Changes to any part of the project need to be reviewed, approved, and documented by the same people in the same way that the original part of the plan was approved

Evaluation of any change should include an impact analysis. How will the change affect the scope, time, cost, and quality of the goods or services being provided?

Changes must be documented in writing. Project team members should also document all important meetings and telephone calls

Page 84: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

84

Contract Close-out Contract close-out includes

product verification to determine if all work was completed correctly and satisfactorily

administrative activities to update records to reflect final results

archiving information for future use Procurement audits identify lessons learned in the

procurement process A procurement audit is a structured review of the

procurement process from the Plan Purchases and Acquisitions process

Records Management System

Page 85: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

85

Using Software to Assist in Project Procurement Management

Word processing software helps in writing proposals and contracts, spreadsheets help in evaluating suppliers, databases help track suppliers, and presentation software aids in presenting procurement-related information

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, many companies started using e-procurement software to do many procurement functions electronically

Companies such as Commerce One, Ariba, Concur Technologies, SAS, and Baan provide corporate procurement services over the Internet

Organizations also use other Internet tools to help find information on suppliers or auction goods and services

Can you name some from Pakistan?

Page 86: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

I have learnt “Silence” from

the talkative,

“Toleration” from the “intolerant”,

& “Kindness” from the unkind; yet strange, I am

ungrateful to

these teachers.

Kahlil Gibran (1883 - 1931)

Page 87: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Iqbal’s Poetry

Page 88: Project Procurement Management Prof. Dr. Attaullah Shah

Thank You