private equity search process timeline & allocation ... 5 private...i. private equity search...

21

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

14 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction
Page 2: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives

II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction IV. Manager Selection & Recommendations V. Requested Board Action

2

1. Footnotes 2. Footnotes

Page 3: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

Section I

3

Page 4: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

4

• TMRS staff presented the 2017 Private Equity Pacing Plan recommending a commitment of up to $600 million of Private Equity exposure.

•TMRS Staff formally launched the 2017 search process, in concert with StepStone.

•Conduct manager reviews through a multi-phase evaluation process for all candidates. •Multiple conference calls with StepStone to score and determine best candidates for

TMRS, as well as incorporate their sourcing and due diligence.

•February 2017: Staff and StepStone currently present two manager/three fund recommendations for the Private Equity Asset Class for $125 million.

Dec 2016

Dec 2016

Q2 2016 –

Q1 2017

Current

Q1 2017

•Execution of the contract, and funding. •Continue second step of 2017 search process for May/June recommendation

timeframe.

Page 5: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

Excess Return Potential ◦ Expected excess return consistent with TMRS’ overall objective for

Private Equity asset class: Russell 3000 + 3.00%. ◦ Identify best in class managers currently in fundraising.

Portfolio Diversification ◦ Balance concentration and diversification across managers. ◦ Ensure sufficient strategy diversification, consistent with policy

guidelines, and whenever possible incorporate tactical and opportunistic considerations into manager selection.

Targeted Commitment Level ◦ Per the December 2016 Board approval, the targeted Private

Equity Pacing Plan for 2017 is up to $600 million.

5

Page 6: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

Section II

6

Page 7: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

7

Manager Screen & Universe Analysis Scoring

Scoring Category Score / Outcome

Manager Screen - Is vehicle consistent w/ TMRS' objectives?

Yes - Take Meeting; No - Don't Take

Meeting Manager Analysis - Does vehicle have adequate capacity and timeline? - PPPPT* Preliminary Review

1 - Advance; 2 - Stop Research

Semi-Finalist Scoring Matrix Scoring Category Score Finalist Manager Review - Questionnaire Review - Detailed PPPPT* Review - In-depth Manager Qualifications Review - Compliance with TMRS IPS - Verification of Research, References, Further Market Research

A - Prioritize for Final Due Diligence

B - Perform More Research C - Stop Research / Manager

not Selected

Final Due Diligence Scoring Matrix Scoring Category Possible Points People (Firm & Team) 0 - 40 points Philosophy (Attractiveness of Opportunity / Portfolio Fit) 0 - 20 points Process (Sourcing, Underwriting and Managing) 0 - 40 points Performance (Historical / Expected) 0 - 40 points Terms (Fees, Liquidity, etc.) 0 - 20 points Total 100†

Page 8: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

8

120 distinct buy-out managers sourced

73 distinct buy-out meetings (61%)

14 on-site growth buy-out meetings (12%)

2 buy-out managers/ 3

funds (1.7%)

Cumulative buy-out manager selection rate 5.8%

Page 9: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

9

Final Due Diligence Scoring Matrix - Aggregated Results*

Recommended Manager/Fund Manager Score† Comparable Mgr. 1 Score

Comparable Mgr. 2 Score

Marlin Equity V, L.P. (Marlin Equity)

100.0 93.0 90.0

Marlin Heritage II, L.P. (Marlin Heritage)

100.0 90.0 89.0

One Rock Capital Partners II, L.P. (One Rock)

100.0 90.5 82.0

*Scoring matrices utilize difference calibrations depending on the strategy being utilized. †Selected managers standardized to a score of 100 to allow comparability among selected managers.

Page 10: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

Section III

10

Page 11: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

11

Strategy considerations: 2015: Overweight special situations early for J-Curve mitigation, efficiency of capital deployment, and tactical opportunities. 2016: Focus on growth opportunity set and continue to add buy-out exposure. 2017: Round out buy-out portfolio, and opportunistically add to growth and credit.

37.9%

27.0%

35.1%

Figure 1 : Private Equity Strategy Diversification by Commitment

Buy-out (40.0% to75.0%)

Growth (5.0% to25.0%)

Special Situations(10.0% to 35.0%)

25.3%

18.1%

23.5%

33.2%

Figure 2 : Private Equity Target Diversification

Buy-out (40.0% to75.0%)Growth (5.0% to25.0%)Special Situations(10.0% to 35.0%)Un-allocated

Page 12: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

12

The overall goal remains identifying top quartile performers to partner with. Position sizing considerations: • Continue to reduce the

unallocated portion of the private equity portfolio while sensibly balancing the trade-off between diversification and concentration.

• Areas of focus are enhancing manager diversification, and building strategic relationships where possible/appropriate.

9.0%

9.0%

7.8%

7.2%

7.2%

6.0% 6.0% 6.0%

6.0%

5.6%

5.5%

4.8%

4.8% 4.2%

3.6%

3.0% 2.4%

2.2%

Figure 3: Private Equity Manager Diversification by Commitment TPG

GSOCarlyleH.I.G.ProvidenceTritiumUpdataMarlin VOne RockSearchlightFTVInclineMercatoKainosFoundryHeritageHarvestGSO Co-Inv.

6.0% 6.0%

5.2%

4.8%

4.8%

4.0%

4.0% 4.0%

4.0% 3.8%

3.7% 3.2% 3.2% 2.8%

2.4% 2.0%

1.6% 1.5%

33.2%

Figure 4: Private Equity Target Manager Diversification

TPGGSOCarlyleH.I.G.ProvidenceTritiumUpdataMarlin VOne RockSearchlightFTVInclineMercatoKainosFoundryHeritageHarvestGSO Co-Inv.Un-allocated

Page 13: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

13

TMRS is focused on taking a measured approach to global geographic diversification.

The Target Portfolio keeps a conservative stance on international exposure.

81.4%

18.6%

Figure 5 : Private Equity Geographic Diversification by Commitment

U.S.A.

International54.4%

12.4%

33.2%

Figure 6 : Private Equity Target Geographic Diversification

U.S.A.InternationalUn-Allocated

Page 14: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

Section IV

14

Page 15: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

15

Summary of Recommendations

Recommended Manager/Fund Strategy Classification

Target Return

Recommended Amount

Marlin Equity Buy-out Strategy 20% / 2.0X $60 million

Marlin Heritage Buy-out Strategy 25% / 2.5X $15 million

One Rock Buy-out Strategy 20% / 2.0X $50 million

Total Net Recommendations: $125 million

Private Equity Pacing model as approved by the TMRS Board of Trustees in December 2016 established up to $600 million as the targeted level of commitments for 2017.

Page 16: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

16

Category Marlin Equity Turnaround Comp 1

Turnaround Comp 2

People 23.5 23.5 21.5 Philosophy 25 23.5 19.5 Process 18.5 18.5 17.5 Performance 17.5 17.5 17.5 Terms 15.5 10 14 Total 100 93 90

Reasons to Invest

- Cohesive senior team with limited turnover – Managing partners have worked together for 9 years at Marlin and many more together while at Gores Group.

- Top quartile performance – Funds I‐III each rank in the top quartile on a net TVM, net IRR and DPI basis relative to their peers.

- Operations‐focused strategy ‐ This differentiated investment approach is expected to provide a significant competitive advantage.

Risks & Mitigants

- Fund size increase – Represents significant increase, but team has success with larger deals.

- Departure of George Kase –Staff has become familiar with the reasoning behind his departure and does not consider Mr. Kase’s departure as a risk.

- Fund IV largely unrealized – The fund is still very young and every position is still in the early stage of the turnaround process.

Marlin invests in the software/technology sector, with additional secondary sectors that the Firm may opportunistically pursue. The fund will follow the same strategy employed by prior Marlin funds, targeting businesses with shared attributes such as sustainable operations, predictable revenue streams, scalable cost structures, and underutilized assets. Marlin has a heavy operational focus, working with portfolio companies to turn underperforming businesses around. Marlin Equity will target investing in 15 to 20 platform companies, committing US $75 – 300 million per investment, invest primarily in North America and Western Europe, with investments outside North America subject to a cap of 25% of commitments. It will be a $2.5 billion fund.

Page 17: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

17

Category Marlin Heritage Small Turnaround 1

Small Turnaround 2

People 23 22 19 Philosophy 21 19 20 Process 18 17 16 Performance 24 18 21 Terms 14 14 13 Total 100 90 89

Reasons to Invest

- Cohesive senior team with limited turnover – Managing partners have worked together for 9 year at Marlin and many more together while at Gores Group.

- Dedicated Investment Team – Marlin’s Heritage team is comprised of 13 dedicated professionals.

- Impressive, low loss ratio – loss ratio of just 3% across all funds

Risks & Mitigants

- Departure of George Kase –Staff has become familiar with the reasoning behind his departure and do not consider Mr. Kase’s departure as a risk.

- Competition – The lower‐end of the technology space has become increasingly competitive over the past several years, but Heritage benefits from Marlin’s scale

- Fund I Immaturity – The fund is still very young and every position is still in the early stage of the turnaround process.

Marlin Heritage follows the same investment philosophy and operationally-focused strategy employed by the larger Marlin funds, but is focused on the Lower Middle Market and limited to North America. Marlin invests primarily in companies within the software/technology sector, as well as a number of secondary sectors that the firm will opportunistically pursue. Marlin Heritage will target businesses with shared attributes such as sustainable operations, predictable revenue streams, scalable cost structures, and underutilized assets. The Firm generally expects Marlin Heritage to make 15 to 20 platform investments in small and lower middle-market companies requiring an initial investment of between $10 million and $60 million. The fund is raising $500 million.

Page 18: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

18

Reasons to Invest

- Senior team experience and cohesion – Managing partners have been in private equity since the late 1990s. One Rock has not had any turnover since inception.

- Strong Fund I and absolute performance – Top quartile track record, with only one deal returning less than a 1.6x multiple.

- Impressive, low loss ratio – loss ratio of just 8% across all funds

Risks & Mitigants

- Fund size increase – One Rock’s target fund size represents a 62% increase from Fund I. However, Fund I deals have required over $200 million of co‐investment capital, suggesting that the firm's growth in fund size will likely not result in strategy drift.

- Mitsubishi ownership – Mitsubishi’s ownership will decline materially in Fund II and the firm provides significant operational resources.

- Fund I largely unrealized – The fund is very young, and assets are performing as expected.

One Rock Capital Partners was founded in 2010 by former professionals of Ripplewood. One Rock will focus on Lower Middle Market companies that primarily operate in the specialty manufacturing, healthcare products, chemicals & process, business services, environmental services and auto retail sectors. One Rock is a value-oriented, operationally-focused manager, targeting control investments in complex transactions. The fund is targeting $700 million and expects to make 8 to 12 investments of $35 to $100 million each, with no less than 80% deployed in North American companies.

Category One Rock Small Buyout

1 Small

Buyout 2 People 23.0 18.5 20.0 Philosophy 21.0 18.5 18.0 Process 18.5 19.5 16.0 Performance 22.0 24.0 15.0 Terms 15.5 10.0 13.0

Total 100.0 90.5 82.0

Page 19: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

Section V

19

Page 20: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

20

TMRS Staff and StepStone Group recommend that the Board of

Trustees approve the selection of the following funds as referenced in the Board Communication Memo for investment:

Marlin Equity V, L.P.: $60 mm to Buy-out Strategy Marlin Heritage II, L.P.: $15 mm to Buy-out Strategy One Rock Capital Partners II, L.P.: $50 mm to Buy-out Strategy

Page 21: Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation ... 5 Private...I. Private Equity Search Process Timeline & Allocation Objectives II. Manager Search Process III. Portfolio Construction

DISCLOSURES

TMRS periodically discloses public information that is not excepted from disclosure under Section 552.0225(b) of the Texas Public Information Act. Information provided

by a manager, a general partner or other data provider to TMRS or a TMRS service provider, and contained in these materials, may have been independently produced or

modified by TMRS or the TMRS service provider.

21