presentation from may 14, 2002
TRANSCRIPT
ASN (RDA)CHIEF ENGINEER
Dr. Harry E. CrispDirector, RDA CHENG Naval CEE
Naval CEE Presented to WMA INCOSE
Naval CEE Presented to WMA INCOSE
14 May 200214 May 2002
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 2 04/08/23
TopicsTopicsTopicsTopics
Naval CEE Purpose
RDA CHENG Website
Collaborative Engineering Data Resource
Integrated Engineering Environment
Summary
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 3 04/08/23
Naval CEE PurposeNaval CEE PurposeNaval CEE PurposeNaval CEE Purpose
To provide an integrated digital environment that:– Enhances the cooperation and exchange of
data, information, and knowledge among Naval stakeholders engaged in ------ activities directed toward assuring integrated and interoperable Naval force systems.
– Enables the integration and interoperability of Naval force systems across the spectrum of the Naval acquisition process.
Naval CEE Terms of Reference,
4 January 2001
Based on Both E-Business and E-Systems Engineering Capabilities
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 4 04/08/23
Collaboration CapabilitiesCollaboration CapabilitiesCollaboration CapabilitiesCollaboration Capabilities
Formal Reviews Markups
Formal Comment Documents
Interactive Electronic Comments
Discussions and Interactions Telephone
Meetings
Video Teleconferences
Threaded E-Discussions
Data Transfer Mail (Documents, Briefings, Reports)
Centralized Repository
Technical Manual
Standalone Tools
Enterprise Environment
Security Enforcement Physical
Electronic
Access Control
Activities Alternatives
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 5 04/08/23
IntegratedEngineeringEnvironment
LiveLinkDRIVERS
Concept Exploration & Definition
Demonstration / ValidationEngineering Manufacturing & Development
Production & Deployment
Upgrade and
Replacent
PHASE
100010010
MGMT
Jan Apr Jul Oct
OutlookServer
DRIVERSConcept Exploration & Definition
Demonstration / Validation
Engineering Manufacturing & Development
Production & Deployment
Upgrade and Replacent
PHASE
100010010
MGMT
Jan Apr Jul Oct
DSC
DecisionSupportEnvironment
Interoperability Data Management and Analysis
Distributed InformationRepository
REQSPEC Logical Structural / HME
CONCEPTUAL
RequirementsRepository
REQSPEC
Logical Structural / HMECONCEPTUAL
ExistingDatabase
REQ
SPECLogical
Structural / HME
CONCEPTUAL
OtherRepository
NAVAL CEE
Joint Services
ASN RDA CHENG
OPNAV
SYSCOMS
PEOs/PMs
CINCs
Fleet
• Leverage Existing Infrastructure• NMCI Reliance
• Classified/Unclassified Connectivity• Information Assurance
Naval Collaborative Engineering Naval Collaborative Engineering EnvironmentEnvironment
Naval Collaborative Engineering Naval Collaborative Engineering EnvironmentEnvironment
Classified and Unclassified Connectivity to Enable Stakeholder Collaboration
CoalitionPartners
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 6 04/08/23
Naval CEE Website “Portal”Naval CEE Website “Portal”Naval CEE Website “Portal”Naval CEE Website “Portal”User Workspaces
Netmeeting
Livelink
Interchange
CEDAR Database B
Database A
Database C
Tool A
Tool BTool C
Mix of Web-Based and Client/Server Technologies
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 7 04/08/23
RDA CHENG Website RDA CHENG Website RDA CHENG Website RDA CHENG Website
Keep team members informed Share information
Collaborate
Keep track of upcoming events
Monitor status of team action items
Access data and tools
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 8 04/08/23
Collaborative Engineering Data ResourceCollaborative Engineering Data ResourceCollaborative Engineering Data ResourceCollaborative Engineering Data Resource
Graphical User Environment
Toolbox• “plug-ins”• Interchange• MS Office
CHENG DB
Work Space• Per user, project• Provides export• Includes local DB• Share Data
Web Interface : Web Pages with Content on Resources
User Access Support
DA
TAIN
FOR
MA
TION
Web Interface
NAVSEA (AMPS)
Web pages•Navigation•Structure•Access
Excel Spreadsheets
MARCOR (MSTAR)
Web Interface
•Navigation•Structure•Access
Application Server pages
DB (Oracle)Dat
a R
esou
rce
Spac
eU
ser
Spac
e N
CEE
Fun
ctio
nal S
pace
On-Line Help
Cross Reference Index
Meta Data
Exploration Layer
User• Answer a Question• Browse Repositories
Graphical Navigation Aid
SPAWAR (VPO)Web Interface
•Navigation•Structure•Access
Server pages
DB
NAVAIR (IDR)
Web Interface
Word (.DOC) Files
Web pages•Navigation•Structure•Access•Content
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 9 04/08/23
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 10 04/08/23
IDR OverviewIDR OverviewIDR OverviewIDR Overview
Authorita-tive Data
Program Links
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 11 04/08/23
IDR - Authoritative DataIDR - Authoritative DataIDR - Authoritative DataIDR - Authoritative Data
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 12 04/08/23
IDR - Authoritative Data (cont.)IDR - Authoritative Data (cont.)
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 13 04/08/23
IDR - Program LinksIDR - Program Links
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 14 04/08/23
Integrated EngineeringIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentEnvironmentIntegrated EngineeringIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentEnvironment
SharepointServer
DRIVERSConcept Exploration & Definition
Demonstration / Validation
Engineering Manufacturing & Development
Production & Deployment
Upgrade and Replacent
PHASE
1000100
10MGMT
Jan Apr Jul Oct
LiveLinkServer
DRIVERSConcept Exploration & Definition
Demonstration / ValidationEngineering Manufacturing & Development
Production & DeploymentUpgrade and Replacent
PHASE
100010010
MGMT
Jan Apr Jul Oct
ObjectServerREQ
SPECLogical Structural / HME
CONCEPTUAL
ExistingDatabase
PhysicalDesign
ENVISION/ERGO
HumanSystems
IntegrationIPME
Cost AnalysisVAMOSCCOMET
ObjectAnalysis
ROSE
FunctionalAnalysisCORE
Risk AnalysisTRIMS
RequirementsAnalysisDOORSModeling
& SimulationNSS
Provides for a Seamless Flow of Information Between Tools
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 15 04/08/23
Interchange OverviewInterchange OverviewInterchange OverviewInterchange Overview
Cost Tools
Project Management
Engineering Tools
ViewerAgent Builder Query Builder Schema
EditorRepository
Administration
To
ol P
lug
-in
Interchange
Server
The Power To Integrate, Coordinate and Collaborate
An Object Oriented Information Infrastructure
Integrates tools and processes into a central engineering repository
Provides access to a common system design representation
Facilitates data sharing and design configuration management
Interrelate data between applications in different domains
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 16 04/08/23
TechnicalTechnical
C4ISR Architecture FrameworkC4ISR Architecture FrameworkC4ISR Architecture FrameworkC4ISR Architecture Framework
Framework
Identifies Standardsand Conventions
Identifies Standardsand Conventions
Guidelines and Process for Developing Architectures That Are Consistent, Comparable, and Integrable
OperationalOperational
Identifies WarfighterInformation Needs
Identifies WarfighterInformation Needs
SystemsSystems
Overlays Capabilities andCharacteristics on Requirements
Overlays Capabilities andCharacteristics on Requirements
High Level Op ConceptHigh Level Op Concept
Command RelationshipsCommand Relationships
Activity ModelActivity Model
Information ExchangeMatrix
Information ExchangeMatrix
Required CapabilitiesMatrix
Required CapabilitiesMatrix
Node ConnectivityDiagram (NCD)
Node ConnectivityDiagram (NCD)
Overlays to NCDOverlays to NCD
System ElementInterface DiagramSystem Element
Interface Diagram
System PerformanceParameters
System PerformanceParameters
Standards andCriteria
Standards andCriteria
Technical ForecastsTechnical Forecasts
System EvolutionDiagram
System EvolutionDiagram
Decision Makers and Operators are Critical Elementsof the Overall Architecture
Decision Makers and Operators are Critical Elementsof the Overall Architecture
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 17 04/08/23
Using Architectures in SystemsUsing Architectures in SystemsEngineeringEngineering
Using Architectures in SystemsUsing Architectures in SystemsEngineeringEngineering
Operational Concept
System Functional Mapping
System Interface Mapping
OV-1OV-4
OV-5
SV-3SV-4
SV-5
OV-2
OV-3
SV-1 TV-1
SV-2 SV-6
Architecture Performanceand Behavior
OV-6CSV-7
ExecutableModel
OV-1OV-1 High-level Operational Concept GraphicHigh-level Operational Concept GraphicOV-2OV-2 Operational Node Connectivity DescriptionOperational Node Connectivity DescriptionOV-3OV-3 Operational Information Exchange MatrixOperational Information Exchange MatrixOV-4OV-4 Command Relationships ChartCommand Relationships ChartOV-5OV-5 Activity ModelActivity ModelOV-6COV-6C Operational Event/Trace DescriptionOperational Event/Trace DescriptionSV-1SV-1 System Interface DescriptionSystem Interface DescriptionSV-2SV-2 Systems Communication DescriptionSystems Communication DescriptionSV-3SV-3 Systems MatrixSystems MatrixSV-4SV-4 System Functionality DescriptionSystem Functionality DescriptionSV-5SV-5 Operational Activity to System Function Operational Activity to System Function
Traceability MatrixTraceability MatrixSV-6SV-6 System Information Exchange MatrixSystem Information Exchange MatrixSV-7SV-7 System Performance Parameters MatrixSystem Performance Parameters MatrixSV-8SV-8 System Evolution DescriptionSystem Evolution DescriptionSV-9SV-9 System Technology ForecastSystem Technology ForecastSV-10SV-10 System Activity Sequence & TimingSystem Activity Sequence & TimingTV-1TV-1 Technical Architecture ProfileTechnical Architecture ProfileTV-2 TV-2 Standards Technology ForecastStandards Technology Forecast
The Role of Engineering and TechnologyThe Role of Engineering and Technology
Lesser
Greater
1st Order Analysis:Functionality--
2nd Order Analysis:Static Interoperability
3rd Order Analysis:Dynamic Interoperability
OV-3
Note: There are dependencies between the Architecture products that are not shown in the System Engineering flow. Many of the products are developed concurrently.
Architectures Provide the Framework for Architectures Provide the Framework for FoS/SoS Systems Engineering & AcquisitionFoS/SoS Systems Engineering & Acquisition
Architectures Provide the Framework for Architectures Provide the Framework for FoS/SoS Systems Engineering & AcquisitionFoS/SoS Systems Engineering & Acquisition
SV-8TV-2
FoS/SoS Evolution
SV-9
SV-10 Rev 4 * 22 Apr 02
DRMOpSits
TTP
DRM: Design Reference MissionOpSit: Operational SituationTTP: Tactics, Techniques, ProceduresFoS: Family of SystemsSoS: System of Systems
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 18 04/08/23
Integrated Engineering EnvironmentIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentSE Process & ProductsSE Process & Products
Integrated Engineering EnvironmentIntegrated Engineering EnvironmentSE Process & ProductsSE Process & Products
Requirement Documents
• Life Cycle Traceability• Change Agent Notification• System Representation• Configuration Management• Tools Integration
Requirement Analysis Tool
SPGMNSORD
SPD
DOORS
Structured Requirements
Function Analysis Tool
CORE
Activity Model
Functional Model
Function Information
Functional Baselines
Interchange (Server)
Project Repository
Systems Spec
Physical Implementation
Information
Resource Constraint
Interchange Client
Architecture Representation
Rational RoseDIAD
JMAAT
Operational View
System View
Technical View
Architecture Information
Experimental Data
System Data
Interface Data
LSSE Analysis
COPATRAB
RCA
TRIMSM&S
COST MODELSHSI
CAD/CAM
AuthoritativeData Bases
CEDAR
NSS
Mission Analysis
Simulation Model
Design
Synthesis
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 19 04/08/23
OV-1
OV-4
OV-5OV-3
OV-2
• Requirement Documents• Activity Timing, Inputs & Outputs• Activity Resource Utilization• Execution Logic• OV-6a, OV-6b, OV-6c, OV-7
Operational Model
SV-1 TV-1
SV-2 SV-6
SV-3
SV-4 SV-5
SV-7
• Control Logic• Functional Resource Utilization• Functional Timing & Data Flows• Conditional Logic (Failure
Conditions, Fault Detection)• SV-10a, SV-10b, SV-10c
Functional Model
RequirementsAnalysis
(DOORS, CORE,
CEDAR)
FunctionalAnalysis
(CORE)
Physical (Design) Model
• Interface Design/Control (SV-11)• Effectiveness Models• FMECA/RAM Analysis• Dynamic Reconfiguration• Ownership Cost Analysis
Design Synthesis(CORE)
Application of Architecture Views & Application of Architecture Views & Tools to Systems EngineeringTools to Systems Engineering
Application of Architecture Views & Application of Architecture Views & Tools to Systems EngineeringTools to Systems Engineering
Interchange
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 20 04/08/23
Executable Operational
Model
Executable Operational
Model
Data Calls
System ORDs
Systems Architecting/Engineering FlowSystems Architecting/Engineering FlowSystems Architecting/Engineering FlowSystems Architecting/Engineering Flow
OperationalAnalysis
Capstone Requirements
Document
Operational Concept
Current Operational Architecture
RequirementsAnalysis
System Functional Mapping
Establish Activity Time-line (Budget)
FunctionalAnalysis
Logical Interface Mapping
Allocate Activities to
Sys. Functions (Budget)
Design Synthesis Assess
Technology Roadmap
Develop System Alternatives
(Perf. Budgets)
Navy Standard Functional Hierarchy
System Specifications,
ICDs
OV-1, OV-2, OV-3, OV-4, OV-5, OV-6
Systems Architecting Systems Engineering
Functional Models
Physical (Design) Models
Establish Activity Time-line (Budget)
Allocate Activities to
Sys. Functions (Budget)
Develop System Alternatives
(Perf. Budgets)
SV-4, SV-5
SV-1, SV-7
SV-9, TV-2
Systems Interfaces Mapping
SV-1, SV-2, SV-3, SV-6, SV-11, TV-1
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 21 04/08/23
Executable SOS ModelExecutable SOS Model
Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow (Continued)(Continued)
Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow Systems Architecting/Engineering Flow (Continued)(Continued)
Systems Analysis
CapabilityStrategic Planning
Establish Capability Evolution Roadmap
Finalize Design
Solution(s)
Program Plans, Budgets,
Milestones
Assess Alternative Cost/Effectiveness
Update Capstone Requirements
Document
Systems Architecting Systems Engineering
Recommended Acquisition
Strategy (CV-6)
Program Alignment
Interoperability Analysis
Architecture Performance and
Behavior
SV-8
SV-10
Systems Interfaces Mapping
Assess Technology Roadmap
SV-8
OV-1
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 22 04/08/23
Information Naval CEE Function Outputs/ Integrated Database
Force Systems Operational Objectives
Force Systems Operational Objectives
SE Data and ProductsSE Data and ProductsSE Data and ProductsSE Data and Products
• Life Cycle Traceability• Change Agent Notification• System Representation• Configuration Management• Tools Integration
Interchange (Server)
Capture Force Systems Information in Data Base
Management SystemForce Systems CharacteristicsForce Systems Characteristics
Force Systems Performance Profile
Force Systems Performance Profile
Platform/System O&M Cost
Profile
Platform/System O&M Cost
Profile
Platform/SystemManningProfile
Platform/SystemManningProfile
Platform/SystemC4ISR Info.
Views
Platform/SystemC4ISR Info.
Views
Integrated Force Systems Requirements
Integrated Force Systems Requirements
Integrated Force Systems Performance
Specifications
Integrated Force Systems Performance
Specifications
Force Systems Operational Functions
Force Systems Operational Functions
Platform/System Interfaces/ICDs
Platform/System Interfaces/ICDs
Platform/System Manning & Task
Profiles
Platform/System Manning & Task
Profiles
Platform/System Ownership Costs Over
Time
Platform/System Ownership Costs Over
Time
Force Systems Effectiveness & MOEs/MOPs
Force Systems Effectiveness & MOEs/MOPs
Force Systems C4ISR Arch. Framework
Views
Force Systems C4ISR Arch. Framework
Views
CRD
CRD/SRD
SPD
SPD
SPD
SPD
CED
TEMP
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 23 04/08/23
Data Integration FlowData Integration FlowData Integration FlowData Integration FlowDOORS
CORE
InterchangeSE Repository
Requirements Model
Operational Model (OVs)
Functional Model (SVs)
Behavior Model
Word,
PowerPoint,
Excel, DIAD, ..
Physical Model
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 24 04/08/23
Naval CEE Infrastructure OverviewNaval CEE Infrastructure OverviewNaval CEE Infrastructure OverviewNaval CEE Infrastructure Overview
OutlookServer
DRIVERSConcept Exploration & Definition
Demonstration / Validation
Engineering Manufacturing & Development
Production & Deployment
Upgrade and Replacent
PHASE
1000100
10MGMT
Jan Apr Jul Oct
LiveLinkServer
DRIVERSConcept Exploration & Definition
Demonstration / ValidationEngineering Manufacturing & Development
Production & DeploymentUpgrade and Replacent
PHASE
100010010
MGMT
Jan Apr Jul Oct
REQSPEC
Logical Structural / HMECONCEPTUAL
ExistingDatabase Object
Server
CHENG
NSWCDDJHUAPL
NUWCNAVSEA
SPAWAR
Conferencing Tools
Document & Object Server Remote Access
Engineering Tools Management Tools
NAVAIR
MARCORP
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 25 04/08/23
SummarySummarySummarySummary
Modern Information Technology Provides Capabilities to Deal with Force Systems Complexity.– Configuration Management and Control of Force
Systems Architectures and Their Evolution Over Time.– Support for Geographically Distributed Teams Involved
in Acquisition Management and Engineering Analysis.
Processes, Methods and Tools are Available to Move Network Centric Warfare Off the View Foils and Into Acquisition!
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 26 04/08/23
DiscussionDiscussionDiscussionDiscussion
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 27 04/08/23
• Requirements management tool• Capture text requirements• Track requirement changes• Documents-to-document linking• Inter-project linking
• Easy to use and access• Web-access utilizing DOORSnetTM • Drag-and-drop linking that create relationships• Built-in graphics for display of statistics and metrics • Filters on all data for faster access to specific information • Color-coded change bars
• Imports/Exports• Microsoft Word• RTF• Interleaf• Framemaker(R)
• Text • Spreadsheets • HTML
DOORS OverviewDOORS OverviewDOORS OverviewDOORS Overview
RDA CHENG PEO Council/CCE Mtg 28 Nov 2001 Slide 28 04/08/23
CORE OverviewCORE OverviewCORE OverviewCORE Overview
Allows system engineers to capture, analyze
and verify design integrity before problems
embed themselves in the system Support C4ISR architecture framework Extensive behavior modeling notations
representing control flow, function flow, data
flow, resource utilization and interface-link
capacity System simulations automatically synchronized
with behavior models Comprehensive traceability System documentation generated directly from
the database as a by-product of the engineering
effort
OPERATIONAL MODELOPERATIONAL MODEL
FUNCTION HIERARCHYFUNCTION HIERARCHY
BEHAVIOR MODELBEHAVIOR MODEL
IMPLEMENTATIONIMPLEMENTATION(PHYSICAL) MODEL(PHYSICAL) MODEL
SIMULATION RESULT SIMULATION RESULT