predictive intelligence for hunting down financial crisis tipping points

17
The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027 Copyright Protected June 2011 1 YOUR FINANCIAL DATA IS TRYING TO TELL YOU SOMETHING. IS YOUR WEALTH MANAGEMENT PROCESS BUILT TO HEAR IT? CMLs Trading Facility and Data Analysis Control Center CATALLACTIC TRANSFORMING PERCEIVED RISK INTO OPPORTUNITY Mr. Hoffman heads the Catastrophe Modeling Research Unit and Risk-Surveillance Observatory at Catallactic Wealth Management Group of Companies (CML), an organization established in 2009 for deploying state-of-the-art mission-resilient and time-sensitive trading technologies. Originally developed in-house over a 16 year period; versatility, transparency, and scalability are the hallmarks of our investment process.

Upload: clear-view-analytics-inc

Post on 18-May-2015

893 views

Category:

Economy & Finance


4 download

DESCRIPTION

Mr. Hoffman, the author of this trend-piece is on a mission for applying physics, finance, and game theory, in new ways for hunting down the broad and large scale differences between expectation and reality in world capital markets. Expanding on the analytic foresight of these broad-based features of natural and economic systems he is on his tenth year of ambitious work for engineering the next incarnation of scientific instrumentation and social network topology metrics for de-cohering the intricate entanglements – which hold clues of the shared beliefs and co-existent financial self-interests embodied among market agents during periods of financial crisis and unusual uncertainty -- across a broad-band of transaction scales and term-structures; all without making any assumptions about the underlying statistical distribution of events.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 1

YOUR FINANCIAL DATA IS TRYING TO TELL YOU SOMETHING.

IS YOUR WEALTH MANAGEMENT PROCESS BUILT TO HEAR IT?

CMLs Trading Facility and Data Analysis Control Center

CATALLACTIC – TRANSFORMING PERCEIVED RISK INTO OPPORTUNITY

Mr. Hoffman heads the Catastrophe Modeling Research Unit and Risk-Surveillance Observatory at

Catallactic Wealth Management Group of Companies (CML), an organization established in 2009 for

deploying state-of-the-art mission-resilient and time-sensitive trading technologies. Originally

developed in-house over a 16 year period; versatility, transparency, and scalability are the

hallmarks of our investment process.

Page 2: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 2

A NEW PARADIGM FOR HUNTING DOWN CRISIS TIPPING POINTS

Everyone is looking for proxies of extreme event phenomena; unfortunately statistical physics and

conventional Capital Asset Pricing are littered with the usage of "weak-signals" for capturing upcoming

aberrations of nature. They offer little, if any causal analysis or understanding of the endogenous factors

influencing the outcome.

In support of this mission, Efrem Hoffman, the founder of the recently launched LinkedIn Group, Global

Macro Dragon King Outliers, encourages inter-disciplinary discussion of an emerging class of financial

anomalies -- known as “Dragon-Kings” -- which was originally coined in 2008 by Marc Groz of Topos, LLC,

and studied and popularized by esteemed Swiss research scientist Didier Sornette of ETH Zurich.

Expanding on the analytic foresight of these broad-based features of natural and economic systems, Mr.

Hoffman is ambitiously working on his tenth year at engineering frontier quantitative tools and scientific

data instrumentation / visual metrics for de-cohering the intricate entanglements – that hold clues of the

shared beliefs and co-existent financial self-interests held among market agents across a broad-band of

transaction scales and term-structures -- without making assumptions about their underlying

distributional tendencies.

He parallels this mission in developing the next incarnation of tools that offer guidance in making real-time

inferences of those high-frequency and low-frequency trader/investor groups that are driving today's most

disruptive irrational outbursts in both the equity and currency markets.

His 10 years of research, funded by a variety of Canadian and US private equity investor groups, strongly

supports the following views:

Applications of Dragon-King Analysis can help identify those special situations, when the range of human

behavior of mass groups of economic, financial, and institutional actors become so unusually unstable, that

the symmetry in the relationships among what they perceive – in magnitude and frequency (at different

scales) -- starts to breakdown.

This class of naturally-occurring phenomena is pervasive throughout financial, social, and economic

systems; yet they cannot be adequately modeled or arbitraged away by many of today’s most sophisticated

statistical or numerical innovations. Through identifying the structural markers and precursory signatures

of these symmetry-breaking events, Mr. Hoffman is developing technologies to make predictions of these

extreme phenomena possible.

Page 3: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 3

He has drilled deep into the market’s micro-structure to unearth the underlying mechanisms of these

elusive flags. Today’s quantitative models in both engineering and finance are placing too much emphasis

on using probability theory for identifying the constancy of relationships among data (and the objects they

represent), when observed at different scales or rates of change.

While these methods try to express how these variables maintain symmetry of their geometries, and

stability in the relationships among their interacting parts (known in scientific parlance as Multi-Fractal

Scaling Laws, of which 99% of Econo-Physics and Behavioral Finance is inappropriately based), they fail to

realize that nature’s most compelling stories and consistently predictive markers of extreme dynamics

(such as Black Swans and Dragon-Kings) lie in the times when such self-ordered patterns of behavior

become disassembled. This occurs when these systems become so extraordinarily complex and entangled

that they reach a critical scale of growth, a sort of tipping point or crisis state in their existence.

On one side of this fault-line rests a picture of near perfect symmetry, while on the other lies an array of

imperfections; a sequence of shattered symmetries, which gives way to dissipative structures that create a

new cycle of decay.

The mechanism that differentiates Dragon-Kings from their distant cousins, the Black Swans, is that not

only do the sub-divisions or replications of their patterned dynamics occur with ever greater frequency

before their onset, but also, at certain stages in their life-cycle, external market events or institutional

stimuli provide just enough “critical” energy to preempt and nudge the system away from otherwise

crossing the tipping point. This leads to mutations or artificial sub-divisions in the scale of human behavior

that is no longer related in constant proportion to its previous range of values.

This is exactly what occurred after the injection of artificial stimulus in 2009, and is the main reason why

our global economy is in a precarious situation of “unusual uncertainty.”

The marked increase in both the magnitude and frequency of such unnatural sub-divisions since the run-up

to the 1998 technology bubble, has led to an alarming increase in unstable market states – a sort of

cancerous growth that has remained with us up to this very day, and likely to play a key role in market

dynamics over the next several years.

When these external artificial stimuli and natural vibrations eventually stress the system to a point where

it can no longer support and endure the buildup of pressure on one side of the divide, the system shrugs (as

the markets did during the Flash Crash of May 6th, 2010), and the energy released on the other end

Page 4: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 4

exaggerates the self-generating feedback dynamics; creating a sort of avalanche effect that pushes the

system into a dissipative cycle of decay -- which often accelerates at a faster rate than it did in its prior state

(counter to the direction preceding the crisis).

Mr. Hoffman is looking to exchange views and establish research alliances with industry peers to continue

his pursuit in hunting down the sub-divisions of market behavior that has driven this period of decay;

specifically those sub-divisions that do not scale well with the power law constants of the preceding cycle;

but rather are governed by a radically new regime that is comprised of a mixture of Dragon-Kings and

traditional exogenous Black Swans.

Through replicating their features across a broad spectrum of irregular scales, their combined effect lacks

the very symmetry that Black Swan crisis-hunters are preconditioned to recognize. That is because the

market actors would not only need to be aware of the behavioral differences between these phenomena,

but would also need to understand how their actions, upon crossing the tipping point, would impact the

demographics of investor types, namely the concentrations of fundamental versus technically-oriented

traders.

Consequently, the dynamics and accompanying events that follow the onset of Dragon-Kings are even more

pronounced, and represent a greater element of surprise than those power-law signatures preceding Black

Swans.

The arbitrage opportunity that is therefore created by a Dragon King Event is of greater measure than the

risk posed on the opposite side of the divide.

The ability to monetize these differences in reward to risk potential can provide a strong mathematical

edge, and will likely serve as the cornerstone of future alpha-generating strategies.

It has been shown that there is neither a characteristic scale that leads to this breakdown, nor a multi-

fractal scaling law that is pervasive across all markets. Mr. Hoffman's research process hones in on those

specific markets and asset classes that are expected to telegraph these differences in human behavior – all

within the context of the current market environment.

This circumvents the limitations of relying on historical precedent (and average deviations) to predict

future outcomes, especially when the distribution of events within the existing range of possible outcomes

Page 5: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 5

are not only pushed to the frontiers of what is Normal (“Black Swans”), but also extended beyond the tails

of the power-law curve (thereby entering the new domain where "Dragon’s" reign).

The quantitative research enterprise should learn to embrace asymmetry -- as one of the only universal

elements that serve as the underlying generator of the fine details and imperfections that we as speculators

observe throughout natural and fractal systems – including financial markets and other complex networks.

What modern finance has done is strait-jacket these fractal assemblies and turned them into holograms –

rigid shadows of their distant past; infinite copies without any flaws – which means they lose their innate

character; thereby, stripping them of their capacity to store any predictive content. Just as the

idiosyncrasies of character can reveal insights into a person’s future behavior, so too can these

asymmetries of the differences in market dynamics, on either side of the divide, help us understand and

predict the behavior of financial markets on a more human-scale.

This new knowledge-domain can help render visible a new field of information that constitutes the source

of what most of our peers frequently misinterpret as outliers — “Black Swans” – those extremely rare high-

impact events, which previously thought to be confined to the outer valence of the Normal Bell Curve, are

now no longer even thought to belong to the wild domain of super-Linear Power Laws -- and their Fractal

Generators.

Analysis and Real-Time Recognition of these phenomena are crucial to our understanding and prediction of

crisis formation, but more importantly, they telegraph super-normal inefficiencies that can be exploited on

four significant fronts.

(1) Most competing models of human behavior underestimate the magnitude of shocks, created by

endogenous regime-shifts in market behavior; thereby, lacking the necessary conviction to guide fund

managers in placing significant allocations ahead of these large-scale events.

(2) Market mechanisms find it particularly difficult to digest discontinuous (non-smooth) jumps in price

and volatility, which are associated with Dragon-Kings. As a logical consequence:

(3) Knowledge of their occurrence would permit volatility-based strategies to more appropriately align

their commitments of capital in the direction of the volatility expansion; thereby extracting additional

sources of return.

Page 6: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 6

(4) Employing a model framework that can more suitably account for the timing and magnitude of

"unusually uncertain" events, would permit "volatility of volatility" (VoVo) models to more appropriately

minimize volatility drag -- through fine-tuning their application of leverage during regime-shifting intervals

of volatility expansion or compression.

(5) Because most research shows that Black Swan events are not predictable, many competing strategy

frameworks fail to recognize that other classes of extreme phenomena, such as Dragon-Kings, are within

the purview of predictability.

When there is little competition, or better yet, people who are dogmatically opposed to the view of

inefficient markets, it opens up greater opportunity for those who can peer into the future and see a new

dimension of the existing data fields – revealing relevancy for making informed financial decisions.

Furthermore, conventional models treat outliers as abnormal system behavior, neglecting the fact that

there are naturally organic (endogenous) processes at work, which repeatedly create these features across

a wide spectrum of scales. Those that prefer to treat outliers as intrinsic characteristics of a system are

more closely aligned with the spirit of Dragon-King Analysis, and the benefits that can be derived from

them.

In this respect, contrarian thinking is not a bad policy, especially when trying to exploit what others either

can't or choose not to see.

More importantly, through incorporating the interaction of these defining system features, Hoffman has

discovered that the natural consequence of their critical transitions, which is central to our strategy

practice, is that the more mature a market becomes, the less energy it requires per unit of applied stress to

tip it into a crisis of similar magnitude -- that is because the difference in the growth of liquidity in the

order-book and the weight of the unwinding of crowded positions, upon crossing a critical transition,

grows disproportionally (super-linearly) as we pass through its window. This feature could be compared to

larger species that consume less energy per pound of flesh than smaller ones. “For instance, while an

elephant is 10,000 times the size of a guinea pig, it needs only 1,000 times as much energy.”

Hoffman says, it doesn’t matter what the market or asset class looks like or where it is situated or how it

evolved to get into that state space — the math almost always works.

Page 7: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 7

This straightforward observation has some surprising implications; it suggests, for instance, that mature

markets are strange characters; a tale of two behaviors – on the one hand they are the real centers of

sustainability, but if pushed too close to the tipping point, and especially if artificially sustained at those

levels through government intervention, before being nudged with enough internal force to cross the

chasm, the pattern of interaction among market actors can become its own agent of systemic crisis and

ruin. Knowing how to spot these points becomes absolutely crucial; and is the starting point of our due

diligence process for assessing risks that are not singularly caused by external circumstances.

When we started trading in modern financial market systems, we did something that had never happened

before in the history of economic life,” Hoffman says. “We have essentially broken away from the equations

of biology, all of which are sub-linear.

What I am referring to is the observation that every other creature gets slower as it gets bigger. That’s why

the elephant trudge along.” But in market-based systems; like sprawling cities, they conform to the

opposite.

As markets and cities evolve and get bigger, everything starts accelerating. There has yet to be an

equivalent scientific demonstration for this behavior in nature. It would be likened to discovering an "[80

year old ] elephant that’s proportionally faster than a mouse.”

Hoffman goes further, and seeks to find a generalized aphorism or feature set that serves to describe the

family (what type) of elephants in nature that can move faster than a mouse – none, he says, if you are like

everyone else, focusing on the averages. But, if you look at critical transitions and then de-cohere the

unusual nodes of social interaction that are underlying their hidden critical stresses, they can be found

everywhere and in any evolving living or manmade system that are comprised of agents that interface not

only at different scales and rates of change, but also entangle -- sharing common points of interest through

their past connections -- regardless of how far apart they are separated in space and/or time.

That is the essence of quantum design, and the piece that was always missing -- no one would look at the

Social Grid, and acknowledge these expressions of irreducible connectivity.

Hoffman indicates that this has huge implications for activist investment groups -- like Berkshire, Carlyle,

and Black Rock -- seeking to invest for significant growth in more mature mid and large-cap companies that

have lower risk profiles and higher grade debt.

Page 8: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 8

Although our industry peers believe that the inevitable decline in profit per employee makes large

companies increasingly vulnerable to market volatility, Hoffman asserts that we can circumvent this

bottleneck by acquiring companies or divesting publicly owned companies that are entering a critical phase

of invisible growth -- not in the proportional increase in company profits, as seen in young firms, but in the

ability for a firm to acquire competitors or divest interests in their own company, at just the point where

they are passing through a critical transition in their open-market valuation. This would naturally lead to

runaway growth or decay, by reinforcement of constant feedback. If this feedback potential is determined

to be large enough to overcome support costs and overhead growing pain expenses for an expensive staff,

companies need not be killed by their mission to keep on getting bigger.”

In a similar vein, government policymakers and security regulators could exploit the knowledge of tipping

points for stabilizing the balance of power and taming the irrational outburst on the Market’s Social Grid --

specifically by targeting the foci points of network activity with small applications of stimuli as quickly as

possible -- and as soon as they get first notice of a potential transition to a critical state. It is hoped that the

application of this domain knowledge will forever eradicate the crude and contrived methods of

conventional intervention warfare – namely through artificially propping up markets with vast amounts of

capital to sustain a false sense of balance, well after crises have erupted – which, as Hoffman adds is like

walking up an escalator going down at an incrementally faster rate – a great expense of energy and wasted

upfront assets; with tremendous opportunity costs.

Hoffman’s goal is to ultimately get policy makers to employ these tools to prevent the very condition from

roiling the markets in the first place. This would have been especially useful on May 6th, considering that

Catallactic’s Quantum Grid Circuitry was flashing warning signs for that exact date up to 6 weeks in

advance.

In the tradition of the mathematical physics paradigm, Mr. Hoffman's ongoing explorative efforts focus on

seeing where these models have made predictions that were significantly different from those of generally

accepted theory; and then, when turning to real-life measurements, we can now observe that nature

consistently votes with the “Dragon.”

Many of the nuances and special properties that enable Dragon-King Signatures to telegraph extreme

events, has been repeatedly uncovered by our visual inspection of network connections on the Financial

Information Grid.

Page 9: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 9

The Dragon-King modeling framework is also uniquely well suited for inclusion in large portfolios and

Fund of Fund (FoF) allocations that are seeking to add diversification without redundancy.

That is because Mr. Hoffman's application of the Dragon-King strategy is one of the few non-probability and

non pattern-recognition models that are have been shown in the lab, to be capable of monetizing market

inefficiencies that lie outside of historical precedent.

But, since almost all alternative investment strategies utilize some form of probability distribution

modeling to identify meaningful relationships in data, they are limited by the historical facts (outputs), no

matter how far back or nearby they look for recurrent patterns.

That is why new modeling frameworks like these are non-correlated to virtually all alternative fund

strategies and market index products; thereby, providing Diversification without Redundancy.

The approach can help circumvent capacity constraints that are associated with large portfolio allocations.

Since Dragon-King phenomena are ubiquitous across all market segments -- asset classes and open

exchange products – as well as almost always incorrectly black-boxed by the industry as unpredictable

'Black Swan' aberrations (extreme outliers), large groups of market participants often ignore their

presence; thereby acting as natural liquidity providers right around the time when the model framework

indicates that one should be looking to execute on these arbitrage themes and new sources of Alpha.

This natural liquidity condition enables Dragon-King strategies to scale-up capital allocations to very

meaningful levels, without significantly impacting market prices or transaction slippage costs.

In summary, legacy methods of data analysis have lacked the focus and sophistication to efficiently exploit

these market inefficiencies, namely, because their means of data acquisition and knowledge extraction have

scrubbed away -- from their view -- the only true source of information content, which frequently lies

dormant and undiscovered in the energetic "critical" divides; embedded within the existing knowledge set.

Mr. Hoffman's strategy application of the Dragon-King Framework is shown to be robust on three separate

domains, namely in:

(i) Generating portfolios that are highly resistant to reverse-engineering practices, namely because the

mere act of seeing where positions were placed, and then looking for recurring patterns -- in historical

Page 10: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 10

context that precedes them; and archetypes of market behavior that follow -- provide no viable or

consistent means for uncovering the actual kernels of truth, which lie buried from the purview of the

existing paradigm.

(ii) Generating portfolios that are resilient to anti-bluffing strategies. Because Dragon-Kings are a function

of long-term processes that have built up over many generations and reinforced across multiple investment

scales, it is immensely more difficult for algorithmic trading practices -- which probe and/or manipulate

the short-term flow of bids and offers in the order book -- to redirect the course of human behavior, be it

long or short-range, especially when crossing the market's critical transition.

When passing through a critical point, the sheer size of commitments that are actually required (not mere

threats of commitments based on order book adjustments), to reverse or veer the market from the path of

least action is formidable, and thus the most logical way to influence market behavior is confined to

executed transactions, which unwind such positions in a direction that is congruent with the expected

trajectory observed through the spectacle of the "Dragon."

(iii) in having a shelf-life exploitability well beyond that of alternative strategies -- that either employ data

mining, patterns of human behavior, or historical precedent matching -- namely because the new approach

is not sensitive to “data torturing” -- inadvertently reconstructing data in ways that facilitate one's

perception of “data mirages” -- relationships and/or patterns that simply do not exist.

One of the elements that makes it difficult for our competitors to see past these illusions is partly the result

of a process, whereby the mere act of market observation, across multiple scales of investor perception,

leads to adjustments or lack of flux in the order book; which further amplifies the unexpected release of

market energy (supply and demand pressures that promote the unwinding of existing financial

commitments or positions).

These pressures tends to tear down and disassociate the links within the Grid, and create an enigma that is

analogous to when a fire (the underlying process) leaves a trail of smoke (the effect) in its wake -- long

after the inferno ceases existence. Because information is not transmitted across all resolutions at the

same, this results in different lags between the processes (cause) and the by-products (effects). At any rate,

reliance on either current or previous patterns of visible behavior (the smoke), interferes with both our

perception of current conditions, and the Financial Grid's present state.

Page 11: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 11

This enigma also finds its parallels in the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanical Systems

(those comprised of physical interactions among their numerous small-scale constituent parts), which

states that the measurement of an effect (the outcome) plays an inextricable role in shaping what we see;

and is therefore not independent of what is visible at all points forward and back. In this sense, what we see

has no arrow in time ( let alone of time ), since the measurement of progress can distort and bend our

perceptions of both our past and future experiences.

A notable consequence of this, derived by Heisenberg, is that the greater our sense of position (of a

particle) -- be it a physical object or price of an asset, which result when constituent financial agents'

perceptions' of price change collides with what they observe in the order book -- the less clear our view of

its momentum. It is important to note that "Heisenberg Uncertainty" does not restrict or preclude the

accurate, simultaneous assessment of both price and momentum in a non-classical world.

So, if we were to take our classical measurement device (empirical and pragmatic observation paradigm)

and shrink it down to a size, small enough, to fit (or be compatible) in a quantum world, then there is

nothing to stop one from reverse-engineering a calibration of price with fields of forward momentum.

So instead of measuring momentum and price at the same time, we need only measure price; and as a

natural consequence of the momentum field's calibration, we can instantly know, with zero latency, how

momentum would be affected on different time horizons for various sensitivities of price and changes in

valuation.

This is the essence of Mr. Hoffman's data capture and modeling process; and is what allows one to preserve

the quantum information that is inevitably lost in empirical models -- which are constrained by the

Copenhagen Interpretation.

Appreciation and exploitation of this radically new source of inefficiency delivers an alternative form of

diversification that can strategically enhance the Alpha-generating capabilities of any portfolio and Fund-

of-Fund strategy mix.

An equally notable deficiency with the machinery of classical finance is that it leads us in search of less

efficient solutions with lower economic utility. Their reliance on evolution -- hard-wired in humans and

conventional computer algorithms, through several millennia of natural selection or simulated iterations,

respectively -- for adapting to incoming data (new information or lack of change) is premised on two

flawed assumptions.

Page 12: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 12

First, it undermines the learning process by inappropriately extrapolating experiences that have been most

useful, and/or of recent recall, and even worse, lack regard for the context changes that may be brought

about by regime-shifts that have long-range consequences.

In this respect, we should all make it our business to analyze the internal market structures that telegraph

these changes in stylized facts and distributional data tendencies. It’s not only that evolution is too slow in

the financial markets, but also incapable of making the necessary adjustments to see past the data mirages

that history presents at all scales of human perception --no matter how far back or nearby one looks.

Secondly, evolution leads us to pursue paths on the way to our destination (targeted outcome) that favor

localized progress (avoiding short-term setbacks to satiate near-term needs), even though a few steps of

fast-forward thinking and rationally-driven gaming simulations would readily yield logically congruent

outcomes that are measurably more efficient.

By doing so, evolutionary models falsely imply that local retrenchments in progress (toward an interim

point of growth or decay) are not part of a larger critical process; that through self-ordered behavior,

produces such setbacks, in order to both maintain system-wide stability and immunity of the Financial Grid

to external shocks -- at all stages of the information discovery process.

In sharp contrast to standard investment practices, the Dragon-King Value Proposition, which is hoped to

power the future of strategy platforms, is shown to overcome these challenges, and deliver frequently

exploitable Alpha-generating opportunities in both ordinary times, and in "unusually uncertain”

environments; especially those inhabited by Dragons bearing crowns, in a minefield of financial fault-lines.

Take note; the model is currently flashing warning signals, specifically:

- indicating how the large cap S&P 100 ($OEF) and S&P 500 ($SPY) is rolling over, and is in a precarious

state of flux, as we proceed into late June and early July; and especially so, when we likely revisit these

capitulation lows, beginning in the period of October 2011 through May of next year. 1306, 1331 is major

resistance on upside -- if hit, massive selling pressure, followed by a plunge to new lows. 1337 to 1365 was

long term resistance before the selloff -- it was near this price zone on April 22nd, where model had first

knowledge of a critical downside transition. 505, 473, 465, and 445 are target support levels on the

downside for the OEX.

Page 13: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 13

There is now a high potential for a flash crash in S&P 100 securities when OEX price trades below 570 for

more than 6 hours; trigger is Valid before July 7th. OEX is currently set at: 566.53. There is also extreme

risk of a meltdown in one of the broadest indices; namely the NYSE World Leaders Index has potential to

fall from near 5600 to 4650 -- with initial near term support levels near 5433 and 5205.

There are several fundamental shifts occurring in the global markets that support these views, namely:

1. Collapsing Money Velocity (Falling ratio of GDP to Money Supply, since money supply has been

expanding faster than growth, which is about to rollover);

2. The big kicker will be a reversal of the US Dollar Index ($UUP) as Budget Deficit spending on foreign

troops will be curtailed, along with contracting credit from the Fed);

Although credit may contract, the effect in an unstable economic environment will lead to a

disproportionately negative impact on declining GDP; thus acting as a positive feedback mechanism that

will further reduce the velocity of money. This is deflationary in a monetary sense.

Since securities are valued in US dollars, a rising dollar will also put downward pressure on the nominal

value of US listed assets (lesser impact on some commodities and managed health care services/products,

as there are real structural supply shocks and long term demographic wealth shifts in the growth of the

middle-class in emerging markets).

A Dollar Rally (when it occurs, it will be sharp and abrupt) has the potential for accelerating the market fall,

especially as early as the third quarter of 2011 or second quarter of 2012.

For details on the trigger conditions for a Dollar Fall, you can review market commentary on twitter under

Global_Macro;

3. Complacency in the value that people are pricing risk into the future with leveraged products;

4. Deteriorating Housing Market and Employment picture.

Information Inquiries Contact: [email protected] or [email protected]

Page 14: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 14

BIO:

Mr. Hoffman, Founding CEO & Financial Model Architect

Based in Toronto, Canada, Mr. Hoffman brings a broad business technology vision to the investment

management and data intelligence companies; and media enterprises he counsels — Catallactic

Management Ltd (CML); Clear View Analytics Inc. (CVA); and SkyScope Phynancial News Network (SPNN).

While consulting for and collaborating with industry experts on computational intelligence, financial

trading, order execution, electronic trading room design, real-time data management, extreme event

modeling and catastrophe prediction; he has gained over 16 years experience researching and developing

intelligent multi-dimensional visualization solutions for the next-incarnation of financial analytic platforms.

Mr. Hoffman heads the Catastrophe Modeling, Risk Intelligence, and Global-Growth Surveillance

Observatory at CVA -- Powered by Catallactic’s Quantum Grid Circuitry (QGC).

He is a recognized inventor of smart-data analysis architecture and self-thinking soft-computing machines,

with working applications, and information technology patents that have been cited internationally on over

46 instances on Patent granted to Fortune 500 Companies, Federal Research Agencies, revered Scientific

Think-Tanks, and preeminent Academic Institutions.

CMLs in-house financial tool-set is derived partly from two US patents; both invented and assigned to

Efrem Hoffman (in 2000 and 2001; accessible at US Patent Office website under Quick-search -- enter first

and last name; both patent titles start with the word Hierarchical).

As social proof of Mr. Hoffman's Patent Publications, they have been shortlisted for inclusion in BrainDex's

CD knowledge source of "215+ fascinating inventions."

With this diverse solution-base, Mr. Hoffman embraces the mathematics of nature and quantum mechanics

to observe Global-Macro Trends on a Human Scale.

Most notably, he brings a mathematical physics perspective to engineer comprehensive information murals

and knowledge maps for enhancing visibility of uncertain outcomes, and expanding the domain of

conventional market analysis and applications for behavioral finance.

Page 15: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 15

His core objectives are to enhance:

Visibility of Future Price and Volatility; Mission-Critical Risk Intelligence Zero-Latency Data Aggregation; Early Identification of Industry and Sector Rotation Trends; Global-Macro Forecasting of Super-Anomalies and Undervalued Liquid-Situations.

His market insights are inspired by observing how the fragmented structure and inherent uncertainty of

conventional market sources interfere with our perception of current conditions; yielding outbursts of

market contagion and extreme price movement, which are translated into actionable strategy.

Mr. Hoffman redefines what it means to manage information overload – by zeroing in on the behavioral

pathways and knowledge structures that form our collective perceptions, we can better target those

orientations that predispose markets to episodes of information contagion and trend reinforcement.

Furthermore, by developing a greater awareness of this social information context, we can identify those

critical points, where new incoming data or lack thereof, has the highest potential for influencing the

underlying market condition.

Through leveraging this collaborative information resource across all asset classes and geographies, Mr.

Hoffman is committed to discovering new vistas for not only flagging and exploiting upcoming and unusual

market events, but also delivering wide-screen transparency of the complex social networks that influence

and create financial fault-lines — the divide between periods of prosperity and unstable regimes of

extreme turbulence and decay.

Mr. Hoffman also holds a deep conviction for writing time-sensitive commentary, trend-pieces, and

investing opinion-focused posts that challenge conventional thinking and legacy market-analysis, especially

when it comes to analyzing emergent trends and super-anomalies of the marketplace.

For a sneak preview of tomorrow's high-impact outbursts of irrational market behavior; and to review

scheduled upcoming broadcasts of his high-conviction market calls, Link to his:

Online Radio Show: http://www.blogtalkradio.com/skyscope-phynancial-news-network

Page 16: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 16

BlogSpot: http://dragonkinginvestor.blogspot.com;

Twitter: http://feeds.feedburner.com/Twitter/Global_macro.

Leveraging these market insights, he also serves as contributing editor to several Financial Blogs and Real-

Time Information Aggregators.

Real-Time tweets of Mr. Hoffman’s market calls are also made available on many primary financial news

agency sites that tag financial stock tickers with time-sensitive Just-In-Time Commentary.

By providing high-impact, time-critical behavioral market news-flow for Financial Media Bureaus,

Investment Bankers, and Market Professionals –

Mr. Hoffman's mission is to help these organizations and their clients manage business expectations in an increasingly competitive G20 Economy.

The mathematical logic underpinning his content is inspired by frontier insights in Behavioral finance and

the Wisdom of Crowds. These concepts are supported by strategic decision-making under extreme

uncertainty, through applying time-tested strategies and rational-choice logic stemming from Quantum

Game Theory.

Page 17: Predictive Intelligence for Hunting Down Financial Crisis Tipping Points

The Orbit of Panic: Telegraphing Financial Market Crises: Critical Transition Analysis of Mass Human Behavior

Catallactic Group of Companies | L'Horizon, Gunsite Road, Brittons Hill, St. Michael, Barbados BB14027

Copyright Protected June 2011 17

YOUR FINANCIAL DATA IS TRYING TO TELL YOU SOMETHING.

IS YOUR WEALTH MANAGEMENT PROCESS BUILT TO HEAR IT?

CMLs Trading Facility and Data Analysis Control Center

DISCLAIMER

The information contained herein is intended for informational, educational and research purposes only. None of the content herein is intended to be, nor should it be construed or used as, financial, legal, tax or investment advice, or a representation as to the appropriateness or suitability of an

investment in any financial vehicle. The information contained herein is as of the date(s) indicated and is not a complete description of the investment platform. This document is being issued by Catallactic’s Analytic Group for information purposes only, and no representation is being made by the organization or any agent of any affiliate as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this document.